The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. You know, talk about what? Togs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twalk.
SPEAKER_03
Hey Craig, um, this year I got some crazy growth goals for my agency, and actually I've been talking to a few other agents. They got some crazy growth goals. So um, can you tell me a little bit what about what you're doing that's just crushing it in your agency right now?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, well, we're doing a lot of internet data leads uh through a uh company called Everquote, and they're actually one of our sponsors. Ooh, yeah. Can you tell us a little bit about that? Yeah, part of the accelerated growth program, um, which includes having your own consultant that's gonna go over your results, and it's it's positioned to make those leads cost less so that you have lower acquisition costs and makes it totally doable.
SPEAKER_03
Awesome. And so so what have been what has been your favorite parts about it so far?
SPEAKER_01
I like the I like the visibility into the results, um, and and being able to compare what the numbers that they get on their side with the numbers that I get on my side, and seeing that they mesh up. So we know that the data is correct and that we're actually uh in in a cost per policy or cost per sale that uh that makes sense. Right. Yeah, they make it real easy to track. And you know what? Guess what? They gave us a deal to offer to all of the insurance dudes and dudettes out there. Oh, I gotta know about this. Yeah, you need to do is go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes. That's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_03
And they give all the insurance dudes out there a killer price on this. So I'm signing up. Well, hello there, Mr.
SPEAKER_00
Hey, Mr. Jason. Look at that. Where's your coffee? Uh, what is the coffee? There we go. So Mr.
SPEAKER_03
Craig, um tasting earlier, way earlier, way earlier, on the webinar about how important it is to not have your eight players do eight players, eight player, right? Or you the head coach doing those activities, right? And it's being able to complete a work environment where those eight players are, or you are doing the task that are the most valuable for you instead of all the other tasks. Oh, and it starts from the bottom, right?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, it starts from the bottom or from the top, whichever way you want to start, but yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, that's true.
SPEAKER_01
Let's analyze it from the bottom.
SPEAKER_03
From the bottom. So we buy we buy lead them. We're our goal is to sell, right? Buy leads, sell them. Right from the bottom, what do we start with?
SPEAKER_01
You get them over here, the lead comes in, it comes into a management system. Yes, right? And then it has to call somebody. So this person who has raised their hand and said, I want to quote Mr. Jason, right? Yes. They they then the phone rings. And who picks up? Well, on the first line, uh, you know, there this could go either way, right? And I've done and I and and I've done it both ways. You've also done it both ways, I believe. Which is um either a telemarketer or a producer picks it up on that first contact.
SPEAKER_03
Right, but uh how many calls does it take to actually get someone to answer that phone?
SPEAKER_01
I could look at real-time statistics, you want to know? Sure. Okay, and I know it's not that much. 8 to 15 percent. 15 on a really good day, 8% on a typical day.
SPEAKER_03
That's right. And and I know we're both doing like what, six calls, seven calls for that first day. Sure. So that means each person is getting called six to seven times, and only 15% pick up.
SPEAKER_01
So today, here you go. Here's today leads generated today. Okay, okay. I'm ready for the leads that that came in today and the statistics on those leads as of today. Okay. 7% with one company, 6.82% with another company, and 7.1% with another company. Seems pretty consistent.
SPEAKER_03
Those are your contacts?
SPEAKER_01
That's my contacts.
SPEAKER_03
I got a I got 12% for day one.
SPEAKER_01
Man, what did you do over there, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_03
I don't know. Well, I don't know, but the point is this is that's a lot of dials, man. So do you think like the barrier to entry to become an agent? I mean, you gotta take a test. You have to get to know all the systems.
SPEAKER_01
You have to make it through your hiring funnel. Let's go, but let's take it back a second, right? You have to be one you have to be the one of the 60 that entered that hiring pipeline and then be the chosen one that was better and or showed up between all the other 60.
SPEAKER_03
Right, which Craig's referring to our 6021 hiring process where it takes 60 people to book an appointment to actually get 20 people to come in, and then usually one out of 20 um we hire.
SPEAKER_01
There you go.
SPEAKER_03
Which is I mean, that's a lot, man. And then you train them, they they learn, they they take the test, you train them in all this stuff. The easiest way to lose someone is having them do four to six hundred dials a day. We've done every day. It's just it's just too much. I mean, I think it's too much.
SPEAKER_01
It is. I mean and when well, and you know what shows that it's too much? If you can get somebody that'll do it for much, much less and doesn't require this, doesn't have the same barriers to entry in order to do this, then why would you waste a an asset and depreciate that asset by making them do something they absolutely don't want to do instead of the thing that they should be doing?
SPEAKER_03
Yep.
SPEAKER_01
Right?
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, so so that's where the telemarketers come in, and that helps subdivide tasks by skill level. And then those those telemarketers could always become agents if you want, but you gotta have somebody on the front lines, yeah, and the agent. Maybe, maybe you get granular and you have like your eight closers and you have them taking on certain leads or something like that. But we have it as simple as you know, telemarketer, agent to just to keep those agents around, make them happy.
SPEAKER_01
You know, I remember in the olden days, six months ago, when I'd look at at the number of dials that the that the agents, and when I say agents, I mean the producers. Um, some worlds they call it LSPs, other worlds they call it producers, other worlds reps, whatever. You know, but your reps best use of their time is what, Mr. Jason?
SPEAKER_03
The agents closing, talking to people. They just need to be talking to people. Right. If they're not talking to people and they're just pressing a button and dialing numbers, it's an extreme waste of talent.
SPEAKER_00
Right.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
So we gotta keep them talking.
SPEAKER_01
You don't have your all-star running back on the punt return team. Right. That's a football reference, Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_03
Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_01
It wasn't skateboarding. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_03
I thought you meant like a pint, like at at the oh boy, honey. Yeah, but it's just a little food for thought. And I think it's really important to subdivide when you when you start building the agency, subdivide tasks and really making sure that we we don't expect too like we don't expect everybody to do it all, because then you can't even you can't figure out ways to make it better. You can't figure out like you can't quantify a lot of stuff. If it's like, okay, you do it all, you take payments, you write policies, you do every single thing possible in the agency. How do you quantify the progress? You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01
How do you quantify it?
SPEAKER_03
I don't know. How do you judge? How do you rate? I mean, I don't I don't know. Yeah, and there's probably a lot of agents that have a good answer for me. Well, I just don't get it.
SPEAKER_01
Well, progress, yeah. How do you? And we know that that, you know, case in point to oh, the sun's so bright that way. Um case in point, in the same way with with when you're buying leads, you can't expect the result today, you expect the result, you know, over the course of the next 60 days, right? And these little 60-day movers from the one that today, it's the same thing.
unknown
Yep.
SPEAKER_01
You know, if if they're not doing if if the telemarkets aren't making X number of dials and the the producers aren't on the phone for four hours, I think four hours is a solid talk time, right? Hour and a half is not a solid talk time. Hour and a half is not enough by any eight-hour day. No, they're they need four hours. If they're if they do an hour and a half, that's one third of the amount of activity they should be doing, right? Basically, that's four. So so if they're doing one third, it takes them three days to get the same amount of eventual results as they would if they did four hours in one day. Right. I mean, it's just a numbers game. And and you, you know, if they're not if they're not closing when they're on the phone for four hours, well, that's on you because we need to train them. You brought them on, they need to be trained, they need to understand how to sell, right? Understand the psychology of sales, so that's on you. And and also if they're not making four hours, if they're not on the phone for four hours, then what are they doing? Right. I just pulled up mine. Today's a little bit of a lazy day, right? There's an hour. Well, some of them are here for two and a half more hours, but you know, everybody's hovering around two hours right now. So my what I'm curious about, you know, I have a couple people at three, so they're they're right, you know, they're right on pace at three hours. But what are the other ones that are at two hours? What's the situation? So tomorrow morning, tomorrow morning it's it's having a talk at the meeting, you know? What's going on? What happened yesterday? Because at the same time, the sales are a little light today. And it all works off of that activity. Gotta have it. Gotta have the numbers. Yeah. And you know, we we talk about these same things a lot, and and then at my agency I talk about these same things a lot. But the only way to continue to get the consistency, the only way to lead them to the place they need to be is to talk talk about it constantly.
SPEAKER_03
Right. You have to be consistent with talking about it.
SPEAKER_01
And that's it.
SPEAKER_03
To get the consistency.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, that drops off, you know? It can drop off. Just like the gym.
SPEAKER_03
Why is it so hard for us to be consistent? Like, it's not none of this stuff is very hard. And the and the honestly, the winners are the the ones that can stay consistent at it. Why is consistency so hard?
SPEAKER_01
Shiny object syndrome, FOMO, FOMO over for something else.
unknown
FOMO.
SPEAKER_01
Other things take priority. Um if there's one thing I've noticed and and I'm also terrible at it too, is is calendar management. Agents are though I mean agents don't I don't even think think that a lot of agents realize or understand that there's a calendar there that they can utilize. A calendar is great. I can't if I don't put it on the calendar, I'm freaking lost. And then sometimes then I don't look at it and then you're lost. Totally lost. Like, what was I supposed to do? Oh yeah, look at the calendar. I need to set up an event for looking at the calendar. Or a reminder. But it but it's little things, right? If if you don't get used to it, or if you don't create the habit, then you're not gonna do it. And what what's the old saying? 21 days to make the habit, three days to break it.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, it's definitely it's takes one day to break a habit.
SPEAKER_01
I'm not gonna do it today. Like Jamie Alter Alderton jumping in the ocean every day, no matter what the temperature is in England. Do you think he wants? Does he want to jump in the ocean? No.
SPEAKER_03
No, he said that he hates it.
SPEAKER_01
He hates it. But he sets himself up for success because he knows if he doesn't do it, he won't do it, right? The the right the moment he doesn't jump in it, the streak is over, it's done.
SPEAKER_03
Right.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, like you or I, if we go to the bar and we do a shot of tequila, it's over. Right. And so you have to keep that habit, you have to be intentional about the things that you're doing in order to foster it. I don't know.
SPEAKER_03
Totally. No, no, no, it's true. And you know it's funny, what I've uh what's working for me like one area is I'm trying to get my back better. Because again, when you when you uh you know you're focused on one thing and it's so easy to let other things go. I let last year I let my back go because I I have old injuries from the the old bartending days. But yeah, yeah. And then last year I built some cubicles that I don't know why. I remember that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Was that a good use of your of your time?
SPEAKER_03
A hundred percent. No, that was the stupidest thing. I bought them from China too to save money, and that ended up being a fiasco with the whole the just the I thought it was I thought it would be kind of funny too, like just like, oh, I'm gonna figure all this out. If it's just it ended up being a nightmare, worst decision ever. But they dropped a pallet off downstairs outside my office and said, Well, we it's just me. I don't bring it in. Just just thousands of pounds, a pallet saran wrapped down.
SPEAKER_01
So we had to bring in off and then build them and build them, and it was incredible. I tried those before, and it's it is a nightmare. Oh, dude, it was and you could have paid two guys 10 bucks an hour each to put that thing together, yeah. And they're good at it, it would have it would have taken it would have cost you 200 bucks, and they're done.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, so my back over the last year, and then having you know, Evie, our our fourth, and holding the kids and oh, just like all that. I let my back go to the point where I could barely walk. And then um, so it's been going, I've been going to physical therapy for the last like I don't know, five months. But it's like I have to do these exercises in the morning and the at night. Like I have to do them every single day. And part of it is doing like push-ups too for my core and all this stuff. So what I've done with that, and I've been very consistent with it, but even on the days when I have no time, I'll bang out like just whatever I can do, whatever I can do, even if it's just a tiny bit of time so that the consistency is there, so that I don't lose the habit. And so, like all let's say like push-ups, I'll just do as many as I can do, one set done. Like, you know, I do these uh seven-way hips exercises. It's sounds cute. It is cute, it's but I do it every day. And if anything, I just decrease the number of them, but I have to do them every day because it's so important. And I end up doing more than I thought I was gonna do, you know, with than when I started. But honestly, if I just didn't do it that one day, it would be 10 times easier to not do it the next day. Oh, and then you're never gonna do it again. Yeah, because we always have that all in or all out mentality. So I don't know how we got to this point with consistency and habits, but gosh, just a couple rambling insurance dudes. Dude, you're rambling.
SPEAKER_01
Or my rambling.
SPEAKER_03
Ramblin'!
SPEAKER_01
Right? A little Zeppelin for you.
unknown
All right.
SPEAKER_00
Well, I think we need to get it. Coffee talk. A little one.
SPEAKER_02
Little one.
SPEAKER_01
You know, move the needle, your little beetle. What what what is that one called? There's a coffee talk about Don't Deedle move the needle like a raging beetle, something like that. I mean, it has the most listens of any coffee coffee talk the whole time. Coffee talk. Is it because of the name?
SPEAKER_03
Because that's it's pretty Craig and I love writing some of the names of these. Yeah. We're dying laughing.
SPEAKER_01
Why don't we call this that same title number two and see if we move the needle? Test it. Ooh, okay. That's fine. I challenge you to test to call this that. I think it's done. All right, buddy. Well, peace out. Peace out. Jason, I would be remiss if I didn't bring up one of our sponsors. Ever quote. Oh, tell me a little bit about them. Well, I've been using them for a couple months, and I'll tell you that the results are delightful. It's been now a couple months, and and over time, my cost per sale has dropped every single week. That is awesome. Tell me, so you're on a specific program with them? Yeah, it's called the Accelerated Growth Program. And this this bad boy gets you a better deal on those leads, so way less expensive, and you get a consultant that's going to actually go over your results to make sure you're tracking properly.
SPEAKER_03
And so you and you've been doing that for the last couple months and uh consulting with them?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, and I see everybody complain about leads and this and that, and it's like, look, if you don't have a process to track and measure your results, then I can totally get it. You don't even know what your results are, right?
SPEAKER_03
And you asked them to give all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there a killer deal on this, and they came through, didn't they?
SPEAKER_01
They came through, and I know you're gonna take advantage of it, but if they go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, that's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, then guess what? What? Deal City.
SPEAKER_03
I'm there.
SPEAKER_01
Do it.
SPEAKER_03
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the Insurance Dudes Podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.