The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
How To Get Paid For Leads Not Pay For Leads | David Caraothers
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast.
SPEAKER_00We all have three stock backgrounds and none of them are the same.
SPEAKER_02Good. That is important.
SPEAKER_00Dave is important. Love it.
SPEAKER_02Been a long time.
SPEAKER_00Been forever. Been forever. I don't know how I've lived without you guys.
SPEAKER_02Less than 24 hours since we were on the one of the most exceptional podcasts that you can listen to. I mean, in the insurance space, I think there's two competing. The rest, no need. But we are super, super glad to have uh David Caruthers back, who's a mastermind in the commercial space.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yes. And so we we we did his podcast yesterday, uh, the power producers. So if you haven't listened, you have to jump on in and do some heavy lifting over there with uh the powerful producers. But um before that, uh or or while we were talking, um David, you you started talking about uh a little funnel that you had uh that you have on with automation for a little policy that people might make fun of you for, but it starts this funnel where you hit some automation with it. Next thing you know, they might become customers, so you actually get paid for your leads.
SPEAKER_02Seems like he's the last one laughing here.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, man, it's pretty cool. We um it's funny because we got several of those funnels built up. Um, the one that I shared with you yesterday is the one that has been the most successful so far. Unfortunately, when that one took off, we decided it would be a great idea to build funnels around gyms and childcare facilities. Go COVID, right? So my ability to create funnels has only superseded my ability by my ability to be clairvoyant. But uh we've got we you know, we've developed quite a few niche markets. That was the prototype for us, and once we got that uh landing page built and sort of the architecture of how things were in a flow flow through it, we can replicate that across a bunch of different lead sources. Um, so it's not captive to wedding insurance per se, but that just seemed to be one that was a natural for us because progressive wants young married couples these days, you know, in the independent channel. And I just had gotten a progressive contract, so that's how I solved the problem.
SPEAKER_01That's so cool. And I love the the thought. So can you kind of for anybody that that didn't listen uh that hasn't yet listened to the power producers? Um can you take us through what what is that funnel?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, sure. So, you know, my goal in anything that I do is always to be one off of what you think I'm doing, so that you never know what I'm really doing. Yes. And so so there may be an end game, there may be a front game. It's up to you to figure out which one it is, but in this case, it's a front game. And so, you know, our agency specializes in middle market commercial business. Our average accounts are between 250 and 500,000 in premium. So for me to be screwing around with a wedding insurance website or whatever else, it's is somewhat laughable. I I can understand, but you know, a lot of my friends are busting my chops about, you know, the fact that I've got this, you know, that we own Florida wedding insurance. And one thing I didn't talk about yesterday is I don't just own Florida wedding insurance. I own Florida Wedding Insurance.com, Tampa WeddingInsurance.com, Naples, Fort Myers, the Keys, and all of them point to that funnel. So we're going to every major wedding destination in Florida, which is basically any city in Florida because it's a huge destination state. And we bought the domains to point back to that same landing page. And so the idea behind it was to get a quote bind issue product for liability out and available to people so that we didn't have to touch it. It became a passive income stream for us. But um in the process of building that, we realized that instead of us just making a passive income stream, it would be better to have a passive income stream that was also a lead source to a much larger income stream relative to what we're getting. So the way that the program's set up, we are allowed to net the commissions out of the placement of the policy. So we take a $50 program administration fee from the group that we're doing this with. And so every time we sell a quote bind issue GL, you know, wedding liability policy, we make $50. Well, the first thing that got real is when we started moving like six to eight of these things a day, and I ran the numbers, and I'm like, holy crap, man, this is like a hundred thousand dollar a year job that I'm not even having to show up for. This is awesome. But we we we use HubSpot as our CRM in the agency. So I'm you know, we're pretty hip to automation. I'm a huge fan of using video as much as you can. We've been using video for years before COVID ever hit, whether it be for video proposals or marketing or just general content. And so we created a sequence around that so that when somebody bought the wedding product, it took them to a thank you page that began an automation sequence with me basically welcoming them to the Florida Risk Partners family, thanking them for the opportunity to do business with them, and then letting them know that while we're not going to be obnoxious about it, we are gonna remind them about other milestones in their life that might happen over the next little bit. And so we have the anniversary date, the date of the wedding, is automatically pulled into HubSpot because that everything is based off of that. So at predetermined times between the time they purchase the policy and their wedding, they'll get reminder email emails from us about probably worth looking at your homeowners, probably worth updating your auto, make sure that you've looked at life and disability, make sure that the ring is covered or the rings are covered, and all of those things. And so it became a really nice lead source for a very young personal lines division in our agency. And, you know, people again, you know how it is, locker room, whatever, guys are gonna bust each other's chops. I was constantly getting made fun of that I'm screwing around with this, but at the end of the day, I look at it this way you know, we drive traffic to those landing pages through search and display ads. And, you know, my Google, I have a Google budget, it's not high. I spend about a hundred bucks a month to drive traffic. We're the number one ranked site on Google for Florida wedding insurance. And so um as long as I'm spending less money on my ad spend than what I'm making on the revenue for the wedding policies, everybody else who's making fun of me is paying to get leads, and I'm getting paid to get leads. So I'm trying to figure out what I'm doing wrong.
SPEAKER_01I love it, and I love it because I wanted I I thought this message should be shared because it's more of a thought process rather than than the sp the specifics of that, but like insurance, man, we can insure so many different things. We have so much knowledge that other people need that it's so good to go narrow on something and ascend them up, right? That you don't you don't have to like we're we're told for so many years that hey bring somebody into the agent, us PNC guys, you know what I mean, and then just sell them everything. And it's like, dude, if somebody's coming in for auto insurance, they don't necessarily want quotes on everything that day, right? We we need to think more of hey, I'm into I love you know RVing, right? Well, why not get you know go into that niche and then ascend them up into my funnel, right? Or or you know, I love the the wedding insurance. Um, but there's there's probably a hundred variations of that that we can do. Um I really like I love I love how you're doing that. I think that's so cool.
SPEAKER_00I will tell you who the niche master is, and if you haven't had him on the show, you should, but it's Mr. Bob Klinger from up in uh Maryland, and you should reach out to Bob and talk to him because this guy his niche game is off the charts. Like he started out with dry cleaners, and uh he just branched out from dry cleaners to Asian restaurants to the people who were doing the equipment sales to the dry cleaners in the Asian restaurants, to the people who are cleaning the vent hoods and the grease traps. Like now, if you have an Asian-owned business in his area of Maryland outside of DC, and you want to get insurance, it's just call Bob. That's it. That's what they tell everybody. And it's funny because I mean, this guy is really, really smart. I mean, I really I I respect him a lot. I appreciate um how he's built his agency, but he actually went to school. I didn't even know this was such a thing. He went to college and got a degree in dry cleaning. That's a thing. That's a thing, and the reason why he picked dry cleaning, or well, I should say the reason why a lot of the Korean people and and and the Asian people who come over pick dry cleaning is because they don't have to know a lot of English. Please, thank you. They give the total in numbers, which is a universal language. That's it. So you have low barriers of entry for these people to come over and start these businesses, and he figured that out. But what he's morphed his agency into is a result of that is just insane. I mean, he's running a multi-million dollar revenue agency as a result. I love that.
SPEAKER_01And and who who would ever think that hoods in in uh dry cleaners would be something to focus on, right? When there's so much stuff, everybody tries to be everything to everybody, and it's like, well, you're not gonna be very good. It's jack of all trades, but master of none.
SPEAKER_00I tell people all the time, man, you know, we are so pigeonholed into being salespeople, right? And I don't I don't like that. I don't like that moniker. I think that um, you know, I don't want to be the insurance salesman. When I think insurance salesman, I think Ned Ryerson from Groundhog Day, right? I just watched that. That's that's that's the guy that everybody thinks that we are, though, right? I mean, if you say, hey, I'm an insurance agent. Oh, no, thanks. I'm good. But you know, at the end of the day, we tie our compensation to the sale of a product. And if you change the way that you look at things and you make your job about solving problems, the sale of the product becomes the funding mechanism for them to have your problem-solving capabilities. Yep. Love it. And so that's how we focus. That's the difference between a trusted advisor and a salesperson.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. And and that's what in in the captive market, that's what they how they always tell us to sell is based on value and stuff, right? But like if solving problems is a value, that is being human. That's like helping someone, you know, it's it's so funny. Why is it when we put on our sales hat, we sell, and we're not human anymore? And it's like, whether it be the way we answer our phone or like, oh my gosh, I can't believe that. Like, just talking to somebody real and being empathetic, and those are the things that actually sell more than selling, is being empathetic and solving their problems, and the sales follow that, not the sale, and then and then you do that stuff. It's crazy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, I mean it's nuts. I mean, right now my agency leads with workers' compensation. It's easier for us to lead with workers' compensation in Florida because we have filed rates with the state, the state determines what the rate of the policy is. If I went to a hundred different carriers, as long as I have the right payrolls by class code, my quote is going to be identical across a hundred carriers. There's no competitive advantage, and we don't have scheduled credits and debits that can be filed against those rates that are material enough to where it's like it is in other states where there's pricing competition. So the competition becomes in the experience modification factor. And that's what we do. We visit the sick. We prospect people who have experience mods that are 1.0 or higher because we know that if we go in and we talk to them, we can help them recover some significant financial inefficiencies inside of their operation. That's a problem. And it's a problem that a lot of agencies aren't addressing because they don't want to learn how to go deep into the mod and understand the math behind it and then create the business case that you can relay to a CFO to get them to make the buying decision, right? Well, unfortunately, I've been doing that for the last fortunately and unfortunately, I've been doing that for the last, you know, four or five years. And I think people that I come into contact with throughout the industry think I'm a one-trick pony when it comes to workers' comp. That's not the case. That's just the problem that I'm solving now. When I first started my career 15 years ago, we had had four hurricanes come through, and the I passed over my house of all four of them, and the issue became property insurance. And so the problem that I needed to solve was how do I help you get admitted property insurance? And I found out found out very quickly that Chubb was the only regular carrier that would write on admitted paper. Everybody was pulling out of Florida left and right. Like there was literally nobody, probably 60 to 70% of the homeowners were in citizens, which is the state fund. And commercial was all in excess and surplus lines. So all I did was I went into Chubb and said, okay, you guys are writing admitted property. I'm brand new at this. I don't know if I'm doing it right or not, but figures to me that if I can get in front of some people and your product, I'm going to be able to solve a problem that's going to get lead to me getting a lot of business. What do you like to write? And they said, look, we like light manufacturing, technology, life sciences, and department of defense contractors, as long as it's masonry non-combustible construction from 1996 or newer. Okay, great. Let's take that and run with it. So what I did was I decided light manufacturing around our area is pretty good. I went to the uh tax collector's website and I did an export of everybody who had paid for an occupational license to be a manufacturer in Hillsborough and Pinellas County. And then I took that list and I went and I went to Reference USA, which is a free tool from the library, and I researched everybody's company to see what their revenues were, how many employees they had, because I wanted to hit a certain threshold and I trimmed everybody off the bottom half of that list. And then I went to the property appraiser's website to verify they had 1996 or newer masonry non-combustible construction. And that's what I worked on. I made that spreadsheet, and in 12 months' time, I went from having no book of business. Literally, I had no book of business. I was brand new in the industry, to writing $457,000 in agency revenue. It was over $3 million in premium that I wrote. And we didn't even get through the letter E on my list. We that was just A, B, C, D, and half a E. So, point being find the problem. I don't care what you're selling, quit selling it. Find the problem or the need that you need to meet and focus on doing that.
SPEAKER_02Right. I love that. There's this uh there's a mindset of I have the product, now I have to educate them so that I they'll understand what I have and then want to buy it. And it seems a lot more challenging than just finding the issue and solving for it.
SPEAKER_00Well, and the other thing, I mean, flip it flip the script a little bit in the personal lines world. One of the one of the most successful personalines people that I know is Jason Kilgo up in Virginia. Kilgo leads with umbrella. Okay. Think about that. If you lead with umbrella, you automatically get to see what the home and auto looks like. So that if you're gonna try and get all three of them, you're doing that in a way that doesn't require you to be a pushy salesperson. You need to do it because this person has some liability concerns, needs an umbrella for it. Might as well quote the rest of the stuff since you're gonna have the underlying coverage to put under the umbrella anyhow. And they kill it doing that.
SPEAKER_01Yep, you're gonna have to raise them, raise those limits on those other policies.
SPEAKER_00So yeah, you're gonna raise them and they're gonna go up too.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. I love it. I love it. Think from the back end rather than from the front end.
SPEAKER_00So much easier. So how many times it doesn't matter what you're doing in life, man? It's anything that you approach. If I I liken it to if you if you start on the back end and work your way toward the to the front to create a defined path, it's a whole lot easier than standing at the edge of a you know a cornfield and trying to find your way to that back end with nothing but a machete. What are the chances you're gonna actually end up where you're supposed to be? Start at the back, work your way forward and breaking it down into actionable steps. It's no different. I mean, you can, if you really wanted to do it the way that you should, you can say, okay, I want to make a hundred thousand dollars this year. Great. Well, how many accounts do I need to have to do that? Well, how many people do I have to meet with to get that many people to buy from me? And how many people do I have to quote to get that many people to meet with me? How many people do I have to call to let me quote? Then you can dial it into, well, I need to make 57 calls a day. I mean, I don't know what the number is, but you know, that's what people don't do. They're so worried about figuring out the the quickest way to get from point A to point B. I tell my team all the time, you have to slow down to speed up. If you slow down and figure everything out, you're gonna always work more efficiently if you have your process identified and easily replicated than if you're just shooting from the hip every time you you turn around.
SPEAKER_02There's a lot of shooting from the hip in this business.
SPEAKER_00Tons, which makes it easy for us to compete, right?
SPEAKER_02Well, and they'll and you know, just massive amounts of dials doesn't equal result, right? Because you don't if you don't know what that result is or where you want to go, then who cares? Because you could get sitting here making all these dials, doing all these things, and say, I did a ton, we were slammed, we did we rode a bunch, but it's still where is the goal? I love the corn the cornfield analogy and working backward, but that's a hundred percent correct. Figure out what you want to make, right? Figure out what you need to bring in, and and you can define exactly what you need. Yeah, and that is the beauty of this business.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, knowing that personal lines operates differently than we do in commercial, I mean, typically when people in commercial prospect, they're looking at 60 to 90 days before renewal, right? That's when they start hammering the phones. You know when I hammer the phones? A month or two after they renewed. Why do I do that? I do that less competition. Number one, there's less competition. Is it more difficult for me to get appointments then? Absolutely. But if I get them, there's an almost 100% chance I'm gonna close them. The reason why I like it a month or two after renewal is because A, if the renewal was bad, it still stings. They remember that. And emotionally, they're gonna be willing to take a meeting. If they have already had their audit, I can get the audited payrolls and everything that I need to do some of my analysis. If they haven't, I can offer to help guide them through that. Um, and then I've got seven or eight months. Oh, the other thing's loss data, right? So if they had to have loss runs to get through the renewal process, all of that data is still credible because it's only a month or two old. I don't have to go back because the loss runs are five months old and ask them to go contact their current agent to get loss information. They've already got it sitting on their desk. So we can get those things and begin to work with them. And we're in there working with people six months before anybody else even thinks about kicking the tires. And by the time renewal time comes, we've already had the deal on lockdown and we're named agent of record before anybody else has a chance to compete.
SPEAKER_01I love it. I love it. The strategy behind it is really where the gold is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's just thinking differently than everybody else does. I mean, I'm not interested in working hard. I've I've I want to work smart. I've said my entire career, I don't want to make 10 phone calls to get one appointment. I want to make one phone call and get 10 appointments. That's why I like to leverage webinars and lunch and learns and all of the other things I can do where I can show up one time and have an audience of 25 or 30 people. Yeah, love it.
SPEAKER_01Love it.
SPEAKER_0230 times the results from one for from the same amount of work.
SPEAKER_01What what what is your biggest piece of advice that you're giving um agents, newer agents that come to you and say, How do you do it, man? Like, what do I need to do? I'm I'm new.
SPEAKER_00So it's funny. I tell people the same thing every single time. Number one, I think that they need to get some level of product knowledge. Um, you know, you need to you need to go get a basis, a basic foundation of insurance understanding. You don't need to know everything up front because chances are you're not brand new in the industry and starting a scratch agency. You've got resources at your agency that can help you with coverage and things like that. But I think that's a thing that most people struggle with, you know, specifically in commercial, but I don't think that it's any different when in personal lines, is just interacting with whoever the buyer is, right? And I mean, I I go back to, and I tell this story all the time, but I go back to the very first really big account that I ever called on. I was 30 years old, the account was $750,000 in premium, and I was sitting in the parking lot, physically sick to my stomach, looking at this place like I have no business talking to these people. Why are they, you know, I don't know what I'm doing. I mean, I don't they have mechanical breakdown. What is mechanical breakdown? I mean, what you know, all of this stuff. And I basically just came to a realization I jerked a knot in my own rear end, and I'm like, look, dude, they've already validated your existence by agreeing to spend time with you for an hour. The only person that doesn't think you belong here is you. Get it through your head that you belong here, get out there and close the deal. That's it. We psych ourselves out. It doesn't matter if it's a $750,000 commercial account that I was scared to walk in the front door or a $750 personalized policy, and I don't want to make the phone call because I'm scared. Somebody might answer on the other end, and I don't know what to say to them.
SPEAKER_02Right. Come up with all the reasons why you can't be successful when all you need to do is just go there.
SPEAKER_00Find one reason why you can.
SPEAKER_02Right. Yeah. I know I'm gonna screw it up. You just crazy. Yeah, it's amazing. It's amazing. So, how did that appointment go?
SPEAKER_00I killed it.
SPEAKER_02You killed it?
SPEAKER_00There you go. Love it. When you um I well, again, man, I do a lot of research. When you're calling on accounts like that, you're not hunting with a shotgun, you're hunting with a rifle. And I, you know, again, a lot of people don't understand, you know, they think that our agency has grown to the size that it is. We do about three and a half million in agency revenue, roughly probably I don't ever even look at premium because premium doesn't pay the bills, revenue does. But I would probably a 25 million in premium, 25, 30 million in premium, something like that. Um, heavily weighted on workers' comp, which is a lower commission percentage, so that drags it down a little bit. But um, you know, I I look at it and we if I wrote two dozen accounts in a year, it's a banner year for me. You know, I like that's a best in class year for me. But I'm also writing accounts that are paying at least 25 grand a pop. So of course that's a banner year, right? Um, but it's um I I I went in and into that account and I I had I killed it because I had done my research. And when you're going after accounts like that and you know that you only need to get a certain number every year to have a banner year, you spend the time on the front end researching. It's not a transactional sale, and you're never gonna sell value in a transaction. You sell value in a relationship, and you have to start building that before your opportunity to drive value comes. I had done all my research, I realized that this particular company um was facing a zoning issue. They were getting forced zoned into uh an unincorporated, they were in an unincorporated portion of Pinellas County and they were getting zoned into um the city of Largo, and it was going to be a very negative financial event for them. I knew that from reading that the person I was meeting with was leading the charge for that. And I literally walked into the first appointment. He's in I could tell that he was, you know, frustrated. He's like, all right, let's go ahead and get this over with. I don't remember exactly what he said, but that's basically what came out of his mouth. And I said, Listen, I understand you think I'm probably here to sell you insurance today. And I'd love to talk to you about your risk management program. But I wanted to start the meeting off by letting you know I've been following everything that's going on in the media, and I know this has to be taking a toll on you. This zoning thing is ridiculous. I've got your back. If there's anything I can do, if you need me to get people to sign petitions, whatever we can do, just let me know. For the next 25 minutes, this guy did nothing except vomit his personal relationship, his business relationship, how it was straining his family. I mean, we just went deep. He forgot what I was there for. But I sat and listened to what he had to say. And he's like, now let's talk about this, the other. I said, listen, you know, I'm gonna be respectful of your time. I don't want to force myself on you. We can schedule another meeting for me to come back. I said, but what I really wanted to talk to you about was this. And he goes, Well, you know, I think we've got that stuff under control a little bit. And I said, Well, listen, I'm I have reason to believe you don't, and I'm not gonna ask you for a bunch of stuff, but if you could just get me, you know, your loss runs and a copy of your experience mod worksheet, I'd like to go ahead and run a mod analysis for you, and I'll make a gentleman's agreement with you. If I can't help you, I'm not even gonna ask you for more of your time. I'll just pick up the phone or shoot you an email and let you know, look, you're great where you're at. If you're not, then I'm gonna ask you to meet with me so I can come in and present my findings. And I'm gonna let you know right now, I'm also gonna ask you to hire me so that you understand that's the expectation on the next meeting. You know, I love it. You know, and so he said, Well, you know, let me see if I can get that stuff, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. Well, so it started off because the his experience mod was a 0.86. Well, one is average, and he was thinking he was doing awesome. When we ran the software report, we basically looked and saw that his minimum mod was a 0.64. So this guy was spending half a million dollars a year on his workers' comp and leaving 22 points of possible improvement on the table to the tune of almost $100,000. And he didn't know any better because he thought he had done good enough. And see, that's part of the problem for the agents out there that don't get this. You need to pay attention to what I'm getting ready to say because this is extremely important for you to listen to. Agents' compensation is flawed in the eyes of the consumer. The worse they perform, the more money you make. What are you doing to solve that problem? And see, we have the ability in P in the commercial arena to net out commissions, right? We can strip them out so the premiums come down below, you know, down to the level they would be if, you know, without me getting paid my 15% or whatever that is. And then we can charge a fee directly to our clients. So in this particular case, I told the guy, I'm like, look, let's just put this on a flat $50,000 fee. You don't need to pay me because you've had some issues with, you know, your property being overly high due to the hurricanes and everything else. I'm comfortable, we can get done what we need to get done. And he had never even heard that before. He'd never heard anybody come in and be willing to give them a flat compensation and number one, do that option, but B, be transparent about it, right? How many people do you think don't even know how much commission an agent makes? You can put 15 disclaimers in the front of a proposal. You're flipping through those lightning fast. All they want to see is how much it costs. So I have no problem. I tell my prospects all the time, my favorite topic to discuss with you is my compensation. You know, let's talk about how I get paid and how much. And so that's a that's a whole different animal when you're going down that road is you're you're giving people creative solutions and you're showing them that you want to be an extension of their team. You don't want to get rich at their expense. And if you do that, you're gold. Now, why did I do that? Because I knew that in a couple of years the mod was going to be low, but I already set the benchmark of my compensation at 50 grand. So when I did the work to make the premiums drop, I was actually making more money on fee in the long term than I would have made in commission. And I could go after raises based on my performance. We could have predetermined benchmarks that say, if I can get your experience mod down by 10%, I want another $15,000 in fee. Well, what's is that a bad decision? I don't think so because if you drop you know fifty thousand dollars in comp premium and you bought that for a fifteen thousand dollar raise to the guy who did it for you, you're ahead. But if you're if you're a commission monkey, you're never gonna operate that way.
SPEAKER_01Love it again, solving problems, right? I mean, it makes sense. I would love to I would love to give you fifteen thousand dollars so I can make it. No, then we're on the same page. I love it. I love it. I I love your thought process between all this um and the way you approach the agency is on such a human level. Um, that I mean that's the reason why you've been so successful at this, and you you think outside the box, and I think it's um it's pretty rare in this industry. I I mean maybe not that rare, but I mean yeah, pretty rare. Pretty rare in this industry to find out.
SPEAKER_00You know what I think? I think the most creative people in the industry are the ones that have been abused or have been dirt poor. The the poorest and most abused people are the ones who find the most creative ways to elevate themselves to a level above the people that either, you know, didn't give them the chance or whatever else. I'll never forget it, man. I mean, I don't I don't remember if I shared this the first time I talked. I told you about the me going in and talking to 10 people. No, no, no, no, no. Different than that. I came out of the grocery industry and um I went to a dozen agencies and nobody could help me. Nobody wanted to give me an opportunity. I was willing to work for peanuts. I just wanted a chance to go in and work hard and prove myself. And I went into an agency that was a legacy agency in this area and took a personality test, one of those Omnia profiles. And I got a call from the recruiter and they and they asked me how I thought it went. I said, I thought it was awesome. I really like the guys. I would love to have an opportunity to go work there. I think I could do well for them. And the recruiter said, Yeah, they didn't get the same vibe about you. And I said, Oh, okay. And they said, and they said, Yeah, they took the um personality test results, and you know, I understand you're a big boy. I'm just gonna say that you weren't right for them. And I said, No, no, no, you I I can take it. Tell me what they said. They said, Well, they just don't think you have the backbone to be successful in this industry. I said, Oh, okay. Tell me what I can't do, and then go watch me do that 10 times better than anybody else you had, right? So, what I how I reacted to that was I finally got a job in an agency, and then I went after that agency, but I didn't go after anybody, I went after the top producer in that agency in his book of business. And every single time I pulled an account from him, I sent the guy who wouldn't hire me a dozen roses in a note thanking for him for motivating me to go out and kick his tail on the streets, and as a result, my book was where it was.
SPEAKER_01That is so awesome. How many dozen roses did you send him? At least a dozen.
SPEAKER_02At least it doesn't any response from those roses.
SPEAKER_00No, thank you. No, I was a mere peon, man. He probably had no clue why didn't I? Meanwhile, I pulled about 300 grand in revenue out of his agency.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, that's and then he got in trouble from his wife because he was getting flowers.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I think I'd like to go one other place and then we'll let you go. I know, I know you're you're super busy and you probably have to get home so you don't get in trouble. But um, you have a unique approach to hiring too, and how you find your your people. You brought it up on the last one, but just in case they missed it, give us a snippet of that because I think it's it's it's incredible.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, again, I know I know I keep saying this, but there's ways you can do this in personal lines agencies too, I'm sure. But you know, again, it goes back to what I said my philosophy is for how I hire people, right? Or not hire people, but I don't want to make 10 calls to get one appointment. I want to make one call to get 10. And an easy way to do that is to develop channel partnerships. Personal lines, everybody's focusing on realtors and loan officers and that whole strategy that's, you know, basically being used by tons and tons of people. And so we do the same thing. I look for people that um are business-to-business salespeople. And one thing I didn't talk about last time, that's part of this process, is I've got a client profile form that I fill out on everybody that's in our book of business. And we put that into our CRM. But I ask them, I want to know who they buy their payroll from, who do they buy their office supplies from, who do they buy their credit card processing, who's their lawyer, who's their accountant. And then I ask them of these people, who do you think I would have the best energy with? And they always tell me, and then I ask them to make an introduction. And so my goal in that is if this person is selling payroll to my client that's a $50 million a year company, there's a really good chance they're selling payroll to other companies that are doing $50 million a year in sales, which means they're my new best friend. I want to, you know, I want to be able to refer business to them because I know that if they're satisfying my client, I can do that without putting my reputation in jeopardy. And I want them to refer business to me. And so we do that. We set that up on a formal relationship where we meet once a month, and every time we meet, it's two booked appointments. I take two booked appointments to my referral partner and they bring two booked appointments to me. That's not, hey, call this guy. I told him you might call him and he's halfway expecting it. Maybe he'll answer. No, it's we walk into your client and we sit down and you're in the meeting with me and we talk shop, just like I'm gonna do for you. And we look, I look at that relationship over three or four months, and I'd see how it's going. If it's going well, I always plant the seed. And I just say, look, you're an awesome salesperson. It just blows my mind that you're sitting here hawking payroll for a living. You know, you there's gotta be better opportunities for you out there. You can't be making that much money. And within 20, you know, they'll they'll defend their position every time, but then within 24 hours, I always get an email or phone call that says, Well, we hey man, what are you talking about yesterday? You you know something I don't know. You got a deal? Or and so we meet again and I take our production reports, and so you know, I'll look at them and you know, we'll use 200 grand over four months is reasonable based on the size of accounts we're going after. And I'll show them, look, man, we we brought in 200,000 in revenue over the course of the last four months since we've been referring business back and forth with each other. If you were on my team, you would have made $80,000 in income for that because I pay 40% on new business. And I'm just wondering, did you make $80,000 over the last four months selling payroll? I mean, they they might make $80,000 a year, you know. And um then we talk and just say, you know, tell me what you want, tell me what you need. You know, we'll get you what you need first and you can go out and earn what you want, but I'm gonna give you a platform to do that. And so we identify it, and then we just have a code inside of HubSpot, just like they have in agency management systems. Anytime something gets referred that we close from that person, we slot it to that referral code. And when our revenue between new and renewal business that they've referred gets to their need level and they're willing to make the jump, we make them the offer to come on board and they walk in the door and I hand them the book of business that they referred. Now, agents by and large are cheap. So I usually get the question of, well, why would you give it to them? Well, because they gave it to me. You know, I mean, I I babysat that revenue long enough for them to come on board. There's no risk to them because they have a revenue stream built already. There's no risk to me because they have a revenue stream built already. And I'm not worried about retention because these are their clients. They're walking into a book of business of people that they've already represented, right? So why in the world do I have to worry about that? And so I have a pipeline of producers that's uh anywhere between really 12 and 18 month process from the time we start that conversation to the time that we bring them into the front door and indoctrinate them. And I always have an idea of who I'm hiring, where they're coming from. And the beauty of it is twofold. Number one, if I get to the four-month mark and I don't like them and I don't think they're gonna fit the culture, I don't ever have to plant the seed. They never know. They never know I was interviewing them for three or four months. Right. If if if they last and they're gonna come on board and it takes them a year to get to where they need to be, over that year, they've been on four appointments a month with me, the two they booked and the two I booked. At 48 appointments with a prospect that's not even your employee yet. I can see how they interface with their client, how they display their value proposition, how they open, how they close, and then they have the same reciprocity on my side of the table. So when they walk in the front door, there's no questions or feeling out period. It's just a matter of getting them into our sales process and helping them understand what needs to happen on the insurance side of things, and it and it works very, very well. Both sides completely bought in. Absolutely. And you know what? If they don't, if they don't hit the mount hit the number, I don't ever have to make the offer, right? I don't have to plant the seed, but if I plant the seed and they don't hit the production number, I can just say, look, I don't think this is gonna work. You're not hitting the numbers you need because I don't want you to come on board and not be able to to validate your what you need a year from now because you're you're slow in bringing business in, either ramp it up or let's just keep this as a referral relationship. And if things heat up, we can talk again in the future. I love it.
SPEAKER_02It's almost the same challenge that you were given in a way, you know, like well, but he didn't give you uh the opportunity, but but um that's why I give people the opportunity.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I I operate with an edge all the time, right? So one of the reasons I give people from outside the industry opportunity is because that opportunity wasn't given to me. So I just took it upon myself to be the guy who tries to give people from outside the industry an opportunity to come in and produce. And that's I mean, that's how I think, but I think that way because I had no money. Okay, right. I had to come up with a way to hire people that were already validated because when I started down this road, I didn't have the ability to give producers a draw, I didn't have the ability to guarantee salaries, I had to figure out a way to have revenue flow in and support them. So I mean that when I that that goes back to what I said before. People who were extremely poor or weren't treated right are always gonna be the most motivated to find the most creative solutions, and that's where I operate from.
SPEAKER_01Love it, David. This is crazy, man. I love everything you do. I love the thought process behind it, and I love that it's not sneaky. I love that it's all based on empathy, love, and care for others. And uh it's awesome, man. It's awesome to see to see all that you do. And if anybody's listening and thinks that any of that was was at all helpful, you gotta listen to his podcast because he's dropping bombs left and right, dropping huge bombs, dropping huge bombs.
SPEAKER_02And that's available on that's on uh it's on all the places, right?
SPEAKER_00iTunes and oh yeah, we're big, we're a big deal, man. We're everywhere.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_00I say that tongue in cheek, but yeah, we're we're on um any place you can find a podcast. Yeah. Although I am trying to get on iHeartRadio. Are you guys on there yet?
SPEAKER_02Yes. Well, yeah, we go to that sprout.
SPEAKER_00How long did that process take? It takes like two or three weeks.
SPEAKER_02It's weird because I've noticed it'll disconnect and then you have to reconnect it. And uh I don't know. Well, they're does anybody use iHeartRadio?
SPEAKER_00Well, they're advertising themselves as the number one podcast platform now.
SPEAKER_02So I don't understand how. I mean, who uses that? But I there must be. Maybe that's why we're not on it because I just said that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, and I'm guilty by association. Thanks.
SPEAKER_02Well, we'll never be on iHeart.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, we'll just figure we'll figure out a new way to develop podcast distribution and make it our own and then sell it to other people. That's my ammo. Yeah, perfect.
SPEAKER_02There we go.
SPEAKER_01So how can people get a hold of you? Where can they where where can they get more David?
SPEAKER_00If you can't find me, then you have a problem. Um yeah, you you can you can Google, you I mean, I'm I'm kidding, obviously, but LinkedIn, I'm very active. Facebook, I'm very I'm I'm very active on all social channels. Um, you can hit me on uh email at David at Florida RiskPartners.com or um you know any of my websites.
SPEAKER_01Cool, love it, man.
SPEAKER_00And if you wedding insurance, yeah, you know, if you're in Florida and you need wedding insurance, flwedding insurance.com. I'm your guy.
SPEAKER_01Well, thanks so much for not only doing this once, but now a second time, especially after you just talked to us yesterday.
SPEAKER_00And uh I feel like I'm training for a marathon, man. Like this is two good, this is two good treadmill sessions in a row. I'm out of breath.
SPEAKER_01I'm out of breath as well.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome. Yeah, I appreciate I appreciate the opportunity, guys. I always like talking with you, and uh glad that uh we could just share a few things that we're doing, and hopefully it helps some of the people who listen. For sure. Exactly. Thanks a lot, man. 100%. Well, gentlemen, we'll holler at you later. Take care. All right, have a good one.
SPEAKER_01Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast. Subscribe really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman