The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Entrepreneurs On Fire John Lee Dumas Ultra DUDE Mr JLD
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey, hey Ms. Mr. Jason. Mr. Craig. Guess what? I oh man. I am I am so excited I'm gonna keep my pants. Oh you you must be on fire. I am on fire. You know what? I'm feeling the heat in here myself. I feel the heat. The heat, and we're not even in the same place in this heat hug. There's a dude who is literally on fire. Is he an entrepreneur on fire? He is. He's a dude Dumas. Dude Dumas? Is it yes? JLD? Are you talking about John Lee Dumas? I am Dumas so excited. I know. It's actually pretty amazing. I I um it it it we just gotta play it. Let's go. It's a it's a fast, quick, one with the flip man, Mr. JLD. Let's JLD in the house to do this. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It's the internal dude podcast.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. JLD.
SPEAKER_00Boys, what's up, guys?
SPEAKER_01It is really JLD.
SPEAKER_00It is JLD in the flash.
SPEAKER_01You didn't get a clip and put him in here. That is friggin' awesome.
SPEAKER_00That's that's coming. That's my next product.
SPEAKER_03That's nice. Then you could do a million podcasts while chilling in Puerto Rico.
unknownYes.
SPEAKER_03Not bad. Well, thank you so much for joining us. This is kind of a long time coming, and you agreed to do it. And wow, thanks. It's awesome, man. Awesome.
SPEAKER_00Well, listen, I'm happy to be here, fired up. It's gonna be a great chat. So uh let's get rocking.
SPEAKER_03We love it. I love it. So, first question we always ask: what was your first concert?
SPEAKER_00My first concert was Tom Petty at Reeds Woods, right uh little south of Boston, if you guys have ever been to a show there. And uh it was fantastic. I remember, you know, I knew like all his big hits, like you know, just the ones we've all heard of. Um, but I never heard of just like the other ones that were like you know a little more obscure that were on the album but weren't like the big number one hits. And so on the the drive there, I listened to him on repeat over and over and over again. So that by the time I got to the concert and heard Tom Petty go into those, I was singing right along. And I at that point I just became like this massive Tom Petty fan. And like I still will go into my um bathroom in the mornings and about take a shower and shave, and I'll say, Alexa, play Tom Petty, and I'll just kick back and remember that first concert.
SPEAKER_03That is awesome. That's a good one. Love it. Mine wasn't so good. Actually, my mom, my mom uh did correct me, and I did go to the Michael Jackson Bad Tour. That was the first one. That was a good one. I thought it was Paula Abdul, which that's a rough one. Straight up, straight up. It had the scat cat and everything. It was hilarious. So good.
SPEAKER_01Amazing. Cool. So hey uh JLD, you literally are one of the reasons why we're doing this. Like why we why we jumped into podcasting. Um, we had, you know, obviously, just like when you got out of the military, uh, you didn't have any idea how to podcast either, right? And thank you for your service.
SPEAKER_00None. Thank you. I appreciate it.
SPEAKER_01I think you know, so many people, and you talk about it a lot on your show, we do too. So many people create these these these roadblocks in their mind that they can't they can't dive in and do something because there's all the million excuses instead of just doing it. Um, you create the fear. Um, but we just dove in. We just said the hell with it, let's just do it, we'll figure it out. We'll get mics, and you know, as we started duct taping everything together, putting it together, now we have some.
SPEAKER_00Sounds like you figured it out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and it's it's it's the best. And um, it's just that grind. Something that is is similar where you were doing you you committed to a podcast a day, you're you're putting in the effort, and then um, which is very similar to the insurance business. So we're specifically tar uh our audience is insurance dudes and dudettes. Uh that's that's who's listening. And where there's this same grind is that it's daily to become an agent, you have to do so many, so many calls, so many sales to to create this big sum that actually drives revenue. And it's it's a super enormous challenge. And I'm just uh, you know, how did you get into that mindset when you were at the beginning and you just started plugging along? And I think that'd be valuable for our our listeners to to hear how you got through that.
