The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Facebook Marketing Mathiesmind Makes Money Multiply Magically
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
How you got into the insurance business.
SPEAKER_00Most agents don't want to talk about sales. They don't want to hear that there's a sales problem. It's a lead problem. Always, always have that.
SPEAKER_03Everybody complains about oh, these leads are crap. But it's like, dude, you can take the best leads with no process and you're you're gonna get no results. Every deal is gonna start the wrong way.
SPEAKER_00I don't think there's a right or a wrong way to um build your business. There's just different ways. Um it's the Internity News Podcast.
SPEAKER_03Boom!
SPEAKER_02John Mathis. How's it going, John Mathis?
SPEAKER_00What's up, brother? Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for coming on, man.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we've been wanting to have you on for a long time. Oh wow, okay. A well-known uh person in this in this industry.
SPEAKER_00It's been a while. We're going on six years now.
SPEAKER_02So yeah. Awesome. Well, uh, before we dive in, why don't you tell us the very first concert that you went to? And way back, I mean, if it was Barney, then you have to say it. Yeah, first concert I went to. We haven't gone to Barney yet.
SPEAKER_00And um, who was it? I want to say I want to say it was actually it's it was called Edgefest in in Dallas. They don't do it anymore. Um they still do it, it's just called something else. The station is called something else, but it was actually a bunch of different uh folks. There was uh I remember Offspring was there. Um God Smack uh was there. Um let's see, there was like uh Sum 41 was there, Incubus was there, so there was a lot. It was a big one, yeah.
SPEAKER_03That had to be what 96, 97?
SPEAKER_00Um yeah, I was probably 15, 16 years old. So um I saw it 20 years ago. That'd be crazy. That makes me old. Yeah, yeah. Wow.
SPEAKER_03Craig Craig was uh 60 at that point.
SPEAKER_02So yeah, I think that's no, that was around when I was into my 70s.
SPEAKER_03So the golden years. I'm just getting ready to say that. Great, Mike.
SPEAKER_02Well, cool, Sean. Why don't you why don't you walk us through how you got into the insurance business, uh, take us all the way through, and then up to what you're doing now, and then we'll go into some other stuff.
SPEAKER_00So uh it's that it's actually been 10 years now that I've uh that I've been in the industry. And uh I I first started, uh I think I started getting licensed in 2009. And um it was coming right off the maybe it was 2008, coming right off the back of the the real estate crash of 08. Um, I actually put myself through college as a real estate agent from 05 to 08, and then things started dipping, and I had a friend in the business, uh, and I don't know if he even knows I tell this story, um, but uh he was uh with shelter insurance and I was sending him on my business, and I was in his office one day, you know, griping about the uh uh about the industry, and you know, he said, You dude, you should be an insurance, you'd be a great insurance agent. I was like, huh. So I got into it, looked at it, actually uh got licensed with farmers. Farmers licensed me as part of their reserve program. Um, I had an offer to go work for State Farm as a um, you know, uh what do you call it, sales rep for one of the agents. But at that time, my ego got in the way, and I was like, no, I'm in, because I was a real estate agent, so I was like, no, I'm the agent. I want to be the agent, I don't want to work for an agent. So I went to farmers and then um went through their training, and then I realized how much there was to learn. And I got kind of scared. I was like, man, this is a lot, not only how to run a business, but then learn this insurance industry. Yeah, maybe there's some method to the madness of going to work for somebody first. So then I went to do that, went back, pulled back on that deal with farmers, went and worked uh as a team member, uh, decided I really liked it. At the time I was living in Missouri, I just finished college, and then I wanted to get back to Dallas, so they said go to Dallas. It's a Texas is a whole other animal. Um, I was in Missouri at the time, so I went to Dallas. So a total of three, almost four years as a team member. Then I was ready to start my own book. But at that time, it was 2010, it uh in in the state of Texas, they there was some lawsuits going on with Department of Insurance and uh you know State Farm back at that time, and there's just like a little bit of a weathering of a storm that needed to happen, and I didn't want to weather that storm as a as a team member anymore. I wanted to start my own book. Ended up going to Liberty Mutual, starting there. Um it's a quite a different setup than most of your traditional agency opportunities. Great company, great benefits, uh, made a great deal of money there. Just wasn't quite what I was uh envisioning for myself because I really wanted to be a business owner and I just wasn't there. Um, so after about three years of that, uh, my first year I was rookie of the year, outsold 1500 other agents that year to just over 700 items and a million in new business premium by myself. Um, and then was number two in Texas, number five in the country, stayed at the top there, and then ultimately in 2014 is what brought me to uh the marketing industry. Uh at the time I had some stuff going on with the television show called Million Dollar Listing New York and LA. We were doing speaking engagements and I kind of helped them build mastermind programs and webinars with showing them how to monetize their fan base. Uh apparently I was supposed to disclose that as part of my employment contract with Liberty. They didn't like it. Uh, they gave me an ultimatum. So I was like, you know what? I can always be an insurance agent. This is a once-in-lifetime deal. I'm gonna do this and let that go. And then that's kind of where the coaching program for insurance agents came out of was um, well, you know, this I knew the TV show thing was only gonna be so long because you know, once the show ended, then that's it. So I I uh built the program because I was like, obviously, I know a little something that other agents don't know about marketing and generating leads, and decided to uh launch the agency alliance mastermind uh back in 2014, and that's uh how I got into the marketing side of things.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome, man. Wow. So, how was that experience with million dollar uh million-dollar listing?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah, it was really cool. Um, you know, the uh it started because uh at the time I was really working with a lot of um mortgage lenders and realtors, and I had my own networking group. So you're familiar with probably like a B and I or a Rotary or something like that. Um well, I started my own because I couldn't find a spot as an insurance agent, and that's oftentimes the issue with those types of groups, is there's no spots. So I was gonna, you know, D and I said, well, you can start one a chapter of ours. And I was like, Well, if I'm gonna start a chapter, I'll just start my own. So I started something called North Texas Area Professionals. Um we ended up growing that thing to eight chapters um uh within the Dallas Fort Worth Metroplex. We had about 120 members, and then we would do monthly happy hours as like a way to recruit and then bring all of our groups together once a month. Well, there's another group that was called real estate a-listers, the um they call real networking, REAL real estate a-listers, and they had their events were awesome. Red carpet, videographers, like it was a big deal, and all the realtors were going. So I told this guy, I still had a big following, and I was trying to try to uh do something at the end of the year so that we didn't compete, his group and my group uh for a holiday. And I said, let's let's do something together. He told me no, he said he didn't want to taint his brand, and so I took offense to that. And I said, Okay, you don't want to taint your brand. So I went out and I was like, I want to get more realtors to my event. So I started at the time this TV show was going on. I started calling, literally cold calling the cast members and was trying to get them to come to my event. What do I got to do? What do I got to pay you? How do we get this to happen? Long story short, I got Madison Hildebrand from uh LA to bite on it. He did the first event with me, blew him out to Dallas. I purposely scheduled the event the day before this the real estate A-Listers event that year in Dallas. So his was on like the 19th, and mine was on the uh 18th. Um, and obviously, you know, if you're gonna do a real estate event, you're gonna go to the one with this this cast member at the time. The show was really high, it was on season three. Everybody loved it, it was a huge hit. Uh, and so I was like, let's do it again. And then I just kind of worked my way through the cast members. Once you got one, then they were friends with the other, they're like, Yeah, he's legit. And then um, you know, just kind of built a company around it, honestly. And then we started doing it all over the country. It was pretty cool. So cool.
SPEAKER_03Is that show still around?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, believe it or not. Yeah. Are you still doing that? Yeah, no, no, no, no. Uh NBC uh after we got a little a little bigger, NBC uh uh got a hold of me, and um yeah, I didn't I didn't want to go down that lawsuit battle with them because at the time I was calling it million dollar mixers, and they said using their cast members and the words million dollar were infringing upon their copyrights. I said, okay, I'll make it very clever. Yeah, I so I went from uh million dollar mixer to um I don't know, some other million something. Um, but then it just they kept hassling me. I guess you know, the bigger we got, the more NBC wanted money. And so we just ended up having to let it go. But it was fine. This is about two years that we uh two years strong that we did it. Um and it was really cool to get to stuff like that. When was when was this? This was uh 2013, uh end of 13, all the way through 14, about mid-15. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Which is interesting. This is like the the real life version of Instagram, what you're doing. Now they do this stuff on Instagram and stuff, right? Monetize an audience and or create an odd build an audience, then monetize it.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Yeah, so I we would host webinars and you know, coaching pro at the time I didn't have a coaching program because I was you know still selling uh insurance. Uh, but I had some people in the coaching business, and I was telling these guys, I was like, look, man, um you guys like people will pay to learn from you. And to them, they were just regular people, like you know, you and I. And and the fact they were mind-blown when they saw these events that I put together and people standing in line to get photo ops. Like, I thought I don't think at the time the celebrity had really sunk in with them that that they were actually celebrities. Um, and so it was really cool to to kind of see and and them be kind of taken aback by it all. Um, and the idea that they could, you know, charge 49 bucks and have a webinar and 200 people from around the world and real estate industry sign up was foreign to them. So it was uh it was pretty neat.
SPEAKER_03It's crazy. It still is foreign to a lot of people, you know what I mean? Like we all like us, we all know, you know, there every industry has it now, the groups that that do that. But um yeah, yeah, it's crazy. It is pretty mind-blowing on on how much you can make. You don't even have to have that big of an audience either.
SPEAKER_00Really don't. I that's what I told them. You know, by the time I got them to do the coaching stuff, I had already launched mine, so I knew that you know, that was my biggest fear was who who's gonna listen to me. I'm not a published author, nobody really knows me outside of the Liberty Mutual world, so like uh it was a big risk, but uh obviously it was uh it was successful. And and I told them, look, I I've got like 1,200 followers at the time, and yeah, if I can do this, you guys have 150,000 followers at the time. You guys have kill it.
SPEAKER_02So walk walk through that because I think that's a it's real important, and overcoming fear, because I think this is what holds most people back from doing anything or be becoming successful, is is that fear. Like people are gonna think I'm an idiot, or people are gonna, I'm gonna say the wrong thing, you know, all these things that when you were a kid you didn't care about, and now for some reason we do, right? I mean, obviously Jason and I don't, otherwise we wouldn't be doing this. Yeah, you know, no, it's uh step through that overcoming that fear.
SPEAKER_00You know, uh for me, I think part of it was um fear, and then you know, part of it was just uh an element of humility, I think, you know, like uh and the unknown, you know. I when when as a captive agent, you get so locked into what's going on in your world um within that company that you don't really know how other companies are operating or what other people are doing. So like social media has has kind of opened up now to before you know 10 years ago, you didn't have the access to know what good really meant. You knew, hey, you might be good in your district or at your company. Um, you know, so part of it was just like, you know, what if this may be great here, but what if that is you know small time anywhere else and my my stats are no good. So I think it's part of the unknown. Um, but yeah, I you know, I think the the biggest thing is is with video. You know, we try to, I've been teaching people to do video since 2013, and people are still afraid to get on and do video. Um and uh I think the biggest thing to to doing is just to do it, you know, just to um not worry about there's always gonna be people that are gonna you know say something negative. Um it doesn't matter what you say, it could be the most positive thing in the world, and it's gonna piss somebody off. Somebody's gonna want to, somebody's gonna do something, and you just it took a little bit of getting used to. I remember the very first video I put out, it was the worst video production-wise. Like the lighting was bad. I was in my car. Um, the the way the light from the the mirror was hitting, it made my teeth look yellow because it's like a yellow light, and there was like this gloss on my teeth, and I I had cotton mouth. I remember doing this like in the video. I did that, it was so terrible. But I got it out, and it was uh the more people that were talking crap about it, the more viral the video went. It went for about 72 hours, and I did about $8,000 in sales in that 72 hours before I got my first cease and desist letter from State Farm for doing it. I was basically calling them out because I had just the working knowledge of it. Um, and I, you know, the premise of the video, I called it the State Farm SmackDown. Um premise of the video was basically calling out agents who are buying these terrible internet leads and you know feeding them to their staffs. Uh, and then they wonder why morale is so low and why people are turning over when they're you know feeding their team garbage that they themselves wouldn't even pick up the phone and call because they know the lead's no good. Um so don't expect your team to do it. And so I was like, if you're a team member and your agents feeding you these terrible leads, tag them. And so it was pretty good. But it it took an element of fear of just saying, just who cares, man, just do it. Like you gotta do it. Um and so just doing it the first time and then just getting used to the the hate that comes with you know trying to get out there and be innovative.
SPEAKER_03Yep. So let's talk about the leads and and your process for getting the leads. What what what where did you develop your process and um yeah, take us through that journey.
SPEAKER_00You know really it was um out of uh not out of necessity, but but after my first six months in the business, I you know, I did everything that everybody else does. I did the networking events, I did the um cold calls, um long nights, you know, the friends and family deal and uh purchasing leads. And I was ready to quit. I was like, this job sucks, man. Like there's nothing fun about building an agency from scratch, at least at that doing it that way. Um I was like, I gotta figure out something else because I can't go into work like this every day and just get told no all day long. Um, and when you have no clients and you're just doing sales, you're you're just pounding phones and trying to find something and make something happen. Um, and at that time, that's you know, social media just started kind of coming on the scenes that you know, ads manager was a new thing. Um, and so I started going to and learning how to use Facebook and seeing if there's a better way to reach people outside of this what's traditional. And I saw all these different targeting filters, and I was like, man, there's like my audience is in here, I can specifically target them now. I just got to figure out how to put it together and a way that's gonna convert it and get a quote request out of it. Um, and so it's really just a way of seeing that it was gonna be something that was important that nobody else was doing. And if I could figure it out, I might just have something um worth hanging on to. And it turns out it I did, it worked out.
SPEAKER_02Well, how did how did you find that it started working? What was it? It was just the it was you were good at the targeting, you were good at the at the copy, like what yeah.
SPEAKER_00So, you know, I think a lot of it is is really kind of understanding the the consumer mindset. Um I kind of took a shortcut because at Liberty Mutual they have this thing called an affinity program. I think some other carators had it too, but you can get discounts to people for um different job titles or places of employment and things like that. And I saw that those things are available. So, like we a big one is they have basically every D1 alumni. If you're if you went to college at a D1 school, they have a specific your your alumni has an agreement with Liberty Corporate, and so I was able to target those people, and I knew that one of the things that we did was go around to you know these fire departments or whatever and tell them about the discount. So I was like, well, what if I just tell them about the discount online and I can avoid the driving around town or cult calling and just basically let this ad serve as the cult call. And I thought, what would I say if I had one sentence to tell somebody about this affinity discount? What would that sentence be? And then I just popped it in there and they worked. They responded. Love it. That's awesome, man. So that's how I started was just getting using what I already had. Um, I think that's what a lot of people, you know, forget. Like there's so much opportunity, there's so many tools at our disposal. Um, people miss the easy shit. Like, you know, Facebook recommendations. You could go on Facebook and type in insurance recommendations in the search bar, and you'll pull up a laundry list of people that are either in your network or friends of friends who've asked for an insurance recommendation, and people do it all day, every day. Hey, my insurance went up. Who do you guys recommend for insurance? Boom, they get like 150 comments. So you can search that out for free on Facebook, and nobody does it. Like you tell somebody that and they're like, wow, I never thought about that. It's like the stuff that's so easy. Um, and I think a lot of it is people don't they forget how hard it was before this technology and social media to read. Right. And now you can do thousands of people a day, tens of thousands of people a day for free if you just put in the work and learn how to use the platform, but people just don't do it.
SPEAKER_02The the yellow pages was the thing, you know, like isn't that crazy? Like people would fight over having the yellow the big yellow page ad.
SPEAKER_03Yep, yep. Dude, that's so funny. Like, I've never thought about just searching that phrase, but that's it's so obvious that it's crazy. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I think that what I what I do like about that, but when it first came out is you know, it was kind of a hidden thing, but now they have a a whole like recommendation section. My thought is, and I don't have any facts behind this or any data or any research, but my my theory is that they will soon monetize the recommendation section as they build it and more and more people use it. Right now, if you ask for recommendation, it automatically puts that box on there and pops you into that section. Um, but I think they're gonna use it as a great place to monetize um you know recommendations and and things like that and and have like featured people in certain categories. I I mean if I'm Mark Zuckerberg, I would, but um, it's a great, great tool and resource, it's easy to use. And that's what I like to try to tell people when I first start working on this like, let's see what you're doing now and where are we missing low-hanging fruit? What's the easiest, you know, the path of least resistance to start getting results today so that we can start to build a long-term future? Because so many agents don't have anything going on, they're in the day-to-day grind, like they have to go in the office today and find a deal today because they didn't have anything that's bringing something in from no seeds planted the week before, the months before. So it's just a day-to-day hustle for so many people. And so if we can at least get them out of that uh mindset, you could start to build longer-term uh plans and start to build a well-oiled machine. I think that's what's currently.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's what I was just gonna say. Especially what's going on now. It's like now you have A, you have the time. B, everybody's on the freaking internet.
SPEAKER_02Like everybody else has the time. They're sitting there. They're they're on Facebook right now.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yep. Or Myspace.
SPEAKER_02I mean older MySpace.
SPEAKER_03Remember Friendster? Were you on that?
SPEAKER_02Friendster. No.
SPEAKER_03Pre pre MySpace. Oh wow.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, no. It was uh yeah, it was like it was like Facebook. I mean, it was but you had to like remember how Facebook was? You had to know someone to get into it. That's how Friendster was. Yeah, Friendster is just like that. Um cool, man. So what what is uh so it so interesting. What other I guess what other um nuggets do you have as far as like low hanging fruit, maybe to get some agents um interested and to kind of see what this kind of world is about and and uh show them what kind of what what internet marketing can do for them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you know, I think it it what I've learned over the last five, six years um Yeah, we worked with thousands of agents, and and um I think the biggest like I've learned more in the last 12 to 18 months since we recently developed uh our own marketing automation platform. And so we watched hundreds of thousands of weeds go through um you know sales process and follow-up journeys and tracked all their movements. And so we've got just an enormous amount of data. And something that I didn't do when I was selling, that I would have, if I could have redone something, I would have learned more about the consumer behaviors and what motivates people to drive, what the motivates people to buy insurance, like how they're how the consumer thinks and what's gonna make them respond. Um because ultimately, I'm of the belief now there's no right or wrong way. I would, if you would have asked me two, three years ago, I would have said the the best way or the right way to market is to use social media and online. And as for today, I don't think there's a right or wrong way to generate a lead. I don't think there's a right or a wrong way to build your business. There's just different ways. Um, and you're gonna get different results. So if you give me a thousand people in a database, um, you know, you can cold call that database, you can mail that database, you can um run ads to that database, you can go knock on their door. Um, there's any number of ways that you can work it. As long as you're working it, you're gonna get results. Um, you know, so as far as low-hanging fruit, I would first establish, okay, what what tools and resources do I have? It surprises the hell out of me today how many people don't have a database. Like, if you if I said give me a thousand people that I can work, they don't have it. Um, or if they do, they don't know how to access it. And so, first and foremost, you have to get like if you were to go and and if you're gonna give your your list of people to call, how do you have that in a format? You got to get it, like put it in an Excel format, have your database so you at least know how many people are at your fingertips, and then from there you can establish what is the best way to work this. Um, you know, is it to call them, is it to mail them, is it to go knock on their door? What am I gonna do? But have it, and you got to put something in place to start working that database because the thing that I've learned is that if you have a thousand people, there there's gonna be at any given time 10 to 15 percent of people that are interested at some level, whether it's willing to hear you, uh, not hang up on your face in your face, you know, like they will visit your website, open an email. At some level, 10 to 15 percent at any given time will at least hear you. 85 to 90 percent aren't they don't want to, they don't want to hear you, they don't want it. Um, and then between one and three percent are gonna take a quote at any given time in your database. So it doesn't matter how you reach that person, that's gonna be like I said, after watching hundreds of thousands of people, that's the law of large numbers says that one to three percent of people at any given time you'll reach that will ask for a quote. So if you you scale that out and we say, okay, I'm gonna cold call my list, okay. So for every hundred dials, you you're probably gonna reach 10 and you'll get one or three between one and three to say yes to a quote for every hundred dials. Now, you can do that also with mail, you could do that also with digital marketing, automation, emails, text. Uh, however, you do it, it doesn't matter. It's you're gonna see those same type of results play out. So, you know, put a something in place to establish who you already have in front of you because that's your path of least resistance. Instead of spending more money to get somebody new in, you got to start working with what you already have and keep something in front of them at all times. And then you can add on. But what I what I tell people is if you don't have a process in place, you don't have some sort of uh workflow or hey, when I get a lead, this is what happens definitively. Whether it's you, your team member, or whatever, it should be a uniformed, systematic approach to how a lead gets worked and how they get followed up with. And then from there, uh you can start piling new leads on. But if you don't have a foundation or a process that you're going to use to follow up and maintain yourself, maintain these these relationships with these leads, you're just piling shit on top of shit, and it's not gonna work. Uh so there's no reason to be buying more leads when you don't have a system or an ecosystem to put them in.
SPEAKER_03You're just that brings yeah, that's a great point because you can have the and what everybody everybody complains about all these leads are crap. But it's like, dude, you can take the best leads with no process and you're you're gonna get no results. Yeah. You might sell one or two policies, but you'll you're never gonna get great results without a process.
SPEAKER_02You're not even gonna sell one or two. I mean, literally, because look look at those numbers that Sean went through, right? If if one or one to three percent is gonna say yes to the quote, well, what's your closing rate on an internet lead? Is that, you know, is that four percent? Well, shoot. So you're gonna get four percent of the one percent. So I mean, you've got to send out a lot of stuff, right? Or take a lot of leads. I mean, yeah, it's amazing. But but it really does come down just to the numbers, you know, and and depending on what systems you're using. Like we have a system that that works really well where we get good analytics, right? So, okay, we know where it's going, we know where the customer journey, where it ends up. We we we're looking at all these things, and it gives us a huge advantage over the guy down the street that's plugging his leads into an Xtel spreadsheet. Yeah right. And I mean, I know you've been doing this long enough, you've talked to enough agents where some of them, the Xtel spreadsheet is actually pretty good technology compared to, you know, like there's people with the paper, right? And you're like, dude, what? Like you can't get results that way.
SPEAKER_00I've got a client who he printed out, he's got a filing cabinet, and over the last 15 years, he's he prints out the lead and they're they're in alphabetical order. Well, at least they're alphabetized.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and and then he's why alphabetized.
SPEAKER_00And then yeah, and he's got them uh some of them by X date. He's got X date files, he's got alphabetical files.
SPEAKER_02So if you do sorry I'm laughing, but but it's like real world. Yeah, what's the benefit of alphabetizing some leads and putting them in a yeah? But that's but this is this is an important distinction. Is people will be will make themselves busy because they think that they're doing something that's that that is hey, hey, I was super busy today. What were you doing? Alphabetizing my printed out internet leads.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Well, what was the result of that? Well, they're in the they're now not on my desk, they're in the file cabinet, right? Like they're never gonna sell.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02And so, you know, focusing on doing the right activity to get to the desired result is what's important.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it all comes down to, like you said, the numbers and the data. And and most people don't have uh they don't have it. They, I mean, uh even your captive companies where you've got access to that type of information, uh, they still don't they don't know it. I mean, and and you have to know how many, you gotta know what your sales process is. How many times am I gonna call them? How many times um you know is it gonna take before I get the first uh appointment, how many follow-ups after that? You know, what does that real life sales process look like? And I think people just get a lead, they'll work it a couple times, and it's very arbitrary. Uh there's no they don't know that hey, the last 10 sales that we've done, we on average call them eight times to get the first appointment and four times after to close it. Like they so they just call it a few times, and I don't know, because it's Wednesday, decide this is not a good lead anymore and put it off. And and and it's kind of, you know, I I fought I felt a lot of the agency owners. There's so many agency owners that are disconnected, uh, they don't understand the day-to-day, uh, they don't they don't know really what the team's going through. Um, and so that that that boils down to lack of leadership. Like if your team doesn't have that, it's because you didn't provide it to them. Um, and unfortunately, I think a lot of the agency owners are run by team members, and they're the team members, I guess for lack of a better term, have their agents by the balls. It's hard to find good help, it's hard to get somebody licensed, and an agent would rather sit on dead weight that they know needs to go, but they don't want to go through the hassle of not having that person and having to hire somebody else, having a little extra workload and then going and finding and licensing somebody else. They would rather just sit on two, three team members that are marginal at best and then blame it on a lead provider and just figure, well, we just got to find the right lead provider. And these team members have been spoiled for the last 10, 15 years of I don't have to have a follow-up process, I don't have to learn how to sell. Why? Because they'll just buy another lead and I'll just get the the ones that are easy, layup deals. And if you actually look, I mean, I I think that insurance has all but lost any sort of sales mentality in the industry. Very much an order-taking industry and a bunch of people who really belong in customer service and or administrative somewhere, and they're not totally.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Our our sales meetings, we do we do one in the morning, we do one in the afternoon. I know Jason does that too, but we it's constant to talk about look, it doesn't matter who it is, they are focused on price. And and we have to convert their thinking to the way that we do it here because it's gonna help them, you know, it's gonna serve their need. But if if you don't do that, then it it it will always gravitate back to the order taking, right? Because that's the way that that's the way the prospect expects to be sold, and that's the way that they they've never been trade on sales, so that's the way that they sell, right? It's the perfect, the perfect marriage because they just do it the way that it's expected to be done. And everybody, you know, then and then you close three percent and you cry about it. And you know, in order to move the needle, you you you have to change that conversation. But they have to be passionate about it, they have to help, they have to recognize that every deal is gonna start the wrong way. Yeah, right. They're not gonna come to you and say, Hey, look, will you tell me the value that your company has? And uh, will you explain why I need higher coverages than I than the state minimum because I really hate insurance and and I and can you take longer? You know, it's just we're they're never gonna ask for the thing that we need to deliver. And so, you know, that's where the finesse and and it's training, like you it's constant training, constant. But then where where marketers like yourself and smart agents that that also are are good at at marketing by going to courses like yours uh can can benefit, is then you're finding the perfect avatar, right? You're you're looking for the ideal client who is gonna be more receptive to this way of thinking. You know, the the college kid with state minimum, that's gonna be a harder discussion. So why are we targeting them, right? The shotgun approach isn't the best way.
SPEAKER_00No, no, I mean you make some really good points. I think the what you said I kind of like the most is um you know they're they're buying on price and your agents are selling on price. And I think that's the that's the key, is that you can't fault the consumer for buying on price because that's what every company has ingrained into the consumer's brain is that all that matters is that we can save you 15%. That's that's that's what matters. And so that's what the consumer has been trained to believe is important. Um, but that's the industry's fault. And and you by yourself as an agent, you aren't going to have the power to change that because it's just too big of an industry. So you can only play that game to get them in front of you once you have the conversation, and then it's on you no longer to sell price. Um, you know, I I had a guy where uh working with a company that we can't mention, but he uh he says that you know these people are all focused on price, uh, all of the the leads are focused on price, and they're just not competitive. Um same company, I showed him the comments from um a campaign in his market with the same exact targeting, and a comment on the ad was somebody from Geico, and she said that she had switched to this other company who we were running the ads for um and was able to get towing. She was able to get um rental car coverage and went from a thousand dollar to uh a uh $500 deductible. And she said it only cost her $20 more a month, and so that she went publicly and like said this on the ad. And so I was like, you know, this is somebody yeah, who who specifically said that she was excited to pay more because she got rental car coverage, which she didn't have, she got towing, which she didn't have, and she had a $500 deductible now instead of a thousand, and she was stoked about that. So obviously that agent sold them correctly, versus you you see that they're with Geico and they're paying less, and you're like, Oh, well, I'm 30% more, I'm not gonna sell this. And I've even I've heard people we have recorder phone conversations at some of these sales calls, and an agent literally said when they quoted it before they delivered the number to the customer, like, oh man, this is a terrible rate. I mean, yeah, like what are we doing?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. There's that's it's unacceptable, right? That to and but that's a lack of training, and the fish rots from the head. So if the leader isn't if this isn't part of the company culture, then it's never gonna change, right? And it starts with those meetings. You gotta have those meetings in the morning, you gotta have the meetings in the afternoon. I just got a uh a message in our messaging system from one of my guys. He said, I just got a sale off build-a-wall moving somebody from 2550 to 25,500. It just came on my other screen. And it's like, you know, that was more, right? But he created the need by asking the right questions and put them in the right situation. And and it by design, it gets them a little pissed off at their current company, right? Because it's like, well, you have a big gap. What are you doing? And so here he is, just moved him. So I can't wait to get that call.
SPEAKER_00They buy what you sell. They buy what you sell. So if you sell price, they're gonna buy price. If you sell value, they're gonna buy value.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, 100%. So what tell us tell us about I'm sorry, man. I cut you off.
SPEAKER_00I was just saying, most agents don't want to talk about sales, they don't want to hear that there's a sales problem. It's a lead problem. Always, always have them. Right.
SPEAKER_02It's blaming the wrong thing. Yeah. Because the yeah, the leads, the leads are the leads. It's a name with a number and they have cars and they need insurance. I mean, it doesn't change. That's what they're doing. There's no Glenn Gary Glenn Ross leads here. So let's talk, let's talk about your program. Do you so do you do you have you have a uh course that that tells people how to design ads or is the is yeah, yeah, we've got um you know we have a ton of courses, you know.
SPEAKER_00Um last year or maybe 18 months ago, I really uh am not as involved with the the coaching side as I used to be. Um it's more digital products at this point. I don't spend a whole lot of time actually teaching people um how to do it. Um the courses are there. The you know, if you can read an instruction manual, you can learn how to do it. Um you know we have a marketing agency now, we work all based on retainer, and we basically do everything for the agents. Um, we just found a lot better success that way because you know, if an agent is trying to learn how to run campaigns and learn the whole marketing thing, it it changes so fast. I mean, like there's times where I'll put out a program and two, three days after everything changed and I gotta re-record the whole thing. So it's like it's it's changing so often uh right now that it's really tough to keep up with if marketing's not your full-time gig. Um and so we um you know we we more focused on our retainer clients and uh for those that you know we still have you know, I don't know, maybe a hundred or hundred and fifty people still paying for the digital product access, but it's not coaching anymore per se.
SPEAKER_02Okay. Well, cool. So how Sean, how do people find you or or where what which what should we put in the show notes that uh yeah?
SPEAKER_00I mean, if you want to learn more about what we do at the marketing agency, just go to surefiredigitalmedia.com. Um, and then uh you can check out uh insurance leadgenie.com as well. Uh and learn more about the automation tools and some of the websites and stuff that we do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, there's a lot of good groups out there um that you guys can join. But do you guys have a Facebook group? We do. Yeah. Uh join their Facebook group. Uh just get plugged in, man. Uh, that's what I would say. Um stay away from groups where there's a lot of trash talking and nonsense going on. Uh, but there's a lot of productive insurance groups that are out there. Um I be careful with with what where you put your money. The one thing I'd say about this industry is there's a lot of there's a lot of trapdoors, um, there's a lot of uh fluff. Um, you know, there's a lot of regurgitated material these days going around. Um, so really just kind of check out the source, um, you know, and you'd be surprised at what you can learn for free. Um, I'm all about max maximizing, you know, what you're able to do to you know, just learn the platforms, learn the audience, see what's available. It's really not hard to do. It really is not hard to do if you want to invest the time. Uh, I personally would say delegation is key. Uh, just like you can't be on every sales call, just hire somebody out, man. Hire an accountant, don't waste time doing your books. Uh, hire good salespeople, hire service people, uh, hire a marketing company, and hire lawyers. Don't don't mess with that stuff so that you can focus working on the business and try not to work in the business if you're in a position that you can do that. Train your staff, get rid of dead weight, and focus on low-hanging fruit. Love it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, love it, Sean. You basically answered the final question.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Which is what advice would you get? What's the one piece of advice? And that there you go. That was that was all the advice.
SPEAKER_00All of it. That's all you need. Yeah, don't complicate it, man. Just you know, think of what I would say is think of uh uh you know, I try to put put an analogy in anything. So you know, if you look at uh sending an email, that's the equivalent of a mailer. Like however your brain currently operates, if you're a mailer, if you're a cold caller, or if you're a live transfer person, like whatever it is that you do to generate your business, um, there's a corresponding digital way to do that. And it's not that digital's better, it's just a little bit more efficient and cost effective. You know, a friend request is like bumping into somebody and it's a virtual handshake at a networking event. You know, uh a message is like an elevator pitch. If you if you message somebody on Facebook, you know, if you um you know look at the recommendations, uh it's a great place to go. Um, you know, sending an email is is like sending a physical mail, it's just a virtual mailbox. Uh, you know, a video message, that's like a cold call. So if you can get that in front of a thousand people, you just made a thousand sales calls. You're probably gonna get hung up on and deleted and moved on by most of them, but your video is there forever, and every time it's played, it's a new sales call uh to your audience. And so just kind of think in terms of that and and look at how you can expand what you're already doing um by using technology and and different tools like that.
SPEAKER_02That's awesome. There's such a huge, there's such huge value in that list, right? In your list, and um we buy all these leads, right? All these leads, whether it's Facebook leads or YouTube leads or or internet leads or whatever, right? But we have the email. And so we're developing a list, and then it it will just sit over there. And it's such a huge thing to take advantage of because you're like you said, I mean you blast out a hundred thousand emails, you're gonna get one percent. And so huge value there. So th Sean, thanks so much for coming on. Really good to meet you. Thanks, guys. Appreciate it. Anthony told me to say hi.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Awesome.
SPEAKER_03Cool, man. Yeah, that was awesome. Great advice um throughout the whole time. So that that was thank you.
SPEAKER_02Really good to meet you, man, and I'll see you on the uh on the Facebook.
SPEAKER_03Cool. Thanks, guys. All right, John. Thank you. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talk in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman