The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Coffee Talk: Banter from the Bunkers
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee twerk. You know, talk about what? Glugs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twerk. Coffee tluck.
SPEAKER_02Now I will go live. Ooh, Mr. Craig. It says to add a title. Oh jeez. Oh jeez. Let me add a title. We are live.
SPEAKER_03That's an amazing title.
SPEAKER_02There you go. Oh, it's setting it up.
SPEAKER_03Alright.
SPEAKER_02Okay, I can't be on our feed because I'm gonna be looking at questions. There we go.
SPEAKER_03Sounds good.
SPEAKER_02We are live.
SPEAKER_03We are live! Wow!
SPEAKER_02We're live.
SPEAKER_03From the bunker. The Pretzinger and Feltman bunker.
SPEAKER_02It's true. The Pretzinger and Feltman bunker.
SPEAKER_03I I need to do some cleaning.
SPEAKER_02Do ya?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, just a little bit. I think I should.
SPEAKER_02What happened? So you left your office.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_02All this stuff in your office?
SPEAKER_03Some of it was, yeah. Yeah. It's in the back.
SPEAKER_02You could have put it in boxes.
SPEAKER_03True.
SPEAKER_02I mean, I'd left everything at the office because we were in such a hurry.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I did growing up. I grabbed some stuff and I I mean I guess I had some stuff back there. Does it look bad?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, I mean, it's looked better. What's in the bucket? You mean this one? Yeah, that one. This one. Right there. Yeah. I'm not gonna do it. I get tetanus. I mean, I can't touch these walls either. It's real rusty.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but hey, at least you're safe.
SPEAKER_02And and I have power.
SPEAKER_03You have power, that's good. That's good.
SPEAKER_02Have you seen that? There was a thing on um the uh I don't know. It was just a video going around. It was from some TV show where the guy they said, you are quarantined, and you can either A, be with your wife, or he goes, B.
SPEAKER_03So good. No, here's a question.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Does your wife know you're doing this right now in your house?
SPEAKER_02Does she know that I'm doing this in my house? Yes. Well, the bunker's downstairs. No, I just said I have to run out. Oh.
SPEAKER_03Gotcha. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It's dicey.
SPEAKER_03It is dicey. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Dicey.
SPEAKER_03So, Mr. Craig, are you working? And are you working from home?
SPEAKER_02Um not yet. We're we're we're flipping the switch.
SPEAKER_03You're flipping the switch. Flipping the switch. So tell me, um, what does that entail for you? Were you prepared for this?
SPEAKER_02Well, I mean, I've been a doomsdayer for quite a long time, so we had a lot of those MREs and you know the ammo. No, um, no, I mean, of course not. I wasn't ready for this. Two weeks ago, we were making fun of it.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_02Were we wrong? So yeah, we were wrong. We were a little bit off, but that's all right. That's what happens. Um now I hope I'm off in the other direction. So uh, no, I mean there's a lot of stuff that has to go into it because at first, I mean, I had bought a bunch of laptops because we had to spend that money, right? The money that some company gives us, but uh so I bought a few more laptops and I bought about four or five more desktops. So we had all these, you know, eight extra computers. And boy, was that some foresight or is that high sight? Which one is it?
SPEAKER_03I don't know, some sort of site.
SPEAKER_02It was like it was it was good sight because now we are putting those together. Monday we're gonna flip the switch, maybe Friday. Um, but the you know, there's there's some positive to all this.
SPEAKER_03Sure, what is that?
SPEAKER_02Contact rate.
SPEAKER_03Right, right.
SPEAKER_02It's gone up a little bit.
SPEAKER_03It has. It has. Um Travis Turner asked, uh, where are you, Craig?
SPEAKER_02I'm in the bunker downstairs.
SPEAKER_03The bunker.
SPEAKER_02The bunker.
SPEAKER_03Tim says he's never seen me so organized. That's right. Yeah. No, I cleaned up for the show.
SPEAKER_02We're actually showing the inside of Jason's mind.
SPEAKER_03That is true.
SPEAKER_02Where are you seeing this?
SPEAKER_03On the face, the the I see in and for Yaman, it's the fat the f the book of Fosh.
SPEAKER_02Oh, look at it. There's Envy. There's our he's our engineer right there.
SPEAKER_03Mr. Envy.
SPEAKER_02I like his little emoji he made with the two arms because that's what he does. Boom! That's a uh cut right there. So our secret. And then Bill Klein just put a flying roll of toilet paper.
SPEAKER_03Love it.
SPEAKER_02Big news toilet paper.
SPEAKER_03So so where are you going? Where are you going with this? I I mean I've I've talked to some agents and some are just they're shutting down cold. Or they're um scaling back. So where are you going with this, Mystic Bay?
SPEAKER_02Look, either it's doom and gloom and we're all screwed and doesn't matter anyway, or there could be opportunity. You know? Okay. So might as well play it out as if it's opportunity until it isn't, and uh then you know change direction. But I'm going to, I mean, I've I've spent I'm spending a little bit more on leads. I actually am getting more leads than I was before any of this happened.
SPEAKER_03So you cranked it up within the last week.
SPEAKER_02We went from we had dialed it back a little bit because I I replaced a couple people, so we were doing some training, and then this little nagging voice in my head that from you back in December, when you were like, nope, don't freak out, turn them up, buy more. I I just I heard that and I just started buying more because I don't get another day that I could buy more if I lose that day. So we, you know, I put it to one, I think we're at 125, right? Well, 125 on ALM and another um 100 from quote nerds, and then I have some uh some oh no okay.
SPEAKER_03I thought you froze. But the hound.
SPEAKER_02The hound.
SPEAKER_03Cool man. I mean, we did we did the same thing. We we cranked it up and um yeah, our team's rocking. And I you know, I think they actually I think a a lot of them like working from home. So uh yeah, this is definitely gonna change the way we do things in the future.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and how are you going to um how you're gonna hold them accountable? Seems like it's hard.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, we're still doing them, we're doing everything this exact same way, but all virtual. Um it's all meetings, meetings at the same time, Zoom meetings, um, which have been a lot of fun, especially when you can change the backgrounds.
SPEAKER_02Don't you think that this if this is right. And and if we go to this type of format, right, where we're we're we're actually working remotely, then you could go out on a limb and say, hey, I can recruit all over the state because what's the difference? They don't have to come to the office.
SPEAKER_03Truth.
SPEAKER_02So that's what I did. I mean, I'm searching, I I'm doing the resume uh sorry, itchy nose. Doing the the resume search on Indeed, and there are so many servers and bartenders right now out there to pick up, to swoop in and pick up. Send them the old sales strengths, have them take that. I have three people in the pipeline right now. We just hired somebody that actually came from a team team hired event, but um that was so we just brought her on. She is starting and she's gonna come in for a two-day crash course starting tomorrow, Thursday, then go home and work, you know, work remote. Give her a computer. Now I I'm a little concerned when I run out of computers to give.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02Anyone know the inventory on the place where we buy computers?
SPEAKER_03I don't.
SPEAKER_02Is do you have any computers in back of you underneath all that stuff?
SPEAKER_03I'll have to check. I'll have to check.
unknownAll right.
SPEAKER_03I think there's like two. But I think it's under this. You can do that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So the first, yeah, my first person, I have one, I do have one person right now that is working from home. And I was ca I I mean, I'm not gonna lie, I was I was a little concerned that maybe there'd be a little less productivity, but according to the program, I mean, she's doing it everything the right way.
SPEAKER_03Nice, nice. And have you seen sales go down lately?
SPEAKER_02No, sales went up.
SPEAKER_03Sales went up, yeah.
SPEAKER_02The event.
SPEAKER_03Right. And ours went down a little bit, but um I mean, we're still pretty much by the end of every day, we're still on pace to hit. I mean, we'll have our best month ever. So it's just really tweaking those things to make it to make it work.
SPEAKER_02I think it goes back to the pillars and looking at that training and being consistent with the training, you know, the that morning meeting, that afternoon meeting, that you gotta bring them together. And I think that when you're remote like this, it's it's so important to get the team back together. Like getting them back together, like in the blues brothers.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02You gotta get automation from God.
SPEAKER_03It's true. I I definitely don't think cranking back is a good idea. A couple reasons, because I think one thing, you crank back, your team sees that, they're they're not gonna have much faith in you at that point, they're gonna lose interest. I mean, and then it's also our duty to I mean, they've invested time with us.
SPEAKER_02So I thought we were doing oh, we weren't gonna Yeah, you gotta make it rain. But yeah here in times of in de economic downturn, everybody a lot of people will panic, the herd will go one direction. Those who take the opposing view and go the other direction are usually the ones that that make out.
SPEAKER_03Right. It's true.
SPEAKER_02I mean, what's the market at today? I don't know. I think I went back up.
SPEAKER_03That's gonna be another one.
SPEAKER_02Way to go not as somebody that talks about that. I'm just saying just in general. No recommendation.
SPEAKER_03You're getting bunker fever over there.
SPEAKER_02I know. I've been down in this. It's it's it's kind of stinky in here. Some fumes like very damp. It's kind of damp in here. I knew I should have taken better care of it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, I agree though. I think that um now's the time to really to really start start uh thinking about changing some processes and and making sure that everything stays the same. I mean, I I 100% think that we can keep we can keep on keeping on. If it get if it gets a little harder, which it will, then you lean into what's working, you know. We've already switched the way that we're talking to people because it's a different environment.
SPEAKER_02Right? We can only control what we're doing.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02So if we control the and make it that we're doing less, then by design, we will get less.
SPEAKER_03Yep. Truth.
SPEAKER_02I mean, there's remember a few weeks ago, all you could hear is people complaining about how there's nobody to hire. Guess what?
SPEAKER_03There's a lot of people.
SPEAKER_02There's a ton of people to hire. I mean, and there's also not just in the you know, the service industry, who are great, and who a lot are of them are great because they have the right personalities for this, but just in our business, because you have them in you have the the scaredy cats that are getting that are leaning up, bleeding back, saying, I'm gonna wait till this is all over. All right, let me give you some some really exciting news. That isn't anytime soon. This isn't over. No, this is likely something that we're gonna experience for a while. And so, you know, if you wait, then you're just gonna shrink. And if you shrink, you're dying.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I've talked I've talked to a lot of people that um that are kind of just hoping it it passes. But it's like then you're you're gambling on something that you don't control, and it's a very small likelihood that it's just gonna pass and everything, nothing's gonna go back to the way it was, right? So now's the time to really invest. Well, we have time, we have two resources time and money, right? Well, money's we have it now, it's gonna be dwindling. So, but we have time and time, we we really need to invest that into thinking how like prepare for the worst, hope for the best, prepare for the worst, so that no matter what happens, you're you're good. Ish.
SPEAKER_02Well, the the excuse of I'm gonna wait till things get better doesn't work because if if if you're going if right now, today, there isn't enough to do something with, and you're gonna wait until it gets better, which during that time you're going to shrink and not recover more more uh resources, then how will it be better?
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_02You know, does anybody does anybody type anything? Did we lose everybody?
SPEAKER_03I don't think so. Yeah, I think we did.
SPEAKER_02Never seen Jason's place so organized. It looked like a sewer, says Travis Turner. Well, Travis. Ha ha ha, Fosh book. Oh boy.
SPEAKER_03Uh call times, have they changed at all? Actually, they've uh some of them have increased.
SPEAKER_02Um let me pull up, I can pull up some data. Let's see.
SPEAKER_03It's just here's the thing, is like there's there's there's you know, there's benefits and and negatives to to what we're seeing in the last week and or two. And yeah, more people are home, less people say they have money. Um so we're asking if they lost their job. I mean, it's time to be a little bit more personable. So what that's what we're trying, that's what we're trying to do is be more like some of some people are scared. So it's like talk to them more like a person. I think that hands down, this is one of the things that we work on in the office more than anything, is to not sound professional. Like the worst thing you can do is sound like a telemarketing salesperson. Yeah, you know, people tend to they come into the office, hey, how's it going? And they sit on the phone and well, well, hello there. Um, is your name this? And it's like, wow, you sound horrible. Like, why you sounded great coming in? What happened? Like, you've been your whole life, you've talked to people and had great interpersonal communication skills, and then all of a sudden you jump on the phone, you sound like a robot. I don't know why we do that.
SPEAKER_02Look at this.
SPEAKER_03Oh, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_02Lead volume's a little down. Yeah, I'm gonna take this off actually. But the lead, if you look, this is this is the now what the heck's happening? I can't do this. The contact. Here's the important thing right here. Contacts are 17.6 percent, 48. Or I'm sorry, 18.6, 20.3. So look at how high the contacts are. This is this is only leads created in this time frame over the last seven days. That's high, right? So if I go here and I go custom and I go, give me give me the dates of the week prior. So let's or let's go to the beginning of the month. So let's go 3.1, 2, 3, 13 for fun. I'm gonna do it and put it there. Let's see if that works. See? Right here. There you go. So like all of these other leads have been much lower for only only leads created in that time frame. I mean, it's almost half. That's crazy.
SPEAKER_03That is crazy.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02So we have double the contact rate. So if we have double the contact rate by default, we're gonna have uh, well, let's see, quoted hot. Um two percent quoted hot. Ooh, that's a little low. But that was before. Let's see now. Last seven days. Yeah, went up to four five and a five percent quoted hot. My cognitive.
SPEAKER_03This is riveting, by the way.
SPEAKER_02Isn't it riveting? Who said that? Did somebody say that?
SPEAKER_03No, I I did. Craig is actually eating out of a can right now, no joke. And I don't think I don't know if that's practicing. I have a feeling this was uh this is habitual.
SPEAKER_02What can I do, man? I'm gonna cover things are clear.
SPEAKER_03What is it? Is it spaghettios?
SPEAKER_02No, it's like a little can of chili.
SPEAKER_03Oh. Or Mel? Or denison's?
SPEAKER_02Man. I don't even know how why this was here in the bunker, but it is.
SPEAKER_03Wow.
SPEAKER_02It's called Cattle Drive Gold.
SPEAKER_03Who makes it? Or is that the brand?
SPEAKER_02That is the maker. It is made with sea salt. Has nitrogen protein.
SPEAKER_03All right. I like it.
SPEAKER_02Oh my gosh, 600 calories in a can.
SPEAKER_03Did you eat the whole can? How'd you heat it up?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. I wouldn't know the benefit. Put it on the sun. I'm I'm practicing. Back see that light back in back of me? It's one of those old halogen lights. It's very warm. I just set it up there.
SPEAKER_03It looks it.
SPEAKER_02You're getting used to this. Yeah. What else?
SPEAKER_03Well, I think that uh I think that we should go live every day. What do you think?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Riveting, crazy. I'm with you.
SPEAKER_03We can um we can do uh some of the the four pillars and go do a little dive into each one. What do you think, Mr. Craig?
SPEAKER_02I'm in. I'm in, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03Well, I think that sounds good.
SPEAKER_02We will do it. We'll spend, you know, what five, ten minutes?
SPEAKER_03Sure. Maybe longer.
SPEAKER_02You look at Zoom, it's real time. You go over to Fa the Book of Fosh, and it's like there's a big lag. Did you notice?
SPEAKER_03There is a lag. You're lagging, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_02Oh, you're lagging, Mr. Jason. Well, you need to clean that room up, so you go do that. I'm gonna sweep all this dub Debris that's in back of me.
SPEAKER_03You got the mop.
SPEAKER_02No, first I have to sweep. I mean, there is literally, look at that.
SPEAKER_03That's a mess.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, I don't think that you should be talking about messes. I mean, I don't even know what this yeah, what's in that blue thing back there? I mean, that I don't even know what that is. Looks like a bedpan.
SPEAKER_03Cat food. Cat food. Bedpan. Oh, this thing right here?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Yeah. Can you clean it up at least next time?
SPEAKER_03I will.
SPEAKER_02All right. Well, I say we say uh Cyanora, and we will see everybody uh tomorrow. I'm gonna have to do it a little bit earlier because boot camp starts at uh nine Pacific. Maybe we'll do it after. Let's do it after.
SPEAKER_03Let's do it after. Uh put down any questions uh anybody wants to talk about tomorrow.
SPEAKER_02We'll pick one of the pillars and we will go.
SPEAKER_03I love it.
SPEAKER_01You wanna blit it, blitz it, blitz, blitz? How do you?
SPEAKER_03There we go.
SPEAKER_01Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_03Hey, you've got to check out the Insurance Dudes Inner Circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman