The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee talk. Coffee talk. Hey Jason. Hey Craig. I'm gonna take a sip of my coffee because it's coffee.
SPEAKER_00
So, Craig, um we just talked to Mark Mercer. His first concert was Michael Jackson. Marco Jackson 5. I love that.
SPEAKER_01
Marco.
SPEAKER_00
Yes.
SPEAKER_01
Mercer.
SPEAKER_00
So what was your first concert that you ever went to?
SPEAKER_01
My very first concert was General Public at Cal State Fullerton. That's right in your area. Ooh. General Public. Remember General Public? I actually don't. You don't? Um I'm not gonna sing. Do it, dude. You gotta do it. You gotta sing it. I can't do it. Can't do it. Maybe we'll we'll play it. Let's play it in the background.
SPEAKER_00
Okay.
SPEAKER_01
There you go. Remember that? You don't remember that song?
SPEAKER_00
No. General public.
SPEAKER_01
I think, isn't there a uh mirror in the bathroom? Yes. There you go. Yeah, yeah. It's sort of like reggae ska-ish.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Can I throw in my second? Because it was a lot of fun. My second, my second one was oingo boingo at the Greek theater. And listen to what I did. This is the hooligan that I was. Okay. Okay. We were in the upper deck, and my friend kept digging me on. I lit the M80. I held it, and then I chucked it up in the air, like way, way high. And I and I highly advise nobody to ever do this. And it exploded up in the air. Luckily, I mean I could have blown my hand off of somebody, or you know, just head. Stupid. Stupid. And this is just hypothetical, of course. But exploded, and Danny Elfman from the stage said something. I like, whoa, who's doing that? Or you know, like, like, and then the whole place went cheered. So I don't know. It was pretty nuts. We didn't get it. Man, that could have that could have not gone the right way. Was there alcohol involved? No, no. I mean that was like eighth grade. Okay. Well, who knows? Yeah, what kind of hooligan you were? No, no alcohol in the middle school, not until mid-high school. That's crazy, man.
SPEAKER_00
My first concert, I was raised by a single mom.
SPEAKER_01
Okay.
SPEAKER_00
So that's the preface to what I'm about to say. My first concert was Paula Abdul. Oh, jeez. And that's back with Scat Cat. Scat Cat came out for opposites attract. I'm not familiar with Scat Cat. He was the the cartoon cat that came out and danced with Paula.
SPEAKER_01
Oh. How does the cartoon cat dance in person?
SPEAKER_00
Was it like a um mascot suit? Yes, it was a full mascot suit. Oh, geez. Fantastic.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, it's true. That is true. Tupac came out in a hologram. Oh, the two packs? No Pac-Man? How about the first video game that you played?
SPEAKER_00
The first video game. It had to be. No, you know, um, I'll never forget my my grandparents when I was young bought me the first Nintendo with the Gyramite. That was the first game system that I got. So I think maybe with Rob the Robot. I don't know.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, okay. That's because I'm old. So that was after Atari and Intellivision and ColecoVision. Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00
You're you're a little older. I'm shocked they actually had video games when you were they did.
SPEAKER_01
They did. And I didn't get the Atari, but I did convince the folks to get me the Intellivision. So I thought you guys just played marbles. Yeah, well, you would think. You would think.
SPEAKER_00
How do we spin this into an insurance stock? Well.
SPEAKER_01
I mean, you've got to do what you like and you don't throw M80s in your agency.
SPEAKER_00
Truth. It's a bad idea. And what would be the modern day version of throwing an M80 in your agency?
SPEAKER_01
Not using something to manage your leads.
SPEAKER_00
Yes, that's true.
SPEAKER_01
You know, like trying to use an Excel spreadsheet or hand handwritten notes files. Because there's just, I mean, there's too much technology at your disposal.
SPEAKER_00
Truth. Yep. And and this is what I always say, because uh people always say, oh gosh, that management system might be a hundred dollars a month per person, right? Like that's expensive. Well, what's what's more expensive is your person doing five times less work. So if that hundred dollars makes them twice as productive, you're basically, let's say they, you know, they're three thousand dollars a month, you're saving fifteen hundred by spending one hundred.
SPEAKER_01
How many dials do you think a person could do by hand with a telephone?
SPEAKER_00
Like the rotary?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, well, I was thinking pasta rotary, not not the one where you go, operator, give me six two three. That's the one that I had when I was a kid. Yeah. Oh, I thought you guys had the uh what was it you?
SPEAKER_00
Oh man. Uh yeah. Yeah. I I don't know. But you're gonna want to shoot yourself after 50. Yes. That sucks. And how many are your your uh dudes and dudettes? A few hundred. A few hundred.
SPEAKER_01
But now I'm not even looking necessarily at the dials, I'm looking at the talk time. Yeah, because here's the most productive activity, right?
SPEAKER_00
It is a hundred percent, but how most people don't answer the phones anymore, sure, right?
SPEAKER_01
So you gotta make those dials to get those meaningful conversations, it could be a hundred dials to get to one meaningful conversation, right?
SPEAKER_00
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
SPEAKER_01
And even if you're buying leads, right? You could I mean we're we're getting uh 166 leads a day. We probably get a hold of 15 of them. Yep. So if you're getting if you're doing leads, and you know how many times you hear somebody say the leads suck. Right. If you buy 20 leads a day, the leads do suck. You don't have enough leads to get to somebody.
SPEAKER_00
Right.
SPEAKER_01
I mean, that's unfortunately the way that it works.
SPEAKER_00
And we always talk about process when it comes to leads and stuff, and like you know, the presentation, the closing, and all this stuff. But one thing that I don't think it's talked about enough is not talking about insurance. Don't bore, don't bore the other person with insurance stock. Like if you can't connect with them outside of insurance, the there's a very little chance that you're gonna be able to sell any insurance.
SPEAKER_01
Let's do some role-playing. Ring ring ring, Mr. Jason. This is Craig down Hello, Mr. Jason. This is Craig down at the insurance agency. Do you have a couple minutes to go over a quote? Click. Right. Click. How about ring ring ring? Hey, Jason. Uh yes. Hello. Hey, uh Jason, how you doing? Pretty good. Who's this? Oh, this is Craig. We talked about six months, maybe eight months ago. Okay. Yeah, we went over some numbers uh on your home insurance, on your auto insurance. You remember talking to me?
SPEAKER_00
No, I don't think like an egg.
SPEAKER_01
I said Craig like an egg. Yeah, see, I remember you laughed. I have it in my notes. You laughed the last time. You don't remember? No, I don't, man. Well, I mean, will you give me five minutes? I I'd like to really help you. Um, we do it a lot different here, and and we just really want to help make sure that you have the right coverage. I'll tell you what, if at the end of this conversation you don't feel you're better off, I will give you, I'll print this thing out, I'll tell you which coverage is, and you take it over to your current insurer and just at least show them what we've just what we've uncovered. Good with that? Craig and egg. Yeah, Craig the Egg. I have Colby. Colby says, Colby says, uh, it's Colby like the cheese. So he says all I mean they love genius. Yeah, Colby like the cheese. You got it. Sometimes he'll say, not Kobe like the Bryant, but Colby like the cheese.
SPEAKER_00
I love that. Yeah. That's a good throws somebody off guard. If you can throw them off guard, you're golden.
SPEAKER_01
He he's been lately the last couple days, he's been saying, uh, I'm I'm calling to offer insurance conversion therapy.
SPEAKER_00
And they love it. That's another thing. You gotta have fun, dude. If you're having fun talking to people, they feel that and they're like, all right, cool. Like I would talk to somebody, I'd stay on the phone every now and then like I like that fun.
SPEAKER_01
I usually answer the phone when it's some number I don't know just to hear what they're gonna say, and typically the parable. Um, but when there's a funny one, I'll I'll hang out. You know, I mean I have no problem hanging up on them. Uh this is so-and-so from 18th click, right? But when it's something funny, I'll listen and then I'll offer them a job. Yeah. They're in the area.
SPEAKER_00
I like that nug. Nug. Well, I think that was a great coffee talk. That started off a little funky. I didn't know if we were gonna be able to uh pull that together today.
SPEAKER_01
Well, look at it. It came together like a couple chickens in a chicken farm.
SPEAKER_00
Well, slap that on your knee and call it Sammy. Okay, Sammy, we'll see you tomorrow. All right.
SPEAKER_01
55% of insurance sales producers say that they have had little or no sales training. Us agents focus on marketing to drive activity and often overlook the sales presentation. Improvements in mindset, shifting focus, rapport, needs diagnosis, value building, creating buy-in, and overcoming objections lead to drastically better closing numbers. The solution? Enroll your team in September sales summit offered by Agency Vault. We will even assess your team to see which of their sales steps need the most improvement. Head to agencyvault.com to sign up before it's full.
SPEAKER_00
Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.