SPEAKER_00For me, honestly, it's about putting in the reps. Like, I'll get that question quite often of John, like, how did you become such a good podcast host, like asking all the questions, challenging your guests, going down rabbit holes, finding a way back out of them, like just really focusing and directing and guiding these interviews and these conversations. Like I could never do that. I'm like, well, of course you can't because you never have before. Do you think I could episodes one through 100? Of course not. I was terrible at my craft, but what did I do? I put in the reps. That insurance agent that picks up the phone call for the first time and gets rejected on the phone is like, I'm so bad at cold calls. Of course you are, because you've never done it before. You need to put in the reps. You need to look at every single one of those phone calls as one tiny step closer to actually becoming good at what you do. So that by call 1000, you actually have a chance. And at that time, it's still only a chance, but at least you're giving yourself a chance because you put in the reps. So, what is the biggest benefit of doing a daily podcast? That in 2,000 days I did 2,000 episodes. I put in the reps. You know, you can equivocate that to the travesty that just happened with Kobe Bryant. I mean, people are just like, how he was so gifted. He was so lucky to be no, he put in the reps. He woke up every morning, he was the first person in the gym, the last person to leave. He was one of the hardest working people in the world at his craft of basketball. And that's why he became one of the greats. And that's actually honestly another reason why such a travesty would happen, is because he was taking that same attitude and drive and putting it into business. And, you know, the impact that he would have had in the business world is like monumental. And the fact that we're robbed of the next 50 years of that is so sad. But you know, that should be an even stronger call to action to every single person who's here. Like, don't waste your life like not putting in the reps on something that you want to be good at. Like, I don't care that you're not good at it today, become good at it a year from now, putting in 365 reps in 365 days. Like you're going to do that. Someone's like, I don't really have an expertise. I'm like, you could spend one weekend on any topic, go to YouTube and type that topic in, say, become better at blank. Watch five hours worth of YouTube videos and tutorials on that one thing, and you'll be better than 98.5% of the world population on that thing by the end of the weekend. So stop putting up these Roblox, these stupid, you know, facades in front of your face, like get over yourself and put in the reps.
SPEAKER_03But you had to have a strong why because I'm sure the first hundred episodes, you're like, at you know, at 50, you're like, Why am I doing this? Like, no one's listening.
SPEAKER_00Kind of nobody was nobody was listening, nobody cared. I was talking to a black room, to a black hole. Yeah, but you know, my why was this. Hey, I want to talk to cool people, just like I'm doing with the two of you today. I love having these conversations. Do you think it was pretty cool for me back in 2012, you know, when I was 32 years old, and just a brand rookie newbie in the entrepreneurial world to have a 30-minute conversation with Seth Godin and then Tim Ferriss, and then Gary Vanderchuk, and then Chris Brogan and Barbara Corcoran, who I was watching every night on Shark Tank, it was unbelievable to have that ability to reach out and have conversations with those people. So even though nobody was listening, and even though I was making no money, and even though I had no traction that was happening, I was still fired up because I was doing something I wanted to be doing. And that's why it's so important that you actually look in the mirror and like take your pulse and say, like, is this something that excites me, that fires me up, that gets my blood moving? Like, is this something that I love doing? And for me, uh yes was the answer when it came to interviewing successful entrepreneurs. That's not gonna be a yes for everybody in the world, it's gonna be a yes for a certain small percentage of the world. Good, join me in the podcasting game. But for all the other people that are listening, that's like that doesn't interest me. Obviously, it's not gonna interest everybody, and that's a good thing. So, what does interest you? Go do that and go do it more often by putting in the reps than anybody else's and become the best in show.
SPEAKER_03Love it. And a lot of the dudes and dudettes out there are part of Fire Nation. Can you give us two, maybe a couple things of behind the scenes, something that you know, maybe that you don't talk about that often that might be of interest?
SPEAKER_00Well, honestly, there's nothing that I don't talk about that often, just because I do pride myself on being a super open book. I love transparency. I love being as open and honest and try and just genuine as possible. That's why for 76 months in a row, I've been publishing our monthly income reports, like literally opening up our finances with my CPA, with my lawyer to make it all, you know, official and believable that, you know, these are actually real numbers. Like we want to like bring that genuineness to everything that we do. But also, you know, in these income reports, like showing what's not working and how we're losing money. Like we're about to be spending over $200,000 in Facebook ads on this upcoming promotion that we're doing for Tony Robbins. By the way, spoiler alert, we might fall flat in our faces and lose $100,000, $150,000, $200,000. Who knows? Or we might make a million dollars. Like you'll know because my income reports will show that later on this year. But guess what? Like, I don't know what's gonna work, but I want to be open and transparent of what works, what doesn't, so you can emulate our successes and avoid our failures. That's big time. But you know, kind of maybe open up a little different side of things because I talk a lot about business with most people, is just my passion about health and wellness. And look, looking at both of you guys, like I can tell that like it's obviously something that you must do at some level because you're not obese and fat like most of America is right now. But the the reality is for me, I couldn't enjoy my wealth. I couldn't enjoy my success to the level that I do if I wasn't in great shape, if I didn't spend the time that I do every single day exercising, meditating, journaling, getting my inner game right so my outer game is right as well. And that's really big for me. So eating the right food, doing the right exercises, strength training, cardio, you know, again, putting that right food in my mouth, having my my headspace so I can do journaling and medit and meditation on a daily basis to make sure that I'm clear and focused. Like that's one thing that I don't get to talk about a lot because it's not super business tactical, which most people want, which I get because I love that stuff too. But I'm passionate about self-care because I know that getting eight hours of sleep a night, I know that eating the right foods, putting in the right work on the exercise machines and the weights and the meditation, the journaling. That's why I didn't just win for three years, but I'm now winning for seven going on 70 years. Like I might live till I'm 150. I might get hit by a bus and die tomorrow, but I might live until I'm 150 years old because man, there's some really cool stuff going on in this world when it comes to, you know, just all these breakthroughs that are happening with cell genetics and stem cells and all this cool stuff. And A, I'm gonna have the money and B, the desire. And C, maybe I'll live long enough to see some pretty cool opportunities coming my way.
SPEAKER_01Well, and you're also you have access to talk to the people that have this knowledge, right? You've put yourself into that position. And that's part of the reason why we did this. I mean, ultimately we wanted to talk to you and talk to the Tony's and talk to the, you know, the and Gary's and all of these folks, but it's given us the ability to reach out and talk to people who we wouldn't have talked to and and most definitely our audience would not have heard from, you know, and and we're super stoked to turn them on to your podcast also. I mean, it's it's huge because that's made a huge difference in the way that we think in this industry that's that sometimes can be a little slow to move, right? They're they're very risk averse.
SPEAKER_00And so that's why it's exciting that you're doing what you're doing because you're taking what's working in a certain industry, in a certain field, in a certain niche, and bringing it into your world. And that's really exciting, and that's one thing I talk about a lot as well is the ripple effect. And that's why I love when I hear, right, right, we open the show up, you saying that, hey, John, you're an inspiration for the show even existing. And I love that because it is hard work doing 2,000 episodes in 2,000 days, and not to mention doing all the other things that we've done with Podcasters Paradise, with my journals, with my traveling the world, speaking and doing all these different things. It's just hard work, like work that I love, but it doesn't make it not hard. It's still hard work. And to hear that, like now you guys are going to be going out and inspiring a whole you know generation and segments of people in your industry is awesome because like that's a ripple effect that you know I've had a hand in. And you know, together we're just making this world a better place.
SPEAKER_03Love it. Absolutely let's talk about real quick um about mentorship. I know that uh you were part of Russell's inner circle, and I know that was kind of a game changer for you, and I'm sure that um you've talked about other forms of mentorship.
SPEAKER_00Um, so yeah, I just got back from a five-day mastermind in Arizona with Russell, with Dean, Tony, I mean, like just like the highest level entrepreneurs performing right now because for me it's all about all ships rise in a high tide. So, how can I get around the most successful people so I can continue to up-level my game? But I kind of cut you off there. So, back to your question.
SPEAKER_03No, I love it. So, yeah, go a little, you can go a little bit more into that if you don't mind.
SPEAKER_00But that's what I'm saying is like you're the average of the five people you spend the most time with. So if you're in the insurance game, like you want to be surrounding yourself with insurance agents that are performing at high levels, and you want to be talking to them, you want to be learning from them, you want to be adding value to them. Like it's so so powerful and so inspiring. And there's actually a quote I got I want to share with you guys. I'll have to pull it up here in a second. Um, but it's it's it's so true and it's so real. Um, I just read it today on James Clear's um newsletter, which is an amazing newsletter. And you really just have to make sure that you are around the right people, but not just being this leech sucking for them. You want to be a leech sucking from them, but not just doing that. You want to also be adding blood, you know, to that as well, be adding value and and and thoughts and ideas. And you can do that. It's just important that you do do that. So, here I'm gonna pull up this if I can right here. Yeah. So let me just get this up right here.
SPEAKER_03Um and I think that's that's a great point that you had because um I think a lot of times, especially in our industry, there can be so much negativity. There's the the high performers and the low performers. The low performers just sit there and they suck from each other this negative energy.
SPEAKER_00And it's like they talk round in circles about woe is me, this isn't working, that's not working. Thanks for giving me a second to pull this out, by the way. So the quote is before you ask for readers, write the article you wish you could read. Before you ask for the sale, create the product you wish you had. Before you need support, be the supporting friend, before you need love, be the loving partner. Always give value before you ask for value. And here's a great example. I made that into a quick little um text message, uh little uh text replacement. Just I hit R R R on my phone and that whole thing comes up. Because I'm gonna start sending that message out to so many people because on my Instagram, you know, I've got a big following, 200,000 plus followers, and I post every single day there. And I get so many people just say, dude, follow me, dude, follow me, dude, help me support my page. And like, I just want to be like, why would I ever in a million years do that? And why in a million years would you think somebody would do that? You're just you're just there, you know, like my stuff, support my page. Like, what are you talking about? Like, you need to understand if you want to get value from somebody, you need to first give value. So I'm literally responding to every one of those idiots with those with that entire phrase there. And one person wrote back, like, bro, I appreciate it, but just like my page, I'm just like, you know what? You're literally never going to get it. And I honestly feel empathy for that person because they're never gonna win, ever. And it's sad.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. And it's possible that maybe that that's the best thing that could happen to them is you telling them no so they could stop and maybe figure it out. That's the goal.
SPEAKER_00That's the goal. That's the hope. And again, I gave you the example of this person that still was just way over his head. And some people still gonna get it, and you're just gonna move on and just hope other people are reading that quote, laughing at that person, and thinking that in their life. So, guys, we got one minute left. What do you got for me?
SPEAKER_03Boom. What's one question that no one asks you that that you wish they would ask?
SPEAKER_00Oh, John, why do you have such an engaging smile? Nobody ever asked me that. And I gotta say it is from my dear mother. She just has a smile that lights up the room, and you know, I remember honestly as a child and as a young adult, like just seeing that smile and saying, you know what? A smile goes a long way. And I actually have on my daily checklist of things to do the first thing is smile. And I look at that even though I'm kind of like, you know, just like the grimacing at my computer, like I'm like, there you go.
SPEAKER_03Love it, love it. Well, that brings that smile brings uh joy to so many people, man. So so thank you so much for doing what you do. We appreciate it. And uh we're gonna we're gonna tell all the dudes and dudettes out there to you know keep promoting that.
SPEAKER_00Dudes, dudes prepare to ignite.
SPEAKER_03So, Craig, not only are we both agents, but we talked to a ton of agents out there. And I feel like a bunch of agents have been talking about the aggressive growth goals this year. Yeah, but you know what the problem is? What everyone's running into shifting their focus from service to sales, and they're trying to do this quickly. But where do you find the growth and how do you do this quickly? They all ask, right? Ask any agent.
SPEAKER_01It's not an easy task. Well, right now there's thousands of consumers shopping online for insurance. In fact, Jason, according to a JD Power study, 74% of insurance shoppers start their search online. Dang, I know, right? And you need a way to connect with them, but it's tough to do on your own. That's where a trusted partner can really make a difference. Connecting you with insurance shoppers in real time and helping drive some serious growth.
SPEAKER_03Well, you know, Everquote is the nation's largest online insurance marketplace with millions of consumers visiting their online sites every month. They're able to connect you with people who are actually shopping for insurance. Not just submitting info. Yeah, not just submitting their info to win a free iPad. We all see that one, right? Yeah, I've seen it. And Everquote's leads are delivered to you within seconds from the time they complete that form.
SPEAKER_01And one of the best things about Everquote is that they're nothing like your typical lead vendor. They become a true partner in your business. You get your own dedicated support, recommendations, and insights to help optimize your results. Plus, uh right, plus tons of best practices. And guess what? What? A great blog. And guess what else? You laid on me, Craig. A resource center to help you with everything from hiring to dealing with common objections. How awesome is that? That is awesome. And I don't think anyone should go at it alone with an average lead vendor.
SPEAKER_03Heck no. Work with a true business partner that has helped thousands of agencies just like yours, Mr. Craig, grow. And right now, Everquote has a special limited time offer for all the dudes and dudettes out there. Did you know that?
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. You know what they need to do? They need to go to the website and they can learn more about the offer and start the conversation about growing their agency now. The links down below in the show notes. Now let's get back to the show. Oh, let's do.
SPEAKER_02Hey, you've got to check out the Insurance Dudes Inner Circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the Insurance Dudes Podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the Insurance Dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman