The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Coffee Talk | Fail-A-Dudes Tel-A-Dudes Covid-Dudes Recap-A-Dudes
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee twerk. You know, talk about what? Tog, tortoise, whatever. It's coffee twerk. Coffee tlock.
SPEAKER_01Hello, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_02I got my coffee.
SPEAKER_01It's gonna be good. Oh Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_00Do you have any coffee in your coffee?
SPEAKER_01I didn't. I already finished it. So you're drip dry. What are you gonna do?
SPEAKER_00It's dirty.
SPEAKER_01It's dirty. It's literally bladder on the inside.
SPEAKER_00It's um well what can you do?
SPEAKER_01Oh now we know we're dirty. Yeah, I got that too. Oh, Mr. Craig. Yeah, I'm gonna do it. I was wondering if I wondered if I could trouble you for some hand sanitizer.
SPEAKER_00Well, I was thinking about running down to the store picking up some toilet paper and some hand sanitizer. Do you want me to need some?
SPEAKER_01Yes, please, please do.
SPEAKER_00Does any just just shoot us a message if you need some hand sanitizer? We're gonna go down and grab some.
SPEAKER_01I have 72 cases in my house, but I could always use some more.
SPEAKER_00Well, you can never have too much hand sanitizer. I mean, a lot. Okay. Okay. Maybe if you drink it, it'll make it stop.
SPEAKER_01Well, Mr. Craig, today was an interesting day, wasn't it?
SPEAKER_00Sure was. It really, really, really was.
SPEAKER_01Well, can you tell me some highlights that stuck out to you, Mr.
SPEAKER_00Craig? Well, let me let me look at my notes. Your notes. Yeah. Oh. Well, Chad, Chad had a really, really, really good pointer. So he does this thing where uh when somebody won't buy, somebody won't buy, then he he trains his uh, I think he does it and he trains his team to do it. So they call 30 minutes after. So the person says, no, we're not gonna go with you, blah, blah, blah, whatever, right? They can't close them. They call up 30 minutes later and they just say, hey, look, I get it. Um, I you know, I understand you're not gonna go with us. That's cool, no big deal. But but could you help me just real quick understand why why that why that's the case so that I know what I can do better next time? So just a little non-threatening uh thing. He takes the he takes the pressure off. I like that. Because you know, in the sale, you're a little bit in the heat of the moment, right? Trying to close them, you're overcoming up objections, karate chopping those objections away.
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I liked it.
SPEAKER_01I like that too.
SPEAKER_00He talked about some automation.
SPEAKER_01He did. No, it's true. Um and then one other thing that we were talking about is failure is inevitable when you try stuff.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And that was something that I was uh thinking about the other day. I was thinking, dang, I'm not failing at enough stuff right now.
SPEAKER_00Dang, Gina.
SPEAKER_01Dang, Gina. And um, it reminds me of this quote uh from Winston Churchill that's success is not final and failure is not fatal. It is the courage to continue that counts. And it's crazy how failure, how risk adverse that we are, and failure is such a bad, it has such a bad name. Like nobody wants to fail. But like you have to fail.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, that's how you learn. Think about when you're a teenager, right? You knew everything, but you really didn't, and so you screwed up. But that's how you learned, and the the people older than you, or the I mean, I mean not even being a teenager, you know, when you're first starting in this business. Oh, you the the the older, you know, octogenarians like me may tell you words of encouragement and say, Hey, uh, you might want to try this way, you know, and then what do you do? Young whippersnapper. Yeah, what does the young whippersnapper do? The opposite, right? No, that guy doesn't know what he's talking about. I mean, history repeats itself, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01True, Mr. Craig. Truth. But it's just so funny that that we we do try so much stuff when you're young and it's not a big deal, and we do fail, and who cares? But then when we get older, we sometimes get to a point where it's like you're not even trying anything new because you don't want to fail, and yeah, but then you know what you're gonna get, and usually I don't know.
SPEAKER_00Wonder why that is.
SPEAKER_01I don't know.
SPEAKER_00You know, like uh when you're a kid, it didn't matter. You got up, you fell over, you cut yourself, you cried, you freaking got back up, you learned how to ride a bike, you got on it, you fell over. I mean, if if you if if when you were learning how to ride the bike, you behave people behaved at that age the way they do now in the risk adversity. I mean, nobody knew how to ride a bike.
SPEAKER_01Right, or do anything.
SPEAKER_00Or do anything. And then somewhere, I don't know, is it like in the teenage years, you get so concerned about what everybody else thinks.
SPEAKER_02Right?
SPEAKER_00So worried about, oh, this if I wear this shirt, is that you know, everybody make fun of me, or and I don't know, maybe that's what starts that that sideways thinking, you know?
SPEAKER_01That's true.
SPEAKER_00Because for a long time I was like that, and and now I've come to this place where who cares? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Totally.
SPEAKER_00It's clear that I do not care. I'm in flip-flops.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Oh, you are in flip-flops in the office. Perfect.
SPEAKER_00Locals.
SPEAKER_01Gosh, I gotta I have shorts on and a t-shirt and a backwards hat.
SPEAKER_00I have had these same jeans on every day this week, though.
SPEAKER_01Jeans and flip-flops. You definitely are from California.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, do people do that in Arizona? I don't know. I don't see it too often, but again, don't care.
SPEAKER_01You're just a dude doing your thing.
SPEAKER_00Just a dude being a bro.
SPEAKER_01Have you ever worn a robe to the grocery store?
SPEAKER_00You know, it's funny that you asked me that. When what was it? There was a course in in college. I took a course, and the social and the society it was like sociology, I think, or psychology, one of those somewhat useless classes. And um they that was the thing. Like they talked about norms, like social norms, laws, rules, and you know, there's a different, like each one of those things is more severe, like law. If you break the law, there's consequence, you know. But like a social norm or more norms, it is like it's not a law, it's just kind of like a generally accepted practice, right? Like a behavior that kind of goes with. And they the teacher said, as part of your homework, we want you to go to the supermarket and wear a bathrobe and observe how people treat you. And it was super uncomfortable. Super uncomfortable. I used to do that. You did? Well, you didn't care. Well, did you do it? Did you do it? Back in my drinking days. Oh, you just were hung over.
SPEAKER_01No, I did it, I did it strictly because I did not put on clothes for the day.
SPEAKER_00And and now, and now best in company.
SPEAKER_01That's right. Some company some company that you can't you can't name, right?
SPEAKER_00No, and we wouldn't. It's probably a car company. I wouldn't either. Can you, but are you allowed to say that you can't name it? I don't know. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01If you are out there and you are working for this company, please don't get me in trouble.
SPEAKER_00I don't know. Right? I don't know that people work for it. That's true. Is that a a facade? Am I in more trouble because of the flip-flops or because of not mentioning it? Let's get down to the rattle tattle here.
SPEAKER_01Let's get down to the rattle tattle.
SPEAKER_00You know, last time yeah, go.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. No, no, no. I I want you to go, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_00Last week, I think it was it was, I'd like to talk a little bit more about what we talked about last week. Okay. Coffee talk, which is actually today. It's funny how that works.
SPEAKER_01It's odd, man. You just blew my mind, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_00It's like time travel. You blew my mind, Mr. Craig. Maybe if we talk about it, that screws up the space-time continuum. Anyway.
SPEAKER_01I think so. Let's ask Marty.
SPEAKER_00How many gigawatts?
SPEAKER_01So no one's listening at this point.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, done. Sorry, guys. Last week we got into the right people being in the right places.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I mean, it was just it just it really is very, very important. I've I've messed that up before. I've taken the best producer, turned them into a manager, thinking that they're gonna produce, and then right, they get taken away from doing the production and managing maybe they're and then they ended up not even being a good manager and then they quit.
SPEAKER_01Right. And you're not talking about jazz.
unknownNo.
SPEAKER_01Because at first I was like, dude, jazz is right there, man.
SPEAKER_00Still here, still here. Still being English.
SPEAKER_01Yes. Yeah, no, it's it's it's so true. And putting those people in the right spots is what will help take your agency to the next level, and it also um help fatigue because there can be a lot of fatigue in this interest uh industry, right, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_00Oh, hands down, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01It's true. And I think one of the hardest positions in this industry are are is the sales producer, and I think it is our job to help them and make that as much of a long-lasting position as possible.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there's a few things to that because if you have turnover, that's expensive. Expensive. And what else?
SPEAKER_01Uh well, it's it's time, it's expensive. And honestly, like, dude, you like your. I mean, I love right now everybody that works for me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And with me. And um I under you. I don't want to lose anybody.
SPEAKER_00Right. You know? No, it's terrible.
SPEAKER_01And I want I want them to like it. I want them to be showing up.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, wrecks the culture, all the stuff Grant said with when we had him on, but like not having the right people in the right places then gets them upset and and not like it, which then creates turnover. And when you have turnover, then you're doing more work and spending more money just to do the HR, right? You're doing all this extra HR, and so so it's it's kind of funny. We will do all these things to try to save money instead of taking that person spending a little bit more and giving them tons of leads, giving them people to call for them so that they're doing the one thing that's gonna get them the best results, make them the most money, which makes them want to stay and makes their job enjoyable. Truth. Right? And so what is that difference in savings if you have, I mean, and I'm not saying I'm perfect at it. Shoot, shoot, you know, I mean I violated one of the one of the commandments, which is thou shalt always be recruiting, you know?
SPEAKER_01That's right.
SPEAKER_00I lose three people because it still happens, right? Totally. And because they just weren't, they're not, they're not doing it. But this is the thing, I didn't let them go. These these people left because they weren't getting uh the results at the level that that their peers were, so they self-ejected. Right? And that's when you have that strong culture, then the ones that aren't cutting it, they actually will just eject because they they feel bad. And I'll tell you, like I hired really good people, and and the people that left, I'm I'm I am a little sad that they left because they were good, they were good people, I like them. Um, but but they left because I was I was paying a higher salary base than most people do in this in in the in my area, in Tucson, for sure, right? As a base. And so then if they're not making if they're not getting results, they feel guilty about it. If you're hiring the right people, right? And they did they left, they said, look, I I love working here, I love my job, I I can't do it. I don't feel right collecting this money, you training me, you coaching me, and I'm still not able to get the results. And I said, I respect that. That's fine, man. Are you reading your email, Mr. Jason? No, no, no, it's put you asleep, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_01That's I mean, what do you do, man? What do you do? You go well, you're supposed to be hiring, but you always need to be looking, right? Or looking, yeah.
SPEAKER_00I mean, I we say it so many times, over and over and over and over again. But what are the chances of finding a really good rock star at the moment that that you just lost somebody and you need them?
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Zero.
SPEAKER_01Right?
SPEAKER_00Well, maybe not zero, point oh one. Well, about the same, about the same chances of catching the coronavirus.
SPEAKER_01Wow. Well, you know, who who oh, you know, we're talking to was it was it chat? No, it was Dimitri, I believe, that was uh that he was the one man show, right? But he lined it up to where everybody else, like he's the he's the initial sale, and then he has a team of what 11 or 12 that are helping complete those sales and doing follow-ups and creating the leads.
SPEAKER_00And yeah, he said that he create he created here.
SPEAKER_01I'm trying to look at you with all that paper, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_00I know. Wreck the rainforest. Um yeah, he's well, he spends the time to build the referral network to hustle out, meet people, and then created the his words, assembly line, right? There's the person that generates or that takes the lead in. There's the person who then quotes the leads or two people. So he has two people working all the leads up, and then they tee it up to him. He calls them, closes them, or doesn't. He said a 75% close. Didn't he say 75%? Yeah. I mean, holy moly. Can you imagine, Mr. Jason, if you were closing 75% of the of the 400 leads you bought a day? That would be nice.
SPEAKER_01That would be nice.
SPEAKER_00But again, many ways to skin the cat. But to to this thing that we're talking about right now, he has the right people in the right places.
SPEAKER_01He does. I mean, that's what we try to do with with um, you know, we know that it takes thousands of calls to get down to those to those ones that even will be willing to do a quote, even though that we're not really asking for the quote. We just assume and ask them the questions until they hang up on us, or they get the quote. Yeah. But but it takes thousands of calls to get the the results that we want, it takes thousands of calls. So, I mean, that's where telemarketers come in. I mean, you gotta, you gotta do it. I mean, you want to create a predictable, a predictable machine in your office so that you don't have to stress and worry about the oh my gosh, am I gonna be able to quote this many people today? Are we or I guess you work at it from sales. Am I gonna get this many sales? Well, if you don't have a process and you're not making thousands of calls, you're you're just crossing your fingers, yeah, you're probably not gonna do very well. That's what I used to do. I didn't do very well.
SPEAKER_00Right. But then you put in the predictable process, the reliable people. And and you know what? As you get as you get down towards the beginning of the sales funnel, it's the hardest part, right? As yes or the top, whatever you want to call it, the the the the the closer towards the beginning, the wider the breadth of the of the number of people that have to come in there. And so the the people who are dealing with that layer of it, right? The 500 dials a day, they have to be reliable. Otherwise, right, oh I had a telemarketer, uh, but they you know, they they lasted for two weeks and it's a pain in the butt. And then that's it. Done.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00Just like, and then at the same time, I had leads, I was buying leads, but they didn't work because, you know, we called and they didn't answer. Well, yeah, 85% aren't gonna answer, maybe 90%. Some days 92% don't answer, right?
SPEAKER_01I you know what uh I just did the math in our agency, and on um I think it takes us about, and this is like fresh leads, takes like 92 calls for a quote. 92 calls for the amount of quotes that we're getting. Takes 92.
SPEAKER_00And you're buying the and you're buying leads.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00That's so I mean it's a because there is you know, same um telemarkers, so it's uh 500 dials and they get four to four to six, four to ten, whatever, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00Sometimes two. You never know.
SPEAKER_01You never know, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_00But they're making 500 dials, and that's what you can predict.
SPEAKER_01Because you can measure that, you can you can just, I mean, that's something that you control. You can only worry about what you control.
SPEAKER_00I that that's what I look at, and that's where you can actually find so you know if anybody has somebody calling at their office, you you want to look for how many dials are they making, and then the contacts. You look at the contacts to to gauge the quality of the lead, right? Because if the contact is below eight percent, then there's something wrong. You know? Yep. If it's I mean, if it's I guess there's no ceiling, you'd be happy with anything that's above nine, ten percent. Um because you that's not that's hard to control, right? That's just a function of the data. And probably maybe even geographic, there could be some effects to that too. Um and then what? Number of quotes, right? So then the quotes will indicate if if the contacts are in line, the quotes are gonna indicate how good the the caller is, right? How good your telemarketer is. And if they're not getting uh one per 100 to 150 dials, then there's something wrong.
SPEAKER_01Yep. That's so Craig, you've been working not to completely change the subject again for the fifth time in this.
SPEAKER_00Is it gonna be about back to the future?
SPEAKER_01No, I was at yes. I wanted to know back to the future. So you're writing something for the insurance dudes and dudettes out there, right? Yeah. Do you want to like give a little sneak peek of what you're writing?
SPEAKER_00Yes. A sneak peek? Like show it? No. No, not show. Oh, you mean like a talk?
SPEAKER_01Verbally show it.
SPEAKER_00Verbally. Yeah. I'll verbally show it. Uh the it's it's the uh the agency. Uh, what did we call it? I mean, insurance dudes? Insurance dudes? Bible? That's right. And it's gonna have the four pillars that create success in the modern agency. What are those four pillars?
SPEAKER_01Hiring, training, motivating, and marketing, making it rain.
SPEAKER_00Make it rain. And those those should be the strategies that every agent is focused on, right?
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yep. And we have some um some episodes with those, and it'll be a good thing that we can share with fellow agents. A little, little, you know, something free to just would you call it a little something something? I would call it a little something something.
SPEAKER_00Something something, not something, not something, something. Or or something, something. Yeah. When was the last time you wore your bathrobe to the supermarket?
SPEAKER_01I don't wear my bathrobe that much these days.
SPEAKER_00I don't even have one.
SPEAKER_01Dude, I have a good furry one. It's so fuzzy. Oh it's nice. It's nice. It makes me feel nice inside to think about it, even.
SPEAKER_00I wonder if this quofy talk has run its course.
SPEAKER_01I think it has. So, everybody out there, please sign up for uh the insurance dudes inner circle. You can join our inner circle. Just go to the insurance dudespodcast.com. Join the inner circle. We're doing a weekly newsletter with our man TJ.
SPEAKER_00We're not sending you garbage. It's not garbage. All you will ever get is the newsletter. That's it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. So it's just gonna be um it'll give you a heads up on what's coming up on the insurance dudes. You can be a part of the inner circle and get some some um some stuff when we release it ahead of time.
SPEAKER_00I have a bunch of swag here. You got some swag. Yeah, I gotta send you some swag.
SPEAKER_01Well, we got some some new swag that we're working on. Some uh we sure do coffee talk mugs, coffee talk mugs, some other stuff.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Some other stuff. Do you think there is anybody left?
SPEAKER_01Nope. Nope.
SPEAKER_00If you are left, make a post on the group and just say, I listened to the whole thing. Or don't. Yeah. That we won't we won't be able to track and measure.
SPEAKER_01Okay.
SPEAKER_00We were in the we were in the top ten uh under business. On the uh on the uh the webs? Yeah, on the internets. On the website for business podcasts. How that happened, remarkable.
SPEAKER_01Greg, you know what we used to do at our our sales meetings? What? I'm a little teapot, short and stout. Here is my handle. Here is my spout. When I get off Steam. Tip me over and pour me out. Hey, you've got to check out the Insurance Dudes Inner Circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman