The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Rusty & Robby | 129 Year Ol Agency Movin The Needle Outta The 1800s.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Good afternoon, Mr. Jason. Good afternoon. Good afternoon, Mr. Craig. You sound like uh Count Calculoff from the start. Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Who do we have on the show? We are about to get down and dirty with Rusty and Robbie. Ooh. You know what? They got an agency that's 129 years old. Shut up. And they're moving that needle out of the 1800s. Oh, let's get it. Hey Craig, um, this year I got some crazy growth goals for my agency. And actually, I've been talking to a few other agents. They got some crazy growth goals. So can you tell me a little bit what about what you're doing that's just crushing it in your agency right now?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well, we're doing a lot of internet data leads uh through a uh company called Everquote, and they're actually one of our sponsors. Ooh, yeah, we're and I've talked a little bit about that. Yeah, part of the accelerated growth program, um, which includes having your own consultant that's gonna go over your results, and it it's it's positioned to make those leads cost less so that you have lower acquisition costs. It makes it totally doable.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. And so so what have been what has been your favorite parts about it so far?
SPEAKER_03I like the I like the visibility into the results, um, and and being able to compare what the the numbers that they get on their side with the numbers that I get on my side and see that they mesh up. So we know that the data is correct and that we're actually uh you know in in a cost per policy or cost per sale that uh that makes sense. Right. Yeah, they make it real easy to track. And you know what? Guess what? They gave us a deal to offer to all of the insurance dudes and dudettes out there. Oh, I gotta know about this. Yeah, you all you need to do is go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes. That's go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes.
SPEAKER_01And they give all the insurance dudes out there a killer price on that. So sign in up. Oh, we've got a group. All right, a group of two.
SPEAKER_03A group of two, a partnership, a partnership, if you will. Imagine I will ourselves a partnership. What are you gentlemen doing?
SPEAKER_05Oh man, we're great. How are you guys?
SPEAKER_03Good. So I see Robbie Burton and Rusty Rourke.
SPEAKER_04Look at that.
SPEAKER_01So okay, before we jump into anything, I want to know the first concert that you guys went to. I mean, I'm talking like give me Barney or give me something that's fun, like 12 years old, less. What did your parents drag you to? Anything good?
SPEAKER_00So my first concert, I was about 12, it was Garth Rooks and Churchy Earwood.
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's a good one. That's like legit good, though.
SPEAKER_00At the Dean Smith Center in Chapel Hill.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so I won't tell you unless you let me tell you my first two.
SPEAKER_01Let's do it. Sold. Sold.
SPEAKER_05It's kind of a comeback story. So the first one I went to was New Kids on the Block.
SPEAKER_03Nice. Yes.
SPEAKER_05That was in Greensboro, I think. And then uh my second was Guns N' Roses Unshapered in seventh grade at the Dean Dome. And that was, you know, kind of a comeback story.
SPEAKER_01Just tour. Sorry. What tour?
SPEAKER_05Oh, I have no idea, man. That was night uh 1989.
SPEAKER_0189. Appetite. 90s was illusions and 80s were appetites. So it's right on that cusp.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, it was after illusions. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Gotcha. All right. So so take us back, guys. Tell us where where you two dudes are from and and the background story.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so uh we're here in um you know not so sunny Martinsville, Virginia. It's in the Blue Ridge Mountains, the southwestern part of the state. Um, this agency's been here for was it 129 years now, right? It's changed a couple of times, and now for real, 129 years. A long time, yeah. 129 years.
SPEAKER_03You guys don't look a day over 21.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's crazy.
SPEAKER_01Dude, that you guys have you guys definitely have the oldest agency that's ever been on here, so that's nice. Yeah. I'm proud of that. That's cool. That's awesome. I'm almost that old.
SPEAKER_05So keep so uh keep going.
SPEAKER_01We cut you off.
SPEAKER_05Um, you know, I think I took over administration in 2015. We rebranded in 2018 the Burton Company. You know, we had seven trading names across five locations, and you know, that's really hard in the digital space, right? Um and then I'll let you kind of tell your story.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so I've been here for a little over seven years now. Um, I came from an IT internet service provider locally. So I was doing tech support and came here and if they're system admin, so now I do all the hardware stuff, computers, printers, take care of software integrations, move business processes to the digital section of the software. And it's been a ri it's been a crazy ride for the past seven years.
SPEAKER_01Crazy. What what got you guys into this this business?
SPEAKER_05Um, I am second generation. So um, I mean, I'm like a kind of a strange duck in the in and that I grew up always kind of wanting to come back to this. It's what I wanted to do, and so I went off and did some other things for a while, and then my dad called me one day and he's like, Look, man, it's either gonna be you or it's gonna be somebody else. So I was like, all right, cool, man, I'll come back. That was 2003. So it's been a while ago now.
SPEAKER_03What what did you do before?
SPEAKER_05Um a variety of things uh in the food service industry. So like uh managed a restaurant, did uh banquet hall, bar attended cooks, weighted tables, basically everything you could do in the restaurant food industry.
SPEAKER_03Hmm. Yeah, I I've been in that business. Uh Jason has as well. So it seems like a lot of uh that that really gives a good, I I guess, uh back like a good background um in being able to talk to people and in in just having you know the skill set to to do which I obviously right now cannot do.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I'm not gonna I'm not going into the but it's it's not because I didn't have a good foundation of customer service from that, right?
SPEAKER_03Right. Yeah. I I like when when we're looking, I mean, one of the things that I think is is you know the pillars of success of an agency is is to always be recruiting and high and looking for for you know people that are gonna be able to produce results. And I really enjoy talking to people that are from the restaurant industry because we've had a lot of success stories uh from bartenders and and servers because you know they can they know how to talk to people, they know how to think on their feet, they're a little bit quicker. Um, do you guys have your own unique hiring strategy that you use at your agency?
SPEAKER_05Uh yeah, I think so, maybe a little bit. We are really, really good friends with all of the other insurance agencies in the region. Um we we are we have a really good relationship, especially with a lot of the direct writers. So um we love them because they send us commercial referrals and because when people um sort of they train people really well, and then to a certain degree they sort of graduate out of that and and they come work with us. So um, you know, we get a lot of employees from not won't name any, but from a lot of the direct direct writer systems in this region, right? So um, you know, it's been a good relationship for us.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. And and um what do you guys do? Like what uh let's see, uh so you've been you've been there for uh seven years doing marketing, right?
SPEAKER_00Uh do a little bit of marketing, but mainly I handle all the software integration. So we use Salesforce, so I take the processes like the commercial lines and personal lines, like their workflows. Okay. I convert them into like screen flows into our system. So the data entry is you don't have to hunt and peck for okay, this has to go in this field, that has to go in that field. It's just a simple screen. They just enter and roll along with it.
SPEAKER_01So I mean, obviously, I mean that's one of the hardest things with uh, you know, generate a couple generations ago doing insurance to compare with now is moving more into the technology side of it. Um, what would you say is the hardest challenges uh for you guys?
SPEAKER_00Is hearing we've always done it this way.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00So you can't you can't always do it the same way, especially within today's technology technology world. I mean, systems change on an overnight basis, really. Um so you have to be able to improvise and adapt and overcome everything.
SPEAKER_03And you built out you've built out various automation?
SPEAKER_00Yes, yes.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01And so um how yeah, how's that changed for you guys? How's that helped?
SPEAKER_00It's definitely reduced the speed of the data entry. Um, helps with not having to double entry stuff. You know, we put it in one time, through one thing, and it puts it all in the places it needs to go. Um, so it's definitely the biggest I would say efficiency is probably the double the data entry side of it.
SPEAKER_03So so that's probably freed up a ton of time, right? For for the different agents in the office, for uh prospecting, for all the different things. How has that changed the way that that agency operates? Because clearly back in you know 129 years ago, they were using uh horses and I don't know.
SPEAKER_05Feathers and ink. Yeah, I don't know. Yeah, we have we have a couple of policies from like the 1890s for a while. I'll see some pictures of them. I don't know. Do you really? Yeah, they're weird. They don't they don't look like policies, they read differently. But um, you know, it's wow. So so for us, for us, this is like kind of like a quest to find a solution to make small business small commercial profitable, right? It's a challenge, it's a challenge across the industry. Um, it's in there's a whole lot of different ways that's being attacked right now, but we're sort of taking a more traditional stance, right? And saying, let's keep all of the um the things that have been good for us for a long time and just be able to do you know more with less utilizing technology. So, you know, yes, what the overall changes is that's what it is, that we can, you know, we can serve that you know business owner that's you know anywhere from 50,000 to you know, say 10 million in sales, it's a little bit underserved by the bill market, and then um, you know, but still like you know, in our opinion, the backbone of of our region are certainly economically, uh, still requires a high level of expertise. Um, and and they and they deserve it, right? So we we are we can offer that and make money doing it. So, you know, that's um for us that that was the mission, or at least part of the mission, and I think we've you know we've hit some of those targets so far, but there's still lots of lots of room to grow into that too.
SPEAKER_00The end goal I would say is probably to make the customer experience better than what it is currently. You always want to improve that customer experience.
SPEAKER_03And how has it changed? How has it moved more towards a customer experiences versus transactions?
SPEAKER_00You want to manage that relationship, um, I would say. Uh, and with the systems we currently have with the automations, we can track how long it takes us to do an endorsement. So we're then we can look back at that with reporting and say, well, why does this take this long and this take this long? What's the difference in the process? So the end result comes the customer gets a better experience, it's a faster experience for them because that's what they want in today's world.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_00They want now, now, now you know Facebook and social media has you know uh trained us to be a now society. So we had the insurance industry has to move forward as well. And we can't keep doing things the same way we've always done them.
SPEAKER_04Okay. Well, yeah.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, let me just add one thing to that real quick. For me, that kind of all adds up to domain expertise, right? So we can measure everything in such fractional units now that we can say, okay, you know, a bot policy with carrier A versus a bot policy with carrier B, carrier, you know, they they will you know dictate a different service burden based on you know all the information we could put together. So if we if you know carrier A is gonna require 50% less time, then that time should translate directly to customer interactions, then you know, little changes like that along the way, if they start to add up, right? So without that information, you can't make those decisions. And and so you know, getting getting into a different platform that allows us to measure in a different way just gives us a greater level of exp of domain expertise.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. I mean, in today's world, those analytics are so powerful to what you can do to produce results. And and I think there's we you know, we talk to a lot of agents, and there's a lot of um, I I'd say independent agents are much more tech or are are have moved into more tech uh that ensure tech space. Uh and and we're slowly getting there, the captives, um, to to get to where we're utilizing the technology the technology that's available because you have bots, you have um, you know, all of these different things that can create this this automation. Have you guys have you guys gone down the road of of of like messenger bots? Have you done anything like that?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, we've we've dabbled in it. Um we just haven't seen the return right now. Um, I know there are some people like uh Joseph D'Souza, pro navigator up in Canada, doing some really cool things with that. Um it just for us hasn't been the top priority. Um doesn't mean there's not uh room or or you know uh ground to be made up there, but for us it hasn't been the answer so far.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. So that's interesting. So you guys are trying a lot of different stuff. Um what what what gets you excited?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think I think probably like our our our best quality is our uh willingness to suffer completely through all this stuff and to try try everything and figure out uh what works and what doesn't because let's be honest, man, a lot of it doesn't move the needle, right? Um you gotta be willing to fail a few times to figure out what works. Um, and certainly we've we've gotten good at that. Oh yeah.
SPEAKER_03Move the ego to the side.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, you just it it's like um I try to, or we, I say I, we certainly try to maintain that perspective, like when you go to make an intervention, you say, hey, this idea is gonna work and gonna make it better. You know, that's just the ego, right? I mean, we have no idea what's gonna happen tomorrow. So we just try to lay out some measurables and say, okay, if we're gonna do this, and we're the goal is to improve this, but let's also measure some other things, and then we implement it and measure the things, and and more times than not, it turns out we're like, you know, it just didn't, it's just it just didn't make a difference.
SPEAKER_00Um have the grandiose plans and think it's a gonna move the needle, you know, a huge amount, but when we like to look at the data, it's like, oh, well, we just moved it an inch to the left.
SPEAKER_05And it turns out wrong way software companies doing demos sometimes, it turns out, may exaggerate ever so slightly, just with the impact that it may have on your business. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Of course, of course. Wow. When has it always been that way for you guys? Like, did did you or did you develop a plan and say, this is gonna work, and then really push towards that without looking at the data?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's that's learned, right? That that behavior is learned a couple times. Yeah, we we've it's like we just said, hey man, how deep is the river? I don't know, let's just dive in, right? Yeah, you know, and we hit the bottom and then we and we figured out, you know, this is the dumb way to do it. So we try to figure out a smart way to do it, and eventually we've, you know, yeah, we've got a lot of room to grow there too, but we've we've iterated to this point for sure.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome. Um, any any mentors that you guys have have looked up to to get to where you are.
SPEAKER_05I have several. I know. Um we read a lot. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_05We pass around a books a lot, we pass around a lot of books, we read a lot. I have we have a couple of business coaches coaches here locally. Um we work with RD Advisory Group, they're fantastic. Um Christopher Cook is an agent right down the road. I try to listen to him when he talks because his agent grows, his agency grows at like 25% a year. Um, so wow. Yeah, he's he's like he's like the most humble dude in the world, but it would you know, I try to listen when he talks, and then um there's other guys in this group like Jeff Roy, certainly he's like a madman. Uh we try to pay attention to what he's doing.
SPEAKER_00Jeff Roy is insane with his technology stack and what he has going on, like it's crazy. And Seth Zorembo, of course, you know, um, with where he's trying to move the industry to, um and just to listen to him speak, it's amazing. Yeah. So what do you guys special?
SPEAKER_01What would you what do you guys specialize in? What would you say your agency? What's your superpower? Like, where where do you guys niche down?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so we're we're we're niched out in like kind of what our region dictates to us. So we do a lot of distribution, forestry, a lot of nonprofits, um, and then just some general transportation. But again, that's like it's what our region has to offer. So um, you know, I I would say that our our superpower is that we try to be like really, really professional, highly educated agents. Um, so you know, opportunities that are here for us that we can take advantage of them.
SPEAKER_03And what about business, what about acquisition? What are what are some your what's your favorite strategy that you've been using lately in business acquisition to to identify with those markets?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, so our um our digital marketing efforts are my favorite for sure. Um, but we're still, you know, um to sort of compare it to the story earlier of our of the way we integrate software. I think we're still early in that process. We're trying things, we're not being successful with all of it, but I firmly believe that we will, and we're getting traction in some areas, so we'll figure that out. Um, and that's fun for me. Uh, but still to this day, our most profitable way of acquiring business is to develop new producers.
SPEAKER_01Any any um hiring tips that you guys have? Hiring training, how do you how is it retaining the staff? These are some problems that I think we all have in our agencies.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, man. I don't know that I have a great answer for you there. I mean, we we um I can tell you that we you know we use a lot of information. We do like uh the last the last producer we hired, we did three po three different profiles. Um wow. We use like Omnia, we did a Colby test, um, and then there was one more, I forgot the name of it, that was a little bit more thorough. But we have like 25 years of the Omnia profiling on on the books, right? So that we have a lot of information to be able to compare there and we trust what those things tell us, right? Um and then as far as training, we uh for new producers, man, we just unleash the CSRs on them for like a few months when they first start. Um, and that seems to work out pretty well. They producers get like a healthy dose of respect for what they go through, and then they also have to do a wide variety of things, right, to give them a little bit of experience.
SPEAKER_03So a new producer, you you make do a little bit of the loving and hugging with the on the with the service team? Like they're uh yeah, with the clients. I mean, you know, not literally loving and hugging, but you know what I mean.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I mean, maybe sometimes, right?
SPEAKER_03Maybe I guess um depends what kind of agency.
SPEAKER_05Not that kind of agency, man. Um, the um yeah, we try to like basically say to do anything and everything they need you to do to make their day easier for a while, right? Um, you gotta earn your stripes by like, you know, if they say go get some coffee, go get the coffee.
SPEAKER_03Oh wow, like pledges.
SPEAKER_05Like pledges, kind of. Not that intense and that is fun.
SPEAKER_04I would agree with having and hugging. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's funny. That is funny. Cool. Well what what would you guys give advice for any newer agents that are coming into the industry or somebody who just um if you can only give one piece of advice to n another agent that's looking for help, what would that be?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, um I would say learn is it, man. I mean like go to school, get every get your hands on everything, get your hands on, whether that be like education programs to the alliance or the associations or from comp you know company provided business books. I don't care what it is, man. You can't you can't get enough.
SPEAKER_00And don't be scared to try new things. Yep, yeah. You gotta walk before you can run. And sometimes you gotta fall down and cross.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. I mean, I this business is has has so much uh so many areas where you're gonna screw up, right? And and it seems like the best way to learn is by doing those screw ups, right? You mess up and you gotta just dust yourself off and and get back up and keep going. There's just so much to learn and know.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I love that, man. I think that's you know, that's like the definition of experience, right? It's how you get there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, for sure. Well, you guys have anything else that you can think of that you'd want to share with the with the listeners as they're listening now, um, probably on their drive home and all pumped up.
SPEAKER_05I'll say one more thing, you know, thanks for listening, and also you know, make sure to check out uh Beatomic Airwaves. There's a lot of great information coming out from Sydney Rowe, and she's amazing.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, awesome.
SPEAKER_05She's putting out some really complex uh ideas and and making it to where like stupid people like me can understand it. So I appreciate her in a variety of ways. Um, so yeah, check out the atomic airwaves, check out the YouTube channel, keep in touch with what's going on there because there's a lot of exciting stuff for sure.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, Sydney's gonna is coming on, I think, next week. So we're super pumped about that. And uh and guys, thank you so much. Uh it's been awesome. We're doing uh the these quick ones in the afternoon. So um if you guys need anything or there's anything we can help with, uh let us know. Reach out, let us know.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, great, Jason. Thank you both.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thank you guys, nice to meet you, Jason. I would be remiss if I didn't bring up one of our sponsors, Everquote. Oh, tell me a little bit about them. Well, I've been using them for a couple months, and I'll tell you that the results are delightful. It's been now a couple months, and and over time, my cost per sale has dropped every single week. That is awesome. Tell me, so you're on a specific program with them? Yeah, it's called the Accelerated Growth Program. And this this bad boy gets you a better deal on those leads, so way less expensive, and you get a consultant that's gonna actually go over your results to make sure you're tracking properly.
SPEAKER_01And so you and you've been doing that for the last couple months and uh consulting with them?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and I and I see everybody complain about leads and this and that, and it's like, look, if you don't have a process to track and measure your results, then I can totally get it. You don't even know what your results are, right?
SPEAKER_01And you asked them to give all the insurance dudes and dudettes out there a killer deal on this, and they came through, didn't they?
SPEAKER_03They came through, and I know you're gonna take advantage of it, but if they go to go.everquote.com forward slash insurance dudes, that's go.com forward slash insurance dudes, then guess what? What? Deal City.
SPEAKER_02I'm there.
SPEAKER_03Do it.
SPEAKER_02Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman