The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
The Blanch Check For Specializing, Saving Time, And MUST Mentoring.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Buckle up, it's the Intern Podcast.
unknownBoom!
SPEAKER_00Boom! Greg! Oh, he does it.
SPEAKER_04Look at that lighthouse right there.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Is that right by is that right near you?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, guys, that's like 10 minutes from my office.
SPEAKER_02That's out the back window?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean I'm I'm literally I could drive down the road, it's a mile away. It's right down the street. Cool. Nice. Famous Jupiter Lighthouse.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_04And you're in Jupiter, Florida. Yeah, I'm kind of on the border. So if you think about like Fort Lauderdale is here, then you've got Boca Ratone, West Palm Beach, where Mr. Trump is, and then Jupiter is about 15 minutes from that. And then Jupiter Island, where all the super, super uber wealthy people live, is five minutes north of that Tiger Woods and all those big, big, big money.
SPEAKER_02So it's Tiger, nice, and Trump.
SPEAKER_04Correct.
SPEAKER_02Right in the sandwich in between. Right in the middle of the big ballers. There you go. That's awesome. Nice. Well, Greg Blanchard, welcome to the insurance dudes. We have to start with the most important question. What was the first concert you went to? All the way back.
SPEAKER_04This is a good one. This is a really good one. So the first concert I ever went to was down at the Hollywood Sportatorium down in Hollywood. And back in those days, um, you know, I was probably 14. I snuck into a rush concert with my oh yeah. It was the 2112 concert back in that day. Nice at the Hollywood Sportatorium. That's where I first got the smell of what marijuana smelled like. Because everybody at the concert was high except for me, and I was 14, but right.
SPEAKER_00And then you were.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so if you think about like the Hard Rock Cafe where the Super Bowl was, like none of that existed when I grew up. If you went, you know, west of I-95, it was all pretty much Everglades. And the only thing that they had out there was the Hollywood Sportatorium where it was so loud and it was a great venue, um, that it took probably 40 minutes to get there, but it was the only, you know, it was out in the boonies back in those days. So none of that existed. Yeah, Weston's, you know, all those different cities you see out there, Miami Stadium, none of that existed when I grew up.
SPEAKER_00Crazy.
SPEAKER_02Crazy. Rush concert around well, I don't know, early late 80s. So it was like uh 1982. No. What? Oh, that was your yours was? Yeah. Mine must have been late 80s because Presto was after 2112, right? Yeah. Yeah. I went to Presto. I got free tickets. Somebody just said, does anybody want a ticket? And we're like, yeah. We were trying to buy tickets, and some guy just gave it to us. And went into the forum. That's right. Fabulous forum in LA.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it was awesome, man. So uh I know we just lost you know the greatest drummer in the history of mankind last month, and Neil Pertz. That was kind of tough for me to take, but he was my he's kind of my hero. I always looked you know up to him as being one of the best musicians that I'd ever heard, you know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, he was a machine. A machine.
SPEAKER_02Well, Jason's a drummer.
SPEAKER_00I am. Yeah, used to be more so than I am now, but right on.
SPEAKER_04Don't ever give up that passion, man. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I did. I did. I gave it up for a long time, and I started playing at church, and and I did that up until the fourth kid, where my wife's like, if you have one second of freedom, you gotta be here. I said, Okay.
SPEAKER_04She put the smack down on you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. Four kids is a lot.
SPEAKER_04Don't tell me about kids. I have six.
SPEAKER_00Oh wow. That's rough.
SPEAKER_04That was my oldest that just came in here. So what ages are your kids? Yeah. Uh let's see. I've got 29, 25, 23. Um, one's gonna be 18 in a couple days.
SPEAKER_00Nice.
SPEAKER_0415. And then my daughter, my seven-year-old, today's her birthday, Eliana. So she turned seven today.
SPEAKER_00Oh, it's awesome. Seven.
SPEAKER_04So you got a whole nother level. Three in the house and three out of the house. And I just got a new puppy today that my wife had purchased. So we have three dogs, two goldfish, and a hamster. So I'm pretty much running the zoo down here.
SPEAKER_02I got conned into a rabbit the other day. A rabbit. There's a rabbit at our house now.
SPEAKER_00Oh man.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00I don't want any pets right now. Well, I'm in the danger zone. We have a what a uh less than a one-year-old, two-year-old, four and an eight-year-old. Five and eight-year-old. Right? I don't know. I don't know, but two of them are in diapers, and it's it's a lot of work right now. But uh we'll be out of the danger zone too soon.
SPEAKER_03Heck yeah. It doesn't work, but I'm using my other one, so test.
SPEAKER_00Yes. We should all have our coffee mugs too.
SPEAKER_02I know, man.
SPEAKER_03I don't have my coffee mug.
SPEAKER_02Well, why but for those that don't know you or haven't met you, and you've been all over the place in a certain carrier, uh, but uh you know, how did you get into insurance? What brought you to this world? Why?
SPEAKER_04How? So it's a pretty funny story, actually. So um I started Scratch in 2007, and the way that I got to this particular industry was this is no lie, I was out on my boat um in the summer of 2007, and I was I had my kids on the boat. We have a place out here called Peanut Island. So when the tide goes out, it exposes the sandbar. And I Craig and I are friends and on Facebook, I think Jason is too, but you guys have probably seen us where the sandbar gets exposed, and everybody's just out there having a good time with dogs and and and drinks, and we have a good time out there. So um it it gets pretty pretty busy out there. So my son went out and uh was walking around the island, and I guess ran into this this other um, you know, this kid that was was on a little life raft that had a had like a cow on it, and they were riding this life raft with the cow around, and this dad was pulling it around. So my one son jumped on there, they became very friendly with the kids. The the dad came over and had a had a bear and said, Hey, my name is Lance, and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. You know, nice to meet you. Um, long story short, I I met you know, his wife, who's Trish, who happens to be a captive agent in my business. And uh, long story short, we got along really, really well. We became very, very good friends. We went out to an award seminar out in um over at the cove in the Bahamas, and they just so happened, I was celebrating my anniversary, and I they just so happened to have one of those award ceremonies out at the cove in the Bahamas, and these guys were in the pool, and I'm rolling up on some of these guys. You know, Iggy was there and Domingo was there, so all these cats are inside this pool supporting these cool watches and those Miami product glasses. I'm like, man, what these guys are rolling, you know, what do these guys do? So Trisha was kind of telling me that they're the insurance business and they're agents, and you know, my mom had worked for uh State Farm for 28 years, and um, you know, I knew about the insurance business, but I didn't want to be a guy that you know was in his khakis all day long, not ever going to work playing golf. That wasn't me. So kind of more of a high adrenaline junkie. So kind of fast forward, um, you know, my friend Trish said, Hey, you know, you should get involved in the insurance business. I've got this recruiter I should have you talk to. You know, she's gonna show you the plan, right? Just like when somebody in the old days wants to show you the Amway plan, you get a little nervous, right? Yeah, right? Yeah, I got a plan. Come do one of these events, right? So she basically set up a meeting with this, with uh, with one of these managers, and she actually told me the plan, said this was a great opportunity, and said you need to fill out this particular application, then we'll we'll see if we can bring you on. Uh 60 days later, I took my uh 215 license and I've got my I took my 220 license in early 60 days. I got both of those licenses, and I was open 30 days after that. So that's kind of how I got the insurance business, really, really quick.
SPEAKER_00Well, what were you doing before that?
SPEAKER_04So I had just sold my real estate business at the time. I had seven real estate offices with my brother. We had a franchise out of Reno, Nevada cut us called Assist to Cell, and that was a franchise um product. There was over 900 locations, and at that time in the real estate business, um, you could throw a sign, you know, in the yard and sell a house. You guys probably remember that Phoenix was a pretty hot bed out there in California. Some of the warmer climates were just you could you have multiple offices on property, and it was in the heyday, like 2000 to 2005. And I was in the real estate business, and um, you know, we did really, really well. I had sold, you know, my part of the business to a competitor, took some time off. Um, my mom, unfortunately, had passed away in in 2006 of Lou Gehrick's disease, and I just I needed to kind of clear my head. I went through a divorce and um just really was trying to find my path. And um, if it wasn't for the fact that my mom had left me some funds through her life insurance policy, you know, I wouldn't be sitting here as an agency owner of four offices today because you know, a portion of that money went into bankrolling this business that has been very, very good to me and my family. So I kind of indirectly got into the insurance business, but um, that's kind of how I got in the insurance business directly was you know, meeting this particular agent um who's a very, very close friend of mine who's a very successful you know agency owner. She kind of got me into the business in 2007. I basically started from scratch.
SPEAKER_00Wow. So you started with one office from scratch, uh months after even considering it, right?
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_00So what was the take me through? I I love the the first year stories because we all have just those pains and like, what the hell am I doing? Right?
