The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Dan HerrenbriuckWe Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------...
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. So coming into this business from the corporate world, what was your hardest, what was the biggest challenge?
SPEAKER_00
Because that's a that's a big agency to you know it it it well i I worked here for what 12 and a half years before I took it over. So when I came in, I was I was green. I was my my background, my degree is in finance. Um it's funny, I I actually wanted to wanted to be an attorney growing up and went to college and realized what law school actually entails, you know, and I I didn't I didn't have that kind of I didn't I didn't have that kind of gumption. Um so I I got a degree in in finance and business administration as a uh as a financial planner for about six weeks out of college. Um you know and I learned very quickly when I was first working there, the the guy in uh our orientation class said 95% of you are not going to make it out of the first year. And he was right. Because financial planners, you start, especially out of college, you know, hey dad, you've been working for 40 years. Let me, you know, let me handle your retirement money. That's how you start your business. You don't know anybody. You know, talking about pressure, you know, forget it. I learned very quickly it wasn't for me, but I always like the sales, I always like people talking to people. Um, so I got in with Free Olay um and started doing route sales for them. So I had, I don't know, 15 or 20 grocery stores on my route and got to know the store managers and and things. But you know, it it's it's just relationships. You know, it's it that's all it is. If you if you're good with people and you you you genuinely enjoy people and and uh talking, you're gonna be successful in this business. You just gotta keep your head down and do it over and over and over again. It's repetition.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Is uh is your dad involved now?
SPEAKER_00
Only from only only from a business standpoint, you know, from a 10,000 foot view looking down, he's uh he and I have business meetings on how to grow and how to move the business, but as far as a day-to-day, you know, he he doesn't come in and really talk to the staff anymore. And you know, I'll I'll call him in every now and then for in in our sales meetings and stuff, and he'll he'll throw a little uh you know a trick or two that worked in 1989, you know, out that we could try and bring back, you know. But no, by and large, he's he's he's removed from the day-to-day side of things.
SPEAKER_01
Just have him sit over on the off to the side and work the microfiche.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, right. That's right.
SPEAKER_01
He knows how to do that.
SPEAKER_00
He's told stories, he's told stories about you know, back back in the day of actually having to hand rate auto policies. You know, they didn't have computers when he first started. You know, he was actually in the the booth at Sears back in the day, you know, and and uh he they would actually hand rate auto policies.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. It's remarkable.
SPEAKER_00
Somebody wouldn't disclose a uh somebody wouldn't disclose a speeding ticket or something, and you know, you rate it by hand, and then they find it you know after the fact, and then the rate goes up, and you got to go and explain those, you know. It's not not like it is today with the touch of a button, you know. Everything about everywhere.
SPEAKER_01
It was so slow. There's a there's a woman here in in Tucson that owns a Hawaiian restaurant, and we got, you know, I had my had one of my shirts on. So she said, Oh, I used to work for an all state agent in Hawaii and back in the early 80s, and and she said, like, so there was that, they were hand rating it, but then they also had to they had to ship the paperwork from Hawaii to to Chicago, right? So think of the lag time before the underwriters even look at it, and then they would have a problem with it, send it back, and it's so it would take weeks for a policy to issue. And you know, you're making eight bucks a year off it. It's just great. I I mean here we are, you know, at the red light.
SPEAKER_00
There's some people here we here here we are sitting in Florida and Arizona having a having a conversation, right? You know, right.
SPEAKER_02
It is crazy. So uh what what do you find right now? What's your biggest challenge in the agency?
SPEAKER_00
Managing staff, just like everybody else. Managing staff.
SPEAKER_02
How many staff do you have?
SPEAKER_00
I've got I've got 11 counting myself.
unknown
Cool.
SPEAKER_02
And are you guys departmentalized?
SPEAKER_00
We are. Yeah. I've got two uh I've got two retention, two young ladies who work on retention. Their job is to call clients all day, every day. Um I've got one person administrative assistant and a second who's kind of floats between those two departments, and then everybody else is sales. You know, and the administrative people they do all the endorsements and mortgage changes and those type type thing, check the mail, you know, do all do all that stuff. Uh, and then I've got everybody else is on in sales, trying to grow it. The jack of all trades. You know, I I I try and keep my I try and keep myself to the quote unquote difficult clients or the more the more intense clients we have, you know, who has the auto home personal umbrella boat and maybe some life insurance with us, you know. If you if you've got a seasonal condo down here, you're probably not gonna talk to me. So we just kinda that's how we that's how we just kind of we try and kind of departmentalize it a little bit. So I mean I say that. So you know, if they want to talk to me, they can talk to me. But everybody's kind of my gatekeeper in that. Because I if you can you can get you can get lagged up in a hurry.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, you can definitely get bogged down.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Rabbit holes. Right.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, some little thing that starts off with, do you have a minute can end up where now you have to call RFC for an afternoon, right?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, exactly. And they need to they need to they just bought a new car and change they need to change out a car.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, that's what no, I'm gonna get you over here. I know that um she's gonna do a much better job helping you on that. So yeah.
SPEAKER_00
And you, you know, like everybody else, you you you have some of those clients who they only want to talk to Dan. And that that's that's fine. You know, I've got one lady who just refuses to give her credit card to anybody else in the office but me. And that's fine. She's 82 years old, too. So you can give a little grace where grace is due.
SPEAKER_01
So we always promise the listeners that we're gonna they're gonna get some juicy tidbits. I think that that um from a you know from a marketing or uh new business acquisition standpoint, and obviously you have a lot of different lines in the in the lake here. Yeah, um so having the having uh what's her name? I guess the the marketing late, Dana? Yeah. So you have Dana, you have Dana going around to the 150 or so loan officers handing out Snickers.
SPEAKER_00
Um and then there's got to be some other significant Yeah, we do we do we do a lot of we do a lot of direct mails, uh direct mail campaigns. Um I'll buy I'll buy internet leads periodically. Um you know, my my opinion on internet leads is you don't buy them to sell. I know Craig and I talked about that a little bit uh a couple weeks ago when we were talking. You you don't I don't buy them with the intention of selling them the day we get them. I buy them for the cross date. Uh because an internet lead, you know, typically you call them and you're the seventh person that's called them and they're tired of talking about their car insurance that day. But six months later, you know, they they're ready to talk. So you buy their name and number is what you're buying out of that. So so we'll do that periodically. I don't do that, um I don't do that you know on a consistent basis. I'll I'll buy them for maybe three months a year and then keep those, you know, keep working the cross dates because you know all this is if you want to grow, it's it's opportunity. You know, the more people you talk to, the more policies you're gonna sell. And uh trying to keep that pipeline full.
SPEAKER_02
What's your number one advice that you would that you'd offer any new agent that's starting out?
SPEAKER_00
Just stick with it. You know, it it'll all work out. People give up too easily on things, you know, my in my experience. And you know, it's not always going to be good months. It's not always gonna be um, you know, I I go home at night and uh you know beat my head against the wall, use my sounding board. Not every day, not every day's not every day's a great day. It's just not. Um, you know, but specifically for for the agency owners uh out there, you know, number one advice I'd give you is don't let your staff see you having a bad day. Keep it keep keep that stuff for home, you know. Never there there are things that Allstate does as a company that makes me want to, you know, it just doesn't make any sense. But you'll never hear me badmouth Allstate to my staff. You know, that's that's who I work for. You know, that's that's that's my number one company that I represent. And and I believe in their product. Do they do everything perfectly? Nope. Neither does State Farm, neither does USA, neither does, you know, any anybody. Um, but uh you'll never hear me, you'll never hear me uh uh say a detrimental word to them to my staff. To my wife, that's a different behind closed doors, you know, that's different, different story, you know, and then you get it out and you move on, you come back the next day, and things always get better the next day.
SPEAKER_02
Yep. If you had to do it all over again from when you started with Allstate, what would you what's the one thing you would do differently?
SPEAKER_00
That's a great question. Uh you know, I I don't know. I I think I did I first of all, I I'm blessed. I walked into a pretty good situation. I'm I married the right girl, um, and and from a business standpoint, not from a personal standpoint and from a business standpoint. So I walked in and I was trained by um by someone with a world of experience. So I can't speak to the guys out there who are starting scratch right now who don't have any experience in in uh in the insurance world. I that's that's foreign to me. Um, you know, so you know, there's not a lot that I would there's not a lot that I would do different. You know, I just be a sponge, learn it. And learn learn coverage. Learn learn what makes you uh different from everybody else, even the other all-state agents. You know, I tell I tell my staff, I don't, I don't see the state farm guys in town town as my competition. I see the other all-state guys as my competition. What makes me different state farm guys sell another product? I can't control what state farm guys sell. That's all their their business. I can't compete against that. It's my product versus their product. But the guy down, the allstate guy down the street sells the exact same thing that I can that I can get an offer. Why should they take me over him or her as the case, maybe? So that's that's kind of the the forefront of my mind all the time. That makes sense.
SPEAKER_02
So it sounds like the two the two nuggets you kind of kind of gave as advice is a perseverance, um, just stick with it, right? And then uh the relationships. Yeah, that's kind of been a common thing. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00
And and everything, everything else will take care of itself. It'll all fall back and fall into place.
SPEAKER_02
I like it.
SPEAKER_00
It really will. So cool.
SPEAKER_02
What what's your uh if you went to go grab fast food around there, what what's your favorite place?
SPEAKER_00
You know, I I there's a McDonald's right by the office, and I haven't been there outside of their coffee. Their coffee is abnormally good. I don't get McDonald's food as in in general is just awful, but their coffee in the morning, it's legit. Um there's a subway here I go to a lot. Um there's a uh um Taco Bell down the street that I've hit up a couple times, but but that's that's about it. Close to us anyway.
SPEAKER_02
Awesome. What's the transition from from where you were going to Florida? What's it culturally?
SPEAKER_00
Well, it it took me about a year um to really like it. It was not a hard decision. Um when we first started talking about it, you know, I I didn't want to do it the same year we got married, um, and and switch careers and move across the country and do all of it all at one time.
SPEAKER_02
Um that's a lot.
SPEAKER_00
I had a you know, I at the time I was a district manager, so I had like nine guys who ran routes for free LA underneath me. And one guy called me at like 10 o'clock at night. He was on his way to the hospital, so he couldn't run his route. And he left his the depot at like 2 30 in the morning to get his route, it was like an hour away from the depot, and you know, so who you gonna call to run a route on you know four hours sleep? So I just said, I'll do it, you know. And so I went home, slept for like three and a half hours, got up. First thing I said when I turned the truck on in the morning was it was seven degrees outside. And that was the day I decided we were going to Florida. Because we were we were planning on going, you know, we were planning on getting and working for another year and then making the move like in 2007. And I just said, you know what, what are we doing here? Like, let's just do it. Rip the band-aid off and and go. And you know, seven degrees, they can they can that's one of the things I don't miss about Indianapolis.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. That's brutal. That's brutal.
SPEAKER_00
It's awful. It's awful. You know, I'm I do miss, I do miss the city, you know, being able to go down and go downtown on a Sunday morning and try and get Colts tickets. And if you don't, you just go across the street to the sports bar and watch the Colts game with you know 150 of your closest friends, you know, that kind of stuff. You know, where I am, I'm like two hours from two hours from Miami. So if you want to do something, you know, in the city, you got a plan to do it, you know. So I miss that little bit of that little bit of it, but but uh I I wouldn't I wouldn't go back. Certainly not in January.
SPEAKER_02
Right. You'll I yeah, I would take I would take the humidity over that. That's just oh brittle.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, it was it's brutal. We have the weather trifecta what uh represented on this call, Arizona, California, Florida. I mean, you everybody else is envious of us. That's cool. Um anything else that you can think. I I know we we sort of touched on advice for for new agents or or anybody buying an agency. Um how about that? How about somebody who's buying an agency? Um, you know, those fundamentals that you bring up, I think are so important.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, I mean, I just know know the book, you know, do your do your due diligence if you're buying a if you're buying a book, know the book and know the staff. You know, look at those look at those loss ratio numbers and and those retention numbers and and all of those things because when you buy when you buy a book, there's gonna be a little bit of attrition. I mean, I'm I took over for my father-in-law, and there's been a little bit of attrition because everybody wanted to talk to Steve. Well, Steve's retired. Well, you know, I'm leaving, I'm leaving. Well, I'm Steve's son-in-law, so you know, I'm still talking to the family. I don't know, I want to talk to Steve. You know, you you're you're gonna get those, you're gonna get those people, you know. So, you know, if you've got if you've got somebody who's uh book a business who's retaining it 70%, you can expect it to go to 60. That's not a good deal, you know. So so no do your due diligence before you before you make that purchase.
SPEAKER_01
Awesome, Dan. Well, hey, we we really really appreciate your time. We're here uh we're right at the we went a little tiny bit over, but but uh thank you so much. You better thanks.
SPEAKER_00
My pleasure. Appreciate it, guys.
SPEAKER_03
Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 in premium. Yes. Even the worst internet leads, where could they go? They can go to live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04
That sounds exciting.
SPEAKER_03
Are we gonna be there?
SPEAKER_04
Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now. That will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_03
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_04
Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03
Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_04
Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content, right?
SPEAKER_03
Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them?
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. Greg, are you going to respond to these texts? I'm going to respond to them for sure. Lives. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean, everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm going to text it right now. 520 214 2219.
SPEAKER_03
All right. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_04
Do we even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_01
I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.