The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Joshua StephensWe Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!------------------------------------------------------------...
If they've never purchased commercial insurance before, like they a lot of times come into it with the same mindset uh of someone shopping for home and auto. Like like it's just give it to me. Like yeah, like like like this will be a 15-minute process.
SPEAKER_02
Like called yesterday.
SPEAKER_04
Let me give you exactly like a couple of like pieces of information. And like I I just need I just need liability because my my lease says that I need like general liability. Like, well, right, let's slow down. Let's like let's have a conversation about this. Um and in that way, like they very much can be similar. And you can kind of tell pretty quickly how uh if a commercial case is one that like you even really like want to take on, like by how easy they are in the uh uh fact-finding stage, and again, how quickly that they are expecting a turnaround. Um you even run into that sometimes with like people that like established businesses that have like been in operation for five, ten years and revenue of over a million. There's like how quickly can can we get this done? Like you've got a pretty complicated business. How much how much how much devoted time can you give me to get all the information that I need? Because then I can turn it around pretty quick. But yeah. But the one uh thing that like, and this is really kind of uh what I've found regardless of whether you're looking at personal lines, commercial, life and health. Um what has served me the uh the best in all those lines with uh uh getting leads, getting like new prospects, always having people to talk to has been uh with uh how well am I doing with uh generating new relationships with the people that talk to my ideal prospects on a regular basis. And so like I I thrive uh when I have when I'm able to cultivate strong referral relationships. Uh and that has been the backbone of like uh of my agency like since day one.
SPEAKER_00
Okay. So let's talk about that. How what kind of things have you done to to break in the uh to to to knock down the door of some of these people that have now become good referral relationships? And I love that whole idea of looking at okay, where are they, where's my avatar hanging out, and how can I find myself, insert myself into that traffic, if you will.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, so uh the uh and I I was uh listening to uh an episode that uh y'all did recently while I was uh shopping uh in Costco uh with, and I can't remember his name, but the mortgage broker.
SPEAKER_00
Of this, of insurance dudes?
SPEAKER_04
Yes, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
And I would think that's the only the only podcast that you would be listening to. Um it was uh I know the um uh it had to be the one that we did on the elite dudes call for the Teledudes members. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, it was it literally like it was just within like the last.
SPEAKER_00
Morgan. Morgan, Tom, Tom Morgan Morgan.
SPEAKER_04
Sure, Tom. Yeah, yep. Um and uh with uh and like they're obvious just like like everyone that like is on the property and casualty side of insurance, like uh those uh like a strong mortgage broker that's sending you business uh can like feed a good bit of premium into your agency every single month. Um, especially uh right now with uh I think I mean in most places in the country, or like I haven't heard anyone uh say that they're living in a area that's suffering from a real estate standpoint. It seems like everyone is buying and selling everywhere. Um, but uh the area of South Carolina that I'm in is been in a real estate boom for like uh shortly after the 08. Yeah, I like short we're talking probably like it's like 2010, like it everything kind of bounced back and it's been just steadily increasing ever since. Um part of that's due to we're having a lot of uh industry setup. So we're having several people come in from the northeast uh constantly. And then you've uh I know several people personally that have like just like like bought and sold homes uh in the past year. Uh I think quarantine is like forced people, like we're we're too close together. We need a bigger house. Yeah, let's get these kids uh in another wing. Right. Um and so they're like we just put ours outside. That's a good strategy. That is a good strategy. In a pen. Uh yep, and so they're uh like like like a good mortgage broker's closing like like six plus like uh deals a month in this area. Um and so like you get you get a handful of of them or uh like or if you're able to train a realtor to start having that conversation like early in the process with home buyers, then like uh they are fantastic referral partners. Uh and so like finding ways to provide value for them, like uh uh uh online lead generation that sends directly to them, uh so that like I mean the mortgage brokers like are at this point are like they have more business than they can handle. Um but they're always looking for uh people that are gonna be like looking to buy six to twelve months from now. Sure. And so if you keep names in front of them uh and can continue to build value, then uh then they tend to want to work with with you versus the uh insurance agent that's just showing up with cookies or ask constantly asking to go to lunch. They don't have time to go to lunch.
SPEAKER_02
No, and and these days, uh yeah, there's not at least on this side, there's not a lot of restaurants. Now it's getting cold and they want us to eat outside.
SPEAKER_04
Oh, yes.
SPEAKER_00
Um it's not cold.
SPEAKER_02
Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_00
It's a little cold.
SPEAKER_02
Well, for yeah, Southern California are it was 60.
SPEAKER_00
I mean, that's that is pretty cold here.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, it's like we're getting and say in South Carolina, it's it's weird. Like we're coming up on Halloween, and like every year, like like that's usually my gauge. Like at Halloween, am I in shorts or or am I in long sleeves? Like never so what is it this year? Shorts is uh it well with the with this tropical storm coming through, like it it could probably still go either way. Like uh like if you like I don't really know. I'll I'll like yeah, it if the jury is out.
SPEAKER_00
Um maybe you can borrow Puxitani Phil.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, like I've like I could like we're at that point where during the day, like it it's getting up to like 80, but then at end of the evening it's dipping down into the 60s. So gotcha. Yep. So tell us uh that that's the strategy a lot of times on personal lines, and like the goal there again is like to keep the CSR busy because like she can handle the vast majority of the of that. Um uh and then uh with uh like I mentioned ACA coming up, uh uh I have uh one or two uh referral part referral partners that focus on like work site products. So like and those people like tend to like that that is all they do. And their goal is to get in front of like uh those businesses that have like 10 to 25 employees and aren't offering benefits of any kind. Uh and so what is what is that like?
SPEAKER_02
What is open enrollment? You got three months and oh three months, it's six weeks. Uh or six six weeks. That's right.
SPEAKER_04
So you got three months, three months of prep sometimes.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, gotta move quick. What is it like? Is it it's just so it's game busters. You have so many different people involved uh getting ready and then with referral partners and everything else, and then boom, it's game time. And it's just like as fast as you can, right? As much as you can.
SPEAKER_04
Yes. It uh it is uh now like the revenue like from uh uh from those six weeks like help like me like like offset like my marketing budget for the rest of the year. Like wow. Uh but the it's six weeks of this all the stuff that like I do not enjoy. Like it is rent and repeat all day long.
SPEAKER_02
It's yeah.
SPEAKER_04
Because you're just 12 hour days? The name oh easy. The the names are different, uh but that that's about it. Everything else is the same. It's like pick a plan, and usually like uh there's this year with there being four different carriers. Now they're not all in every county, but uh there might be a couple more plans, but usually like uh the plan choices end up being narrowed down from like 25 down to like two or three that everyone's choosing from. So they're just how are you well?
SPEAKER_00
I'm sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_04
Well, it's like the uh and so like uh where I was going with that is just it there's not a whole lot of thinking involved. It's you enter the numbers, punch in the information, click the plan, and then you just and it's like on to the next one.
SPEAKER_02
Sign up, yeah.
SPEAKER_04
Wow. So your wife and it kind of goes on a wave for 15.
SPEAKER_02
What is it for six weeks?
SPEAKER_04
You're yeah, it's six weeks, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Do so so how do you where do you get the new business from? Is that all from the referral partners for this too? Or do you have like uh you buy leave?
SPEAKER_04
Not like nine uh uh uh nine, like uh with uh uh over with ACA business, it's over 90 percent coming from referral partners.
SPEAKER_00
Wow, hmm. And that's the old people and and the other just for for in case Jason doesn't know that that would be the old people.
SPEAKER_04
Uh uh the no, that would be Medicare. Yeah, that's yeah, that's the 65 and our under 65 market.
SPEAKER_02
For somebody like K Jason might not know the acronym, what does ACA stand for? Affordable Care Act.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, that's the Obamacare.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Don't think about it too much.
SPEAKER_04
I try not to I try not to use the Obamacare term because it it elicits like specific feelings in everyone that hears it.
SPEAKER_02
Right.
SPEAKER_04
That makes sense. It's either like you either like, oh okay, cool, or you're like, I don't want anything to do with it. I call it what it is.
SPEAKER_02
Knows that Craig and I had no idea what ACA is and we're insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_04
Oh yeah, I mean it's most people don't like don't even operate. Like I found like most agencies do not deal in it at all.
unknown
Really?
SPEAKER_00
If you ask me about dials contacts, um uh transfers, quota transfers, and sales, I'm good at that. Property.
SPEAKER_04
Very narrow auto property, yes. Narrow and yeah, narrow indeed.
SPEAKER_00
And how to acquire.
SPEAKER_04
Yes. Um, but yeah, so like it's uh like the vast majority of like a business in every line is coming from referral partners. So like most of my marketing is uh I'd say for every dollar that I spend in in marketing, 75, maybe even 80 cents is actually geared towards creating value for a referral partner.
SPEAKER_02
That's awesome.
SPEAKER_04
Because the more you can keep like uh opportunities in front of them, like the more that you're like the more my name can be in their inbox, the better.
SPEAKER_02
Love it. What would be uh so if you started all over again, um and you you've obviously been through uh different way different versions, you know, every few years, um what would you what would you do like what would be the fast track? What would take you to where you are today? What would you focus on? And if somebody's coming into this, what would you what would that advice be?
SPEAKER_04
Uh if I were starting all over again, I I would have probably tried to get to the like a setup that I have now as quickly as possible, like fully independent, everything's like uh under my shingle. Uh and uh I would have I I and it's not feasible advice for everyone, but it's uh as much as you can afford to pump back into your marketing every year, like like increase it like every chance you get. Yeah because it's gonna continue to pay off.
SPEAKER_02
Like that we always preach that. It always goes back to marketing, like those agents that don't spend are the ones that are complaining about the whole market situation and everything that's going on.
SPEAKER_04
Absolutely, and it's uh I think I've I think I've even heard like y'all say it like if I like can I could invest like a hundred dollars into an index fund and hope that the index returns an average eight percent a year, or I can have far more control over what happens with with that hundred dollars and try to create a rate of return inside my business of like 10 to 20 percent every year. Like kind of a no-brainer.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, no-brainer. Any of these things, you're paying some other person to manage it, pay all those embedded capital gains, all that other stuff. So you're losing uh you know three to four percent just just off the top before it even tanks or grows. But I mean it's the top. So you lost 35 just to be able to have the honor of paying somebody else five percent to lose your money. Why not lose your own money by investing in your business? I mean, if you're gonna lose it, and and if you're not, you're not gonna lose it. That's the thing, right? You if you make the right process, money in, money out.
SPEAKER_04
Yep, and it's like and even like outside of uh uh the financial cost, like you mentioned, of uh like investing like in the market, like uh I would much rather be the one in control of what's happening with the business or businesses that I'm investing in than like I hope I hope they're run well. Like it seems like like at least once a week you're finding out that some business that like was once like on top of its game has like fallen from glory. Yeah, way. I read an article this morning about uh was it SAP, like the the tech company SAP that's like lost like like double digit, like like large double digit like market cap losses, all because they couldn't get to cloud computing fast enough.
SPEAKER_00
Oh yeah, it's like and a lot of I'd rather be in control, yeah. Well, a lot of businesses drive are are now suffering because they pulled marketing going into COVID, and like we did the opposite. We literally we had a meeting, and that's right when we launched the the uh the teledudes part, you know. And so not only did we put the pedal to the metal with us, but we launched the other thing because everybody needs to make phone calls. I mean, that's at the end of the day, if you're not reaching out, and guess what? Everybody was home, people are still home, and they're probably gonna be home next year. So, I mean, I'll take those extra contacts all day long. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04
My operating expenses since COVID, like from like pre-COVID to like shortly after, probably went up. I I haven't actually like done the math because I'm I'm afraid to actually see the number. Uh, but uh if I were gonna ballpark it, it's probably 3x like what I was spending before. I was like and part of it was like I could uh I can probably I have a lot more purchasing power right now than than I might have had like uh back in January, February, because there's uh uh there's more availability. Yep.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. Awesome, Josh. What would you uh if somebody wants to get a hold of you interested in uh reaching out, what where where could they see you? Where the where can they get some info on you?
SPEAKER_04
Oh yeah, but uh they could uh Google the agency, it's AFL Financial. Uh uh and we're in uh Greenville, South Carolina. Nice. Is it green there? It is, it's very green.
SPEAKER_00
Nice. It's not green here. It's not in Arizona, it's brown, it's brown and everything bites. Oh yeah, including Craig. The plants, the birds, the wives, mammals, the wives, everybody. They all bite.
SPEAKER_04
The uh I've been to Arizona once, but I was I was young. I wasn't yeah, probably like in middle school.
SPEAKER_00
Well, just if anybody uh if you hear anybody talking about Arizona, we have closed the borders and we're not taking anybody else from California. So thank you. I don't know anyone in California, so we've reached capacity from uh the Californians, and uh we'll we'll let's end it at that. Um appreciate it so much, Joshua. It's been awesome to have you on the uh podcast. Uh we'll we'll post your link if anybody wants to wants to jump on and see that. And uh it's been awesome, man. Really good information. Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_02
I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00
Bye, dude.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, thanks, man.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. Thanks. Have a good one.
SPEAKER_01
Yep, bye. Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 in premium, even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03
They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_01
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03
Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_01
Live.teled.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03
Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content, right?
SPEAKER_01
Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them?
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm in. Are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 5202142219.
SPEAKER_01
All right, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03
Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_00
I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.