The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. You know, talk about what? Glugs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee tok. Coffee tok.
SPEAKER_01
Well, okay. So it's coffee talk, and we've just been having big problems the whole time.
SPEAKER_02
Big problems. Time burners. Time burners. So speaking about time burners, we were talking earlier about processes. We sure were. That's for sure. And we were discussing with a gentleman that will be on our uh podcast later about uh his processes. Don't you mean a dude? A dude. A dude about his processes. And so what he did is um he was flipping some real estate, came out with a process, and then packaged that process and sold that. And now he's making tens of millions of dollars. Tens of millions. If not hundreds. Because of those what? Processes. Processes. And we were speaking earlier in a group about like internet leads and data leads, and everybody wants to know. Yeah uh how do how what's the magic bullet? And honestly, it comes down to processes. Processes.
SPEAKER_01
Because if you you have to you have to have processes, otherwise you can't track and measure what's happening. Tracking and measuring, you have to be able to measure. So let me give you an example. And I don't think we brought this up, but I have two, I have two um really like it's a good example because these two of my LSPs or sales guys that sit next to each other, and and how in how insanely disp different, not disparant, disparant, how insanely different they are. Okay. One of them I would call an Alan Iverson. Okay. Because he's naturally gifted but doesn't want to follow the processes.
unknown
Right?
SPEAKER_01
Doesn't want to run the plays, doesn't want to practice. And then we have the other one who is not naturally gifted. Okay. I call him a robot sometimes. Like we and we, you know, jokingly, like we all get along, and and and he knows, like he's very clear. He's like, look, I just need the thing and I will follow it. And right. So so what happened is he's following it perfectly, and this guy has the most talk time of everybody. He's the hardest working one, four and a half hours, but he's he's struggling to close. But right, but by having the right and he and he tested well on the sales strengths identifier, so he's he can sell. He just in this environment getting data leads that are probably the hardest to close and have a longer have that long sales cycle, he's great up until there's a there's an objection, and he hasn't heard that objection before. Right? And you know why? Because our process was super tight up until the close, but then no process or really strong one that he felt comfortable with, and we practiced after that. And so in talking with the guy that we just had on, F and Stefan. Ooh, yeah, what in talking with him, I started getting in the weeds like I normally do. I go in and like I have to figure it all out. I should have been an engineer, I guess. But he he I said, you know, what about the logic? Like, what if they say this? Do you do this? Or if we say this, should we do this? And what did he say, Jason?
SPEAKER_02
He follows the Jordan Belfort straight line method. The wolf of Wall Street. So in and in that method is you figure out everything that you have scripted out, you know the answers to the questions. And no matter what the answer is, it goes on to the following question. Or the following step, right? Well, yeah, or step statement question, yeah. So it basically you just follow the straight line, and no matter what, as long as you read that out, it's it's so funny.
SPEAKER_01
Even in the seven steps, the the that's you know, the the thing that you do in sales blueprint, the the trusted advisor stuff. Overcome objections, the step overcome objections doesn't have a million different ways that you go, it's always the same thing, and it's like it's just clear, it's clear as mud that we're going about it and making it too difficult. Like, okay, because he would go, if he says this, what do you say? If he says this, what do you say? If he says this, and it's like it doesn't matter what he says, it's all the same. Right. To your point of you peel back the onion, you peel the onion. Because no matter what the what the objection is, it's likely not what the objection is.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, and it so it's super good. Like this is what we teach um our staff and stuff is to keep asking questions. Okay, it's too high. And well, what about that was too high? But just keep that mentality where you and it's it's good because it frees up you from having to talk. Yeah, the the person talks, and then you get down to exactly what it is, and you can start, I don't know, telling them solutions to their problem and keep the conversation going. It's almost like not like a close, it's almost like a conversation that you want to keep going and you want them to lead it.
SPEAKER_01
And totally turn it around, too. We'll say, um, or something that my mentor always would do with me if I came up with an excuse. But if it wasn't that, what would it be? Right? So I need to talk to my wife. If you didn't have to talk to your wife, what would you have to do? Right. And they're just like, huh.
SPEAKER_02
And so that's the that's the granular granular of that part, and what and that's great, right? That and and there's some different sales methods on on those parts. But then I think as uh what's that? You cut out the I think as agencies, oh, well, let me go back. I think that that is a we we have we we hear that sales process everywhere, overcoming injections and all that stuff, but you also have to have a process in which um how do the leads come in? Uh what does it look like? A fail-proof way that those leads don't get lost, a fail-proof follow-up way. Uh follow-up um uh it's almost like a choose your own adventure, but you have to write it. So, how do those leads come in? Uh, what's the email sequence that goes out? What's the calling sequence that goes out? Um for us the hearsay texting sequence. The hearsay texting. Everybody has to on on that first call um say, hey, I'm texting you, whatever right now, just text back, yes. So so basically, you want to write out the entire process of from A to Z, how you want that to look. Because I think the hardest thing for us as leaders um is to convey the message clearly of what we expect and what we want. And with that, I mean it is hard to it's hard when it's not written down. Like we all as leaders need to take the time to write down what we expect and the clear path of that. And it becomes very easy for them to follow that when it's written down, and it becomes very easy to hold people accountable when that's written down.
SPEAKER_01
So as people it's all this work up front, right? And that's what prevents us up, it it prevents us from doing it. But once that work is done, yeah, it's just tweaking and measuring. If you don't do that work, then it's a heck of a lot more work. Yeah. The other side, and it's costing you a lot of money.
SPEAKER_02
Right. And that's the thing, especially when you're running like a ton of leads and a ton of agents and everything, you need to have everything written down because you want to see where you can. So we've gotten our cost for policy down really low, but it's just the only reason why is because we started somewhere and it was an expensive entry because you got to buy all these leads, right? And you kind of have a process when you first do it. But how do you know what the process is if you don't have a process, right? So you you have this general idea of how to do it and you buy them. And then within that, you're like, okay, now I need to write the emails like this. I want them to sound more natural. So how's the email sequence? How's the calling sequence? Um, different leads usually have different uh a different way to approach them. So you can tweak all those areas, just like anybody does on any business, right? Just you tweak those all the different parts to it, and then eventually your cost for policy that was just astronomical gets tightened, you know, down, down, down, down. It is expensive at first, I will say.
SPEAKER_01
Because time is the most valuable thing, right? It is, yeah. So I mean you notice what I just did.
SPEAKER_02
Yes. What the the the fashe? I see fashe bootfash.
SPEAKER_01
The book of flash. It's a little coffee talk live in the book of coffee talk live, talking about the process. The process.
SPEAKER_02
The process.
SPEAKER_01
What and and there's it's for everything, right? Not just so there's the sales process for us the seven steps, or whatever process you're using. Then you have what you're talking about, which was was the process to how are you working the lead once it's in. What about the process to get the leads?
SPEAKER_02
Right. Exactly. And and those those things can be tweaked. I mean, everything can and must be tweaked, and tracked and measured. Tracked and measured.
SPEAKER_01
But you have to set it up first.
SPEAKER_02
You do. Yep. And so when people say, like, what's the you know, how do you do that, or how do you do doing those sales, or anything like that, it's like, dude, you got to get on the track if you're gonna if you're gonna race. So get on the track, start it, and then you can start tweaking the process. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01
It's a lot, I mean, it's it's it's really hard because it can be there's so many different processes you have to put together, and then each one of them takes so much time to get where it's down and you're doing it, right? Yeah. So um, but hey, I I is it's it's just it's just get on the track. Yep.
SPEAKER_02
So a couple of things that like you gotta do training, you gotta do, um, you gotta do the overcoming objections, what you normally see, but then you you have to um get into the weeds of where you buy because everybody the leads all come from the same places. So where are you buying your leads? What little tweaks can you do into the leads to kind of get a little bit better lead?
SPEAKER_01
But they're all yeah, let me let me time out you there for a second, because I think that's really important. You always hear and you always see, have you heard about this lead place and how are they doing? Right. Or, you know, hey, which leads are the best? I mean, dude, you know which leads are the best? The ones that don't cost the most. Because as long as the and we're asking the wrong question. The the question shouldn't be which leads are the best. The the question should be what is the process that you have for working those data leads, for working those live calls, for working the aged leads, right? Right different kinds of those leads, but what is your process? Because you could go to a show. You know, one of the guys here in Tucson, uh, we'll do a shout out to uh uh uh to Duncan out Duncan Duncan. Um Keith Duncan, man, I'm can't even think when I'm on the spot here. But Keith Duncan goes to the uh the it's called Saba. It's like the Southern Arizona Home Builders or Association or something. He does that every year and he gets all these leads, right? I know well he must get all these leads. I'd I'd assume that's what he goes there for. But you know, is there a process on the back end to work those leads? So you you know, likely there is because he continues to go back and gets results from it. Yep. But you I've also heard people go, Well, yeah, I had a booth, but I didn't get anything out of that. Well, what did you do? Did you call them once? Did you text them through hearsay one time? Did you what did you do? Right. You know, for us, we when a when an interwebs lead comes in, I mean, they're getting hit every two hours the first day, the second day, the third day, it's every four hours. Then then it starts to trickle off. But we're not we're not talking to what what is it? I I mean lately our data is indicating that we're not getting a quote or talking to somebody until about the tenth call. Tenth. Yep. How many people call beyond the third? Right. That's it. So I don't care. I'll buy all the leads because you know what? Nobody else is calling past the third or fourth.
SPEAKER_02
Right. Except all the dudes and dudettes that are listening, right? Yeah, it's that's a hundred percent it. And it's just it all has to be written out. There has to be a process to it. I mean, uh even a follow-up process, process. If you're buying all the leads, what what is the lead cost over three, you know, one month, three months, six months, one year? It drastically goes down.
SPEAKER_01
I was a month behind you, and I remember what two weeks in, I'm like, dude, we're not we're not closing in them, and then I'm saying 500 bucks a day. What do we what do we do? And you're like, I said crank them. Trust the process, buy more. He said you're not buying enough. Keep buying more. And I think this this month to date from ALM, the one that everybody hates, 31 items. Oh, wait, nice. You know what? He just got three, and then earlier today we got another three with a life, and I think those are all ALM. So six or seven today from ALM. Nice. So don't buy any ALM because I want them all. At least not in Arizona or California, right? Please, yeah. But if you do have anybody moving to Arizona or California, you know who to talk to. Plug. Which Craig doesn't actually have plugs. Um, it's all natural up there, isn't it? It is all natural. Not bad for an old dude. I mean, that's right. And all the hair is still here. All the hair is still there. Actually, this is what it looks like when you do this business and you're 21. That's right. I am 17. Well, you behave like you're 17. That's what you know, Alf says. You have Alf on your wall. That's right. Boom. Who do you prefer more, Alf or E.T.? Alf. Alf. More relatable. Yeah. Yeah. He doesn't say much, E.T. He's pretty quiet.
SPEAKER_02
He just wants to go home.
SPEAKER_01
And he got sick.
SPEAKER_02
That's not a fun. Who wants to hang out with somebody that just wants to go home the whole time?
SPEAKER_01
And take apart your little your little wordplay game.
SPEAKER_02
Right. Alf wanted to eat cats. That's interesting.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
I'm not I'm not a huge. He froze. Just me. I don't I don't want them to be eaten, but uh I'm more of a dog guy. Yeah. Yeah. Would you say you're more of a dog or cat guy?
SPEAKER_01
You seem like a cat guy. I'm becoming a neither.
unknown
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. I'm in a neither. I hear you. You're heartless. I hear what you're saying. You're heartless. It's it's the kids talk you into it, then you get it. They promise they're gonna, it's the same old, age old thing, you know? Right. They're gonna take care of them, they're gonna do all the work, and then who does? Who does all the work? Right. And then you resent that. You don't want to, yeah. You can't go on vacation. The dogs don't even like me.
SPEAKER_02
That's why you don't because they they smell it. He doesn't even want us here. Look at him up there. Meh.
SPEAKER_01
Eating his food. One of the dogs. Not even giving me any. He's so dumb he ran into the wall and knocked his tooth out. I mean, come on. Come on. Perfect. All right. Well, we lost everybody, so yeah. What can you do?
SPEAKER_00
Coffee talk.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Is that it? Does anybody have any questions? What if there uh we could take a question live?
SPEAKER_02
Oh, oh, a little extended coffee talk.
SPEAKER_01
Nessa Gundr. This says, I could get a shitload of leads.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_01
What's up, Craig Pretzinger? Nobody gave you a shout out. Yeah, nobody's typing anything. I guess they don't want to uh one of your agents or the dog? Well, uh, no comment, Ryan Cheo. No comment. I don't even know where you're seeing all this. On the on the book of Osh. Oh, the book. Did it not? Yeah, I'm live now in the insurance dudes group. Gotcha. Yeah. Crankin. Cranking. Um, okay. Well, looks like uh our viewership is dwindling. So why don't we wrap that up? Yeah. Sounds like something else you wanted to dive into? Deep dive. No, I'm tired today. And if you if you have iTunes or one of the other ones, Spotify, of course, do what I always ask, which is give us a review and uh little rating. This guy back right there. The jazz, that guy is on today. That guy's good one. I'm pointing right at him.
SPEAKER_02
He gives the deep dark secrets of Craig and the uh dangerous things that he's doing in his agency, so you gotta listen to it. What? There's no there's no dangerous things.
SPEAKER_01
Well, the skydiving and the yeah, the underwater ballet dancing. No, none of that. None of that. All right, buddy. All right. Well, you have a uh a great one. We'll see you next Dudeness Day. Sounds good. Yeah. Then the following. We're out. We are out. We're out. We're out.
SPEAKER_02
If I can figure out how to turn it off. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the Insurance Dudes Podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.