The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Magic Marketing Marty Amador Mad Knowledge Nuggets You’ll Adore Part 1
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Intern podcast.
SPEAKER_01Boom! Boom. Boom.
SPEAKER_03Oh, look at that.
SPEAKER_01Martin's a fight.
SPEAKER_03Small Valley Karate Championship. Whoever is not watching this is missing out. Yeah. Are you gonna sweep the leg or are you gonna do the crane?
SPEAKER_01I'm sweeping the leg, bro. Come on, man.
SPEAKER_02I know the crane is a weak move. So Martin has on a Cobra Kai shirt, and the background is the legendary Battle of Johnny and uh Daniel. Daniel's son. Is it son or son?
SPEAKER_01Sun. Son. I don't know. Son.
SPEAKER_03I know I know Mr. Martin Amador from Colorado. You uh have been on before, but it was a unique episode in that the power went out and it just ended. So we're this is part D where we want to uh really uh dive a little bit deeper because we just were touching the surface there, huh?
SPEAKER_02And Martin's been in our elite dudes group and he's dropped some bomb content. Boom, blowing up that elite group with some awesome some bomb bomb.
SPEAKER_01Yes, bomb stuff, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, awesome. Yeah, love that the elite group. I think it may be the best part of the week. It is the best part. It is, yeah. So if I you know, likely I know that there's some super dudes and super dudettes out there that probably wrote down and know the trivia of what your favorite or what your first concert was, but just for fun, why don't you tell the rest of the listeners that have come on?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't think I don't think I I should maybe it was something else the before, I'm not sure. But anyways, but yeah, but no, actually it was uh first concert. So I'm I'm uh I didn't really like uh rock at all growing up, so I wasn't really uh you know Bon Jovi, Metallica, I never really liked them. Um but um the one rock band that really got me into it was uh uh Rage Against the Machine. So um yeah, so we actually went, I actually went with a buddy to uh the first Coachella uh um in '89. Yeah, so so that was amazing. So that we did, we had uh I think we watched Tool also there. So it was uh it was great. It was great. So it was a great festival. It was hot, it was hot out there in Indio, man. It's like it always is. Yeah, I'm sure there's there's like uh you know a big city there now, but you know, it was then it was nothing.
SPEAKER_03So did you get lost in the desert for like two months and just traveling nomad?
SPEAKER_01Pretty much, pretty much, yeah. I think everybody was just you know having a good time out there, you know. Sure.
SPEAKER_03Well, so for the folks who don't remember from uh the note the copious note-taking that they had uh from the last episode, um, and their workbook, their insurance dude's workbook available. I don't know. There is one. Um at Sears. Order that at Sears. Get in at Sears. Um, where uh where did you start? How'd you get into this?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. So um man, I've only been doing this about three years, but you you don't have to have a uh uh a degree to to sell insurance. That's for sure, right? So uh, but no, it's um I've always managed people, um, you know, since I was very young, you know, just kind of um coaching them, managing them. Um, and I ended up in insurance about three years ago from a referral from a buddy. Um and I'm like, I don't want to do that. You know, it's it's it's not sexy, right? Insurance is not sexy at all. So uh but uh what were you doing before? Man, I worked for a corporate. I was uh ATT direct TV for about 10 to 15 years. So that's right. Yeah, yeah. So um call centers and stuff like that. So um, but yeah, no, it's definitely, I mean, you guys know, right? It's it's people management, man, people management 101, right? And you know, and uh and uh and making it fun, making it, you know, making it sexy, right? So so that's kind of uh our mission, right? To to make it fun and and and be successful, you know. So awesome.
SPEAKER_02That's cool, man. And then then so since then, uh what's so interesting, so we were talking about how you've dropped some some bombs in the in the group. I mean, you're really into marketing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. So um, yeah, it's something I really kind of I'm I I love technology, right? So I'm always kind of looking for the next thing, you know. So um, you know, and uh yeah, so I'm always kind of looking for for different ways to communicate, different ways to, you know, to learn. And and you know, being dropped into a brand new agency, not knowing what the heck I was doing, um, I had to figure that out pretty fast. So it was sink or swim. So I I I joined all the groups, joined all the groups, talked to all the people, um, you know, did all my types of marketing, did my own marketing, you know, and things like that. But uh, but no, it's I'm still learning, right? So it's still it's still a uh a journey, a journey when it comes to marketing.
SPEAKER_02I think anybody that does it, I mean I don't think it's a static thing. I think anybody that does it well is into it and it they're constantly trying stuff. There's like an RD side of it, there's a nerdy side of it, because I love it too. And it's like, yeah, I'll crack out at night, like just like searching stuff and like figuring out stuff, linking, linking stuff together.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the rabbit holes, the rabbit holes of marketing.
SPEAKER_01Totally, totally. Yeah, no, you can you can definitely, you know, take it takes a lot of time. I think you know, I I was probably doing marketing 80% of my day, probably, you know, at the very beginning, trying to figure it out, you know. Um, but but I mean it it's it's a good thing, right? I mean, I know a lot of people, you know, they they rely on different lead vendors and stuff like that. And and it's I I think it's okay to do that, right? The supplement, but to know like what's all going behind the scenes and stuff like that, and how they're actually generating leads for you, it's like, man, I can do that. But hey, do I really want to do that? Because it's gonna take my whole day, right?
SPEAKER_03So, so we were we we were just talking about that, um, Jason and I yesterday. We were working on some stuff for the teledudes, and it it came up it. We know we we're always working on these different marketing things and different pieces, but it was it's so funny because you'll start working on one thing, and then you realize, oh, I have to do this other step. So you're on step one, but then you go over here to fix the one thing so that you can get to step two, but it's like takes all day, right, to do that thing, and then you're like, What the hell was I even doing? And then at the end, it's like you wind back, and now you're right back at step one. Now you can go to step two, and then it just like the whole time, you know, it's like, oh, I'm gonna make an ad, and then the pixel. You're like, ah, yeah, and then you gotta do this whole thing, right? And yeah, it's just it's amazing.
SPEAKER_01Yep, and you need and you need this program and you need that for this app, and you need that, and you need this, and then like what? I don't even know my login, you know, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I think that's how we end up with so many logins is so many different things, right?
SPEAKER_01It's so true, it's so true, it's so true, yeah. So, but I I think the the biggest thing that I've kind of I've kind of learned is that um obviously you have to have many, many lead sources. It can't you can't depend on one, right? You cannot. So um, you know, because it will dry up and you move on doesn't mean that you're never gonna do it again. It just means that hey, I'm gonna take a break from it, right? But but the one thing that that I I I would, you know, no matter, no matter even if you're an independent or a captive agent, um like branding, branding your own name and your own, your your your own agency is key. It's key in this in this age, you know. I mean, with with uh, you know, gone are the days where where you're you know you're paying for a billboard or you're paying for you know a bus stop sign or whatever, right? I mean, people are on digital, right? So all forms of digital, right? Being able to, you know, um use that and leverage that to get your name out, right? To get your name out and and and not and not shove insurance down their throat, right? It's it's just like you know, I I think we were talking about it a couple uh a couple weeks back about you know people posting on social, you know, hey, you know, buy by you know, let me quote you or whatever, whatever they put up.
SPEAKER_03I just save somebody 200 bucks. It's like yeah, nobody is calling you when you're calling, right?
SPEAKER_01I mean your mom may like it, right? Your mom may like the post.
SPEAKER_03She's sharing it.
SPEAKER_01She may share it, she may share it, you know. But uh, but but no, it's so true, right? But but I mean, I think that's my approach, right? When it comes to branding, I'm like, I'm not necessarily saying, hey, you know, I want you to know who I am, right? I want you to know who I am, I want you to know who my staff is. I want you to know that I like Karate Kid and Cobra Kai, right? And it's just like, you know, like even some of the social content, right? Who cares if you fumble up words and it's you know, it's nothing, you know, it's just dude, just be yourself, right? That's why people are gonna buy from you. That's why people are gonna stay from you.
SPEAKER_02It's almost better. It's better to not be perfect. It's so weird. So, in marketing in general, the days of polished stuff being better, being more legitimate than unpolished are completely over. Because you can have a video that is just slamming, like by a director, you had the whole team out there, right? People aren't gonna click on it because it looks like a like a BS ad. Where if you have your phone and it's all jumbly and you dropped it and then you pick it back up, like somebody will watch that. And it's like, dude, you just did that with your phone. And like this other one cost a thousand bucks or ten thousand bucks. Uh I don't know what people are paying. But uh but it's like as far as marketing goes, uh it's uh what you used to because I think the deal was back in the day is that okay, they must be a good company if they can afford to make this video. And now uh there's a different perception of if they made this polished video, they must be sleazy and they're gonna take my money and not uh provide value. Like for some reason, like a something real. Like they, you know, it was like that time when um you know reality TV became more real than than you know the old soap operas or whatever, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. It like I think in the old days it legitimized your your status, and there weren't so many different distribution methods, right? But now it's everywhere, and so everybody is up in everybody's business now, right? They everybody knows what you're doing. So if you're doing this, you know, hundred thousand dollar production, they're like, Who the who is this guy over here, right? They're like, Jason doesn't do that, he doesn't put a suit on. What the hell is this, right? They're like fake, fake news over here, you know. So they they just they just want you to be authentic, right? And and uh you make the jokes, you say the stuff, you don't say I save somebody 500 bucks because they don't care, like nobody's they're not gonna stop while as they're scrolling their feed, right? Going through, and they're like mindlessly going through their feed and go, Oh right. No, they're looking at pictures of cats and clowns with memes on them, right? So that's what you deliver. There's a guy. Um, do you follow Tyler Rhymer? Rhymer? Ramer, uh he's a he's an agent, he's a he's an independent and he does memes, like he makes memes. That's all he does. And and he's freaking hilarious. Like he makes really good ones, or he gets them from somewhere, but he posts that, and that's the idea, right? You want to be in front of them. Branding isn't uh an instant result. Branding is when Martin gets pissed and needs insurance, he's gonna think of me because I'm funny and I like to golf or whatever, right? And then then they're gonna connect. That's what you do, you build the audience that way. It's the approach, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, exactly. Exactly. It's funny, funny story is that uh um, you know, the like how TikTok is so big now, right? So, so the uh the you know, the Travis Scott burger. The Travis Scott, I'm like sure you all heard about it, right? So so the Travis Scott burger. So I've I've been to McDonald's two times since that since that came out, uh with my kids, of course, right? But uh, but yeah, so we've been to McDonald's two times. So it's just a quarter pounder with cheese with some barbecue sauce. That's it.
SPEAKER_03Really?
SPEAKER_01That's all it is, and a sprite and some barbecue sauce. That's all it is. That's all it is. But I'm just saying is that you know, the these silly things like this, right? That that you just get into people's, you know, face, they're gonna remember, right? They're gonna remember. So whether if if it's a stupid TikTok video where we're or whether it's you know, whatever it is, right? Just kind of you know, being yourself and showing showing them what you offer or showing them who you are, it's like they're gonna remember that, right? So so that's the key. So yeah, so that's really kind of like how for for me, like how I'm focused, I'm focused on branding my agency. So um, that's been fun.
SPEAKER_02Two things I I want to say about that. One is I'm so sick of everybody being so health conscious that I'm so glad that you went to McDonald's and had a burger.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. See, so so if everybody could hate insurance too, right? So hate insurance, but they'll see a funny video and they'll like, oh, I'm gonna call this guy because I he I thought he was pretty funny, right?
SPEAKER_03So they're buying it, they're gonna buy it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, they're gonna buy it.
SPEAKER_02That's so funny. That's so funny. And you do a ton of I I've noticed that you just do a ton of videos. Um, and I know that you get a lot of responses from them. And a day, like you know, you hear about oh, this social media channel's dead or this is dead. Um, whatever, it doesn't matter. They're all you know here and there, right? It's a it's trends or whatever. But but like your stuff isn't dead because you're doing you're you're doing pattern interrupt type stuff where it's like, oh, I I you come on my feed, it's like I gotta watch the video. I'm like, ah, it's funny.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, I mean I obviously, yeah, it's just it's just you know, try to be consistent, you know, get some type of pattern, but just like, you know, um, I've tried to mirror stuff off of TikTok and stuff too, right? So different things. But um, but yeah, no, I mean it it's it's just posting, posting regularly and you know, going for engagement. I I think when people think of uh of posting on social, they think they want to get something out of it, right? Like what do you what do you want to get out of it, right? Oh, here's a lead form, right, to fill that out. I mean, nobody's gonna click on that lead form for that, right? Just put your face out there, you know, those things like that. You know, maybe do a giveaway here and there, you know. I mean, it it's just to stay, you know, involved in in the in the area and local local presence and stuff. So um, so yeah, but no, I mean that that's your that's your local presence now, right? So um your local presence, your your involvement in the community, those type of things like that is gonna be on all all types of social.
SPEAKER_02So I think you nailed it though when you said um you're not the stuff that you're posting is never asking for them to fill out a form or like them to do something. You're just giving them some content and leaving it at that, which you're giving them something that engages. Like I noticed that you get a lot of engages on your post. Um so that's a great thing to think about, especially you know, in this day and age where there's uh billions of things on your feeds. I mean, we have tons of sure to your point, there's TikTok now, and there's all kinds of stuff. So it's like if you're asking for something, it's like, dude, I don't want to deal with this guy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. No, they they know you're an expert in your field, right? They are they know you are. So it's like, so I mean, we've got I've gotten calls from friends, relatives, you know, like, hey, you know, I have a question. I have an insurance question. I'm like, yeah, yeah, well, let's let's sit down, we can talk, you know, those type of things like that. That's what you want, right? I mean, that's what you want. So, so that's that's what makes it fun, you know, and it makes it more enjoyable when you're able to do those things like that, you know. So instead of calling the guy saying the call, the guy you get from a lead aggregator that you know that doesn't that doesn't want insurance and is complaining about everything, right? So uh well you gotta call that guy 60 times.
SPEAKER_03That's the yeah, 60 times. That's true. That's true. Yeah, that's true. But but so so I'm hearing from that post post consistently, right? Like you have to be consistent, you can't just post one this one time this week and then go, this shit doesn't work, right? Social media doesn't work, but so you can't do that, or you have to you have to be consistent and um and then relevant, right? You want to you want to pick something that's trending, so you do the Travis Scott thing because it's something that's relevant right now, right? Or you bring or you bring that into the equation because it's something that's relevant, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Just be funny, just be funny, just bring something relevant and you know in the area and the community and the weather, whatever it is, just be silly, dude, right? I mean, just be silly, but but but have some type of value that you're giving them, right? Like, oh, I didn't know that, right? Like I didn't I didn't know about you know ride for higher type of stuff, or I didn't know about you know a deductible or whatever it is. If they take one little thing from it, you know, it's a it's a less than a 30 to 50 second video, right? I mean, that they just listen to, you know. So um, so yeah, I mean, if they can get something from that, you know, I'm like, you're you're reaching more people too, right? And and sharing with them, you know, giving them something value, you know. So um, but yeah, no, it's it's it's it's really good, I think.
SPEAKER_03What about yeah, though, Craig? What about Google? So I know Google, go go the Google. Have you heard of what number one? Have you heard of the Google?
SPEAKER_01The Google, yeah. I heard that I heard of it.
SPEAKER_03Number two, have you heard of the Google My Business?
SPEAKER_01Google My Business, yeah.
SPEAKER_03GMB is I know you have because you you've talked yeah, you GMB. You you've you've talked about it a lot in the in the elite group, and it's um it's awesome because it really is a a poor man's way to create some traffic, right? Like you don't have to really spend any money, any money at all, and you can actually get some results. Why don't you talk about that? Because I really appreciated the stuff that you told me.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, no, it's um, you know, I I started looking at it and you started seeing all the the different the analytics and the it's really easy, really simple too, right? The platform, it's not very difficult, but I mean that's where people are finding us, right? You know, that's where when people look for insurance, they're going to Google, right? They're they're Google, they're they're that's where they're they're they're finding us. So um, so yeah, so just just making that, treating that like it as you would a social media platform. Um, you know, posting, um you know, um going through there, making sure your reviews, updating your reviews, uh, doing those things like that. I mean, is it it's been it's been huge. And um, I mean, you can see the volume, right? Um, and it's it's just been able to help and and give a give a better um a better look for the agency, right? For people just kind of searching, searching on there. So yeah.
SPEAKER_03Do you build a page out on there too?
SPEAKER_01No, no, no. I I link our my own website on there.
SPEAKER_00So you can you can you can be continuous. It's the inch-rands, dude. Don't turn it off, man. That really be rude. We're dropping knowledge on the radio, so just turn it up.
SPEAKER_02So we put together a little webinar from all the things that we've learned, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, totally. I love it. It was a lot of fun um doing it, putting it together, and uh there's some really good stuff in there.
SPEAKER_02Yes, what did we learn? We learned how to sell hundreds of thousands of premium a month using any internet leads, and this is based on a whole bunch of big dudes selling ton and ton and ton of premium a month, like over a million.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it it it eliminates that turnover, right? The staff doesn't get burned out. It does, it creates predictable sales, like whoa, right? Well, and we also learned how we can copy the processes of the big, giant, fastest growing PNC carriers and the big local agents. Yep. That was a lot of fun.
SPEAKER_02So it was fun. We put it together, we it's on a website go to love dot teledudes.com. That's l-o-v-e.com. How do you spell like that on the fly, Mr.
SPEAKER_03Jason?
SPEAKER_02Well, it took me some practice, but it's love.t e L dudes.com.
SPEAKER_03You are good at that. So let me get this straight. It's love l-ov dot teledudes.com. Love.teledudes.com. I love that.
SPEAKER_02I love it too. I surprised you too, Mr. Craig. You know, it tricked me.
SPEAKER_00Wait, are they even listening to this on the radio anymore?
SPEAKER_03I love it. I love it. Nice.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman