The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Magic Marketing Marty Amador Mad Knowledge Nuggets You’ll Adore Part 2
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Welcome up. It's the insurance podcast.
SPEAKER_03Do you build a page out on there too?
SPEAKER_01No, no, no. I I link our my own website on there. So you can you can you can create that and create their own your own traffic that way. Um and then yeah, I mean, so you can do that and then I mean obviously there there is a component to do Google My Business and stuff or to do uh Google Ad AdWords too. But I mean for the most part, if you treat that as a social media page, you know, I mean do posts, do videos, do things like that. I mean, you're you're you're golden. You're you're gonna be able to see the traffic.
SPEAKER_03So I gave a bunch of the team, just just give them manager access and say, just take pictures and post them, you know, like take pictures of each other, take pictures at work, say I'm just down here, you know, working, eating lunch, whatever. But it starts putting the pictures, and it's crazy. Like some of these pictures get thousands of views, yeah, and and Google likes that, right? So the and the uh algorithm is gonna start pushing it up to the top, exactly. And looking at mine, like our search views is up 34%, 402 views. This is the smaller office, and then map views up 53%. So it's rewarding because we're posting pictures, you know. Yeah, that's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03No, it's a phone number comes across, right?
SPEAKER_01Like, I mean, yeah, yeah, yeah. You can look at at people's, you know, other other business types and see what they have on there, and most of them like is a is a picture of a dumpster, right? Is like they just have they have the parking lot and they have the picture of a dumpster, right?
SPEAKER_03I'm like, so awesome.
SPEAKER_01Are you are you gonna click on that? I'm I'm not gonna click on that. I'm gonna click on one that I you know I could see their I could see their uh their staff and their reviews and you know any post that they might do, you know. I'm like, I'm gonna I'm gonna click on that one, right? So sure. So yeah, so no, that that's been huge. And then and I mean even um, you know, Google Maps and stuff too, you know, making sure that that that shows up on your maps too. So um, so it's pretty neat.
SPEAKER_03So yeah. Little quick side tip, and I'm man, I'm killing you. I'm sorry. Um no, is the COVID update? There's a COVID update. And in that, it's there's an actual call now. There's a it like it appears about 70% of the time, I would guess, but you can you can it's uh like a click to call. So if you status, you can type, you can put whatever you want in the COVID update. So we'll put something fun in there, but then it has call now. So just a little Google's probably gonna put me to the bottom of the pile. I'm sorry, Google, I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, there was something else I found on there too, was the uh they had uh they had uh mask, like mask required and different things like that for safety. Because obviously people are still have that the safety conscience in mind, right? Too. Especially if you know, like for our our office, we get a lot of walk in, walk-in business, but um, but I mean, so that's an option that we did also. So so I mean that there's a lot of different things that you can do on it. So um also, too, if if you ever do see something on your listing, on your Google listing, you can also um you can also send there's a there's a place on there, I can't remember exactly where, but you can um update it. So like if something's not correct, you can you you have to email Google um and report it. But uh, but no, it's pretty, pretty neat. Pretty neat. I I really I really like love using Google My Business. I think it's one of those things where a lot of agencies just don't know about it, right? Yeah, they don't know, they don't know how to add the request for quote button on the on the screen. Yeah, there's a lot of little things, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. It's money.
SPEAKER_02That's what we talked about in the elite group uh a couple of weeks ago. And it was it's just one of those funny things. Like you don't really think about it unless it's somebody kind of brings it up. And then when you do it, it's like, I can't believe that I didn't have that button, like a simple button to request, you know what I mean? Because these people are searching Google, so it's like, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01And you get them, like you get them.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01No, it's and it's all free, right? It's all it's that platform's free. I mean, you can see, I mean, we got I mean, we average probably around 70 calls every month um on that. So obviously, some are probably service and stuff like that, but I mean that's where all of our call-in stuff comes from.
SPEAKER_02So seven who couldn't use an extra, just an extra 70 calls, 70 and other stuff.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_03And they'll get the best service over there.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, yeah. Yeah. At least that's what I see in the videos. That's what I hear in the videos. I haven't been over there. Um yeah, so like, okay, here's a good question. Well, I rated my own question before I asked it, but um, here's a great question. Let's say that's um if you just okay, so you came in three month years ago. If you just came in now, what advice would you give to yourself uh as far as marketing? Uh what what would be the first few steps that you would advise yourself to take?
SPEAKER_01First, I would learn how to do a woo foo form or some type of form. Yeah. So do some type of form. Um no, but I I think um learn, I mean, there's there's so many platforms, so many places that you can go to do it. But I I think just learning, um, learning Facebook. Obviously, you know, people are gonna say Facebook is is dead for lead generation, um, but you could still get leads off of that. Um learn Google, Google AdWords, um, spend some time in there. Um, you know, you don't have to run 20 ads, but you know, do do one ad, right? Do one or two ads, a home, a home and auto ad, right? If you do a home and auto ad, uh learn that. Um and then, yeah, and then just just I I think um from a marketing standpoint, just be consistent and and and post and post daily. Post daily if you could, right? Come up with your own niche. Um, who do you want to reach? Um, you know, and come up with something that's your own, you know, about who's your personality, you know? Somebody will connect. Somebody will connect to it.
SPEAKER_03So you're you're running you're running uh Google AdWords for home and auto?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So I've I've had one consistent consistently for for a while already.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, so I mean, aren't you competing against GICO, Progressive, Um, State Farm, Alphrate, and like other ones?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So um we've changed it up a bit. Um this this year we did our own kind of website, so we're trying to kind of gain gain some uh some uh higher rankings on that. Yeah. So we're not pig piggybacking off of uh you know the company and stuff. But um, but yeah, so um, but yeah, no, I mean you are you are competing a little bit, but you have to you have to manage it, right? You have to manage it. Um, you know, and it's very, I mean, it's it's not that expensive, you know. Maybe, maybe a couple hundred dollars a month to have some traffic and to have some SEO where where it's where you're gaining some some some clout some clout on your website and stuff. Um, but I mean, even even you could even do a landing page, you know, a simple landing page too, and have it, you know, have one ad right off of that. I mean, I I I'm not a big proponent of click the calls on the on the Google AdWords, but I do like doing um landing pages instead, um, because you get a higher intent customer if they're gonna go to your landing page. Um, so I like doing that better. Um, but uh but yeah, no, I've run them consistently. Um we're doing life ad right now, a life life insurance ad um with some video and stuff like that. But I mean, for the most part, I mean it's it's uh you know just just very simple, very simple, not not not overthinking it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think that's the problem, right? That that's the problem with video, is I think people overthink it and they might do some sort of cheesy picture that's like clip art, right? And then it's like they don't get a good response, and it's like, dude, you're not really showing any personality or anything.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, no, you have to. And I mean, and then and obviously, you know, people are gonna watch the videos and stuff, and they may not necessarily click the link to fill out a form or do something like that, but then you can also retarget, right? You can retarget them too, um, the people that have visited those landing pages, so um with a pixel or do something with it, you know, so you can do something like that with it. So um, but yeah, I mean it just kind of I mean that that's the biggest thing. Just kind of keep it simple, but you know, but you have to learn the platforms, you know. Even if you end up having somebody else do it for you, um, in the end, you I mean, I I would I I would do like a training course, you know, there's plenty of them out there um that you can that you can join, you know, and and learn, you know, that's how I learn, you know, by doing it hands-on and then like, oh, I don't want to do this, I'm gonna pay somebody else to do this, you know, yeah, type of thing, you know. But but um, but no, it's good just to kind of learn the the the business behind it, right?
SPEAKER_03So it's good to know how that thing works, like where the traffic goes and what traffic is and and what a pixel is and what retargeting is. I mean, without knowing that, then you're just throwing money and anybody could tell you anything, right? So I bet you there's somebody listening right now that doesn't know what a pixel is and doesn't know what retargeting is. Like it make it so easy that that uh that a four-year-old could understand. That one of uh one of Jason's kids can understand it when they hear it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So so you go on to you go on to YouTube and you click an ad on YouTube and they click on it, you go to it, you watch three minutes of the or you know, 30 seconds of the video, it's gonna show up on your feed later, you know.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there you go.
SPEAKER_01Your YouTube page is retargeting. That's retargeting. So like, oh yeah, I I was I saw the I saw this video earlier while I was you know waiting for my Chipotle in line, you know, and then and then like, oh yeah, this that makes sense, you know. What they said, I'm gonna go back and click it. Or I oh here he is, you know, here he is again.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's interesting. That you know, everybody says that that that the Google's listening to us and and you know hitting us with ads based on what we're talking about, but we may be reading something that they're able to target very easily or watching something because we're doing stuff all day long, right? And they know that we engaged with a certain post just by slowing down, right? They know we've engaged. So I think that's probably more likely. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, there's words, there's words in your ad that are on the web page that are linked together, that it there it just goes, it's a rabbit hole. Like Jason said, we're we're you know, there's so it's so complicated and deep when you really get into it, right? So but um, but yeah, no, it it's it's definitely it's definitely good to learn. Good to learn. So that but that's why you pay other people to do it, but it's good to learn as a as an agent to know where it goes, right?
SPEAKER_02So you don't know what you don't know, so like you gotta at least know what to look for.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, no, it's it's just part of the team, right? It's part of the team. So are you drinking beer? No, I don't drink. I'm just kidding. I just I had a craving for a beer when you did that, dude. So you can have one, that's fine.
SPEAKER_03I don't care about that.
SPEAKER_01I know.
SPEAKER_03GG Dave.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, but it it's uh it's it's really, really, really important just to kind of learn. I and other things too, right? You have to learn it before so you can teach it to somebody else, right? That's that's what replication in our business, right? You you teach somebody, you learn how to quote and the way you like to, you know, quote, and then you train somebody else to do it, you know, and then you it just multiplies, right? So so that that's that's the key to to run a successful business, right? And and to find the people that are better at a certain thing than you are, right? So, I mean, obviously that's that's a hard task because we have hard we have higher standards as business owners, right? So we have really high standards. So, but um, but you're gonna find those people when you train them and you look at their at their strengths too, you know. So um, same thing with marketing, marketing companies. You gotta, all right, you know, this is what it's gonna be, right? This is what it's gonna be. I'm okay with that, right? So I know I know the ins and outs and what they're doing and how they're marketing and where where they're where they're getting the leads from, but I'm okay with that, right? So because I don't want to do it.
SPEAKER_03So how long do you how long do you go down a certain path with a certain marketing strategy, spend, spend, spend until you eject? Because I know you don't do something, do it for a week and then say, this doesn't work, right? Like how long do you use before you decide that it's not it's not performing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I usually I usually do like a three-month, three month to six months. So um on different things. So um, I mean, obviously mailers, those type of things like that, that's gonna be more long term. Um, but uh, but I mean, for for marketing strategies, I usually do, you know, three to six months um on different lead sources to kind of test them out. Like I've done like chatbots and stuff like that, you know, and and different things like that. So um, you know, but it's it's one of those things where it's like, okay, like I I'm not really getting that many leads off of doing a chat bot, and I'm spending this amount of time doing it. So it's like, yeah, like I I'm it's not worth it, right? In the in the end. So so although it seems fun, it seems it is fun, and like, yeah, it is fun, just the all the the workflows and how yeah, it's just it's just crazy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So it's uh it's one of those rabbit holes that we were talking about earlier.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. No, I mean, honestly, if if if if I wasn't selling insurance, I would probably be some doing something in marketing, to be honest with you, you know. So uh, you know, just doing, you know, and a lot of agents do that, right? A lot of agents do that. So so so yeah, it's it's definitely fun, a fun part of the side of the business.
SPEAKER_02So it is. Well, what I like about what I've heard, I mean, you've had uh you've you've had multiple things that you've had your hands in, uh marketing-wise, and you try out a ton of different things, and you're always uh you're not looking for the um uh the silver bullet. You're like you get it, you know that you have to do multiple things and and you're constantly uh not ejecting um before uh uh giving it a good shot. Um what uh what advice would you give to people as far as far as that goes? Because I I I know when I first started spending, it was like, oh my gosh, like it you don't see an immediate return. So it's like, hey, what you're doing with the videos, that is time like this is what people are thinking. It's so time consuming. And especially if you're not gonna put a form out there, it's like, well, then I'm not gonna get any leads. Well, if I'm not gonna be video if I don't get leads, and then not to mention the spend and all this money going out. What advice would you give to that agent? Because I feel like I I was that agent at one point.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I um no, that's a good point. I I think for me, I have like a top five. I have a top five lead sources, and um, and it it's different every honestly, it's different every month. Um, you know, whether it be telemarketers, whether it be, you know, when walk-ins, when we had a lot of walk-ins or call-ins or mailers, whatever it is. So just really track your core top five for like a newer agent or somebody that's barely starting out, I would probably narrow that down to like probably three, maybe like a top three lead source, and just really kind of invest and monitor and and calculate your cost per sale and everything like that, and be on top of those metrics. Um, so another thing too is is is not just uh narrowing your your your target audience and like who you want to market to, like, for example, like zip codes and different things like that, like knowing where your sales are coming from, right? So I'm not gonna market all to Colorado if my main zip codes are you know the five that are next to me, right? So, so I'm gonna kind of get you know narrow in there. So um, so yeah, so top three, um, and then just build out as you grow, right? Keep those consistent and then and then build out another lead source, spend a little money on chatbots, spend a little money on, you know, any type of automation thing, emails or email blast or whatever, you know, that you that you want to do. So you just just kind of you know, you use those other resources just to kind of you know test out different things and see how it goes, you know. So you need but you need to have top three at least. At least.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, there's so many things to do. There's so many ways to skin the cat. Um, and I think that you need to pick something that you enjoy, right? If you're gonna if you're gonna do marketing, you gotta pick something you like uh and and align with that and then stick it out. That's what I'm hearing, right? Like the you got a three to six months, you gotta spend, you have to probably spend a little bit more than you're comfortable spending, but there's ways to do that because you're gonna get it back. You're gonna get it back as long as you stick with it. There's gonna be some duds along the way, right? But you that's just part of business, making those bets. You know, you're making those bets, and hopefully they're mitigated by uh some level of knowledge, and they're not just shooting blind, but um, yeah, I mean, those I love the three things. I think in the front end, you probably something a little bit more immediate, right? Like you're not gonna go, all right, mailers are my thing. Uh if you gotta if you have to write business now, then mailer is not the way to go, right? That's gonna take a little time, but it's gonna get results, you know, it's gonna get results down the road. Um, but you also have to be ready to spend, huh? And you're a you're a big proponent of the of the you've you've had some success with the mailers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I mean if you if you if you work that in tandem with with telemarketing, um, you know, having a telemarketing team and being able to, you know, to follow up and make sure that you have some type of process. I mean, everything has to have a process, right? It can't just be, you know, I'm gonna I'm gonna throw you know a couple grand at you know some some lee vendors, right? And and see what happens, right? It's not gonna happen, right? So you have to have some type of strategy, right? So, so um, so yeah, so so definitely that there's there's different ways to kind of look at it. And but it has to be, you know, whether it's your sales training also, right? So you have to have that as part of it too, right? So it's it's it's a big component of it. So um, so you can have all the leads you want, but if you don't have the right people that are quoting these people, then I mean you're throwing money out the window. So yeah.
SPEAKER_03And quoting different sources is different, you know? Yeah. Quoting an internet lead versus quoting um a call-in from a mailer, two different things, you know. Yeah, I mean, and and so those people need to be trained too. I mean, that's I would say the majority of my time in the agency is is is just coaching the people. That's that's the and that's the best use of the time because I get a multiple, you know, there's 10 of them coaching 10 people that you you know you stack it, and then now they're gonna get results. But if you don't coach them, yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, like I mean, I heard a little bit of the of the of the podcast before, um, the elite dudes one, and I I, you know, it the having a team meeting and doing those things like that and coaching around your lead sources and knowing, you know, having your staff knowing like what you're spending. I mean, not exactly what you're spending, but like, hey, you know, like I'm investing in these these leads, right? So they know it's an investment in them too, right? Not just, you know, not you know, so I that that's that's important.
SPEAKER_02So how and I I've actually been I'll tell my team exactly how much I'm spending because it's like it's like crazy, it's like this is I like I'm investing and I and I say the same thing. I'm investing in you, you're investing me. So we need to have a good uh communication between this. Like if you're gonna take a day off, like you gotta let me know ahead of time because I'm uh investing in leads and I want to be able to give you the right stuff, you know what I mean? And uh pull back when you need to be pulled back and push forward when you want to be pushed forward so that at the end of the day, you and I both win. But it's gotta, it's good, you gotta be on the same page, like otherwise it can it can go awry.
SPEAKER_03Does Jason get angry if four people are out and there's still 500 leads coming in? You know, I mean it's just like what?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I mean uh Well, that's that's the worst thing, the phone ringing and nobody's there to pick it up, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it happens, that's the thing. Like these things are gonna happen. Like, if you think that it's not gonna happen and you want the world to work perfectly, then yeah, go somewhere else. Go teach yoga because it's it's not gonna this isn't gonna work here, right? There's gonna be the day where everybody's gone, and maybe you blow a gasket because that's what happens to me. But but I also then you adjust, you have to adjust, you know. Yeah, um, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. No, that's that that's key. That's key. The adjustment and being able to to to to pivot and be able to change. I mean, that's that's the beautiful thing about being a being a small business owner, is that you know, even if if we're with a even if we work with a captive agent agency or a captive company, that we can still have the the the opportunity to change things in our agency, right? So it's like the things we we can we can't worry about, you know, if systems aren't working right, right? We I we still need we still need to produce, right? I can't I can't control that, right? It's the it's the it's the golden rule, right? Control what you can control, you know? So So yeah, it's all about attitude and having a good time, you know?
SPEAKER_02Love it. I think that exhausts so many questions.
SPEAKER_03Oh, Craig, you got another one. No, I don't. What I'm gonna do is I'm gonna say, so when people have a client who's gonna move to Colorado, especially all the people moving there from California right now, I know that. My sister and her family just moved there. Yeah, my sister and her whole family just moved there, right before all the fire stuff. Yeah, yeah, or they move here. So they're they're moving either here or your place. Um, where how can they find you? Uh is there a number they should call for the for the office, or just Google you? What do they do?
SPEAKER_01If you Google me, then I'll I'll pop up uh probably top five there.
SPEAKER_03There you go. That SEO is working.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. See, posting on Google My Business is worth it, bro. Yeah, so it helps out.
SPEAKER_02So everybody, everybody listening to this, um, you have to uh Google Martin Amrador in in Colorado and he's gonna pop up and you can see all the videos, and it's pretty cool. So yeah, um give him give him some extra traffic.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, yeah. Share those videos for them. Yeah, for sure. All right. Well, thank you for uh coming and joining. We we love it. I'm glad that the power didn't go out this time, and we I know, I know. So this is perfect.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, awesome. Appreciate it. Awesome, man.
SPEAKER_03We'll see you next time.
SPEAKER_01All right, bye.
SPEAKER_00It's the insurance dudes. Don't turn it off, man. That really be room. We're dropping knowledge on the radio, so just turn it up.
SPEAKER_02So we put together a little webinar from all the things that we've learned, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, totally. I love it. It was a lot of fun um doing it, putting it together, and there's some really good stuff in there.
SPEAKER_02Yes, what did we learn? We learned how to sell hundreds of thousands of premium a month using any internet leads, and this is based on a whole bunch of big dudes selling ton and ton, ton of premium a month, like over a million.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it it it eliminates that turnover, right? The staff doesn't get burned out, it does, it creates predictable sales, like whoa, right? Well, and we also learned how we can copy the processes of the big, giant, fastest growing PNC carriers and the big local agents.
SPEAKER_02Yep. That was a lot of fun. So it was fun. We put it together, we it's on a website. Go to love.teledudes.com. That's l-o-v-e.com. How do you spell like that on the fly, Mr. Jason? Well, it took me some practice, but it's love.tel dudes.com.
SPEAKER_03You are good at that. So let me get this straight. It's lovel.teledudes.com. Love.teledudes.com. I love that.
SPEAKER_02I love it too. I surprised you too, Mr. Craig. You didn't know it tricked me.
SPEAKER_00Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_03I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman