The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twerk. Uh you know, talk about what? Tog, daughters, whatever. It's coffee tok. Coffee talk. It's coffee talk.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, Mr. Jason, did you just slurp down a cup of joe? That was a good cup of coffee.
SPEAKER_01
I'm Jazz. Oh, are you? I'm not your jazz. I see him in the background there.
SPEAKER_03
Right there.
SPEAKER_01
You know, it's a new year, and a lot of people want to lose weight. They got all these new year's resolutions, right? Yeah. You hear it all the time. You got one? Um stay consistent. Stay consistent. So we were talking a little bit um about habits. And a lot of time we create these giant habits for us, like, oh, I gotta lose weight, and I'm you know, and then we then it's like, okay, so I'm gonna go to the gym for an hour. Dude, you haven't been to the gym in six months or maybe six years, and you're just gonna go for an hour. It's like crazy. It's like the amount of it's either it's either ding dongs and ho-hos or whatever, or it's I'm gonna work out for a long period of time, right? Uh-huh. It just cut out, yeah. No we're good. Okay. So it's either just we're eating crap, or we're gonna work out for a ton of time. Why that's such a big gap. Like, so I was reading this book, and we're they're talking about you gotta two things. One is create a habit. To create a habit, just go to the gym, walk in the gym every day. Like, start there. And if you're there every day, that's what that was one of the things. So that's from a book called Atomic Habocks. That that was another. Yeah, just walk in the gym and then eventually, you know, be there for 10 minutes, be there for 15 or whatever. Eventually, you're gonna want to when you have that habit, you're gonna want to work out if you're there, anyways.
SPEAKER_03
I think, didn't he say you start by just just doing your route, your route to work, drive by the gym. Right. Yeah, you start to drive that direction, right? Yeah. And then it's like, okay, now stop and go in. Like you make it so baby step, and then you're doing it.
SPEAKER_01
Yep. And so that's that's the thing. Um, is that we gotta going into this next year, and if you really want something to stick with our habits, we got to make realistic habits and just small, small habits that will eventually add up and create the result you want. And then another little nuggets uh that I that um somebody else said recently was you create a micro habit, something that is super simple that supports the big habit. So if it's pack your gym bag the night before, you know what I mean, or put on your gym clothes the night before, or Jamie Alderon, put on your swimsuit so you can degrees. But do something that's super easy that supports that habit so that when you're you know, when you're like, ah, I just don't feel like you're like, but I already kind of set this up and ah, you know what I mean? So it really helps you create that.
SPEAKER_03
That's that's what I love about Orange Theory is once you sign up for the class for the next day, uh-huh, if you don't cancel it within eight hours, they charge you 12 bucks. And it's 12 bucks, big deal. But but you're thinking, well, I already pay $125 to have this membership. Now I'm gonna pay 12 bucks every time. It's like you already feel like a loser if you cancel, right? And then on top of it, you're getting whacked 12 bucks. So yeah, I don't pay that 12 bucks. I'm just like, well, I'm gonna go because I'm not paying 12 bucks.
SPEAKER_01
Right. That's awesome. I like that one. Well, that's it, man. I mean, it's just we gotta create those good habits, and then I would I would say the third thing to that is if the habits that we are doing, if the people that we want to be like have different habits than we have now, our habits are what got us here, right? So if we're doing the same habits that we always do and we expect to be where Joe Schmoe is, but Joe Schmo has a giant agency and he's crushing it. Well, do the habits that he has, don't do the habits that you have. Your habits got you where you are today, right? Like follow those habits. You plateaued, yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Follow Jay Atkins I was gonna say jump in Jay habits, yeah. Right, and then Jay is trying to get to the Grant Cardone level, and then Grant's trying to get to the Tony Robbins level. Oops, and you know, so yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So I mean it's it's all it's it will we everything we do is based off of little habits.
SPEAKER_03
So so let's dive a little bit deeper. What are some little habits that an agency owner could could could work on?
SPEAKER_01
Number one for the team, I would say, is have a meeting uh daily. At least one. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
And if not two. We it it got kind of tough to have our afternoon one now, like we're just doing our morning, and I'm gonna try to get back to the doing both, but it doesn't have to be long, right? Like that's the thing is is everybody meeting in and of itself is the shittiest word ever. You know, like nobody wants to go to ah, it's a meeting, right? Like, I can't handle five minutes past you know the the start of the meeting, but I'm done. Yep, so make it quick, five, ten minutes. You know, rip riff on a talk, have your own coffee talk. Yep. You know, have a coffee talk with your staff. Yeah, we're work on one of the steps of whatever your sales process is. Um, you know, work on overcoming objections, role play, listen to a call. There's there's a multitude of things you can do, or or rip something off the internet about motivation and just talk about it. It doesn't matter. Anything, something to engage the staff and get them pumped.
SPEAKER_01
I would say another yeah, I would say another big one is don't handle everything as it comes at you. I it's crazy. The insurance in industry, it's just there's so much to do, right? There's so much just busy work.
SPEAKER_03
Last in, first out.
SPEAKER_01
Everybody's doing last in, first out. Last in first out.
SPEAKER_03
Oh, I just got a text, oh, I just got a messenger, oh, I just got a TikTok. Five out of two. But but it's it's it's just constantly coming coming at you. Yeah, like turn that shit off. You know, I turn off my notifications during the day. Yeah, otherwise I'm gonna go crazy because I am I very squirrel. You know, I'm like, oh look, oh god, what look, oh, somebody sent me a message on Instagram, it's top priority, right? Yep. No, it's the who cares? Look at that tomorrow, look at that tonight, you know, and if you don't get to it, then do it tomorrow. Exactly. And I took a long time to get back to people.
SPEAKER_01
No, and I think this is it, is that there are some very important things to do, you know, whether it's the macro of where you want your agency to be, or if it's you know, the the person that just lost someone or something huge that we're covering, you know what I mean? So you gotta make a priority list, make sure that you're handling the most important stuff first, and that though, so at the end of the day, if you don't get to everything, that it's not the important stuff that you didn't get to.
SPEAKER_03
Right. That's why. Look at this.
SPEAKER_01
Oh what you got there, Mr. Craig.
SPEAKER_03
Look what I got. John Mastery Journal. It's John Lee Dumas mastery journal. And so it's a hundred-day thing, which I read all the stuff, but it you know, they like you do this little recaps, this little sample thing, but it's this little it's a paper journal. I know it's weird, but I think there's I also think, and and something that he said, John Lee Dumas, uh, who we're gonna have on the show, um, he said that one of my favorite podcasters, one of my favorites. Um but uh it's it's just having the establishing routines and and establishing this micro consistency, or not micro just consistency, you know, and then yeah, you do your morning routine, and and he breaks your day up into four sessions, four sessions that you're going to spend important activities on, and you will not be interrupted during that time. So you and then you're also you may not finish the thing you're working on. So, like I want to write a book, right? It's something I'm I'm I'm working on, and and we're gonna probably do something together here, but um, you know, so okay, I block out an hour. I'm not gonna finish a freaking book in an hour, right? But I'm gonna at least knock out a paragraph, if it's not a page or two pages, you know, depending on how fast my fat fingers can type that day. But I mean, you know, and so boom, that might be a priority, maybe on Tuesdays, Wednesdays, and Thursdays or something, you know, that that's that's what you do, but you can knock it out. You know, when are you gonna have your one-on-ones with your team? Or do you have one-on-ones? I don't know. I mean, some people probably never meet with their team. I found when when I don't meet with my team, at least, at least I mean it has to be monthly, uh weekly, right? Where you're where you're just checking in with them, because if you don't, it starts going over towards uh, you know, if anybody has followed the agency vault stuff, the left pyramid, right? You start selling on price instead of doing all those things that they all know how to do, but it seems harder, and selling on value, right? And and all of the steps that that that do that. So, I mean, our role as that agency owner is so it's it's so it's so critical that we're working on the business, and that's how we provide the support. They know we're busy, they know that we can't answer the freaking phone for this guy that's mad that his rate went up, you know. So to help them understand what to say, not Jason's too busy. Right. Jason is in a meeting or Jason is you know on a podcast, on a podcast. Jason is Jason is doing the things that that drive activity to the agency. That's his job here. He used to do all this stuff, but he doesn't anymore. That's why he hired me. I'm gonna take care of this for you. I mean, if somebody understands it from that perspective, it's fine. Yep, but you know, our our time is worth something, you know, as as agency owners, and it's not adding a car. Right. A monkey can add a car. In fact, a client can add a car online. I mean, you know, so so there's no there's there should never be a place where the agent is doing that unless they truly love it. Like if they love it, then okay, here on the Mastery Journal, you block out session four is taking inbound calls, and you do that for that hour, but you don't do it beyond that hour. If you're taking calls all day long, then you're in reactive mode and you're never going to advance your agency. And especially with with some companies have different compensation coming. I mean, the same old stuff is not gonna work the same old way. Yep, that's it. I just went on a rant.
SPEAKER_00
I love it. You're passionate. I heard your passion. Could you hear my passion? I could hear it. Over some coffee, over some coffee.
SPEAKER_03
Um, one other thing. I think we did two. Did we have two?
SPEAKER_01
We did two. We did two.
SPEAKER_03
One other thing that to be consistent.
SPEAKER_01
We said the meetings, yes, and what was the other uh meetings and the journaling and and uh prioritizing, prioritizing your day and not just handling things that come in. What else? I would say I would say really getting out. Like like sometimes I'll take a walk around the building or something and just step away and just kind of disconnect for a second.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
I've often talked to you whilst you're doing that. Yes, I like it. It's it helps me to kind of I don't know, re-reassess stuff.
SPEAKER_03
You know, so that makes me think of another thing. So uh uh to that point, a lot of agents are very siloed and don't know a lot of the other agents. We've been blessed that we somehow a lot of people like to listen to this, and so we've connected with a lot of agents. Um, but but you you can't be siloed, you can't be on an island. Um in order to really grow and and learn things, you know, certainly you're gonna listen to this podcast and subscribe to it, but you're also going to reach out to other agents. Certainly. I mean, you would you would be insane to not subscribe to this podcast and get notifications.
SPEAKER_01
And well, that's why you just why we started it. I mean, honestly, that's why uh so take everything to the next level. Um and this has helped us. So if you can't, if you end up not being able to reach out to other agents or something, just throw this in while you while you do a little jaunt around the office to get a little exercise, get those steps in, right? And um learn from learn from others.
SPEAKER_03
Well, yeah, and we were the little guys at one point, right? And I'm I'm not yeah, I'm not suggesting that we're the big guys. I we're somewhere in the middle, but um, you know, there's the you know, like the Dave Williams, you know, with the with the giant 30 million or 25 million dollar book where where I remember the first time I called him, I didn't know him, and I was I was all I was all nervous, you know. But then oh he's just a he's just a dude and he's with a booming voice. Yeah, yeah. But um, no, super, you know, and and uh everybody that's it most folks that are in this business are are super relatable and easy to talk to. Yep. I mean every one of them, you know. Like I've I've reached Nick Ayres, I always think could come up with his name, but he's he's goofy and he's fun to talk to. You know, you can reach like you basically anybody is is somewhat accessible, right?
SPEAKER_01
You know, if you're yeah, don't and then it's the same thing in life with your family and everything else. It's like you cannot be on an island. You just gotta you gotta talk about stuff, get it out there, get good feedback. And in our agencies, it's the same.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, and not be afraid. Just got to do it.
SPEAKER_01
Not be afraid, just do just do it in 2020. Like like Nikkei says.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, Nikkei. 2020 is the year of the vision 2020. Ooh. All right, well, I think that's Mr. Jason, Mr. Craig. Well, that was another fantastic episode of Coffee Talk, Coffee Talking. All right, buddy, sponsored by you, the listener, who's going to leave a review on iTunes. Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_01
Thank you so much for listener and listening and leaving a review.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, thank you. Yay!
SPEAKER_01
All right, we'll see you guys next week. So, Craig, not only are we both agents, but we talked to a ton of agents out there. And I feel like a bunch of agents have been talking about the aggressive growth goals this year. Yeah. But you know what the problem is? What? Everyone's running into shifting their focus from service to sales, and they're trying to do this quickly. But where do you find the growth and how do you do this quickly? They all ask, right? Ask any agent.
SPEAKER_03
It's not an easy task. Well, right now there's thousands of consumers shopping online for insurance. In fact, Jason, according to a JD Power study, 74% of insurance shoppers start their search online. Dang, I know, right? And you need a way to connect with them, but it's tough to do on your own. That's where a trusted partner can really make a difference. Connecting you with insurance shoppers in real time and helping drive some serious growth.
SPEAKER_01
Well, you know, Everquote is the nation's largest online insurance marketplace with millions of consumers visiting their online sites every month. They're able to connect you with people who are actually shopping for insurance. Not just submitting their info. Yeah, not just submitting their info to win a free iPad. We all seen that one, right? Yeah, I've seen it. And Everquote's leads are delivered to you within seconds from the time they complete that form.
SPEAKER_03
And one of the best things about Everquote is that they're nothing like your typical lead vendor. They become a true partner in your business. You get your own dedicated support, recommendations, and insights to help optimize your results. Plus, uh right, plus tons of best practices. And guess what? What a great blog. And guess what else? You laid on me, Craig. A resource center to help you with everything from hiring to dealing with common objections. How awesome is that? That is awesome.
SPEAKER_01
And I don't think anyone should go at it alone with an average lead vendor. Heck no. Work with a true business partner that has helped thousands of agencies just like yours, Mr. Craig, grow. And right now, Everquote has a special limited time offer for all the dudes and dudettes out there. Did you know that?
SPEAKER_03
That's awesome. You know what they need to do? They need to go to the website and they can learn more about the offer and start the conversation about growing their agency now. The links down below in the show notes. Now let's get back to the show. Ooh, let's do.
SPEAKER_02
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the Insurance Dudes Podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the Insurance Dudes Podcast. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.