The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes chat with Martin AmadorWe Are Insurance Dudes!!! We Are Here To Learn From All The Incredible Insurance Dudes And Dudettes We Speak With And To Pass The Knowledge Nuggets That We Learn To Our Dedicated And Amazing DudeNation!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!--------------------------------------------------------------...
Boom. Who do we have today? Mr. Martin Amador from Colorado.
SPEAKER_02
Let's go back. What what took you, what got you to where you are now? You're an agency owner.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, I've always been in kind of people management, right?
SPEAKER_02
So have how do you stay motivated and how do you keep your team motivated?
SPEAKER_00
Honestly, I just make it fun, man.
SPEAKER_04
This is I I think that you need to find other agents that are successful and just learn from them.
SPEAKER_02
Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast.
SPEAKER_04
Well, thank you for joining.
SPEAKER_02
Yes, thank you. Before we deep dive in, two questions today. Two first questions. Two first. Okay. Two first. Okay. First, two first. The background behind me. It is from an 80s TV show. You tell me what living room. I know you've seen it.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah. Some reruns, perhaps. I can imagine him just one of the people one of the characters just sliding through that door.
I'm not a Seinfeld fan personally, but I I recognize that from reruns.
SPEAKER_04
Here's your bonus question. What band is behind me?
SPEAKER_00
Oh man.
SPEAKER_04
Making it even harder, the lead singer's head is cut off.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. I don't like the way that guy's looking at you from the back, man. I know.
SPEAKER_02
He's it's a little bit more. And they are wearing comfortable gear.
SPEAKER_00
They are wearing comfortable. My 80s rock is not that not that good, bro. So um man, but I love the stash though. I'm trying to catch up with the stash there. I don't, I don't, I'm not sure. Um, I'm gonna say like the slayer, is it slayer? No, they're more they're they're more hardcore than those guys.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah, those guys are those get some may consider these guys hardcore.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, those guys look like they'll get rolled up, man.
SPEAKER_04
This is Judas Priest. Judas Priest, okay is the correct answer. Okay, all right. Yeah, fun time. So important.
SPEAKER_02
Let's let's go back. What what took you, what got you to where you are now? You're an agency owner, and how did you get there? Is that what you uh wanted to do when you were seven?
unknown
Totally.
SPEAKER_00
Wow, yeah, isn't it that's all we wanted to do, right? We all wanted to be agents, super agents. Yeah, no, actually, no. Um, yeah, I've always been in in kind of people management, right? So um I've never thought I would own a own a business, so um and be an agent, but uh, but yeah, no, um actually a friend brought me in. A friend brought me in, and those are the the best ones, right? You you you realize um, you know, like I'm not a salesperson, I don't want to be a salesperson, right? So and and he's like, why don't you do this? And I'm like, I don't know, I don't really want to do that, you know. So, but um, but no, well, when I got into it, I um I just I figured out man, it's more about just managing people, man, managing people, managing personalities, you know. So um, so that that's been the fun part. So and what were you doing before? Man, I was corporate man for years. I've been corporate in corporate management, bunch of different companies. Um my last one I worked for AT ⁇ T, so a call center. Um, but uh, but yeah, no, I I I I did that a bunch of people management throughout the throughout the years. So uh so a lot of those, a lot of that's really kind of helped me, you know, in in uh in in the the industry that we're in, because it's it's really just people management, right?
SPEAKER_04
So uh so but uh so no it was so it was super easy once you once you dove in.
SPEAKER_00
So it was super easy, yeah. No, no, no, definitely challenges because you don't know what I mean. I've never really hired salespeople, it was more service, right? So um so kind of figuring that part out is has has been a challenge. You really don't know what you what you need, right? Or what you want, you know. So um, but uh but yeah, no, that that was uh that was the hard part, right? Figuring out what type of salespeople you need, you know. Um, but uh yeah, yeah, I I had I had when I first started I had a staff full of service people. So and and it was horrible, right? So it's like you know, shoveling your money in the in the fire pit, you know.
SPEAKER_04
So uh but uh but no, it's uh but it's not hard, just do this, and they're like, no, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, no, no.
SPEAKER_00
So um, yeah, I'm I'm definitely uh uh through the years I I've learned I'm I'm a people person motivating, right? To try to motivate them to get the most out of that person, but um I'm not so much of a process guy, um, although we do need those processes in our business, right? Um to be consistent. But um, but yeah, no, I mean it it's I I think leadership is is is definitely um, you know, it's like coaching, right? I mean it's like a coach. We're just trying to, you know, work with what we got, right? Well what we got and and try to put the people in the best uh best position to win.
SPEAKER_02
So how how do you stay motivated and how do you keep your team motivated?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, so um honestly, I just make it fun, man. This is we're we're we're in a in a boring industry, bro, right? I mean, nobody really nobody wants to talk to us, bro. You know, right? We're all the people we're we're getting hug up on, and you know, and then the the people that we do talk to, you know, we want to, you know, give them the best. But but yeah, I I think I think that, I mean, just kind of you know, you know, leaning towards the educational piece, right? And and and really kind of focusing on um you know, on what you can do. Not everybody's gonna bite, right? But but you know, that that's a that's a thing for my team, right? Just to kind of keep them motivated, right? Just to keep them interested, keep them fun, play cornhole, play games, you know, throughout the day, you know, do those things like that. It's it's because it's it's boring work, right? So yeah.
SPEAKER_02
I was just so we just onboarded a new person and it yesterday was her first day, and I told her, I said, listen, it it's you know, if you learn our process, it's proven to work, but like everybody here is 90% knows, right? Salespeople that get that's uh you that you have to get used to knows people that can't handle that can't win. It's the people that that does not bother. That's like the skill. It the skill isn't to like shine during the 5% or 10%. The skill is the shine during the 90%, you know? So the that you're right, like motivation is such a huge deal. So you incentivize them games you got going on, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
So games, um, definitely, and I mean I I think the biggest thing is just the communication piece, right? I mean, um I mean, I I I want to give them the tools they need to succeed, right? So, but I don't want to be micromanaging and doing all this extra work, right? Yeah that we all love to do, right? So that that's that's the hard part, but it's like give them the why. I want them to understand, right? I want to get them, I want to get them inspired, right? I mean, because or else they're just gonna be they're just gonna be those service people that I hired at the beginning, right? So I don't want that, I don't want a clock puncher, right? So yeah, so I mean just different things, like different incentives, um, you know, um, just to keep them motivated, keep them interested, right? So that's that's a hard part in sales to stay interested, you know. So yeah. It and how often are you changing that? Oh yeah. Changing what?
SPEAKER_04
How often are you changing that? Like the like today, is it a daily thing? You come up with a new thing each day, each week. What's and and give an example, like what's a great thing that that they had a lot of fun with recently? Yeah, no, staker beans.
SPEAKER_00
Staker beans, staker beans, right? Yeah, no, but I just think things like that, right? Obviously, I mean, a lot of people are motivated by money, but like some people just want recognition too, right? So um, I mean, honestly, it doesn't have to be big. That's the that's my my problem sometimes is I want it to be this big, extravagant, or let me just throw money at it, right? And then it'll it'll blossom into something, right? But no, it it's it's it's about being consistent, right? About being consistent with just meeting together, meeting together, meetings. And as much as I I I hate I don't like them, right? Because I feel like, oh great, I want to sell more stuff. They need to be talking to other people. But I think that 30 minutes daily or the 15 minutes daily, just really connecting with them and sometimes not even talking about work, right? Sometimes just talking about what's going on, right? It really kind of helps them to open up, not just to me, to the prospects too. So um, so I just think it doesn't have to be simple. I mean, it doesn't have to be hard, just very simple and um, you know, keep it simple. That that's my thing. Keep it simple as possible. Um, you know, throw lunches out there, throw throw drinks out there, you know, um, those things like that, you know.
SPEAKER_02
But love it. So um team management. You you were um you had some insight on some team management as far as the way you handle handle your team.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, yeah, definitely. And and I mean, I think what uh what we're just sharing right now, just having a daily consistent meeting with them, um, you know, really kind of talking to them. I I you have to figure out, you know, each personality. And like I was sharing earlier, just how I like how I I came through management and managing people, right? That that's the that's the hard part, right? I mean, we can't we can't just um expect the results, right? Expect the results and and you know be there at the finish line when they're you know, hey, you're 10 quotes short for the month, right? You can't do that, right? It has to be a journey, you know, with each staff member, right? So um yeah, I you can't cookie cut the the all the processes, all the the the things like that. It's to me, it's more of a human thing, right? I'm more trying to connect to you. What makes you tick? Tell me about your family, tell me about your your kids, you know, what's going on, you know, those type of things. I mean, I think those those things have helped me a lot through the years because it's just been, you know, I've been able to connect, right? And they've been able to, I've I've been able to share with them. They probably helped me more than I've helped them, you know. So um, so it's it's it's more of a more of a philosophy than than an actual process or strategy, right? But I I think that's the biggest thing, you know, you have to walk along with them and through the whole process sometimes, right? So, or check up on them, right? So, um, so so that's been huge for me. And I mean, honestly, being a being a parent sometimes that kind of helps me sometimes. I mean, you have when you think of your staff, you're like, Yeah, I got two kids or three kids, but I got five more kids at the office that I have to deal with. So it's true, right? It's true. Yeah, so so you you almost have to uh to to to tie them together somehow, you know.
SPEAKER_02
So totally, yeah, it does. It's very like the the philosophy behind managing both is very, very similar.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, yeah, for sure. Yeah, and I I think another big thing is that they I mean there has to be an end goal, right? For everybody, everybody has an end goal, right? Um, and you know, whether it's open up an agency or you know, go back to school or whatever, whatever they want to do, man. I mean, I I for me, I'm always trying to figure out what that person really wants, right? And and help them get there, you know, whether it's you know, I I I try not to be selfish about it, right? And just say, hey, if if my top producer wants to go do something, then hey, I'm gonna help you do that, right? And and I just feel by having that mentality, it just helps you out. It just comes back. It just comes back. It's just, you know, and I mean I I've seen that so many times um through my career, and it's even happened to me, right? So different mentors and different people in my in my life that that's helped me along the way, right? That's given back.
SPEAKER_02
So definitely that's kind of my my leaving us with a cliffhanger there, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_04
Well, so so far, what are your thoughts, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_02
Very true. Team. I mean, it's like we can't do anything without our team. And um I think a lot of people do uh struggle with they just hire people, they bring them on, and it's like just just do your job, just sell. It's kind of like when we're prospecting in general, right? Everybody's people, so it's like you gotta connect outside of what you're selling. You just have to connect, and I think that we have to do that with our our staff as well.
SPEAKER_04
All of this stuff, whether it's with the staff or or with the prospects or with your kids, it's all the same stuff, you know? Yeah, have a process, have a framework to that. Um have do the same things. I mean, you're you're going to you're gonna be more effective with your kids and have a better relationship with your kids if you listen to their needs and then you give them what they want and you care, you truly care. Same thing with the staff, right? It's amazing how many times I've learned something from doing something at the office and then been able to apply that at home and vice versa, right? And share those stories.
SPEAKER_02
Because human behavior is just human behavior, and our whole goal as leaders is to just lead our team, whether the team be the family at home or it's the same skill. It's the same and it's the connecting is the same thing. We all have the same basic needs. And we lost Martin.
SPEAKER_04
We lost him.
SPEAKER_02
Where'd he go?
SPEAKER_04
Martin is a team. Can you hear me? Help me.
SPEAKER_02
Well, I I can't ask him the final question because he's not on here.
SPEAKER_04
Yeah. Well, um, if if I was Martin and I was going to give one piece of advice to agents coming to an end, I would say I I think that you need to find other agents that are successful and are getting results and and just learn from them. Ask them. Don't be afraid to ask. I think that there's a lot of people that are afraid to just ask questions and get to know people. Some agents may not have time, they may blow you off. That's fine. You know what? You're gonna get a lot better response from agents than you do from prospects. So at least it's not gonna be a 10% success rate. You're gonna have a much higher success rate. But get out there, meet people, um, meet, you know, call Mr. Jason or Mr. Craig. No, but reach out and and talk, you know, talk to other agents. They're gonna share ideas. I think that we've moved away from this scarcity mindset, and really the ones that are the most successful are the ones that are willing to help.
SPEAKER_02
Yep. And Martin's in our our um our elite group, and we've learned a lot from him, and he, you know, hopefully he has learned something from us. But um, yeah, it's really it's really cool to to share those times. What we'll do is we'll wrap right now and we'll get Martin on for a part deah.
SPEAKER_04
That'll be fun. Sounds good, Mr. Craig. All right, Mr. Jason. It's been another great time.
SPEAKER_01
We'll have uh do your radio voice to sign out. Oh, the yeah, because we're trying a new platform. So this is our this is our radio, radio voice because we have a higher frame rate. What does that mean for you? Better audio quality.
SPEAKER_03
I love it. So let's go ahead and sign it off here. This is uh WPA. Dudes, WWWPA Q. All right, two stops.
SPEAKER_02
Dude, hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes.com. Hey, Facebook, check out the insurance disk, hey, Facebook, subscribe to the comments.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.