The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Fuhriously Finding Fundamental Financial Favorites with Fervor
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Were you expecting a pandemic?
SPEAKER_02I was going for it.
SPEAKER_01So good job. Do you think that coming from that environment really set you up to be successful in this environment?
SPEAKER_04And so it definitely gave me a great advantage. What's the best piece of advice just in general? I feel like come from uh Justin Furyman, bring in the fury.
SPEAKER_01I already know what to bring in. Bring in the fury.
SPEAKER_04The fury.
SPEAKER_00The fury.
SPEAKER_04I'm sure you've heard that a lot. Is that like your everybody's bringing the fury?
SPEAKER_00I think I've had most nicknames of anybody that I know growing up because it just depends on the group, right? Like you got Fury, you got Furry Man. Like, you know, there's some that I probably can't say while being recorded, but we'll leave those um on the side. But so many names. And funny thing, like, so my middle name's Justin, but I um I don't know if I should broadcast this first name is different name that I would consider an old person name. And that was exposed when I started working for uh company. You know, made it 20 23 years with nobody knowing my first name except for like a handful of people, and then all of a sudden it's exposed. And I joke I'll go by that name when I hit 50 because it's an old person's name.
SPEAKER_01So now you have to say is it Winston?
SPEAKER_00Is it Myrtle? Winston would be those would be worse. So I guess I freaking Dale. So first name's Dale, and nobody knew that for three years, and then you know, stepbrothers, you know, get a lot of nicknames.
SPEAKER_01So there's a buddy of mine that like we go way back, he's actually from Iowa, and um, I met him here in college, and uh like we anytime we leave messages on now. I never leave messages anymore, but when we used to leave messages on voicemail, we'd always we'd always go like, Hey, oh, this is Dale down here at the uh at the hay shop, and and we'd just have like this whole thing, but we always started with Dale. So yeah, there you go.
SPEAKER_00Well, you got King of the Hill stepbrothers, you know. It's out there.
SPEAKER_04NASCAR.
SPEAKER_00NASCAR, yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's freaking great.
SPEAKER_00Dale is like I said, I'll go by that. When I hit 50, I'll start responding to Dale and switch it on your 50th birthday.
SPEAKER_01It's gonna be Dale's birthday.
SPEAKER_00Well, so that was actually like one of the bigger nicknames that stuck around. I was on a softball team when this kind of came about, and so they got jerseys and they um basically had my name old man Dale on the back. And I used to work in this call center and I would be part of the mentoring group. Um, I ran the whole mentoring group for this call center, and there's this little department over in the corner that all were like the softball team, you know. So I'd be doing this tour on day one for new employees, and we'd be walking around, and then it was just kind of like um finding Nemo, the mine, mine, like everyone would just be popping up like Dale, Dale, and so I couldn't escape that one. I had to move a thousand miles away to uh Nebraska to my new home, which is where I'm at now, and it's kind of another secret. So until then.
SPEAKER_01Well, it was a secret, right?
SPEAKER_04It was.
SPEAKER_01Dale.
SPEAKER_04So, Dale, how did you get into insurance?
SPEAKER_01That's a great question. But what about gosh?
SPEAKER_04Wow, darn it. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_01All right, the first concert you went to, Dale.
SPEAKER_00Oh. First concert. I gotta I gotta go way back to 2016. And I made that was your first concert. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Nothing when you were a kid.
SPEAKER_00Nothing. Like the biggest thing I could think of that might have been close was like county fair outside of the fairground. Um, my mom went into Bon Jovi, and this is when I didn't know who Bon Jovi was. So that's if you want to count that, I have no idea. I couldn't hear but loud banging on music. But first concert was 2016, went to the used and taken back Sunday, and they were kind of a comeback tour, and that was the first one I paid for a ticket and stood in line and went inside to see somebody.
SPEAKER_04The you dude, both those are good. Both those are so so your first stuck on Bon Jovi. That's I know Bon Jovi's the best. Yeah, yeah. Did you have hair back then?
SPEAKER_00Back uh when Bon Jovi was playing or 2016. Yeah, yeah. No, I've um I've been shaved since 2014, so you know, nice ripe, the ripe age of 24, you know. Right, nice right, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I want to do it, but my wife won't let me do what shave. I want to go sh I want a complete shave, so I I got a mohawk, but it's that's funny.
SPEAKER_01It's a good mohawk's okay, but bald isn't.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, she just wants something on my head for right now, I guess. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00A lot of people uh it's thinning though. There's a lot of people that their hair's getting a little shaggy right now with not being able to go get it cut, and I offer my barber services all the time, but nobody's ticking me up on it. So that's awesome.
SPEAKER_01I was I this morning I was thinking it's a little long. I would normally be going to Kiko. I would text him right about now, and no Kiko, so I may just get the buzzers out.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, dude, let's do it.
SPEAKER_00Let's just that'd be good luck on Craig.
SPEAKER_04Let's start the bald revolution. Like, let's do it. We don't need we don't need to deal with haircast on a coffee toilet. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Well, looking at your background, I've actually had to think about this a little bit. I don't know if you guys watched like Walking Dead or anything, but I'm like, Yeah, if if it got like that degree, and I had to start shaving my head with no razors because I can't go by razors. I was like, would I be man enough to pull out that knife and do it like you see on the movies, you know?
SPEAKER_01You would have to go by Dale at that point.
SPEAKER_00I would have to, yeah. If you're hopefully I last longer than the guy in Walking Dead named Dale. So right.
SPEAKER_01He didn't make it very long, did he? No. It's like the very first season right there.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, so so you you opened an agency um just a few months ago.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um late last year, um, September.
SPEAKER_01September. Is that the same time as that's the same time as no, you're October, Jason. I'm October. And I'm November. Yeah, look at that. Right. September, October. We just got it straight.
SPEAKER_00Me and him are in September together.
SPEAKER_01Uh oh, yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Chao.
SPEAKER_00Cheo.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome, man. So so is that your first agency?
SPEAKER_00First agency. Um what were you doing before? What's that? Call center.
SPEAKER_04What were you doing before?
SPEAKER_00Call center. So I have like eight years of call center experience, you know. Did some for um direct TV tech support, you know, learned patience with um helping people find the source button on the remote. Just rip those ads off. But a lot of years in call center. So five years of call center experience with an insurance company, and ended up working with some agents after that. And through three years of spending time working with agencies, I decided that, you know, this is something I always thought I would do. That's why I took the job working with agency owners was hey, might want to do this. I've had some pretty influential people in my life be insurance agents, you know, like they're my baseball coaches through high school and college. And I'm just like, what are you doing that you're at all these practices and games? You know, like what do you do for work? And they're like, I'm an insurance office, you know, down the road. And I was like, Well, that seems like a great gig, you know. You don't have to go work, you just coach baseball all the time. That's awesome. So it was always something I thought about. I didn't know what that would be like, though, for me. And I was in the call center, you know, it kind of bottleneck for career-wise. So it was, hey, let's try working with some agencies, see what that looks like, and basically helped them train their staff. And from training staff, it was a few years of that, and I'm like, let's give this a go, you know. This is a great move for me to have some freedom, hopefully, in the future, and you know, put it on the line and see if it's what I want to be doing for the rest of my life. So we're in the mix of it right now, and we're doing pretty well, I would say.
SPEAKER_01Were you expecting a pandemic?
SPEAKER_00I was planning for it.
SPEAKER_01So good job. Yeah, obviously that's bunker.
SPEAKER_00No, that's been the challenge, you know, is just what can you not expect for? And you know, that's I would always tell people um when I was working with agencies, like you always be recruiting, you always got to plan, like you're you're a business owner, and you gotta protect your business. And one of those ways in our small business is through always recruiting and having five people that for the most part you said, I have a job for you when I'm ready, you know. And then that way it's not starting that process when you decide you need it. And much easier said than done, you know. You guys all know it's easy to say that, but that's what I'm learning is my way of balancing everything and being able to execute it right now.
SPEAKER_01It is a balance, and you have to you have to create these behaviors because if you don't, then it just falls apart, right? Um down into the little micro pieces of the agency, all the different pillars, right? There's the hiring, there's the um the training, there's the making it rain, or the marketing. Um why am I missing the fourth one?
SPEAKER_03Motivate.
SPEAKER_01There's motivating. You're not motivated enough to motivate. But you uh we have to be up here as the as the maestro and and really pull those strings so that those things get done and what can happen, and especially in the spot where you're at right now, you know, coming in, is you can get sucked down into the granular and then the other stuff falls to the side, right? Because it seems like, whoa, this is this is a big problem, this inspection. It's like, well, maybe, but there has to be somebody that can handle that because you've got to handle the other pillars also, and as soon as that balance falls out of place, there's a lot of risk, and we're supposed to be managing risk, right? Because you can say, I'm not gonna hire right now, I I'm gonna put that over here off to the side, I don't need anybody. And and you can do that, and maybe it'll work out, but only for a certain amount of time because it's inevitable that you will have to have somebody new, and if you'd wait until that moment when you need them, we've all experienced what happens, right? In fact, Jason was just talking about it before we got on here. Bringing bringing somebody on that is is just bringing somebody on that is just gonna fill the seat is actually gonna cost you more than than if you had planned and done the right thing. Or maybe it wasn't Jason, maybe it was one of the guests.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, no, no, no. I mean, uh yeah, that's how I look at it. It's like um, you know, you if you can make someone do if somebody can if you can get double the amount of work out of one person, it's beneficial for you and that other person because that other person's gonna crush it, right? And then so so are you, you're gonna maintain keep that person. You're you're you're really doing a service to you and your um your staff if you can create that kind of environment where you're really, you know giving them the tools to crush it rather than just sit there too, like knowing their roles too, you know, like having come from a call center.
SPEAKER_00I that was something where it's like, hey, can I have my team doing the prospecting, or do I want them quoting and closing? And I think you guys do it better than most, you know, but trying to allow them to be doing those items that you'd rather them do, you know, and it's it's a balance because you do gotta make pick up the phone and make the phone call, you know, you gotta call your quoted, you gotta get them back on the phone, and you gotta build your pipeline. You know, you got the golden rule, which is something my team tries to do is we try to hit those prospecting hours, but supplementing, you know, those extra calls and quotes has been like that's not something you want to pay my team to do, you know. Like just coming from that call center environment. That's the last thing I want some of my producers, any of my producers doing.
SPEAKER_01But well, yeah, the the the day is filled with eight hours and or eight or nine or whatever it is, and it's easy. They're gonna find something to do, right? Your staff is gonna find something to do, whether that something is prospecting or it's it's being the most productive, which is they're near the bottom of the funnel, right? If we're looking at it as a sales funnel, they have to be talking to these guys down at the bottom, right? That are gonna have a higher likelihood of tipping and being a yes, a higher likelihood of being closer to that 30th dial where where uh it it really is gonna increase the likelihood that we get a sale. Right, and so um I think that's one of the really important roles of of what we do is is helping them with that because people will feel busy no matter, you know, like I was so busy today. And then it's like, well, okay, but you had two quotes. You know, what what were you busy with? Oh well, one of the people I sold yesterday called and then this happened, and you know, and and then you start going in and diving in and and and inspecting what was going on, and it's like, well, shoot, they were doing all the wrong stuff, you know, and and it happens, and you know, they may feel good that they did those things to help that person, but if we have if we have a divided team where it's you know the service team and the sales team, um, it's it's so important to inspect that because I mean that that that's a real example that just happened. You know, one of my one of my producers yesterday no day before yesterday, she had one quote, and I'm I'm going, what? What I mean, what happened, you know? And well, the you know, all the stuff, you know, here's all the the reasons. But a b a bunch of it was her taking on service things from the people she had recently sold because she felt obligated to do it. Okay, well, do I make it a beater up time or make it a training opportunity, right? And and so it's a it's a training opportunity. It's like, oh, okay, well then then we're not you're not man what we need to do is manage the expectations of of the um the prospect, right? You close them, they're done. So now what you need to do is say, since you're done, or or since we, you know, we we just took the accountability number, this is now what's going to happen. When you need something, you don't want to talk to me. I don't do that stuff. In fact, I don't even know how to pull up the ID cards. What I do is bring on the new the clients, make them feel good, and then I toss it over to the people who are really good at taking care of our of our actual clients. And so trust me, I like you and you're great, and you like me, but you're gonna love jazz, or you're gonna love you know, so and so. And so setting up and managing expectations is is huge. And um, you know, it's like what we need to do with our staff and what they need to do with the clients. There's my diatribe.
SPEAKER_00No, I'd get soup calls when I was in the call center. They'd like supervisor can do more. And I'm like, I'm the last person you want to talk to. My team does five hours or eight hours a day, five days a week. They're the ones doing this insurance work. I'm trying to figure out how to motivate them, how to keep them fun, you know, managing their performance. And you don't want to talk to me. I I forget what insurable interest means or whatever, you know.
SPEAKER_01So coming from do you think that coming from that environment really set you up um to be successful in this environment?
SPEAKER_00It had because there's always pros and cons and balances, and some people go way far on each side, and I had basically always done the call center, you know, and then I worked and I gotta saw what was present in good agencies, what was present in the non-performing agencies, and was able to kind of piece together the formula that I thought would work for me and my team. And so it definitely gave me a pretty great advantage compared to some people come in with no industry experience. You know, I understood the insurance and the sales talk and the psychology that goes to every word that you're saying, how you say it, when you say it, you know, and there's so many times like we get trained, you know, and the training's never over, it starts, and you get told this is how you do a quote. But that question about what has you shopping for insurance or whatever, how you say it and when you're placing it can yield two completely different results. And that's the piece that doesn't ever get trained by I think the education people, the people that are in sales, you know, and it's not that they do a bad job, but if you're not in it every day, it's just so much harder. Like when I was out of and doing more coaching, I was not as good as at doing it. So it's being in it and being able to practice and repeat.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. We we uh like I beat it into my sales team's heads the the importance of the of the needs diagnosing and the questions um, you know, with uh like something like that, what has you shopping? We go even beyond, and it's um the last time you did a review, was that in person or was that over the phone? Or even better, we'll say um the last time you did a review with your Geico agent, was that in person or was that over the phone? And and so there's you're catching them off guard in a number of different ways, right? They're they're like, wait, review, wait, I don't have an agent, wait, you know, and and all these different things. Was I supposed to? So the idea is to get them, you know, questioning themselves a little bit or questioning who they have. And it could be Geico, it could be anybody, I just picked that, but no offense, Geico. And um yeah, so so yeah, but asking the right questions, right? The power of our questions creates the the quality of their responses, and it it totally shifts how they think about it, and it's important to get them to that place. Yeah, like I mean, there is and and I but Jason, you probably remember this um way back to Preston Schmidley. Yeah, the question, like he just says, why? You know, and we were we were role-playing yesterday with one of my guys, the guy um he was trying to do a build a wall, the guy said, No, I'm not comfortable talking about what's in my checking account. And he went into this whole, oh, but if you do this, he made it all he overcomplicated, he talked himself out of there was no way he was gonna get this guy to trust him anymore, and all he needed to do was say, Well, why? And just wait. Yeah, you know? I mean, there there's a lot of power behind why, and then they'll give you some reason that maybe BS, and you go, Well, but why? And you just keep whyin' them until you get to the real thing, and it's so simple. Um but it's sometimes uncomfortable, you know.
SPEAKER_04We call that peeling the onion in the agency. Right? That's always like, or what's the price, you know what I mean? Well, what what's expensive? You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01Like what's expensive about it?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Oh, I I I can't, yeah. If you keep asking why you'll get down to the truth, the real reason, like what is the real reason?
SPEAKER_00And you can tell if it's a real objection, you know, because so many times it's a scapegoat, and when you can get them to try to explain their rationale, that's when you find out if it's a real concern or they're just trying to blow you off. And you know, totally going through some of the training that I have recently um with Craig, you know, being able to get to a short no is something that I think my team um has sucked at, you know, like that's like we're learning, we're like, oh man, we got so many people that we're still talking to from September, you know, and suck might be the harsh word there, but we're all just like, man, that's right. Like, we need to get them to telling us no and find out legitimately why, so we can set that follow-up, that X date, you know, like we're not gonna win now. That's okay. It's this sales game of numbers, and it's not selling eight out of ten, it's closer to two out of ten.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, especially when you when you're buying a hundred leads or two hundred leads or whatever a day, and you have you have six telemarketers over here calling and sending them over to these LSPs. And so this this whole streamlined process, if if we if we can't move these people into the no car. And then talk to them later, then they're just clogging up the pipeline, right? With their indecision. So, you know, the power of that one question, the why must you do this today, I mean, it sounds weird, it's totally uncomfortable, it makes them uncomfortable, but guess what? You get a yes or you get a no, and it's done. And that's what you want, you know? You try to overcome the objection, find out if you what it is, but you'll get a good sense for it if they're blowing you off, and then that's fine, move on. And um, I don't know why the well, I it's lack of sales training, is is why, but but we don't like to hear no, or we don't want to hear the no because we think that, well, oh, this was gonna be a good one. I don't want to get the no. But it's like, no, there's 99 more behind this one. Who cares? You know, just get to the next one. Because the more you can get to, that's when you get to yes. So I'm monopolizing it.
SPEAKER_04So um, so what have you done in your agency from the beginning? The maybe what what what did you take from the call center? Um, the call center world that you brought into to this that really gave you a leg up on on high performance sales?
SPEAKER_00Standard process. I mean, you don't get to in a call center, choose how to do your interaction. You know, you're told this is how you authenticate, this is how you set expectations, this is how you go into XYZ at the quote, and it's you're you're checked on that, you know. My job when I was in the call center was essentially sit next to my team side by side and take a call with them, you know, grade them on that call right then, you know, and then it was listen to calls record so they don't know that I'm doing it on that one, right? Because when you're sitting next to them, that you get the best version of them, and you're just like, hey, why can't you do that every time? You knew I was listening, so you're perfect, right? You do that every time, you're gonna get results that you probably never dreamed of doing. And and that's the thing. Um, like there's a book that probably molded me more than anything else. Um, one of my mentors and close friends gave it to me when I was in high school called The Slight Edge by I think it was Jeff Olson. And it's just like compounding, you know, it's like you do one thing every day, you just don't realize the impact it has to you're so far down the path, you know. And he kind of talks to it in some different ways, like you eat a salad one day, Jason, and I eat a pizza, it doesn't make you healthy or me unhealthy, but what's that result 30 days or a year down the road of that same decision, right? And that's what we don't do over our calls as well as we think we do.
SPEAKER_01And right, the groove make the groove.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So, like that book though, it's like you don't realize it until you're you know, day 28, 29, day 30 that you are so much further along than what you thought, you know. And that's been the hugest thing is the scripting and being able to do that now. Opportunity is executing it, right? Like, hey, I got all these things, like I don't think we're immune as agency owners from blocking that time and setting that as a priority, you know, and the better that you can do those things, the better I think you deliver your value to the customers.
SPEAKER_01For sure.
SPEAKER_04How much time a day do you spend doing that?
SPEAKER_00I start every morning off with the meeting where we look at prior day results and do a little role play, do a little communication, um, a little bit, hey, what are we going to do today to make sure we're following our processes, you know, maybe some goals or games or something like that. Then try to hit the middle of the day with a little huddle. So we kind of jump in, um, introducing listening to a call there, trying to structure that better. And I have one thing at the end of the day with my team called DMAs, um, different making actions. And so ending the day with updating how many quotes did you do, how many build a walls, you know, what do you need to do tomorrow? Like, who are your top three people? You know, like the DMAs kind of you make those what you need them to be, but there's what's going to make a difference tomorrow. So I try like coming from the call center, I'm trying not to micromanage my team, but I understand from my background some of the things I think need to happen every day. And so the blueprint or skeleton I try to do is we start the morning with this. We have a quick check-in in the middle of the day for where are we at? Do we need to do any course corrections? And then ending the day. And I try to hit two power hours with my team, you know, in those blocks, and then the rest of the time, you know, it's like do what you need to. If you don't have people on the phone or quotes, make some phone calls or you know, let me know what you think's gonna get you there. You know, I have sometimes people say I want to go do some networking or something. That's great, but quantify it for me because most people say I want to go network, but they don't like like I want to do this, it's gonna get me more sales. I was like, well, how many more sales, right?
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_00How do you know? Like, like if you could break it down where if I meet with like let's just use kind of like business cases, you know, like you gotta meet it's like equation, you gotta meet four people to get one close. So if you're telling me you're gonna go meet these 10 businesses during that period, okay, you got my interest, but if you just say you want to go network, then you're not right working. I don't know, I just I just think it doesn't fair, you know. It's yeah, you gotta be specific and yeah, have that intention to it, which is that standard process. Like, how do you go from that hello to that close rate?
SPEAKER_01Right. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_04So what are yeah, Hugo.
SPEAKER_01I was just gonna from from a marketing standpoint, um as a new agent, and and I think that a lot of agents in in all across the spectrum, whether it's you know, farmers, state farm, or any of these other ones that we may know, um they come in and they're ill-equipped to to really be successful because they don't know vendors, they don't know strategies, they don't know what works in in their area geographically, you know, and there's there's so many different ways to skin the cat. Um, what kind of things did Dev you come in using to make sure that you have adequate workflow for your team to make it happen?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, um, well, I'm like the easiest person to sell something to, you know, you give me a deal or perceived deal, and I'm all in on buying more of it. And so any of the a lot of internet leads and anybody that's like, hey, we'll give you price match this. I'm like, cool, sign me up, let me get some free money from it, you know, because it doesn't grow on trees. And I just started off with pretty much like five, six, seven different internet lead companies just letting them all come in and tracking those results, which ones are working, which ones aren't. You know, I know the average premium that I've written off of each one and the cost to acquire that per item. And I have some better item acquisition leads, but their premiums are like $300 and something dollars. And I have some that are maybe like $20 more cost per item, but their premiums two, three hundred dollars more. So I don't need to go necessarily for the lowest item acquisition. I want the one that's you know gonna give that, you know, how do you get paid? That's that's kind of the other thing, is know how you get paid and know your rules. You know, a good salesperson I think understands that and they find a way to make that happen. You know, we're in business, and you know, if you go try to sell a bunch of commercial stuff early on in our work, you're kind of getting off the railroad tracks and whatnot. So try to keep it simple with just home and auto leads and measure what's working, what's not, and you know, six months, seven months started to weed them out as I learned which ones are working best for us, you know.
SPEAKER_01So so you stick with them, so you have a good yeah, I and that's important. I think that a lot of agents eject too quickly. Um, you know, this doesn't work, and we we say it over and over again. I feel like a broken record sometimes, but you know, we we have to help people understand this that you aren't gonna know how this thing is performing for at least a couple months, and you have to have a process behind it, otherwise just don't get them. Just buy mailers, right? Dump a bunch of mailers and then get and wait for the phone calls because to work the internet leads, you have to have a very, very airtight process, otherwise, money just be falling out, falling out the pockets, as they say. Right.
SPEAKER_04Money be falling out, be falling out the pocket. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But I think it's when you're go ahead, Jason.
SPEAKER_03No, no, no, you go.
SPEAKER_00Well, I just guess we're on the same path. I I don't consider myself a very analytical person, but I made that comment to my team and they all wanted to throw stuff at me because they're like, there's no way. But you know, this is like the biggest investment I've ever made in my life, and I did a lot to make it happen. And I don't like making decisions off perceptions, you know, and I would have done that past with somebody else's money or lower value items, but like I need this to um be a business, right? And businesses don't just make decisions these days based off of you know, no data. So I tried to be good about looking at that and making those smart decisions and and smart decisions having enough data within there to know that that's the number, you know, you can get good or bad results early on, and that may or may not be what it's gonna be like, you know. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, just to keep take the emotion out of it. Which is so easy for me to do. Making fun of myself.
SPEAKER_04So what if what if what what would like if somebody wanted to if you were about to talk to yourself months ago when you first started, what would what advice would you give to that to him setting up the agency from what you've learned over the last six months?
SPEAKER_00That's a good one right there. Um really think hard, I'd say, about what those top priorities are. You know, you have three or four or five things that need to be done each day, and doing a better job of blocking those. Um, I think that got me and my team off to a very great start, and then some comfortability set in, and you know, some of the things that we would time block and very specifically rally around as a team, I don't think we do as great of a job at now and trying to just get back to that. And so those things haven't changed, you know, they haven't changed since too much since everybody got into business on what it takes, the activity it takes. And it's just easy to find the easy way out, you know. And you know, when we were open, I had a book that I had behind me, but I needed the growth part to be successful for it to work. And so I had my service team and they took care of that side, and it's like we have to do these things like we're a scratch agency, and that meant our activity and productivity, and we just had some rules in place around our power hours that we're a little loose on right now. So I think it'd be what are those things and make sure to block those and execute them, you know. I would say, like when I would coach some agents before, I would sit down with them, talk through those processes, and they say, Okay, during this time, I need to call for monolines, you know. And I'm like, Great. So Tuesdays, Thursdays, you're calling for monolines at four o'clock. And I would call them at like 4.05, and they would chat with me for 30 minutes. I was like, I was calling for one reason, and that was to hope that you would say, Why are you calling me? We just came up with this plan, and you're supposed I'm supposed to be doing these calls. But how many agents ever said that to me, right? I mean, I didn't have I didn't have anyone do it, and it's it's just easy to get away from, but I think that's the level that I'm trying to get back to. But I don't think the whole day needs to be that way, you know, or if I'm back in a call center, which isn't exactly what I'm trying to do either.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think from the call center, you probably bought some you brought some really good experience in that it's not just um or uh it's not that it's not, it's it that that you're utilizing data to make those decisions, that you look at your your sales pipeline and you know that we need a certain number of dials or a certain number of contacts, because I it's probably inbound coming from the call center, but we need a certain number of contacts, and those contacts then need to convert into a certain number of quotes, which are then gonna convert into a certain number of sales, right? And and over time you're gonna have some number that's gonna pretty stay pretty consistent, right? Um, and then you can look at this process and know where do I have to spend my energy, right? If if they're not if somebody's if you have a producer and their their closing percentage is lower than the than the average, well, now we have a training situation, right? So, okay, where are we breaking down in the sales process? If if it's over here on this end, well, is it with whoever you have calling, whether you have the telemarketers or you have the producers, um, but just having the right also the right butts in the right seats, right, to to maximize the time spent. How is that set up?
SPEAKER_00Like, how is it in the call center set up that way?
SPEAKER_01Well, no, like how have you taken what you've learned from the call center and then translated that into what you do in the agency? Yeah, how have you set that up?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, definitely segmenting the roles, you know, like it's super easy for my, especially on my team, you know, small team. I have just the one service person and I handle the overflow and the stuff that the agency owner, you know, reviews, things like that. But the sales team does sales and that kind of keeps them there. And then there's the telemarketers to help supplement that prospecting for them. Um, there's the different marketing, whether it be some other live calls or some mailers to try and add those additional calls, you know, because yeah, with the the um telemarketing's great, it supplements so much of their work. Um, but sometimes, you know, like we do enough of it that you get to the people that are ready for the quote that are ready to make a change. Um, but you can't replace when mailers or something else does work and they're coming ready to decide to buy because they saw your Google ad and they need insurance today, you know. Um so it's trying to have a couple of those channels, but it starts with the activity, and you know, that can be done at a lot less expense, you know, using telemarketers rather than your sales team, and then having them focus on the talk time and quoting households and you know, it takes a variable out of that coaching within your office, and I don't have to train the talk pass on the telemarketer, I don't have to kind of manage that side. So it keeps it a little bit more in my wheelhouse where I've done so much in hey, you got somebody on the phone, you have just 10 to 30 minutes with them. How are you making the most of that? And are you asking for the business and how successful are you at?
SPEAKER_01Well, because there's a there's a uh um there's a huge barrier to entry and cost associated with bringing on a producer, right? They they have to study, they have to pass their test, they have to then you know f take whatever the carrier um requires, do all these things. This could be months, and then if you have them doing the job that somebody can be paid seven bucks an hour to do, all of a sudden you're going backwards, right? And and you're using that resource in the wrong place. Like this person needs to be talking to producers or needs to be talking to prospects and closing them. That is their ultimate number one activity, right? Is is more quotes. And them making 200 dials is not is not a good effective use of their time. And it burns them out. It burns them out. I mean, I used to I I used to think that way that they needed to do that, like almost like you know, their pledges and this is their their pledge ship and and this is how they become actors or whatever. But um just because that's how I did it in the 1800s doesn't mean that that's the way that they need to do it, right? And um, I think that it's tough to to expect somebody to to do that kind of volume consistently. You know, I mean the power hour is a great idea, and I think that that's good because it it shows them what they hey, this is the alternative, you know, but um, and they could pick some pick up some wins off it, but doing that 45 hours a week, uh that's that's how you burn somebody that cost a lot of money to get to that seat.
SPEAKER_04I think it's a different day and age, too. Like I I mean at one point in time you could be a part of the you could, you know, maybe have a producer and they plug in their network and you could create a lot of sales from that. But I don't think that it's necessarily like that today, um, at least in not in my area. And um it's it's always cool to encourage and start those centers of influence, but I think that you still got to supplement those centers of influence with some sort of traffic. You need to create predictable um sales in your office.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you can move it like over time, eventually. That's great if you're like um Heronbrook in Florida or the the glove box guys, right? Where they have I don't know however many lenders sending a business. But you can't you cannot scale that situation and have you know a hundred leads come in tomorrow from lenders. It's not gonna happen. And so, yeah, it's something to work towards, but then it's another pillar out here that you know I guess to to Jason's point, paying for that traffic, you get it immediately. You know, in the same way you run an ad, if you're selling flashlights on the internet, you buy an ad, you're gonna get a certain number of people are gonna hit that landing page to buy those flashlights. And it's the same thing with internet leads. Yeah, most of them suck, and most of them don't say yes, but you know what, some of them do, and that's what you're looking for, right? It's the same thing. It's just it's it's all the same thing. That's why you pay a premium to have a well, not now, but you pay a premium to have a store at the mall, right? Because there's traffic, right? And it's it's the same, it's just yeah, pay for a premium location for a restaurant, traffic. Traffic, traffic, traffic, traffic secrets. Well, what um I mean, I know what advice is one we've done today?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. I know what you would give yourself advice on when you started, but what would you give somebody just overall that you've learned throughout your entire career with Call Center and with uh your agency, what's the best piece of advice just in general that you've gotten that's really just helped you mentally take yourself to the next level?
SPEAKER_00I feel like coming from a background of playing sports and doing baseball at a couple levels that I'm just competitive and knowing the score, knowing your number, um, just super important, you know, whether that's because you're trying to get to the data and the ROI or you're trying to hit sales goals or operate your business. I think that is probably the thing that you need to dive into is know exactly how you're gonna get there. And then it's the process and execution, you know. Um, I love like we have a lot of agents that like to share best practices. I mean, this podcast is an example of it, but it's the execution of what's being shared, you know, and you can't do everything. You know, I listen to podcasts a ton and I hear a lot of stuff, but I can't do everything I hear um agents doing across the country. But there have been a couple things here and there that I've taken and trying to execute better and better each day, um, based off the numbers that I have, you know, on my computer with my Excel sheets that are super messy. But that's I just kind of just know the number. Know the number and then execute your plan, you know.
SPEAKER_01Is an equation, you know, and um you can definitely get there fairly easily. And I think it's almost like sometimes when you do work that equation, the numbers are so big on the back end when you back it all the way out down to dials that or you know, whatever it is, or leads that you're just like, uh and I think people just go, eh, never mind, I'll just keep doing what I'm doing, and ex and hope that something else happens. But it's like mathematically it works out a certain way, depending on where you funnel that cash.
SPEAKER_00So um and going back to that book that's just like it molded me more than anything, I think like that salad or pizza every day, you know, it's also like it's easy to do a pizza or a salad. Like that day, that decision is easy, but it's not as easy to do it a week, a month, you know, continuing that. And it's just a daily decision that you get to choose, but so much easier said than done.
SPEAKER_01And I can tell you on lockdown, I've been opting for pizza more often, and I think it's starting to take it.
SPEAKER_00But keep keep a score with that, you know. Like one of the things I did take from the call center um is like what are the five things that I need to be doing every week? And then I was graded, you know, as a manager on that. Did I hit all my coachings for the week? Did I get all my quality reviews? Did I hit 100% many weeks? Normally not, but did I go from 60 to 70 percent, you know, one week to the next, you know?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So how many extra things did you do that week because you had that metric to look at? You know, at the end of the day, it's like, oh crap, I didn't get this done. I gotta push that in. Whereas normally you'd be like, ah, forget it. Hey, he's done. No, I love it.
SPEAKER_01All right. Well, Justin, it has been awesome. It's been uh good to meet you over the the months here, too. Um and chat, and and uh it's it's a lot of fun. I'm glad that you're part of this, and uh obviously a really good insurance dude.
SPEAKER_00Appreciate it. I appreciate you guys. This is um first podcast I've ever done. I always thought like, hey, I could do a podcast, that'd be cool, you know. Uh not the top priority at the moment, but I love the information that's shared and it's cool. Um a little bit of a commute to my office every morning. People are like, you gonna move down there? I was like, nope, I lose my podcast time. I like that there you go. Yep.
SPEAKER_04I know that's what I I miss, I miss not driving.
SPEAKER_01I drove today. I I only come here on Wednesday to to the studio.
SPEAKER_00To the bunker, the bunker.
SPEAKER_01The bunker, yeah. Yep.
SPEAKER_00No, I appreciate you guys and the invitation. It's been great. Cool.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, awesome. Well, thank you. Yeah, we'll check in with you down the road here, and um and uh yeah. Thank you. Thanks a lot.
SPEAKER_04Thank you.
SPEAKER_01All right, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Thanks, Desmond. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman