The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee talk. You know, talk about what? Tog, daughter. Whatever. It's coffee talk. Coffee tlock.
SPEAKER_02
Hello, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_03
Well, hello, Mr. Jason. It feels like a long time since we've recorded it.
SPEAKER_01
Your your mug's cute.
SPEAKER_03
Look at this. It's got a oh, you can't. Oh. Oh, it has a little kitty cat on it.
SPEAKER_02
There it is. Damn. So uh we don't have our mics because we're we're talking our little air potties.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, and I'm out here in this wasteland.
SPEAKER_02
Right.
SPEAKER_03
I'm here in the apocalypse. We're not doing too much better over there. No.
SPEAKER_02
We're COVID creeping.
SPEAKER_03
If I see a zombie come up behind you, I'll let you know.
SPEAKER_02
Uh Craig, how are you handling the whole lockdown?
SPEAKER_03
Well, it's tight quarters over here. It doesn't look tight.
SPEAKER_01
It looks like you're out in the field.
SPEAKER_03
Well, I had to get away. I had to break away. But um, you know, as we were just talking before, in many situations, you're either going to look at at whether or not this situation is an opportunity or a challenge, right? And oftentimes, those challenges, if you can find the opportunity within the challenge, then you're making progress, right? Now you're cooking with propane or gasoline, right? And I like briskets too, though. Brisket. I mean, then you do the little pellets and the smoker, but whatever you're using, briskets are delicious, and you have to find that opportunity.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, right? So because we hear we've talked to so many people, and it's so divided right now. Some people are going all in, and some people are just on the sidelines waiting for the storm to pass. And you had some thoughts on that, Mr. Craig. Well, yeah. When's the storm gonna pass? We don't know, and it seems like they keep pushing back the date.
unknown
Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
It's funny. I this morning I read, or I not read, I mean, uh well, I guess you read. I saw Twitter that Trump was talking about um, you know, that they they will soon have a plan for when they will lift the shutdown. Okay, so then they're not gonna soon lift the shutdown, they're gonna soon have the plan for when they will then lift the the shutdown, which then who even knows if that's even accurate, right? But right, as you read, you know, around the interwebs, and I saw something on Facebook too. Uh pen just landed in my cup, uh, saw on Facebook too, that they're thinking 18 months. Yeah. 18 months, right? So a year and a half. Yeah. Now, if you hunker down and wait it out, likely a year and a half is long. That's probably when the when the vaccine is around, you know, when they get the vaccine. They'll start easing stuff fairly soon, probably. But sure, you wait it out. I think not only are you putting yourself at a distinct disadvantage, but you're missing quite possibly, Jason, the biggest opportunity of a lifetime.
SPEAKER_02
I think you are right, but let's just clarify what you mean by that. Because it seems like it's not an opportunity, that it's a devastation, which it is, but what do you mean by that, Mr. Craig?
SPEAKER_03
Well, oh, I'm gonna tell you, Mr. Jason, what I mean by that. If if if I'm sitting here thinking that this is a this is a huge challenge, it's the biggest worst thing that's ever happened, then likely many others are too. So, what is the likelihood that many others are going to go and double down right now?
SPEAKER_02
Hmm.
SPEAKER_03
The old SNN, slim and none.
SPEAKER_02
Slim to none. That's right.
SPEAKER_03
Right. I'd say right now, for those of you who are card counters, this is the time when the when the count is really high and you should be pushing in and making the big bets. Okay. And if not, then we're all screwed and we're we're done anyway. Who cares? Have your guns of whiskey ready. But right. No, I mean, it it literally is is the time. You know, um, when we talk about the call cadence, like when you're when you're making dials or you have people making dials for you or whatnot, um, how many people call the lead one time? Yeah, right. Most, right? Most of them, I'd say 90%, probably not even 100%, call the lead the first time, right? Right? They think about what they're gonna say. I don't want to say the wrong thing, all that crap. How many people call the second time? A lot less. How many people call the third time? Right. All right, how many people call the tenth time? Only you and I.
unknown
Right.
SPEAKER_03
Right? And so so what we know is the likelihood that everybody else, that that the majority of people are pulling it back is very high.
SPEAKER_02
Very high.
SPEAKER_03
So so by going in, by buying more leads, by calling more people, you're you're definitely going to come out of this thing already on the first turn while everybody else is still at starting line, hunkering down, coming up with their plan, writing down their new strategy. Oh, you know what? You're already behind. That's your strategy. You just lost.
SPEAKER_02
Yep. It's true. There's so much. And what are your thoughts? Yeah, it's there's so much opportunity, and I think that part of it is this is like uh you you look at it like you're not just doing something uh to maybe plug the leak for right now, but you're also setting in new processes that you can use in the future to really take your agency to the next level. Like, especially we were just talking about a lot of people didn't know what Zoom meetings were before this thing, and now kids know what Zoom meetings are because they're having virtual play dates.
SPEAKER_03
So remember when we when we had my daughter on um on uh uh coffee talk or machine, whatever. But she didn't know how to operate Zoom. Now that's how she's taking her college classes.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. Yep. So I think that yeah, setting up the Zoom meetings for work, um uh yeah, just all those, all those like things that you have to do remotely can be a huge tool for the future when you're not remote, but now you want to like get your teams on, or maybe like, hey, you're taking a vacation and and you can do a virtual meeting and your team's already kind of used to it. Or if it's uh you know, new lease so lead sources, training. I mean, you name it. You could there's so many different things that you can do now that will set you up so that when it is back to normal, you're 10 steps ahead than you were when you first started.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Well, oh yeah, at the beginning here, I was just talking about marketing, sales, and and and new biz, right? But but what if we're talking about hiring? What if we're talking about meeting as a team? What if we're talking about all of these other aspects of the job? So, how many people would hire a remote person pre-COVID? Right. Now, I mean, if if you aren't still always be recruiting, I mean, this is a great excuse for people to say, oh, I'm not gonna, I'm not gonna hire anybody till after. Well, we have the we have the the highest now unemployment rate than we've had in in decades, right? Right. Directly following the lowest unemployment. So now what opportunity now there's actually good prospects out there to hire. So if you can hire somebody under these conditions, like I just started somebody, we'll see how it works, right? But I mean we have to train her on Zoom. Well, what a great opportunity because now we have recordings of all those trainings, so now we can use those to train the next person.
SPEAKER_02
And not to mention it's something that is probably not gonna work out incredibly well at first, but you would never have tried this if things were back to normal because there is a steep barrier to entry when it comes to learning how to do this. But now you're gonna do it, and so by the time this thing's over, there is gonna be a process where you can teach people on Zoom. If you can now hire throughout the state and you're not just subject to that one area and you have a solid process by then, you're gonna be able to crush it. I mean, that's a huge um limitation to agencies, is when you have to hire someone that's that's right uh near the office or something like that.
SPEAKER_03
Right. But now I can dip into the Phoenix pool, I can dip into the Flagstaff pool, I can dip into wherever, right? Yep, press it, Safford, Thatcher, all those great places. Press it. Sure, you betcha. I like it, man. You betcha, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_02
So in and you and I uh have uh partnered with some people to to bring some services to agents to help them kind of take their agencies to the next level, and that's something that we did that we came up with within this time too, which is fantastic. Hey, hey! Hi you're on coffee talk.
SPEAKER_03
You're you're on coffee talk. What all right she's driving up to uh to as you to pick up her the rest of her stuff.
SPEAKER_02
A sue. You don't have to spell it out. But yes, um, so you and I came up with some stuff and and now we're we're helping some agencies. We're partnered up with some people to help some agencies with uh telemarketing and and leads and stuff like that. So it's something that you and I did. So it and there's always those times that you know, and even if it's no matter what it is, there's either we can learn through this time, we can uh take businesses to the next level, or just little things. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Well, if we cry on our spilled milk, you know what's gonna happen is we're gonna find the other people who are crying in their spilled milk, and then we're just gonna sit there and all cry together about our spilled milk. Or you find the people that aren't doing that, the ones that are getting it done. I mean, that's why I love being attached to uh to you, Mr. Jason, because I mean your best oh uh you did really well with your company. And uh and and you're crushing it on the with using those telemarketers. I mean, that's why I modeled that that whole system. I mean, I'm not gonna I'm not a genius over here. I'm gonna I'm gonna model what the best of the best are doing.
SPEAKER_01
That's what that's what uh we did. So it's all the it's all the same. Yeah. And you copy what Russell Brunson's doing.
SPEAKER_02
What do you think that the crying over spilled milk references babies and kids? Or do you think that when that was uh when that phrase came about that people were like adults were drinking a lot of milk?
SPEAKER_03
That's a good question because I I can I can honestly tell you, I do not drink a lot of milk. No. No, it doesn't work. I feel like I'm crying about that. Yeah. It should be crying over the non-drank milk. Do you say milk or do you say milk? I think m I don't know. Milk.
SPEAKER_02
I like milk milk. I could see adults being uh, you know, crying over spilled whiskey.
SPEAKER_03
In my old days I would wine?
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
And I think I'd cry over spilled milk. I'd be get angry over spilled milk. Right.
SPEAKER_02
I'm sure you got emotional a few times. Oh, me.
SPEAKER_01
Oh boy. Oh, I think we have coffee talk. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Thanks for joining.
SPEAKER_01
Thanks for joining. Take advantage of this time, everybody.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Take advantage. Shoot us a message. You know what? Join uh the uh the group.
SPEAKER_02
Join the group, join the the mailing list. Now we have weekly mailing lists um to keep everybody. It's called the dude's letter. The dude's letter, so we can all stick around each other and be positive together.
SPEAKER_03
You know, it's it's funny when somebody joins the group, it asks, did you sign up for the dude's letter? And and some people say no. I don't understand why you wouldn't want the dude's letter in your inbox once a week. I don't know, Mr. Craig. I bet those are the same people that don't go and leave a review over on iTunes. If you haven't left your review, Jason will shave his head if you leave a the best review. Yes. Right here on Coffee Talk. Yep. That's a coffee talk. Oh, got a sale. Ooh, all right. Auto. There you go.
SPEAKER_02
There you go. Coffee talk.
SPEAKER_03
All right, coffee talk.
SPEAKER_02
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes.com.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.