The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Ashley Mauldin Perpetually Pays It Forward Fabulously Fantastically Flawlessly
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Five seconds so long. Five seconds is long. Before we start, don't explain it. They don't care. They don't care. Do they care about this guest though? Yes. Craig, who do we have? Oh, let me tell you who we have. We have Ashley Malden. Perpetually pays it forward fabulously, fantastically, flawlessly. Ooh, what about ferociously?
SPEAKER_00Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. Boom!
SPEAKER_01Oh man, I I was looking down. Oh, look at that. Ashley. Maldon. Ashley. I said it right, right?
SPEAKER_05Uh-huh. Most people, man, I get so many mispronunciations of my name. Like, um, is there a Miss Maudlin in?
SPEAKER_01Maudlin? Sorry. Mayaldine. Mayald.
SPEAKER_04Maldine. Maudlin. Moldine. I'm sorry. There's nobody here by that name.
SPEAKER_00You gotta love it when they actually mix up the letters. It's like you would just look at it one extra second.
SPEAKER_05Right? It's like the L is before the N. I mean, this is just phonetics.
SPEAKER_01Right. Phonetics 101.
SPEAKER_03Yes. Well, I'll send you some hooks on Phonics.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, books on Phonics. Thank you for popping on here. Yes. Thanks for having me. Yeah, we start every episode with Jason.
SPEAKER_00Mr. Jason. One the one question of what was your first concert? Go all the way back to Barney if if that's if that I'm waiting for somebody to say Barney. All the way back.
SPEAKER_03My first concert was Modest Mouse.
SPEAKER_01It's a real concert. Okay. Yeah. That's a cool one. Modest Mouse. So we know what side of the argument you lie on when it comes to the uh wacky tobacky.
SPEAKER_05I I don't do it myself. I mean, I'll answer the question.
SPEAKER_01I didn't inhale.
SPEAKER_05I didn't inhale.
SPEAKER_01Well, so you've been in you've been in uh an agent with a captive for uh how long?
SPEAKER_05Uh I took over the agency December 1st of 2016. Oh, four years. Almost a little over three. Yeah, a little over three, three and a half almost.
SPEAKER_01Using Arizona math. So so how has it been? Talk talk talk about it. Let's let's talk about uh how you led up to that, and then you're also an entrepreneur, have a have another business, and I'd love to hear about this. I think you even have a building. So let's dive through that.
SPEAKER_05Um, well, it just kind of the whole the whole thing just kind of happened. I wasn't uh looking to become an insurance agent. My father-in-law owned the agency he started in 1973, I believe. It was his one and only job, and he was ready to retire and sell. And uh my husband and his three brothers, none of them had any interest in in taking over the agency. And I was like, you can't just let that go to just anybody. And so I was like, I want to buy it. And so I bought it, and here I am.
SPEAKER_01And so, you know, it's it everything isn't always easy. Um, there's a lot of struggle, especially at the front end when you're learning how to how to do this.
SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah. I mean, it's been a definite roller coaster. Um, you know, when I came in, like I said, I had no I had no insurance experience. I I'd had I started a photography business in 2006, 2006. Um, and so I had experience, you know, running a business, but I I didn't have any employees. I was the only employee. Um and uh so that's been the just the scale of running an agency versus you know being an individual sole proprietor where you're you know just creating you're creating art for people, it's very different than it is selling something that you know people don't really care to talk about. You have to make them want to talk about it. People love photos, yeah, they love it when you make them look pretty, you know. But when you're trying to sell them an intangible service or product, that that's a lot more complicated. And you know, just the scale of tracking the expenses and and managing staff and you know, all of that is is challenging at times.
SPEAKER_01What what do you think is the most challenging?
SPEAKER_05Managing people.
SPEAKER_01For me at least.
SPEAKER_00We've heard that before.
SPEAKER_05Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yes. So when did you when did you take over the agency?
SPEAKER_05December of 2016, December 1st.
SPEAKER_00And so you came into this and you're just like, ah, what was the first initial month like?
SPEAKER_05Um well, I didn't get a lot of sleep. And at the time, so you know, my husband works in the oil and gas industry. He's a petrophysicist, so petroleum engineering. He's you know, smart guy that spends his day doing spreadsheets and looking at all this kind of fancy stuff that I don't understand. Um, so he travels, he travels a lot. Um, he travels to the Middle East, Saudi Arabia. Um, they just got finished doing a huge project for Aramco. And so at the time, uh we were living in DFW, um, like Dallas Fort Worth area. The agency is in the Amarillo, which is about 320 miles away. Um, he was in Saudi Arabia when I appointed, when I actually took over the agency. So I I was here um with my kids, um doing all of that by myself while he was, you know, on the other side of the planet. And so that first month was um very challenging. We were living with his parents um because we didn't have a house here yet. And uh so yeah, um, draining our bank account until I got my first commission check. You know. Um and then, you know, about four or five months after I took over the agency, I ended up with shingles because I was so stressed. So that's kind of that's kind of when I was like, okay, I need to, I need to take a step back and and kind of figure out the balance of things because you know, I'm my health is being affected at this point. And I'm not even I'm barely six months into this. I can't keep doing myself. I can't keep doing this to myself.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's crazy. So what what how did that epiphany come? Like what was what was next?
SPEAKER_05Um, so at that point, I kind of um right now. I kind of decided that you know I was going to, you know, not work 12 hours a day. And one thing that I've found is that is that you kind of have to make all the different facets of your life work together rather than having, you know, this business and that business and mom and wife. In order to make things balanced and create balance in your life, you make all of those work together. So, you know, my husband started, he started coming up to the office and using my spare office to do his work. So we were able to kind of spend our time together that way. And then I would, you know, leave at 2:30 in the afternoon and go pick up my kids. And some days I would stay home in the afternoon with them. Um, and some days I'd bring them up to the office and they would sit sit next to me and do their homework and read. And so we were able to keep that balance where I was spending time with them, they were seeing me working. Um, so they were seeing what I was doing. Um, and and I wasn't neglecting one part of my life for the other.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. And I think every every agent goes through that. I a version of that. Like, you know, I I like even when I came in here three years ago, um, it was definitely 12-hour days. And you think it's almost like you you try to do it all and you think that that has to be the way it's done. I did it for the whole first year.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. It's it's so easy to do that.
SPEAKER_00But it's so you've moved on. I mean, you're you're definitely in a different place now at the agency. How did you get from that uh part that was incredibly difficult and uh time consuming to where you are now?
SPEAKER_05Well, I mean, you know, we've I've gone through, you know, lots of difficult times in my life. And so I try to always keep the mindset of, you know, this is this is only a season, it's not going to be like this forever. And just continuing to pursue and be objective about your situations and and realize that, you know, it's if I don't want it to be like this forever, it doesn't have to be. How can I change it? Um, you know, how can I make all the areas of my life work cohesively and work together rather rather than just running myself ragged and then I burn out and then I'm making careless mistakes because I'm I'm not thinking clearly. Um I mean, and that's really it's really just keeping that mindset of this isn't gonna last forever. You know, I'll figure it out and and being proactive about figuring it out and and being okay asking for help. You know, that's that's one big thing that that I think a lot of people, and I myself included, struggle with, especially entrepreneurs, you know, when it's your business, you know, your whole life savings has been sunk into it. And so it's it's really hard to ask for help with that, you know, because nobody's gonna care as much as you do, you know.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_05But you you have to, you have to let people help you. You know, my my in-laws a lot of times help me. They help me so much. They'll pick up my kids and and take them to piano practice if I can't get out of the office or you know, stuff like that. It's especially when Ryan's gone. I don't I don't know how I would have survived without them when he's when he's on the other side of the planet.
SPEAKER_00Man, that's rough. So um, what is some of that advice that when you finally did reach out, what what was some of the best advice that you got?
SPEAKER_05Oh gosh, that's a hard one. I've gotten lots of really good advice. Um, I would say, you know, the one that I hear the most and that's been the most helpful is control what you can control. You know, I mean, we hear that so often, but it's really true. You know, there are things, there are things in life, there are things in business, in your personal life, and relationships that you can control, and there are things that you cannot control. One thing you can control is how you react to situations. So am I gonna let a situation stress me out and upset me and and hurt me personally, or am I going to you know, try to be proactive and and not let it bother me and and just keep going. You know what I mean? It's yeah, that's you know, you just have to kind of wash your hands of things at some time.
SPEAKER_00Like, this is not something that I can control, so you know, whatever will be will be yeah, and I think that that's the one thing that everybody has to realize. Like a lot, a lot of people have their eyes on what they can't control. It's like, don't look there, you can't control that. You can control what you do. And if you know if you showed up, you did the right thing, you know, you picked it, you got to pick up your kids too. Who cares if it's like sales struggle at work? Like you, you, you, you did everything when you were there that you could possibly do to maximize your time because you knew you had to go pick up your kids, and then you were there for them too. So you like that's success right there.
SPEAKER_05Right. And it's I mean, at the end of your life, nobody is going to nobody's gonna pay attention to how much money you had at the bank or how many insurance policies you sold. You know, but what they will pay attention to to is the impact that you had on the people around you. You know, if am I spent am I spending my days, am I spending each moment uh doing everything that I possibly can to make my life fulfilling and to make an impact on the people around me? You know, I'm not the highest producer, you know, and I probably never will be, but I'm okay with that, you know, because I'm making a difference, you know, and that's ultimately what matters. I know that I'm doing everything that I possibly can, the best that I possibly can. And so to me, that's like you said, to me, that's success.
SPEAKER_00That is success. Yeah. It's it's what what is the cost of, you know, you see some of the top agencies out there, and like what is the cost of some of those agencies? You know what I mean? Like everything that wasn't that the first law of like economics, everything comes at a like there's always a give and take, there's always a trade-off.
SPEAKER_05And it's a matter of what you're willing to give up, you know. Like there are people in my husband's company who they make way more money than him, but they live in Kazakhstan and they don't see their families, you know. They they're there for nine months out of the year and they come home. Do they make $700,000 a year? Yeah. But is that really worth it? To me, it's not. To Ryan, it's not, you know, and he's like, Yeah, I could, I could, you know, I could go and do this, but it's it's just not worth it to me, you know. I mean it's like, you know, that's and that's why in a lot of industries, especially in the oil industry, um, the divorce rate is super high. You know, I mean, because people are gone and they're they're chasing that, you know, they're chasing that money or they're chasing that, you know, that success that they, you know, they think what they think is success. And then uh and then at the end of your life you look back and you're like, I have nothing to show for that. I have a bunch of money in the bank, but I've failed all the people around me, and that's that's just not worth it to me.
SPEAKER_00It's so funny because money is that the thing that's supposed to create opportunity for us, but we allow the way to get money to suck the opportunity from us right in such worse ways than just not even working.
SPEAKER_05Like, I mean, don't get me wrong, like you know, I am I am motivated by money, but not not to the extent where I'm I'm gonna sacrifice relationships and living, you know, and spend all of my time working. Like I don't want I don't want that. I don't my kids don't need that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_05You know, I mean, if I'm not around, then what kind of what kind of humans are they gonna end up becoming? You know, and it all comes back to the impact that you make on the people around you, whether it's your customers, whether it's you know, the people that work for you, whether it's your family. Um that's the biggest thing in life, you know, investing in people. And you know, one thing that Ryan and I do uh with with some of the money that we make is we use that money to invest in people. Um like you know, Craig, you were talking about the other business. So we've got um we've got the agency and then we have a coffee shop. We also built a commercial building um to house the agency and the coffee shop. And the coffee shop was really my brother-in-law's thing. He's been a barista for years and years. It's kind of always been something that he's wanted to do is have his own coffee shop. Well, you know, so we invested in that for him, you know, invested in in Thai rather than, you know, doing our own thing. You know, coffee is not our dream, you know. We didn't really know a whole lot about coffee when we started the project, you know, and that's you know, we've we've paid college tuition for people, you know, our friends who we are we feel like just we wanted to invest in them, you know, and so that's that's how we spend a good portion of the money is is just investing in people.
SPEAKER_00That's super cool. That's super but I'm sure that the coffee helps run the agency.
SPEAKER_05Oh, yeah, it definitely keeps me productive. Yeah, it's an endless supply of caffeine.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome.
SPEAKER_05I I tell my staff, I'm like, one of the perks of working here is that you can get free coffee drinks whenever you want.
SPEAKER_00That's awesome. That is a huge perk.
SPEAKER_05It's a perk. Yeah, it's a good perk. Whenever you want, just go next door. I do tell them though, if there's a line, then you have to wait.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, don't, yeah, exactly. What would um what would your big piece of advice be to anybody getting into this um from everything that you've learned over the last few years?
SPEAKER_05Um, which I think we already kind of went over it, but yeah, it would be it would be, you know, the whole the whole balance thing, keeping a balance and and control what you can control and don't let the don't let those other things invade your headspace. Because it'll it will it will take over like a virus, you know.
SPEAKER_01For sure. Having having the strong mindset and and not feeding into negativity, right? And and there's especially right now in some places a lot of negativity, and so it's it's important to keep a handle on that.
SPEAKER_05Um and sometimes it's hard, you know. Sometimes you have to make the conscious effort to just disconnect um and say, you know what, I'm gonna step back from this for a minute, I'm gonna unfollow these pages, or you know, I'm gonna delete Facebook off of my phone for a little while. Um because you know, otherwise, if if you're struggling with that, it's just constant in your face, negativity, you know, people complaining, and you know, even the strongest person can get caught up in that.
SPEAKER_03Right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05But you know, I I try to look at things that you know, yeah, there are difficult things going on, and but you don't have you know, I st we still have really great jobs. You know, totally we have yeah, we have great opportunities. I mean, there are people in other countries that don't even have access to clean water, you know, and I have a fireplace in my house that I can turn on with a switch. So I don't really feel like I have any room to complain about anything, you know.
SPEAKER_00Totally.
SPEAKER_05I mean, I've got it pretty good. We all do.
SPEAKER_00And you you're right, like we all control what we do. It's like we control who what we listen to, we control who we listen to, we control what we look at. I mean, all this stuff. It's it's like literally our mood, our mood is actually controlled by us. Like what we are allowing ourselves to take in or out. No, it's all good.
SPEAKER_05Sorry, I thought I put this on silent. My bad.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that that perspective's huge. I mean, there are yeah, I mean, we got it good. We got it good.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, if you if you if you kind of if you look into the law of attraction, um, and if you've ever you know looked into it or read anything about it, you you can create your own universe. You know, you're gonna attract what you're thinking about, what you're spending your time, you know, what what are you making your God in your life? You know, what are you worshiping in your life? You know, what are you spending your time dwelling on and thinking about and and reading about? And you're gonna create that, you're gonna attract that into your life, you know, if you're constantly, you know, reading threads of people complaining and about how things are terrible, your life is gonna be terrible, you know, and yep. That I mean, people always tease me about that, but I'm like, you know, you you create your world, you know. I mean, if you're if you're a positive glass half full type person, then typically when something happens, you're gonna be able to process it with your glass half full. It's just, you know, and but maybe that's the cheerleader in me, you know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, but I mean it's something to work on, like with the we need to strive in that direction rather than the other direction and let ourselves get sucked away.
SPEAKER_05I mean, that's that's a good way to you know harbor depression and and just you know just negativity and and not being able to enjoy your life. I mean, we don't have a whole lot of time here, you know. So, you know, I really don't want to spend it being upset and angry all the time, right? You know, I mean credit. Make the best of what I got.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I only have like three years left. I mean, I'm 92. I mean yesterday, and now he's on his deathbed, so just like that.
SPEAKER_05It goes by so fast. I was so my daughter, um, my daughter's about to be seven, and my son is about to be eleven. When we moved here and I took over the agency, my son was my daughter's age. My son was just a little, he was about seven and a half. He was just a little older than she is now. And I I had that realization yesterday, and it kind of made me panic a little bit. I'm like, golly, I mean, when we moved here, she was just barely three. Now she's like almost done with first grade, you know. And yeah, my son's about to be in middle school. It's kind of depressing.
SPEAKER_00It is everything's short. We gotta just enjoy, you know, enjoy the moment.
SPEAKER_05Be in the moment, be in the moment, be where your feet are.
SPEAKER_00Be where your for sure.
SPEAKER_01Well, we know you're super busy and you've got the two businesses, so um, we appreciate your time to come on. Um with the agent interviews, we go pretty quick, and and uh it's been awesome. It's just great to great to connect and uh good to see you again. Haven't talked to you now.
SPEAKER_05I know it's been crazy.
SPEAKER_01You want to give a shout out to any agents that you're friends with? Give a shout out.
SPEAKER_05I'm friends with tons of them. Like Christina, Christina Crock, Javier, uh Lauren, Janny, Melissa. You guys, we have a Melissa and Lauren and Christina and I, we have a we have a group text that we that we have going on every day. And so it's really awesome. If you don't have a group text going on with with several agents, um, you're really missing out. I mean, it helps keep me saying, Yes, yes, every every morning one of us is one of us is texting, you know, hope you guys are having a great day. And it's it's fantastic. So that's yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's the nugget of of this podcast, I would say, is like definitely get yourself a group. If you don't, if you're not into that group, that supportive group, find a few people. Find your tribe. Do that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_05Find your tribe.
SPEAKER_00Not enough people.
SPEAKER_01Insurance dudes could be the tribe. You never know. Well, I'll give out Craig's number. Yeah, it's all good. So um, thank you, and uh, we'll catch up with you down the road. Thanks, Ashley.
SPEAKER_05All right, thanks.
SPEAKER_00Thanks so much.
SPEAKER_05Bye bye.
SPEAKER_00Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast. Subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman