The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee twerk. You know, talk about what? Glugs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twerk.
SPEAKER_03
Coffee twerk. Hey Craig, um, this year I got some crazy growth goals for my agency, and actually I've been talking to a few other agents. They got some crazy growth goals. So um, can you tell me a little bit about what you're doing that's just crushing it in your agency right now?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, well, we're doing a lot of internet data leads uh through a uh company called Everquote, and they're actually one of our sponsors. Ooh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Can you tell me a little bit about that?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, part of the accelerated growth program, um, which includes having your own consultant that's gonna go over your results, and it's it's positioned to make those leads cost less so that you have lower acquisition costs and makes it totally doable.
SPEAKER_03
Awesome. And so so what have been what has been your favorite parts about it so far?
SPEAKER_01
I like the I like the visibility into the results, um, and and being able to compare what the the numbers that they get on their side with the numbers that I get on my side and seeing that they mesh up so we know that the data is correct and that we're actually uh you know in in a cost per policy or cost per sale that uh that makes sense. Right. Yeah, they make it real easy to track. And you know what? Guess what? They gave us a deal to offer to all of the insurance dudes and dudettes out there. Oh, I gotta know about this. Yeah, you all you need to do is go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes. That's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_03
And they give all the insurance dudes out there a killer price on this. So I'm signing up. Oh, I literally hurt my back when I was trying to get all amped up for coffee.
SPEAKER_02
For coffee talk. Talk.
SPEAKER_01
We we almost didn't do a coffee talk. We weren't going to, and probably we shouldn't, considering we're going long on time, and we we have to do the bumpers. Running on fumes. I have to be at my other office, which is about 25 minutes away in 22 minutes. Yeah, and I have an interview coming up, which brings up a good point, right?
SPEAKER_03
That's what we're just talking about. Yeah. So this is gonna be a quick one.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. It's it's um here here I went complaining about well, yeah. I wasn't really complaining, I was just talking about it because I just got the text from one of my guys who flipped out a little bit earlier because one of the softwares wasn't working.
SPEAKER_03
That happens in insurance, yeah.
SPEAKER_01
It's weird. So, you know, something wasn't working, he had a meltdown because he's trying to close the business and he can't. It's the end of the month, you know, all that. And then meanwhile, um, somebody else did something kooky, and you know, you can't control for these things. Nope. You can't. You told me what you lost top producer.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, yeah, like like people are leaving um for things that are out out of my control, like um uh and uh yeah, things that are out of my control. Oh, it's just so funny. I just got a a message that says that my interview coming in has been changed. Brings us back to the interview part portion of this talk. Um so yeah, so people there's a couple people that I'm losing that due to circumstances that are like moving and um pregnancy and all kinds of stuff, right?
SPEAKER_01
Right. Life happens, life happens, and I mean, I think the you know, we talked to lots of agents on and off this thing, and one thing that you or the thing you hear the most of is the complaining about the the staff, right? Because it can be hard, and and no offense to any staff here, it's it's like you know, we're spinning a lot of balls up in the air or juggling a lot of balls or whatever it is, and and trying to manage all of these different things, and so it would just be nice if this thing ran smoothly, but to your point earlier that I don't think we captured it's not going to run smoothly. It never will, right? The processes could run smoothly, but you're still gonna have to bring people in and people are gonna leave. Bring people in, people are gonna leave.
SPEAKER_03
So you better tighten up those processes. So we so knowing that, like perfect the my idea of the perfect agency is I would have an onboarding process that was lock solid, like so solid that you know, in less than two weeks, they are an expert. Just to every minute of every day lock down, you'd have a hiring process where every week, no matter what, you do that, you know, those interviews or whatever. I mean, literally at all that stuff should just be ongoing. It can never end because it's guaranteed. I mean, what's your average well, you know, what's the average span of a newer employee? What's the average span? It depends, man.
SPEAKER_01
It's tough. I mean, I think statistically, it's it's it's like a 70% turnover in a year, right? You don't keep them. I mean, I think that as you tighten up processes and maybe pay higher, um, then then you may have some long longevity. I mean, there's some agents that have that have had the same people forever, but I think in an environment where you really need to grow and you need to write a lot of business and and the there's a lot of accountability to being on the phone all day and making a lot of doing doing 10 quoted households a day, like that's a grind. Yep. And so I guess they gotta be paid, right? They number one, first and foremost, if you're not paying them, I mean, what's I I would think that it would be more attractive to go work at a Chick-fil-A.
unknown
Right.
SPEAKER_01
Right.
SPEAKER_03
Totally. Yep, and and I think I I think that um I mean that like it's just one of those things that you have to have those processes in place to just keep it going. Yeah. Because because yeah, you might have people that stay here and there um a long time, and then but you're guaranteed to have some sort of turn turnover, you know.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Um well, and I mean, if you're the business owner, then you want to be able to plug in and then unplug anytime, you know, that you want, right? I mean, that's the whole point of business ownership. And so if there isn't a tight process in place, what happens when you leave or you have something planned? You're gonna go somewhere that's far away, and you know, two people quit. If there's no process in place, all of a sudden you're handcuffed to that thing.
SPEAKER_03
And it's it's having the proper expectations. Like that's what started this. Was you were talking about that, and I said it's a it's guaranteed to continue to happen. Like, it's just there's not gonna be a point where it doesn't. You know what I mean? And I think some of us, um, especially in the insurance field for some reason, we think that like, oh, okay, especially smaller agencies, like, oh, okay, I don't have to worry about this. And then when they do leave or something like that, you're like shocked. And then you go into like survival mode. And it's like, dude, the why would you even think uh that this wasn't gonna happen? And if you and if you did have someone for a long time, it's not like I can't believe they left. It's like wow, like they stayed for a long time. You know, that's the mindset.
SPEAKER_01
Are you gonna be grateful or are you gonna complain, right? I mean, let's be grateful. They squeezed you you were able to get uh 250,000 premium out of them. Did you just say you squeezed them for squeezed them, squeezed 250 premium out of them? I don't know. Whatever you want to call it.
SPEAKER_02
What? You're juiced, you're juicing your your stack, man. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
I mean he's pointing to his head. Yeah, up here. Probably, never mind. It's probably consistent across the board and all the different kinds of marbles. You're losing them clearly, buddy, dude.
SPEAKER_03
Well I just think that clear expectations and always be, you know, we talk about it all the time, but always keep those things always be recruiting going and go. That's it. So keep recruiting. You know what? Which brings us up to a good point. You and I have both been using somebody that we really well huge shout out, huge, thankful shout out. Are you talking about DW? Yes, Dave Williams over at Team Hired, Team Hired, dude, and Tom Bianco, dude. Like awesome. Tommy, Tommy B. Awesome, awesome operation that they got going there. Talk about consistency, they work with you. I mean, when we don't have time and we can afford it, like, and their prices aren't bad at all. Dude, just rock rock them. There's no reason, and they they they do it the right way. I mean, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01
I I I get so I I'll run that the the thing, have them all come. I've did it, you know. We talked about I did it in November. I have another one set up for the first week of February here. So in a week or so. And if I can extract, you know, there's already 25 people are SVP'd. If I can get three out of it, I mean, huge. And and it'll it costs a few grand or whatever it is, you know. For I think I don't even care because at the end of the day, it's way less than the agony and pain of looking myself, and I'm gonna have a lot of candidates there. And um, yeah, it works.
SPEAKER_03
And I wouldn't yeah, I I would almost say when it comes down to price, um look at how much time you save, and they're gonna work with you. So don't rule it out. Just see, like, give it a try. Like, call them up, reach out. Yeah, Dave, it's a game, it's a game changeable. Honestly, we've I've tried some some other services that are expensive and they're just expensive, and it's just like, what am I getting? But like you're getting a lot with with Team Hired.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, huge shout out. Olivia's awesome. Um, the whole thing. Yeah, huge shout out to them. But I'm super stoked for the next one because I have I mean, I have four people, four people still here that I got in November. In one interview. One interview. In one interview.
SPEAKER_03
So that I mean that that says everything.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I bring them in and then I give them the the assessment, the um, I'm gonna give myself a plug, the the sales strengths identifier after just to test it, and then then I do uh one-on-one interview. So that's my process, right? But I I'm paying to have the front end, which is the most difficult end, just handled. Because I'm still looking on Indeed and I still fire off resumes. You know how many people I've gotten since November from the resumes that I go check and and all that? How many? A goose egg. Oh, so you got zero from that. How many hours have you put in? I do it when I I do it as I'm checking my email in the morning, but okay. Yeah, maybe I don't know, probably 10, 20 minutes every morning. So add that up. It's a lot of wasted time. I could have couple. A couple hours a week, two or three hours a week. Two or three hours a week. How many weeks have it been? Tons, dozens, dozens.
SPEAKER_03
It's too much. Yeah, it's too much. We all need to figure out ways to save our time. Not I mean, uh, we're in an industry that everything sucks our time. We need to figure out ways to save our time. Yeah, the god of minutes, save our sanity.
SPEAKER_01
SOS. And nothing else matters. Ooh, we're talking about a little Metallica. Ow. Ooh, all right. Well, thank you guys, and thank you, team hired and Dave Williams and Tom Bianco. And uh and you know that wasn't even planned. And you know what? That's the best. Thank you, Jason. Thank you, Mr. Craig. I'm grateful for you. You're a good guy. I'm grateful for you too, buddy. Yeah, couple of dudes sharing sharing a moment live, live, live recorded, like Cyberman Live. See ya.
SPEAKER_02
See ya, Jason.
SPEAKER_01
I would be remiss if I didn't bring up one of our sponsors, Everquote. Oh, tell me a little bit about them. Well, I've been using them for a couple months, and I'll tell you that the results are delightful. It's been now a couple months, and and over time, my cost per sale has dropped every single week. That is awesome. Tell me, so you're on a specific program with them? Yeah, it's called the Accelerated Growth Program. And this this bad boy gets you a better deal on those leads, so way less expensive, and you get a consultant that's gonna actually go over your results to make sure you're tracking properly.
SPEAKER_03
And so you and you've been doing that for the last couple months and uh consulting with them?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, and I and I see everybody complain about leads and this and that, and it's like, look, if you don't have a process to track and measure your results, then I can totally get it. You don't even know what your results are, right?
SPEAKER_03
And you asked them to give all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there a killer deal on this, and they came through, didn't they?
SPEAKER_01
They came through, and I know you're gonna take advantage of it, but if they go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, that's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, then guess what? What? Deal City.
SPEAKER_03
I'm there.
SPEAKER_01
Do it.
SPEAKER_03
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the Insurance Dudes Podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.