The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Master Insurance Marketer Martina Brugnoni Drops Bombs! Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. Boom! Oh that's pretty that's pretty in sync. Unlike our our boy band out of sync.
SPEAKER_02Out of sync. Out of sync. How you doing, Martina? Martina Brugnoni. Did I say it right? Yes.
SPEAKER_00You nailed it. That never happens.
SPEAKER_03It never happens on our end either.
SPEAKER_00So how are you guys doing?
SPEAKER_02Awesome. Welcome to the insurance dudes podcast. The world-famous insurance dudes podcast. Now over 200 episodes strong on iTunes. And all the other ones. Yeah. Yeah. So honored. Yeah. Oh, I can tell. I am. Well, so uh you're you're no stranger to the insurance world. You're uh after you got out of, you went to to SUNY, huh?
SPEAKER_00Is that do you guys know what that is?
SPEAKER_02It's something University of New York.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so New York, New York has so many state schools that they have a whole system for state schools called the SUNY system. So it's just state University of New York at wherever the campus is. But I think there's like 15 or 20 of them.
SPEAKER_02It's like Cal State or UC in California. Here in Arizona, there's two. Well, no, three in AU. Everybody forgets about them. And uh, well, okay, so you you were you came from there, did a internship over there on a morning show. That must have been a lot of fun. Um super fun.
SPEAKER_00Hated waking up that early, but yeah, it was fun.
SPEAKER_02I know. That's crazy. You do have to get up early. Uh-huh. So from there, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Before we go into all this, what the first question, Mr. Craig. Okay. Do it. So, Martina, what was the first concert you ever went to? And take us back. Hopefully, it's like Barney or something.
SPEAKER_00No, it wasn't Barney. I think I was in seventh grade and it was Fallout Boy.
SPEAKER_03Oh, nice! Fallout boy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. First Fallout Boy. Yeah, it's kind of embarrassing, but that was it. Potentially the final Fallout Boy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Where where did you see him?
SPEAKER_00I I saw him at this venue that was actually like, I want to say it was like five minutes from my house, and it was on a Wednesday night, which was obviously a school night. So I remember my mom bringing me there with one of my girlfriends, dumped us off, and then yeah. We were talking out with Fallout Boy.
SPEAKER_02What was the best concert you've been to? Your favorite of all time.
SPEAKER_00I've seen Rihanna a lot. I love Rihanna, but I also, oh, the best one, easy hands down. The Jonas uh Jonas Brothers did their tour this past year, and my little sister's a huge fan. So for Christmas, I got her and my older sister, all of us, like these VIP seats in Dallas. So we were literally like 10 feet away from them the whole time. It was crazy. It was oh that's cool.
SPEAKER_03I heard they're great.
SPEAKER_00They're really good, you know. And you always think of them as like such a little teeny bopper band, but they're really actually very put on a good show.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's about putting on the big the big production, right? It's a big yeah, it's not like going to a punk show.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_02Cool. Okay. So let me get back to what I was into here. If I may, Mr. D. Mr. Craig. So after uh this internship, uh uh State Farm. So this is this is your break into the beautiful and wonderful world that we all know is insurance, the insurance industry. Cutting edge, always fast, quickest technology, exciting. And I know Big Red has some really powerful technology under the hood when they're when you're doing quotes. Still in uh DOS, I think. I don't know. I don't know. Oh, well, okay. So that was uh that's June, that was back 2009 to 2014. Then you jumped into uh YPC Media, and I think a lot of people in our neck of the woods, uh, which we won't talk about know that name. Uh YPC Media. I did. I think I think uh Mr. Jason does. Um and uh so you were there for a long time.
SPEAKER_00Five years. Five years. I was there for five years, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Or loyalists. If you did the Enneagram, I bet you're the loyalist.
SPEAKER_00No, I'm not. I'm the oh, it's I think it's number eight. I don't remember what it is.
SPEAKER_02Oh eight, that's what Jason is. Jason's the challenges. The challenge. The challenges. I'm seven, the enthusiast.
SPEAKER_00I might be thinking of a different one. I know I'm eight for something. Maybe that is it.
SPEAKER_03But anyway, there's so many different things. I was looking into it last night. This is totally derailing the conversation, but man, I was like, I was searching around for all the different ones. Me and my wife are going through, and then you fill it out, and man, that is a long time for sure.
SPEAKER_02That's funny though. I'm I'm a seven, you're a seven with a second is an eight, you're an eight with a second as a seven. So that is why we're good balance there. Um, and then you said I'm gonna do it on my own. I'm gonna take, I wanna, I don't want to have to work as much. I want my own business, and I am going to go and open a marketing company. So here we are. Talk to us about this journey. I love it.
SPEAKER_00Uh, where do you want me to start? Back at State Farm?
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, let's go there. Yeah, I think that's a good state farm.
SPEAKER_00I gosh, I learned a lot there. So my dad worked, um, he was like a I really don't know exactly what he did, like what his job title and it kills him. We used to call him a claims officer, but he was something up in claims. So I always grew up with State Farm my whole life. And then when I was 18, when I was in college, I wanted to get a job that I could go back and forth to. I was sick of working in retail, I was sick of working in like coffee shops, stuff like that. So I'm like, Dad, like get me with one of your friends that's an agent and let me go work in the office. So he's like, here, you call him yourself. If you want a job, you're gonna call him and you're gonna talk to him and get it yourself. So I did, and I started just doing like, you know, basic customer service stuff. And they were like, wow, you're you're really good on the phone for being so young and inexperienced, and then started setting appointments. And then that was back when um this makes me sound so old, but that was back when like Facebook was first getting really big and when they first started to come out with like business pages. So he's like, Do you want to do this? I don't really know how any of this stuff works. So that's how I really got started um doing online stuff for state firm agents was for the agent that I actually worked at. And then obviously it's blown up like crazy since then. Um, so in college, I majored in marketing and public relations. So once I graduated, I was like, okay, I want to actually get into marketing. That's what I enjoy, that's what I love to do. I love doing sales. So I started working at YPC Media. Um, I was hired at YPC Media as the assistant sales manager. So there was a sales manager. They had never had an assistant sales manager, but they needed one. And so I started doing that. I absolutely hated it. I hated training, I hated managing all that stuff. And I remember one day the sales were really, really down. And I'm like, I can't wait for you guys to figure this out anymore. So I just picked up the phone and I started doing some sales. And then I remember our CFO came up to me after like two days where I was doing sales and he's like, Are you starting to do the math? And I'm like, what? He's like, Do you see how much money you could be making if if you were to go into sales instead of this assistant bullshit? And I'm like, Yeah, you're right. So um I I started doing sales and then kind of the obvious move for me, because we had already had a couple reps there that were working with state farm agents. So I'm like, oh, I got this. I know state farm better than you guys do. Like, watch. So I kind of just went out and I I remember I picked my own market because they the two guys that were doing it before kind of had, you know, uh, they were working with a lot of like the Texas agents and Georgia and all that. So I'm like, all right, I'm gonna go somewhere that like you guys I think are a little too scared to do, which is New York City. So I just started printing out a bunch of agents in New York City, ended up talking to a very, very big agent there who's still a very close client, and he ended up uh giving me a ton of referrals, so it just kind of grew from there. So yeah, that's why I was there for five years because it took a while.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. It does, it does take a while to fill up that pipeline, you know, and and just get it humming along. But once it does, it's great.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it it kind of went from, you know, I'm I'm just doing marketing with with these agents to starting to get invited to present at study groups. We ended up hosting our own conference with a bunch of agents. I ended up needing to hire and train a team underneath me. So it really got very big where the company built its own insurance department just based off of you know the other guys that were doing it and myself uh growing the program there.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's awesome! Congratulations. And you should never feel old if you're in the room with me. And I know that Jason wanted to drop this show.
SPEAKER_03I did, I did, and I saw him. I was old when Facebook I mean, Craig remembers the first computer, right? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02The the abacus. They're like, we have this new thing that we can do math with, and it's called an abacus. I don't even know what it is.
SPEAKER_03What's an abacus? I don't either.
SPEAKER_02I'm like, huh. Oh, that's it.
SPEAKER_03I'm leaving. And then Craig will tell you about uh back when you started with insurance and there was microfish, right? Well, it was before that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, it was before the microfish.
SPEAKER_00Did you do door-to-door insurance sales? Were you one of those?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, no, I'm not really that old. So, but almost. Yeah, so so the big splash into marketing, you know. So you you learned you had five years to cut your teeth. Now you go in. Um, what was that like? What was that transition? And I I'm sure you'd been thinking of it for a long time, right? But moving from that corporate world and then off onto your own. Talk about that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so it I was actually very lucky at YPC because it was a new program, it was a new department, really, that we had created, that they gave us a lot of um say, I guess, in how we wanted to grow it, but I wasn't necessarily given as much say as the other person that was doing it with me. And obviously that got frustrated. I'm type A. I want to be the leader, I want to be the one calling the shots. So when I moved to Dallas, um, which was February 2019, made a huge, huge change. I had been in Rochester, New York my whole life. And, you know, things just started to, it sounds dramatic to say unravel, but unravel even further with my relationship with them. And I was kind of like, you know what, I am the one that my clients want to work with. They trust me. It's not the company's name, it's it's that they want to work with me. And I know that if I were to do this on my own, that I would be successful because I have that much confidence in myself, but also in my relationship with my clients. So the biggest struggle there was not uh getting clients. It was getting out of a non-compete that I had signed when I was 24 years old and had no idea what I was signing. So obviously had to get an attorney, crazy expensive, months of back and forth, back and forth. It was a huge loss for YPC financially. So they weren't just gonna say, yeah, here, you know, go take all your clients, have at it. So it was kind of a back and forth of that. And then I think the other big struggle was I had moved to Dallas and the two girls that were right away without any hesitation, yes, we're joining this company with you. They were in New York still. So not only are we building a brand new company, we're doing it remote. So I'm teaching these girls an industry that they're not as well versed in as I am. They have uh Marisa, one of the girls, had come from a state farm background. She was working at Northwestern Mutual, so she definitely had insurance experience, but not within the marketing inside of it. Um, so training them and teaching them what we were doing from Dallas while they were in New York was really, really tough. But they're just really awesome, hardworking, very smart girls. So, you know, it kind of worked out. And then uh I ended up getting one of my old team members from YPC, Elena, came down um to Dallas with me. And she also started working with Uptown, hired a couple other salespeople, a couple other operations people, and here we are.
SPEAKER_02Here you are. Here we are. And was uh how how how big of an impact was COVID? Not at all. Perfect.
SPEAKER_00I don't want to say not at all. I don't want to say not at all. Uh the biggest thing I think was just kind of being there for the agents and understanding that they a lot of them were putting their marketing on the back burner, not that they were like canceling it because there was a lot of shopping going on, but they were kind of like, hey, I can't do our our meeting this week. I've got XYZ going on, you know. So just we just kind of had to be there for them in the background and kind of waited out while while the agents kind of dealt with all the stuff that they were going through, which was I think a lot more. Yeah, a lot of uncertainty for sure at first.
SPEAKER_02There was there was uncertainty, yeah. I mean, it was nuts. And like we launched a tele team, like telemarketing company in the middle of all of that, and were able to actually, I mean, I thought it performed much better than we we had even anticipated. And I think it was pretty fortunate because there are a lot of people at home. Contact rates just went through the roof, you know. So from uh on the retail side, you know, just just reaching out, it was it was good. But that's it. If you have the right strategies in place, when when the world's biggest event happens, you're in good shape, you know. And so um, it was good for both our agencies and launching that. But we were a little like, oh shit, maybe that was that time.
SPEAKER_00But yeah, I mean the marketing marketing was totally fine. I had also started a recruiting side of the business in February, right before all this hit, and that absolutely blew up in my face. Uh, you know, the licensing places closed down, all these people were just, you know, we can't have you come in for an interview, so that just completely uh didn't pan out.
SPEAKER_03Well, I I want to get a little bit into the marketing because because you know, all the insurance dudes love talking about the marketing. You have a crazy amount of experience. Um can we go through a little bit of of some strategy tactics or anything that that some big stuff uh that maybe somebody hasn't dove uh highly into marketing or uh an agent? Yeah. What would be the starting from like 101? What would you what would be?
SPEAKER_00So you want me to do uh specific to state farm agents or just in general insurance agents? Because we only work with state farm agents, but I am obviously familiar with an independent, those other companies.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I would say um I I I think I mean this is my take. I could be totally way off, but I feel like the captive agents have it harder. They're in a smaller box where um they can only do so much. Where if you take some of those smaller box tactics, throw them in the independent world, it's like, wow, that could that can really work. Because now not only can they do this, they can add on 20 other things that you know captives aren't allowed to do. So let's let's do something a little get bit more geared towards captives, um, because I think that, you know, yeah, I think everybody could use that advice.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so all right, first thing, you have to know your market and you have to have realistic expectations for your market. If you have a friend that's in uh Las Vegas and they're getting XYZ result, and you're in a suburb in Pennsylvania, the middle of nowhere, and you think, oh, my friend is is getting this amount. Uh, can you do this for me? No, you have to understand the realities of your market and also the realities of the internet. I think having realistic expectations, being in an industry where there's so many different companies out there that are always calling and promising you, hey, we're gonna guarantee you this top spot, we're gonna guarantee 500 zillion leads, it's really important to have realistic expectations and understand how the internet actually works and that there's only so much that you can do, right? So, captive agents, you have to optimize your website within that box as much as you can. So you are in a box, but it doesn't mean you can't work within that box, right? So the content on your website, uh, you know, anything that you can take advantage of, you have to be taking advantage of because you're already starting, you know, a step back because you're stuck within this box. You have all these compliance restrictions that, you know, you can't do the cool marketing stuff that a lot of companies can do, which sucks. It's really frustrating. As a creative person, it's it's annoying for me because I'm like, oh, I just saw this really cool thing come out. Can't do it though. You know, the companies aren't gonna allow it. Um, so working within the box, uh, having realistic expectations. Um, a big thing I think is just being present. And when I say being present, getting reviews from your customers is important. Um, interacting with your customers online. So if they do leave your review, respond to them. You know, so many agents we see online, they have all these customer reviews and there's no responses. They give you the response platform for a reason. You know, you got to think about it like if somebody walked into your business and said, Hey, Craig, you guys do such a great job. I'm such a happy client. Thank you so much. And you just turned around and walked the other way. You know, you never do that. So when somebody's shopping online, they they see, you know, oh, this guy responded to his clients. He's obviously very engaged. Um, pictures are huge as well. Not only do they help you show up more often in different searches on social media more often. Um, but if you think about consumers now are so bombarded with every, I mean, every second there's something different flashing in our face, trying to get our attention, right? So if I'm going online and I'm looking for a new nail salon, right? I there's no chance I'm gonna walk in somewhere that doesn't have reviews and I can't see what the salon looks like, right? Because I know I have that option in other places. So if you're not taking advantage of very what I believe to be basic needs of an online presence right now, they're gonna move right along to somebody that does because they feel that instant connection with them already. So building your brand um can be very easily done through, you know, pictures, reviews, engaging with people uh that are online.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. iPhone photos or professional photos?
SPEAKER_00iPhone photos are fine. Absolutely all day long. All day long.
SPEAKER_02I even take a picture of the review and then post that as a picture.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you can do that.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it doesn't really, you just gotta have stuff up, you know.
SPEAKER_03Huh. But I take a picture of taking a picture and then I'll take a picture of that. That I think that that's on the next level.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, it is very good strength. Yeah, the dream within the dream.
SPEAKER_03But but doesn't it seem like that kind of stuff? Like it's I think a lot of people don't post pictures or and we've gotten this conversation about videos and stuff, because it's like, oh, I gotta, you know, make it look professional. But at the same time, it's like if it looks too professional, then it looks scammy.
SPEAKER_00Like exactly. Exactly. Think about the the online personality now is very genuine. Like if you look at my business posts, there's professional pictures, but all the content, the the captions is just how I would normally talk because we the value of an insurance agent is the human being, right? I care about you, I know you, I know your family. So if you take that and you bring it online and you just show your genuine real self, the some of the best online presence I that I see with agents, they're always doing selfies, right? Just taking the picture wherever they are, if they're out in the community, if it's in front of their office, if you know something fun happened with their team, the real live time, like take a picture, let's post it. That is so taking a selfie. That is so much more effective than you know, saying, oh, well, I don't have really nice professional pictures, or my team doesn't want to dress up or this or that. Like, no, you don't need to do that at all.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I almost think that because I see, you know, I mean, I'm obviously looking around, um, but I see a lot of agents that have around suits. Yeah, why not? They're wearing suits and stuff, and it's almost like I don't know if it's just because I'm more casual, but I I just I almost look at it like that that can't be like it looks fake. But I think I would like as a consumer to uh see pictures of real people that are like maybe having maybe fun, you know.
SPEAKER_00Could you imagine insurance agents having fun?
SPEAKER_02Like, think about okay, think about like when Progressive first started doing marketing, they bring in flow and they're making it funny, and then Geico's doing it. And like when they when they created the image of the in of the insurance agent, those two tools in suits, like I mean, they didn't come up with that just magically, right? There was market research that went into well, what do you think of insurance agents? And everybody said it's some it's some tool in a suit, and they people don't want that, right? Like, not not the people that now we are marketing to. We're not marketing to the 90 somethings, like me. Right. We're marketing to the to the younger crowd, the millennials. I mean, they're pretty soon the millennials are gonna have the biggest buying power of everybody, and it's gonna be something, right? So we have to totally change the ways. I like that you said the millennials, the the YouTube millennials, the YouTubes.
SPEAKER_03Oh, I'm starting to get giddy. I'm starting to get giddy. Uh cool. Like that, no, that's that's fantastic advice.
SPEAKER_01Um to be continuous. It's the insurance dudes. Don't turn it off, man. That really be rude. We're dropping knowledge on the radio, so just turn it up.
SPEAKER_03So we put together a little webinar from all the things that we've learned, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, totally. I love it. It was a lot of fun um doing it, putting it together, and there's some really good stuff in there.
SPEAKER_03Yes, we learned how to sell hundreds of thousands of premium a month using any internet leads, and this is based on a whole bunch of big dudes selling ton and ton, ton of premium a month, like over a million.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and it it it eliminates that turnover, right? The staff doesn't get burned out.
SPEAKER_03It does, it creates predictable sales, like whoa, right?
SPEAKER_02Well, and we also learned how we can copy the processes of the big, giant, fastest growing PNC carriers and the big local agents.
SPEAKER_03Yep. That was a lot of fun. So it was fun. We put it together, we it's on a website go to love.teledudes.com. That's l-o-v-e.t-e-l-ed-udes.com. How do you spell like that on the fly, Mr. Jason? Well, it took me some practice, but it's love.t e L E Dudes.com.
SPEAKER_02You are good at that. So let me get this straight. It's love.teledudes.com.
SPEAKER_03Love.teledudes.com. I love that. I love it too. I surprised you too, Mr. Craig. You didn't know it tricked me.
SPEAKER_01Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_02I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman