The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Social Savage Slick Sellin With Nicholas Sakha, We gonna get you, Sakha
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Did you feel like no matter what objective you gave that you weren't gonna get out of this? We were uh you know we were putting our heads together on how to overcome all the objectives. You assume that you assume the clothes, that's for sure. Yeah. Well you'll get a corner by making the objective. Um what was it? What was the last one? Uh I I haven't it was the time. So you only had time until the next uh uh you only had 20 minutes. We said, well that's perfect. Great. Boom. Let's do this.
SPEAKER_04Where are you guys at? Is that your office studio?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, this is my office, and then that's Jason's office. So I'm in Arizona I'm in Tucson, Arizona. Jason is in Huntington Beach. Beautiful Huntington Beach, where I'd rather be.
SPEAKER_04Dave, say that we started together. Like you're in our group photo in Chicago.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I know. It's crazy. So I still talk to uh I talk to you every once in a while now, and then uh Dave. I still talk to Dave.
SPEAKER_04Dave, Dave, uh David Rodmacher. Oh I I don't think I I don't think I remember him.
SPEAKER_01He was uh he was pretty outspoken.
SPEAKER_04Okay.
SPEAKER_01Skinny dude. Kinda kind of outspoken.
SPEAKER_04I I've gotta look. We gotta like we've gotta do like uh we've gotta look at that photo and then and see the uh the last who remain.
SPEAKER_03There you go. 25%. So so uh hey Nick, we've talked a little bit on the phone and and uh starting to get to know each other. Um obviously you know Jason, but what what brought you to this world? The insurance world?
SPEAKER_01Insurance world. Yes. What made you in insurance world? Not this world as in uh you know planet Earth.
SPEAKER_03We we know how that works. It's uh male male chromosome and a female movie.
SPEAKER_04Well my parents met and you know my dad had a lot of charm. Now I'm just kidding. But now the insurance world, so uh I was in banking and trying to finish my degree. I was in banking for uh for a US bank. I was there for about seven years, uh, but I hated it. I hated like the corporate structure, corporate America. And after, you know, as soon as I got that degree and US bank, you know, pretty much helped me get it, um, I quit. And I was kind of moving on up the corporate ladder, but I hated it, you know. I just hate like corporate structure, you know, like even when I walk even now when I walk into like a corporate building, like I just want to throw up because I just I hate that uh I hate the vibe, you know. Um and so I quit to go work and I was in business banking at the time, but went to go work with a business customer of mine, and that felt I fell flat on my face there. I mean, that was talk about like cold sales. I was like going business to business trying to sell mobile app technology. Like, like, hey, your big your business, I noticed you guys don't have an app, you know. Is a business owner available? You know, and I mean, and that was hard as shit. So you know, so even then, I mean, like, just because of that, I don't allow like any excuses for my for my staff, right? But uh I did that so flat on my face, you know, lost like all the rest of my money, and I found myself just with my literally just with my 401k, and and one of my best friends, uh William Duran, he was an agent for about a year and a half, two years, and um he just you know, I remember we I remember it was his sister's birthday, and and he they invited me and they went to go play top golf, and I literally had no money. And so uh I was I was in my head, I'm like, man, this will be the first birthday of Maddie that I that I've ever missed. And in my mind, I'm calculating like, you know, uh top golf's like at least sixty dollars. I I can't afford that. So I'm like, hey guys, uh I just I can't make it, you know? And so he told me he was already a year into the into uh his agency, maybe a year and a half, two years, and he's like, just come, I I got you. And I I didn't even like that, but I was like, all right, you know, fine. So I went, I'm having a beer, uh and and he's like, and he's like, you should open up an agency. And I I mean I was like, Well, I don't really I never really had management experience, so I don't know if I can do that. And he's like, You'll be fine, like I know you'll be fine, and you should do it. And at this point, like literally, I'm like, I had no choice, so I just decided to do it. I just took a leap and I was like, all right, you know, fuck it. And uh I'm glad I did because it all worked out. I mean, we're we're we're we're scaling right now, we're we're doing our best, and now three years later, um, it's it's been fun.
SPEAKER_01We skipped the first question. When we so ah, we did skip the first question. We're gonna go back to that, but what was the first concert you ever went to?
SPEAKER_04The first concert? Oh shit. Dang, um, I I I can't remember, but there's uh there's a Christian rock band named Red. And they're I mean they don't even sound like Christian music, right? Like Christian rock, you know. Um and uh they kind of sound like Lincoln Park, but cooler. And I remember Yeah, uh and I went to this like they were smaller back then, but I went to this like local church that they were performing at now. They're big, now they do like concerts at Hard Rock and stuff like that. But um, but I think that was my first concert.
SPEAKER_01Nice. That's awesome. That's awesome. Hey, Graham Bob, uh, same thing, uh Christian Christian artists. And actually, I used to play in Christian bands growing up. That's really that's where, yeah. That's interesting.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome, man.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Um ever get a chance, give them a listen. Red music, they're they're they're sick.
SPEAKER_01I've seen them around. Yeah, I'll definitely check them out. I love like switch foot and then I like POD and all those old bands.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Good stuff. Good stuff. Hey, so now going back to what we were talking about, um, the one cool thing I like about seeing you on Facebook and everything is you really use social media probably more than any other insurance agent I know.
SPEAKER_02Really tell us, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Does that how does that play into your marketing strategy? And does it tell us the results from that?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so I I knew from I remember uh going, I remember in in training, right? They're like, what is your marketing strategy? And I was like, social media, yeah. I was like the only one. I was like, I'm gonna use this thing, and and it's if people go to social media to escape, right? Like they don't go to get sold, but everybody on there is selling, so you gotta kind of market yourself in a way that people don't really feel like they're being sold, i.e. make them laugh, make them connect with you. Um think about like the Kardashians, right? These girls have their TV show and the whole TV show is about their life and how they're gonna launch these businesses to sell you stuff, and then now they're you know, they're selling they're selling every single one of their products and they're like the best at, you know, in the makeup industry or whatever it is. But but they show that kind of real life aspect about them. So I don't know, I've always I've always known that and maybe I just listened to Gary Vaynerchuk a lot and and and kind of gravitated towards towards that. But I've always I grew up in it, so uh it just I always found it as a good tool. Like I was you know, I remember MySpace days where like I decked out a page and when you went to my page it was like mus the music would start, you'd have the your own little background and you'd deck it out how you wanted. Um it's just a good tool to to get business. There's so much business from there. Um and it just it's really work for us. So yeah, uh I'm on that thing. I I make my staff post weekly, daily, and you know, we share content and and just kind of I gotta I don't know, just show your life, you know what I'm saying? It doesn't you don't you gotta mix it together, and I don't think I know that's hard for some people, uh, but when you can mix it together to where like you know uh it doesn't really seem like you're selling, you're just being yourself, um it works.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, it used to be then the olden days, it used to be there was work and there was your personal life, and especially the life of the entrepreneur, which is all of us, it's there's a blend, you know, and showing what you do personally helps facilitate you being a human and not just some corporate bullshit, you know, that that people can't relate with, and that's for the same reason that you and I and Jason, if we walk into a corporate building, we're like I mean, that's most people. Most people don't want to live the that that situation. It's the worst. If if a business has an HR department, it's like, oh boy, right? It's just take away the fun department.
SPEAKER_04So I I think the greatest person to use social media right now, and if you look at his uh look at his Instagram, look at The Rock, okay? The Rock is probably the best at selling everybody without making it seem like he's selling you. If you pull up his Instagram right now, his last 10 to 15 posts, he's selling you on something. The new Jumanji movie just came out. Thank you for making it the number one movie in the world. I'm coming out with uh my own tequila coming out in March. You know, cheers to cheers to the new Jumanji movie, you know, and I'm sipping my and let's all me, Jack Black, and Kevin Hart are all sipping my new Terramana tequila coming out in March. And then um now he's promoting his new movie, right? Uh he's gonna be a DC character, um, I don't know, the Black Adams or something like that. And so now he's promoting that, and he's building up anticipation for that. And then he's selling you on Under Armour and you know, and his shoes, and and then oh, I'm sponsored by Voss Water. And so like every single one of his posts, there's a strategy behind it, he's not just he's not just posting the posts, he's doing it, you know, he's selling you without even, you know, real and then people are buying into it, they're not even realizing that they're being sold. And so if you want to like really see somebody who's exceptional at that, look up the rock uh and just see how he does that, he how he strategically posts.
SPEAKER_03Well, the whole thing is developing rapport with the audience, right? And in sales, rapport is at is 50, 40 of the sale, right? Most people want to jump to the sale, especially when you're young. You're rushing to try to close, and then you're overcoming objections, and you know, like the Cardone method is you know, bam, bam hammer them, hammer them, woo! And it's like, no, dude, you gotta connect, right? Connect with them. And and what better way than to have some fun? I mean, if you're creative, and all three of us are pretty creative, you know, I love using my right brain and coming up with goofy graphics and and all that. That's fun, you know, coming up with the with something that people will connect and resonate with. And then they it also has your personal touch to it. Like your movies are dude, your movies are exceptional. Like they're so fun. So good. You know, I love them. You know, anybody who who hasn't who doesn't know you or hasn't seen them, they've got to become friends with you, or at least follow your agency on Facebook. Um, I we could we'll put a a link to your agency page in the show notes, but um, I mean, it's they're hilarious, you know? They're just great, really good, really well done.
SPEAKER_01Do you get a lot of response from those?
SPEAKER_04I do. I do. Um, it's uh I'm just now getting to like uh I just hired somebody to to really kind of track the analytics and stuff like that, because that is something that I wasn't really like doing. I was just putting out content, but um, so I'm gonna really find out what the like the conversion rate and how many, you know, all that how that's really gonna, you know, how that really looks. But I just know just logically thinking that that everyone gravitates towards it. Like if everyone thinks about me in the topic of insurance, then I won. You know, because they're gonna they're gonna reach out to me when it comes at their when the rate goes up or when you know they're you know and it you know what another thing it also does too is I don't know about you guys, but in my our market, like everyone in Vegas, well if you're an insurance, you know each other. And um, and so it also has helped with like attracting a few good candidates, like because people say, like, you know, I've seen your office and I've seen your agencies and and I've seen you guys around, and and so people when something doesn't work out with like uh say a staff or for you know somebody at State Farm or something like that, they end up you know kind of reaching out to me. So it kind of works. It's like a double-headed double-edged sword, actually. So it's really awesome.
SPEAKER_03Dude, it makes you the expert, right? Yeah, if they think of insurance, your name comes up. It's amazing.
SPEAKER_04I just want everyone to think about me as it relates to insurance. If they need a quote, if they you know, what whatever that might be. And you've got like geicos and progressive. I'll be honest. If I'm being honest, geo and progressives have funnier commercials than than than we do. I think so. Especially Geico. I think their commercials are funnier than ours. And so I feel like I've gotta make something to kind of combat that. Otherwise, they're not gonna reach out to me so or or my agency.
SPEAKER_03Right. There's still well.
SPEAKER_01Go ahead, man. And I think there's another thing that's happening too. Like, talk about like the the cult because I can tell you have a killer culture in your office. Tell us what like what it does do those videos bring together kind of your staff and everything when you do those?
SPEAKER_04It does, it does because it's different. Like, you know, if we sit down and we're like, hey guys, we need to create something, and I don't waste any time. Like, we come up with a couple ideas. I'm like, all right, let's do it now. We're not just gonna sit on this idea, right? So you also gotta kind of pay attention to what's relevant and what's trending, right? You know, so that video of the you know the video of the girl getting accepted to the college, and then it kind of went viral where everyone was making a video with that, and then the dad's like, no way, no way. Well, that's our most recent video, and what's most what I'm most proud about in that video, because that one was a hit. I mean, people absolutely love that one, um, and it made them laugh, uh, was that I had nothing to do with that one. And so my my staff just did that, and that was one of the first videos that they just executed. I wasn't even at that office. I was at my other office, and then they rolled out with it, and I was like, oh my god, you're like tears coming down.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, it's whatever's like ever and you're gonna know what's relevant, what's like trending, you know, just just take a look at what's on your feed, and you're gonna see what people are posting, whether it's Salt Bay, or whether it's um, you know, there's so many different you know, memes or cat thing, you know, like that was huge for a lot, and it still comes back, it still creeps in every now and then a different version, right?
SPEAKER_04But if I were to make it like right now, it wouldn't be as powerful as when it was first trending.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_04So and it's so easy to tweak it to your industry. I mean, sometimes it's like, okay, that wasn't funny, and and sometimes it's like, damn, you know, but but you've got to play the content game because people go on social media to escape. And that's why there's a new app called TikTok, where like the young people are TikTok. TikTok. It's like the modern day Vine.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And it's crazy. People go on there because it's like escapism, you know. So you've got to figure out kind of how to how to you know blend in with that without making people feel like they're being sold, you know. It's like a there's a weird science to it.
SPEAKER_01So make them like you.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So I I I remember another thing. So when you started, I remember thinking um you were starting in Vegas, and I remember people saying, like, oh, that's a tough market. And so generally speaking, it's a pretty tough market, right? Just Nevada in general.
SPEAKER_04Uh we're we're the lost Nevada, no, Vegas, yes, because there's lawyers galore out here. So our uninsured, underinsured is through the roof. I mean, there's a there's a billboard for a lawyer on every block.
SPEAKER_01The worst.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01So what what have you learned in the last three years? Because it's been three years. Congrats. Wow. Um the last three years. What what have you learned? What would you do differently? Uh, and what what what has worked the best for you?
SPEAKER_04I think what I do, I mean, and I I listened to your guys' podcast, and and one thing that I would totally do differently was with my second office, I was so conservative with I was so conservative with with that with uh the beginning of my ECP contract, like I was still buying like the same amount of leads and not really like 10xing per se. Um I was just playing a conservative. So that was uh if I could go back again or maybe I get a third office or something like that, maybe I I I go in with bigger balls, I guess you could say. Um but I mean we're and we're doing good. We're doing good. Um by by any means um we're still doing good. Uh, but I think I would have maybe I would have you know upped that a little bit. But as far as what I do differently is I I kind of I mean it's hard to say because hindsight's always 2020. Um but I would have definitely bought the Tesla sooner. No, you know, right? I would have gotten around, I would have maybe, you know, your podcast I don't think was a was a was around back then, but I would have maybe further educated myself on on everything. I would have got around, you know, the ASAs, the Kreb Wiggins, like uh I would have gotten around more of that, you know, early on to like expedite my development, you know, because I kind of you know looking back, uh it all worked out perfectly and it's still working out perfectly, but I think I would have seek more mentorship early on outside of Vegas.
SPEAKER_01Mentorship. So more more training and hiring.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. How how's the hiring? Hiring is it's our uh what I take pride in is uh is is I don't really get too much turnover um in unless and I think that has to do with the culture. I'm like I'm so like I I'm so big on vibes that you know, and it's obvious whenever there's there's a conflict in your office, and so I address it like right away. And um Yeah, because I don't let nothing linger. We're not gonna brush anything under the rug. We're gonna address it, whatever's going on right away. And hiring has been good. I've been able to retain a lot of people. Um now I'm you know, but this is never ending, man. It's never ending. Like I thought I had both of my offices like ready to go, and then some changes need to happen, and and you know, one office is in a rebuilding stage, and I'm still still hiring, still training, coaching, developing, and trying to build some some strong leaders within my office because it's impossible to scale without them.
SPEAKER_01Yep. And that's why we we always follow that structure the hire, train, motivate, and make it rain. For I love that. Love that Tolga, man. Tolga.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Agency Zoom. Yeah, yep. Shout out to Agency Zoom.
SPEAKER_01It's funny that you say that about um, I I don't I as far as like uh investing enough right up front, I don't think that the anyone, even the ones that have 10x'd it, right? I don't think anyone says that they wouldn't have gone harder. You know what I mean? Like you go 50 people deep and it's still like, well, could have done 60.
SPEAKER_05Could have done six yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_04But it's always, you know, it's it's it's yeah. It's always in retrospect, you know. It's like one you're going through it, it's one thing, but yeah, but a completely different other thing once you're looking at the hump.
SPEAKER_03You're looking at those numbers, and you know, when when you're spending 600, 700, 800,000 bucks on leads every day, woo, it starts it starts adding up quick, you know, and you can you can get nervous because you're like, wow, the self-doubt comes in, right? The doubt comes in, you're like, but what if this happens, but what if this happens? Instead of thinking, what will happen, which is if you're buying those leads and you have the right process, you're gonna close them and you're gonna get results. I mean, it just happens, you know. We turn off our lead, like I got a little nervous a few weeks ago, turn off leads, and then we saw three weeks later, you see the little dip because you turned them off three weeks ago. You know, it's like, ah, why'd I do that? You know, and so um just gotta keep keep grinding.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, man. And and it's it's yeah, I mean, to back on that question, like what you do differently, it's everything seems to work out how it was supposed to, you know. Like, I don't think I could have a conversation with myself three years ago, like, you know, and and tell myself everything I showed you doing, and I I wouldn't, you know, I don't know if I'd do it any differently, but one thing's for sure, it's like I I I think it's important to invest in yourself. Like uh my you know, Dave Williams, everybody knows Dave. Yeah, he like what what I'm I'm so inspired about by him is he he invests in his self-development so much. Like he's constantly going to I've seen him at um I've seen him at all sorts of events and he really keeps investing in himself and and that's the only way that you know you and I mean and look at his success, you know, look look how far uh look how uh look how far he's come and I think it's because he continued to get around like the right people and yeah and stoke up podcasts like this one, you know?
SPEAKER_01Yeah well thank you, my man. Well, cool. I I know that this is gonna be a quick one. So before we go, what's the one piece of advice that you give to any insurance agent starting? The one golden nugget.
SPEAKER_04I think I mean we kind of talked about it, but social media, man. Like if you're not if you're not creative and if you're not good at it, then hire somebody uh to manage your social media, but you've got to put out content or you'll become irrelevant in this modern like I know for a fact that like older agents hate my guts because you know, like I'm the one that they're thinking about, you know, as far as from a marketing standpoint. So social media is just not gonna go anywhere, and you know, it's it's just so important. So it's helped me uh tremendously. I mean, it's carried on over to my staff as well. Look, and if you're if you have staff, I know for a fact that every single one of your employees are are swiping their timelines, they're they're scrolling all day long, and if uh I tell them, hey, stop being a producer, uh stop being a consumer on social media and start becoming a producer, produce content, post, like I get on them. I'm friends, they all follow me, they all watch my stuff. If I post something, sometimes I watch just to see how quickly they watch whatever I posted. So I'm like, oh, so you're on social media all day, huh? So if they're gonna be on it, they need to be a producer, they need to produce content and post content so that way people can also think about them and the topic of insurance, and not just you know, if you're your employees are all on it anyway, whether you like it or not, you might as well get them to post and to get business from it.
SPEAKER_01Love it. I love it. That's totally the opposite. I I think that a lot of people would say, yeah, get off, get off your phone.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, like that's the I think everyone's on their phone no matter what. No matter whether we like it or not. If you're and if you're if you're not at the same place, like and you you're you know, you're just it's it is what it is.
SPEAKER_03So man. Well, you have an interview right now, huh?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Go go do it. Thank you so much, Nick. Good, good catching up with you.
SPEAKER_04I'm honored to be on. I always listen to you guys, so you know, I really appreciate it. And that's awesome. Keep doing what you guys are doing. Like, I got so much value from the guests that you guys have on the show. Um, you know, and I I think I've told you guys a couple times just through message, but you know, if I get to tell you in person, you know, keep doing what you're doing because it makes a difference. Like the perspective I get, the value I get from you guys is uh um is huge. And it's I implement things all the time that I'm learning from your guys on the podcast.
SPEAKER_01We're blessed to meet the people we get to meet.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01That's why we do it. It's like we just learn. Well, thank you, brother.
SPEAKER_04I'll see you guys in person soon.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, for sure.
SPEAKER_03If I there may be another comment.
SPEAKER_04Thanks, guys.
SPEAKER_00Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dude inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live copy in our private Facebook group.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman