The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig, let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. You know, talk about what? Glugs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee twalk.
SPEAKER_03
Coffee twalk. You know what's funny about what you just said to me? What, Mr.
SPEAKER_00
Craig?
SPEAKER_03
Well, I was complaining about this other thing that I'm working on and how I had to hire one of the people that was actually one of our guests, Erzabet Pivko. Shout out. Uh a contract, right? To write up a contract. And I said, uh, fifteen hundred bucks.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. And I said, that's that's less than a third that you'll make in one month. Just to put the wheels on the car.
SPEAKER_03
Well, how about to wrap the insurance around the car?
SPEAKER_00
Oh.
SPEAKER_03
Do a little a little wrap. I said, uh huh.
SPEAKER_00
Aha. And then we said it takes money to make money, yo.
SPEAKER_03
It does. Right? Yeah. And you know, you talk to agents, and I'll take agents and they'll we'll talk about our lead spend. Oh, I gotta cut back my cost. I can't I can't spend this on leads. Right. How are you gonna generate activity and and revenue if you don't spend on leads?
SPEAKER_00
I think at times us as agents put on our on our agent hat rather than our business hat. And I think the business hat will tell you that the your agency should be a money machine. You should have systems and processes in which you invest X amount of dollars and then you get X amount out. Based on the systems and processes, you create predictable income. And I think a lot of times we look at the immediate return rather than the one year, two year, three year. That's the whole reason why we're in this business is because of the recurring revenue. So you need to figure out what's your lifetime customer value and really how much do you make per person. Because even if you make five dollars more than that and you're putting money in and you're bonusing and all this stuff, you're gonna net so much more money. And at the end of the day, that's what we need to do.
SPEAKER_03
Well, and all of the benefits of being a business owner, right? Like the lunches and all the other expenses, the sleepless nights, the stress. No. I mean, you wouldn't be able to tell, but I'm but I'm actually 21.
unknown
Right.
SPEAKER_00
But but it actually eliminates all that stress. So investing a little bit more and creating that predictable income based on your systems and processes will create less stress. It will cost more up front, will net you more later.
SPEAKER_03
Guaranteed Jason, I don't have any money, I don't have any cash flow. How am I supposed to invest in something when I don't have any money in the first place?
SPEAKER_00
You gotta borrow against the business or uh borrow. And you know what? That's the bottom line. That's how we all got into this originally. We all borrowed, and we got to a certain point, and we sometimes we need to borrow again. And basically, if you're not willing to do that, then you don't have enough faith in your systems and processes. So go back to your systems and processes, document, go get a job. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03
Because it's not gonna change. That'd be a nightmare. If you keep doing the same thing, right, and expect the different results, we all know what that is. But if if you continue, like when is there gonna be more? Right? Mo money, mo money, mo money, mo problems. But if you if you keep doing the same thing, right? Oh, I have to cut back. The second you're cutting back, like when is it gonna change where all of a sudden some magic extra amount of money is coming in?
SPEAKER_00
You always have to be increasing the top line of your business. Always if you're cutting back, you're dying, you're cutting off the lifeblood. The putting money into the business is the lifeblood, and you gotta grow it. You gotta keep it's it'll never be flat. It'll either be growing or dying. One of the two, one of the two.
SPEAKER_03
Well, the beauty is okay, right? You you talked about a predictable systems and processes to create predictable income, right? Yes. So so the beauty of what we do is we have all the numbers, we have the equation. You know, sure. If you need help with the equation, we could put that up on the in the show notes, but you can take all the way from what your close per what your close ratio is all the way back to how many calls you need to make, right? The whole thing. So you can input the 5,000 calls and you're gonna get this result. Yep. What does it cost to do 5,000 calls from labor from to everything, right? 5,000 calls, and then at the end, does the cost of what you did at the front, is it less than what you got at the end? Because if it's less, even if it's if it's 50 cents less, it doesn't matter. You you came out ahead and you're gonna bonus.
SPEAKER_00
And it's it might be a little bit more at first, but it's that lifetime value. You gotta look at that lifetime value. Don't look like just the six months, it can be 12 months, it can be 18 months. What's your what is the life, what is the average length of time that your customer stays with you, and you can back it out that way. And and if you really do the numbers, you will notice that you're gonna make a crap ton of money. I mean, that's the only reason why any agents are making any money without doing anything, is because people are lazy and they stay with their insurance agent.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. Well, think about the cost. You were we were before we turned on the uh record button, we were we were talking about the cost, um, the cost per policy. There's probably only one percent of the agents out there actually look at cost per policy. What did it cost to acquire that new business? And that's part of this equation we're talking about, but there's a number where it makes sense. There's a number where it doesn't make sense. And and what I found really interesting when when um, you know, I it wasn't something I looked as closely at before doing ECP. Now it's something you have to look at. And you know what? Next year for people of a certain company, it's a it is again, it's gonna be something that everybody needs to look at because you're gonna have to invest to create growth. And that cost per policy, it if you look at today, based off of the lead you bought today, it's gonna be through the roof, right? Right. And then but but you can, you know, what's interesting, and I remember I think my first day I looked at it, and my cost per policy was 1200 bucks or something, and I'm like, ah, right. But then I look at it at the end of the month, the 30-day mover, oh, okay, we're at 180 per policy. You know, that's that's it's still not done. It's still not done. Like you're at 80 bucks a policy or 85, right? I mean, so and you've been doing it for two years like this.
SPEAKER_00
Well, that's my that's my two, that's my um one year? That's about a month and a half. But listen, this this is the whole thing, and and this is what we've talked about. You you just jumped on this train. So when you first jump on the train, you're looking at all the metrics, and there's no way that like you're gonna get as great of a cost for policy as me because I have been doing this for two years and tweaking my systems. So now I've again I call it the money machine. I I I constantly tweak my money machine to get the best result out of it. And that's what you gotta you gotta jump on the on the track if you want to race. So you jumped on the track, you're racing, you're getting a great cost per policy, but as you go, you're gonna be tweaking what what things can we control to tweak those numbers?
SPEAKER_03
And we have each number. So, okay, if my close ratio is five percent instead of 12%, what and those are just random numbers, but what is okay, then I know if everything else stays the same, this is the thing I can tweak right now, is the the close ratio. So that means meeting, listening to the calls, interacting with them, figure out why their close ratio is less than the guy next to them or the dudette next to them. Right. Why are they closing less? Okay, let's work on that. Let's maybe it's they they're not handling the objections right. Maybe they're not they're not creating value or finding the pain up in the front. And then we increase that. Okay, now we are still not getting that cost per policy down where we want to. So where else can we tweak it? Right? There's so many little parts along that road that you can constantly tweak with.
SPEAKER_00
I mean, there's everything down to email sequence, yeah. Uh uh call duration, uh call uh the call sequence, um, getting telemarketers for the team, that was a big help for for me because what's the biggest pain point of an LSP is making yes. So making it that's still part of that motor. So how do you retain people? You know what I mean? Besides you got to make them happy, you got to make sure that they know your vision, and your vision is pretty freaking solid and cool, and you got to make sure that their pain points are being addressed. One of its being calls and stuff. I mean, it's not the it's a it's a grueling, it's it's like they're basically like an athlete, yeah, and they're gonna be constantly taxed. So it's like, how can we give them those you know, breaths of fresh air? Like, how can we make it better for them?
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, less dials, more talk time, right? Uh and and having like I love your ratio, the one to one. So if you have one telemarketer for each producer, then that telemarketer is generating an extra 500 dials per day that wouldn't have happened. And then if you didn't have that and you didn't have that activity, then who has to do that? Right. LSP and what LSP is gonna stay if they have to do 700 dials a day. Because mine are averaging about 200, right? 200 dials that's great with tele with support from telemarketer, right? You know, and then somebody will say, Well, what? How the hell are you doing 700 dials day in, day out for a telemarketer to LSP team? Well, you have to you gotta have enough leads in there. Yep. Right? So there's another part of the equation, you know, there's just so many moving parts to make this car run.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. There's the leads that close. You gotta know how what's your lead time. Some leads close fast, some leads close long, some of the long-term leads might be a better cost per policy. So you really gotta, I mean, you gotta look at all this stuff. On the surface, everybody talks about, oh, what's the you know, overcoming objections? Sure. That's like such a small piece to the overall machine, and that's a great piece. Um, you gotta have those systems in place, but you gotta keep dissecting each part of every part of the process. What what emails are working, what emails are not working, what what calls, um what's the what's your close time per vendor? Um so I mean you just gotta you gotta look at it like a machine.
SPEAKER_03
There's a way to have the analytics to understand each moving part of each equation, and and if you're not looking at those things, then you're just guessing.
SPEAKER_00
Which I wouldn't I wouldn't be spending as much as I'm spending now.
SPEAKER_03
Right. You know, dropping 20k or whatever it is, you know, yeah, a month on leads, you better have right, yeah, and you better have some certainty around where you know where the those gaps are.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. And and here's what this is so funny. I was talking to my wife the other day, and I was like I'm sure she'd love to hear about this. Dude, when I told her how much we're spending per day on like leads and all this stuff, she was like, oh my gosh, she's like, I'm gonna have a panic attack. I'm like, no, no, no, don't worry. Like, like literally have it, it's it's a money machine. You put a certain amount of money in and you have a certain amount of money out, and it's because of all those pieces that we that we've tweaked. So I I mean, I know uh like I'm a I'm not a lavish guy, I don't spend a lot of money on on anything, but I do on the hats you're wearing. I do, but I spend a lot of insurance in California. Well, that's right. But I do spend a lot on the business because I know that if hey, if I put in ten dollars, I'm gonna get 12 back. And the bottom line is this I'd rather do that than to take the money out, spend 30% on taxes, uh, invest it in somebody else's business that that has the the steering wheel, uh, have some some guy take a percentage of it, and then you make four percent a year, even at nine percent. It's like I can do better than that. And if you take away all the the percentages, the chunks that everybody took out, it's it's not it's barely anything. It's pennies to compare with what that what we can create if we create a money machine.
SPEAKER_03
It's interesting that you know what I don't know what percent is our worker bees versus what percent are entrepreneurs, but the worker bees feel safe in the confines of their their little journey, being the worker bee, and doing what you just said, right? You take your extra your extra money, you invest it in this market and get your seven or eight percent, and and that's it, right? Yeah. Playing it safe. I mean, we have a unique opportunity because we've decided to own a business. And when you decide to own a business, the way that you make more money is not by cutting expenses. Right. It's not by saying, well, oh, I'm short. I better get rid of somebody, and I better, I mean, that's when that's when you've in essence given up, right? That's what a big company that's doing layoffs, uh the the you know, they're the sears.
SPEAKER_00
And I will I will add too that I do have empathy for those. There is the other side. There's the agent that just wants to be an agent and not so much a business owner, and I get it. And if that like if that's comfortable, then stay in that. Like I really think everybody needs to be very aware of where you want to be. And if that's it, do that. That's better for you. I get it. I don't think that there's a right way or a wrong way, but you know, a lot of people want that like money machine, but you gotta be very realistic and self-aware of what you want. It does take a bit of a risk, and it takes a lot more work uh working under the hood to make sure that you built that money machine correctly. Any stress? And do I stress? No, is there does it create any stress at all? I yes, but it's such a better stress. Like I feel like I have control that way. Where if if for me, um, like to the person that thinks like uh oh my gosh, investing all that is stressful, to me, not doing that and letting like a company be the be the one that that has all the control, and I'm just like, I'm along for the ride and I'll just sell the minimum, to me, that's stressful because um I don't like I mean that's personally why I became a business owner. I like taking control of that.
SPEAKER_03
And you I mean, I couldn't go in there every day and half-ass it knowing that all of my efforts are going to put money in somebody else's pocket, right?
SPEAKER_00
But there's something there's something to be said for the for the people that you know they they work a few days a week, and you know what I mean? They're just they're cruising. It's good, man. I I that I can't I can't cruise, I can't relax like that. Like that's not me. So that's why I put so much on my plate. It's ridiculous. I always like fixing the w wheels back on the car. That's a plate overflow. That's fun. Yes, that's fun. Building, creating.
SPEAKER_03
I mean, I it's interesting how there is like I I think we run a pretty similar schedule, and like there isn't a free minute. You know, even even to get on this today, I ran through my door at exactly noon. Like when when we have to which was 10 minutes late. Which was 10 minutes late. Yeah. Yeah. I can't make I can't make anybody happy, so just gotta keep rolling.
SPEAKER_01
Be happy, myself. Dude, don't listen. Don't listen to your wife. You can make it everybody happy. I'm just joking.
SPEAKER_03
She's a sweetheart. Didn't she say hi to you when when I answered the phone?
SPEAKER_01
Well, yeah, she's a sweetheart. She puts up with you. I know. Same with mine. I would not put up with me. I would not put up with me. They are angels.
SPEAKER_02
Yes.
SPEAKER_00
They keep the wheels on on this car.
SPEAKER_01
Why? I love doing hand gestures on this thing because most people don't see them.
SPEAKER_03
I do this one like when we're talking about numbers and figures, this little I don't know why.
SPEAKER_01
This little like like like inch thing with your fingers.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, like an inch. Like this specific number right here. And size.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. Well, I think that's a good guy talk.
SPEAKER_00
Man, that wasn't very funny. Oh. It's just not a funny day. It's fun. It's fun.
SPEAKER_03
But it's not knee. Yeah. Is there anything else that we could bring up? No. Okay.
SPEAKER_01
I think we're good. I think we're good until next week, and then it's you know, we're coming up on the holidays, man.
SPEAKER_03
Are we gonna interview Santa Claus on one of these episodes? Definitely. Definitely. Yeah. Quanza claus?
SPEAKER_01
Quanza claus. Rabbi Claus. Yeah. I don't know. I don't know how all this works. Uh all right. I think that's good.
SPEAKER_03
Feels like we could have gone into offensive territory. So the wheels are turned that. Well, uh, thank you all, and we'll see you next week. Yes. Coffee duck. Coffee duck. Coffee.
SPEAKER_02
Coffee duck.
SPEAKER_03
Coffee duck.
SPEAKER_00
Hey, you've got to check out the insurance dudes inner circle coming soon, where you get extended interviews as well as live coffee talks in our private Facebook group. Join the mailing list today at the Insurance Dudes Podcast.com. Hey, thanks for checking out the Insurance Dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out of this.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.