The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Jeremy Olson & Kristin Isaacson | Get Down With Sales Roleplay Secrets | A New Hope
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Mr. Jason.
SPEAKER_04Mr. Cra.
SPEAKER_03Oh boy, we've got a doozy. Ooh, from the rainy cold afterquest, we have Jeremy Olsen and Kristen Isaacson get naughty with some sales roleplay secrets.
SPEAKER_05Ooh, I'm gonna get under the covers with this one. Let's do it. Do it. It's the insurance dude podcast.
SPEAKER_02Well, he he told me his microphone's a little bit better in the next year.
SPEAKER_03I didn't say that. All I said was, and it's the same one that Jason has, which he said you need to get this one because it's the one that Michael Jackson recorded Thriller on.
SPEAKER_00No way.
SPEAKER_03Yes. Well, it's not this the exact one. Jason has the exact one that Michael Jackson. No idea.
SPEAKER_00Nice to meet you, by the way, Jason.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, good to meet you guys. Yeah, what's the you're in California, right, Jason? I am in California. Yep. Honey to beach right now. California's on fire. Has been, yeah. It's no good.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, so this speaking of Michael Jackson, directed towards Jeremy. What were you doing the year that Michael Jackson's thriller was released? That's 1979.
SPEAKER_02Well, you gotta give me a hint of what year. What year was it? And I can tell you. That's 1979. So it's a-way!
SPEAKER_011979?
SPEAKER_021979, I was seven years old. I was probably at a Sonics game because that happens to be the year they won the championship. And I would have been in, I don't know, what would I have been in at seven? Kindergarten? I would have been seven ishable. Ish?
SPEAKER_03Yeah. First, maybe? I don't know. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, we had Fred Brown, we had Gus Williams. I mean, the Sonics were the best back then.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Some agents that we get on here, they're like, I was a 20-year agent at that point.
SPEAKER_02No, I actually had, believe it or not, at that point in my life, I was seven and I had known for three years that I wanted to be an insurance. Wow. No. Oh, yeah. No, we talk about this a lot.
SPEAKER_00It actually needs to be like, I always say we need to make like an insurance action figure doll out of him. Like it'd be Jeremy with his backpack now. It used to be his briefcase, but he like literally was toddling around like a little insurance robot when he was probably three years old.
SPEAKER_02No, my my grandfather was uh he was about a 35-year agent. So I used to go into his office all every Saturday and hang out. My dad was a 45-year agent. So wow. Yeah. It's all I've ever wanted to be. Third year generation or third generation. Yeah, I just had to go with the other company though, just so I could kind of do my own thing. But uh yeah, it's it's been in my family forever.
SPEAKER_05So let's let's start there. Let's go back to the beginning. So you and I think we just did. So from from diapers, pretty much, you wanted to be an insurance.
SPEAKER_00The diapers?
SPEAKER_05Sorry. I got four kids. Two of mine are in diapers right now. I get a lot of diapers.
SPEAKER_00That's so cute. It's so cute when they're little like that, but the diapers are kind of yeah.
SPEAKER_03Do you have a diaper genie? I do. Multiple. By the way, diaper genie. Yeah. We're gonna group that out if you don't cough up.
SPEAKER_00We measure success by whether you have a diaper genie or not.
unknownSorry.
SPEAKER_00We diaper.
SPEAKER_03So you you jumped into insurance right after, right out of college.
SPEAKER_02Oh, absolutely. Yeah, no, I graduated Saturday, June 10th, 1995. I started Monday, June 12th. Wow. I don't want to miss a day.
SPEAKER_03I don't know what's more amazing, that you did it right after or that you remember the day that you graduated from college.
SPEAKER_02Amazing. Oh, it was the best day of my life.
SPEAKER_00He's like he really is an insurance manager. No, I mean it is true.
SPEAKER_02It's it's always been something I wanted to do and just uh, you know, really got lucky with the path that I took. I was a bank teller, which I actually took that job so I could kind of learn how to, you know, just deal with people, build or poor. I intentionally took that job. And during those four years in college, I got to know a local all-state guy and just went to him and said, Hey, why don't I work for you for a couple of years, learn the industry, and you can be my mentor, and then I'll do my own thing in a few years. And that's what we did. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_05It's so crazy. And I was just thinking about this the other day that all the jobs and experiences we've ever had really define who we are and how we sell insurance or whatever we're doing tomorrow. And that's what I try to tell our team a lot is like like these skills are crazy. Like you're learning things that'll change your life and your kids' lives if you really learn how to a sell, but sell yourself. And it's selling is everything. So I don't know. Just a reflection.
SPEAKER_00That that's it's actually true. I I actually went back to school later in life and I had to um write a learning autobiography of all of my past experience, um, up until like, you know, I don't know, I went back and graduated like six years ago. And so it is I did exactly that. You had to actually write what each experience um how it equated into a learning experience and what you got out of it. And if you map it out from the beginning, even when you were in high school, all the way up until now, you see this like common thread.
SPEAKER_04Yep.
SPEAKER_00Um, and it really gives you like your character traits and who you are. It's it was really an interesting process. Yeah, if you guys ever want to read my book, just you know, let me know.
SPEAKER_03Okay. Yeah. So Kristen, uh what about you? And how did I like you to start with where you started, how you ended up uh with uh Carnegie, and then then hooking up with Jeremy. And you guys can fight over that content.
SPEAKER_00We can fight over the content.
SPEAKER_02We'll leave the Dale Carnegie part to you because that is truly her first love.
SPEAKER_00He's jealous of Dale Carnegie. He's dead, actually. Um so I uh I actually was in insurance. I actually worked for MetLife Insurance um before I worked for Dale Carnegie, and I left MetLife Insurance saying, I'm never gonna be in insurance again. Like insurance is not my thing. I really wanted to get into professional development.
SPEAKER_02Well, you would have called it boring.
SPEAKER_00I called it boring, yep. And I, you know, I had a good run there, but I was on the financial services side and was passionate about helping people, but there was just something that didn't click for me to continue the rest of my career. I was very um passionate about this Dale Carnegie thing. I found out that they had a training center right by where I lived, and I wanted to be a part of that. So I was pretty aggressive. I went over there and just said, you guys should hire me, and this is why. And um, I didn't stop until I got the job.
SPEAKER_01There you go.
SPEAKER_00So that does tell you something about me because I do that with pretty much everything in life. If I really believe in it, I'll go for it and um am pretty persistent. But uh so I started working for Dale Carnegie, absolutely loved uh my career there, and I still work there as a certified trainer, so I teach classes there probably about three to four times a year. It's an eight-week commitment every time I do it. And I teach the world-famous Dale Carnegie class, which is a um basically like a foundational class and teaching people how to communicate more effectively, build their confidence, and just help them be more authentic, showing up in the world. And that's where Jeremy brought some of his team members into our classes, and uh we started working, teaching some of his team members one-on-one. He contracted me through Dale Carnegie as a coach. And it wasn't something like the typical contract that we did. And uh and then as I continued to hear what his vision was.
SPEAKER_02Well, I I just remember, yeah. So we we had gone to a few workshops, and I remember one day Kristen called me and said, Hey, you know what, your one of your employees, Mike, uh, asked if I could just stop by his office. He's struggling. Would you mind? You know, she wasn't wanting to charge me or anything, just can I go help him? And so she, I don't know if you spent an hour or half a day there. Yeah, I don't know. But just saw a world of difference. And so um I just called her and said, Hey, is there any way I can have you work with more of my team members on a one-on-one basis? And so we talked to you know, the franchise owner and eventually worked it out to where you could work. I think it was the Fab 13, we called it, because it was 13 of my team members that she would meet with once a week for an hour or so.
SPEAKER_00Actually, it was only a half an hour. I just did these half an hour coaching sessions with 13 of his team members.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and it was just awesome. I've always loved coaching, just a huge believer in it. And uh, so I just started planting a seed that, man, wouldn't it be really cool? Like if I had one of you in my agency. And I said, no.
SPEAKER_00But uh it eventually it eventually ended up, I did because I loved what I did so much, but I would say his story, like just like with you guys, his story was so compelling. And he actually made talking about insurance and thinking about selling insurance fun. And I had never seen, I thought there's no way that if he can get me to actually think it would be fun to coach on insurance and talk about insurance. Um, there's something really weird going on here. And so I ended up coming over to the dark side and working for him full time as the team coach and then continuing with Dale Carnegie in a different way, just working, um, teaching that one class that I'm so passionate about.
SPEAKER_03That's that is awesome. Yeah, that's awesome. That is awesome. Well, thank you. But but if this if if that's the dark side, then does that make Jeremy the Emperor?
SPEAKER_00I I don't follow Star Wars, but I think so.
SPEAKER_05So how how how have you combined the two? Talk talk about that, like uh Kristen. So what did you take from the the Carnegie class and um how have you kind of put that with insurance?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think the big thing, like what Carnegie is so famous for is just like effective, clear communication. And so once I started hearing uh like the way that Jeremy talked about insurance, I started documenting that basically, and we started creating like talk paths that were very clear and concise because what I was hearing on phone calls when I was listening, just coaching our team members, is people can get definitely get pretty mucky in the way that they talk about insurance. They can actually confuse the customer more than they help them. And so we wanted our communication with our team members, uh talking to prospects and customers to be very clear and concise. And so we created this roadmap and a sales process specifically for our agency that was, in my opinion, very spot on, extremely intentional, and um has given us just a huge lift in our agency. So that's kind of where it started. And then I would say just my background in coaching and the methodology of how I coach, it's ingrained in me. Um, so you know, we do coaching in the moment at Dale Carnegie. And so I, you know, there's no other way. I always say I've been certified to interrupt people. And so that's really how how I do it is I just interrupt people when I'm noticing something and um redirect them. And so I don't teach like the Dale Carnegie Prince, you know. Well, I mean, anybody can Google the Dale Carnegie principles. We talk about them a ton and we try to live by that as our values in our agency, but I don't teach like the Dale Carnegie class in our agency, but I do obviously that's ingrained in me, the methodology and the way like you can learn so much just from reading that book, How to Win Friends and Influence People. Um, but it's ingrained in everything that I do because I believe in it so much.
SPEAKER_03And you guys listen to calls and and play them back, I would guess.
SPEAKER_00All the time. Yeah, we absolutely love doing that. And I would say the most important thing is that there's just so many different ways to coach. Um, and you've got to change it up. So, what I hear a ton when people are coaching their people is um, oh, I wouldn't buy from you, try again. Nope, wouldn't buy for yourself, try again. Well, you're not you're gonna stuck on the phones today, so uh I don't even think I want you on the phones. So there's that, you know, there's that approach, and sometimes there's the approach where people will coach to like so many things that the team member might like feel like overwhelmed and like they can't. So we're just coaching to build confidence. We try to get a lot of peer-to-peer coaching and a lot of collaboration. I would say the collaboration is the biggest thing of what we do is just get that cross-communication going with our team members, with prospects, with customers, in everything that we do.
SPEAKER_03The the confidence is so critical, right? The more you pump them up and the more they believe in the product, believe in in what they're doing is is going to help, then that's where they really make the difference. Because if they're timid, the the prospect hears it, the prospect takes control. And with that confidence, then they maintain the control of the conversation and can really take it to the next place.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and I don't know if this has happened with you guys, but when I first started here, everybody was saying, I can't talk like Jeremy. He taught, and he is, he's amazing, like at talking and thinking ahead and having that confidence. And I think that everybody on our team was like, that was actually diminishing their confidence. So I don't know if that happens with you guys in your agency, but that's why we created these talk fast to say, actually, you actually can talk like Jeremy.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, no, and I would say that's a big part of why I did bring Kristen on. I've never been a real structured guy. I I've just always been very in the trenches. I love to meet with customers. I think the year she came on board, I had personally done 400 in-person reviews with customers. I love like my dream day is to have eight back-to-back reviews lined up. Love that day. Uh, but I would just come back from those and you know, probably sold 15 items and I would say, team, just go do that. And uh would really give them a ton of guidance because I I don't have a coaching background. And so when I brought Kristen on board, you know, one of the first things that she said is I'd love to implement role play in your agency. And I ran the other way because it's definitely not something that I had ever done with my team or had done myself, not not real comfortable with it. But I played along and let her do it with them and just kind of watch from afar and then eventually would do it myself. And I just saw the the huge benefits in that, and that's why we have this other thing.
SPEAKER_00I actually I actually tricked him into it, but he doesn't he, you know, that's a good story. But I, you know, all of a sudden he it's kind of like edging back into like, oh, what's she doing over there? People are really liking that.
SPEAKER_02But I I do remember early on, she she called me, or we were, you know, working together and she said, What's your sales process? And I I honestly said, I have no idea. I really just talk to the customers and just connect with them. That's what this job is all about. None of us have jobs if we don't have customers. And to me, that relationship, you know, this whole trusted advisor thing is not new to me. That's how I've always done my business, is just getting in the trenches and being with customers or everything. Just right before I got on here with you guys, I was scheduling a coffee with a 35-year customer for Friday morning. That's what I love doing. That's awesome. And and I think that's what Kristen really brings to the table. She thinks the same way, that's what she's always coaching to is it's everything we do is for the benefit of the customer. If they're upset, if they're wrong, it doesn't matter. They're always right in our agency. Customer's always right, period.
SPEAKER_05That's awesome. And and to your point, I want to bring up two things. One is nobody cares about your business as much as you do. So you might go into it and you care so much that you'll have a con a free-flowing conversation with somebody, and it's easy to sell. When you bring somebody that's new in the office, they're kind of they feel uncomfortable and and they just they they care, they just don't care about the business as much as you do. So it's it's uh important to have um talk pass and uh role playing. And going back to role-playing what you said, it being uncomfortable, it's a hundred percent uncomfortable for everybody. Let's get that out there. Like we see people doing it on Facebook, and oh yeah, let's role play. And you know, you see more of that now, but it is not comfortable for anybody at first.
SPEAKER_00I think everybody needs to say that out loud because yeah, well, and I I always say it's kind of like the universe getting back at me because I have to say that I don't even know. I I remember when I was going through my certification at Dale Kearney, that was my first, you know, real experience with having to memorize things, role-play them, feel uncomfortable. I was in front of like, you know, people that have been doing this forever. I go through recertification every three years, and I dread, I actually am dreading it because I know that I'm gonna be picked apart and coached, and you know, I am the product when I go and teach those classes. So, but I just remember thinking, I'm never gonna make this. I don't think I'm gonna be able to do this, to actually like get into this role play and um role play these things enough to get certified. And there was a point where um I might have said a bad word in my head. I'm not really good at swearing, so I don't say them out loud. But um, I just got to the point where I literally one day I left and I had done it, I just felt like I did everything wrong and I cried about role-playing things. Like literally, I did because we were reenacting all these things. Um and I thought I'm not gonna do it. And then I just thought, screw it. You know, like I am actually, I don't really care. You've got to kind of let like everything go and not care what people think of you in order to make this work and care more about the end result because I think the thing that really holds people back from being effective in role play is caring about what people are looking at, what they think of you. And oh, you're not doing it. We're not, I think we create this safe environment where people want to be coached because we're in there with them, cheering them on, and we just have a very unique way between the two of us where um we, I mean, we have people team members coming to us all the time now. We have such an open communication in our environment where people will role-play anything, any kind of scenario, and uh, and then we do that on our show too, which is kind of interesting because we have the we call them victims, we call them willing victims, but um, we have them come on our show. We've never coached them before, but they actually want the coaching and they want to feel that kind of uncomfortable because they know it will make them better. And uh, so yeah, I would say everybody doesn't like it, um, especially at first.
SPEAKER_03But then when they see the results, breaking through the uncomfortability is what gives you the results. You were uncomfortable, but if you hadn't done that, you wouldn't be where you are right now, right? People want to stay comfortable and sit there and and keep saying the same things that aren't getting them the results because at least they don't feel nervous and they're not worried about what people think. Yeah, and it's like completely backwards. You're never gonna get I want to make more, but I want to keep doing it this way. Well, yeah, not gonna change.
SPEAKER_05We actually did we I made our whole staff, we did um I'm a little teapot. I made everybody, we all sang it. It did like the whole, you know, tip me over and pour me out thing. And it and talk about breaking through the uncomfortability.
SPEAKER_02How many do you have on your team, Jason?
SPEAKER_05Uh right now 12. Yeah. So it's uh and now now we're doing two meetings a day. So I mean this stuff gets it's you know, once you get once you break through the what first 10 times by I mean, it could be up to 10 times, it's uncomfortable.
SPEAKER_00It could be up to 100. I mean, it just depends on the person, right?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and it really does, and what you were saying earlier, it really does make a difference when it comes from peers. Because when I was first um implementing like role-playing reviewing calls and stuff, I was just doing it. And so I'd bring people in and it was it was uncomfortable. They kind of listen to me, but like then when we started doing it with our like top performers, coaching and stuff like that, it it's it's a different meaning. Like it's a peer-to-peer thing, is a different uh it's a different meaning altogether. And like now I just I have our team running our own meetings and it is peer-to-peer, and it just it's so much more effective, I think. Um so yeah, ha talk about that. Talk about the how the peer to peer has worked um in your agency.
SPEAKER_00Um well, I would say the first thing is is that you kind of gotta teach people like how to do peer to peer coaching. Um Because um what I noticed at first when we started with peer-to-peer is people would go, uh they would come from a very critical perspective. And so they would say, Oh, you need to do this different, this different. I didn't like the way that sounded. And they're they're almost like more real and raw than like we are. We're like trying to build that confidence and they're thinking, no, I'm gonna get in there and I'm gonna tell them the way it is, you know. So they get really excited, but that's it does it's not effective because it you it may work like one time for people to go, oh, I really like that. I'll put it on as feedback, but then after a while it kind of wears on you, and you might be there might be some that are like that people stay away from. So we're not trying to break down that team unity. Um, so I always tell people tell them what they're doing right because everybody's doing something right. So start there and then um give them one thing that you think like that in a positive way that you think that they could improve on. And so, and that's it. Like if you're doing peer-to-peer, that's it. And if there's you know, then they can have a conversation about it. And because they're both doing like the same, have the same roles, they'll really respect the feedback. Yeah, but um, if you get too much like a know it all and too many things that you're trying to like get them to change, it can be very defeating.
SPEAKER_02Well, and that just all starts with the culture. And I I'd say we've, you know, Cameron, Kristen and I, we've worked on this culture that we have between six locations for years. We're always trying to do things just to we call it one team. We want our team to truly think of themselves as one. And so, like this video pod we're on right now, we have our entire team on video every minute of every day. So they can all hear each other, every single conversation, and so they'll be chatting things like, Oh, great job, keep going with that, or you know, they'll give them compliments or they'll give them pointers, but all day long they're you know in the trenches with one another.
SPEAKER_03I and I was gonna ask that was my next thing to ask about because I know that you did we talked a little bit about touched on it in Seattle, but so every like they can look on the Zoom screen and they can see any every single one of their peers.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, we have it broken down into two pods. So we have an outbound sales team where they're doing leads, they're on one screen, we have an inbound on another. Last month, though, we mixed it up and we did uh accountability partners. So we just had two on a pod all day long. So if it was you and I, I would hear you all day long. And that did again talk about work, you know, working on the culture. We thought that would be a great way to get team members together that maybe didn't know each other really well. For one month, they were on video with each other every minute of every workday.
SPEAKER_03So to walk through the listeners, if they want to do something like that, is it like they have their headphones for the system, right? Their phone system, and then on the computer, the audio is just kicking out the zoom or whatever.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and so it does get tricky. Happy to help anybody with it. Uh or came just walking out, but you do you have to use that you just committed to. No, you have to use your name of it, but you've you've got to turn if you take a phone call, you want to turn Zoom down so you don't hear both.
SPEAKER_00It depends on your phone system and how it interfaces. Like you'll just need to kind of figure that out.
SPEAKER_02Okay, yeah, and I would say it's been one of the best things we've ever done. At the beginning, a lot of people said, Boy, this is like big brother. You guys are you have us on video at all hours. Uh, a lot of people didn't like it.
SPEAKER_00But then when we didn't do it like last month, we had people pair up, they're like, I miss my group.
SPEAKER_01So it does, yeah.
SPEAKER_00With I mean, especially with having six offices, I mean, it does bring people together. And um, you do have to, I would say, as a manager, you need to know that you do have to remind people to turn their video on. And some people, you know, will be a little bit more, you know, I would say resistant to it at first, but they can see the benefit of it. It's not big brother watching, it's more team unity. Um, sometimes, like we have people that are transferring the influence, so they're dialing and then they're transferring it to a senior sales advisor. And a lot of times that helps them know if someone's on the phone. They can just look on the video pod and see if someone's on the phone so they can transfer it if no one's answering the group chat. Um, but it helps me too. So I'll zoom in and I'll be listening to all of them talking at once, and then I'll hear something that maybe I want to listen to that call, and so then I'll I'll just click into that call and listen to it live.
SPEAKER_02Wow, that's an amazing way to the ability to coach, it's just made a huge difference because that is. I know me, I always feel guilty if I don't talk to everybody and see everybody every day. And you know, I feel like I'm leaving them out, and this just gives you the ability with one click to go on there. I've seen them all. And like Kristen said, you hear something, you pick something up that you want to talk to or you know, coach on, you just do it right then.
SPEAKER_03And you can do it from anywhere, you could be on your yacht with your with your phone, the big uh Olsen yacht over there, and and uh and look at the team.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_03That's right. We've done it.
SPEAKER_00And the other thing is I think that you can find like um people that maybe have something really like they're doing something really great on a call. And so I might zoom them and say, let's roleplay that. I really liked, I liked hearing what you were saying. And so I'm learning from them, and we might say, Hey, you guys, listen to what Jeff just did. Um, and we might talk about it on our team call the next day and role play that. Like it's like the role plays and the topics are endless if you're really listening and if you're really have a cohesive team. So I think we have that approach that we don't want it all just to come from us, we want feedback. I you know, we want people to say, hey, look at how I made this my own. Maybe somebody else would um be interested in that.
SPEAKER_03So isn't it amazing how when you're doing those coaching calls that you pick stuff up like all day? Like I'll pick stuff up from my team yesterday. One of my while I was listening to a call whilst you know live, and she said something that I had never done, I hadn't ever thought of. She was talking about liability, and she said, Let's say you, because she was explaining what liability meant. Let's say you hit me. So instead of saying, you know, you if you hit someone, because we always say if you hit someone, she's she made it, you hit me, and my kids are in the car, and all of a sudden it's this, you know, they're connected, right? Yeah, yeah, I was like, Oh, I can't believe I've never even thought of that before. And it was just it was, but it was great. And then the the one, like the the prospect that she was talking to, it drew her in. Yeah, you could hear she goes, Oh, I would never want to hit you. And you know, all of a sudden they're they were connected, and she closed it, and it was it was great. I mean, I don't know, it was just really cool. And so you pick up, yeah, you pick up all kinds of stuff all day.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we we do that with our team all the time, right? Right before our show yesterday, we were having Miles help us with you know tweaking the talk path because he's so awesome at that.
SPEAKER_00And did you see that video on our Facebook page, Craig?
SPEAKER_02I haven't gone there. I it's been gotta go watch Miles what he did.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah, for sure. And we definitely want to talk about so so that's a good segue into it. So you have the show for the role play at the at the Olsen Agency, and that's on your Facebook page. Um, and it's it's real simple. I mean, and I I I don't I could even, you know, it's what 79 bucks a month, and people can just uh be part of it, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, I I would say that uh that's just our niche. That's what you know, together we love coaching role play, and it's just a unique balance. I've got the 20, almost 25 years of insurance, so I bring a lot of the talk pass and just insurance experience and language, and then to pair that up with a certified instructor is pretty unique. And I just think Kristen has a very unique way of coaching role play because it is uh it's all done on the positive side. She's not, you know, breaking anybody down. And uh we I believe it's the number one thing that you can do to improve your agency is implementing role play. I truly believe that. And I fought it myself for years, didn't want to do it, never had done it for 18, but it's it's really done wonders in my own agency. And so when I saw her skills, I thought, man, this would be great to be able to offer to other agencies and other staff who might not be able to do it. So, yeah, for $79 once a week, we come on live on Zoom just like this, and we pick two random staff members from agencies around the country that I've they've never met, which is the cool part of it. They've never met each other, we've never met them, they just volunteered because they're a member, and we pick a talk path. And we, I'd say, what do you think we spend on it each week designing this talk path?
SPEAKER_00Uh well, I mean, it just depends on the talk path, but we do like actually, uh, even though we have the talk paths like in our mind, we we role play them in our agency and make sure that's why we call it role play with the Olsen Agency, because our team is really helping us with this too, because I'm listening to them role play it with me.
SPEAKER_02But I don't know, maybe if we're to prep for the show, I would say five hours, like yeah, we really want to make each talk path, you know, each week something where somebody can literally run back to their desk and use it right then. And we do a blend of sales and service, objections, just about anything you can think of. Uh, and so we roll, we come out with a talk path, we teach it, and we talk about the why behind it. We don't start the show out by just saying, do this, it works. We talk about the why. We spend a good 10 or 15 minutes on that. Then we have these again random team members role-play it live. Like they're nervous.
SPEAKER_00They they are, they're willing, but nervous, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Because it's just so real and raw, which is kind of the draw of the whole show. So they role play it live, and Kristen might interrupt them, I might give them some coaching, but we you you see the second time around just how different and how improved they are, and so everybody gets something out of it. First of all, LSPs, you know, staff members that are watching are learning these talk paths, learning how to role play, but then agency owners, because I know uh I certainly didn't know how to coach role play. And so agency owners, when they're watching, they're watching Kristen, you know, coach on it, they pick up how to actually coach. So for $79, we feel it's a pretty darn good deal.
SPEAKER_03That's a pretty good deal for sure. And how much of a difference have you seen because you were resistant to the coaching uh originally? Or I mean, I'm sorry, not to the coaching, to the to the role play. How like from a from a true perspective of results, how much different did it seem? And I mean, you know, there's there's different metrics. There's the, you know, how well are they writing business? Are they closing better? But then there's also, I would think, a retention of staff factor, too.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, for sure. This this does so many things. First of all, the customer wins because we're talking the right way to them. We're always leading with protection. So, number one, customer wins. But then, just in terms of how, like we always laugh. You can go into one office and drive over to the next one, they're all talking the same way. So the customer gets the same experience no matter where they call. And we just know they're gonna be sold the proper coverage, good protection, uh, because that's what we coach and that's what we role play. We we never you know go light on coverage.
SPEAKER_00But then when you're talking about like team unity and retention, um, it has done, I think like that's that's huge. It's we always say that we're a family here, and um, the team really uh does uh treat each other like family, and I think that some of that is a good portion of it, is because of the culture that we have. Because what role play does is it opens up the communication across all channels of the business, not just like with talking to customers, but it really makes them. I don't know, if you came and met our team, I mean, or even like looked at some of the chats, like they they're just so open in the way that they communicate. I think it attracts a certain type of person. I was thinking when you guys were talking too about um Jeremy at first and how he wanted to be an insurance agent since you know, since he was a child and came from um three generations of insurance agents. Uh if there sometimes we have people that don't work out because we're just, you know, business, you know, he's a business owner, we're running a business, and uh, you know, not everybody's going to stay. Not everybody loves this environment. You have to actually really be a team player and be involved with the team. If you're a lone wolf, this does not work.
SPEAKER_01Right.
SPEAKER_00So um, but when we have people that leave, and I would say there's no one that leaves and gets into insurance somewhere else. This is a great place to work if you want to be an insurance. But if someone says, you know, insurance just isn't my thing, I've never seen a more hurt look on his face. Like, how could you say that? You know, look at all that we've put into you and done. And, you know, like he just does not, it doesn't compute how someone could not love insurance. And, you know, I think that's what's so special about um, you know, what we do here is that that's who's leading the helm, is it's just in his blood through and through. And uh so people, you know, that work here really get that, but they there's just this willingness that's just very different than any anywhere else I've seen.
SPEAKER_03It's like an elf telling Santa that that they don't like presents.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. No, I mean the look, I just am like when people I've had that happen a few times, and I'm just thinking in my mind, you don't know what you just did to this person sitting by me, you know.
unknownThat's terrible.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, no, we we actually had somebody leave a couple weeks ago for that reason. They just didn't love the industry, and we were meeting him for lunch, and I had all these ways I was gonna be able to, I mean, what can I throw at him? What can I change for him? I I want him to stay, love him, want him to be a part of our team. And the first thing was I just don't like insurance, and I I don't think I said because there was nothing I could save someone like that. And yeah, to me, I just I just don't get that because I I do truly believe this is the best industry in the world.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Being independent you just stood up and silently walked away.
SPEAKER_00No, he I mean, I had to lead the con the rest of the conversation, but he yeah, he was pretty heartbroken. I mean, I could tell. I was just like, oh man, I can just feel that. Like, how could you do this to me?
SPEAKER_02Well, and it's not about it's not about me, it's not at all. But man, the agency's losing production, it's them. I'm thinking, gosh, you could have this amazing life uh in this industry helping people. That's what my thought is, yeah.
SPEAKER_03What they can do for the agency.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, sure.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, every everybody thinks it's a a commodity and that they just need to have it, and and they don't realize like the the even some of our the people that come to work for us don't realize the importance of the liability part, right? There's no understanding of the liability. It's I have this insurance to fix my car, and because the DMV tells me to. Yeah, right. They don't realize the actual what's at stake. They pay the financial advisor all this money, they pay the lawyer all this money, but they think that we're just, you know, these oh, it's just the insurance person. And it's like I I would argue we're more important because without us, their stuff isn't protected, right?
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I think um, I I mean role playing has changed our agency. I know it's changed Craig, obviously it's changed your agency. So for people out there that are still they're on the fence, this is still super uncomfortable, but maybe they'll dabble. Uh is there some tips that you can give them to maybe try to get a little session going? Maybe they're not ready to jump into um to like a full subscription service with you guys. They're not ready to invest that kind of time and energy into it. How can they dabble with it where they can get their maybe their team together or a couple people? What are some tips that you guys would have?
SPEAKER_00Well, actually, Jason, I I loved what you did when you said you made everybody sing what was the song you made them sing?
SPEAKER_05Little Little Teapot. Little teapot.
SPEAKER_00So um I mean, if you so one thing that I would say is um practice character traits. So even if you're doing um like the little teapot, like say that you had your whole team do that, I'm a little teapot, um, and maybe you said, you know what, we're gonna practice doing I'm a little teapot with confidence today. And before that, what does that look like? And so um if you had a whole bunch of little confident teapots, um, then how does that translate? Then it always has to translate into okay, then how do you show that same kind of confidence um on your phone calls or when you're talking to people in person? And so when people actually see um what the character trait is, that's a great place to start. So I guess my point is it doesn't matter what you role play, role play a character trait. And so that's one place.
SPEAKER_02And then I don't think I've ever heard that. I like this.
SPEAKER_03That is that is the nugget. That uh nugget I don't know where it came from.
SPEAKER_02Well, don't even start. But no, and I I think that is really exactly what our show, kind of what my vision of starting this company was is 90% of agents don't want to lead role play, so we'll do it for you. Like for a $20 bill, we'll come live into your office uh on Zoom and do it for you. You can be, you know, you can be assured that your team would role play once a week, uh, it would just be virtual.
SPEAKER_00So that would be my other tip is it's role play one topic a week. So if you think about it, like, and I have people saying this all the time, they'll, you know, we'll teach a role play and then they'll say, okay, that's what I'm gonna focus on this week with my team. Because the biggest thing is if you're gonna invest your time in something, even if it's I'm a little teapot, or if it's you know, if it's something with your team, you want to see how that translates into business results, right? So the only way to get business results is repetition. And so the repetition is roll one thing out at a time because if you I I all I can tell you is do not confuse your team with too much at once. So um one thing at a time and then repetition the whole week, um, and and then listen to the calls for it. So sometimes we do like promos, like if we have a certain phrase that we want people to say, we'll do a promo where they will give them, you know, five dollars a call each time they say it, um, just to have a little bit of fun, and then they'll have to send us like what their calls are, and then we'll listen back. But um it you just can't confuse it, keep it simple. And then the other one is dabbling in it really doesn't work, Jason. I'm sorry, but it uh you have to be consistent. So I would say the dabble is take baby steps into just trying it and have one specific day a week that you do it. You know, say you don't want to do it every day, do it one day a week, that's a baby step, but be consistent.
SPEAKER_02Well, and then I was also gonna mention it's funny you should ask uh because we actually did a webinar. It's been about three weeks before we were starting our company on how to implement role play in your agency, and we gave that for free to anybody who wants it. So any listeners who would like that, uh, we would certainly pass it along to you.
SPEAKER_03Is that on the on your page on the Facebook?
SPEAKER_02Well, no, it's not on our page. We have it on our on our business page for members, but anybody that wants it, I I can get a copy to you.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, get me a copy, we'll post it in the show notes. We'll we'll make a link to it and then people can grab it right here on iTunes or wherever you're listening to.
SPEAKER_02And we gave plenty of these mic draw tips.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I I I honestly would just like to see um Craig and Jason with confidence uh role play. I'm a little teapot.
SPEAKER_03This moment?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Are you ready, Craig? I I think I could do it.
SPEAKER_00Okay, wait, wait. First of all, let's do some coaching before. Okay, so give me your um what does like how do you exude confidence? What does that look like to you?
SPEAKER_02You like that?
SPEAKER_00They're puffing up their chest, they're standing up straight. Yeah, they've got smiles on their face. Okay, so this is these are good coaching tips when you're teaching your team or coaching your team. Yeah, we can tell you're totally okay. So let's go. Let's hear it.
SPEAKER_05All right, Craig. One, two, three. I'm a little tea, short and stout. Here is my handle. Here is my spout. When I get all steamed up, I don't know the rest. Hear me shout.
SPEAKER_04Just tip me over and bore me out. Yes, yeah, I added that one.
SPEAKER_03There you go. That's good. I need to, I'm gonna have to play that back and so that I know those words. So we're gonna do that. That's a good one.
SPEAKER_05Well, we had YouTube it um on the phone because no no nobody knows the whole the whole song.
SPEAKER_03I knew the first verse. Well, okay, now can you uh critique that please?
SPEAKER_00Well, I would say that Jason, first of all, I absolutely love your smile. Um thank you. So and you were smiling the whole time and it changed your tone of voice. So I would say that you had a more positive tone of voice. Um in order to continue to utilize that tone of voice, I would smile really big when you're talking. To anyone because that really works.
SPEAKER_05That does work. I love that.
SPEAKER_00Craig, I also love your just you actually have a very uh childlike quality. And um, but you can work that to your advantage because even though you didn't know the words, um that look in your that twinkle in your eyes like you were remembering childhood from singing the song, yeah, actually um made would make people buy from you.
SPEAKER_03So a little bit of kindergarten came back.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I would um maybe both of you you could work on if I would give you one tip, work on the words.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, definitely. I didn't even know this was gonna happen.
SPEAKER_00I know, yeah. And coordinated, um, coordinated body motions, like the same things, you know.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, we were a little off. We weren't in sync.
SPEAKER_00We can I I can work.
SPEAKER_05We weren't very backstreet boys on that.
SPEAKER_02How many of these uh shows do you guys do a week? Is it one, two, three to five?
SPEAKER_03Really?
SPEAKER_02Oh wow, you record them and then how long uh till they air two weeks.
SPEAKER_03Two weeks.
SPEAKER_01They gotta do it.
SPEAKER_03We had it was about four weeks, and then we got a little lax a couple of the weeks on his ECP launch, and then mine we got behind a little bit.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, and I will say the way you coached, so critiquing the coaching is awesome. I love the way you coach because you led with something that was super positive, and then at the very end, just no, you could maybe tweak this. I love that. No, no, it's true though. I mean, that with Greg, it's all good.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I wish she was practicing it with me. I like at the very beginning of our show, she used to do that yesterday. I I can't wait for you to see this moment. We we had uh play victim, and she was amazing. I've I actually verified with my whole team I was right on this. No, she was amazing. I I picked up this microphone and I said, Boy, if I could disconnect this thing right now, I would just drop it. That was whoa. In the past, Kristen probably would have done like she just did with you. You know, I think that was very positive. That was great. Bring up give them some. No, she went right to are you kidding?
SPEAKER_00No, I didn't do that. I just said there's some things that I might, you know, like I love this. This is something that I could tell you're reading from the script, so let's try it again. I'm gonna give you actually a do-over to be even more authentic.
SPEAKER_02But we have pulled the office and it was good.
SPEAKER_00Well, so this is the scoop. I think there's always something you can improve on, even if you're great. And 100% you want to actually get that permission, that's another tip, is get that permission up front from your team members. Is it okay if I coach you?
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, because if you ask them, then they're gonna be more open. And you might even ask them, like, you know, what what are you looking to gain? They might say, I want to be more genuine. Okay, that's what I'm gonna look for when I'm coaching you. And then bring that. Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. See, these are the things. I mean, the nuggets are just coming out.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I don't know. I we could talk all day. I just would like to do maybe we'll work again next week on that little teapot thing.
SPEAKER_03Yes. Well, uh, we're we're up against the wall. There's two things we have to do. We do have a final question, and then we have to take a selfie before, so we get everybody for the the thing, it's a new thing we're doing. So if if you could give one piece of advice to somebody starting in this business, which is a much different world than when you started back when it was microfiche and ducks.
SPEAKER_02I still have my machine actually. What would you what advice would you give? It's funny because I I do go around sometimes and I speak to groups of new agents, and there's always somebody that asks exactly that question. And I think what they're looking for is the name of a vendor, maybe the name, you know, what lead to buy. And I always say the same thing. I say, you know, one piece of advice. If it were me, the minute I leave this room, I would walk downstairs, get in your car, and drive to the nearest bank and take out the biggest line of credit you can. Because that is the only reason I have six offices, is because from day one, I have borrowed and invested and made my grip business grow. There is, you can't do this business if you're not willing to invest and grow. It's all about growth. So don't be love it.
SPEAKER_03That's amazing because I think you and only one other person said anything even remotely close to that, and it was Jay Atkins.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, he actually took that from me when we met three or four years ago, and I love Jay, but we met three or four years ago, and I gave him that same talk. And I think he actually did go get in his car and drive to the bank. He he never had thought of that either. And it it is so true. You've got to invest. Hire, I always overhire. I always try to have a bench. I always, if there's a new lead, something new I can buy that will help my business grow, I'm all in. There is no way I'm not gonna do it.
SPEAKER_03So many agents are that were they're fearful to spend the money to get the results. And and if you don't spend money, you just hope that the phone rings, it isn't gonna happen.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, right.
SPEAKER_02No, last night I was, I know we gotta wrap this up, but last night I was talking to an agency owner, and he was you know kind of down on some of the changes and saying, you know, I I can't do it, I'm gonna have to cut staff. And I said, give me the bottom line numbers. How much do you need to grow? And by the end, he was going to hire three people. It just mass out. There's no other business that you get renewals from, there's no other business that you can pay for a team member with all these different, you know, ways that we can earn income in one year. It just doesn't happen.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and the math works. Like you just it's it's all there. Every piece of that equation is there to make the money. It's amazing. So they uh I know everybody here already has their cards out, they're ready to jump and and jump into the role play at the Olsen Agency. Where do they go? How do they find it?
SPEAKER_02Insurance roleplay.com.
SPEAKER_03Okay, and we will put a link to the uh to the thing uh in the notes, in the show notes. Well, not the dot com.
SPEAKER_02The other part of it is we we do make it fun, like what you saw today with the you know, the joking around, and that's how we are. That's how she coaches. She does 90% of the coaching on the show. I bring the insurance stuff, but we do. We just have fun with it.
SPEAKER_00And he does give me like an extra hard time, and I'm always right.
SPEAKER_03No, I know another uh not the not so positive feedback. I know, you know, but Jeremy beat up over there. I well, I can't believe thank both of you. This is awesome. Uh, would you come back again if we wanted if we uh had some spots up available here in the future?
SPEAKER_00Of course, but I have a question for you. Will you guys come on our show and be guest coaches? I want to hear your talk.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, of course.
SPEAKER_00Okay, there you go.
SPEAKER_02We love we love having guest coaches.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, no, we we'll be calling on you.
SPEAKER_02All right, okay. Perfect.
SPEAKER_05So should we do selfie? Yeah, oh I almost forgot. Do you guys want to do one too?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_05So group selfie. You guys go first.
SPEAKER_03Selfies? All right. Oh, there we are.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you guys gotta talk because I don't want Craig's back in the picture.
SPEAKER_03Oh, okay. There. There. Okay, now what are we doing?
SPEAKER_00Wait, how do I do that with two people?
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Oh, we can it's a new segment.
SPEAKER_00Wait.
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Ooh, three. Three pictures.
SPEAKER_00So I get it, like they're photobombing, you guys are photobombing our selfie. Right. Oh my gosh, that's so funny. I did that on our call yesterday and I posted on our Facebook page like right before the show. No. Oh my god. He can't post that. It's horrible. Oh my goodness. You guys are funny.
SPEAKER_05Right. We appreciate it. Yeah, we appreciate it. Heck out of this. This was awesome. A ton of knowledge nuggets for everyone. And I think people should start implementing tomorrow, today, role-playing. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00I really want you guys, like, I think I want you both on the show at the same time. I don't know how I'm gonna manage that yet, but I'll right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. We will do it.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_0355% of insurance sales producers say that they have had little or no sales training. Us agents focus on marketing to drive activity and often overlook the sales presentation. Improvements in mindset, shifting focus, report, needs diagnosis, value building, creating buy-in, and overcoming objections lead to drastically better closing numbers. The solution? Enroll your team in September sales summit offered by Agency Vault. We will even assess your team to see which of their sales steps need the most improvement. Head to agencyvault.com to sign up before it's full.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman