The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat on Motivational Monday!We Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!---------------------------------------------------------...
We're all feeling it. This year is so different because everything that's going on is horrible.
SPEAKER_00
Well, everybody behaves and responds differently when they're put under pressure.
SPEAKER_02
There's so many deaths through all the different things that's going on, and that's a big deal. But hello there, Mr. Correct. There we go. Motivational Monday. Let's do it. We've never really addressed this, but we are in the craziest year because everything that's going on is horrible.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, this can keep this can turn into a really a really rough situation and it and it keeps downward spiraling. To be able to lead the people who work for you, you have to rise up and you have to in hard times.
SPEAKER_02
We need to rise up and be the good leaders. Now's the time to be the leaders, not buckle up. It's the insurance dudes podcast. So this is a special edition motivational Monday. How about that?
SPEAKER_00
Happy Monday to you. Top.
SPEAKER_02
Happy Monday to you.
SPEAKER_00
So we're are we talking to them from the past? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
They're in the future. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
But right now, when they're listening, we're in the past. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Right. So crazy. Dude, we've we've never really addressed this, but we are in the craziest year. It's literally a historic year. It's like one thing after the next, right? Yeah. It is incredibly hard to stay motivated for some people. And even staff and everything else. So what we've been Craig and I have been talking to agents, and agents um are having trouble staying motivated, not to mention our staff. I mean, even in our office. It's it's kind of hard now, you know, months into this, and then we got new craziness going around us, and it seems to be a lot of heated emotions and anger out there.
SPEAKER_00
So angry.
SPEAKER_02
But not to diminish any of those feelings, but like honestly, I wanted to talk about how you know anger does breed anger. Right? We can kind of agree on that, like usually, um, or or at least what what we've seen, but also love will you know, love, empathy, kindness. I mean that that will also breed love, empathy, and kindness.
SPEAKER_00
More love. More love.
SPEAKER_02
Yep.
SPEAKER_00
Yes. A lot of people did.
SPEAKER_02
Right.
SPEAKER_00
The list goes on.
SPEAKER_02
Right. Even the Bible, right?
SPEAKER_00
The great Caesar love. Yeah. There you go.
SPEAKER_02
And I think it's super important right now to just focus on there's a lot of hurt people out there, and for us to just be kind, loving, be there for each other, and not go down the anger, frustrated, and everything else road.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, this can keep this can turn into a really, a really rough situation, and it and it keeps downward spiraling. Or we turn it around, we say, okay, enough is enough. Let's let's be kind to each other. I remember after 9-11. I mean, you must have been in kindergarten when that happened, but I do remember there was this stretch after 9-11 and even in New York where people were really, really nice to each other. You know, people started going, Wow, let's get back to the basics, you know, let's freaking love thy neighbor and do all these things that we sort of forget about because we're in this wrapped up in this crazy world, and now it's this crazy world on top of this crazy world, yeah. Where you don't even know what you're being fed if you watch TV. I mean, we don't even turn the TV on.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, we don't need to.
SPEAKER_00
Um, yeah, I mean, you don't even know what if what you're watching is something that's real. I was telling you before, like, even if I'm walking down the street now, I don't even know if what I'm looking at out there is real.
unknown
Right.
SPEAKER_00
What the hell is going on around here? You know?
SPEAKER_02
Yep. I mean, we've gotten some crazy customers that have called in that have made it difficult on the staff. The staff has been through some, you know, crazy times in the past that the the stuff recently is has brought up emotions. And a lot of the conversations that we've had has to go like like that I've had, has to be around the subject of every we don't know where everybody comes from. We don't know past experiences that people have been a part of that things like this can trigger. So it's like everybody, anybody that is having a hard time, anybody that is emotionally charged, dude, like you don't know where they came from. Like you don't understand how chart like never take somebody's word for face value. Like we've had it, oh, like like this. We had a a customer call in, she was very heated, very heated. Um, and it and it stuff got brought up uh about the recent um some of the recent craziness. And like I literally had a conversation with one of our agents, and I said, dude, she's living in a not nice area. She's got riots going on around her. Like she's just pissed. Like if you call her on a different time, she's not gonna be like that. Like she's yeah, we don't know what it's like. Like, I don't live in an area that's getting burnt down. You know what I mean? So, so for that, for that alone, like she's going through something. So don't take that as face value. Like, like we need to love, like feel empathy towards that person, not feel like, oh my gosh, that person's a jerk, right?
SPEAKER_00
Right. Well, everybody behaves and responds differently when they're put under pressure, right? Like there's that's clearly is pressure, right? Now you you've got real life, and then you've got all this crap just right in your front yard. Um, and even like you look at the uh you know, different assessments, like the disc test. If you look at the disc test, they they they have your different your four different dimensions are laid out. Um, I don't know if you're you know the disc, you know, the the I can't remember what the acronym is, but those first two ones can be low for somebody. You know, normally like a service person, right, is is gonna have low DNI. And then um, you know, but when they're under pressure, it's like totally different. That thing could skyrocket, right? So maybe this person is totally cool, totally chill when um when uh that was distracting. They're they're totally cool when um under normal circumstances, right? But then you put a little pressure, throw a little pressure into the mix, and all of a sudden, boom, you know, it's a volatile, it's like pouring gas.
SPEAKER_01
Right. So true. Yeah, under pressure. Yeah, there's a song about that, different, yeah, different lyric.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, well, and vanilla ice took that and made ice ice baby.
SPEAKER_02
But he added the ting to it, so that was the difference. Remember that argument?
SPEAKER_00
Oh, so he that's why he was allowed to.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, he said it's it's it is different. It's dun dun ting.
SPEAKER_00
Oh yeah. That is different.
SPEAKER_02
Google it. That is the best argument I've ever heard right there. When he came back with that, he was he was dead serious about it, too.
SPEAKER_00
Not to get off on a tangent here, but like when uh when a band covers uh another performer's thing live on stage, don't they change the words too? Like they throw some you know nonsense into the middle of the song, so they're like, Well, no, it was my interpretation, it wasn't that right. It's funny how they have to do that. Yeah, how does that tie in?
SPEAKER_02
It doesn't, but let's go back to being under pressure. It's like a pressure cooker, man. Like we're all we're all feeling it. This year is so different than other. I mean, even if you're not a part in those, you know.
SPEAKER_00
Dude, I mean, unless you live in the middle of the Amazon rainforest, it's some, you know, like and you've never had contact with the outside world, like literally all of us are in this uh humans across the world are in this thing together. Yeah, well, now I guess the bonus thing is here in the US, we have some extra stuff, but but um you know that hopefully we can that can help create, you know, like we always talk about is this gonna be a positive or a negative, right? Can we turn this into a positive situation? I think yes. I think that, hey, look, there's more awareness about how much racial tension there is, apparently, right? And there's there's a lot of feelings about that and and ways that things are are done that we need to take a look at.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Because clearly people are upset, right? Um, and without getting we don't want I'm not touching it with a 10-foot pole, but but you know, we can move beyond that and like you said, spread the love, not the hate, and we'll get into a better place.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, a hundred percent. I think that that's I think it's real easy to get sucked in to the to the negativity and everything. And I'm not saying to not feel, and I'm not saying to to make anything less than what it is, because everything that's going on is horrible. There's so many deaths through all the different things that's going on, and that's a big deal. But the way we handle ourselves through that and the way we treat each other and like we are like under a pressure cooker. So it's like like some people are just they're hot. They get they can get hot like that, you know what I mean? And we can too. And it's just, I think that now's the time that we all need to double down on maybe taking an extra look at ourselves, being a little extra kind, doing the extra, you know, we've all seen that paying it forward, you know what I mean? Pay it forward, dude. Now we need to do it more than ever. I think now's the time to really just to just go that direction. Like, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Well, and we're most of the people here that if they've hung in after that whole music thing um and are still listening, have our are agents, right? Or are people who are business owners. Um, and there's probably some some uh some employees of but but there's oh yeah, pressure as the business owner, and then to be able to lead the people who work for you, you have to rise up and you have to take that approach. You can't be losing it, you know. Oh, I'm under pressure. It's like, well, yeah, so are they, right? And they're they don't know if they're gonna have a job.
SPEAKER_02
And they're worse, they're yeah, like yeah, they're more pressure.
SPEAKER_00
You know, they're there and looking up to the captain.
SPEAKER_02
We are very privileged being agency owners, and in the hard times, we need to rise up and be the good leaders. Now's the time to be the leaders, not in the good times, right? Well, I guess I in all times, right? But now we're being a little bit privileged in that circumstance. We need to go above and beyond. Above and beyond, above and beyond, under pressure. Let's leave that for Monday. Lead your teams with with dignity, with with enthusiasm, with love, kindness.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, yeah. And you know what? We were gonna leave it right there. But but let me I want to touch back in because we did talk about uh the over the overcoming objections and doing training with our staff last week or the um last Wednesday.
SPEAKER_01
Because we had multiple conversations.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, I want to check in on that because we've continued to do it, and you know when you start to as you start to do these things over and over and over and over, that repetition creates a skill. And I have, I'm telling you, it is it is crazy. We I've been here every morning after my ride. Um, even when I fell today, 30 miles fell, came in. And I'm I'm in here meeting with them, and they're just like they're so grateful to be trained. I'm not saying I'm some magician, but but it's uh it's it's to two our points here. They want to be led, they want to be helped. They had a they had a little bit of a rough patch at the end of last month, or a couple of them did. One one gentleman was coming, you know, into some tough waters because he had a really bad month, and we we sat down, we talked, I said, look, we're gonna train extra. And all of a sudden, he every day has written something, every single day.
SPEAKER_02
You mentioned him on a few podcasts ago. He's the dude that sold six grand last month, right?
SPEAKER_00
Even even less. I don't even want to so bad.
SPEAKER_02
It was so embarrassing. You said six grand to make it better.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, I lied, I doubled it. It was like 3600. It was no bueno, right? And but but he had started right when the virus happened, and then no real training, work from home. So it was a little tough.
SPEAKER_02
And so you feel like, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
It's like, well, yeah, so I said, I'm gonna give you this month, and now he's lighting it up. He's he's number two on the board. Um, he today, today he's written two households. He's probably gonna get a hat trick. If he gets a hat trick, I'm gonna go give him a hundred bucks. But it's it's just you know, it's it's awesome, but but it's all from the training, and what he picked up was what we talked about last time, which was the which was the shut up, like the oldest sales thing in the world, which is drop the freaking clothes and shut up, and that's all he's done. Like, like he's now he's getting good at the objections too, but like just that. He's like, it is unreal. Like, and they always want to talk. They always want like I want to talk, you know. What this is what this is why we do this, so we don't talk in other circumstances. That's awesome. But yeah, I just want to check in on that. So I think um maybe next coffee talk we'll do another check-in.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, check in how Gunner's doing. His name's Gunner. Uh greatest name ever. He needs to be number one. So, my question is this I I heard that a policy a day keeps Craig away. That's true. They don't even want me here.
SPEAKER_00
They want me here in the morning, then they want me to leave. Right. And I just shut this conference door and yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. All right.
SPEAKER_00
Work on the work on the compliance.
SPEAKER_02
There we go. Motivational Monday. Let's do it. Let's lead, lead, lead.
SPEAKER_00
Lead, lead, lead.
SPEAKER_02
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast. Subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.