The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
TJ Larkin | Legacy Agency Owner Ga Ga on Growth
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hello King, Mr. Craig. Hello, Mr. Jason. Hello, hello, hello. Hello, Mr. Jason. Hello, hello. Hello, hello, hello.
SPEAKER_03So TJ, you know what we're gonna do? What's up? I'm gonna do little uh insurance dudes here on you. How about that?
SPEAKER_01Uh I don't know about that. Why not? You're a dude. I am a dude, that's true. Are you a dude? And an insurance dude. I am an insurance dude. I that is correct.
SPEAKER_04I technically qualify. You met the technical.
SPEAKER_02It's the insurance dude podcast.
SPEAKER_00Kaka! Kaka! Kaka!
SPEAKER_04Is this can you hear me?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, is this your guys' normal intro to each other?
SPEAKER_03Pretty much. Yeah, nice. I injured my back a bit doing that.
unknownNice.
SPEAKER_01What's up, TJ? What's going on, guys? How's white?
SPEAKER_05Awesome. The best bra.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03So, TJ, you know what we're gonna do? What's up? We're gonna do little uh insurance dudes here on you. How about that? Uh I don't know about that.
SPEAKER_01Why not? You're a dude. I am a dude, that's true. Are you a dude? And an insurance dude. I am an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_04I that is correct. I technically qualify.
SPEAKER_03You've met the criteria. How long have you been an insurance dude? Uh I've been an insurance dude.
SPEAKER_04How long have you guys been around? Like Earth? No. Um I've been an agent since 2014.
SPEAKER_05Oh, cool. Yeah. Jason. He just teed one up for you. How long have you guys been around? And then you were supposed to say, well, I haven't been around that long, but Craig has been around since the dinosaurs. There you go.
SPEAKER_04That's what I was looking for.
SPEAKER_03I'm off my game. Craig takes a vacation. I I lose my my touch. You were camping or something though. Maybe that's it. I did camp. I did camp. Nice. Yeah. So since 2014, did you buy an agency or did you uh start a scratch?
SPEAKER_04I bought an agency in Arizona, actually. Um I bought an agency in Scottsdale in 2014. Yeah. It's funny I didn't uh know Craig when I was when I was in Arizona, but uh here we are now. But uh yeah, so I I had an agency for a couple years in Arizona and then and then uh I came back to California to take over my parents' agencies. No both my parents are agents out here.
SPEAKER_03That's so cool. And how long were how long have they been agents?
SPEAKER_0430, 40 years.
SPEAKER_03Have you always thought about being an agent since you were young?
SPEAKER_04I always thought about never being an agent.
SPEAKER_05So but then you learned it was the most rewarding and best, most fun job ever.
SPEAKER_03Well, I mean, kinda, yeah. Let's take us through that journey. So so what were you off? What were you gonna do? I wanted to be a rock star. That obviously didn't pan out.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Um, I had no idea what I wanted to do. So I got into it's funny, my parents were in insurance for um 30, 40 years. I always said it was stupid and I never wanted to do it, and it was horrible.
SPEAKER_05Right.
SPEAKER_04And then my buddy says, I got a job as an adjuster, and you should come do it with me. And I so of course, my buddy, I listened to him. So I did it. So yeah, so I was an adjuster for nine years. Wow. Yeah, yeah. So I did home adjusting and then I did cat adjusting. So I traveled the whole country, saw some crazy, crazy stuff, and then found the right girl and said I gotta settle down. And that's when all of a sudden my parents talk about being an agent started to I started to listen.
SPEAKER_03Nice. Yeah, definitely. That was uh that was one of my motivations too, was once I got married, kids. It's like, hmm, that sound that bullering job sounds pretty cool. Yep, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_04I mean, I was I was on the road three weeks a month. So that uh that doesn't really work with with having a real life trying to settle down.
SPEAKER_03So yeah. Did and did that help you become an agent? What perspective did you bring from that experience that helped you as an agent?
SPEAKER_04Oh, I mean it it helps me a ton to really understand that side of the business. It's funny, I wish I understood being an agent when I was an adjuster. So now I look back at how I was an adjuster, I was like, man, I wish I understood what those guys go through, you know? And so yeah, um, you know, denying claims and you know, knowing you guys are gonna get an angry call and like not really weren't, you know, just didn't even I didn't even understand your side of the business. Like, this is just what we do. We deny claims when it should be denied. You say no, yeah. So just that's that's what we're taught to do. So I mean, if it should be denied, you know. Um so uh yeah, it was it was an interesting, interesting gig seeing. I mean, the types of damage I've seen. I did murder claims. Um, you'd be surprised how expensive those are. But uh houses, I think I did uh Sandy, yeah. I saw the I didn't do it, but I think I did the next door one to the one that was on the cover of Time magazine because like half the house was standing and half wasn't. So I did that. I did a claim for one of those and actually multiple of those. It's pretty crazy.
SPEAKER_03Crazy. So with that, like what with those experiences, what takeaways would you have that maybe an agent wouldn't have in those circumstances?
SPEAKER_04I mean, those are a little different just because they're so intense and so much going on, and it's you know, it's crazy. But like the normal claims, I think the key is just staying in touch with the customer. Like we, I don't know what's changed, it's been a while, but um the amount of work we have, we can't really stay in touch with them as much as you would want. And and a lot of times, you know, we speak claims adjuster talk, right? So, oh, this is our CV, and this you know, you try your best, but you're not gonna do a great job. So, as an agent to actually break it down for the customer and say, I know this is what they're telling you, but let me tell you in real world, this is what it means, this is why. That would be super helpful, yeah.
SPEAKER_03And that's interesting because a lot of times, you know, you hear from agents all the time that oh, the claims adjusters, like it's almost like they're just so beat up by the agents, you know, you know what I mean? Like and they get so poo-pooed on because of the way it was treated. But to your point, yeah, I mean that from that with that much going on, that's gotta be tough. And that really is our role, right? Our role is to be the face of that and uh kind of uh comfort, yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I mean, as an adjuster, it's all about you know, reading that policy and finding the tiny little things about this and that. And is there a windstorm opening or did the opening because of this? And like, you know, it's just so complicated. And so as an agent, you got to be able to break that down for people. So yeah, yeah, yeah. Luckily, I didn't get beat up too much from agents though. I so I can I'm happy about that. That wasn't too bad.
SPEAKER_05Well, yeah, from clients?
SPEAKER_04Oh, yeah, it is is bad. It was bad. Yeah, one I I never had anything too terrible, but I was threatened once where it was like scary. I had kind of had to run away. But uh and then there's ones where I was in um Newark, New Jersey, and I was sent into a building that was clearly um occupied by homeless people, and it was pitch black in the daytime. That was scary. That was scary. Oh and they kind of it was I actually left and told them I wouldn't do it, and then they said, Well, just get a flashlight, go at noon, you'll be fine. And uh I don't know, I just did it, but I I hope times have changed since then. They wouldn't make people do that anymore. That was like really scary. Now they got robots, but who would do it? Yeah, they have robots. Well, they should have they should have just provided like a security guard for me or something, probably would have been the smart thing to do. Right. Claim bot. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, but claims claims was fun, and I feel like it's kind of helped me a lot to understand what we sell, you know, and to understand the policy and why, you know, when I hear denials, I think I'm probably one of the nicest guys when we get denials and customers complain, and I have to call the adjuster and ask what's going on. I already know what they're dealing with, and I'm just like, just clarify it for me so I can break it down for them. Like I'm not sitting there yelling at them because I know exactly and I know they're right, usually. So right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Crazy. So taking over, so you get into the insurance game or into the agent game. And uh how is that journey over the last five years?
SPEAKER_04It's it's been a little crazy, yeah. Learning learning some of this agent stuff, you know, claims and and uh what we do, alliance and all this, it's completely opposite. Like they don't use anything. I didn't even know what a policy number was as an adjuster. I mean, okay, I knew what it was technically, but you don't even deal with policy numbers. It's like somebody calls and gives me a policy number, I'm like, that's that's nothing. Like, give me your claim number. I cannot search this at all. And so to come here, and then it's the exact opposite of that, right? If somebody gives you a claim number, what are you gonna do with it now?
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_04It's nothing, you know. So um, but it's been it's been a challenge. I remember that first week was was a nightmare. I had no idea what I was doing at all. And it that definitely lasted more than a week, but the first week was really bad. And uh and then just kind of slowly going from being clueless to starting to get a grasp of it to now being pretty having a pretty good grasp, not totally, but sort of understanding it.
SPEAKER_03You bought that agency in Arizona, did you uh sell it?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I sold it two years later. Yep. Oh, cool. And then you came over here? And then I came here to to uh my parents have bigger uh agencies, so even just running theirs was more profitable than owning my own in Arizona.
SPEAKER_03Oh, cool. So that's awesome.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. So then I was running two offices, about 15 employees. So I went from having one employee who was awesome, and I could kind of just trust him, he just kind of ran the show, to now having 15 in two different locations. That was a big that was that was a huge change.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, how different was that?
SPEAKER_04Oh, it's like a different job. I mean, completely different job. Because you know, when I had one employee, I was answering the phone half the time, you know, doing half the service work. Now you got 15 employees, I'm not doing any of the work and just trying to keep up with you know, I mean, one thing I can teach a lot of agents about, I feel like, from knowing the wrong way to do things is culture issues. You know, we had a lot of a lot of culture problems, um, and learning how to get through those was was challenging. Uh really challenging. It took a long time.
SPEAKER_03So did you have a couple the you know turnovers in staff completely or what what tied no, you know, honestly, I wish we had that.
SPEAKER_04It was a slow trickle, which which is bad because what happened right? Yeah, because what happens is like the one cancer like has already infected that group, and then when they're gone, the people who come in learn about the cancer and the way things were with the cancer from everybody else who experienced it personally, and then it can even happen to the third tier. Then that some of those people leave, and then they still have it. So it's sometimes it, you know. I first learned about agents who sometimes when they buy a book, they go in and day one they they just get rid of everybody. And at first I didn't understand that at all, and now I do because that what how it used to be is can be so damaging, especially in a long-term agency that knows about the 80s, you know.
SPEAKER_05From like from a human standpoint, it's tough to make that decision and do it, but I can also understand it because from a business standpoint, like starting fresh is there's there's no better way because as I've had that scenario play out so many times. One person was terrible, they poisoned everybody else, or some of the other people, you get rid of him, but then now this person over here is thinking that way, and you can't ah, it's so hard to get them back. Yeah, they've just they're gone.
SPEAKER_03It's just like hiring, it's like hiring somebody that's been in the industry for 10 years, right?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, yeah, they're gonna do it your way or they're gonna do it their way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. Oh, they're gonna do it their way or they're gonna do it their way.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But it's not in my nature to be that type of person, and that that harmed me. Like I can very clearly look back and reflect and say, caring about people too much um was damaging to the business. So you kind of you have to be able to put that business hat on and say, I gotta do what the right thing is for the business, and not just what what feels good or what feels right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, right. Because you got to look at the agency as a whole, it's like a it's its own entity, so it's not gonna hurt everybody. You gotta get rid of the person that is causing the pain for multiple people. And here's the other thing is that person that's causing all that pain probably doesn't care much about the business or the people in it because they wouldn't be acting like that. So you can care more for them than they actually care for themselves. And that's that's not good.
SPEAKER_04You're describing what happened. So you're absolutely right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_05But absolutely, you know what? And I think that in our in our world, you know, most of us are salespeople, right? And I think that there's something behind the need to be a salesperson, like you want people to like you, so you're a nice guy, you get along with prospects, you know, it's this whole you're a nice guy, you know, a nice gal, whatever. And that's why you can sell, right? That that's part of the whole thing because you can connect, you can create rapport. Where and so then with your staff, you're you're a nice guy and you're a salesperson. So you can sometimes, even with the cancer, you can still kind of you know, uh, maybe I won't, maybe, maybe I'm I'm making the wrong call right now, you know, and you go back to that nice guy attitude when you need to be business. I mean, there's a time when, and especially when there's 15 of them, you know, when you scale, holy moly, cancer just it grows exponentially.
SPEAKER_04And the other thing we learned too is the the fear that you have of if you lose the cancer and what you're gonna lose, especially I'm sure a lot of the older agents think of, oh, the older clients who like that person, that fear is always overblown. Like, I I can't believe even I thought it was gonna be at least a little bad, and it wasn't. It just wasn't. So it's DC. Yeah, yeah, it just wasn't that big of a deal. And so that's your whole reason for holding on to a cancer. That's that's another reason you're wrong to not do it.
SPEAKER_05Excuses, yeah, yeah. Come up with a million excuses why we don't want to do the one thing that is gonna be painful, which is telling them to leave when they're actually gonna expect it anyway because they're acting like a jackass. Yeah, yep. You know, I mean, they you tell them every time I've had that conversation, you sit down and they're like, Oh, okay, I get it. And you're like, Man, I was sitting there, couldn't sleep the night before, you know, at the beginning. Now it's pretty, you know, it's a lot easier. Yeah, yeah, I think it gets easier. Yeah, definitely.
SPEAKER_03Were your parents good mentors to you um for your agent? I mean, uh, obviously it's gonna be harder with parents, right? Like even my mom was a personal trainer, and it's like I never listened to her for a personal training. You know what I mean? I'll listen to other people, but it's just that mental block with parents. So, who were some mentors with you?
SPEAKER_04Well, my parents were great mentors in a lot of ways, and it probably is relevant to what's going on now, in that uh one of the ways my parents got so big was being smart during the last time the company made major changes and a lot of agents freaked out. They jumped in and bought up a bunch of agencies when everybody was freaking out and trying to get out. So that ended up being an amazing decision, and that's why we got big agencies now. Um, that doesn't always mean that history is gonna repeat itself, but theoretically, it's good to keep that in mind, right? So, in that sense, it's been super valuable to see you know what can happen when you be positive and try to um go with the flow and and make smart business decisions, especially with acquiring when that makes sense. Because even then they let them acquire uh a bunch of agencies and put them all in one office. So I only have one location um when technically it's like seven or eight agencies in one.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So I hope they do that again, although I'm not sure if they will. Yeah. Maybe, never know.
SPEAKER_03That's cool, man. So so when when it when a change comes and everybody's freaking out, you're kind of laughing, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah. Well, sort of. I mean, you know, it's not always the same, I'm not always laughing, but sometimes, I mean, the back of my head is yeah, how to find the positive in it, right? I mean, you could easily dwell on the negative, or you could say, okay, yeah, maybe there is negative, but maybe there's positive as well. So can I put that energy toward the positive? That's what I'm yeah.
SPEAKER_05That's what I'm trying to there is typically gonna be a positive and a negative.
SPEAKER_04Exactly. Almost everything there is, yeah, yeah, yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. And it's easy to focus on the negative and it's easy to listen to the to the negative Nancy's that are out there or negative uh Nates.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Just be gender correct. But yeah, but that's it. And your parents did uh they did listen, uh they did lean into the negativity and they use that as a positivity, right? They use that as the leverage to find how to get them to the next level. And it's like, I mean, I think that when when there are when there's a problem is when a solution is needed, and um there's a lot of opportunity. There's always opportunity and problems.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, exactly. Exactly. You hear a lot about how some of the richest guys, they they're excited for the next crash, right? Because a crash is a problem, but there's opportunities in it.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_04Yep. So you got to find those. And they can receive bigger opportunities than normal.
SPEAKER_05In any crash or any any you know, sell-off, right, which is what may be happening uh in in some companies. Is if if there's a sell-off, then it drives prices down. If prices are low, then I mean, when do you, you know, what's the what does Warren Buffett say? Right? Buy low. So there is a tremendous amount of opportunity that seems to be on the horizon.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And for a lot of the people with with books, with loans, like me, um, I'm you know, Ray Dalio's been in the news a lot lately, and he talked about how he spent so much money during the 08 crash. And his answer was either it's gonna get better and I'm gonna make a ton of money, or the whole world is gonna collapse anyway. So, what difference does it make? And it's kind of like if you already have a loan on your book, I mean, who cares if it's bigger? If you're gonna file for bankruptcy anyway, then what difference does it make? Go all in.
SPEAKER_03That's true. So yeah, that's kind of like when we talked to Jay Atkins, it was the same kind of kind of thing. He's he's a very all in type guy. And you see any of these big agents, you know, I uh anybody that's successful, they're all all in. You know, there's nobody's just dabbling, no one's like, uh, this kind of sucks. Like nobody, yeah, nobody's super successful on that line. But it's yeah, yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_05Calculate your risk and and make a decision.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, indecision can be just super costly. Yeah, yeah. And I've seen that too.
SPEAKER_05So yeah. Our guest that we we talked to before you um was was talking a lot about that kind of stuff, you know, like leaving your job to to become an entrepreneur, and and the things that he would hear, because he coaches, he helps people with that kind of thing. And you know, it's it's constantly, well, I'm gonna I'll I'll do that when I'm ready, or I'll do that in five years, I'll do that in ten years, or but it's yeah, and it never happens.
SPEAKER_04No, never happen.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely, absolutely. Yep. It's uh yep. Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman