The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Olivia Schmitt: Insurance Fan Gurl Will Totally Drop Knowledge Nuggets on BEST CSR Practices
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
The first question, which is what was the first concert you've ever been to? How did you get into the insurance world?
SPEAKER_04Oh my god.
SPEAKER_01I don't know. But we we're really, really fascinated and interested in marketing.
SPEAKER_04That's that's how this industry works. Like you have no idea whose hand you're taking at any given time. You know them, but you're not sure exactly.
SPEAKER_01What would one piece of advice be that you give to somebody that's jumping into this world?
SPEAKER_04Maybe there's an insurance fanboy out there. If you're out there, I would like to meet you.
SPEAKER_00Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast.
SPEAKER_04Boom!
SPEAKER_00I like that.
SPEAKER_01I'm scared. Olivia Schmidt, how are you doing?
SPEAKER_04I am I am doing well. Um, I mean, obviously I'm home. I have three kids. I apologize in advance if like one of them comes in and is like, hey, mom, and they'll ask like the most random question.
SPEAKER_01That's with them.
SPEAKER_04So yeah.
SPEAKER_01Remember that like the thing, the big thing on the news where the guy was talking on Zoom and then the kid came in and the lady came and like is grabbing him out. Like now that's just normal. Exactly. It's every day. Normal life room. Every time that happens here. So the the kid will come through the virtual background and like reaching reaching from beyond from the other side, like six cents style.
SPEAKER_04I like it.
SPEAKER_01Sure.
SPEAKER_00Well, before we get going, we always ask the first question, which is what was the first concert you've ever been to?
SPEAKER_04Okay, so I'm way back. I'm glad that I I like tuned in enough to like know that this question was coming because otherwise I would I would have to take like five minutes and think about it. Um so I am pretty sure I was trying to think back if like I don't know, I think I've lived a little bit of a sheltered teenage life, totally sheltered teenage life. So um I believe it was Weezer.
SPEAKER_01Oh wow.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Wow, that is a great one.
SPEAKER_01Yep. That has not come up.
SPEAKER_00What tour?
SPEAKER_04Oh my gosh. So I mean, so this would have been 18 years ago. I'm glad I can't say it was 20 years ago, but it was probably 18 years ago. Um so which album album? I don't even know what album they were promoting at the time. I mean that's what about Pinkerton.
SPEAKER_00They're all colors.
SPEAKER_04They're all colors.
SPEAKER_00Ooh, Pinkerton was yeah, Pinkerton was 90s, I think.
SPEAKER_01I mean, I was around in the 90s. I know that you were probably born in 99 or something, but me?
SPEAKER_04Not quite. I mean you're pretty close. Um yeah, so no, I wish I would have like, I wish I was an original, and when I was, you know, super young, I went on the blue album tour, but that wasn't that wasn't the case. So yeah, I don't know. I mean, I want to say Pinkerton, but I don't believe they performed a lot of Pinkerton songs, so I don't know, but I've I've seen them three times. So that's awesome.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's a good one. We have never had a Weezer, never.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, one concert was Weezer and Foo Fighters.
SPEAKER_00Oh, that's good.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Pinkerton came out.
SPEAKER_01No.
SPEAKER_00No.
SPEAKER_01I always get confused. One of them is from here. Meat puppets.
SPEAKER_00Meat puppets. That sounds about right.
SPEAKER_04I was gonna say both Weezer and um Foo Fighters are they're California people, aren't they?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Well, we'll give Meat Puppets to Arizona.
SPEAKER_04I love Weezer, but I I love them.
SPEAKER_00They are good, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Really good.
SPEAKER_00I hope so What's that? Yelled at it.
SPEAKER_03I hope to be that cool someday.
SPEAKER_00You already are. You already are. So, Olivia, how did you get into the insurance world? Take us through that journey.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I ended up completely by accident. Um, it was like a friend of a friend asked if I wanted to apply for a job. I had met this person one time and they were like, oh, hey, we have a job opening. You want to drop off your resume? And I was like, I guess I could do that. At the time, I was a massage therapist. Okay, so like absolutely not in any sort of like office-related industry whatsoever. Yeah, I wouldn't be working right now. Maybe I'd be on vacation somewhere. I don't know. Um, but uh yeah, so I dropped off my resume. Turned out I knew a couple of people that worked there, which maybe helped me. I don't know, but yeah, but then yeah, two weeks later I was um learning insurance. So it was it's pretty crazy. That was 15, six almost 16 years ago. So yeah, so it's been it's been a little, a little bit of a journey.
SPEAKER_01Was that an agency?
SPEAKER_04What's that?
SPEAKER_01It was it an agency or what yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yep, worked in worked in an agency, started out in commercial lines. Um, there was another agent that came on about the time. So I was I was working pretty much directly with one agent, um, at least for the first uh couple of years of my career. Actually, we worked together really closely for nine years. Um so it was kind of nice. We we kind of came up in the industry together. Um, you know, I was I was working with him from a servicing standpoint and supporting his sales strategy. And so yeah, it was it was good. We're still friends to this day. So um, so yeah, all good things. And I um yeah, I just I I love insurance. I just I wish I could like love it less, but I I don't think I can.
SPEAKER_00You love it, you love it. I love it. Which you know, uh, so I'm sure that's not something.
SPEAKER_01I wore this sweater every time you think insurance, you put on that sweater.
SPEAKER_04Wear it every day.
SPEAKER_00Well, what were I mean, what made you fall in love with it? Uh I I'm sure when you were young, you weren't like, oh, insurance is gonna be awesome when I grow up.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you know, I never even I didn't know anything about insurance. I mean, I don't even know, like I couldn't even tell you who paid my premiums. I assume my parents, I I had no idea. Um, but about that time I was starting, like I was living on my own. So I was I was learning just about the premium side as a customer um and didn't necessarily love that part. But I think that as I got into it, it was just there's so much to learn. So you never you're never gonna know it all. And there's so many great people. Um, I think that for me, it was just finding a lot of great connections and just building relationships with people. Um, you know, I don't know. I mean, I have I have clients that have become really good friends, you know. So from from back when I was with the agency. And so I just feel I feel like it's such a great way to connect with people, whether they're your clients or coworkers or people from all over the country. Like, you know, I I joke that I could kind of go anywhere, like any city in any state, and probably have somebody, a connection in the insurance industry there, and I could like couch surf if that was my speed. Um, you know, like it's just such a welcome, it really is like a welcoming relationship-based industry. And that I don't know, I feel like that's that kind of like hooked me and then reeled me in. And then I did try and get out at one point. I left, I went and did project management at IBM for a year and realized that that was not where I was meant to be. I really had insurance in my blood. Um, I was sitting, I was having lunch with a client um while I was still at IBM and we were like talking about his bond rates. Um, and he was like, I just am really not sure why you're not in insurance. If we're gonna go have lunch and you're gonna talk to me about bond rates, like clearly this is something that you love, and we should just you you should probably go back. And I went back um, I don't know, 10 uh probably a month later, I was back at the age of the yeah.
SPEAKER_01Same back to the same place.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. So I feel like it's hard once it gets in your blood, it's like you can't get it out. I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_04Kind of I mean I would be interested to see of all of the industries, how many people stay in the insurance industry in some fashion for their entire career?
SPEAKER_01Maybe not at the same place, maybe not the same agency or doing the exact same thing, but how many uh how what is the longevity in just different worlds within well because if you stick it out for a while, it's like there's so much, right? Yeah, from the whatever the systems, the the knowledge, the test, the I mean, just everything. There's there's just so much that it's like you think I gotta do that somewhere else, like learn all this stuff again. And just I don't know, it's not attractive. It's not attractive.
SPEAKER_04No, no, but I mean we have really amazing people. And yeah, I mean, I feel like that's the biggest thing for me, is just relationships and you know, I I I don't know. I mean, if there's an industry where you can kind of make whatever career you want, like insurance is it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's a lot of ways to slice the pie. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00So it is uh it is awesome. I mean, it is like we always joke around about uh because nobody really wants to talk about it, none of your friends or anything like that, but like until they have a problem, then they want to know everything that you know. Oh yeah, right, especially at any hour of the yes, yes.
SPEAKER_04I invited you here for dinner and I would like to talk about my roof.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But it's just it's crazy though, because it is it's so helpful, like it really does. I mean, we are helping people, so it's it's such a it's very rewarding type, very rewarding industry, I'd say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, yeah, it you're helping them when they often don't even want to be helped, they don't realize how much they need that help, right? Right? It's it because they're just trained. We were talking about this with a previous guest. I mean, they're trained to think, I just need to find the cheapest rate. That that's all this thing is. It's something I have to have and it needs to be cheap. And um, and and I'm I'm guessing you were from the you came from the independent world. Yep. Yep, and so there there is a little bit of that on that side because there's more offerings, so it's easier. You can go, oh well, this one's a little less, let's talk about this one. Um, but but there's still the quality is still so important, right? Right.
SPEAKER_04Exactly. Like your role as an advisor, because I mean they're they are trusting you with the most important stuff in their life, whether they realize it or not. And so to make sure that you're doing the right thing, like operating in the best interest of the client, making sure you know what you're talking about, like there is a lot of responsibility in the role, but also when you're able to help them through really difficult situations, then you realize in those moments that all of that work, even if you had to hassle with them over purchasing certain coverage or whatever, like it's all paid off now in this moment. So, um, so yeah, I mean, I think there's I feel like there's a lot more wins than not in yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And and you know, coaching the team, getting your team to understand this, because often they're gonna sell in the way that they've been sold, which is you know, the the industry standard of find the cheapest thing. Right. And um they have a huge responsibility to help somebody understand that on their worst day that they ever have, they they don't think about the fact that they save 10 bucks, right? They think about holy crap, I better have a million to protect me right now. Right because I just hit this person, right? And and so it's that I don't know, it's every day. I I that's that is what's pretty cool about this industry.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And I did notice on your LinkedIn that you actually say insurance fangirl.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. So I I adapted that name almost two years ago. Um, yeah, I was I mean, I was trying to come up with something to express my adoration of the industry. Oh my god. I am I'm like straight up geek here. Um, but yeah, I mean, I'm I'm a fan of of insurance and I'm a fan of the people. So yeah, I felt like it was appropriate.
SPEAKER_01Well, when you're at the virtual happy hour and you're talking to people on Zoom, then in these difficult times, then you would say, I'm an insurance fangirl, and they all get, Oh, tell me more.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, every everybody wants to know that girl.
SPEAKER_01Well, okay, so so you're at the agency for how when did you when did you wrap it up there? And then was it next to to your current endeavor at at Total CSR?
SPEAKER_04Yes, yes. So I uh everything just happened really quickly, right? So I was um I was done at the agency uh at the end of January and started with Total CSR right away. So have not been to Total CSR for a ton of time. Yeah, yeah, just a couple months ago. So um it's all it's all pretty new. I think the good thing is that um insurance knowledge is still pretty fresh in my mind. Um I'm trying to make sure that I don't lose that because I mean you spend 15 years building that knowledge, like I don't want to lose it, um, but also trying to make space in my brain for a whole new role. So um, so yeah, just trying to mash it all in here.
SPEAKER_01Okay. Yeah, so so you're director of marketing. Yes. Talk to us about that, and then well, I guess talk to us about what Total CSR is, and then how how I guess I would I'm I'm guessing it serves the the insurance space.
SPEAKER_03Yes, it does.
SPEAKER_01And but we we're really, really fascinated and interested in in marketing and how how different strategies from different areas can really help um agency owners in their space. So you have that little bridge over by doing both.
SPEAKER_04Yes, so hopefully all of that plays out exactly um how it should, right? In terms of taking my experience of being in the industry on the agency side for 15 years and then going to the vendor side. So it is it is a big, it's a mindset shift for me in terms of like this is it's it is a different channel, right? Um, but uh yeah, so Total CSR is a training and onboarding product for people that are new to the industry, or if you want to cross-train them. So if you have somebody going from personal lines to commercial lines, vice versa. So they've created um like the the training curriculum programs in commercial lines, personal lines, group benefits, soft skills, and producer training. Um, and so they're just continuing to build on that and expand on that. Um, the goal behind that was really hey, when we have somebody start out in the industry, it's taking a year to train them. And I remember those days when I started in the industry. You go through licensing school, they say, that's great, you got your license now, forget everything that you learned in licensing school, we're gonna teach you the real stuff. So this program is the real stuff, but consolidated. So you're not waiting 12 months um to really be able to utilize that person in your agency, you're consolidating it down to a few weeks. And so um, you know, just making sure that you're giving them a really good, healthy baseline of information and then they can just continue to build on that. Um, so yeah, it's it's pretty cool. And I mean, I've been a big fan of it. I was a big fan of it on the agency side. We never purchased it at the agency that I worked at, but um obviously was able to create a connection there. And that's what I'm saying like connections are crazy. Like you just you don't know when a connection with somebody is gonna mean something other than I'm shaking your hand at a, you know, at a trade show at a conference. Like you you're never sure when that's going to um play out into something different in your life. Um, but yeah, I was lucky enough to meet them when they first launched the company. Our paths crossed at different conferences, and we started talking in October. And yeah, so in January, you know, late January, I started with the company. So um, so yeah, it's just that was total sidebar. But that's that's how this industry works. Like you have no idea whose hand you're shaking at any given time. You know them, but you're not sure exactly what they're gonna mean in your life down the road, right? Yeah, um so yeah, so my goal is to really um obviously make sure that we're getting awareness about the product out there. Um, we think it's super valuable. Um, I think the industry needs more uh education and materials that are applicable to the job that's being done. Not a bunch of like we're gonna throw a bunch of policy forms at you that you may never read. And not that that stuff's not important, but let's let's cover the basics first. Let's cover the foundation that makes you feel capable and confident when you're first sitting at that desk having to talk to a customer. And then and then we can start working on the other, you know, higher level, you know, intermediate and advanced information. Um, because sometimes I think either we try and pile too much on or we don't give them enough. And so creating that bridge in the middle, I think is um it's important and it's needed. So yeah, so I'm just trying to get more awareness out there um and just continue to understand what is meaningful to agents and make sure that we're always providing the content that is actually going to help somebody out, whether it's agency operations or if it's just um, you know, managing people, hiring practices, whatever it is, you know, training, obviously, big deal for us. Um we just want to make sure that we're always giving just the right information, stuff that's going to be usable to people. I don't want to fill the internet with a bunch of fluff. I want it to be really good stuff that people can take back and and apply to what they're doing.
SPEAKER_00Do you see a lot of um independent agents or or even captives use using the platform?
SPEAKER_04Um primarily independent agents. Um, but um certainly it's it's an option for anybody in the P well for for anybody. I won't I don't want to say just the P and C world, but anybody in the agency world.
SPEAKER_00So And how how long are the programs like like take us through like what would be the benefits if for our agency, uh let's say I was onboarding a whole bunch of people um and I'm worried about training them. What would you do?
SPEAKER_04So huge benefit is that you don't have to do the training. Nobody in your office has to do the training except for the individual that needs to be trained. So they get to sit down at the desk and you know start working through those training programs, whatever their discipline is, whatever you're hiring them for. It's very focused on what they need to be doing. Um, and so you're making sure that your original set of employees are able to continue executing on their primary duties, um, and your new employee is getting some very good, thorough, consistent training so that they're able to hit the ground running in a much shorter time span. So commercial lines is the longest training module. Um, I think commercial lines is just probably more involved in my experience on the agency side and looking through the program, it's just more involved. Um, so that's going to be your longest program. Personal lines next to that, soft skills is a great, great addition. Um, I I love that one. I think it's one of those things that we just kind of forget about. We assume that if you were nice in your interview, you know how to talk on the phone and deal with some things, you know? Not necessarily the case. Uh so that's uh obviously a great one. Um, group benefits and producer training a little bit shorter. So um so yeah, commercial lines is just it's always gonna take the longest. I just feel like there's there's so much more involved in that.
SPEAKER_00So that's awesome. That's that's cool that it has the the soft skills as well. Like that is very very important for agents. What were you gonna say, Craig?
SPEAKER_01Well, I just I so how how can somebody like it, I guess. In the independent world, there's a lot of similarities between the agencies, but it could I know Jason asked, but in the in this space. So let's say I'm I'm bringing people on for my my actual agency. How would we be able to use that so that our new hire was trained and it was relevant to them in our space?
SPEAKER_04So what do you what do you mean in your space?
SPEAKER_01Well I I mean in the ki in the captive space.
SPEAKER_04Is there oh yeah, I mean it's it it it's insurance information, right? So it's it's accord forms, it's um the basics of general liability, it's you know the basics of a home policy. So it's not it's it's not necessarily getting into like super hyper specific stuff, right? Um where that I'm I'm not and I'm not sure what you guys use for continuing at now. Um but I mean you guys kind of do you guys use the same stuff? I mean I don't I don't know if it's is it different in the captive world?
SPEAKER_01Yeah I probably I don't know so so I don't know that that side as much.
SPEAKER_00Um yeah so continuing at is in like it's just in the courses the the like the we basically so in the captive world it's basically we don't have much to go on other than the little bit of training um that the company provides and then it's kind of you know kind of go at it and and I and I do and I we do have you know basic yeah I guess like basic deck pages and stuff like that that we'll go through with our employees to to because it like to your point when you take those darn tests it's just like I almost feel like people are more confused than if you sat down with them for 30 minutes and explained liability, like after this 52-hour course and everything, and they go to the the license center, take it, barely pass, and then afterwards it's like they don't even barely know what liability is because it's so convoluted by that point.
SPEAKER_04It's not anything that they can take back and apply to a conversation with a client, you know? It's like so it's really like Total CSR is designed to give them the the real practical stuff. Like these are the questions that are gonna come up. This is the stuff you're gonna encounter, and this is how you're going to become valuable in your role. Um, so yeah, I mean it's uh it's just been one of those things I feel like has been lacking for such a long time, and we don't realize it, right? Because we're just like, oh, this is this is part of getting a license and maintaining a license, and then everything else, we're just gonna learn as we go and hope that we don't mess it up along the way. Um yeah, so this is I feel like it's just a much better way to like build a healthy foundation of the right set of information, and then just you know, then you're more prepared to take on more complex coverage and claims scenarios. But yeah, I I think it's it's very much needed. Um, just from my experience working in insurance, hiring people, trying to train people, trying to make sure that I train them the same per the same way that somebody else on my team was going to train them. Like you don't even know, like you're mixing in people's perspectives as well. Or I had this one thing happen once, and this is how it was covered.
SPEAKER_02Right.
SPEAKER_04You know what I mean? Like it happened this one time, never happened again. It was like lightning struck and we got this claim covered, or something like that. You know, so it's like giving them something consistent to go on, and you know that every single person in your organization is being trained the same way. It's it's definitely much more reliable than hoping that every person in your organization speaks about every scenario the same way.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Well, awesome. So how can people find the uh is it total totalcsr.com?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, totalcsr.com. We try and keep it simple. There's a little button where it says book a demo.
SPEAKER_01There we go. Okay, so they can go there, they book a demo, see how it works, um, and then uh get that thing signed up and and uh not have to deal with baptism by fire at their agency.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean that's a that's a great way to put it. I forget I used to use that all the time. I mean it's funny because that's exactly what I said for the longest time. When I started in the industry, I was handed a book of business on day one. They're like, go get go get your license, but kind of look at this stuff.
SPEAKER_01Here's the book. Hi.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, here's your computer. We don't know how it turns on.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I don't know how to turn it on, but you can figure it out. But it is, it's a ton of overwhelm. So so before we run, what would one what would one piece of advice be that you'd give to somebody that's jumping into this this world and and uh for some reason and and is a fangirl of insurance or a fanboy, or fanboy or a fanboy.
SPEAKER_04Maybe there's an insurance fanboy out there. If you're out there, I would like to meet you. Um oh my gosh, I would say find a mentor. It's the most powerful thing, I think, in terms of being able to really feel comfortable and feel like you have somebody that you can go to with questions and you know, whether it's I have no idea what I'm doing or if it's I have a really specific coverage question. So just that person, I was so so lucky to have great mentors and continue to have really good mentors. I think it's I think it's a differentiator for sure.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, awesome. Jason, anything?
SPEAKER_00Love it. No, I love it. I think that the mentorship was uh was is a great piece of advice because actually the our last guest gave the same advice, and honestly, like we I mean, even somebody coming in with a lot of knowledge still needs a mentor to get to that next level or or wherever they anytime we do anything new. But I think insurance is one of those spaces where there's a lot going on and we definitely need some help.
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah, yeah. I mean, and the thing is, it's like typically your mentors are gonna have they will have forgotten more than you're ever gonna know when it comes to insurance. Yeah, you know, or or you know, something very specific in your role. So it's like, yeah, I've I've been so incredibly lucky, and I know I would not be in the career that I'm in right now had it had it not been for those people in my path. So yeah, super lucky.
SPEAKER_01That's that's awesome. Well, Olivia Schmidt, thank you for uh being a dudette on the insurance dudes. We appreciate it. Yes, absolutely, and uh we'll see you down the road, okay?
SPEAKER_04Okay, sounds good.
SPEAKER_00All right, thanks, Olivia.
SPEAKER_04Thank you.
SPEAKER_00Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman