The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Craig. Yes. Yes? Yes. Well, I think it's time for some good. Our courage broke here, dude.
SPEAKER_01
Goldy Talk.
SPEAKER_00
I have no coffee.
SPEAKER_01
Wow.
SPEAKER_00
Brutal. I know. I'm about to go get a bull, an El Toro, if you will.
SPEAKER_02
A bull.
SPEAKER_00
How do you say red? Rojo in Spanish.
SPEAKER_02
El Toro. Rojo.
SPEAKER_00
There we go.
SPEAKER_01
Rojo.
SPEAKER_00
Um, yeah, so we were talking about internet leads. Is that right? We sure were. So this is a while ago, and now I'm bringing it back. And I wanted to do three secret tips to internet leads. Because that's all my agency does. And um we have a tips. Ooh. Ooh. Three secret tips. You're making it dirty. Oh. But I want anything to do with three. So here's a couple tips for any agency I think that's working internet leads. Um, three of the top three tips I would say. One is kind of going against the grain of what everybody teaches, which is the top three things that anybody wants that fills out anything on the internet is they want it to be cheap, fast, and easy. So you have to address what the people want originally. Now, are you gonna go into the long quote? Perhaps you, I mean, that's the goal, and that's what we're gonna do. But you have to let them know, don't worry, it's gonna take a minute, right? Don't worry, this is gonna, we're gonna give you the absolute cheapest rate. You know what I mean? And it's gonna be fast, super easy, super easy. So then as long as everything you address immediately falls into those three categories, then say it. If it doesn't, don't say it. Like that's it. So that's that's one philosophy. Um, the opening line, you gotta come up with something wherever you're from, what people call to talk to their friends. Use that. Hey Craig, how's it going, man?
SPEAKER_02
You so whatever it may be. Yeah. I'll have to agree with you because ever since we incorporated this here, especially on aged leads and internet leads, uh, we have a much better keep them on the phone time. Yeah. And it's because there's some curiosity, right? They'll they'll say something along the lines of, and I I coached them into it doesn't matter, you must pause. Right. So, hey Craig, how's it going? And then zip it. Wait until they they will fill that that awkward silence. Yeah, and then they say something, what wait, what? Who who is this? What's this about? And then like Steve back here, one of my new guys, has been saying, Oh, it's Steve. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00
Pause long pause. If you think you're being sold, you hang up, dude. When I go into a store and I want to buy something, somebody comes up, can I help you? No, I don't want you to help me. You're annoying, like right. You're gonna take longer. Yeah, so nobody wants that. You so uh automatically the thing that we have in our pocket that we can use as a resource is we're we're not corporate, so we don't have to say something corporate, or and you know, all telemarketers have to say something corporate, don't do it. So that's that's the get go.
SPEAKER_02
They're they're uh they're they can get let go by not following the script.
SPEAKER_00
Yep. They're good too. You should you should uh like we've had our staff call them and they will try to close you that one call close every single time. Yeah, because once it's gone, that's it. Yep. The stakes are higher. Yeah, exactly. So that's the that's the key is open like that. Um and then and then what we say is yeah, you reached out on our website to lower your auto insurance rate. Are you still at this address? Do you still have this car? Do you still this? So that's the the third secret is you assume the quote.
unknown
Yes.
SPEAKER_00
Who cares if they hang up? So this is what happens every single day in my office, probably to five people per agent. Is this they call up? No, I'm not interested. No, no, no, no, I totally get it. Don't the no, I I I don't have enough time. That's the number one that we hear. Oh, oh no, I totally get it, man. Are you still have the this car? Do you still have this? You just and you know what you did there?
SPEAKER_02
You agree with them, yes, and then you go right back into what you're doing. Yeah, oh, I can I get it. Now, do you still have the Honda and the so it's agree, ignore, move on back to the question?
SPEAKER_00
That's it. If you can get someone, and I tell them this it's not like talking to your friend. This is a skill, so it's not gonna be something that you're gonna get right away, and you have to work on this. You have to get it out of your mind that you're talking to your friends or you're you're relearning how to talk to people on this.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
So that's the number one thing. If you can get someone to think like that, then they'll be good at them. And then I mean, we half the quotes that we do are turnarounds, and it ends up being longer, and they thank us for oh, I can't believe you explained all that. And then you go and through the coverages and everything. I no one's ever told me that. Yeah, exactly. Because you've shut down everybody, and all those other people didn't, yeah, they gave up. So we're doing them a service. Once your agent, so this is the uh, I guess the fourth secret would be this three. You have to make your agents realize this within the first few days of working with you. You have about one or two weeks to get your agents off the ground, otherwise, they're done. They turn into uh like their self-doubt, those negative thoughts take over and there's no turning back. So you have to have those wins right away. You have to teach them that that technique to go through to get the quote within the first few days, and you have to give them some wins right off the bat. If they can't win right off the bat, then their limiting beliefs will take over, and that's it. They're done. And you might as well let them go. So those are some nuggets. Those are my those are the honestly, probably the best nuggets I think that have worked in our agency.
SPEAKER_02
Well, and you've gone through a lot of newbies in the last three months. Dude, even in the last you know, even the last couple years, man. Well, yeah, even more so. It's crazy. But that it's the same thing. I I think that's a huge, a huge knowledge nugget in that you you've got to transfer that win to them early on because it's gonna affect their mindset. I mean, I have somebody that's struggling, and you know, it's it's likely a majority of my fault because I've been busy, you know, opening the other office, doing all this other things that I couldn't give the time that I needed to to him so that he could get those wins. So I think he's a little in his head right now.
SPEAKER_00
So here's the deal is buy him a lead that will close, or or have somebody it's like he needs to have a lead that closes. The the what we think as agency owners is hey, we're gonna throw them in the cheap leads, they better turn this stuff around. If they can't turn it around, then they're not gonna be good for the agency. Well, first, you gotta give them give them something that they can believe in. Now, here's the other thing is here's here's nugget number five, I would say. Five of three? Five of three is have another person that's actually doing this in the office, one of your top guys, coach them so they can see this, so they see that it works. So it's not just coming from you know, somebody who's not doing this or somebody who seems like uh uh on a different level. So it has to come, they they it has to be peer-based. And and the here's another thing. If your the peers help each other out, then there's a more solid foundation within um within the office amongst each other. They all got to help each other. We do we do two meetings a day. We have the meetings led by team leaders. Um, we review calls. They they give input, they each give input on their calls. We have call scripts that they gotta follow. So so it's trying to create a culture where it's like a lot of self-improvement and that everybody's kind of listening to each other, helping each other out. I think it's working.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
But then again, who knows, right? The second you think it's working, then something else will happen.
SPEAKER_02
Exactly. But you have to be ready, ride the wave. You gotta ride that wave.
SPEAKER_00
Ride the wave. I got blessed with a freaking awesome team. I love everybody in the office right now, and it's really cool.
SPEAKER_01
But I think but uh yeah, that's some coffee talk. That's a good coffee talk. Good coffee talk. Which was on last week. Dogs. Dogs never dogs, right here. Dogs. Is that your dog?
SPEAKER_02
It used to be he died. Ah that's the problem with dogs, they die.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Mine's outlived her expectancy.
SPEAKER_02
Well, I'll see you next week, Jason. All right. Bye bye. That's good. Bye.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.