The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
What happened, Mr. Jason? Why am I so funny? Because you're slipping discs.
SPEAKER_02
The Wi-Fi. The Wi-Fi.
SPEAKER_01
Guess what? The Wi-Fi is named at my office.
SPEAKER_02
What?
SPEAKER_01
Death Star. Guess Star.
SPEAKER_02
Death Star. Oh, Death Star.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. And then at the other building, Death Star 2. Ooh. Ooh. I like it. Well. You made me think of something when you said that your back hurts. Oh, perfect. Yeah. My back hurts too. And you know what it is? We're sitting around too much.
SPEAKER_02
I I started doing the um the 10,000. I'm trying to do the 10,000 steps a day. Can you hear me?
SPEAKER_01
Oh, yeah. The little challenge in the insurance dubes group in on Facebook.
SPEAKER_02
Yes, yes. And I've I'm anywhere from 7,500 to 10,000 right now a day.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_02
But dude, I I swear though, like the one that was over 10,000, I know I walk less than I did yesterday and it said 7,500, but I think I was talking on my phone with my my watch hand walking around with that. So it wasn't it wasn't uh counting the steps.
SPEAKER_01
Why were you using your ear your ear pods?
SPEAKER_02
No, I was oh uh because I think they were out or something.
SPEAKER_01
Got a charge.
SPEAKER_02
No, no, I was looking at my phone because I had to like I was trying to work and talk and walk at the same time. Well which is a challenge for insurance agents.
SPEAKER_01
So we talked about uh a couple times ago about setting up microhabits, creating consistency, yeah, doing all things. Otherwise, you start working towards going the other direction.
SPEAKER_02
Truth.
SPEAKER_01
Guess when the last time I worked out was I would say pre-vacation. It's true. The last time I went to the gym was pre-vacation.
SPEAKER_02
Do you still have to pay the money every day?
SPEAKER_01
I was on Thanksgiving. No, no, no, only if I don't show up, which today I signed up last night. It was gonna be my triumphant return to Orange Theory. Guess what I did?
SPEAKER_00
Slept it.
SPEAKER_01
Yep, 10 bucks. So at least they lowered it. It's not 12 bucks, it's 10 bucks. But that's a reminder. Like I'm looking at this text on my phone, consumed in self-hate and saying you are a loser and all these things. And and then to top it off, I'm running a Ragnar relay on January 31st. So now I'm getting stressed out because I have a deadline where I must be in some kind of physical condition, or I'm gonna be in a lot of trouble. And I'm at, I feel like I'm below ground zero.
SPEAKER_00
Right.
SPEAKER_01
The plus side is I was in the water paddling a ton and trying to save my life from drowning from these giant waves the whole time while I was on the on island. So I was working out. I think there was some cardio there, uh, but I have to get in the gym. So my commitment right now to create consistency on the health set part of my life is I will be at Orange Theory tomorrow morning.
SPEAKER_02
You're making a declaration on the dudes on air, on the dudes.
SPEAKER_01
I will be there. And I, you know, I've made declarations before and then failed, but this one I have to. I mean, and so to tie it back into the back, like I've noticed if I don't work out, my back starts to hurt. Yep. Because it's yeah, it it definitely is involved with the core, right? So if you're not working out your core, which is ironic, right? Like you feel your back and you want to like get a back massage, but but really it's it's the opposing side, that gut, because you're eating ice cream instead of doing sit-ups, and you know, you're so you're out of balance.
SPEAKER_02
If you don't work your core, you're gonna hit the floor.
SPEAKER_01
If you don't work your co, you're gonna hit the flow.
SPEAKER_02
So how many days have you been back from vacation? Um a week. A week. So seven days-ish.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, I came back last Wednesday.
SPEAKER_02
And how many of those days did you wake up on? Uh did you sleep in?
SPEAKER_01
All of them. So this morning, every day progressively, I've been getting up early, earlier. Today I got up at 7:15, which was the earliest I've gotten up the whole time. I think tomorrow I can broach this the 6 a.m. Well, tomorrow I'm gonna set my alarm. I haven't set my alarm either. I set my alarm this, I will set my alarm tomorrow for 6. Hopefully, not snooze. No, I won't snooze. I will bounce up painfully, go get coffee, and then drink an energy thing and and go to the gym at at um seven.
SPEAKER_02
Have since you've been back, have you picked up where you've left off with any habits? Or were are they kind of all out the door? Are they all still on vacation?
SPEAKER_01
I'm I am uh recording agents, uh insurance dudes. So that's one habit I've installed. Um I've I haven't been on my staff meetings, it's just been my operations manager running those. Um, I am installing a new habit, which is uh I'm gonna in person with the ECP salespeople because they sort of have gotten away from the the talk time and the you know, their their talk time's gone down, their number of quotes have gone down, and and I was trying to explain that today where hey, I'm buying more leads, but we have less talk time, we're like going the wrong direction. So we just got to get back on track. We're still on pace for the best month. Um, and I threw a couple contests out uh this week. I said if we get our uh agency zoom ding, if we get our agency zoom ding up to um uh back to zero, because we're not at zero right now, we're about twenty thousand behind goal. If we get that back to zero, I will take everybody out to Fleming's. Ooh, yeah, but that's like twenty thousand in premium, so it'll pay full itself. Dang, you big spender. Well, there's two vegetarians, so that saves a hundred dollars. Like a hundred dollars off that Fleming Center. I'm just kidding, they can order whatever they want.
SPEAKER_02
Nice, even cocktails? Yeah, but $30 cocktails.
SPEAKER_01
There's some legality about serving cocktails at a work phase. Oh, that's right. They're gonna have to not not have that happen. They can bring their own beer.
SPEAKER_02
But where are we going with this?
SPEAKER_01
Well, it it comes down to but number one, you gotta recognize, right? So I I'm recognizing. I don't know if the self-hatred helps. That doesn't really do anything, you know, to get mad at yourself. Because you wake up, it's a new day. Tomorrow I'm gonna wake up, it's a new day. I mean, in theory, I guess I could go to the gym tonight. I just I'm not an afternoon gym person because I've eaten and don't feel like it, but again, more excuses. I like to play the excuse game and just you know, how many times am I making up an excuse? Because they're all excuses.
SPEAKER_02
Right. So you're gonna go after today. Now you gotta do it.
SPEAKER_01
Do I need to go? Okay.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Well, I do have to take my son to lacrosse at six, so I'll have to figure out the logistics. If there's a six o'clock class, then I'll okay. I'll go.
SPEAKER_02
Just do this. Why don't you do this? We remember how we talked about the microhabits? Go in there for 10 minutes. Walk on the treadmill.
SPEAKER_01
Just walk. Well, it's a it's like orange theory doesn't work like that. There is a oh, there's a 645. Okay, here we go. You're watching.
SPEAKER_02
Are you gonna do it? You gonna add it? Book. Book. Now you don't want to lose that twelve dollars now. Oh, you're there. You're there. There's book and guess what? You don't have to be self-loathing now for the rest of the day. You just got that monkey off your back.
SPEAKER_01
And they'll give me back my 10 bucks because I'm going to a course on the same day, so they will actually refund me.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, so there you go. All that self-loathing is now.
SPEAKER_01
I'm actually proud of myself right now, Jason.
SPEAKER_02
You're proud of yourself.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. For doing what I need to do.
SPEAKER_02
Therapy. This is also a therapy section.
SPEAKER_01
I feel like a weight just came off my shoulders.
SPEAKER_02
Yes. And that's it, isn't it? Don't we get bogged down by all those things that we want to do that we never do? Or that we put off.
SPEAKER_01
And then we focus on the fact that we didn't do it. Right. And then we're like, well, I suck because I didn't do it. But instead, you get your good friend on. You have him talking to evaporating all those excuses and then doing it. And look what happened. So it comes down to taking to recognizing and then taking action.
SPEAKER_02
You better recognize.
SPEAKER_01
Because if I miss this one and now I I am within the window where I cannot cancel, so I have to go, or I will get hit with another $10 charge. Then I'll have to put a gun in my mouth. And I don't want to do that. You just get too far.
SPEAKER_02
Too far.
SPEAKER_01
So so thank you.
SPEAKER_02
Yes, thank you. And we'll leave it on that. So everybody, you better recognize.
SPEAKER_01
You better recognize before you disgruntalize.
SPEAKER_00
Then hypnotize. All right, sounds good. Mr. Jason. Mr. Craig. And what was this?
SPEAKER_01
Quell V Talk. And we're out. Oh, wait. What if they didn't subscribe?
SPEAKER_02
Oh, then they should subscribe because you need that. Oh, on the iTunes or the Googly. I think Googly Podcasts, Spotify. Stitcher. You the YouTubes, and we're going to go back to at some point that will be consistent.
SPEAKER_01
At some point. Well, I think that that problem is being solved today.
SPEAKER_02
It's so much time to upload this. Yeah. I think that's what we're solving today. All right.
SPEAKER_01
And why don't we why don't we give a shout out to our sponsor? We're never going to end it. Just this the last last spot last shout out so we can get their name on there. We've we have added a sponsor, and uh there are spots for the that sponsorship if you have a business and you want to sponsor it. But we'd like to thank and uh welcome Everquote as a sponsor. We have a publicly traded company sponsoring this podcast.
SPEAKER_02
That's right. That's right. And they're great.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. And hey, I I forgot to congratulate you.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. I have a feeling.
SPEAKER_01
100th episode.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, snap. We didn't even know. That's so funny that we didn't even know.
SPEAKER_01
And then Buzz Sprout sent me a message and said, Congratulations, you did 100 episodes.
SPEAKER_02
That's so crazy.
SPEAKER_01
Who knew? We didn't.
SPEAKER_02
We didn't do anything fun for it.
SPEAKER_01
Over 60,000 downloads. Dang. I know. Right. 60K. 60,000. So we have to be a sponsor like Everquote. 60,000 downloads.
SPEAKER_02
60,000. And climbing.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. So we will see you. I I I think that by March well, whatever. That'll be a lot. We'll be back soon.
SPEAKER_00
Quote we don't. Que don't
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.