The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Dj Jazy Jaz Top 3 Sales Producers Challenges & Solutions | Get All Jazzed UP YO!
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Yo Jason. Yo, Mr. Craig. Oh, Mr. Jason. We got we got somebody good. Ooh, I'm excited. Yeah. What's with you? You tell me. Cuz I'm I'm cool like that. Oh, so am I. We got DJ Jazzy Jazz. Keep going. We got DJ Jazzy Jazz. Top three sales producers challenges and solutions. Let's get all jazzed up, yo. I'm gonna bathe in that. Woo! Woo, bathe in it.
SPEAKER_04Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast. I didn't expect a deep voice.
SPEAKER_00I didn't expect it. No.
SPEAKER_02That's jazz. So you see him. I mean, a lot of people have seen him back there.
SPEAKER_04Yes. Yes. You do uh turn your camera a little bit. We could we got two angles. Two angles of jazz. Yes. First off, is jazz your your birth name?
SPEAKER_00It is, yeah. My mom actually couldn't decide between Jasper or Basil. So she came up with Jazz.
SPEAKER_04Those are all I just even I didn't even know that.
SPEAKER_02I can't believe you question it. Do you even care? No, I don't think. Apparently I don't. You know, no. I like Jazz a lot, and um he probably doesn't like me, but we've we uh I even went I went to a party with him like two weeks ago.
SPEAKER_00That was interesting to say the least. So let's start there. Oh no. How do I explain that one?
SPEAKER_02Um I don't know uh here. I walked in, okay, and I brought, like I don't drink, I brought wine and I uh you know to give to the host, and um which was weird. I hadn't bought wine in over five years, probably. And then I got some I got a six pack of fake beer, which I figured nobody would drink, and I'm like, you know, I'll have I haven't had any for dooleys? No, it wasn't O'Doules, it was St. Pauli girl one, I think. Okay. Some other no, it wasn't that either. I don't know what it was, but um, I probably won't be having any for a long time. It was just meh. So I walk in, I'm handed, well, it's the the the woman at the door says, Are you one of the main characters? Oh, that's good. I said, What? Um no, no, I'm not. And she goes, Oh, well then I'm instructed to hand you this. And she hands me this folder, and it says crawfish on it.
SPEAKER_00Was it was it cray crayfish? Crayfish.
SPEAKER_02Oh, crayf, it was crayfish.
SPEAKER_00Crayfish, which later, which later turned into crawdaddy.
SPEAKER_02I mean everyone I became crawdaddy. So was this a themed party? Was it but apparently people got very extensive emails with a description of who they were and what their role was in this thing. Um I I still don't know what the hell happened.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so basically what it was, it was uh it was a it was a murder mystery party. Oh it was in the theme of summoning an eldritch god, almost like Cthulhu. And we had to figure out what sacrifice was the right sacrifices to summon this Eldritch god. I I have no idea.
SPEAKER_02It was the most bizarre thing I've ever been.
SPEAKER_00No, nobody actually really knew what was going on until maybe about three quarters into the night, and then it was just like I think when everybody was slightly inebriated, that's when it all kind of clicked. Yeah. That's good.
SPEAKER_04Whose friend was this?
SPEAKER_00Uh that was my friend. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_04A lady friend.
SPEAKER_00It was a lady friend, yes. You are used to date, and but yeah, now we're just kind of friends now.
SPEAKER_02So nice. At one point, the the hose behind the refrigerator broke, exploded, water was everywhere. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04And it was gone. Was that part of it? No, no, it was not.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, that did happen. That did happen.
SPEAKER_04So, Craig, Jazz. Jazz, you work at Craig's agency. I do. We we should have said we should have said that from the beginning. Because people are gonna be like, what's going on here? But um, dude, I think that working on the front lines of insurance agency is one of the hardest jobs on the planet. I mean, you hear a lot of stuff, right? Yes, yeah, definitely. So, what are some of the big pain points that you would say? Like, truthfully, like what's if you could do without the top three things, what would they be?
SPEAKER_00If I could do without the top three things in insurance, uh well, first off, I'd probably say the rate differences. Right. Right? So, because that's that's one of the major things. A lot of people are very interested in price. Right? Very interested in price. So, you know, as an insurance agent, as a licensed producer, you want to try and take them off of price and more along the lines of what that coverage is gonna be doing for them. Right? So, one of the big pains for me on the front lines is the such exasperated rates for all the different insurance companies.
SPEAKER_04So is it and it's gotta be annoying when you hear like Craig talk about, well, you gotta build the value, right? But he's not on the front line, so it's super easy for him to say, right? How annoying is that?
SPEAKER_02I don't know why they don't just deliver this and it's no problem.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Um to begin with, to be when I first started, when I first started, yes, yes, it was very annoying and very frustrating. Right. But then once you get into it and you actually realize the value yourself, uh once you hear stories of say insurance claims and just stories from other people saying, Oh, I wish I had this insurance, what you're telling me and what you're explaining to me, then it basically just opens your eyes and you think, Oh, okay, what Craig is actually talking about isn't a bunch of bullets.
SPEAKER_04So that brings me up to okay, so that's one great pain point that's probably difficult to get over. And you're right, it is a mindset thing, and you do have to get over the hump. So for you, what would your advice be for agency for agency owners or whatever to I mean, how do you relay that? What would be the best way to break through? And for LSPs. Yeah, that's what I mean. Like, like, so we're this is for agents that are hiring people and getting them on their team. If this is one of the big pain points, the question is like, what's the best way to get over that so it's not so annoying?
SPEAKER_00Oh the best way. For me, the best way, because Craig had the chip away at me quite a lot. Yeah. I I I had the barrier there. I'm gonna I had the barrier there, and everybody did the the uncomfort. It's um yeah, the best way to do it would just be keep, keep, keep going on at the employees, the LSPs, just just keep going on about them, keep going over, and just explain how it is so important to get the uh point across that you know liability coverage is the main point of insurance and how we want to protect you know our clients. We want to protect our clients, you know, from that possible, you know, the the possible I don't know, let's say the uh possible event that they may be sued, yeah, the possible loss or something along those lines. Yeah, it's that you just have to keep just like a little a little chisel on a wall, just keep cheese, just keep pounding on them. Because that's what Craig did to me, and it and it worked.
SPEAKER_02You only have a couple minutes on the phone when you're talking to a lead or you're talking to you know some potential client. And it's funny though, because we had um it's something that's come up recently. Actually, Colby Like the Cheese has brought it up, one of my other guys had and he said, Look, everybody to get them to move, like let's say somebody with state minimum, right? In Arizona's 1530, to get somebody to move from 1530 to 2550 sometimes can be like trying to move a freaking mountain across the the you know, and um and then you try to move their their deductible from 500 to a thousand and they have a meltdown. And and so it's like wait a minute. You're you're mad about this 500 bucks that you could potentially pay, but you're not thinking about this potential ten thousand, fifteen, twenty, twenty-five thousand you could you will potentially pay if you hurt somebody, right? If you're in that same accident, that's your fault. Who cares about five hundred or a thousand dollars? What you should be caring about is the fifty, two hundred, you know, fifty, hundred, million.
SPEAKER_00175,000 that you've got to pay out now due to the loss. Or I think that's the other person. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04I think a good point of this is that is you uh it's a lot of work to convince somebody of that, right? It takes a long time, and so you can't give up. Like I think running an agency and running a team, uh being on a team, you need everybody on the same the same team, the same vision, the same like goals. Everybody has to see eye to eye, otherwise, you know, the office gets all out of whack. But I think a lot of people don't put in the time, like it's a lot of time. You know what I mean? To Jazz's point, it took a while. You have to keep chipping away. Um so what's another pain point?
SPEAKER_00Another pain point.
SPEAKER_04Um somebody who's on the front lines more or has been more recently than like Craig or I. You know what I mean? I think people listen to you a lot more.
SPEAKER_00I would say I'm not entirely sure what it's like at other agencies. But the the systems and I and what it's like at other comp companies, but the systems and the technology, that is uh a big fault. Coming from an i coming from an IT background, um which I used to be, I used to work for the UK government. So yeah, that was interesting as well. Uh but the the um the actual systems in place and the IT are you know it that's that's kind of a hard one. That is kind of like a a blocker in regards to um in regards to say training, uh getting a quote, putting a quote together, etc. etc. But you know, just keeping people on their toes and doing meetings, maybe like two times a day, um, because that's what we are currently doing. We're having meetings two times a day at least to just kind of keep people, you know, moving. And that's gonna look, we can't do much about the IT. Let's just keep going, let's throw, let's put the quote together, we'll work through it, et cetera, et cetera. So, you know, that's that's what we do here.
SPEAKER_04It's and so before doing the because I know that's a newer thing that you guys have done, before doing the two meetings. Uh yeah, well, it was a new yeah, I mean you just it's crazy, but it seems daunting for somebody that doesn't do meetings. First, you do like one a week, or or you know what I mean, then you might do one a day, but then now doing two a day. What has been the difference in change uh that you've seen with everybody?
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, no, it brings people together.
SPEAKER_02Brings people together and it's yeah, with three three offices, too, right? The only way is to we get on Zoom and then we're all talking.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and it brings people together, it encourages others uh to actually talk to each other, talk to each other and communicate and pump each other up, and it and it does work. It does definitely work. You know, we've we've had some Krabby employees, and uh they start they start smiling now. Now that they're involved, they feel like they're involved because talking about Krabby Patty. No, um, but it it keeps people involved, it keeps people engaged with everyone in the different places, you know, and you're seeing people's face, you know, instead of just on the phone or anything like that.
SPEAKER_02So and then reinfor reinforcing the word tracks, those things that we're saying on on calls that are working. Yeah, yeah. Like you you helped a lot with that, and then you know, seven steps and all these different things, but incorporating a lot of different ones, and like, okay, we're gonna say these things, and you start getting the same result, and maybe it's not the sale, but it's the same objection, right? And then it's like, oh, okay, we're we are consistently getting to this, so now we need to figure out how to get to overcoming that because you know, so creating that process I think has just been huge, and having those meetings, like you know, you you brought up to me, so I I grabbed that, and then you know, Jazz being the operations manager here, you know, he's involved in that, and it's just it's really cool to see how it it has an impact because it it 100% has an impact. It's crazy. Like even today, one of my veterans, and they're the hardest to to change the way they do things. We were talking about tie-downs, we're talking about um using the person's name, right? Just little like little simple details that they don't think makes a difference. But if we're on that meeting two times a day and that's all we're talking about all week, is you you gotta say, isn't that awesome, Jim? Isn't that really cool, Jim? Like, you know, at the end of each benefit. So today she's over at the other office, and I'm sitting there, and I said, Don't forget the tie downs. And she rolls her eyes, but then she she did it, closes it. Yep. It's the it the the damage is always in the details. It is it's amazing.
SPEAKER_04It's amazing. So that was number two. What's the third pain point you'd say? That's a good question. It's a good question. And I have a backup one if you don't have.
SPEAKER_00I was trying to think of one earlier, actually. Um, for the last one.
SPEAKER_04Let's see. Um, how about this? What is the number one suggestion you would have for an agency owner out there? For an agency owner. What would you suggest to Craig? What could he do better? What could he do better? And this is constructive. This is a this is a simple thing. It's not in public.
SPEAKER_00So no, that's absolutely fine. So what could what could he do better? Um for agency owners, I guess, in general, uh would be to be more I guess more involved, I guess, with the whole process. With the whole pro no, no, Craig, not in that sense. Let's let's say let's I'm using Craig as an example, okay? Just I mean just for the whole scope scope of things, right? Not saying that Craig isn't involved because he is, yes, deals you know, deals with the training and getting people pumped up and hyped up because uh I'm I'm I'm a little mellow. I'm not particularly good at that, right? But just having the owners just involved and incorporated in the whole system of things in general, you know.
SPEAKER_04And how so specifically? Like specific actionable um suggestions. What would make it see more involved? Because I think that the you know, there is a problem with that in general, because the more an organization in general grows, the hard most the more disconnected people get. Um because you have to in order to to scale. Um but what what would you suggest? Because now you guys have three offices and a lot going on, new people coming in. I mean, it's there's a lot to it. Yeah. Um what would it create those connection points you would think?
SPEAKER_00God That is really I I can't actually think of too many. I mean, the only thing that I can think of at this point in time is just emails and more communication in in in that regard, you know. Yeah. Um just the communication in general. You know, just kind of back and forth between let's just say an owner and the managers of the offices or something like that. But then but then again, that's when you have higher managers to be able to do that as well. Like you said, you know, if a company is growing, the owner doesn't really have the place. Yeah, yeah, the owner's all over the place. He doesn't, you know, he or she doesn't have the time to be nitpicking and micromanaging this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this, this.
SPEAKER_02You know, but so you know, you do see though, and in and us, basically like talking to so many different agents, um, you do see that though. I think they pick the wrong places to spend and and and put their focus. And I'm not perfect. You know, I'll I'll get into the weeds sometimes when I shouldn't be in the weeds. Uh that that I should trust Jazz to handle or trust one of the other office managers to handle so that you know there's that you know, there's the trust. Um I think something that's made a difference here is that I do really try to connect with them and and know them. And you know, aside from not knowing how Jazz got his name, um know the things. Right? Like where there's a connection. We are like a family. Yeah. You know, we all know each other really well, and if somebody comes in and it doesn't fit, then they're they're not gonna hang out anymore. We don't put up with it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, like I said, I wasn't specific specifically talking about Craig. Right. You know, he he admits yes, he may have some faults here or there, but awesomely enough many faults. Awesomely enough, me and him can actually talk and banter about it. You know? Whereas whereas other places from the stories that I've heard you know from other agents and you know other agencies is completely disconnected. Right. Completely disconnected. You know, so I guess just that that owner management you know LSP employee what have you communication and the ties there. You know sometimes they can the owner can skip the management and go to the employees but you know obviously let the management know. Etc etc you know that that would probably be my the only other thing that I can think of again not personally here because Craig and I can communicate. No I'm not I'm not we've spent we have spent many a times after office hours chatting about what we're going to be doing going forward and just in general.
SPEAKER_02Yeah we were here till we were here I mean we were I was at the other office and he was at this office we were talking till 8 30 last night on Zoom.
SPEAKER_04Yeah that's funny I think it goes back to it's the same thing like in a sale when you have to connect on things other than insurance it's the same way at work right you can't just talk about work every all the time you got to talk about other things that helps that connection point.
SPEAKER_02A lot of people closed up rapport with your stuff right the the mentality of my way or the highway that doesn't work and you know we in like having the millennial whisperer on you know he made it very clear that that is not doesn't work anything yeah you know and and so it's like you know I don't know that it is kind of like they're more your friends that's probably gonna make some people like cringe but you have to you have to have that that um that there you know the millennial whisperer said you should you should be involved in people's uh social like follow them on Facebook follow them on Instagram and then what it what a tremendous opportunity to say oh I saw you went to the LARP party this weekend and you know you were Mr. Crab or whatever. Yeah but or go or go but yeah you know I I I mean I do we're I'm I every single one of the staff here I'm friends with them. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_04On on social you know I mean it just is so yeah I I was just talking uh to my uh some of my staff the other day and like I always ask them there's so much that's going on in all of our lives and we're talking about it and I love I love just talking about I love just talking obviously but um I uh during our meeting I was saying like there's so much on a deeper level when we're doing we're doing so many quotes a day it's ridiculous. But I said you know give a hundred percent every time because you you know what even if you don't get the sale on a deeper more human level there's two parts one is if you do your best you're always going to feel good um the other thing is that if you're just even excited the tone of voice that you have you could literally change somebody's day like if they're having a bad day and you have a good connection a good talk it can really help them out in the day. So who cares about the sale on every call be positive be happy like connect with them because on a human level outside the money and this wanting to get the sale just connect like you'll feel good about yourself you'll make others feel good and it'll be kind of infectious. Well it's fun yeah it makes everything have fun yeah it's definitely right it's definitely right I mean you know I just I had a call just recently quoted and didn't go for it we were about maybe double or triple the prize but the guy actually thanked me for having a chat and explaining things to him and just you know and and he thanked me he said you know it's been awesome speaking to you and I said you know what you too and that guy you feel good yeah he's gonna remember jazz he's gonna you know in two years or three years or maybe a year whatever something's gonna happen it's gonna his stuff is gonna go up yeah right and even if it doesn't who cares that right true but two humans' lives are better yeah definitely you know what I mean like outside of everything like if you net that every day like it's the laws of attraction if you're just constantly doing a good job you feel good about yourself you're constantly connecting to people making other people feel better guaranteed good things are gonna happen to you it's just like this I and we all have those friends that are just oh like everything sucks and everything's negative and everything bad happens to them they have bad luck it's like no no no you're inviting this stuff you are a bummer to be around and the only people that are gonna talk to you for more than two seconds are people that you know are bummers too.
SPEAKER_03Yeah be a good person definitely definitely gotta smile every day get it got to smile every day it makes others smile it makes others smile well jazz thank you so much for uh for the for the chat oh yeah no problem thank you for breaking up the work day yeah definitely definitely does definitely does now I'm all hot and sweaty being on camera no problem thank you very much yeah awesome I I I may see you yeah maybe maybe it was good talking to you I usually see you but I don't talk to you all right all right have a good one see ya hey you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group join the mailing list today at the insurance dudes podcast dot com. Hey thanks for checking out the insurance dudes hey please subscribe we got some really great stuff coming out
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman