The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twerk. Coffee twerk. Coffee.
SPEAKER_00
Coffee. It's a coffee talk. So Craig, you just got off a vacation. We just talked to somebody, um, Jamie, and we talked about the unplugged time, making time to unplug. And it really helps us get a grasp of what's going on around us and really plan and implement. So, man, you had two weeks off two weeks of just surfing. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
You look like some would argue that it's not real surfing since it's bodyboarding, but I think it is. Oh, I I thought it was real surfing. So you're bodyboarding. I am, yeah. Yeah, it's not real surfing. I just just Mike Stewart. Wow. Yeah, not the not the cheapos. It's not a more boogie. Ah.
SPEAKER_00
Moray. Yeah. So my question is this. What was your takeaways? So you you you've been you hit it hard this year. You had a you did a lot this year. Um. And then you just pulled that plug. What what takeaways do you have from your two weeks off?
SPEAKER_03
Well, it was hard to pull the plug because and I planned to not pull the plug. In fact, I had my I had two laptops originally, because there's the the company laptop and then there's the the this the MacBook. Um I I put the uh company one off in a pile and did not bring that. So did not check my email for two weeks, and I I delegated it. So I did a lot of stuff that Jamie was talking about um in his episode, which is this Friday. Yes. Or next Friday. Well, whatever. Whatever. Whatever. It's Jamie Alderton, who's awesome.
SPEAKER_00
Uh awesome, awesome dude.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Um, but I did. I I literally pretty much unplugged. I I checked in, I mean, I looked at agency Zoom um to see our numbers, which surprisingly were higher without me there than with me here. So either I did a really good job before I left, or they're just better off without me. Or you did a really bad job before you left. But we're on pace for our biggest month. So, you know, that's boom. Yeah. Yeah. Love it. Um, so takeaways. I I mean the the place that I went to is uh and I talk about all the time, it's Hawaii and and I go to Kauai. And um, I like to get in the water and I pretty much sit, I'm in the water the whole time. I mean, more than some of the locals that that are out there, although they're in the water the whole time too. Um and it's what I love to do, you know. That that is what I love to do. I love to ride the wave and get in get in the barrel and just do do all of those things that the Hawaiians do. And yes. Um and so to do that and just turn off left brain, you know, like like a dolphin does. I don't know if you know this, but dolphins turn off half their brain. They never they never go to sleep, they only turn off half, which is pretty easy. I learned that. Um, but yeah, I mean, I basically turned off the left brain. I really didn't check too many emails at all. I was a little bit of Facebook, and you know how we get hit on Facebook on Messenger a lot. I responded to a few of them, but you know, there were there's too many to actually respond to all of them. So there are a couple I responded, I responded to you and I responded to a couple other people. But um, yeah, it was pretty much I had to just unplug.
SPEAKER_00
Did you did you recalibrate uh the focus for the year? I'm sure you had a reflection of last year, and you you have uh yeah, I'm sure you thought a lot about this year. What are some of the things that you're gonna implement that maybe you wouldn't have thought of if um or did you reassess?
SPEAKER_03
I just reassessed. I mean, it's the it's the systems, and and you know, you really helped a lot with simplifying the systems too. I I will always for some reason overcomplicate everything. Or not always, I will tend to overcomplicate everything, and I think a lot of people do that in the same way that when they're you know, when we if we post our numbers in our some of our smaller groups that we have, and then people, well, how'd you do that? It's like, well, it's it, you know, we quote a lot, buy a lot of leads and quote them. I mean, that's what we do, you know. It's pretty, it's pretty simple. You spend money, you spend X, and you get out three X or whatever it is. Yep. And that's just you know, and it's it's it's stay that course and and not get scared when you have a day that that they write a thousand in premium, because if they write a thousand today, that means they're writing twelve thousand tomorrow. Right, you know, so but still that's not fun. I don't like that. I don't know, it scares me, especially when you dropped a thousand on leads. You know, you dropped a thousand, they can't even write two two items. I mean, come on, what's happening over here? But right you have to I think that it's so important to recognize, and I and you know, you asking me about where I was, the wave is a great analogy because it is a wave. I mean, business ownership, whether it's insurance or it's a marketing business or whatever business you have, it is gonna be a wave, it's gonna be a summer wave. Right, you're gonna have your your huge, your $20,000 day, and you're gonna have your zero. And the zero for some reason seems monumentally worse than how great that 20,000 seemed. And you you could have the 20,000 yesterday and you forget all about it when you have a zero day, right? And it trunks everything. That's it. The wheels just fell off. I'm screwed, I gotta give up, I suck, you know, and you have to be able to stay centered.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. How funny is that? Is that it's a I was just talking to um our staff about this about like you know, it takes that one person to yell at you about following up with them too much, and then all of a sudden you change your whole behavior because 98% of the people won't even mention how much you're harassing them.
SPEAKER_03
Everybody gets mad when you call so many times. No, one person did.
SPEAKER_00
But it takes that yeah, and then and then and then they change the behavior. That one person goes, you know what? I I don't want to I don't want to deal with that again. So now I'm gonna change my behavior for 100% of the time, even though it works on 98% of the people, you know what I mean? So but but you gotta, and I it's crazy when you look at it that way because it's like, why are you leaning into the one or two percent, lean into the 98%? You could you could see this everywhere in life.
SPEAKER_03
I mean, not just in business, but in life itself. I mean, we everybody has to take their shoes off at the airport because one person blew up a building, and you know that that might stir up the controversy, but yeah, you know, but and certainly not minimalizing it, but how what percent of people have a bomb in their shoe? Right. I laugh because I almost zero percent expect you to say that. No, but you know what's well I was just on a plane, so I was thinking these things, right? Because that that's what you think because you go through the airport and you have to go through the security. I think in my opinion, this whole the whole security thing is a big freaking a big show. It's a big show. It's it's because you know what I can go pay 75 bucks and get get pre-check, and then they don't make me take my shoes off. So I mean, I don't know.
SPEAKER_00
That's it. Got a little philosophical. I think that's it. I I I mean, I like I like this those takeaways, and I think that um not overcomplicating things for this year is a a huge a huge thing. And going back to what you said about like buying leads or or whatever we're doing is just break it down to the smallest, serve the smallest, niche it down as much as you can. Lean it, you can sure we sell tons of stuff, right? But don't just go out, hey, I can just sell to anybody. Like really niche down on where you're going. Like if you're going auto, just go all in on auto. You can even niche it down further, or what whatever it may be to get the conversation started. Know that you can do the rest, of course you can do the rest, but you gotta really focus, make it simple, and then um simple.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, how can you make it even simpler? By having a process, right? By having that process so many times, right? Or quit yeah, but but so many so many people will say, What is the thing that everybody asks all the time in all the Facebook groups? What leads are working, right? Right. Hey, what leads are you doing? And and my answer is I don't care. It doesn't matter. The the one that gets the one that has the lowest CP uh is cost per sale. Yep. And and they're they all pretty much end up being about the same because if you call them 30 times, they're gonna eventually let you quote them. Or they're gonna say, put me on the do not call. All right, fine. Either way, we've we've come to some kind of realization with this one lead. Yep. But but the leads are the gas. The leads are the gas that you put in the gas tank of the of the car, and the car's the the agency. And if you don't put gas in the car, I don't know any other way that that you're gonna make it happen. I mean, I see people all the time talking about how they well, I don't do leads. Okay, well, then you gotta do something. You gotta do something to create quote activity. Yep. I mean, you know, those lender referrals, that's great, but that's a long-term strategy. And yeah, to Jamie's point, you know, when's the best time to start your lead, your loan off your loan officer strategy? 10 years ago or today, or you know, whatever. But you you just need to start doing that, but it's not gonna get you results for a while. So in the meantime, you've got to pay to play.
SPEAKER_00
Pay to play, or at least uh let that be at least part of your strategy. There's gotta be part marketing in your strategy, there has to be, and to diversify. You I mean, you can't have all your eggs in one basket.
SPEAKER_03
At the macro, at the most macro of levels, your agency really, this might ruffle feathers. Your agency should just be one revenue stream in your overall business portfolio, right? And then within that agency, there should be multiple revenue streams, lenders, um you know, uh leads, uh telemarketer calls, whatever, you know, all these different little pieces of that pie. And then you can get it, and then you can even drill it down further. Okay, within leads, is it ever quote? That's a nice mention for ever quote. Um is it uh ALM? Is it whatever, right? Is it elephant, underground elephants that click to call so who knows? But you you can break it down at another micro level, right? Totally. I love that yeah, so you can blow it up anyway.
SPEAKER_00
You and the blown up stuff, and well, I think that's a good coffee talk, and I think that's make it simple and just lean in this year, right?
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, I think we're gonna have a really good coffee coffee talk next week. So I can't wait to hear it.
SPEAKER_00
All right. We'll see you next week. Bye, buddy. Okay, see you next week. Coffee.
SPEAKER_01
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.