The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Mike “Mortgage” Jones | Goin’ Pro With Football Shows, Baseball Throws, And Loan Officer Flows
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Ding ding ding ding ding.
SPEAKER_01Ding ding.
SPEAKER_00Yes, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_01You still need the room.
SPEAKER_00No. No, I'm not gonna do it.
SPEAKER_01But there is a beautiful picture on the wall.
SPEAKER_00Never gonna get it, never gonna get it, never gonna get it. Never gonna get it.
SPEAKER_01Aren't you gonna ask me, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_00Oh, Mr. Mr. Craig, who do we have today?
SPEAKER_01Well, this is from our special lone officer series.
SPEAKER_00Ooh. We have I'm feeling a little lone in my house.
SPEAKER_01Well, aren't we all? We have Mike Mortgage Jones going pro with football shows, baseball throws, and lone officer flows. Who knows?
SPEAKER_00Let's go!
SPEAKER_01Let's go. All right. Mike Jones. Mike Jones. How you doing, my man?
SPEAKER_03I'm good. I'm good. Just uh adjusting to everyday life. I know life's changed for us all. It's it's it's challenging, I should say.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So are you home and with family around you?
SPEAKER_03Yes. Yes, I'm home, two young kids, wife, so two dogs. It's a party, all day long.
SPEAKER_01Isn't it just delightful?
SPEAKER_03Right. Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Well, before we dive in, and I don't know if you've if you've listened to insurance dudes at all, but the first question we ask everybody is what was the first concert you went to? And you can go way back. You could have been a little kid.
SPEAKER_03Oh, that's a good one. First concert I went to. Man. I went to Barney? No, so I'm originally from Texas. And I went to the rodeo, it's a big deal out there in the Houston area. And they always have a huge celebrity. And I remember when I was in a ninth grade, Destiny's Child was there.
SPEAKER_02Wow.
SPEAKER_03Which they're originally from Houston, too. Yeah, this is in Houston Astrodome. Yeah, it was it was a big deal. I remember that. But as an adult, um I went to a Jay-Z concert and I went to uh to a Maxwell concert, which was really good, surprisingly good. Nice. And yeah, that's about it.
SPEAKER_01Well, cool. Welcome, welcome to the insurance dudes. So you're actually not an insurance dude, but you work in the work closely, likely, with some insurance dudes. And um one of the things that that we're doing is we branch out um and and provide more value to our audience, the insurance dudes and dudets out there, is loan officers are huge in in what the resources that and knowledge they have and how there's that intersection of our industries, right? Um of our some of our best clients come from our centers of influence being loan officers, realtors, um, you know, and and and such. So we love uh you to tell a little bit about your background, how you got into the business, and uh we'll we'll then go from there.
SPEAKER_03You want the long version or short version?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, whatever.
SPEAKER_03In between, okay.
SPEAKER_01Well I mean a little on lockdown.
SPEAKER_03Right, exactly. We have time. Yeah, right. So just uh my story, I guess. Uh like I said, born and raised in Houston, Texas. Uh I came out to Arizona um on a football scholarship. I played at Arizona State, um, but I also played baseball as well. So I played two sports in college. Um, yeah, I played professionally both sports as well, got drafted in baseball and played in NFL for two and a half years. And then it's incredible. A lifetime ago. I'm sorry. For the Cardinals? Cardinals were my last team, actually. So for the Texans, Seattle, and the Arizona Cardinals. That's amazing. So bounce around two, three teams in two years. Um, played in the Gulf Coast League in Tampa, Florida, got drafted by the Yankees in baseball. Um, yeah. And then and then I my phone stopped ringing. So I realized, okay, well, football might be coming to an end. And then it took it took some time to accept that and learn that you gotta find something else now. That plan B that your parents have been talking about. Oh, yeah, it is tough. It's more mental than anything, but yes, it is tough. But I always was taught that there's more to life other than sports, and you always have to have a plan B, C, D, E, and F G. Um, and then again, my phone stopped ringing, and I I got a job working at the W Hotel in Scottsdale. Um, just something part-time, consistent income, had time to stay in shape just in case if the phone rang. Did ring. Um and I met met someone, got into corporate security. I did that for a few years. Then I became an executive admin at the second of the same company for a few years, and then um was expecting a baby, and and I always knew that I wasn't gonna do that forever, and I've always looked forward for a challenge, I should say. And during this whole time, I've always coached kids and trained kids. I've been doing it what 12 10 years now, and I've always loved giving back and helping people. And I and one of the kids I was coaching, his father was in the mortgage business, my now boss, um, told me about what he what he does and what uh what the mortgage business is all about. And he said I'd I'd be a good fit, good people person, got a little bit of a story. So I studied, got my license, and I've been doing it ever since. And I love it. I honestly I wish I would have done it a lot a lot sooner. Um because just the fact that you get to help people every day, every day is different. Um, it's challenging, and it allows me to have the flexibility to be super dad, which is my ultimate goal in my why for everything. It's just yeah, I want to be just super dad. Um mainly because back to my story, I'm single, single, um only child raised by a single mother. So I've always had pride in when I become a father, I'm gonna take it to another level.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so yeah, that's awesome. You're likely very competitive, right?
SPEAKER_03Uh yeah, I mean it's it's natural, I guess.
SPEAKER_01To make it to professional sports, though. I mean, you were in high school the best of the best, and then you get to college, and maybe it's a little more challenging, but still, in for you to make the step from college to NFL, you had to be the best of college, and it must like each level must have been so interesting to see, like, oh shit, there's a lot of guys that are freaking fast. Like, you get to the NFL and it's like a whole nother thing, right? I mean, just exactly so fast.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I was just gonna hit on that. Um, people like when you go to the next level from high school, the jump from high school to the to college. Yes, it is a change in in speed and just everything, really. But the jump from college to the NFL, it's a whole nother ball game when you get up there. Like it's if we're talking about grown men that are feeding their family and making a ton of money, and it's more than competitive, it's like a lifestyle. And people think they all I see is money if what they see on TV internal sports center ESP and oh, such and such is making $10 million a year. You know what in the third quarter when it's third and 15 and he's exhausted, he's not thinking about how much money he's making. He's thinking about making the play and beating the man in front of him, and that consistently happens every single play. And people don't look at that, they just look at the paycheck, which is a grind out there. And I encourage people if you ever have the opportunity to uh stand on the sidelines for an NFL game or get really good seats those first like 10 rows, watch the speed of the game. You tell me if you can go out there and perform, and and it blows people's minds. So that's just something I like to put things in perspective for people from my experience.
SPEAKER_00You know, we we talked to uh Mikey Taylor, professional skateboarder, and um I find it real interesting. My mom was also uh she was uh in the junior Olympics and she kind of went through this transitional phase. Uh especially recently where she stopped doing athl being athletic, you know what I mean, where she got out of aerobics after that, and um it's incredible what happens. I like I played music when I was young and and uh you know would go on tour with bands and stuff. I mean, I it wasn't anything incredible, but it was like I really thought I was gonna do music my whole life. It's one of those passion things. And I think like football, baseball, um the Olympic or you know, gymnastics or whatever it may be, you have these passion things that you do, and it's like you dedicate your life. You think about it all the time, you eat, breathe, everything. And then at some point you do something else, and it's like, dude, you got your identity is so wrapped up in this thing, and it's like all of a sudden you have to do like a mind change, and it's like when you were talking about how hard it was going out of football. I was like, Yeah, like it's it's that is an incredible change for some.
SPEAKER_03It was it was it is an incredible change. It's something that you're not familiar with. Like that was the part just accepting, okay. Well, I don't have the structure of I have a meeting at this time, I have practice at this time, I have a game at this time. I didn't have that anymore. And I'm such a very structured person, I had to find out what else works for me, what else can I do to structure my life? And that's one of the things I've been working on, even with my current job of just building structure of what I do. Um, and me personally, I I thrive better when I have like a schedule, I should say.
SPEAKER_01Nice interesting. My my daughter did did gymnastics, got to level 10. She would have, she was right at the point where scholarships and all that kind of stuff, and and then she got injured and she said, Look, I just I can't do it anymore. You know, I was at the point like I will get you, I will buy you a brand new Jeep if you just finish this thing, you know, go to college. And and she's like, No, I I I I wish I had a new Jeep, but that's how much I don't want to do it anymore. I can't because I'm so much pain. She was she took that structure that you that you speak of, you know, and it was like she was able to apply that to to school and just like boom, boom, straight A's. Just just just really use that in in your experience, and then like how did you take your structure and the way that you've been almost programmed, right? Because you've done it for so long, and apply it to this this industry, which is very similar to ours, where there's almost no structure, and the only way you know, like you have to create structure yourself, yeah, right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, um that that was the challenging part because I just expected things to be already structured, yeah. And when I when I caught myself stressing more and I caught myself losing things and being unorganized, I did my homework in and and talked to some people that have been doing it for a while. Like, well, what made you successful? How how did you get to where you are? And that's what they said. Time block, set your schedules, own your time. Um don't just change things just because your phone rings, stay the course, and it's gonna relieve stress, your business is gonna be a lot better. Um, you're gonna your services are gonna be a lot better, you'll just feel better, you'll sleep better, and that's kind of what I've I've been doing over the over the past couple of years is try to keep to my schedule, my time blocks, and then um nowadays it's it's almost like I'm starting from the beginning because I have two young kids and they have homeschool, so I have time blocks of homeschool for like an hour and a half, three times a day, and then on top of it, I have to do my job full time, and then my wife's busy as well, so it's just like yeah, but we're figuring it out, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So, how has it been? Like, like as you uh get to the next level in this business, like what what kind of things are you doing as a loan officer to find business to grow your business?
SPEAKER_03To be honest, I'm I've always been a huge relationship guy. Um, before this all happened, I I try to have my like tour of local coffee shops and just meet people once a day and just build relationships with those people. And I don't always look for business. I like to have conversations, I like to learn other people's stories and their why and why they are who they are and how they get to where they are. And if business comes from that, fantastic. If not, then no worries. At least I learned it and I always end the things with what can I do to help others and what can I do to achieve your goals. Um, so I've networked a lot with like coffee meetings. Um lately, I've done a couple of Zoom calls, but uh personally it's not the same, but it is something obviously social media that that helps with building business. Um but other than that, that's that's that's the core of how I build my business now, um, as of late, and with this whole curveball with the world now. Yeah, I'm trying to find other creative ways to do it.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. Um, I'd like to jump into uh so so I I know our going back to what credit said originally, um, I know our two world worlds definitely collide, right? The insurance and uh loan officer mortgage industry. Um what experience have you had with insurance agents?
SPEAKER_03Oh, quite a bit. I have I have a few of them, you know what's the funny part is I actually thought about going into insurance when I was on that crossing roads. Like, what do I want to do? Mortgages, do I want to be a full-time coach? Do I want to go to insurance? I I started studying for the exam and then I started taking the other exam and it just clicked more for me. Um yeah, I have a few insurance partners that I use, um, obviously mostly for homeowners insurance because people will get on a contract and looking for the best rates possible for homeowners insurance, or if I really need something to make the deal work, um, have a few people that help me out with that and shopping other companies. Um, but other than that, that's that's the most interaction I get with insurance guys like yourselves. Um, and I also have a former teammate that works for an insurance company um and that that I bounce ideas off of and just to get his opinion on things that I may not be the most educated about.
SPEAKER_00So that that's that that's great. So you work with some insurance dudes. Um what how do you how did you cultivate those relationships? Did they approach you? Did you approach them?
SPEAKER_03Um a little bit of both. Uh, like I said, social media, I try to make a presence there. People will reach out and if would love to have coffee with me because they see that I'm having coffee with other people and there'll be insurance guys or gals, I should say. Um, so that's another way. And um one one of my main ladies, she was a referral from an old manager that I used to have, and she's been doing insurance for I think as long as I've been alive. So I lean on her a lot when I have questions, and she's always available um with any questions that I have, text, phone call, email anytime. So um that that's again, that's pretty much all I really do with insurance, but at the same time, I know it's it makes or breaks my deals, that's for sure.
SPEAKER_00And and how yeah, how uh how many insurance guys or girls hit you up to try to develop those relationships? And what would you say would stand out to develop those relationships? Like what would catch your attention?
SPEAKER_03Um I mean it's it used used to be quite often, not as much anymore. Um, but for them to get my attention, like I I like to I like to meet in person um first. Maybe if it is social media or something, and there's something that we can relate to that draws me in or my attention, children, athletic background, et cetera, et cetera. That that kind of breaks the ice to meet in person and then just I just like to click with people. It's not always about what they have to offer, the cheapest price, highest price, the service, just clicking with people and building relationships where we can work together and achieve one main goal with helping other people, not uh helping other people and protecting other people.
SPEAKER_00Love it.
SPEAKER_01So as other folks, you know, they they they they make this choice and they're on the fence whether to go into insurance or going to to possibly being a loan officer. What kind of advice would you give to somebody that was interested in in entering your industry?
SPEAKER_03Be patient. Be patient.
SPEAKER_01The one thing that nobody wants to be, exactly.
SPEAKER_03Be be patient, be consistent, and those are the biggest things, really. Just being patient because it's not gonna happen overnight, it's not gonna happen when you want it to happen. But if you're patient and consistent and work hard, it'll eventually happen. You'll eventually achieve your goals, or at least you'll see a light at the end of the tunnels. Um, because my my first year, it was it was a grind, that's for sure. It's it's an eye-opener.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. How was it a gu a grind? What kind of things happened that made it really challenging?
SPEAKER_03It's it's a huge learning curve because in in my world that the guidelines are changing all the time, and you always have to learn new things almost daily. Because if you don't, it can change whether a loan will close or not. So that was that was a big part of it, and just trial and error, learning from your mistakes. Um, that was another thing that I wasn't really used to, I should say. Like I've I've messed up maybe once in my past in the past doing whatever I was doing, but I figured it out the second time. Here, there's always something that you have to go through or learn just to make things happen so you feel more comfortable down the road. Because it might be one way to solve a problem, but next time you can be presented with the same problem, but you need to solve it a different way. Um, so just the learning, being educated, trial and error, um not making as much money as you thought you were gonna make. Um, if you do have a family, I'm sure you're gonna get an ear full when you get home, things like that. That was that was that was a part of the the the struggle and the grind that I had to go through. But again, be being patient, continuing to learn, continuing to learn from others has definitely helped me in in my career.
SPEAKER_00What would you say what what's some of the best advice that you've had along the way? Like, like what are some standout points that like maybe a mentor or everyone you know needs to know what you do.
SPEAKER_03That was a big one for me because I was uh I wouldn't say I would say a private person. I I keep to my circle, I stay to myself and my family, and then I had to commit to social media, which I wasn't too excited about. Um, but then I I learned that I that's the way to do it nowadays, the 21st century. And every every time you go somewhere, people are looking down at their phone. Like you can walk into a Starbucks, right? Not today, but before this all happened, and 90% of the people are that looking at some kind of device. And if you can stay in front of them, then that's a huge help. So social media um was a big part of uh what the mentor taught me. Everyone needs to know, be patient, be consistent, and just just have a passion for what you do and help other people.
SPEAKER_01Is your social media is that do you just do organic or do you use do you pay, do you use any paid ads or I don't.
SPEAKER_03It's just all me, me, myself, and I every now and then throw my family in there, share my story, crack a couple jokes, say some facts that people need to hear, keep them motivated, inspirational stuff, just across the board. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_00And when you first started that, you said that you were um definitely more to yourself, and I think a lot of people can relate. There's a lot of people in our industry that don't do social media. How did you overcome that? Like what got you to going from I'm not posting anything to like now I'm posting about my family and I'm trying to motivate, like you're kind of running the gamut.
SPEAKER_03I I've always I got over what other people think a long time ago. And it has to do a lot to do with sports and just being on that stage and in front of the cameras and doing interviews. Like I was comfortable and confident with who I am a long time ago. So just to be in front of people and put a camera where there's no one really around, it was a piece of cake for me. Like there's really nobody there. I'm used to people watching physically rather than a camera looking at you the whole time. And people are gonna judge you whether you do well or don't. You just have to be confident in yourself and understand you're doing the right thing to help other people and let yeah haters hate, I guess I should say.
SPEAKER_01And you gotta be prepared for the haters, right? And if you were if you go to the NFL that or even when you Told me when you're in college and you're telling people I want to be in the NFL, I bet you more people would tell you, you know how hard it is to get you know and give you all the reasons why you can't do it instead of the reasons why you can. It's just like when we started podcasts, you know, a year 150 episodes ago. It's like, oh yeah, sure. You know how saturated that is. That's so hard to do. It's like, well, then let's grind it out. I mean, we've gotten plenty of the you know the thumbs down. It's like, okay, we must be doing something right if we have a you know, it's like a bug you can't let it go.
SPEAKER_03Exactly. And and I tell my I tell my players that I coach that you're doing something right if people are hating you. If no one doesn't like what you're doing, you're not doing something right. You need to try right things that you're doing. Someone can hate.
SPEAKER_01Right. The people that that get self-conscious and feel uncomfortable because you're doing better are the one are gonna be the haters.
SPEAKER_03So if you don't have any, then you're not doing exactly you're not doing the right things. You need you need to get more.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yep. What would you say? Uh, so we usually ask this to insurance agents, and I'm just curious, what would you um what advice, best advice you would give somebody coming into the mortgage industry if you had to give them one piece of advice freshly new coming in? There might be an insurance dude out there that said, you know what, I'm switching industries because I know, like like you said, you started studying for the insurance. I mean, I I did real estate before. I mean, it's so funny how the worlds are just so you know, so intertwined. Yeah, they are.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Yeah, same avenues. Um advice for someone coming in as an LO. Um back to the back to what I was taught. Just be patient, man. Just be patient. It's gonna happen. You got into this business for the flexibility, most people, and to make some money. Most people, right? It's not gonna happen today. It's people, or I actually was taught it's a three-year plan. So the first year is gonna drive drag your face through S H I T, yeah. And then the second year will be mud, and then the third year will just be dirt, and you'll be able to dust it off, and then you'll you'll know what you're doing after that. And that's that's kind of the approach that I tell myself. Because when I first started, and at least got on my own, because I started at consumer direct on the on the phone all the time. Um, that first month, I was just like, I'm ready to go, go, go, go, go. And I'm not used to failing so much. And I was just like, man, am I doing something wrong? And I just reconnect with people that have been doing it, and they tell you, Mike, you've been you're doing it. You're doing all the right things, you're doing the things on social media, you have to go through this. Remember the three-year plan? And I just tell myself, well, I I I don't have three years, but at the same time, it's you're it's just part of life, really. You have to go through these steps to be successful.
SPEAKER_01Just people give up and keep going. Exactly.
SPEAKER_00I I like that analogy. Crap mud dirt for three years, and that's pretty much in our industry, too. I mean, it's it's kind of the same thing. It's like, you know, you yeah, it's a lot of it's a lot of a grind. And those who come out on the other side of the cons, you know, being consistent are awesome. And it's almost like that that grind also teaches you a ton. Mike, I want to thank you so much for for all this awesome advice. And I want to I want to say that uh I love how you put your family and your kids in the forefront of what you're doing, and um, it's really cool. It's uh cool to have priorities.
SPEAKER_03Well, thank you. Thank you. That's that's the motivation. That's my why. I mean, why else would you do it? This is that's what you're remembered, that's your legacy. It's not what other people think, it's not what other people approve and things like that. Like, I don't have time for that. My my job is to provide and make sure that they're taken care of, they're taught lessons that I wasn't taught, so they have a head start in life when life presents itself to them.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. Love it. Well, thank you, Mike. I I am definitely gonna reach out since you're right up the street, and uh we'll probably chat some more. Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_03Let me know once once we're allowed to come out of the house.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it. Once they won't shoot us the moment we step outside. Exactly. It is Arizona, it's a little different here, Jason. Right. So, well, hey, Mike, thank you so much, man. And uh we look forward to chatting with you down the road.
SPEAKER_03Well, thank you guys for having me. I appreciate it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00All right, you got it, Mike. Have a good one. You too. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman