The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
David Denning Jumpstarts Agency Marketing With Secret Playbook part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Intern Dude Podcast.
SPEAKER_05I it's it's it's interesting. Um having so I have a we have some um some groups also. I mean there's a trillion of these Facebook groups on the Facebook. Um but one of the one of the things that that comes up constantly, and you said it earlier, is you know, which which lead company are you using? Which lead company are using? You see it over and over and over again. I think it's entirely the wrong question, right? Like the the question that they should be asking is what process do you follow when you get leads? Because the leads don't matter. The leads don't matter, right? We talked a little bit on on your thing. It's like if you can't, if if it's a zero percent contact rate, they suck. If it's 10 or better, they're good. That's it, right? It doesn't really matter because what you do with those leads at that point is what does matter. And so you know, you'll ask people how many times you call on them? Three, four, I mean, four is about tops, you know, and it takes it takes so many dials, so many dials.
SPEAKER_00Well, is it the average average to even get in contact with them if you don't get them on the initial one is like nine or ten, something around there, and then average per average amount of contacts for purchasing decisions like up to 20 something. So, you know, your four or five dials is not gonna set you up for a high contact rate for sure. Um, especially if the only thing you're doing is dialing. I mean, with text, email, messaging, you know, all these different ways of getting in contact with people, people don't answer the phones as much anymore because you know, most of it's spam. Um, most of it's, you know, people you know trying to sell them something, which obviously we're trying to get in touch with them because we know we can help them and we do want to help them. But, you know, especially millennials and millennials would rather like you know jump out a window than answer a phone. So if you can hit them up through, you know, text or messenger or something like that, something they're not gonna leave unread. I mean, like, I don't know about you guys. If I have a voicemail, if I like was using ringless voicemail or something, or if I have a text or a Facebook message, I'm gonna read it. Like, I'm I hate uh maybe it's me, I'm OCD, maybe, but I I don't like leaving those things unread. Like, who left me a voicemail? What is it? Is it important? Okay, I'm gonna listen to it. So, but if I see a number, in fact, the phones now are getting so good at recognizing spam numbers, and that you know it'll just be like probably spam or spam number. I'm like, okay, well, I'm definitely not answering that. And I've had legitimate businesses call me that it's flagged them as that on my phone. So I can only imagine what people that are are really, really doing those are getting flagged as. So I mean, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yep, I know. And and now with the new iOS 14 and the new version of um Android, they just updated it where numbers are getting uh uh are getting Marcus spam like so easily it's unreal.
SPEAKER_05Yep.
SPEAKER_02So then there's you know you gotta put in systems in place to overcome those things and and don't use your personal number for your dials and your calls.
SPEAKER_00You don't want your personal number getting mark to spam. Uh yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It's definitely it's definitely interesting how the um the questions are. You're asking the wrong questions because it really does come down to uh I I guess for leads it would be processed because with the right process in place, the the the leads over time really only move it move the needle so much. You know what I mean? The right process can move all the leads to a good spot or or move them to where none of them get results. So right.
SPEAKER_00And at some point that's gonna involve at least some sort of automation or software at some point. I mean, you're you're only gonna be able to do so much manually at scale unless you opt to invest in you know very expensive type leads that, yeah, your contact rate may be way higher. I mean, I think that's something too, is most agents don't really recognize the or realize the different types of leads that they can get. It's like, oh, everything's internet leads or you know, everything's data, or or or on the opposite end, I expect every lead to have the you know, credit card ready when they answer the phone and ready to purchase insurance right then and there. And you know, in reality, I think you know, a lot fall kind of in the in-between spectrum. Yeah, you can pay a lot for and get a little, especially if you haven't done due diligence or ever. But um, realizing that there is such a thing as data, there is such a thing as short form, there's such a thing as age leads, there is real-time leads, there is live transfers, there is all these kind of different ones, you know, they don't necessarily realize that. And so they go with you know, maybe internet leads, but they have no process. And so they're just kind of manually calling them a couple times and hoping it works out, which is not the way to be effective internet leads. So, as you guys probably well know, so yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, well, and then back to those metrics on them. You know, if they're not looking back at the metrics, then so if you're you know, I I don't know what a premium lead costs because I wouldn't ever get that, but but it's what twenty if it's 20 bucks for some lead that's supposedly better. I mean, you got to sell one in five for it to be uh worth it, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean it all depends on what line of insurance and stuff as well, you know. Yeah, I guess that's true. For PC, yeah, if you're making 50 bucks off a new auto policy or 150 off a new home or something like that, yeah, you need to convert a significant amount of those. Right. But yeah, if you're final expense or something like that, where you're making, you know, 500,000 plus off a sale, then okay, maybe it's a little different. And so I mean, that's that's the thing too. All the lines are totally different, you know. Um, but it all once again, it all does it doesn't matter because it all comes down to your metrics and your tracking. Um you're generating ROI, that's that's what matters at the end of the day. It doesn't matter.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_02What's the what are some uh some I mean, obviously this year has been been nuts, uh this year's been nuts, right? So what are some trends that you've seen uh throughout this across all the different lines of insurance? And uh what what are some ways that people have adapted to it to really crush it?
SPEAKER_00That's a great question because those discussions have been going on all year in the group and when I've been talking with people, and it's been super interesting. Like life and health for the most side has had their best year ever and best record months ever, because everybody's thinking about it and talking about it and concerned about it. And so it, you know, they're they're not really having to convince people that you know that this is, you know, because you know, in in the past it's been, yeah, this is intangible. Like you guys mentioned, you know, really all insurance is intangible, you can't really touch it or ever. But when you see people dying and affected, you know, health-wise with COVID and passing away and families left with GoFundMeans and all that sort of stuff, health and life insurance is on their minds constantly. So they've been doing quite well. Um, I have in all not so much in PNC because PNC does a lot of telesales in general, but on life and health, there is a lot of face-to-face focused um agencies and agents that that's all they did. And and absolutely, you know, it's great to sit down face to face and be able to read that, but they've had to shift heavily over into the telemarketing side or sorry, the telesales side and um or Zoom calls or whatever and stuff. And so for some of them, it's been hugely challenging, especially for these career face-to-face agents that have been doing this for decades or whatever. It's like, well, now I'm supposed to shift over and talk on the phone. And it's been a struggle for a lot. And but for some, they've adapted and picked that up that skill. And now, uh, you know, once COVID kind of slows down and stuff, they have both skills. They can sell from the home, they can go face to face. They have the options there at least. And I think for a lot of the agents that have always done telesales, I mean, they they were they were almost, you know, is like Christmas to them because they're like, I've already been doing this, I'm already good at this, I didn't have to change anything, and now I'm getting much higher contact rate, much more people interested, I'm selling a bunch more, and I've had this the skill that you know now is translating. On the PNC side, I think a lot of them did, you know, take hits a lot during during this year, or at least initially during this year. Um, you know, some you know, some people just view it as an expense rather than really um peace of mind and having the proper coverage when things eventually at some point do go wrong. Um, and then especially the commercial side. Uh businesses really slowed down on on everything and looking at expenses once this went down because a lot of them, like, can I even keep my employees? Is my business even able to stay open? You look at restaurants and all these things that you know were were shut down or had to hold up. And so, yeah, commercial um, commercial agents had it had a tough time. Um, I think it is shaken back a little bit now. But yeah, initially um it was pretty rough. I mean, we had one one um agency owner come into our program. She had gone four months with no new business on the commercial side and just had some, you know, a little bit of renewals coming in, but office was in a mall and the mall was shut down to COVID, so she couldn't work out of her office and you know, let go of her office admin she'd had forever and send that home. Like, can I even keep my agency open or ever? And uh and yeah, we we helped her out a little bit. Now now she's got like four producers and office admin back and is doing quite well now. But but I think a lot of agents ended up in that position. It was, you know, if especially if they were were hit pretty hard, like man, how long can I can I do this? How long can I survive with with this whole how the industry's changed, or if they've refused to adapt. And that's another thing, just refusing to adapt. I mean, this industry, you gotta be a little flexible and adaptable. And whether that's a new software or a new technique, uh, new, you know, whatever it is, you gotta adapt and kind of that's just business in general, I guess.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, anything. I mean, you you know that times are gonna change. Bob Dylan said so. And so we we have to be well, never mind. I guess I've heard the name before. You you have that, I'm pretty sure. You gotta be kidding me. But but honestly, if if you're not able to move and change and do these things, like I mean, look, I'm 90 and all of a sudden I learned how to do internet leads. And now I look younger. So but but really it is. I I mean, I at one point did say they suck, I did all that, and and it it it's true. It's it's all about the process, and usually it is it, you know, when things go wrong, it's gonna fall on the shoulders of the of the agency owner and whether they can they can look at themselves in the mirror and accept that responsibility. You know, some some folks can't, they want to point the finger. So um, you know, if we could break through with anybody on anything, I know you talk about it with people too. It's like, look, it's it is what it is. If they change the commission structure, if they change it, you know, you gotta there's nothing you can do about it, but but hanging out with five people that are also complaining about it is gonna get you nowhere, it's gonna bring you down, bring you down.
SPEAKER_00So run. Locus of control, right? You know, external locus of control. Everything happens to me. I have, I know I can't go, hey, the leads are bad, I'm just at a bad agency, you know. You know, I don't have the right, you know, dialer system or whatever. Like, that's why I'm not successful versus the internal locus of control, like I'm in control of how things work out, and you know, and the people that have that mindset and that focus are the ones, they're the top eight percent. You know, that's another thing they have in common. They're the ones that know they control where they're at and their destiness destiny, and they're putting that that work, that time, building the connections, all that sort of stuff in, and you know, they reap the results out of it. When you have that like everything happens to me mindset, it this this industry is gonna be real rough for you because uh it really does come down to to you at the end of the day.
SPEAKER_05And yeah, you know, a problem for every solution. Yeah. Say what? Sorry, I cut you off. Uh a pro I just said a problem for every solution. Yeah, there's this it's just like uh stop.
SPEAKER_00I mean, that's I mean that's another thing you hear every day, too, is yeah, and and there's not too much you can do about it. If you don't have the right mindset at the very beginning, and I know you guys were talking about that on Monday, um, is not nothing else really is gonna matter. I mean, you can have all the you know the best systems and processes and everything, but if you're already going into it like I'm probably not gonna make it, I'm probably gonna fail, like, oh I should probably go ahead and start looking at other jobs and other stuff like that. You're you already have have failed. Like you're not gonna make it when you have that mindset. It all starts with that.
SPEAKER_02So that is no matter what, like that is the number one, as Craig and I have put together some trainings and stuff. Um and we've interviewed everybody and and all this, all the data that we have, the number one thing is the mindset. Where there's a will, there's a way. And and that's what that's what the most successful people in the world doing with other industries, as we've talked about that were incredibly successful. It's just a different mindset. So it always starts with that. Like that's the first thing in any training, even if you're training your your team or anything else, it's all starts with the mindset, like hands down, because without that, there's no ground to stand on.
SPEAKER_05Well, and we're humans, we're gonna get down, you're gonna have a bad day, and then you're gonna get on your pity potty and and do that whole thing. But if you're in the training, if you're around other people that have the proper mindset, then you're gonna get it, you know, you get out of it, and you're able to move. I you're about to say something. I can see this grin.
SPEAKER_00You said you set the timer. Uh you give yourself your your your 30 seconds, your five minutes, your hour, or whatever, your pity party, sure. And then that timer's up, you're you're back to it. You know, you had your little time. But yeah, I mean, can't you can't stay down, you can't stay negative, you can't focus on you know the negatives or whatever. I mean, every no is one step closer to a yes statistically, you know. That's but that's the great part of looking at it as a numbers game because it is orever, that you know, hey, it's a numbers game, right? Like if I'm getting those, eventually I'm getting that yes. If I'm calling enough times, eventually I'm getting connected with people and getting that sale. And so, yeah, you look at it that frame versus like, oh, I got another no, I got another no. It's like, but yeah, you got you know five sales today. Yeah, but I got eight no's or you know, twenty no's or whatever. It's like, does it matter? Like you got the five sales. So yeah.
SPEAKER_02You're always gonna get a ton more no's than yeses. And I always say it's not how you handle the yeses, it's how you handle the no's. The no's take you to the yeses, and if you can't get through the no's, then you can't get to the yeses.
SPEAKER_00I mean any any fun stuff with your agents or whatever, like you know, the solo cups with the beads or whatever and stuff, and you you know take each one out each time you get a no and you know that that much closer to a yes or whatever. I mean, you guys, I think you guys probably do the feats, right? Where you you click off each each dial or whatever, um, and like do your certain amount of dials or whatever.
SPEAKER_05Um they just take a knife and one, two.
SPEAKER_01After a certain amount of no's, I think I don't think that's gonna be the most way of doing it.
SPEAKER_05It's like I can have 10 10 no's a day and then well they can see and tells them, you know, they they know, and and at the end of the day, it's it's just they just know what they need to do. You know, they need to be on the phone for four hours, they need to do a hundred dials, they need to take a bunch of transfers, they need to quote 10 households. I mean, anybody that is looking at their people and they see three quotes, I mean, dude, ain't gonna happen. Like it is not going to happen, you know. So it's like we look at this. Oh, I want to write 200,000. Okay, well, guess what? You got to do a whole lot of stuff over here for that to happen. Don't even look at that number. That number doesn't matter because that number is just a symptom of doing these things, right? It's the result that you get from that thing, and that leads into the other thing.
SPEAKER_00Like mindset, you're right, it's absolutely the foundation, the first thing. And if they don't have the right mindset, I mean there's not much you can do after that. Or if you're an agency owner with a right not the don't the right mindset, it's it's not going to go too far or ever. And so that's one of the first things we we typically focus on. And then the next one's what you're talking about, is those agents knowing their metrics and what they need to do and what their goals are and what they're trying to hit. And so that roadmap and goals and metrics and tracking is the next thing. Because you know, I'll also talk to so many that, like, oh, yeah, what's your AP goals this week and this month? When are you looking to bring on producers? What are your you know, metrics for tracking this ore? And they're like, I just want to sell a bunch and grow a big agency and be really successful. It's like, well, that's not really a plan, that's a hope and dream. Like, what are what are you doing to get to that point or ever? What's your what's your roadmap? What's you know, what are you measuring against every day and knowing what you're you're shooting for? And they a lot of them just don't have it. And so you can't hit what you don't have. Um, so I mean, and that's frustrating as a from a producer side too, as an agency owner, if your producers don't know what they need to be doing and what what success metrics look like for them, then they're also gonna struggle. Um, and you know, that's not fun to not know how you're being measured or you know what success even looks like. So yeah.
SPEAKER_02So, David, what would you say that is a a bunch of hot knowledge nuggets dropping all over this episode?
SPEAKER_05Dropping from 40,000 feet. It is unreal. Just hot knowledge nuggets.
SPEAKER_02What would be the number one piece of advice you'd give somebody coming in the industry right now to get them to that next level?
SPEAKER_00From an agent producer standpoint, finding yeah, agency owner standpoint. Agency owner standpoint. Okay, yeah, a new agency owner coming in, finding a the right program or um coaching, you know, mentorship, whatever that is, that's gonna help you avoid all those common mistakes that you know beginning new agency owners potentially make and really keep you on the right track with the right mindset, the right goals, the right framework for getting you to where you need to go and not letting you. I mean, because you guys, you know, it probably from when you were doing it, even though you guys probably had good uplines and trainings and stuff, but a lot come in and it's like, well, now I'm going from producer to agency owner potentially, and and now I'm in charge of a lot of different get people on the phone and sell them. Now I have to do hiring, now I have to do you know, all the cost, I have to do HR, I have to do all these things that all of a sudden like they're overwhelmed and they just don't know what to do. And so having someone be able to like, oh, here's the roadmap, here's step one, two, three, four, and here's how you you know you you move along that is is huge. And that would probably be my number one thing for new agency owners. It's not always about the contract percent, it's not always about you know the lead source, it's really about having someone and and avoiding those mistakes in the first place and having someone be able to help lay out that roadmap for you. And I think that's the quickest way to to accelerate to jumpstart you know that that process as a new agency owner.
SPEAKER_05Jumpstart go, right? Where and where where can they uh they can hook up with the group, just you can type jumpstart or um marketing for insurance agents in the Facebook, in the Facebook Google as literally a name marketing for insurance agents by jumpstart go.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, there you go. And they can uh very simple name. Uh it works out great.
SPEAKER_05And if you are listening, I we encourage you to go over to the YouTube channel, uh, subscribe, and then put in the comments whether or not he looks like Jon Snow.
SPEAKER_00Oh my hair. I think Mr.
SPEAKER_05David Denning does look like Jon Snow. I would say what is he like north of the wall? Cold, which is why I'm in Florida. So pass exactly. Well, awesome. Thank you so much for for uh coming on. Well, well, yeah, definitely gonna have to bring you back on down the road. Um, and you just dropped another knowledge bomb in our group as well.
SPEAKER_00So you guys are welcome anytime, of course.
SPEAKER_05Awesome, man.
SPEAKER_00So many knowledge moms.
SPEAKER_05Thanks so much.
SPEAKER_03Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_04They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting.
SPEAKER_03Are we gonna be there?
SPEAKER_04Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_04Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_04Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_03Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520 214 2219!
SPEAKER_03Alright, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_04Bye, Mr. Greg. Wait, can we even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_05I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman