The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Knights Of The Insurance Hiring Roundtable Deep Dive With Dave Williams And Kat Ternes
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Oh, Mr. Jason. Oh, Mr.
SPEAKER_06Craig.
SPEAKER_04I would like to introduce the knight of the insurance hiring round table. Deep.
SPEAKER_05Dave Williams and Cat. Uh it sounds like we're gonna learn a lot today. Well slap that cat and throw it over the wall.
SPEAKER_06Buckle up, it's the insurance dude podcast.
SPEAKER_03Well well, awesome. I I guess this is not a typical one of our podcasts, huh? Jason, is it? No, it is not. This is different. So we have Kat Turns from um from Agency Zoom, who was coerced coerced into uh working with Tolga. And then Dave Williams, uh a friend of the show that's been on uh before. So welcome.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, how's it going, guys? Awesome. Great, how you doing? Good, doing well, doing well.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So um actually the agency Zoom reached out to to organize this and and just kind of have a frank conversation about hiring, and who better to bring on to help facilitate that than Dave Williams, one of the co-founders of um Team Hired.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, we appreciate the opportunity to coming on and joining you guys and talking about it.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, love it.
SPEAKER_00Thank you.
SPEAKER_06So so Dave, um, let's a lot of people know you as an agent, and uh let's let's kind of go how how did you start Team Hired? And um can you take us kind of through that process?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. So, I mean, I've always had a passion for working with people and staffing and recruiting. That's kind of been my forte even before uh Allstate. You know, before Allstate, I worked at Circuit City as a store manager. I was in charge of a $20 million superstore, had a staff of 60 people, and we are constantly in recruiting. So when I when I came into Allstate, you know, we took a lot of the basic fundamentals that I did at Circuit City and I did in retail as an executive there, implemented them into Allstate. And I would say a big part of our success over the years of 10 years being in business, you know, so we started as a scratch agency, we grew to nearly $20 million in premium, mostly organically over time over the 10 years. But a big part of that success was really having a dynamic hiring process, and I'd say always having the mentality to always be hiring. So we were never in a situation where we would lose one of our best people or we'd be reactive, where we maybe had to make a bad hiring decision or a rushed hiring decision to get somebody in their filled position. So we are always, you know, just always in the process of hiring. And that honestly, that's probably one of my favorite parts of the job is getting to interact with people and in that hiring process. And I feel that that was something we mastered over time. And looking out just in the insurance vertical, and in even outside of that, in other businesses, the one thing I think is like the most difficult thing for the average business is finding good people. And I guess I just wanted to take my passion and to to be able to do that and our process to help others. And we we've been blessed to have a lot of success around the country so far. I think we're in the triple digits of how many positions that we've uh that we've filled for agents around the country. And we basically we dissected the hiring process of you know, really what gets in the way. And you know, one of the biggest things is, you know, especially for agency owners, business owners out there, is there's so many different hats that average business owner is wearing that there's not a lot of time to be in that mentality of always be hiring and always staffing. And when you break it down, like all the things that are involved in finding the right people, it's you're putting up job ads, you're hosting resumes, you're vetting those people. But to make the right hiring decision, what we found almost statistically, it takes about nine to ten bodies, nine to ten live people in front of you doing an interview to find that one rock star. So I thought to myself, and we thought to myself, my partner, uh, you know, Tom Bianco, like, how do we solve that for everybody out there? And we we really took a process that was working really well for us in order to do that. And that was hosting career events and hiring events for businesses and agency owners. You know, so basically what that looks like is you know, we'll put ads up all over the area. Like when we're even recruiting for ourselves internally, we'll put ads up all over the area. One of our last recruiting events that we did for ourselves internally, we had 145 people scheduled for a big career event that we did. We had 72 people show up, and the end result of that was uh six to seven hires that we had. And a lot of those people are doing very, very well for us. But that's what we'll do. We'll put ads up all over the area. We have a dedicated recruiter that works hand in hand with all of our clients, and she'll schedule these career events. And myself and our team will actually coach up the business owner how to effectively facilitate these career events. So now you're not spending an hour one-on-one with every single candidate, but you're literally sitting there in a group of five to ten people that you're interviewing simultaneously. So it's conserving time, and you get to talk to all those people in one hour segment. But the the cool thing about it, I think, in my opinion, it is it creates a unique dynamic and atmosphere there. So, what we found in the years of staffing and recruiting is there's a lot of professional interviewers out there. And what I mean by that is they've been on so many different interviews, they're just like really good at answering those same interview questions over and over again. And that can cause somebody to, you know, maybe make the wrong hire because they get in, they talk the talk, but when they get in, they can't walk the walk. Like they got call reluctance, they lack confidence. What's unique about this, like this group dynamic that we do is when they're in when you're interviewing everybody else, that professional interviewer maybe that lacks confidence, this creates a little bit higher pressure of an interview situation to see how they react a bit under pressure because now they're interviewing from you, the prospective employer, but they got four other strangers sitting next to them that they gotta perform in front of. And those people that might not be cut on the cloth that you're looking for, they get weeded out in that process very quickly so you don't make a hiring mistake. But the opposite end of that, like the rock stars, the ones that do very well, they tend to stand out extremely well. They're the ones that are the most articulate, the ones with the most energy. And then those are the ones we recommend our clients to bring back for the uh for that second one-on-one interview at that point. But the process, it's worked really, really well so far. And we've again we've been having success for ourselves and across the country for agents.
SPEAKER_03Dude, that that's awesome, Dave. Thank you. Um, and you know, I actually had some experience uh because you didn't know on the rocked the house for you guys whether you had what like 24 people show up. You I yeah, I think there we're there were 25, five or late, so we booted them, but they ended up sitting out there the whole time. We didn't even know they were out there, they just sat in the front. Um but but yeah, we got results, and and I would do want to talk about that. But before I get to that, I think that it's important to acknowledge something that you said near the beginning, which is the it is probably one of the hardest parts finding top candidates and and sort of like in the way that we do our sales, right? We create a funnel. So we have a whole bunch of people that we call, then we have a a little bit less that we quote, and then we get down to the sales, right? So I as the business owner, the way that you're gonna be most effective is by doing that same thing with the potential, you know, with the always be recruiting and always be hiring. Um I think that agency owners, um, whether captive or or independent or or even you know ECP or startup, whatever it is, and especially in those instances where it's really high turnover because they don't know what's going on, um, that they that they'll if they get somebody good, they they kind of get comfortable and they think, oh, well, I I'm good, you know, because I have a solid team.
SPEAKER_00They let their foot off the gas, right? Right.
SPEAKER_03You know, and and even in in I've I mean I've done this 10 years, I've I'm fairly experienced. I I don't think I'm by any means, you know, some pro at all this because you learn something new every day. But I opened on November 1st, I had seven people. I lost five of them in the first two weeks, right? Just all of a sudden it's like everything went wrong, you know, and so that was around the same time when when we set up the event. So we got out of the event, there were 25 showed up, 20 that we brought into the room, and we hired five of them. Now, of the five, two have started. One has ghosted me, another one moved away, and the other third one is taking her test tomorrow. So there may be a third, which I think would be great numbers off of having 20 people. You know, if we got that's a huge win. A huge win.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, to live I am wrong.
SPEAKER_03I actually one of them uh he started before the other two who started a couple days ago. No, I have three, so I'll have four potentially. And the the first one to give real numbers, he's at almost 15,000 in premium for December, and he started December 1st.
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. That's phenomenal.
SPEAKER_03So, you know, that's that's a big win.
SPEAKER_00And that's better numbers than I can work with out here. Like trying to do software in InsureTech to bring on the team of five that we just brought on. We started with 80 people. Woo! And that was it, it is a time suck. Like Dave mentioned, you know, as an agency owner, you can never like let off the gas to you know what Craig was mentioning there. You just never know when you're safe because you're really never safe. You know, your best performer could get a fantastic opportunity and you don't want to hold them back. Um, you certainly want to be, you know, happy for them and say, Oh, I've, you know, put people in successful positions. Um, and then there are times that people are gonna be uh a bad hire, you know, you want to avoid those the most to your ability or a rushed hire, which is somewhere kind of in between. You know, those are the people that come in and you you apply 1080 10 to them and you're like, you know, this just isn't working out, or you need so much of my time. But yeah, it was it is beyond difficult. And it's a candidates market across the whole country right now. You know, the unemployment rate is down. Um, we're seeing this uh just uniformly across the industries. And I think we're all looking for experienced good talent too, you know, people that are really gonna be a great fit for our organization long term. You know, we don't we're not looking for short-term seasonal hires, you know, as close to Christmas as we are, we're that's not what we're looking for. We're looking for people that are gonna make a big impact in our organizations, and that just makes it even harder to find the right people.
SPEAKER_06Yeah. And I think one of the big problems is most or or a lot of agents, a lot of agencies are delusional about everything across the board, you know, about sales. I mean, it's the same process for hiring is that it's sales. You know, you have to get those hundred people in there to find five to ten or or or whatever that may that number may be in your area. But I mean, it's it's just numbers, just like uh quotes and everything. And it's like if people really want to get serious about hitting their numbers, hitting, you know, getting enough people in the office so they can actually sell and and all this stuff, they gotta get this stuff down. They gotta be real about the numbers and know that hey, if I have to, if I have 10 hires, I need to get 100 people in there. And realistically, I have eight hours in the day, I gotta motivate my current staff, I've got to do all this stuff. I have to bring in a team to bring in a team. Like there's no way one person can do it all.
SPEAKER_03It's just one little spoke of the wheel, you know? Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we've seen that like the exact same thing because what happens a lot, because it can be a daunting process, we find that they're they're looking for that perfect candidate. And a lot of times what can happen is like there's this over analysis paralysis that leads to the end result being hiring nobody or getting nobody in front of you. But at that point, Jason, what we found is it it's a numbers game. The same way, you know, it might take you 10 quotes to close a deal, but not every one of those quotes is gonna be an IS4, and that's why our process is like we get all these live people in front of somebody, and it's by design, there's gonna be some people that don't fit the cloth in there, but we know out of nine to ten live candidates, there's gonna be inevitably a rock star amongst them that's gonna be the right mold in in the agency that's gonna be able to deliver.
SPEAKER_03Right, and that's it could so so it when when we had them, what we did, I brought him into my conference room. So we brought them all in the conference room, and then I gave a little spiel, you know, welcomed them all, said a said a whole thing. And then I said, Does anybody have any questions? The first guy that that just started going, like he just you know went, hey, I'm from Geico, and he did he presented himself in front of everybody. He's the one that actually is the one that wrote the 15k. Like it was like you could see like just right off the bat. And then there were there were three others because we broke into like breakouts. So it was my operations manager and then another manager from another office. So we had three, we had you know, three different rooms where it was a smaller group, did the setting. Two of the ones that were in my room are the guys that just started, and then the two from one of the other rooms, one of them was was good. I think she's gonna start tomorrow. She's probably gonna pass. And then um the other one who they said she was quiet, but then when I did one-on-one interviews, I liked her. And to your point about the professional interviewer, she's one that's disappeared. So I went against the whole, you know, I was like, ah, I shouldn't have, I shouldn't have known, you know. But it but it's remarkable because one thing that they all said was, I did not expect to be in a room with a whole bunch of people and have to talk like that. And it's like, well, that's the job, right?
SPEAKER_01You're and that's the great thing about it too, because it creates this dynamic where they are caught up a little bit off guard with it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And you know, we find the key is is we have an orientation, we simply explain the process. During the orientation, you know, we we find it's important to talk about the opportunity at your business at Allstate, the culture, what it looks like, so they really understand the career path and this the size of the scope of the opportunity that they have in front of them there. But again, it creates this a little bit higher pressure environment where that professional interview, they're not they're not used to that, catches them off guard, and again, prevents you from making that potential hiring mistake.
SPEAKER_06Yep.
SPEAKER_00I think that competition factor too, like you really see who's gonna like put their head down and like grind and like has that grit to like get out there and talk about it and be confident that you, like you said, what you're doing. Um, I think it does remove that professional interviewer from the area that they are most comfortable just going through the motions in and gives us that advantage again to really see the inherent skills that hopefully we've all identified as valuable within our agencies or our businesses.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_06And and I'll and I'll bring up something. So I I've actually been doing this for about six months now, uh, the the big group interviews, and it's a little intimidating at first. Like, and and I think that there are a lot of agency owners out there probably when they're listening to this, think like, wow, that's an uncomfortable situation. Yeah. And it is at first, just like coaching is, just like everything else is. So get over it. And if you really wanna, if you really want like doing one-on-one interviews in this day and age, just you'll never you'll never reach your goals. I mean, that's like doing one one quote a day. Like, how are you ever gonna sell anything?
SPEAKER_01And it and it's that's exactly why we make part of our process, too. It's not just we're gonna deliver people to you, but we do have a coaching element to it too. So when we're in there, we're gonna walk somebody through that process A to Z to make sure when they walk into their first career event, they're comfortable, they're confident. And then we find just exactly that. Like some people are like, hey, I've never done this before, they're a little bit nervous, but after they do it, it's almost like every single time I will never interview any other way ever again, because it it just it delivers the result and it's just a lot more, a lot more efficient.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, and we've we've used Team Hired, and and last uh we we were supposed to have an event last week. My my entire family got sick. It was a nightmare, and and I had to be out of the office and stuff. And they rescheduled everything. And I, dude, if I didn't have the team hired team helping with that, we would never like there's no way I would have rescheduled or I would have been so behind the eight ball. So it's like you gotta you gotta invest in somebody to help you with the hiring. Because when life happens, it's like that's the last thing you're gonna, you're never gonna call those people out of the list of stuff you have to do. The hiring part of it is the last thing that you'll probably um you know put at the top of your list because to run your agency.
SPEAKER_00I think everybody has to be aware of their own like shortcomings, whether that's in like an agency management position, like I can recruit, but I can't train, you know, it's not my strong suit. So I need to look at options of how once I bring these people in and I've busted my butt to get them in the door and they're here, like, how do I keep them around? You know, that's like an option all the way to, you know, there might be some people that are the most sincere and devoted like coaches, and they just struggle creating enough time then for new hires. So yeah, I think people have to either bring on a person that like fulfills their weaknesses, and that's a difficult hire. Uh that's a super self-aware, you know, reflective hire is who's gonna meld well with you, or you have to get somebody, you know, like Dave's team that's professional at it and is giving you like, listen, we know the numbers, here's the process, follow it, and you're gonna get the kind of you know results that you need, and then you can do a fantastic job at the things that you're really incredibly talented at. You know, there's no point struggling over things that you're are never gonna really move the needle for your business.
SPEAKER_01And I completely agree with that statement too, because that that getting them in the door, that's one part of the process. But it's like when you find that like that right person, that superstar, now it's like, how do I keep them? How do I maintain them? How do I motivate them? So, what we found is a best practice for that too is what we'll do in our organization. So we we got pretty high retention. A lot of our people have been with us like three to five years. And I believe that's because you know, we have a defined career path for everybody that's in our organization. If they start with us for a telemarketer, they know the length of time and the actions and steps that they need to take to get to that licensed sales producer position. They know what they need to do to become a senior licensed sales producer, they know what they need to do, become a supervisor, sales director, all the way up towards you know, mentoring to the point where they can open up their own agency. So when we have them come in, is the best practice. We'll find like one of the best people in our organization that's got the most potential, and maybe they have goals to open up their own agency one day or be an agency manager, we'll involve them in the process and we'll tell them that hey, this is gonna be part of your development. We want you to be in this process, and this is gonna be a perfect test for you because, in my opinion, the most important thing in running an agency, there's a million things to focus on, or running a business in general, is being able to bring on the right people, but then develop them to the level where they're gonna be able to grow your business. And this is gonna be a test for you. We're gonna essentially put this person under your wing for 90 days to see how well you can do. And we have involved in that process from A to Z, even in the upfront orientation, we'll have that um key person speak to a day in the life of the position with the candidates. We'll allow them to ask some interview questions. And then once we onboard that person, which we have that candidate in part of the decision-making process, they're mentoring underneath them. And then what we do is we put an incentive structure in place and say, hey, if this person hits this performance level in the first month, maybe you're gonna get a thousand dollar bonus. If they hit this performance level, you're gonna get a $1,500 bonus. So they're incentivized during that 90-day process. But what's also what's great about it is this new person that knows nothing about the business is mentoring underneath our best, most capable, most talented individual. And we find a lot of the training honestly comes through osmosis when they're sitting next to that caliber of individual before you see it, like day one, week one, uh, month in, all of a sudden they're mimicking and styling the behaviors, the mannerisms, the talk pass of that individual. And all of a sudden you have a mini-me of that of that person that's out on your floor. And we we found that to work very well in helping develop somebody in our agency that's looking to go to the next level, but at the same time, get that person in that, you know, early on, get some early wins and success and the right level of training and support.
SPEAKER_06I think that's a key is get the new hires with the early wins. I see it so often, and in our agency, we know that if somebody's not selling within two weeks, that their self esteem is down. Oh, there's no almost no recovering.
SPEAKER_01And in that mindset, once they get to that point, it's so tough to overcome that because now they've developed over two weeks, they've developed limit. beliefs and it's tough to break those reliefs those those beliefs that they have there but when they're when they're sitting alongside your best I I've always found like I have a terminology I like to use shadow of a leader like shadow of a leader to me is very important it's like what shadow are you casting your in your agency every single day because you can come in and demand people to do something or instruct people to do something but I've always found people will do as you do before they do as you say. And if you have them next to somebody that's literally they're seeing them eat, live and breathe they're practicing what they preach like there's no excuse not to do it. Like they just get it's like get on the train or get off and we found the right people more times than not they're going to get on the train and they're going to start to mimic the same behaviors and results.
SPEAKER_00Right. Makes sense.
unknownYep.
SPEAKER_00You're using that top 10% of your hires to really move the middle that initial you know that 80% that's always going to be there using those all stars and giving them more responsibility which you know so many people are craving uh how do I get to the next step? What's the plan? Yeah that's that's certainly part of it. That our recruiting style style has even come out of a similar mentorship and the opportunity as you're becoming successful to take on additional responsibilities as often as possible you know bringing in a referral somebody that is friends of friends whether that was at a previous company and organization whether that was you know they went to college together we hire a relatively I don't know group of young people so you know we still have that as a successful funnel. But yeah it just it helps so much to have the mentorship attached to the leadership that it's like you said Dave just not do as I say not as I do but you they're really watching you like live and breathe as a wonderful example. No absolutely Kat can you kind of talk about your background with hiring and and your ramping up of um agency zoom and and kind of your process yeah so like I said to start off our process it is a little bit nutty we do cold outreach um of the people I've hired in the past and that's anywhere from what you guys would consider equivalent to a telemarketer. You know if I was looking for somebody to be able to sell to all state agents it certainly wouldn't hurt to go grab an all-state telemarketer or a sales producer. Those would be really the two roles that I've spent a lot of time with um and we traditionally bring them into that telemarketing role initially and then groom them and grow them up into the organization. We do our best to not bring somebody in ahead of somebody else who's been there busting their butt. But it does it starts with them doing some amount of outreach, us doing cold outreach out of everyone I've hired, I've only ever taken one active candidate. Everybody else is sitting at a desk job, sitting pretty, liking their life, making the most of it you know they're even if their job isn't perfect, they have that like grit and that intensity to like go make the most of it. So yeah that that slows down the process but I think one of the things too to the point that you're all using that I love and we've done similar in the past are those events. You got to treat it like a pipeline and you can never kill a deal in a pipeline. You know like if somebody says like if I'm talking to Jason and I'm like listen Jason I think you have a good opportunity to learn more at your current company and he's like you know Kat, yeah I'm probably okay where I'm at. Don't force it you know figure out what the difference is going to be when you can make that greatest impact and make sure Jason's coming to those group events so that everybody else that's there for the first time knows what type of person you're looking for. Turn Jason into the biggest advocate for your company and then make sure that everybody that is part of your company is attending those events too you know Craig I think you said you had your operations manager there. You can't just have one person you know you can't just have the rock star there. It's got to be everybody uh because you just don't know who's gonna come in the door and who's gonna matter most and connect with someone on an individualized level. So we do proactive outreach. We're spending time with people on a one-to-one basis but as soon as somebody's in that pipeline you know until they tell me cat you're crazy lady please go away like stop checking out my LinkedIn profile. We're we're staying in touch and making sure they're attending those group events and we try and keep a pretty tight schedule on those to be doing those once every two months um you know I want to know if the smallest thing starts coming up in somebody's life that they're starting to feel like they're topping out at their current career and then it's my job to nurture them and if I can get them into my organization and take them to that next level uh to get to do that then.
SPEAKER_01So that's great.
SPEAKER_03Yeah I think it's important to nod to the to the uh importance of expertise. Um and Dave you know your background before you but and I it's such a great story I I I almost want to have you tell it again um you know how I can give you the cliff notes version of it I mean I think that's great in case anybody missed the original um the original podcast with with you because that's that's a really cool story. And then the importance though that because you've done all these things and you've done it 10,000 times it's much more effective even though it may seem like it costs a lot to to bring in somebody to do this whether it's team hired or somebody else but but you bring somebody in and they know how to do this thing. And look your time is better spent over here because like I said I mean you're you're doing a million things and you hire the wrong person because you're doing it on the cheap it doesn't pay off but um if if you could I mean your story's great I love the no absolutely and on that point too we actually kind of perfected it down to a science where the you know the cost of our package we found ends up being more affordable than they're putting up all the ad spend following the normal process that we do.
SPEAKER_01You know, could we go as low as you know $15 to $2,000 for in in a higher in the package which which again I think works out pretty competitive when you look at the average recruiting agency that's uh that's out there and uh you know small price to pay to have a a you know a superstar join your team and your organization.
SPEAKER_00Dave are you taking on new clients because when you tell me and I'm going to coffee like every morning starting at 6 30 when the coffee shop opens and I'm coming into work at nine um and you tell me for $15 to $2,000 you know I'm gonna be able to sit down and like have good candidates show up at my door like I could use some extra sleep. So you tell me when you start taking on new clients.
SPEAKER_01Consider it no we'll connect after the call but no I mean to give you give you the you know cliff notes version of you know my story again I mean I've been again was with Allstate for for 10 years that led up to you know launching team hired. But you know back 10 years ago I fell uh you know down on my luck a little bit you know I I deal with health challenges and back then it was at its worse I had some autoimmune issues that put me off of work for about six months on disability and you know I used to play college baseball and uh I I thought that's what I was gonna do uh my entire life that didn't pan out and I had to figure out what I was gonna do and I started uh just selling car stereos at Circuit City found out I was pretty good at sales good with people moved up very quickly became an executive store manager and that was my career for 10 years and uh when I started having health issues I went off to work on disability for about six months probably got in the the worst financial position I ever was in because not working for six months not getting an income uh it it it's it it makes it pretty difficult. Finally got to the point, you know, health wise I wasn't ready to come back to work but I had to force myself to come back to work because otherwise uh I was going to lose my position. So came back to work before I was ready and then three months later I got hit again and found out the circuit city was following chapter 11 uh in and going bankrupt. So now I was going to lose my career at the same time and it was just a lot of a lot of mixed emotions it was a lot of change but it was a it was a blessing in disguise because it it canapulted me and into in into the the right scene. So what you know what happened next throughout that process was I had a friend of the family that was with Allstate. You know I was done working with people and even at the time I had doctors telling me that hey you know what most people with what you got they end up on long-term disability it's nothing to be ashamed of and I was I just told myself I'm like that's not the life that I'm gonna live I'm gonna create a life on my own terms that's conducive to my health it's conducive to my family and I literally no no lie I can show you a picture I still have it hanging in my office at home I wrote myself out a check for a million dollars and that check for a million dollars wasn't about the money at all. It was something to give me a mental picture and a visual every single day. I literally looked at that check every single day and what it meant to me was creating that life for myself creating a life that was on my own terms taking care of my family because you know my parents I wanted to you know take care of my beautiful wife and provide a life for her and my parents growing up literally like gave the shirts off their back for me and never me and my sister I had a brother that went down the wrong path and they never wanted to see us go down that same path. So they literally sacrificed everything never bought new clothes never went on vacation so I made it my mission that I wanted to be able to give back to them and be able to gain enough resources that I could provide them a life of their dreams and I was able to um you know God willing bring them on probably eight inner circle trips. They went to every single Allstate award trip that they were able to win and you know it was a complete blessing. But when back when uh I first started talking to somebody at Allstate about the opportunity I was like you know what I'm in. People were then telling me hey go work for somebody first I was like you know what I'm just gonna go all in I'm just gonna figure this thing out open up an agency but the problem I had was I just came back from a difficult financial situation and didn't have the capital. So shortly after that I just started getting my licensing I was like you know I'm gonna figure it out I'm gonna figure out a way and then when the liquidators came into Circuit City they basically said all the open merchandise Dave we need to blow out and we just got to get rid of it pennies and a dollar anything that's a customer return any open merchandise I saw that as my opportunity to raise capital. I took the last about $7,000 out of my 401 ended up buying um close to $80,000 of the merchandise took it all sold it all online paid off my debt and then raised the capital I needed for my first scratch agency hired two people that lost their job with me at Certain City and honestly like we just from day one of my agency open I I acted as if I I still looked at that check every single day and realized that was my freedom and I acted as if somebody was trying to take that away from me 24 hours a day. No joke when I first got in there day one our instructor came in to train us on how to quote how to run an agency all that and they said the first two weeks we're going to be training and then you can start selling and I'm like listen I don't have the luxury to do that. I'm literally 30 60 days away from you know being out of business if we don't hit some major revenue. So I'm like what what I'd rather have you do is train me, teach me and coach me while I'm in action and our first location was across from the DMV inside of a shopping mall and I literally ran out and started grabbing people out of line and I still my first customer is still with me to this day Geraldo Hernandez our first customer I remember bringing him in out of the DMV line we signed up as motorcycle his home his autos and I had no idea what I was doing it literally took us I think five hours to sign up all of his policies with this trainer and instructor and then that's how we learn but we learn fast but because you know back to my point like shadow of a leader because I set that level of intensity and I set that kind of tone what do you think the two employees that I just unbonded how do you think they acted and performed it was like literally there was no room to do anything but hustle and grind all day long. And that's what we did to build a business and we didn't have anything fancy back then it wasn't we I didn't have the money to buy leads I didn't have any of the stuff I literally worked out of a phone book the equivalent of a phone book we're using Cole XD's sales genie and just pounding the phones all day long getting people perfecting our pitch getting people interested quoting them and closing them and I think in our very first month we did 70 something items we started to bring some revenue in and then I started to pull myself out of the business and focus on the business building best practices processes systems investing in marketing that you know allowed us to scale it today to you know close to 20 million dollars in revenue that's exceptional that's like the kind of thing that you like tell a team during the like you know halftime for like national championship like I got back out there get back out there like that is of course it is it is and and so that's why I would love um to kind of get your head I'd love to know where your head's at with this so when you hire someone um what are you looking for?
SPEAKER_06Like with all that experience and with your drive and and what you've been able to do what are the qualities that you would say are the just hands down what you're looking for?
SPEAKER_01Yeah so I mean what we're looking for at the end of the day is that high energy individual that's motivated that's driven that's looking for that opportunity to get him to the next level a lot of the people that have moved on from us to own their own agencies to become agency managers you name it they started in you know we had some people that were you know flipping burgers they were they're like they're looking for a career path and I love somebody that's hungry that's looking for that opportunity and they've just never gotten it in life and somebody that's really hungry and willing to put in the degree of effort that it takes to be extremely successful in that business or in this business. So I mean that that's really the caliber of person we're looking for somebody dynamic. I know there's a lot of people out there they're looking for sometimes to fill that void and looking for the path the least resistant like hey I want a licensed person that's already trained. And I've actually found that more times than not that that can be detrimental because what I found when you hire a licensed candidate and there's exceptions to this rule but more times than not you hire a licensed candidate they're not out in the job market looking because they're crushing it somewhere else and they up and level like precisely a hundred percent work out somewhere else they're hopping habitually agency to agency and what I find with that is embedded limited beliefs in that person is typically not coachable. But most importantly and more even more detrimental when they come into your operation like all the other great people in your operation they can come in and bring them down very quickly with their mentality and their attitude because they they might have come from an environment you're asking them to do 40 50 items in a month performance wise and insurance vertical and they came from an environment or an agency that hasn't done that in four months. So they might nod their head yeah I'll do that I'll get it done but what really what they're thinking is like that impossible like Dave's out of his mind there's no way I can do that. But they're not saying that you know who they're saying that to is all the other people in your office. Yeah when they hear when other people in your office hear that intrinsically over and over from somebody they perceive is experienced in the business that can they all of a sudden you got somebody having a bad week or a bad month they start to buy into that person and you take a really good producer in your agency and it brings them down. So I like somebody that's that's got the right cloth like even somebody that's in retail we hire people from Best Buy for example you know we we know that somebody from Best Buy if they're working in their TV department their computer department that's one of the higher gross margin areas in Best Buy and they'll put their best salespeople in there. And they'll also when they promote their salespeople to a supervisor it's typically their best salespeople and they're really undercompensated. A lot of their supervisors at Best Buy make $14 an hour. So somebody like that that's in retail I know that's hungry they're willing to put in retail hours and they're grinding and not even getting compensating according to the degree of effort they're putting in and I can plug them into this give them a career that person is going to stick with me they're gonna be loyal that's somebody I can mold and develop and if I tell them hey 40 items is the price of admission to to earn your seat here they're gonna do it and they're gonna do whatever it takes. So I'd rather take somebody from the ground up mold them coach them and that's that's how every single superstar we've had in our organization they started without a license and we we've gotten them to that point where um you know they're crushing it now.
SPEAKER_00I feel like this might not come as a surprise in the insurance space considering how much time we spend at each of these respective areas but the two people that like I will take time with no matter who they are bartenders and caddies if you are willing to haul around somebody else's junk in the heat and you like can just make small talk like you're a walking agency management system to me. You know you like know what is up and same with a bartender like if you can keep that small talk and you're engaging and you can multitask to that level and you're on your feet all day like and I say like I can give you you know a career path there's gonna be growth here you know there's gonna be stability and not working until you know 3 or 4 a.m anymore carrying kegs like life's better you know and it's just an opportunity and we grade everybody when we go through during the on like the actual recruiting process on uh grit, passion curiosity uh competition and whether they're a challenger you know can I change your mind as a person? You know am I curious enough to understand you and then impactful and passionate enough to change your mind um and and those those are just people that have it you know it's been in green no different than the people at Best Buy that probably get told like hey kick rocks you know nine out of 10 times but they're still just as cheery when I walk in right after somebody else and there's already a long line like they're working their butts off. Like there's just a lot of people out there that don't have any bad habits they don't have those limiting behaviors or that mindset. And you can just do so much like with a good training program and like the right um tech stack and everything you need to make them successful there are so many opportunities out there. And we I mean our first 30 days they're they're kept track of off of a really really small quota like really reduced like get in understand it learn it so that you can maintain your personality and feel confident in what you do. And then we we judge them off of 360s how are they integrating are they supporting their teammates are theyighing down one teammate are they weighing down the group and we just rate um six core competencies in that 360 on a scale of one to five and that doesn't come from me that comes from the peers the people that are in that role with them and that's how we start weeding out Dave to your point like the bad apples you know if somebody comes in even if they're an all-star everybody's had that lone wolf before even if they're an all-star like and they're killing the culture and they're pulling down the opportunity somebody else has to be great six months from now a year from now whatever it takes them to get there that's a bigger indication and a bigger like red flag to me than just you know you come up one item short you come up four items short you know you're 10% behind I can get you there. If you have the you know the passion for doing it and you have the grit and the curiosity we'll get you there. But if you just have that poor attitude you're never gonna overcome that.
SPEAKER_06Yep. And we've had the same experience as you as you did Dave with with hiring those experienced uh agents it's almost almost never worked out uh almost never uh and and the other thing to what Cal was saying is dude you got to have a culture of gratitude like you gotta have people that are grateful for being there um then it makes uh an entire culture of where you're grateful that they're there and like everybody's helping each other you actually want to show up to work there's been a couple times in our agency where I just didn't even want to show up like it's horrible. And those those rock stars I I had a couple uh those rock stars that really weren't rock stars but that had the highest sales at the time really brought down everybody else and they eventually left and and then you have to clean up after their messes for years.
SPEAKER_01Well it's not worth having them in organization. Like I was honestly in the same shoes at at one point Jason so I always having the same thing going on organization. We had a couple people that were you know crushing it sales wise but they weren't living in breathing like our company culture the way we wanted it to and you know I think for over time I think a lot of people can relate you know like oh this person's performing I'm gonna let this slide let this slide but I went to a conference and I heard this guy speak up on stage his name was JJ he operated the number one through seven Honda dealerships in the entire country he ran seven Honda dealerships and every one of them ranked one through seven in the country and they asked him on stage what do you attribute your success to and he said non compromising company culture and he laid out non negotiables and the that was the biggest thing I took out of the way of the culture I immediately developed my non negotiables I went back and I said you know what my name is on the door going forward I'm not gonna walk in a work environment anything less Than my perfect work environment. So I developed these non-negotiables and laid it out to our team. And we gave people time to adapt. We basically told them, like, I don't care how much you sell, if you cannot eat, leave, and eat, live, and breathe our company culture and non-negotiables going forward, you just can't be off the team. And basically, you know, some of the non-negotiables we put in place was uh, you know, always be coachable to PMA. So we require PMA. If you look in our agency, we got signs up everywhere that said no negativity allowed. But PMA is positive mental attitude. Like it's literally a terminal offense in our agency. If we catch somebody in there perpetuating negativity intentionally that's bringing down their teammates, like that being said, you know, people can have problems and we got an open door policy where they can come to us. But what we don't tolerate is somebody expressing their problems in a negative way that's bringing down others that's not conducive to our work atmosphere. You know, living with integrity with every single thing that they do, always be coachable, training every single day. Those are some of the non-negotiables that we put in place for everybody, and we drew a line, and we had some people that were top performers of us and they couldn't adapt to that and we separated ways. And you know, some people are afraid of that, like, oh, it's gonna kill my production. But our production increased. Like everybody was glad when we had this culture, and now what we do is we protect the heck out of that culture. So when we bring in a new hire, like a lot of times our agency and our people and our team, they'll vet that person out before they even get in there. They're like, this person isn't living our core values as an agency, or this person can't hold up to them, and we'll get rid of them before they even become a problem. So I I found culture is like absolute must, absolute key. Develop the right custom culture and protect it at all costs.
SPEAKER_03So huge. And and also on the on the hunt, right? If you are looking for just license, and even more specific, because you hear it all the time, if somebody's all state or farmers, oh, I want them to have farmers experience, right? And it's like, well, let's just shrink the candidate pool when we have to actually create a big funnel, right?
SPEAKER_01Why would we limit ourselves to that's almost like the equivalent of saying, you know what, I'm not gonna quote anybody, I'm not gonna review anybody's insurance policy unless I know they have an 800 perfect credit score, they own three houses, and they have seven cars. You're gonna go out of business looking for that person. You're never gonna hire anybody looking for that person. You're gonna get what's gonna happen out of it is an over-analysis paralysis in the situation that's gonna result in not the results that you're looking for. So it is, you know, it's a it's a numbers game.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you'll end up if you if you have your expectations and you've set this net so tight, you'll end up with those rushed hires. They're not gonna be necessarily bad hires, but you'll compromise to a point to get people there in the time frame that you need them. And rather than being open-minded to some exceptional talent that needed development from the get-go, you end up with some average talent that maybe have some, you know, bad habits here and there that they're just never gonna be the rock stars. You know, you're never gonna have that upward potential sitting there that you could develop. No diamonds in the rest, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think I think the message here is too, it's not just about finding the hire. There's a lot of components of getting the hire, developing the hire, maintaining the hire in there, too. That's that's what I love about the process with recruiting. So, a team hire, that's why we try to differentiate ourselves too, is you know, we'll be as involved in the process as you let us. Like somebody can call my phone anytime, and if it's not even about hiring, if it's about company culture, whatever it is, you know, I want that to be a massive success for the customer because it is it's not just a one, a one avenue of getting the person in there. There's a lot of steps in getting them to be a top performer and then you know, retaining that person in in you know, within your uh within your company culture.
SPEAKER_06I want to touch on something real quick. In your opinion, if you had a smaller agency that only needs like two to three people, or maybe even just two, would you hire one at a time to find the right person?
SPEAKER_01No, I would always be overstaffed by one person because at the end of the day, if if you're prepared to lose somebody and you always got somebody on the bench, um, I would 100% overstaff, especially going into the environment that we're gonna be facing coming up, you know, because compensation models change. It's all about acquisition. If you go into that and you're not prepared to, you know, acquis execute an acquisition model, um, you know, it's gonna be a tough go-ahead and you could get behind really quickly. And by not having that extra person in falling in a reactive hiring state, it could cost you your year, could cost you your bonus, cost you everything. It's gonna be detrimental at your office. So I would I'd be we have a philosophy to always have a bench. So one of the things that we'll do and that we found to be real successful too, is especially if we bring somebody in, um, a lot of times we'll start them in what we call a sales support role. So we'll reward our top producers by assigning a sales support agent to them that's basically doing some of the heavy lifting, calling out, giving talk passing, generating live quotes. So they'll start in that role, hitting the phones, just a real simple job description where they got to get on the phone and talk to, you know, you gotta make $250 a day and talk to people, give a specific pitch and support one of our best sales reps. So that's rewarding our top sales reps. So instead of investing as much into live transfers and a lot of marketing, we'll invest in people to generate those live transfers ourselves internally. But what that's doing at the same time is that's giving additional people in our organization. It's a creating a bench. So the ones that come in and perform at a very high level, we'll set the expectation. If you come in 30, 60 days and you crush it, you're you're generating like 1.5 to two quotes an hour, and you're helping one of our or couple of our licensed sales producers really succeed. We'll give you the opportunity to get in their shoes really quickly. So get this done in 60 days, over deliver for us. We'll then invest in you at that point, get you license, and allow you to live in the shoes that everybody else's. So, I mean, what that does is they come in, they start crushing it for 60 days, delivering like some pretty good results for our sales producers, but that gives us a good gauge before we go in and make a major investment, get somebody license, invest in all this training, and find out they don't work out. This gives us a good snapshot of how they act in our culture, how they work with their coworkers. In a lower position, are they trying to earn their keep to get to the next level or are they just settling? So if they come in and they're living all the attributes that we look for, that's how we know like this person is gonna be our next rock star on the sales team, and then we'll promote them and move them up to the to the role.
SPEAKER_06Love that. Yeah, that's a great that's a great idea. Okay, we've we've had you guys for an hour, and thank you guys so much. Um, what is one one knowledge nugget that you would give to any insurance agent out there when it comes to hiring? Um let's start with you, Kat, and then and then you, Dave. One knowledge nugget.
SPEAKER_00Thanks for having us like for the hour. One Dave, your story is awesome, and Craig and Jason, as always, you guys are absolutely great. Um thank you. Um God, I would tell them to just so be hyper aware of what they need, they're non-negotiables, and then don't take a moment looking away from those. You know, know yourself, be that self-awareness is so important. And then never ever, whether it's during recruiting or even when you make a hire, it's not always gonna be perfect, but just never step away from that. Um, you're you're gonna end up somewhere down the road, like kicking yourself in the butt, and you don't want to have to be like cleaning up after those types of mistakes, and you don't want them to have the effect on the rest of your team and your agency. Um, so I think a lot of people are at the point that they're running an agency self-aware, tune into that and stick to it. Like just be awesome at what you're doing.
SPEAKER_06That's awesome. Yeah, love it.
SPEAKER_01And I would I would say honestly, don't rush. Like, don't just because the first person that walks in the door or somebody's got a license, don't just rush and try to panel staff.
SPEAKER_02Oh no, I ready to be my whole thing.
SPEAKER_01It might sound good and it might sound easy, but you're gonna pay for it. Don't rush. So I would encourage people to involve your entire organization. Literally lay out the roadmap. What would a perfect employee look like? What are what are our non-negotiables? What is our culture? And then get the whole organization involved, allow, allow key staff members to interview, allow your hiring manager to interview, have you interviewed and then come together in a consensus and say, can this person eat, live, and breathe our culture? Is this person going to be a problem, any capacity? How's this person's attitude? How's this person's work ethic and collectively come together? And like I went to, I don't know if anybody's ever uh gone to the Zappos experience out in Vegas, but Zappos, the shoe company, they literally have one of the craziest hiring processes I've ever seen. I went on the Zappos tour, and it's a six-month process to bring somebody in their organization. They get so in-depth with it, and it's so important to them to protect their company culture that they have the the cab driver is involved in the hiring process that brings the person to their organization. And the cab driver, the cab driver strikes a picture of conversation to it unbeknownst to the candidate, and they'll interview the cab driver like, how did this person react? How did they the receptionist is involved? How did this person interact with you? They have a brand ambassador that walks that person around and introduces them to everybody in the organization, and they go after the fact and ask them, How did what did you think about this person? And then even when they decide to hire them, they literally have them on a six-month probation where they're like going through this test the entire time where essentially the entire organization is voting on if this person belongs permanently as a part of our team or not. And they take it so serious that at the end of that six months, if they accept somebody in a permanent position and they graduate, they literally have an auditorium built at Zappos and they invite the entire family, they invite the person up on stage almost like a graduation ceremony, welcoming them into the company. So I saw that, like we obviously didn't bring our hiring process to that level, but I saw that and how important it was and how serious they took their company culture. And to me, like that was like a major takeaway is you know, take your time, make sure that you involve multiple people in the process, really define what your culture looks like and what you think the best employee attributes would look like in your organization, and ask yourself does this person stack up and can they live my expectations?
SPEAKER_03Dave Williams dropping the mic at the end. That's awesome, man. Yeah, but yeah, so much so much more leverage in having too many candidates versus the other way around because they come in and they see you're struggling, they're gonna take advantage of that, right? They they can't fire me. I can take the day off because they can't do anything, right? So you want to put it in a position where you have the leverage. You guys, thank you so much. Um, I we definitely should do this again.
SPEAKER_01No, I'd love to. Absolutely. I'm passionate about this stuff, I love talking about it too. Even if there's anybody out there, like even if you're not looking at the hire us on the willing to have conversations about, I love I love staffing, recruiting, and helping me.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Kat. Thank you, Dave. We'll we'll put the link for Team Hired in the show notes. I think it's floating around in there right now in a bunch of the episodes. So um we we appreciate everything you bring, and uh it works. It really works.
SPEAKER_01So thank you.
SPEAKER_06I I think there's a lot of a lot of stuff in there that people might not have thought about, you know, and that's huge on why we we why we do this to begin with, is just to open everyone's mind to the to the ways you know successful people have have done it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean you don't know what you don't know.
SPEAKER_06You don't. That's true.
SPEAKER_00All right, so true. Thank you so much, guys.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, uh great. Thank you guys.
SPEAKER_00Hi guys.
SPEAKER_06Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the insurance dudespodcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes podcast. Subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming up.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman