The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
David Denning Jumpstarts Agency Marketing With Secret Playbook PART 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast.
SPEAKER_04Boom. David Denning. David Denning.
SPEAKER_00What's up? That's me. David's on here.
SPEAKER_01How you doing?
SPEAKER_00I'm good, man. Excited. It was uh excited having you guys on a live. You guys absolutely crushed it. So it's uh fun to hang out with you guys. Looking forward to it.
SPEAKER_01Thanks. That was two days ago, and uh we're back. It's like uh we're all working together all the time.
SPEAKER_00Exactly, man. I gotta get out there to your side of the country. So I don't know. Sunny f suddy sunny southern Florida is pretty nice, so um yeah. Yeah. Don't go don't visit Craig. It's too hot.
SPEAKER_04Oh so I'm in this room, my office at the house, and I got new windows. You would think that it would not be hot in here anymore. Guess what? Hottest room in the house, hottest room in the house. Is it this supercomputer? Probably probably it.
SPEAKER_01Too much processing power going on there. Processing before we start, we gotta go. First question.
SPEAKER_04Ooh, first question. Have you ever had a mullet?
SPEAKER_00Is that the first question? I don't know. The answer is no, not really. I have had hair down to my shoulders before, specifically just so I could get called Jon Snow. And so when it happened, I was the most excited in the world. The airport in Southeast Asia, someone's like, Oh, kind of look like Jon Snow. It's like bam, I'm done with this. Too hot now, I'm ready to cut it off. So I pretty much within a few weeks of that, I was like, okay, I accomplished what I set out for. I'm done. It was way too hot. And my hair is curly, so it gets crazy when it gets long. But I did have a mohawk though, uh, in South Africa when I was living there. There was a cherry that you'd shave off, you know, they'd give you a haircut or whatever, and you'd earn money for people donating or whatever for doing that. And people would get like shaved heads or mohawks or whatever and stuff. So I was like, you know what? My friends are having mohawks, I'll take one too, or whatever. Um, but I have super curly hair, and I don't know if you guys have ever seen a curly mohawk, but it looks really weird. Uh, but I kept that for a good three to six months. What do they call a curly mohawk? Because there's the question. I don't know. There's probably some term out there, I would have to imagine.
SPEAKER_04Well, you gotta be careful what you Google these days. I yeah. Reporter or something. So so are you suggesting we play a round of speed breakers? I think we should play speed breakers, Mr. Craig. Well, guess what? Is actually the first the first question. Are you ready for speed breakers? We gotta get through this in in under 20 seconds, and there's like 10 things.
SPEAKER_00Oh wow, okay.
SPEAKER_04You ready? First crush.
SPEAKER_00Uh Kira Knightley.
SPEAKER_04Most embarrassing thing your mom ever caught you doing.
SPEAKER_00Uh probably something inappropriate with my now wife. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Fastest speed ever driven.
SPEAKER_00Oh, uh maybe like 115, 120? I don't know. Serial? Oh, I don't even need cereal anymore, but uh I like Cocoa Buffs.
SPEAKER_04How many kids? Have you made cry?
SPEAKER_00Oh, have I made cry? Oh, probably at least 10, maybe 50. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04Count Dracula or Count Dracula?
SPEAKER_00Uh Dracula.
SPEAKER_04Fastest mile.
SPEAKER_00Running or driving? Because I'll take the driving quality. Yeah. Sub one minute mile driving, so yeah. Favorite flavor. Uh hot.
SPEAKER_04Dogs or cats? Dogs, for sure. Obviously, that's when we hang up on people. Tacos or burritos? Ooh.
SPEAKER_00Tacos. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Trump or Biden, you don't have to answer that question. Trump students.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Anybody but Trump, but that doesn't necessarily mean Biden, but yeah, how about that? Hopefully I didn't lose my fan base there, but whatever. Well, this is awesome. So let's dive. Libertarian, it's a third party. So I don't I'll I'll take neither side. That was the option.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, how about that? Love it. Stay silent. I don't touch that politics stuff.
SPEAKER_00Uh yeah, it's just too depressing. I try not to think about it.
SPEAKER_04Well, so so you're you you're in the insurance space here, uh, have a huge group with uh what there's over 15,000 in there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, getting close to 16. Yeah, that's a good group.
SPEAKER_04Good job.
SPEAKER_00Look of face.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So how did you gravitate? Why don't you tell your story how you got got over here, uh, what your how you are involved in insurance and what's going on? Cool.
SPEAKER_00How far back we want to go? I was born in 1989. And uh no, it's uh yeah, I've got yeah, it's uh qu I'll give you a very quick rundown, uh, because it's it's been a wild ride to even end up in this spot. So um uh my degree construction management project management. I mean treatments ended up in South Africa for a couple years and doing that and you know, coming back, you know, wanted to start a business that we could kind of run from wherever. We like travel, we like working in different parts of the world. So, you know, started up a business web agency with my wife, uh instilled business partner as well. And uh we ran that for a few years, met our partner Renee Cabrera, who had background in the insurance industry, he had been life licensed in the agent in the industry since like '95. And uh he had a company running AdWords and Facebook ads and social media for about 200 agents and agencies in the insurance industry. A lot of them were state farm uh back then. And uh he was like, hey, there's there's a huge need in this industry for you know good support and resources and training. A lot of people are thrown a contract and told figure it out. And I think there's a huge need for filling that gap in there. Um, and just a need for agents to connect and really learn what's out there too, because you don't know what you don't know. And when you talk with other agents, you're like, wait a second, um, you're getting all this support and these higher commission rates or all this stuff going on. Like, I didn't know that existed. And so, you know, we started the our group as really uh a place for us to initially connect with a lot of them and help out in a bunch of different ways, and uh for them to find referral partners, us to a bit of training, us to have, you know, top industry experts come in and talk about things and different stuff, and you know, us to find really quality resources and tools and stuff for them as well and help help kind of train them and also bring people in to do trainings and stuff in there. And so it's grown massively throughout the years. I don't think we ever knew it would kind of grow to where it did, um, and just mostly try to keep it super positive atmosphere where you know people don't get ripped apart for asking a newbie question because there's a lot of people, you know, just getting licensed to people that have been there 40 plus years. And so I kind of like that it's a good mix in there, so everybody's getting value out of it, is what our goal is.
SPEAKER_01So it is a good mix, and it is a I mean, the resources you go live all the time, and there's a ton of free training. I mean, how many times a week do you guys go live?
SPEAKER_00So we used to do a lot more. I used to do like two or three one-hour lives a week or whatever. So I've probably done like 400 plus lives at this point. So very familiar with Facebook Live and then also everything that can go wrong on one. So um at this point, yeah. But yeah, no, we now we go live about once a week on Mondays at 6 p.m. Eastern time is when we typically do them. And then we'll run watch parties throughout the week because we know people are busy duh selling insurance, and so we'll run watch parties and have it, you know, there throughout the week for them. And we'll occasionally do like you know some one-off trainings and stuff outside of that as well. We find doing too much agents are just busy, so I don't want to pull them away too much because they need to be actually you know selling, putting in the work. Like you can watch as many Facebook Live as you want, but it's not gonna help you do anything unless you can actually go apply stuff from it. So um, so yeah, you know, I do a lot though. I I I've been on camera way too much, I think.
SPEAKER_01So what are maybe like the top three things that you've learned? Um big biggest takeaways since you've gotten to talk to so many insurance agents.
SPEAKER_00Uh I think some of the biggest takeaways are that a lot of their issues, the vast majority, fall into similar categories. So, I mean, you're no one's alone out there. They're all struggling with a lot of the same things. And, you know, talking with thousands over these years, because I'll have a lot of individual calls with them to find out what they need help with or what's kind of going on with their business, or just connecting with them as well. And it all comes down to like, you know, first is the pipeline and filling that up, a consistent quality pipeline. You know, that's always the first. Like, and that's why all the questions are like, where's a good lead vendor? Who's a good lead vendor? Because everybody thinks there's this magical lead vendor that will solve all their problems. In reality, that's not the case, as you guys will know. Um, that it isn't just like find the right lead vendor and your problems are solved. But honestly, a lot of people get thrown into the contract and like, hey, go talk to your friends and family, and then after that, I have no idea, figure it out. And that's not a lot of fun to be in that spot. And then, you know, and then people to sales calls spend all the dialing one number after another when there's the most efficient or more efficient resources and tools out there, like Teledudes, for example. Um, you know, a little soft bitch. Uh but yeah, but uh yeah, I mean, there's much better ways and software and tools and different things out there to not spend all your time trying to get people those appointments, but rather spend all your time on those appointments actually helping people and making money for your producers for you, and then sales, and then obviously hiring and scaling an agency. Everything kind of falls within those categories.
SPEAKER_04So yeah, it's interesting because um you can people can get in the especially when you come in new and you're in this business, you think that um obviously you have to hustle, and and they'll tie that hustle to any kind of hustle. If I'm hustling, then I'm doing a good job, right? And so, like you said, to your point, calling that same number 10,000 times may feel like hustling, but it's probably not the best use. The the most important thing they can do is be on those appointments all day long, right? Even if it costs money to create those appointments, they're gonna make more money by doing that. If they spend half their day, you know, there's some metric that they make money as a result of the appointment or the number of appointments. And so if you spend half the day trying to get the appointments, well, you just wasted half that day when you could have paid for somebody to do it.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, I think this thing needs to be changed like activity breeds success. It's really the right activity breed success. Smoot. But it's not it's not really gonna breed success. Like I can I can go out and knock every door in the city, but is that the best use of time with trying to find people to purchase insurance? Probably not. But I hustled real hard. I probably passed out and died in southern Florida doing that. But you know, there's better, better ways to do it. So yeah.
SPEAKER_04So what are some of the ways to do it that you've seen?
SPEAKER_00Well, I mean, as far as like the pipeline in general, it's normally having a pretty good mix of of organic social media, strategic referral partner relationships, generating your own, and then working with vendors. And between all that, really having you know a consistent pipeline that isn't all your eggs in one basket and relying in one spot. And so um, you know, a lot of people you have these people out here, you know, I would never buy a lead in my life, you know, that's you know, a waste of money and a waste of time. It's like, wait a second, you're exchanging money uh and exchange, you know, in the for having additional time and having those given to you, and you know it's a numbers game at that point. And at the end of the day, it is a numbers game, you know. And you I mean, I've seen your guys' you know, worksheets and and everything. It's a you know, you guys know it's a numbers game. You know, if I have this many leads with this much contact rate, and this is my closing rate, and this is my average, you know, AP or whatever, then this is my ROI. You know, people people like, oh, I've never spent any money on leads, and you know, I'll you know, I'll sell 10,000 AP or you know, whatever type of insurance for selling, 10,000 AP a week. I was like, well, I could do leads, and yeah, I'm paying, I'm paying like you know, 5,000 in leads maybe, but I'm doing like 25,000 in AP. It's like it's the scalability factor and ROI factor that I think a lot of people just look at you know, leads and really anything in their business as an expense rather than investment and really gauging stuff by the return. Like if I can do a five times return versus a one-time return, why wouldn't I do the five times even if it cost me some money?
SPEAKER_01So and how have you been able to talk to agents that were in that first mindset and move them along and and show them and have them uh have success after that?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think I think a bit of it's building up the trust and what they can do with the resources that they have at first. I mean, if if people don't have a budget of money to spend, they don't have a budget of money to spend. Now, I know, you know, hey, if really you'll you'll find it if it's that important to you. You'll rack up the credit card and you'll pay off the credit card after investing. I know Craig kind of talked about that initially when he was getting going, and you know, that's that's taking the risk, risking it to get the biscuit, right? Um, you're you're you're putting in the investment, you're going for it. And you and you'll get it done too. When you have that sitting out there on the card, you're like, you know what, I'm I'm getting this thing done because out there that I gotta get paid off, and you know, ultimately I got into this to make money, not not uh have additional debt. But yeah, um, but yeah, when I'm talking to them, you know, yeah, agents come all the time. Like, I don't have a budget, you know, I don't have you know money to purchase leads. And it's like, okay, well, let's look at what you're currently doing. You know, uh, do you have stuff coming in for strategic strategic referral partners? And then do you have stuff coming in off your social media? They're like normally like, no, I, you know, I call family and friends and I go knock doors or whatever, or I, you know, pull out a phone book and I call numbers. Well, it's like, okay, well, there's there's ways to generate, you know, free in exchange of your time, leads off of social media and spending the time on those relationships or even networking and stuff. And then yeah, as you get additional budget, you can now exchange that money for that time and you can now start working leads or generating your own leads. And so it's really meeting them where they're at and helping them kind of achieve a level of success um and then helping them scale that from there. So if they don't they don't have the budget to kind of really start working this stuff, then we'll we'll work with them where they're at and then get them to that point. Like with uh the closures quick or ever, when we had, you know, people come in. We had you know, first questions are always like, Hey, I need a good lead vendor, I need a good lead source because I want to grow and scale my business. And say, Well, wait a sec, well, how much do you have coming in off your social media and referral relationships? That should still keep you pretty busy in the meantime. And they're like, Oh, I don't have much. Well, let's start there first and really optimize that so you've got a consistent flow there that you can then supplement with leads and then scale from there with leads. If you don't have that stuff, then you know that's the that's the easy stuff. Get that stuff rolling, and then you can go, you know, so you know, scale with leads. But if you don't have that, then you know, um, I mean that's that's like the the stuff you can generate without having to drop a boatload of money. So right.
SPEAKER_04Well, you either are gonna you're gonna have to spend something. You're either either gonna spend sweat, um, time, or money, right? Those are your three things. Um, and sweat and time is usually somehow related, but it's gonna be a mixture, right? For the most part, right?
SPEAKER_00Which is why I've never understood uh why agents, you know, um view view the leads they get as free, um, that not they've never spent money on leads, but they'll go spend eight hours at networking events hoping to bring some leads, you know, through. Those are the most expensive leads you've ever bought, because when you look at your you know, how much your time is worth, like if I was working leads and I was selling, you know, oh my are you know, I'm actually would make you know 250, 500 an hour, you know, if I'm spending all my time selling or whatever. But if I'm going to networking events and spending eight hours to get one prospect that maybe I'll sell, well, now your leads, you know, your cost per lead at that point is in the thousands. So, you know, people just don't value the time and realize that their time is worth money.
SPEAKER_04And then that cost per sale is probably triple that or quadruple that because you have 25% closing. So yeah, it's amazing. Um, and you know, different people, different coaches over time have have kind of painted that picture. For me, I mean, there's there's been aha moments where it's like, oh, you know, really it is, it's it's tremendous unlocking that time because you can put yourself so far ahead, right? So you may spend 20 grand on leads this month or whatever, some budget, but you're saving all that time going to those networks, doing all the the hard stuff, like knocking on doors and doing tents at shows and and I think a lot of people don't realize the speed at the too, speed comes into play because that is time.
SPEAKER_01So if you can do 10 years within one year, you just save nine years of time, even if it did cost more money. Now you're in a position where you're gonna be reaping the reward faster and living that that life that you wanted to. And I don't think people really realize the that um there is only two assets time or money. That's it that you exchange. Employees exchange time for money, and employers exchange their money for uh the employees' time. And that's that's it. That's all we have as people. Like um and yeah, when you start really just thinking granularly about that, it's like wow.
SPEAKER_04Um I so I was thinking about that exact thing while I was writing this morning, and um and and then I that's where I came where I had those things like this in my span X in the in the see-through one. So I did get some looks. Um but but that but I thought of this third component because you can you exchange your your like I exchanged my money to get time from uh you know to leverage time. So now I have 10 people that are doing the work that I couldn't do by myself. So I'm getting 10 times. But then there's also a tie to how how well they're working at that thing. And I call that the like that's the sweat. So it's our job to help move that sweat, right? We're the coach that needs to move their sweat so that they are driven to produce those results because somebody could exchange the time and just sit there, right? Um, and they're not bought in, they don't see the vision, whatever it is. But um, you know, it's it's important to also, I think, nod, take a nod and really a really hard look at that equity. How hard are they performing or how well are they performing? Hard are they?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Yeah, and as an agency owner, that's your that's your role and your responsibility is helping make sure they're successful and helping make sure they're efficient and set up that way. You're exchanging your money and and and time as well for them being able to do way more production and way more you know success overall as the agency than you could do by yourself. And your role's really moved away from being the producer role into now the hey, I'm setting up my team for success and I'm investing in them. I know you guys significantly invest in leads and resources and tools like you know, dialers and systems and stuff for your team to be the most efficient at what they're doing.
SPEAKER_04So I mean and we're constantly looking. Yeah, it's not change to the next shiny object, it's it's use the data that you gather from doing the activity and then make a decision on it. You know, what we we we had a little bit of a dip, and so I'm freaking out and and and having conversations with the team, and then I'm talking with Jason about it. It's like, oh, I've looked, I my leads haven't been filling in as much as they need to be. So it actually was a lead problem. I don't know if it's as much volume coming in, and you know, he's laughing at me that the lead problem. But but that's the beauty of it is that there's analytics and you can you can quickly solve in this situation. You know, if I'm going out to all these events and trying to do all these things, it's really hard to diagnose what's working, and you know, it's just like that's a shotgun approach. I'd rather just you know be narrow and and be able to track it, track and measure.
SPEAKER_00And that's something we preach all the time is data-driven decisions. Too many agents, agency owners have no idea what's going on or you know, any data behind that. You know, I'll ask, you know, okay, you know, where are you lead sources, lead vendors, for example? Oh, where do you use them as lead vendors? What's your you know, cost per sale off of those and your ROI? And how are you deciding, you know, which ones to spend more with or less with, and which ones are generating the best returns? And they're like, I just order from all of them and try to sell them and hope I'm making money. And it's like, yeah, how are you how are you making these decisions without data? You know, and and talk to so many that just people just don't track their numbers, they don't know their closing percentage, they don't know you know their average talk time, that all these things that really you kind of have to know to be all the you talk to the top eight percent, the top producers, the top agency owners, they they can quote those numbers by heart, you know, any day of the week or whatever, but you know, a lot of agents just don't realize the importance of knowing those numbers so they can make those decisions, right?
SPEAKER_01So let's dive into that. You've talked to the top 1%. Uh, I know that you've dealt uh talked to a lot of big agents. What are some of the commonalities between all of them? What are the everyone that you know they're gonna say this, they're gonna do they do this.
SPEAKER_00The the top ones have all invested in themselves and their growth and in their success. So they're not afraid to put put money into something if it's going to generate a return for them. Whether that's leads, whether that's, you know, and I would pretty much say all of them have invested in coaching and training in one way, shape, or fashion, whether that's maybe you know something with their commission or for being with an organization that has really, really good support and training and resources, or whether it's them just individually investing within programs that are going to push them forward and help them get to where they need to be quicker and avoid mistakes that you know they would make if they hadn't learned that that was a mistake before they even made it. Um they they're constantly talking to other top people in the industry, that whole like you're the average of the five people you surround yourself with. I mean, I know we kind of brush that off sometimes a little bit, but it's so true. Like if you're hanging out with a bunch of brand new agents or agents that you just don't really want to put the work out, work in, or you know, you're you know, agency owners that aren't really looking to really push and grow, they're like, Yeah, I'm happy where I'm at. You're you're gonna end up in the same boat and you're also not gonna be set up for success, too. So they're always, I mean, they're going to top events, they're going to top masterminds and networking type stuff, and they're just constantly looking for ways to improve and push because I mean, you guys know this this industry isn't stable. It changes constantly. You know, at least over the last 10 to 20, you know, 15 years or so. I mean, yeah, the industry before that maybe didn't change too much for 100 years, but with the, you know, with the internet and digital marketing and millennials and all these, you know, new, you know, uh purchasing behaviors and buying decisions and also the like 10,000 a day now becoming uh over 65 and entering Medicare, final expense type markets and stuff, everything's changing a bunch. And if you don't kind of keep up with that, you get left behind. Um, or if you come into it not really trying to learn that and grow with that, you're also gonna get left behind. So I think that's some commonalities. They're always pushing, they're always looking to invest in themselves and push forward, knowing they'll get a return off of that. You know, they're take they're taking the risks too, but they know, hey, I'm gonna I'm gonna do my due diligence, but I'll get a return off of what I put the money into. They're not scared to do that. So I think that's probably one thing.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. They ask the right questions. Yeah. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh write 100,000 in premium off of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_03They can go to live.teledudes.com. Ooh, that sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process. Super awesome.
SPEAKER_02I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teledudes.com. Live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_02Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, which is awesome. But they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. I'm into it. Greg, are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520 214 2219!
SPEAKER_02Alright. I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03Bye, Mr. Greg. Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_04I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman