The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. Hey, I love it. I love doing some coffee twalk. Well, you know, talk about what? Dogs, daughters, whatever. It's coffee tuck. Coffee tok. So, you know what's funny, Jason? Ha! What, Craig? Well, it's my daughter's birthday. Nine birthday. How teen. Yeah. Nineteen years. So I thought it'd be funny if we brought her on. What do you think? I think that's a fantastic idea. Let's do it. So you know how we do everything on Zoom, right? Yeah. You know that. Yeah. You're aware. I've heard. I'm aware. Yeah. I think. So sometimes I'm not aware. Well, yeah. So we do it on Zoom, and um, she goes to ASU, which is uh college, apparently up uh up about a hundred uh miles away from Tucson, and she needed help with her homework for econ or something, I don't know, one some class. And and she said, uh, do you know anything about Excel? And I'm like, that's what I do. I mean, I love Excel, you know, so so I said, sure, let's hop on a Zoom. And she's like, what's a Zoom? And and you know, like millennials are so good at all this computer stuff, it was pretty funny because I sent her the link, she couldn't log in, then she finally logged in, and then it was this whole like she couldn't get the audio to work, and I had to like texting her and calling her and say, look, you just click the little, you know, like the same thing that we do when we're talking to agents. So I thought it was funny.
SPEAKER_01
Did and and did she think that dad was pretty cool? I think she ever surprised, yeah.
SPEAKER_02
No, maybe I don't know, but she was surprised that the that that I was um that I was able that I had a technology that she hadn't seen, and I was better at utilizing it than she is. And without further ado, let's welcome Isabella Pretzinger into Yay. Hey, hey! Hi, does she have a oh she has audio it works? Happy birthday Happy birthday you're live with the dudes on the insurance dudes. What do you think of this? It's gotta be more entertaining than that, or we're gonna lose all the listeners. So um it's your birthday.
SPEAKER_00
It's my birthday.
SPEAKER_01
Are you gonna party like it's your birthday? Oh boy. What are you what are you doing? What what's what's gonna make dad nervous here? Let's put him on the spot. Everything. Everything. That's right. Are you going are you going to the bars?
SPEAKER_00
No. I'm not old enough.
SPEAKER_01
Oh, that's right. That's what I like to hear. I mean, I'm sure Craig went to bars when he was 19.
SPEAKER_00
I can go to frat party, Dad.
SPEAKER_02
What's that?
SPEAKER_00
I can go to frat parties.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, that's great. That's great. This is gonna be good. Well, so um, I I thought it'd be fun to bring you on because it's your birthday and you're pretty good with social media. And we talk about social media a lot on this show. And I think I just looked up, you have about almost 4,000 followers on Instagram, and they're not fake followers because when you post something, you get a thousand likes, so a 25% responses is is pretty high. I think of our few hundred that we have for the show, we'll get like 10 likes. Yay. So, what do you do? Like, how how does that happen besides wearing a bikini in there?
SPEAKER_00
Um, I think it's because a lot of the like followers that I have are like mutual people, like I'll meet people, or like when people follow me, a lot of the times it says like followed by another, like this person that you follow. So a lot of it's not mutual, so that way like active, I guess.
SPEAKER_02
So is that part of your strategy and growing your Instagram?
SPEAKER_00
Well, I don't really have strategies.
SPEAKER_02
I think that it's just natural because you have good genes, but um like my Instagram is like a business or anything. But it is your brand, you know, like it it's a reflection of who you are, and you post the things that you like. So while it's not a business, you know, whatever you go into, that's something that's gonna be looked at and um you can use to your advantage. I mean, it could it can become a business.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, people like companies like message me and ask me to like review their stuff sometimes, or they say like if they send me free stuff, if I like post it on my story, then they'll give me like a discount code or something that I can give to my followers, but I've never done it really.
SPEAKER_02
Well, I didn't do it.
SPEAKER_00
I did it once, but I forget what happened. Like someone like sent me necklaces, and then one of the necklaces broke, so I never like shout my story.
SPEAKER_02
Well, so what so they they give you offers like that? Like if you you promote the brand, then will uh whatever pay do they pay you?
SPEAKER_00
Well, the that necklace place and like a how a lot of other ones of them work, they like give you a discount code that you can like tell your followers and then you get like some commission off of it.
SPEAKER_02
If you like oh, so it's affiliate marketing.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
So you post the link, then then that person, um, if they purchase it, it tracks it and you get some money or whatever.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah.
SPEAKER_02
That's pretty interesting, Jason?
SPEAKER_01
That is interesting. Uh you you want to hear something funny. This is just random, but um, anytime Craig and I don't know what to say next, Craig always says Well, there it's just uh what what do you say? There's just uh it's so powerful. It's just so powerful, and then I say, Well, that that's awesome, and it buys us about five seconds to think of something to go into next. Yes, and I was just about to do that, and I thought it would be funnier just actually saying it. That is so powerful. It's awesome. What do you think about uh insurance? Um have you thought about going into it following the old dad?
SPEAKER_00
No.
SPEAKER_01
No, why not?
SPEAKER_00
I don't know, it's never really crossed my mind.
SPEAKER_01
What do you think about doing?
SPEAKER_00
Um now I'm in business school, so I don't know. I think well I wasn't really like that interested in business. I just went into business school because I didn't know what else to do. But now that I'm like learning more about it, I think it's actually cool and like I think it would be something good to study.
SPEAKER_01
Are you hard are you working and going to school at the same time?
SPEAKER_00
No, I was working, but I worked in Tucson, so then when I came here I stopped working, and I don't have my car here, so I don't know how to get to a job.
SPEAKER_01
What intri So we we employ we're employing obviously younger and younger people as we get older and older, like your dad used to be your age at one point, which is probably shocking to you.
SPEAKER_00
But um years ago.
SPEAKER_01
Many back when the dinosaurs roamed the planet. But like what these days, like what do you look for in a job? Like, how could an a boring insurance agency, like what would be there that would intrigue you?
SPEAKER_00
In an insurance agency?
SPEAKER_01
Yeah, or just in any job. Like if you go out on an interview, like what do you look for?
SPEAKER_00
Well, my last job, I was a gymnastics coach, and I thought, like, I like doing that because I did gymnastics for so long, but also because like it wasn't just a job where you had to like sit at a desk all day or just like stand in a place and like talk to people. Like I was like moving around and like talking to people all the time, and I thought that was fun. So I think that like that aspect of it where like I just don't want to like sit down all day.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, I don't sit all day long.
SPEAKER_00
I never said you sat all day long.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_01
I'm just saying. Not anymore. You did at one point before the stand-up desk became cool. Oh man, I I made the stand-up desk cool. But I mean, I it seems to me like that a lot of younger people are, and I say younger people like an old person, but um are looking more for like company culture and perks, benefits other than pay. Like if you had to sit at a desk all day for 25 bucks an hour, or if you could do something that you thought was like really cool with some cool people for 20 bucks an hour, you'd probably go 20 bucks an hour, right?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So what are what are some things that intrigue you? Like what if you could give old people at desk job advice, what would you give them for somebody like you and your friends, for your friends? Okay, so if you had to work for Craig, right? Old dad, and and he said you have your job is to hire people like your friends, which he should have asked you as a I have, but we're gonna replay that conversation. Okay, perfect. How could he entice your friends to work for his boring office?
SPEAKER_00
Um I feel like like all of my friends too, like think the same way as me, like they want to have something that's fun to them. Yeah. So I mean, if you just like sell it like it's gonna be like really fun, like you can like have these benefits or whatever, and like more freedoms to do what you want, like time freedom, or more of like activity freedom, like creativity with it, I guess. Then that would be more intriguing.
SPEAKER_01
Interesting.
SPEAKER_02
Well, so okay, a lot of this job is is making calls over the phone, and uh or at least traditionally, right? It's been making calls over the phone. Now with social media, you can actually connect with potential prospects by you know through messenger or like offering a job to one of my friends where it was like a social media, like someone who controls the social media, that would be like interesting for people, I think.
SPEAKER_00
Or just things that like our generation is more involved with.
SPEAKER_02
So what are some of those things besides social media? Um in social media like advertising, and then maybe like building your network like online, and then like do podcasts, they're pretty cool, pretty cool it does allow us to make a lot of things 100 top 100 marketing podcasts in the nation. Ah, look at that. True story. So as a um what let's let's say you were searching out insurance, like as a as a consumer. So now you're not on the worker side, but you're a consumer. What would you look for? Like if if I wasn't gonna help you, if you had to go figure it out, how would you connect with a with a company and what would you be looking for? Would it not matter or would it doesn't matter? Would you want to talk with somebody that knew what they were talking about? You know, dive into that a little bit.
SPEAKER_00
I feel like when I whenever I like get something new or sign up for something, I always just look at the reviews and like base my decision off of the reviews.
SPEAKER_01
Online.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
Um yeah. What about um we just talked to somebody about doing uh video like actually sending out like video proposals? Do you think that would help if somebody sent you a video with a screenshot and said, Hey, listen, we just talked about this, about this insurance. This is these are all the coverages that you would get. Hey, I know it's super boring, but like if this happened, this is what would well and and I just wanted to give you this video so that you can show your friends. And if anybody, you know, if you have any questions, hit me up later.
SPEAKER_00
Do you think that would help a little bit more than just more interesting than like reading an email or just getting like a long message that no one really wants to read?
SPEAKER_02
Right. That's what Todd said. Nobody nobody wants to read the text. I don't want to read the text.
SPEAKER_00
I feel like if you open an email and it's a bunch of words, then you usually just like out of it.
SPEAKER_01
I agree. I agree. It's so funny that people always do things like in business, like a certain way, and then they go and act a certain way as a consumer and don't go put the dot, connect the dots. I don't want to read anything.
SPEAKER_02
You know what I mean? Like he doesn't want to read books, he just gets he gets the books on Audible, which now he's taught me, and now I that's what I do. I don't read anymore. I have all these books, it's too much work. It's way too much work. You can't look at other things.
SPEAKER_00
I think that's why like Instagram is so popular for advertising and stuff, because it's not reading stuff, it's like seeing a picture that like catches your eye, and then you like want to look at more.
SPEAKER_02
What what kind of picture captures your eye?
SPEAKER_00
Well, for me, like right now, like shopping and stuff, like when I see like clothes, I always get sponsored clothes and like random stuff like that, and then I'll always click on it. Or yesterday I got an ad for this like hoodie. It's a huge hoodie, but it's a blanket.
SPEAKER_02
Just what you need.
SPEAKER_00
I know, and then I sponsored it to like three of my friends.
SPEAKER_02
That's a snuggie.
SPEAKER_00
No, it's not a snuggy.
SPEAKER_02
It's like she has a snuggy, I think.
SPEAKER_00
I don't like that.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_00
It's like a really big hoodie, but it's like super thick, like a blanket. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01
It sounds like they were watching some snuggy infomercials.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah.
SPEAKER_01
So here's a random question. Um so what kind of dude do you think you're gonna marry, and how are you gonna scare your dad? Like, what kind of dude do you look for? And then I want Craig's response.
SPEAKER_00
Oh, I have a boyfriend already.
SPEAKER_01
And and by the way, I have that. What's that?
SPEAKER_00
I have a boyfriend. I think my dad fix him.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, Grayson is awesome. She helped me fix her car that she crashed.
SPEAKER_00
He's here.
SPEAKER_02
Grayson's there, yeah. Hey Grayson, poke your head around. What's up? How's it going, buddy?
unknown
Good.
SPEAKER_01
Look at it the whole time. Yeah. Oh, perfect. Trying to make her uncomfortable. That's what I'm trying to do with Craig. It's perfect. Nothing phases me. Oh. Don't challenge. Don't challenge. Well, happy birthday. Thank you so much for coming on and giving us some insight to the dude. Yeah. There's a lot of older older insurance guys uh older than Craig out there.
SPEAKER_02
You're not gonna believe this, but there's ones older than me.
SPEAKER_00
No way.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, yeah. Jason's almost as old as me. Yeah, but not. So there's that. No. He does have a sleeve. Should I get a sleeve like Jason?
SPEAKER_00
Should I get a sleeve like Jason?
SPEAKER_02
Ah. Oh. Good one. No sleeves. I got the nose ring.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, you like it?
SPEAKER_01
That's great. That's awesome. I used to have a nose ring in plugs and stuff, and my daughter's. What is this? Like, what's this hole? God, yeah. I used to wear eyeliner at one point, too. Horrible. Horrible. Oh boy.
SPEAKER_02
Well, I was a musician. You've just been on Coffee Talk. If there was one thing, if there was one thing that you could tell insurance agency, old, boring insurance agents, to attract people like you and your friends as buyers, what would that be?
SPEAKER_00
I don't know, really. Just like in a way, I feel like the biggest way is just like capture our attention. That's the most important part. Because then like for me, usually like once I see something, then I just want it right away. So if I see something that I like, or that's like, oh, that sounds good, then I'll just get it.
SPEAKER_02
Perfect. Must be nice to have a Magic American Express card.
SPEAKER_00
You can't use that anymore.
SPEAKER_02
Oh, that's right. I did. I cut her off. So thank you. No, that's that's helpful. And and I think that that your uh I don't know speaks volumes because insurance isn't something that is on your mind or your friend's mind. And so the only way to make it something that's on your mind is to make it something that will catch capture the attention, right? It would have to be something interesting.
SPEAKER_01
I have one more question. Do you care to ever own a house or a car, or would you rather just rent them and pay a like a monthly fee?
SPEAKER_00
I think for a house I'd rather rent it, but for a car, I'd rather buy it.
SPEAKER_01
I would have thought you would have said renting on both. Well, I think more and more people are going renting Yeah. People just don't care to own that much anymore.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, I I read that about like millennials and stuff that more and more people are renting houses.
SPEAKER_01
Yeah. All right. That's just just the thought. Happy birthday. Thank you. Happy birthday. Be good.
SPEAKER_02
Grayson, be good. What's up for? I'll be great. All right. Thank you. Love ya.
SPEAKER_00
Love you.
SPEAKER_02
Bye. Good meeting ya. 55% of insurance sales producers say that they have had little or no sales of training. Us agents focus on marketing to drive activity and often overlook the sales presentation. Improvements in mindset, shifting focus, rapport, needs diagnosis, value building, creating buy-in, and overcoming objections lead to drastically better closing numbers. The solution? Enroll your team in September sales summit offered by Agency Vault. We will even assess your team to see which of their sales devs need the most improvement. Head to agencyvault.com to sign up before it's full.
SPEAKER_01
Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.