The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Master Insurance Marketer Martina Brugnoni Drops Bombs! Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's another podcast. What have what has changed a little bit throughout you know this last year? I know, you know, Facebook, man, a few years ago that was you know lightning, but like um just in general, in your world, what has changed uh recently that that we should take notice of?
SPEAKER_05So in terms of social media, if we're talking Facebook and Instagram primarily, which I would say are the only two social media platforms really worthwhile for an agent. Um the biggest thing I would say that has changed is the preference to paid advertising, meaning that their algorithm literally changed. So if I do a post from Uptown Marketing's business page, the algorithm is gonna make it so maybe five percent, yeah, exactly. We're gonna get crooked.
SPEAKER_03It's crazy.
SPEAKER_05And you know, Facebook's a business, right? So they want ads and they understand that if if they really screw you on the organic reach, you're gonna say, All right, well, I guess I'm gonna boost this post because no one's gonna see it otherwise. So it's almost now. Yeah, if you want anyone to see a post, you better throw $20 on it or no one's gonna Yeah.
SPEAKER_03We were just talking about this because we were, you know, we run a webinar every Tuesday for the telemarketing and put a post and it used to work pretty well, but it then it says scene by three, right? I'm like, Yeah, I mean, what? And it was I posted from my personal into our group, and that's tied to the the you know to the teledudes, and it and it just crickets, but then it then of course a little while later says, Would you like to boost this post, right? It just the second you log in. Hey, you want to boost this post? People are looking at it. It's like, oh, all three of them, huh? And so it's just yeah, I mean, you gotta pay to play.
SPEAKER_05They've really and I mean, even like, you know, a year ago, I used to tell people, well, it's okay, just share it to your personal page because so many people that are in your network are gonna see it. Well, the algorithm caught on to people doing that. If you share a business post, it's less likely to show up even if it comes from your own page because it's a shared business post.
SPEAKER_03I even tried to put a space in the middle of the word, and I'm gonna tested it. It doesn't, it knows.
SPEAKER_05Just get that credit card out. That's the only way we're gonna get people to see it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_00What about the Google box?
SPEAKER_03Google.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it seems like Google's really uh, I mean, it's picking up steam. It's you know, uh I guess you have your interruption marketing, which is Facebook, but like these are people that are actually searching for stuff. Um what has changed it with Google?
SPEAKER_05So the biggest change I would say with Google is that the whole experience of Google is now, I don't know if you guys have noticed this. It's designed to keep you on Google. You don't go to a website anymore, you don't go to whatever the page is. If you want a cookie recipe and you search for it, it's just gonna show up. You're not gonna have to go to BettyCrocker.com or whatever it is, it's there.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, the thing at the top, right? The little yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05It's the not I mean, the knowledge bar, all that stuff, the everything is is designed to keep you on Google as long as possible. So I think for agents, um, you know, it's nice because it will be more likely to drive a phone call, which everybody would prefer a phone call over anything else. Um, but I mean, yeah, it's it's it's going more and more where Google just wants you to stay on Google. And it's the same thing with Facebook, where the preference is always going to the paid ads. You know, if if you do paid ads, you're gonna just get a traffic that you'll never be able to get organically, and they know that, so they take advantage of it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Google keeps you on for Google Display Network, all that stuff. Um, but for whatever reason, Google Plus never took off, and maybe in a hundred years it will, but it's just terrible. No, I mean they actually went away.
SPEAKER_05It went away totally.
SPEAKER_03Oh, it did, it's gone.
SPEAKER_05It did, yeah. It's just Google My Business now. So that's you know what you used to log in when we used to manage the business pages five years ago. We would log in, it was their Google Plus, and then it was your business account was through your Google Plus. Now there is no Google Plus anymore, it doesn't exist. So you just log into your Gmail, you've got your business listing, you've got your AdWords in there, the whole thing lives under that Gmail.
SPEAKER_00Okay. And Google My Business is rocking, right? Like that's huge for agents.
SPEAKER_05So that's I think with local businesses, what's cool is that Google My Business is adding more and more features to that. So they'll add the products feature, they'll add the services. Anytime Google adds something, always do it, right? Because they're gonna always prioritize somebody that's taking advantage of what they're offering. You know, if if we've got two agents, right, and one of them has some stuff, not all of it, and the other one's just completely decked out their business listing. They've taken advantage of every single thing compliantly that they can within that platform. Of course, Google's gonna be like, yes, you're our little poster child now, you're showing off all of our features, you're gonna be the best result for the consumer, and you're gonna show up more often.
SPEAKER_03So I wanna I wanna help somebody uh envision the experience they have when they meet you and they work with uptown marketing. Okay. So what what does that look like? Do they sit down, you start talking with them, you help them create an avatar, and then you attack that audience? Or what what is that? Some juicy tidbits without giving too much away.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so what we do, um, we'll do like a consultation call, you know, because everybody's coming from a different company. It's super important to know where they're coming from. Are you coming from the corporate program? Are you coming from a vendor that has no idea, you know, what's up, what's down? How do we transition you properly is number one. Um, but really we we sit down and we learn about their market, we learn about their team, the way their agency's structured. It's really, really important for agents to work with a company that's gonna truly individualize it. If you're a brand new agent in your first year, you need to be marketing completely different than if you've been an agent for 20 years, right? Uh the market, obviously, again, super, super important. So we're gonna find out everything that you need, set you up with what's the best fit for you. Usually that's gonna be a combination of an SEO campaign. So helping you show up more often organically on Google and uh search engine marketing. So SEM, which would be Google Ads and Facebook and Instagram ads.
SPEAKER_03Um we can we as the individual agent can compete with the big, the big money players on the top of Google if somebody searches and you can, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, but here's the thing you you really don't you're not gonna be able to do that with the keyword of insurance. So we're usually gonna be targeting uh the brand keywords. We have to get uh compliance approval through Google. We have a paralegal that we work with um through the company that will use uh the trademark authorization to say, hey, yep, you can you can use those keywords. Um so yeah, you you can you just have to be strategic about how you're spending your budget and the keywords that you're bidding on. Um so after you say, all right, cool, let's, you know, move forward. I want to be an uptown client, then we have a series of three appointments where um, I mean, they're setup appointments, you know. So we take care of your website, we fill out that box as much as possible for you. Um, your Bing listing, your Apple listing. We need to make sure that Siri's gonna recognize you if somebody talks to Siri instead of typing in. Um, I mean, we do the nextdoor app. I don't know if you guys are familiar with that at all. That's really, really good for agents. Um, so we do listings on there for you, we optimize your Facebook page, we optimize your Yelp page, uh, set up the ad words. If we're doing Facebook ads, we'll set those up with you. So there's a process. Uh, it takes about a month after you sign up where we're getting everything in place. And then we do either 30-day or 60-day account reviews with the agents to kind of check on things along the way, look at your numbers, make sure stuff's working. If it's not, we'll change some things around and you know, just kind of move along that way.
SPEAKER_00And how long does it usually take to start gaining some serious traction? Because I can imagine, I mean, this stuff is gonna take some time, right? You can't just it is, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and that's you know, that's an important part of setting those realistic expectations with the agent, but it's also it's really important to have the experience to know what's realistic and what's not. So I know a new agent that just opens in Los Angeles, it's gonna take years for them to show up organically. It could very well take years. But the nice thing is that there's so many different ways that we can search now that we don't have to just go for insurance Los Angeles, right? Because they may never show up for that search. It's too big, there's too much else out there. But what we're specializing in helping agents show up for is a location-related search, which is okay, instead of just typing in insurance Los Angeles, nobody really turt types in the city anymore, right? There's there's Google Analytics on it. They don't type the name of the city in because we don't have to. All we do is we pull out our phone and we type in insurance. So that's a location-related search. Google shows a result based off of what they know about your location and the businesses around you. Um, so to go back to the question, how long does it take? You know, there's there's little milestones that you can reach quicker than others. I would say to really this is so tough to answer because if everything were to stay the same on the internet forever, there was no other changes, which it would be. I would say, yeah, right? It'll never change. Everything, uh, you know, average agent, average market, you're gonna get a good feel for your results within 90 days. Now, Google could wake up tomorrow, it could be a completely different site. It could be totally different, no warning. And my job is to figure it out and figure out how we're gonna, you know, keep everybody moving along. So it's it's tough to give that answer because there's so many variables that go into it.
SPEAKER_03So, how do you handle the mindset of the agent who has the notoriously short fuse on getting results?
SPEAKER_05You mean all of them?
SPEAKER_03Right, all of them. Well, I think we understand it.
SPEAKER_05We tell them up front, you know, we tell them in the initial uh consultation call, like it's not gonna happen overnight. Now, the nice thing and why I always recommend combining the paid ads with the search engine optimization is because the paid ads will show up whenever you start paying. Very easy. If you want to show up in the ad section, just pay and you'll be there. So it's it's super important to to kind of complement those two together because while we're building the organics, your ads are going to be right there. So you're gonna be getting the quotes in as soon as those ads turn on. Um, and then you know, as as that's going up, the the SEO is going up as well, and eventually you get to you know a good place where they're both kind of rocking for you.
SPEAKER_03Love it.
SPEAKER_00What do you see? What do you see are um some of the biggest mistakes agents make?
SPEAKER_05Getting 25 Google reviews in one day. Pay do not pay your team to get Google reviews, do not give them a daily contest or a weekly contest. Do not do it, do not leave yourself a review.
SPEAKER_03Um I do that every day.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, you'd be surprised. I log into John Smith's account and it's like best agent ever, John Smith. I'm like, really? Uh isn't that good? What other mistakes? The other mistake I think too is business. Yeah. The other mistake I think that I've seen a lot over the years is letting the very understandable frustration of this industry make you give up. You know, this doesn't work. This company screwed me over. I don't know how this works, it's confusing to me. Um, you know, I've heard it all, but you're crazy to think that there's not people shopping online for insurance that you need to be in front of. So it's really important to just get with the right company that understands your industry enough and can kind of take the uh stress of it away from you without saying, all right, I throw my hands up. This this stuff doesn't work. That kind of thing.
SPEAKER_03We've been doing this for one day and it is not working.
SPEAKER_05The phones aren't ringing, Martina. Right.
SPEAKER_03In every other business, in every other industry, you create a marketing plan and then you stick to it, right? 90 days, we're gonna see if we got the results because then we have data, like people are making emotional decisions, not data-driven decisions, and we know what happens with that, right?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and it's interesting you say that because think about the personality type of an insurance agent, an insurance agent. They're huge egomaniacs, right? So they will get absolutely livid if they see another agent in their town online, especially if it's from the same company. So it's I mean, I I hear it so often. I've heard this from day one. Why is that agent uh down the street from me showing up higher than me on Google? He he doesn't write any business. And I'm like, well, that's not the way it works. Google doesn't know how much business you guys write, they only know what they know, and and you have problems with your presence, which is why you're not showing up. But uh yeah, man, that is really tough, the the competitiveness. But I think that with our company, at least, one of our advantages is that we only work with one agent per market, you know. So that's a huge benefit that you don't have to be competing, at least with Uptown with uh the other agents around you.
SPEAKER_03Oh, cool. That's cool. Um, so so the last thing I know that you uh also have a sh a daily or a weekly show. Totally different, totally different subject, right? The called is it called The Pitch? I'm trying to read it. The pitch The Pitch, a dating show.
SPEAKER_05It is, yeah. So I started uh back in May, I started this group, which was just like on a weird whim and it kind of blew up. It's called Dallas Wingman. So what it is is it's a big Facebook group, similar to the big insurance agent groups. And you can be in there if you're single and you're looking for somebody, or you could be in there if you're not single and post one of your friends and be their wingman. And so you're posting pictures, you're saying, This is, you know, I did it with my friend Whitney. This is my friend Whitney. She's 31, she's an executive, she lives here, she XYZ, and people can comment, they'll, you know, go into her private messages, whatever. So this group got really, really big. And I ended up teaming up with um a girl I know here in Dallas that is the CEO of Vouch, which is a dating app, and creating this show called The Pitch, where it's a kind of similar concept where it's live on YouTube and um people will come on and pitch their single friends. So if I was pitching Whitney, I'm gonna do a PowerPoint. Um, I'm gonna say these are the reasons why Whitney's awesome. She makes great enchiladas, she's got a cute dog, all this stuff, and you know the audience interacts. It's cool. It's a lot of fun. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03How many viewers do you get on that?
SPEAKER_05Um, about 800 on the last one we did. Yeah, it's still pretty new, but we all have uh all the hosts on it have pretty good networks. And you know, the people that go on it obviously are telling all their friends about it. So I think that's kind of helping it it uh pick up.
SPEAKER_03So YouTube is it similar uh to Facebook in that if you go live on Facebook, it jams you up to the top and you get rewarded for that. But you know, most people are scared to do it. Um, is it the same thing on YouTube?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it is. So you go up to the top, anyone that's subscribing um is gonna get a reminder, and then people can comment stuff live. So they'll actually our producer will show, like, if somebody's in the comment section, they'll pop it up on the screen, so it makes it fun because it's you know more interactive than a typical show.
SPEAKER_03And it puts it in front of people that aren't even subscribing to just as random, yeah.
SPEAKER_05I mean, we we put it will YouTube will do that on its own, they'll they'll you know make suggestions for you. But you know, we put the link out there a ton of different places, so there's yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Awesome. That's awesome. Well, why don't you drop the last one?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. So I I just want to recap on this. You dropped some just fire content of marketing, then we switched into something completely binge-worthy. Like, I know people are gonna jump on that. That sounds like a crazy awesome concept that has to be hilarious. Yeah, so so so that is really unexpectedly awesome. Um but the channel, what what's that channel called?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, sorry, what's the channel called? So while you're over there subscribing to the insurance dudes podcast, go over to the pitch dating show, subscribe to us, and uh you'll have the two best channels.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I mean, so I I know a TV show or something's gonna rip you off on that. It's a matter of time. I know it's a lot of people. What is the TV? Yeah, yeah. Um, so I I just last question, big question is what would be the number one piece of advice you give to any insurance agent coming into the insurance industry, um, or or somebody that's ready to just dive into marketing.
SPEAKER_05Just call me. No. Um, I would say well, really, you could call me. No, I would say the biggest thing is do something different. Don't just go with what your company tells you to do. Be compliant, of course. Don't get yourself into trouble, but make yourself stand out because the insurance industry online is one of the most cutthroat, competitive, crazy, scrappy things to do in terms of marketing. So if you don't do something different, if you don't have a strong, really good Facebook presence and personality, you're gonna get passed over for somebody that does.
SPEAKER_00Makes sense.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03Okay. So the date, so one more time, uh the the dating show channel and then the Instagram, because I know that you're uh probably isn't everything. You yeah, you rattle them off. Tell us everything, rattle them off so they can put it in the notes.
SPEAKER_05Uptown marketing, uh uptownmarketing.com. Instagram is uptown underscore marketing, Facebook is just uptown marketing. Okay. The pitch dating show is our YouTube channel is the pitch dating show. The Instagram is at the pitch dating show. Um, and then my personal Instagram is Martina Nicole Brugnoni, B-R-U-G-N-O-N I, which you might have to just put that one up online. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Or check out the notes. We'll put it in the show notes.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, just go to the notes.
SPEAKER_03That's it. Well, uh so awesome to have you on here. I I just caught your name um scrolling through the Instagrams. And uh there. There you were.
SPEAKER_04I'm glad to be on. Thank you guys so much. Really awesome to have you on.
SPEAKER_03This is awesome. So um, we will catch up with you down the road. Um, I think that you may be one of those that we call on as a repeat.
SPEAKER_05I hope so.
SPEAKER_03I would certainly do like an annual check-in, you know?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, absolutely. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_03We will see you down the back. Thanks. Thanks, Martina.
SPEAKER_01Hey Jason. Yes, Mr. Craig. That was another awesome episode, wasn't it? Mm-hmm. Well, if people want to get a little bit more action and learn how to do uh 100,000 in premium of even the worst internet leads, where could they go?
SPEAKER_02They can go to live.teledudes.com. That sounds exciting. Are we gonna be there? Yes. It's a weekly call that we're doing right now that will, it's live and it will show you the process. The entire process is super awesome.
SPEAKER_01I love it. Let's do it.
SPEAKER_02Let's do it. Sign up right now, live.teled.com.
SPEAKER_01Live.teledudes.com. That's live.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_02Hey Craig, there's a new community that we are starting that I cannot wait to tell everybody about. It is our live texting community where you and I are going to answer people's questions and give them free content.
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_01Are you kidding me? We get to talk to them?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, which is awesome, but they have to opt in. They have to text us at 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. Nice. Craig, are you gonna respond to these texts? I'm gonna respond to them for sure. Live. I'm into it too. It's gonna be awesome. And it's a it's gonna be our new texting community where we're gonna get back to everybody that we can and drop some crazy content. Free content and free um the calculator that you just came up with. Mmm. That's right. The calling calculator. Sales material. I mean everything for insurance agents. This is it. It's the best texting community out there for insurance agents. Well, what the heck is that number again? I can't remember it. It's 520-214-2219. That's 520-214-2219. I love it. I'm gonna text it right now. 520 214 2219!
SPEAKER_01Alright, I'll see you later, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_02Bye, Mr. Craig. Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_01I love it.
SPEAKER_03I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman