The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, twatters, whatever. It's coffee twalk.
SPEAKER_00
Coffee tok. The coffee talk. Craig, welcome back, my man. We've gone for for a spell there.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Went away with my son. Did some uh some boogie boarding for the last two weeks. Mexico. Beautiful. Mexico. How was it then? Well, we got a place out in the middle of nowhere because I thought it'd be a great idea to be off the grid. Yes. Well, there was no AC and it was about 95 degrees.
SPEAKER_00
Let me ask you a question. When you presented that idea to your wife, what did she say? Oh, that's a great idea. No, no, no. I know that, but I'm saying, did she have an opinion on you doing that?
SPEAKER_01
There's always an opinion, Jason. Right, right.
SPEAKER_00
Was her opinion correct?
SPEAKER_01
Of course it was.
SPEAKER_00
It always is. I love it. And then what happened halfway through that?
SPEAKER_01
Well, so after uh when we first got there, she said the the woman who owned it said, oh, and and at night it's it's warmer than it is during the day. I thought, what how's how is that even possible? I mean, we're on the beach, but it but it literally was hotter at night. And so after I got got food poisoning and the water went out, it was time to leave. It was time to leave. So we packed up in shame, left the Airbnb, and went to a um all-inclusive resort in town, which was very, very reasonably priced because of the vid.
SPEAKER_00
Right. So you're back now, and we had a we had a big week this week. We had uh, you know, David DeFord on the uh on the old podcast, final expense selling, man.
SPEAKER_01
Final expenses and a couple books he has.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. And so I wanted to talk to you about this because um I was talking to another another agent about this, and it's so it's funny. Like the um actually I was talking to our staff about this, our our sales team. And when you're in a desperate place, it's very hard to sell. Like if you're in that place where you have to sell and you start getting desperate. That's why, you know, when salespeople go in and out of of of of selling, the magic of when they are selling is they're on cloud nine, they they have this aura about them, they're they're they sound so positive and like it's no big deal. Like they don't sound desperate, you know. When you are desperate, it sounds like a different thing. And uh, when we were talking to David, he was talking about that, about not you know, have more leads and uh more of a pipeline coming in than almost that you can handle. And um I thought didn't he say commission breath? He said commission breath. You need to not be desperate, right?
SPEAKER_01
A hundred percent. I just upped our leaves. We're doing 500 a day because it's better to have too many than too few, right? There's no excuse. There's no excuse for getting the quotes for for just getting it done. Because if you have the front end of the funnel, is is full, like overfloweth, right? Because you're eventually gonna get to them. That's our equity anyway, right? We're gonna get to those leads. So I don't really care. Only 10% are gonna answer. So that's 50. We got 50 that are gonna answer, and we're gonna be able to quote a day out of the 500. The other 450 are all equity. Eventually, we're gonna quote them.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. Yeah, it's just it's crazy to think about how desperate you can sound. I was just talking to uh another agent uh actually yesterday, and he was talking about, you know, that this is kind of a different subject, but it'll cut it'll come back. But he was talking about how he's friends with all the agents down where he is. Everybody's kind of negative, no one's doing well, they're looking at the past, and I don't know if you've heard this before. I mean, I'm newer in the industry only four years, so it's like I probably I've heard this from older agents that have been doing this longer than four years, which I know is incredibly not long, so it's incredibly short. But um, they they were saying, you know, they there's like this pride thing in insurance where it's like I don't buy leads, it's like it's bad to buy leads. They they have this thing that's like it's a bad thing. Oh, I don't I don't buy the leads. And I'm thinking to myself, what business owner is proud about not investing in their business? Like what a weird thing to be proud about, and it was kind of a negative vibe that he was saying that um some of the other agents have, and I've I mean I've heard it before. Um, but then it made me think about that this podcast, and um how he said, you know, you you gotta make uh you gotta make sure that you you have a ton of leads coming in so you don't get that desperation. And I started um he asked me some advice, and I said, dude, the it's a crazy. So when you start investing, you know, you think you're just gonna get these leads, right? But there's a lot that comes with that. One is your agents start acting different. They realize like they're starting, they're starting to quote more, they're more excited. When you're in that desperation mode, you you start feeling stressed out, and then you're you're come on, guys, you gotta sell, you gotta sell. Then they're under the pressure, and then they're not happy. And it's like this whole negative vibe that goes with that. But when you're like investing in yourself, um, and everybody's doing good. I mean, dude, the culture is so much more fun. Not to mention that what do people do when they take money out? Like, let's say you make an extra 200,000 this year, you can't put it in the bank, you're gonna you're gonna invest it, right? What probably on the market or something, right? And then people take cuts of that, right? So you're investing it in other businesses. To me, and call me naive or whatever, I don't care. But why would I invest in somebody else's business and bleed my business to do so? That is to me the stupidest thing I think anybody could do. Why wouldn't you reinvest in your own business, not pay the taxes of taking the money out of it? Yeah, and invest in your own business so that you can build the snowball so big that you don't even have to sweat the small stuff.
SPEAKER_01
Right. Yeah, that's that's where um that's where I feel like I've gotten to. I think that's where you've gotten to, where you know, when when we get asked like, oh, should I spend this much a day or this much? It's like I don't really care, man. I don't I don't look at the little I look at the bigger picture. If I buy 500 and it costs me 1500, well, you know what, I'm gonna give back 4500 because it just works. Once you have the machine humming along, the it it all falls into place. I don't worry about all the little costs and try to save a dollar here or a dollar there. It doesn't matter. The machine starts working. If there's if there's higher costs, well, then you know what, less taxes and chalk it up to learning. But you you can't make a decision on whether or not your leads are working in a week or two weeks or three weeks. You need 60, 90 days, right? Right. I mean, right? Big companies don't make a move based on some marketing strategy they invested in last week, right? They they go with it for six months or a year, and they're like, okay, this thing costs a billion dollars, it didn't work, now we got to change direction. But you know, you don't put your toe in. It just isn't gonna work, and that's what I love about having it set up this where we buy leads because you can quantify. You know, I know, like you know, I know we have the analytics of how many contacts did we get off those leads, how many uh quotes did we get off the contacts. You know, it's just it makes it so simple when you're talking about it in the way that you talked about it before, like where they don't buy leads. Well, how do you even track it if you're not buying leads? Right? Right. I mean, it's just anecdotal observational information, right? Oh, well, I have 10 loan officers and they're sending me some stuff. Well, yeah, but there's no there's no guarantee to that flow. Like we pay money in exchange for that money, we have a guaranteed amount of data that's coming in that then gets processed, right? Yep, that data turns into oh it was seven calls, and that seven calls resulted in a contact. The con seven of the contacts resulted in whatever, right? Some numbers that tells us then what our acquisition cost is, and it's beautiful. Like it takes all the all the rocket science out of the thing, and I'm not smart enough to track stuff if it's not easy to track. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
I think the moral of this in going into the weekend, what to think about is take your head out of the weeds, which is somewhere else. My head's getting my head gets in the weeds so much, and I'm like concentrating on what affects now and this week, and don't take your head above the the trees and look down and look at the big picture. Look at the big picture. If you're not spending your time on what's gonna help you in a year or two, then you're just going to keep creating the same results. If you're just doing today what it takes to get to the next day, then you're you really don't have a GPS at that point. And you're just going to keep creating what you already have, which is cool if that's what you want to do. But if you really want to um your business to to go further or whatever, is dude, just you gotta figure out a plan. You gotta invest in yourself, invest in yourself and take a chance, right?
SPEAKER_01
I mean, that's what business is. It's it's it's a it's a bunch of strategic bets and in anticipation that it will lead to something. It's it's not a guess, you're not just throwing a dart at it, but you're also are are making a bet, right? You're making a bet that if you spend this fifteen thousand dollars this month in 90 days, you're gonna get 45,000 back. Yeah, that's what it is. And and sometimes you don't and you survive, you're gonna live. Yep, right? Because the ones that you lose, that's okay because you're gonna make it up for the ones that you do win. But once you find the one that wins, and I know that I found the one that wins that wins for me, and it's only because of the activity, right? Like buying some lead is no better than somebody else buying some lead somewhere else. It's just that I've called them 60 times. Perseverance pays off.
SPEAKER_00
Yep.
SPEAKER_01
And and then what it also does, not to beat a dead horse, is is to is it allowed for me to go to combo with my son for two weeks, and all I had to do on a daily basis, which even pissed him off because it took me 20 seconds, but I wasn't focused, you know, was oh, how many leads came in? Good 300, how many? I just would look at the numbers because I'm OCD like that. I had to at least just see the numbers, but you know what? I really didn't need to, I just like to. But it allowed for that and and it worked, and we still wrote whatever 55,000 or 60,000 while I was gone. I mean, I'm clearly unimportant to this whole thing now that it's now that it's set up, which is great, right? You want to be unimportant. Right.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. I think that that's a great coffee talk and something to do. Coffee talk.
SPEAKER_01
Have a powerful, powerful weekend.
SPEAKER_00
Powerful. Yeah. I don't even know other P words. Cool, cool. Everybody, subscribe to this, please. We need more subscribers. Um, subscribe to this, check it out on the tubes of you, the tunes of i. Yeah, or dude, whatever, man.
SPEAKER_01
You're gonna hear the extended plays on all of the different audio podcast places, like uh what is there? Spotify, iTunes, all those things. The googlers, whatever, all of that. And now Amazon, where we just got we just uh submitted to be on Amazon, so that's pretty cool. Um, but but then you'll get the little micro plays, like little tidbits of of delight over on YouTube. Plus, you get to look at us. Which I don't know if that's a good thing. All right, that's good.
SPEAKER_00
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.