The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Jorge CarbonellWe Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!------------------------------------------------------------...
That's how we do. Welcome. Exactly. Welcome. George Carbonall to the insurance data system. Love it. It's been a long time of coming. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Thanks, guys. Appreciate it. Should we do that? Thank you. Do that view. Yeah, there we go. Yeah, look at that. Now he's the he's the uh with the beard. I mean, if you're if you're listening to this, you've got to go over to the YouTube channel because look at that beard. Yes, very strong.
SPEAKER_02
Under the clock tower. Under the clock tower.
SPEAKER_00
What's that? I was gonna say post post-corporate beard. You know, we used to look like this.
SPEAKER_02
Right. Right. And I want to hear that story, but before we dive in, Craig, I think you have something for him.
SPEAKER_03
Oh, we're gonna play a round of speedbreakers. This is what everybody's talking about. And we are ready to go. All you have to do is answer as quickly as possible. There's no thinking here. This is all instinct. All right? All right. Are you ready? Let's play. Oh, hold on. I really was gonna get fancy here. Oh, I don't know where it is. I was gonna play a little ding, but I don't know where it is. All right. Let's play speed breakers. George Carbon, have you ever had a mullet? No. First crush. First crush?
SPEAKER_00
Middle school.
SPEAKER_03
Most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing.
SPEAKER_00
Um I played the fifth.
SPEAKER_03
Fastest speed ever driven.
SPEAKER_00
Fastest speed ever driven? Um 95.
SPEAKER_03
95. Wow. Uh favorite cereal.
SPEAKER_00
Captain Crunch.
SPEAKER_03
How many? That's a good one. How many kids have you made cry? How many kids have you made cry?
SPEAKER_00
Probably a lot. I used to play football so I made it. Oh, there you go.
SPEAKER_03
Count chocolate or count Dracula? Dracula? Fastest mile?
And Trump or Biden? You don't have to you don't have to answer that one. That's all right. Oh, there it is. Another successful round of speedbreakers.
SPEAKER_02
Well, we got George Carvanaugh. So, George, let's just dive in, man. Give us a little a little background. What was the first concert you ever went to, by the way?
SPEAKER_00
First concert? Man, honestly, I haven't been to too many concerts. My wife always makes fun of me about that. But my first concert was a J. Cole concert in downtown downtown Cleveland. And it was like before he had actually blown up. And there might have been a hundred people in there. It was awesome.
SPEAKER_03
Wow.
SPEAKER_00
Who was it?
unknown
J.
SPEAKER_00
Cole, rapper.
SPEAKER_02
Nice. Take us. I love that.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, right. That's my first concert. Then went to a couple of Rick Ross concerts, Lou Wayne. So I like rap music. Nice.
SPEAKER_02
Well, take us back from then to now. How did you become an insurance agent? What was that crazy journey? Because I don't think you wanted to do that back when you uh were going to rap concerts. Or maybe.
SPEAKER_00
No, not at all. I mean, it's kind of like I know a lot of people kind of trip into the industry. Nobody kind of grows up like, I want to be an insurance agent. Um, it was more of a I I graduated with a criminal justice and free law. Um, you know, I thought I wanted to be a lawyer, uh, did a lot of research. I didn't really want to be a cop or anything like that, um, even though my sisters are cops, um, and uh I just didn't want to put myself through that. But um, you know, I started Googling what do I do with a criminal justice degree? And uh claims came up. So um interviewed uh with the company, started on the corporate side as a claims adjuster, kind of worked my way up through there, became a claims leader. Uh they kept moving around state to state, um, ended up working at a corporate head uh headquarters, and uh, I was a product manager, and that was super cool. Um, did that for a couple years, but I uh wanted to I needed to be back in the field. It was just like meeting after meeting after meeting. It was like we never actually did anything. Um it was crazy. So um, so yeah, I mean they kicked me out, went back into the field, uh, became kind of a market sales leader, um, trainee role, and you know, got to work with a lot of great agents, and um, some of them are now my friends and mentors, and uh it really just encouraged me to, you know, I can do more. Um so I quit my job in September of last year and and uh started up my agency.
SPEAKER_02
What were so that's pretty cool, man? You don't hear about that too often, or you don't get to hear the stories of somebody that worked helping agents and then becoming an agent. What were some of the things that you learned through that journey that has helped you just crush it?
SPEAKER_00
Um man, the biggest thing is uh perseverance. Um one of my um one of my mentors and a good and good friend is an Indiana agent, um Jeff Hodelberg. I mean, I I was helped working in his his agency and uh just the culture that he created within his agency. And um shout out to his team, love his team, uh great friends of mine now. Uh just that culture, the people, the competition, just everybody working together and getting better. It just I mentioned earlier, like I played football and it just it connected with me. I felt the energy on a daily basis where I really never felt that on the corporate side. Um so I just like kind of living living to that and getting better every day.
SPEAKER_03
That's so amazing um that you had the opportunity to go into a high performing agency because I think a lot of agents start and they don't get to see that, so they don't have a real good vision of of kind of what you know what there is or what to expect or what to build to.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. Yeah, you kind of see what's possible, right? You know, when you kind of start fresh, and you know, I know when we kind of presented the different opportunities and stuff, people kind of want to start small, and you know, I'm you know have like maybe like you know, they have a goal, but they don't really know what maybe exceptional looks like and how to get there, or like you know, things like that. So they kind of have a a shorter goal. Whereas like when I started, first of all, I thought I knew most of what I needed to know, and then you kind of so you start with day one and it's like pow. It's just like a you get stiff armed, and it's like it's like man, I really don't know anything, and now it's just kind of like a whole new learning curve, and it's um just kind of stay ahead of it.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. There's so much pressure up front, right? Because the the fuse is ticking or the fuse is burning, time is ticking, you're you're just overwhelmed because there's all these systems you have to learn, and you know, how did you what did you do? Like, what was it like on day one?
SPEAKER_00
Man, well, day one, uh day one was unpacking boxes, man. Like I remember I was doing interviews and and I just you know I was doing interviews out of Starbucks, and you know, my my first hire, like her first day here, it was like there was like a chair and a desk, and just everything was boxes. And um, I mean she's she's stuck with me since then. She's now uh my sales manager. Um, she's awesome, and she's kind of been with me through this journey. So, you know, to me it's just finding the right people that that believe in what what you're doing as a team and um and really taking care of those people.
SPEAKER_02
Love it. What are you trending for right now? Sales for this month. So I got I got I got my Zoom right there. Um 254,000? 254,000. That is awesome. So what was the first month like? And what are you doing now that really is uh I mean, take us through every step. So you know, it had to be uh it's tough hiring, right? It's uh it's hard to hire, it's hard to train, it's hard to motivate, it's hard to make those kind of sales happen. And I'm sure you didn't do that right out of the gate. So what how did you get to that point so fast? And what were the big turning points within that journey?
SPEAKER_00
Um, I think it's testing a lot of different stuff. Um, so I was, you know, I obviously like most agents, you know, just buying everything, everything out there um and just learning from it. And the biggest thing that I realized was that we we just needed the activity. Um, and my people just weren't doing enough activity to get there. And it's not that they weren't trying, they just didn't have enough time in the day. They were you know quoting eight to ten households a day. You you're not gonna get you know a hundred to you know two hundred dials a day as well. Um, they just there wasn't enough time in the day. So I you know, we know we needed to kind of create some type of funnel or we needed somebody else to come in and make those dials. So I actually started kind of implementing like a telemarketing team. So I mean I started hiring people and I would start to like train them as a telemarketer first and have them do that for a couple months, and then I would kind of see if there would be a good sales producer and then get them licensed and started there. But to Craig's point earlier, you know, I'm on a I'm on a timeline, right? So it's it's everything's taken. So you kind of need the results now so that you can continue to grow at the same clip. Um, so you know, we just outsourced it now. I mean, we started we started outsourcing it, got three telemarketers. Um, within a couple of weeks, we're at five, seven, and I mean we're at 10 telemarketers making six, seven thousand dollars a day.
SPEAKER_02
And that's kind of what's helping us out right now. That's crazy. What was your first month's sales like?
SPEAKER_00
So when we first started, we were doing um 40 to 50,000, and man, it was crazy. Like everyone's talking to me, like, man, how are you doing that? That's great. And I'm sitting here, sitting, I'm just like, this is not great. Like, I know we can do better. There's just so there's so much room for improvement. But the crazy thing is that's probably what's wrong with me because I'm still sitting here, like, there's still so much room for improvement.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, it it's amazing how the like the different levels are just you know, you hit 100, you're like, Yeah, well, now I need 150. And then you hit 150, you're like, Well, I gotta get 200, and it just keeps escalating, right?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, it's exciting though, but that's why we do what we do, and we you know, that's what keeps us going, right? Like it should be like that. Like I I you know, I play competitive sports my entire life. I mean, I play collegiate football, and it's like you play to win, you play to be the best. And if if you're not trying to be the best, then why are you doing it anymore? So um, I just like to keep getting better. Same for my team.
SPEAKER_02
If you don't move ahead, if you're not trying to constantly push yourself, then everybody's going to pass you because there's going to be all those other people that are pushing themselves. Um the sports analogy is perfect because it it really is the same thing. I mean, we're have you have you ever Googled in your area how many insurance agents there are? It's ludicrous, like right, like across the whole nation. So we we are in competition. Um kind of with the carriers now too, right? Because all the carriers are are going more and more direct, and that's uh just the nature of uh the market in general, so in any industry, going more and more direct. So we gotta push. We gotta push. And that's incredible that you were able to go from 40,000, 50,000 um now trending for 250 in December, which is usually a uh tougher month for some agencies. So kudos to you, my man. Yeah, no, just keep pushing. Just keep pushing, just keep pushing. So, what are the how did you find your team?
SPEAKER_00
Um, uh so I at first it was just kind of like what everybody did, you know, posting on Facebook, you know, looking for great team members. Um, then it was kind of the whole MD thing and just keep recruiting. Um, and then now I use um a couple of different services uh to get like group interviews. Uh I find that that's kind of the um kind of most efficient way. Use my guy Gary, and uh, you know, he gets me gets me in front of 10 people in 30 minutes or to an hour, and I get to pick the you know, top of the top. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Now, do you have you had a continual uh hiring you've been continually hiring since you opened, pretty much?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, pretty much. And um, and at the beginning, it was because of necessity to to attrition, and that's the biggest thing too. I mean, if you think about uh you know kind of the the burnout from the activity and things like that that we put some of the producers through, I hire people to sell. Um, I don't hire people necessarily to market. I know there's a million different ways to skin the cat, but um my my I always explain it like my goal or my role here as the agency owner is to make the phone ring and to help develop you. That's that's really what I'm here for. Um, and then it's your job to kind of manage your business and make manage your pipeline, make your sales. Um, anything you do outside of that is is kind of like the cherry on top. You know, you're just gonna, you know, you're gonna develop your referral networks, things like that. But um, yeah, for me it's making the phone ring. So at first it was they were kind of out doing all the outbound activity. I was just buying the leads, uh, and people would like do it for a month and they'd like be great. I'm like, this kid's gonna, you know, kill it. And then like month two, it was like, you know, you can kind of sense that you know that that trend wasn't gonna continue. And then by month three, they were out of here because it was just like we're just burning them out so quickly. Uh, and you know, now I don't lose anybody unless it's you know up to me. It could be performance-based. Maybe it's just not a good fit. What is it that keeps them? Um, you know, honestly, I just I took a screenshot of um I showed this to my sales manager uh last week, and I took a screenshot of a conversation that the team was having in Slack, and it was just a a lot of props to like the agency culture and stuff, and just in top in in regards to like the leads and you know the opportunity that we have with the agency, um that conversation would have never taken place, you know, 12 months ago. Absolutely not. Um so I just kind of took a screenshot just to keep it, just to kind of show that you're doing the right thing and on the right track and just continue to scale it.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, what have you done to build that culture?
SPEAKER_00
Uh bring the right people in that are like a to be continuous.
SPEAKER_04
Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_01
They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_04
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01
Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04
Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01
Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content, right?
SPEAKER_04
Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Greg, are you going to respond to these texts? I'm going to respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean, everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520 214 2219.
SPEAKER_04
All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01
Bye, Mr. Craig. Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_03
I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.