The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Jeff MajorWe Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------...
Yes! This is gonna be a fun, fun podcast from the Elite Dudes Group.
SPEAKER_01
The Elite Dudes Group. It's true.
SPEAKER_02
Who do we have?
SPEAKER_01
Craig? Well, we have Mr. Jeff Majors. He's a loan officer. And we'll get into some of those details here in a second. He's gonna tell his story. But first I want to also welcome there's a bunch of the Elite Dude members are in here right now.
SPEAKER_02
Yes.
SPEAKER_01
Just chilling. So it looks like the Brady Bunch because we've got everybody up on the screens here. So it's pretty cool. But let's introduce Jeff. Jeff, why don't you tell us a little bit? Whoa, slow down.
SPEAKER_02
What's the first question?
SPEAKER_01
What's the first concert that you went to? The first concert.
SPEAKER_00
Boys to men.
SPEAKER_01
Boys to men?
SPEAKER_00
Yes. I was waiting to see some responses on that one. It would have been no, I think it was TFOL. It was who? It was a punk show. I think it was like TOL at uh at Old World.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, I used to go to Old World all the time. I saw Blink 182 there and old hardcore bands.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, exactly. But we've that's awesome.
SPEAKER_02
We've had uh we've had new kids on the block, backstreet boys. We've had some good ones.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, make sense.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, wouldn't be a shocker if that was true. So so Jeff, uh take us back um all the way from your old punk days uh to now. How did you get into uh to where you're at?
SPEAKER_00
Well, good question. That uh I've been in the industry for so right now I'm a mortgage broker. I've been in doing loans since I got out of the Air Force in 2001, right before 9-11, actually. I well, I had a service connected knee issue. I had surgery, so they didn't actually call me back after 9-11 happened. And so in the Air Force, I was a this is kind of a funny label, but aircraft loadmaster. So what I was in charge of was the load in charge of loads, coming on and off of the actual fuselage. So I had to make sure that everything was tied down, the weight and balance was proper, give it to the pilot, and that's what I did. So actually, the reason I mentioned that is that was kind of my love for math. So it kind of was an easy segue into um loans. And uh and how I got into that was basically it was in the retail space. I worked for a prior to that, I worked for a small broker, kind of just learning the tricks of the trade. It's the coolest thing, it's actually similar to insurance, where you're not really selling anything. It's not it's like a necessity, right, for people to take advantage of being a homeowner or and if you're not insured, it's kind of similar, right? But I'm just here to save people money. So paying less, it's not it's kind of you know, you there's not actually a product that you're pushing on people. The numbers speak for themselves, and you can just kind of move on, surround yourself with good people. And over the years I have done that. Um most recently I was a um manager for a large company called Loan Depot. And you might have heard of them. They're they're uh like number two in the country to quicken in terms of uh retail loans. So all Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHAVA, all of the they call them um government sponsored entities, um kind of cookie cutter type of loans. Um I managed about 25 people for the retention department. So everybody that had a loan currently with Loan Depot, and if as we saw benefit or as they called in, I would manage a team of loan officers to go out there and just kind of connect the dots to see if the current market works out, and it was great. Bit of a grind. Um and after 19 years in the business, um I recently, just this past October, actually got my mortgage broker's license. So it's just a little bit of a different approach. Um, I met Brandon uh just through soccer. Our two daughters, nine-year-olds, uh, were playing on um kind of the mission via hill little AYSO all-star team. And that's kind of how we met. And I have an older daughter as well. It just came to a point where I needed to slow things down. I've had some good years behind me. I've known the business, and it's it was time to start working for myself rather than working for the man kind of thing. Free up some time, make sure my kids remember who I am. Because uh that and my wife too that matters. So um that's what I've been doing recently since October. It's kind of been weird with this whole COVID thing that hit us in March. So I'm pretty much just referral-based, community-based. I have access to about 120 different uh wholesale lenders and the platform that I work with, it's called C2 Financial. So I use my broker's license. And I have an overarching broker, um, which is C2. It's the largest kind of broker community and in the country that allows us to have pre-negotiated, very low rates and terms um with some of the top wholesale lenders out there. So it makes it a little easy so I don't have to haggle on price and all that. It just comes kind of at my fingertips and just make myself available for the services that I can offer for my cell phone, picking up the phone every day and or every time it comes in, and just keeping the volume a little bit low, but making big impact. So that's basically what I'm saying.
SPEAKER_01
So hey Jeff, so so um loan officers are the holy grail of referrals for insurance dudes, right? Um it when we connect with a good a good uh loan officer and and we're providing good service uh uh for that loan officer, then then we can really get fed. And um, you know, so what what as a loan officer, what are you looking for in a relationship with a insurance dude or do that, and and how are they going to most effectively help you so you want to drive them traffic or steer traffic their way?
SPEAKER_00
That's a great question. Um so like I kind of referred to earlier on in the conversation, um, the similarities between insurance and loans, it's pretty organic, right? So uh referrals being wanted on both ends of that. So there's just basic, some simple basic questions. I think anytime in a transaction that I have, um, and it's one thing that most loan officers don't think about, but if an insurance person that I was uh involved with reminded me to just ask the question, hey, when's the last time you shop for insurance? Because I need a declarations page on every loan I do, right? Hey, are you bundling right now? I know that sometimes that's easier, but it's not always cheaper. I always just recommend, you know, I can take what you have now, but maybe over the next week or so call my buddy or call them and see if they can beat it. And then they can send me whatever I would need to get this going while we're on the topic of saving you money, right? So that would be value add if I would remember to say it something like that. So as these relationships get stoked, right? And I had because I have my own insurance buddy that you know, uh there's not a ton of loyalty there, but just a little bit of effort, and same thing um could be reciprocated on on my on the other end, you know what I mean? So as an insurance agent, um that would really pique my attention is if an insurance agent approached me as a mortgage broker in the Michigan Viejo community um and said, Hey, here's what I do. I'm looking for relationships. I talk to people all the time. Not all of them are homeowners, some of them are actually looking to buy. I ask one simple open-ended question. All of a sudden, man, if I asked this question, would you be the guy that'd be able to handle something like this and ask them if they're looking to buy a house, right? Can you get paid qualified? Or you know, since we're saving money on insurance, have you thought about refinance? I've seen a lot of stuff in the headlines. I have a great guy for you. Just those simple things just to think about it and get get outside of our little world and always think about the next little that would be coming in. So that's what I would recommend.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. I love it. And go. You go. No, I went. You you go.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, it's it's funny how uh when it comes to all this stuff with sales or or insurance, or I mean it's all the same. I was just talking to Brandon about this. Um Brandon works with us at the uh teledudes, and I was just talking about it, doesn't matter, there is a skill of connection that it like that somebody either has or doesn't. You it's arguable whether or not you could teach it to somebody, but um like that communication, that connection is everything, right? You can't just bring somebody in and teach them that. They have to they have to have that, and usually it's developed over a long period of time. And it doesn't matter if you're talking about insurance is boring, loans are boring, right? But those connections are key. I think.
SPEAKER_00
Absolutely, absolutely. And you know the the funniest thing is with insurance and like I I have my loan application, right? Residential loan application, they call it the 1003, and you can get in the weeds, but it's different than being an accountant, right? So if you're an accountant, you're just crunching numbers, and that's what you dig, that's what you get off on. Okay, so I mean that's just what's exciting about your business. That's not people probably like you and I, what it is the sales thing, whether you're selling you have to be into your product, and uh you can get stoked about the product where uh where I think most of it becomes um most of the excitement comes is being able to present the value, right? So if you actually care about the consumer, no matter what it is, somebody called you to save money. Oh my gosh, this is awesome! I can save you with refines. I'm saving like right now in this climate, the least amount of benefit that I've done in the last probably 20, 20 applications that I've been sent in over the past month or two was $350 a month savings. That's like a car payment for most people. And those are the little things you focus in on is what are you gonna do? And some of this stuff's cliche. It's like when people are like, oh, like backing away, and you're like, okay, it sounds like you know, you have an opportunity for me to slide $350 under your front porch on the first of every month. Would you take that or not? Right. I would. So what's the real objection here, type of thing, right? Like, this is a no-brainer. I'm not even selling you anything. It must be me. That's fine. Let me let me hear more about what what's what's really bugging you, type of thing.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, right?
SPEAKER_00
It's just all about the value. So that gets me going.
SPEAKER_01
Love it. Yeah, and and I I think that that that's something there, totally a little bit of a tangent there that that Jason brought up was was that sales process. Like you you can train that, like you can train how to build value, you can train how to overcome objections, you can train um a lot of those things, but that that ability to connect, that rep, you know, ability to to create rapport, talk to people, that's very, very challenging to train. You know, we've had I've had producers where you bring them in and and you're like, okay, well, no, all you need to do is ask them something like, Hey, are you a Tucson native? Because they're either gonna say yes or no, and then you have somewhere to go with that, right? Like, no, oh, okay, where are you from? Right? Or yes, oh wow, there's only a couple of you, you know, like it it literally just opens the door. And if and some people you teach them these things, they get then they can't even work with that. So it's real important to to be in this line of of work to be able to have those conversations and connect, right? Uh with the clients, but also with these uh ancillary services. Like for us, it's loan officers, right? If we connect with loan officers, realtors, and and um I'm missing one, but loan officers are really the bread and butter. Like you guys can provide the the most value to our clients, um, and and uh and they say yes, they trust you, right? Because you're handling saving them that money. So I know there was a question in there somewhere, but um I I just it it it's it's really, really awesome to have these good relationships.
SPEAKER_02
Um yeah, and I love how you said that it's all that it is all relationship-based, like most of your business. Um it's just funny because we do get in the weed so many, so many times with you know, the technical stuff, um, especially if you're an independent agent, you got a lot of cool stuff that you can do. Uh with all the technical stuff, but at the end of the day, man, I mean, you cannot beat a relationship. Like if you have a relationship with a couple different people that are crushing it, I mean, you guys can uh all just kill it just because everybody, you know, you're building those relationships with each other, but also they're you know, it's it compounds as we all you know talk to other people and stuff. So it can be super powerful. Well, there's no question.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, this is the interesting thing, and you brought this up, Jeff. You you said that um uh a lot of times you don't remember to ask, right? You don't remember for for the for the agent. And I've heard this um many, many times in meeting loan officers. I'll say, hey, um, you know, I'm my name's Craig Pretzinger. I own a couple agencies, and we we like to connect with with people who have the same kind of business model and want to drive um lots and lots of activity to their agency. We help by bringing you activity, and and in turn, we would hope that we could that could be a two-way thing. And they'll almost every time say, you know what, this happens all the time. Uh an agent comes in, I see them one time, maybe two times, and then never again, right? And so that aligns with what you said that you don't remember, and all it takes literally is a call a week, right? Or send a card or send over some donuts or or whatever, right? Just just connect because people are gonna do business with people they know, like, and trust. And if I if I go say hi to you one time and then you never see me again, I mean there isn't much there, right? So how often does that happen to you?
SPEAKER_00
Or has it happened?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, yeah. Where they where they say, Hey, I want to come and let's let's you know send business back and forth, and then oh, are you talking about the insurance age the insurance agents specifically hitting honestly not a lot?
SPEAKER_00
And yeah, interesting. I do just in my management days too. Um I try to make it most easy on my borrowers, right? So there's certain things a lot of people don't have their declarations page at their fingertips. And I don't you guys may receive some of these calls. So I always ask, you know, I have one right now. It's they bought a house, I'm doing like an FHA streamline loan. I have everything that I need for them, but they're like, I don't know who my insurance agent is. And I'm like, okay, let me ask you this question. If your house caught on fire, who would you call? I don't know. I'm like, okay, so who has your car insurance? Triple A. A lot of people bundle, is it them? They had they had zero idea. So what I typically do, like with this person, they're super busy. What I would do if she actually knew who it was, I would just Google, hey, all state, right, or whoever it is, and then oh, it's probably this person in your community. What's their name? And if because a lot of people don't have it in there, I could find you online really easily. And then what I do as a loan officer or broker is I pick up the phone, three-way call, super easy on these iPhones, hit the plus button and merge, and boom, it's there. Introduce myself. Hey, excellent. Hey, Linda, do I have your permission to talk to your insurance agent? Blah, blah, blah. And then send over your the deck page. Is that okay if they send it directly to me? Shoot me an email. Boom, there's a connection right there between a loan officer that can hand you more business for the next time. I open the door. I don't know how many calls like that you guys may get, but if you ever do get one, um there they just did your work for you in terms of creating a relationship with a referral source.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Always be thinking about where your next bit of business is coming from. And your job gets so easy because it's funny, you're not gonna be up at night thinking about where the next deal is because you'll wake up to a text message from Jeff Major saying, Hey, I need somebody to quote you. I remember who you are, instead of freaking out and being like, Oh, dude, I need to fill up my pipeline here, or whatever, however that works, maybe it's got to be part of the training process in the agency and it's got to be part of everybody's dialogue.
SPEAKER_01
Like, um, it's not I don't think it's being greedy, it's it's it's being able to identify and find the the the places in a conversation where it's gonna be of mutual benefit, right? So the um somebody calls in to make a payment, somebody calls in to whatever, do yeah, get get ID cards. There's something that can come out of that call, whether it's a client or it's it's a loan officer calling in or whoever, there's always something that can come out of that call that's gonna be mutually beneficial for both parties. And so if if the staff, if if everybody that answers that phone is able to think like that, you're 100%. You know, like you're you're all of a sudden stacking your efforts, you're getting results from the those call-ins instead of okay, I did it by, and then okay, how am I gonna find something? Right? Like you just had it right there. Don't turn it off, man. That really gives me a room. We're dropping out the radio, so just turn it up.
SPEAKER_02
So we put together a little webinar from all the things that we've learned, right?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, totally. I love it. It was a lot of fun um doing it, putting it together, and there's some really good stuff in there.
SPEAKER_02
Yes, what did we learn? We learned how to sell hundreds of thousands of premium a month using any internet leads, and this is based on a whole bunch of big dudes selling ton and ton of premium a month, like over a million.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, and it it it eliminates that turnover, right? The staff doesn't get burned out. It does, it creates predictable sales, like whoa, right? Well, and we also learned how we can copy the processes of big, giant, fastest growing PNC carriers and the big local agents.
SPEAKER_02
Yep. That was a lot of fun. So it was fun. We put it together, we it's on a website. Go to love.teledudes.com. That's l-o-v-e.t-e-l-ed-u-d-e-s.com How do you spell like that on the fly, Mr. Jason? Well, it took me some practice, but it's love.tel dudes.com.
SPEAKER_01
You are good at that. So let me get this straight. It's loveloved.com. Love.teledudes.com. I love that.
SPEAKER_02
I love it too. I surprised you too, Mr. Craig. You didn't know it tricked me.
SPEAKER_01
Wait, do they even listen to this on the radio anymore? I love it. I love it. Nice. Uh
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.