The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Joshua StephensWe Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!------------------------------------------------------------...
I I think if people saw the lead up to before we boomed, they would be like, what? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Joshua.
SPEAKER_00
Already two.
SPEAKER_03
What's up, my man?
SPEAKER_00
Just trying to sell some insurance. Nice.
SPEAKER_03
Everybody's favorite thing. I'm excited about this one. Oh. Yeah, before we dive in, why don't we hit a round of speed breakers? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Icebreaker to get to know you a little better. Let's go.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_02
It's the first thing.
SPEAKER_03
First thing that comes to mind, you gotta go quick. You only have two seconds, or I'll move to the next one.
unknown
Oh.
SPEAKER_00
Are you ready?
SPEAKER_03
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Probably not, but.
SPEAKER_03
You ready?
unknown
I love it.
SPEAKER_03
Alright, here we go. Speedbreakers. Ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_00
No. Oh, that's a lie. I have.
SPEAKER_03
Yes. Perfect. First crush.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, Brittany in the third grade.
SPEAKER_03
Most embarrassing thing your mom caught you doing.
SPEAKER_00
That's a stunning. Probably like in a lie.
SPEAKER_03
Fastest speed you've ever driven.
SPEAKER_00
130 miles per hour.
SPEAKER_03
Ooh, that's about where I was. Favorite cereal?
SPEAKER_00
Cinnamon touch crunch.
SPEAKER_03
Nice. Good one. How many kids?
SPEAKER_00
Two.
SPEAKER_03
Have you made cry? You gotta wait till the end of the question, please.
SPEAKER_00
Say that one again?
SPEAKER_03
How many kids have you made cry?
SPEAKER_00
Oh, uh like two.
SPEAKER_03
Two. Good. Count chocula or count Dracula?
SPEAKER_00
Dracula.
SPEAKER_03
Fastest mile.
SPEAKER_00
Fastest mile, but seven minutes.
SPEAKER_03
Nice. Favorite flavor?
SPEAKER_00
Chocolate?
SPEAKER_03
Good answer. Or peanut butter.
SPEAKER_00
Peanut butter. It's peanut butter.
SPEAKER_03
Peanut butter. Dogs or cats?
SPEAKER_00
Dogs.
SPEAKER_03
We're almost there. Tacos or burritos.
SPEAKER_00
Burritos.
SPEAKER_03
And leading up to next week, Trump or Biden? You don't have to answer that one.
SPEAKER_00
I'm gonna go ahead and clean the fifth on that one.
SPEAKER_03
You did really well on Speedbreaker. So Joshua Stevens. Welcome to the insurance dudes. So you are uh a partner at is this right? AFL Financial? No.
SPEAKER_00
Yes.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Firefly is.
SPEAKER_00
Technically, I'm the only I'm the only active partner. I have a couple of like silent partners.
SPEAKER_03
Self-partner. Love it. So so um, and then I see modern woodsman of America.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, that was uh that was a while ago.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, okay.
SPEAKER_00
That was uh that's where I cut my that's where I cut my teeth in the insurance business.
SPEAKER_03
Awesome, awesome. So why don't why don't you tell us how you got into insurance, where you came from, go back to the beginning.
SPEAKER_00
All right. Uh uh I I came into insurance, I I guess you'd say like do a like a series of unfortunate events. Like us all. Uh I was uh uh when I was a little bit younger, but uh still like technically an adult. I uh well going all the way back to childhood, like I didn't know what kind of business I wanted to own, but like it was like whenever anyone asked, I was like, I just know that I don't want to have like a real boss. Yeah, and so uh the first opportunity that I uh that presented itself to me to uh own a business, like I was like, I'm a smart guy, I'll figure it out. And made literally every mistake that that you can make uh in a business. Uh and uh when I finally uh decided to tuck my tail and uh and get out of there, my wife was like, you need to go get a get a real job for a while. Yeah. And uh I uh uh found uh the opportunity with uh uh uh Modern Woodman, which you mentioned, uh which they're a fraternal uh life insurance company.
SPEAKER_03
Okay.
SPEAKER_00
Uh and what does that mean? A fraternal they have not-for-profit status. Uh it's uh and uh they're uh so like you have like mutuals are like essentially like stock companies, fraternals are uh like uh not-for-profits for the benefit of the members. Got it. And so I knew that.
SPEAKER_02
I just asking, I was checking for Craig because Craig didn't got you.
SPEAKER_00
I was gonna ask just in case Jason doesn't know what that is, then um and it was there were some interesting uh like uh like language like differences there too. Like it was very like uh you did not use the word policy, uh everything it was certificates uh uh theme. They weren't uh clients, they were members.
SPEAKER_02
Okay.
SPEAKER_00
Uh but uh uh but it was I mean it was a great organization, and uh uh I learned a lot about the life insurance business.
SPEAKER_02
And uh and just exciting right out of the gate for you.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. You had some good inventors over there? I did, I did. Uh uh, especially because they also had uh a broker dealer side of the business, which was really interesting to me. So I I got to learn the security side of the business also. Nice. But when I when I was decided that that was what I was gonna do, uh like my wife uh affectionately said, like, uh, I told you to get a job, and you went and got a like commission only job. I'm like, yeah, you did not clarify that I had to go get a nine to five like uh like salary job. You just get a job. So I did. Nice.
SPEAKER_02
Right, without a paycheck, right?
SPEAKER_00
She's thinking yes, yeah. Oh yeah. Uh and of course they they had think like like like like guarantees which were just draws on future income.
SPEAKER_05
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Um but uh but luckily I I uh uh I had success uh like well relatively speaking, uh pretty quick out of the gate. But uh as you know, like the life insurance, uh where one big thing where the life insurance side is much different than property and casualty is uh the like the upfront pay is uh is better, but oh yeah the residual is like little to none. Right. Um and uh that was one of the many things that enticed me on the property and casualty side to uh to make that switch. Uh and so like I did I was with them for exactly two years. Okay. And uh another one of those moments where my wife was like, really? Well uh was You put in two years, and I put in two years, and I made the switch. Uh and when I made the switch, I didn't like go to work for uh another agency. It's like no, I'm just gonna start one, just like like do it myself. Uh and I did that like when our uh youngest daughter was like two or three weeks old.
SPEAKER_02
Oh perfect timing. You're not getting sleep, the wife can't sleep, and now you're gonna start a new career over again.
SPEAKER_00
Yes. I was like, it it's like like I've been doing this for a couple years, and of course that was like like actual naive like thinking, because it was like, how different can it be than than life? Like if anything, life's harder. Like uh it didn't take long for me to realize like how wrong I was about that.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, yeah. Life, life and uh PC are definitely I mean they're both difficult, they're two different beats. Um and patience is a huge one with with life. Uh so that is interesting because usually people start with P and C and then go to life or something like that. So go going from life to PC, this is an interesting story because you don't hear it so often.
SPEAKER_00
Uh yeah, it it is and it is like one of the things I've like found like fascinating, just like having conversations with people and like with different experiences like throughout insurance is uh I mean you come across several people that are uh licensed in both they were heavily like uh lean towards one or the other, and that's typically the way that's always leaned. It's either I've always done TNC and I've got a life license so that I can cross-sell and that type of thing, or it's vice versa. Uh and uh whichever side that you are firmly on is like the natural inclination is the other side is way more difficult than than what you do. Like it's it's fascinating like to talk to PNC people that are like, oh god, like I can't imagine doing like like like straight life. And it's like people on the life side like like and typically people that are like much heavily, much more heavy on the the life side, rarely, if ever, are actually even deal in property and casualty, right? From what I from what I've like uh experienced. Yeah, but isn't it? And they just naturally think it's very difficult.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, PNC side is like the peasants, right?
SPEAKER_00
It's like the uh looked at like the uh like the blue-collar workers of the it was actually like from the now uh before I was in PNC at all, like the uh what I found was among people like in the life business, like was more times than not, it was like uh respectful of the property and casualty because I just believed that like it's far more complicated than than my simple brain can can manage. Like way way more moving parts, which there are more moving parts, but it's just like anything else, the more you do it, the more comfortable you get.
SPEAKER_02
Yep. And maybe that's the difference, right? Is that it if they're so different, like one you know, uh P and C you have to move fast to be able to produce the numbers that make sense, and life takes a lot longer, and it's patience, and you get a bigger payoff, and it's just two different mindsets. So uh if you're looking from either direction, the other one seems insane because there's the other two completely different cell cycles. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
And it's uh the uh and so like and what I I tend to to think of it as like like PNC is uh difficult because like there are more moving parts uh to the policies, but they're like it's uh uh there can be more than one claim over the life of this policy.
SPEAKER_02
That's true, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
And for several different things, right uh the and people want it quick. Like it's like they make up their mind they want to see if they can save money, they want it to be done like yesterday. Yep. Uh and with life, it's uh uh it is it's a much it's a longer sell cycle, and that's not just like the upfront sell, because you've got to sell it to the prospect, and then you've got to sell it to the underwriter.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, oh yeah. Well, and then from a mark, so so you left there um and you're you're doing did you start a scratch, like you just started from from the ground up again?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so uh officially, so like I started my agency and I I uh within my agency I got uh some life appointments through like an FMO, uh and uh and I got some health carrier appointments. Had never like really done health, but uh I'd gotten enough like questions from prospects and clients about it. I was like, there's oh so there's a market there. So like I started, and at the time uh in South Carolina, we only had one uh we only had one carrier still offering ACA uh in the state. Uh this year we're gonna have four. Uh uh and so uh it's gotten like four times as complicated in the last two years uh for uh for health. Uh but I was uh partnering with uh with another uh PNC agency uh initially uh for the the little bit of property and casualty business that I was actually doing. Um again, because I like I found that like uh it's more than just like passing the test. That was one thing with like with the life uh licensing, I felt like uh actually passing the exam, like, okay, I know everything I need to know to be able to have the conversation with someone uh and be able to explain the differences and the different types of policies and options and that type of stuff. And it was just a matter of being able to learn how to quote apply and that all that type of stuff. And with property and casualty, it is much more like like study to take the exam so they give you a license, and then you can go and learn how to do this. Uh the and so I've I found like uh pretty quickly that uh I don't know enough to be fast enough to be ultra competitive, and I didn't know how to get appointments. So uh I partnered up with the other agency, still was not doing a ton of property and casualty, uh, kind of flipped that switch to actually like uh do it uh in-house uh really just like what are we October? Uh like about eight months ago. And so like it's really only that uh what I would consider like my time, like like actually focused on property and casualty is only been for a short period of time.
SPEAKER_05
Okay.
SPEAKER_00
I had like a what if two-year learning period, and then I've really kind of been attacking it for the past we'll say year.
SPEAKER_02
What have you learned that what what were some of the the big mind mind opening things that that you've experienced with that um now being involved in that?
SPEAKER_00
Uh it much more suits my like uh like the way that I operate, especially uh commercial. Like I I much prefer commercial to personal lines. Uh I have a CSR that I like I try to push all personal lines to her. Uh uh because like I I strive in like solving problems, and the more complicated the better. And so with commercial, that gives me a chance to actually like use my brain a little bit. And uh and it's not as okay, yeah, you've got a home, how old's the roof? Right. You have a pole, trampoline, that type of thing. Yeah, like it's the same thing, like just rinse and repeat. Uh but I mean, even with uh commercial, like two different like businesses in the exact same uh uh industry are going to be compared like vastly different. And so it's a lot more like uh in-depth conversations, getting to know uh who the prospect is and uh uh and uh and piecing it all together.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, commercial policies are just they're such a beast to compare with the standard auto or home uh policy, and there's so much to it, and you have to have relationships with multiple carriers because there's so many different risks. What can seem like the same risk can be completely different, um, just based on all the different facts.
SPEAKER_00
I mean, yeah, everybody's business is but just one thing, like like one thing can like like like uh uh completely uh change the outlook uh of a business to an underwriter. Yep. As an example, like I do a lot of garages, like like uh auto garages, and okay uh like you take one that like uh even like touches motorcycles, we're talking about a completely different type of business. Really? From a carrier standpoint.
SPEAKER_02
Do do they see that as higher risk adding motorcycles?
SPEAKER_00
Okay. Absolutely. Crazy a lot of them see like like uh garages working on motorcycles the same as they like see them working on uh 18-wheelers. Oh like it's almost no differentiation between those two things. That's crazy. And that's just an exact like I'm uh uh I need to like I I feel like I have mental stimulation throughout the day. And if I were just like uh sitting here like like like processing like home auto umbrellas, like I I would I'd lose my mind.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. Yeah, it is it's it's almost like a puzzle, right? Each business is so unique. I mean, just like I can run my everybody thinks insurance is the same, right? But even one PNC office can run so differently than than the next, and with business insurance, it's I mean, it's all different. There's not two that are that run the exact same, right?
SPEAKER_05
Yes to be continue.
SPEAKER_04
Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_05
Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_04
Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and and learn how to do uh 100,000 in premium, even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_01
They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process. Super awesome.
SPEAKER_04
I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_01
Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04
Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_01
Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content. Right? Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them? Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Greg, are you going to respond to these texts? I'm going to respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's going to be awesome. And it's a it's going to be our new texting community where we're going to get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean, everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520-214-2219.
SPEAKER_04
Alright, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01
Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_03
I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.