SPEAKER_04Oh my god, it was a complete train wreck. And my particular captive, um, their educational system was so I would say outdated at the time. Was um a little bit, a little outdated. Um so I went through the entire process and um they told me I need to do this, this, and this with all these different types of marketing um, you know, programs. And I thought to myself, that doesn't make a lot of sense to me. So for the first 10 months, I kind of ran my agency by myself for the first 10 months with no employees. I didn't have any employees. I didn't have number one the money to fund an employees, and I had no idea what I was doing. And at that time, we were on enhanced um commission program, it was a different type of program than it is today. But um, I think I sold 12 auto items in four months. That's all I sold. Ooh, lighting it up. Killing it.
SPEAKER_02Um just killing it. I just I had no clue. They're really happy.
SPEAKER_04My 12 customers are just yeah, I mean, so I sold 12 auto policies, but literally the first day that I was open, I had an English woman come into my office and say, Hey, you sold insurance, you know, I need to buy a condo policy, but it's a seasonal residence for me. I'm only there three months out of the year. Now, you guys got to understand in Florida, you know, we we have 15 different carriers that we write through, and we have a maze, a myriad of things that we go through to try to be able to even write a freaking policy. And because we're in the wind pool and you have to deal with the fare plan, I had to write it through two separate carriers. I'm trying to call my captive. Obviously, they can't help me because well, we we don't we can't help you because that's not our product. So it was a complete train wreck, guys. I mean, as bad as it could be bad could be is how kind of I started my first day in the business.
SPEAKER_02How long did it take you to write that condo?
SPEAKER_04Probably three hours. And I had to I had to rely on a senior um uh agent who was gracious enough to help me because I had no idea what I was doing. And she said, you know, you need to write this and this, this, and this, but you know, you have to put the wind mitigation discounts in the policy, and you have to put the form, and oh, and that's only for the wind policy. If you want to write the hazard policy, that's a separate policy. Completely had no idea what I was doing. I think I sold like an $1,800 policy for a condo policy. I I hope it was right. I mean, she seemed like a really nice lady.
SPEAKER_00You know, uh and uh uh that that story that's there's always a similar story to that. Um it just some people are still living in that story where they don't get over that hump. But man, those are the those are the times that really teach you uh how to do this game is to get your top bashed in. It's never the smooth sailing. I've known agents that have walked into offices that were running pretty smooth. Um they've been around for like 30 years, they get in the office, but they don't learn anything, and the thing just slowly starts. It's a slowly sinking ship, but they came in so smoothly that they never had to learn um how to even sell a policy, really. It's you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, for sure. I'm right there with you guys, 100%.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I love that. So then take us through that. So when was the aha moment uh you know, when you went from selling 12 items in four months to um start actually cranking?
SPEAKER_04The the thing about it was that it it was very humbling for me, is because I was so excited, you know, I had my office set up, I knew where all these people were gonna sit. Um, I thought the phones were gonna ring. My first day, I mean, in those days, we didn't Facebook wasn't there was no Facebook, right? I remember the people that I graduated with, you know, I was the one that set up a conference call with everybody to kind of keep in touch. That was kind of my my Facebook group, but I'm a telephone, you know. I think I used the free conference calling platform, you know, they gave me some, you know, area code of five, six, you know, three, whatever the area code number was, to make these free conference calls. But that is the way I started to learn how everybody was doing things in the early days. Um, I would literally lock my door and go outside of my office and go visit real estate people that I had done business with. I had um real estate agents that worked for me that went on to become real estate brokers. And that's kind of where I started the vendor relationships. And I thought to myself, okay, there's gotta be a better way to build this business than to send direct mail and a cold call. So that was the antithesis of how I started, you know, finding those strategic relationships and being able to build my business with a very, very low ROI. And um, so I remember calls would come into my cell phone and I would, you know, be in my car and you know, try to take the information down to do a quote. But all I was doing in the first literally uh four months was getting outside the office and knocking on doors and going to every single real estate function I could go to, meeting, um, MLS, um, you know, lunch and learn, everything that I could do to educate myself because agents in my captive, they weren't gonna share anything with me at all. I mean, I would call these other agents up and say, hey, this I'm new on the block and I'm trying, I'm struggling with this. And they're like, sorry, I, you know, there's nothing I can do for you. Maybe try, you know, direct mail, like the company says, or cold call. So in those days, I mean, nobody was willing to help me. So I had to kind of figure it all out, you know, on my own. And it was it was a very, very hard time for me. But I think the resilience that I built, just like you hear when people that come up, they're from the projects or a broken home, you know, that grit mentality, I knew that I could sell anything to everybody and I had the gift of gab. So I knew if I kind of just stayed the course with that, things would kind of turn over. And then in my 10-month, I finally hired my first employee. And my first employee came from actually the gal who got me into the business that said, Hey, listen, I got an application from this gal. She has some experience with state farm, but I just I can't put her on right now because I'm I'm too full of people. So I took her, and uh, she is the one that kind of helped shape my business for the next 10 years after that because she know she knew more about insurance than I could possibly ever know. And she she had two years of experience, so I didn't know you know my ass for my elbow then.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_02And how quickly did you realize that okay, I I need to get people in here because if I keep doing this myself, I'm gonna go crazy.
SPEAKER_04So once I could afford to uh bring an employee on, and I saw what happened in 30 days from having a process in place with another individual, that I thought to myself, okay, I literally had her screen to screen right across from me, like you and I are looking at in front of me. She didn't know how to sell, but she sure could, you know, service and knew the language. So I knew that if I could teach her how to sell like all the things I've sold throughout my lifetime and give her the gift of gab through a transfer of influence and coach her right in front of me, I knew I could replicate replicate myself every 30 days. So um after I had her, literally 30 days after that, I put three more associates on, and we were four strong for the next probably two and a half years.
SPEAKER_00Nice. Awesome. Wow. So what um during that time as you're growing, what were some of the I mean, I I think another another struggle is when you start getting employees and you don't, especially when you're new in the business, you start getting employees and you're like, I don't know what's the best use of their time and my time, and like kind of figuring out that structure. Was that difficult?
SPEAKER_04Well, I think once I started to get some momentum and um I had the ability to find the tools that I needed to be successful, I kind of leaned on some people that were senior agents that finally kind of opened up because we started to get some traction. And I originally started organically with all of us servicing everything, but I think I was one of the first agents in my marketplace to say, okay, I've got this girl that's gonna only do service, and then you know, myself, you know, Diane and Loretta are gonna sell. So there were three of us selling and one of us serving at that particular time. So that was a very new idea back in 2007, 2008, because I didn't know anybody was doing that. Everybody was a hybrid agency. So I thought to myself, you know, I came from the real estate business and I know mortgage companies. Mortgage companies have got a loan officer and they have a processor. The loan officer is the rainmaker, right? And then the processor is the one that's kind of cultivating the crop, right? Making sure that everything's okay, and they're very process-driven. So at a at an early time in my career, we kind of broke a broke from that mold and started running in that direction. And that's kind of what was the game changer for me was converting from the way people were doing things traditionally to a um a very structured, specialized agency. And then when it got to the point where it was very specialized in our market, I separated so Laritza started to do auto and Diane and I started to do homes because our average home premium in Florida in those days, after the hurricanes and after our carrier shut down, our average premium was like $3,600 a policy for hurricane coverage. So I was like, you know what, let me go and chase those big ticket items. And at that, that those times the auto wasn't really much, but I thought, wow, if I could start to build my book of business with some big, big premiums, you know, I'll get to where I need to be. And um, that's kind of how I built that business organically with um with built, I built it on, you know, I some one of the old agents said to me, you know, the best way to get into the home is through the garage, and that's the house. So that's kind of how I built my business right there.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome.
SPEAKER_02And it made it worth your time because the commissions are actually such that it's worth doing that, right? So that that's awesome. And in a lot of states where you know we can do that and the the premium is 500, then we have to get pretty creative about how we acquire that new business and and you know who we have doing that. I love the specialization though, putting the somebody on auto and somebody is do is that something that's prevalent in Florida or not really unless you have a larger agency.
SPEAKER_04Um most people in Florida have people selling all lines, but uh guys, I tell you, it's it's it's a beast in Florida with all the regulations that we have and kind of the nuances that have to do with hurricane coverage. Um I have found that it cripples somebody to try to get them to do all lines. I couldn't imagine having a successful agency where people did home, auto, flood, you know, all the lines of insurance, and then also having to service their books. I just don't think you'll get the the um the production out of your people if they're not specialized.
SPEAKER_02Right. You're taken away from their ability to sell.
SPEAKER_04For sure, for sure. That's just the way I see it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm lazy. Like I'm that's what we do in our agency, and it made it so much. I'm like, we were all doing everything and trying to figure it out. I mean, I remember writing a business policy, and it literally took me eight hours, and it was a maybe a $600 policy. I said, That's it, we're never doing business. I'm not allowing anyone to do business. We're literally just focusing on the and then once we started really the more narrow we got, the more productive we got. Uh because yeah, no, I mean, how can you expect somebody to do all that?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, guys, I say this all the time to my team listen, you're never gonna send a cardiologist to do Dental surgery. You're not gonna do that, right?
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_04I mean, you gotta specialize. And that's when I found out that I had some people that were super, super strong, you know, with the auto stuff because it's very, very quick and um it's very transactional. I hate to do it to say that when it really isn't, we really do things a little bit differently. But I think the sales cycle is completely different in in my market, you know, between an auto person and somebody that's auto renter, motorcycle boat, and somebody that's consulting with a home policy because there's a lot more moving parts that go into that consultation.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. When they come and and then when the auto pol, when the auto prospect comes to you, it most certainly is at least at the forefront of their mind a transaction. Right? This is gonna be a transaction, we need to do it quick. And so whether or not you have the process to slow it down, uh, you know, is is really critical, and then move that into you know, get it over to your home person or get it over to the flood person. But I love how it's broken up into specialties because then you have you know, this, you know, you have all the different pillars in your agency. Yeah, that works for me.
SPEAKER_04I you know, other agents you know in Florida might run it differently, but I've beaten up the idea so many different times. We we first tried to have people all sell lines and it was just broken and we couldn't get to our numbers. And it was funny, last year in in uh in March, I went over to the West Coast to see Kevin Greenwell and Jeff East. And you know, those guys, I mean, those guys walk on water. I mean, those guys are some incredible agency owners. They come from a really, really good lineage of um of training, and and they're so grateful and they're humble. But they said, Greg, why are you doing it that way? Why don't you just have your guys sell all lines of insurance? It's one relationship that capture all the information, and everything is great. But you know, the West Coast, Naples area, those guys are just kind of everything's unicorns and rainbows out there. You come to the East Coast, you know, Palm Beach, Boca Ratone, you're talking people from New Jersey, New York, things are fast. Miami, you got a bunch of scammers down there, so you never know what you're gonna get, you know. So I came back here, I tried it for 60 days, it wrecked my business, and that's why we didn't get to where we needed to be the year before last, because I changed it up and tried to have everybody selling all lines in Florida. It just didn't work, so I'll never go back to selling all lines again in Florida, I promise you.
SPEAKER_02Isn't it funny? Like you can you you can be just clicking along, going everything's going great, and some idea comes along, and you're like, you know what, we'll try that. When all you had to do was just pour gas on this fire over here because it was working, you know. We get either bored or complacent, or I don't know what it is, you know, like this could be better. It's like, no, this already is better. Let's put money on this thing, right? Yeah, man.
SPEAKER_04I mean, my shop has never been an internet lead shop. I'm not one of those agency owners that has, you know, 12 guys ready on the phone to do, you know, live transfers and close and then just grow. I we're not like that. Our our business runs so much differently than that. We've tried to get into that space, but we've just never been able to, you know, um cap double down on that whole process. You know, direct mail all day long. Relationships, center resilient influence. I can I can run with the best of them. But the internet lead game has never been one that's it's bared a lot of fruit for us. And I've tried that game so many different times. I've got a lot of big megas out there like me that rely on that type of business to to grow, but I've just never been able to implement that in the way we do business. So it's everybody runs their shot differently.
SPEAKER_00Florida, right? I mean, is that what you're gonna say?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, everything I've heard from a lead standpoint is Florida is just brutal. It's so saturated. Yeah, I guess.
SPEAKER_04I I mean that I talk some Texas, is as you guys know, is a huge market. And I talked to my buddy Justin Slocum out in Texas, and the guy spends a ton of money on internet leads and direct mail, but in those markets, they have house and auto together. So they're probably picking up house auto. That's probably three items, and maybe an umbrella policy, which is a fourth item. So if you got you know a guy writing 60 items a month, I can see where that could happen. If in Florida, yeah, I guys could sell everything on the same paper. I mean, we would average probably 60, 70 items a producer, but the reality of the situation is it just it just doesn't happen that way. So it's you gotta really get, you know, like you guys said before, Jason, I thought you get to get kicked in the teeth a couple times to understand what you're really, really good at and what you're not good at.
SPEAKER_00And what you like doing. I think this is a a good point that you see a lot of people all over the internet selling incredible numbers, but we're all in different markets, and it's really important for everybody to realize like, don't feel bad, don't compare yourself to somebody else, um, especially in this business, because there's there are there's so many ways to make it happen, but really get to know your market, get to know which direction works for you. Um, and don't beat yourself up over it. Because I I I I think that. I mean, when I first got into this, I was I beat myself up. I was in your spot where it's like I couldn't sell more than I mean, we had an eight, we had like three people in the office, including well, two other people including myself. We couldn't sell more than like 12 items a month. And I was working 12 hour days. Um, I couldn't even get, and I always tell people this, I couldn't get my own mom to sign up for eight months. Eight months. And I'm like, dude, I need policies.
SPEAKER_02How important is that, right? True.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but it's like, yeah, there's you know, try like we we and I love talking to so many people that come on here, and there's so many different ways that it works for people, and especially with personality types and stuff. Uh but I I I really want to stress to everybody that's listening or watching that dude, don't beat yourself up. Like there's different ways to do it, and if it doesn't work in your area, it doesn't work, it's not a big deal.
SPEAKER_02Well, you know, and even even the stuff that is working doesn't always work. The things run, you know. I mean, yeah, you gotta hang in there.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, one of my mentors, I told him I was jumping on this call before, um, and he said to me, he's like, Don't ever chase what your captive wants you to do. Take care of what's underneath your feet, right? Because that's what really is the most important. He said, You have an amazing group of friends, you have an amazing family, you have an amazing business. If you're not on the leaderboard, that doesn't matter, doesn't mean you're not the most profitable. Hell, these guys could be on the leader leaderboard and they could be bleeding cash or they could be very, very successful, but you have to measure your success, you know, based on what your goals are with your team, and that's everything that you can control. So that kind of hit home with me today because our numbers came out for last for the for the year to date, and we got some cat down in Miami writing 1300 autos, just autos in three months.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_04406, that's 406 autos a month. That's right.
SPEAKER_00But to your point, it's expensive. Like, yeah, yeah. You where are you gonna check the metrics out? Because if somebody's not spending as much as me, they're making more, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_04It's like it's all relevant. There are I I know this agent personally, he's spending $75,000 a month in marketing. You know, our budget like our budget right now is $9,000 a month, and we're writing about $225,000 in premium. That's a pretty good ROI in my book. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Oh, yeah. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_02You you it it's what comfort level do you have with that cash going out? I get to this point where it's like at about 20, yeah, I'm like, I okay. I'm getting nervous because if I you know, it's all you you you can pay, you can pay on the Amex, you can pay wherever, and then you have 30 days and you get it, you usually get it back. I mean, typically it comes back and it comes back more, but man, when you hit a dip, it's like oh change your whole year. You know, it'll change your whole year. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00What is some of the hardest? Oh, sorry.
SPEAKER_02I was just there's so many moving parts with the staff, something could go wrong. Sometimes those those outliers, the best producers, are doing something goofy and you have to get rid of them, and then you know, so it just it just there's there's so many moving parts, and you got to keep your eye on that ball.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I I I had a buddy that's just put something on Facebook the other day that said, Hey, I've got this independent agency and this and that. I'm over here. And I'm like, dude, you did you get smoked? You know, I had no idea. These people like are like Phoenix, they come from up the ashes out of nowhere, and they were doing things they shouldn't have been doing, you know. So I'm not judge, jury, or any executioner. It just it sometimes when the numbers are too sounds too too good to be true, it usually is.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah. Yeah. What um what were some of the hardest struggles that you've had through the throughout the last what 13 years that you've been doing this?
SPEAKER_04Probably the top of my list is um trying to understand that I'm the people that work for me are never gonna want it as much as I want it for them as they want it for themselves. You know what I mean? So I just want it for these people more than they want it for themselves. And yes, you know, I I think I think that's the biggest struggle. I think all of us have the same talent pool, you know, um problems that we always have. I, you know, from me to you guys and everybody that's listening, I don't know if I can count on one hand the people I have on my sales department have been here more than three years. You know, they're like they're like they're like a running back. It's like getting Emmett Smith and letting that guy run for you for six years, then you burn him out. That's just that's the reality of our situation. And my longest tenured employees um are my sales manager, my operations manager, and uh my customer service manager. You know, their tenure has been with me on average of of nine years. So it's hard to find that good talent and get people to buy into what you do because let's face it, a lot of people don't think insurance is exciting, right? It's not Gary Vee and it's not Grant Cardone, it's insurance. You know, you're selling vaporware, so it's hard to be able to get people excited about those times of things. But but you can see right now what's going on in our business, the residual factor, you couldn't take me out of this place tomorrow if you asked me to, or give me, you know, a four-time multiple, because the four times multiple is great, but this is a legacy business that I hope to bring in, you know, my kids so they can finally try what they want to do, and they say, you know what, dad's got a pretty good gig, it's residual. You know, no matter what happens with us, the competition, everybody's in the kind of the same stream. There's never going to be a replacement for people that want to do business with each other. And uh that's why I think the insurance business is such a great business. But yeah, the talent, the hiring is the most you know, difficult um part of our business.
SPEAKER_02Well, you see all the other businesses in different industries now, they all are trying to model some sort of subscription business, right? The gym, the you know, everything is a the car washes. I mean, you go to the car wash, they want to sell you on the pay 30 bucks a month or whatever, so you keep coming back, and then you never go, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, my son owns a mobile detailing business. I mean, luckily, every time I sell an auto policy, I give away a free car wash to his business. So I mean, it's a good business, right? So he's got an embedded business, but you know, he's on a subscription program. My best friend owns three car washes. You talk about a place that prints cash, those places are cash flow heavy. But he's on a subscription-based business. He knows down to the droplet what his profit is because he's such a good um integrator in the business, right? And the subscription-based model is gonna be a winner as long as you price it correctly. You give the customer what they want and you provide exceptional customer service. And he does all of those, and everything this guy touches turns to gold. So he helps me with my son's mobile business and they work together. So it's a it's a that's a very good point about the subscription place model using them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, how huge is that? As this is a big nugget, actually, because you can link up with a car wash place and because everybody gets their car washed, right? And they there's an incentive for them to even discount it because then they're gonna take a swing at selling their subscription, right? It's like free marketing.
SPEAKER_04Yep, so that's why my one of my staff members on Saturdays goes into this car wash and has his computer there and does quotes right there and gives away a free car wash the next time they come in. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_02Drop and pop that marketing nugget.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome. Um, go going back to hiring a little bit. So, where where okay, and I think everybody's well, I know everybody struggles with the same thing. How do you approach your hiring now?
SPEAKER_04So we're all friends here, and uh you know, Dave Williams is a good friend of mine. His group hiring approach changed the business for me. I will never do a one-on-one interview again, ever.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_04I won't. Because the amount of time, see, I've got a operations manager that you know will put out the ad, he'll call the prospect, he'll set up you know the interview process, it'll waste an hour of my not waste, it'll use an hour of my sales manager's time. 30% of the time he'll get ghosted. I think we've all been there and done that. Even when we hire these people, they ghost us. So that's it's just the strangest phenomenon, and everybody knows that that's kind of been the theme over the past probably three to four years, I'd probably say, since the market's been so good and job um unemployment is so so low. But you know, we did we started uh, yeah, it was. We started the um the group hiring back in January. And um, I was a little skeptical at first, but once I got the hang of it, you know, I can pitch and pivot and I can present with the best of them. So when I did those first three interviews on a Monday night, a Tuesday night, and then a Friday afternoon, I will never hire another way again because it gives you the ability to have between nine and 12 individuals inside your office at the same time and just ask softball questions and find out, you know, which one's gonna kind of jump out of their skin to ask and answer those questions. It doesn't necessarily mean they're the best producers, but it's all part of the process. And then um after that, you know, we send out your assessment that I use religiously because it's such a great tool. So little little props on that product because it's um we won't bring anybody in unless they scored between um a nine point or ninety to 90, 90 points or 96, something like that. That's we won't take anybody less than a 90. So, and only maybe out of 10 people we'll just get one person that scores high on that scale. But that's a very good um barometer of who we're gonna bring in and sit down. And after that, I'd say if we get 45 people in, we'll have um eight to ten assessments, and then we'll probably have three candidates that we bring in or four, and we'll usually hire 50% of those because if they go through the entire process, there's a lot of different things we put them through in order for them to even come into the interview process. So it's almost like if you're gonna make this career, you have to get your license, you have to go into the training platform, and you have to take the assessment, and you have to bring in 25 deck pages. So if you can't do any of that, we don't even hire you.
SPEAKER_02Isn't it interesting though? It's so hard to get them to even show up, and then you make it so difficult for them to get through, so they have to get through this gauntlet. But when they do, they're freaking good. You got a rock star, dude.
SPEAKER_04Like the the the I still have the two people that I had from the group interview process that are still here. Yep. It's only been since January, but hey, that's a long time in our business.
SPEAKER_02I did uh I did a great group interview in November, and we I still have I hired five, I still have four of them. That's amazing. You know, it's just and I needed them, man. It was like two, and then pickings out there, guys.
SPEAKER_04It's slim pickings.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it is. Yeah, yeah, it's the only way to maximize your your your time. Your time's valuable. Why would you do one-on-ones where honestly out here it's one out of three, like literally it's one out of three that show up to the interview. If like that's pretty good, one out of three.
SPEAKER_04You've got to have 60 applicants to get to one. Yeah, but I think what'll happen is after the cycle goes through, I think we're gonna see a lot of candidates that are scratching their head and saying, you know what, maybe I'm wanting to get in a stable career, you know? Yeah, maybe show them and expose them to our business and say, hey, you know, we've never shut down and I've never lost an employee. I I guaranteed all of my 17 people that work for me. I guaranteed everybody that we weren't gonna lay off a single individual and we haven't done it. So that staying power will bring us some momentum that totally add to our team down the road.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_02I had this talk with I keep it. No, no, no, we did it as well. And I think he had the same talk uh with with the team. It's like, look, you guys are safe. Don't freak out, just just let's keep getting results. And and we found the contact ratio's gone up. I mean, we were at at 8 to 12 percent before this. Now we're up we're north of 24 percent on contact ratio. So it's it's actually good that people are home.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you can thrive anytime anything's shaken up, you can thrive because everybody's out of their uh comfort zone. Everything's they're not busy because they're constantly doing the same thing that they do every day. So it's like it's there's always opportunity. I I think that there's yeah. Um, guys, do it again.
SPEAKER_02I don't think they want to I don't think they want to take a phone call so they don't have to talk to their family because they're going nuts with cabin fever, you know. Like, here let me grab this. I don't know who it is. Right. It's the insurance company. Hurry, let me talk to them.
unknownAll right.
SPEAKER_00The one time.
SPEAKER_02The one time. All right, I know what you're asking.
SPEAKER_00Yes. So, Greg, what would be the number one piece of advice you give anybody coming into the insurance agency? The number one.
SPEAKER_04So let me ask you a question and clarify that. The number one is maybe agency owner, or for somebody that's gonna come and work into the insurance agency as an employee?
SPEAKER_00I would see I would say agency owner.
SPEAKER_04You need to find a mentor and you need to be coachable, right? And have some humility because there is so much to learn, and there's so many people out there that are willing to share. You have to be able to get into a system that you can replicate and follow what these people that train um say. Because if I would have had you know those mentors in my life and the training platform and access to all these modules and coaching and call recording, dude, my business would be $40 million right now instead of $26 million, you know? Um but but I'm fortunate enough to kind of come from the school of hard knocks and do things kind of the old school way because a lot of the things that I've learned over the course of my sales career, and I've sold everything that you can think of, was that it's all about your ability to grind it out. I tell my team all the time, I can teach you how to sell, I can teach you how to overcome objections, but I can't teach you how to grind it out and stroke it out. I can't teach you how to do that. I just can't, you can't teach that grit. So um that's kind of the words of advice that I would have. Make sure you find a mentor and you learn and you ask questions because there's people. I have people, agency owners that come into my office to train, and I can I will show them what to do and they'll check in with me six months later and I'll ask how they're doing. 90% of them are still where they were. You know why? Because they did not take action. Right? They came and they spent their time to come over to my agency and learn all the processes. I don't charge them for it. I just do it because I knew it's my way, it's my way to pay it forward. Not all of them, but most of them say, you know, Greg, I was gonna get to that, or you know what, I didn't have the money for that, or you know what, it's probably not a good time for me to implement that process. But that unfortunately is the lack of ability to take action on the things that you learn from the people that know better than you do, usually what cripples everybody.
SPEAKER_02They have this excuse that they need to know it better or whatever. One of my team yesterday, we were because we were working on our build-a-wall thing, the you know, this uh questioning strategy, and and um she said, Well, I'm working on doing it. I'm like, what the hell does working on doing? You need to do it, not work on like working on do it means nothing. It means you're not doing it, right? So that's it.
SPEAKER_04You're you're playing you're playing that game that all the kids play online where they're building the blocks, right? You're are you working on it? Are you punching through the wall? Are you making breakthroughs, right? Are you trying? Are you trying to jump on the phone? Are you role-playing? Are you getting with your coach and saying, Hey, can you listen to this call? Because it really, really didn't do well, or can you coach me on it? And you have to be proactive, right?
SPEAKER_02Yep. Yep. Awesome, man. Love it. Thank you. Thank you so much for coming on. Um, we it was this is great. Was that helpful for you guys?
SPEAKER_00It was super helpful. Yeah, for sure. Definitely.
SPEAKER_02Some definitely some good uh knowledge nuggets in there.
SPEAKER_00Good knowledge nuggets, solid nuggets, yes, solid nuggets.
SPEAKER_04Well, guys, thanks for having me on. I very much appreciate it. You guys ever get down to South Florida? You let me know. We'll take a cruise down the inner coastal right there and head off to the same. Yes.
SPEAKER_02Over there. Oh, go see the lighthouse, all right. All right, Greg. All right, guys. Thanks so much, Greg. Stay safe.
SPEAKER_00All right, thank you soon. Take care. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast. Hey, please subscribe. We've got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman