The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
$100,000,000 Agency Monster Growth Secret | Open Your GloveBox It’s Andy and Ryan Mathisen
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
And action.
SPEAKER_02Who's doing what? Hey Jason.
SPEAKER_05Craig? Guess what? Guess what? I would love to know why you tell me.
SPEAKER_03Well, we got the hundred million dollar agency monster growth secret. Open your glove box. Open your glove box. It's Andy and Ryan. Matheson.
SPEAKER_05I'm gonna take a big old bite of that. Buckle up, it's the insurance dudes podcast.
SPEAKER_02Alright. Well, welcome. Welcome. Drew Llewellyn. We had Trey Llewellyn.
SPEAKER_00And actually, it's uh reading as Drew Llewellyn, but that's just our company's Zoom account. I'm Andy and Ryan. So Ryan Matheson. I need to change how that reads actually right now.
SPEAKER_05I'm Stampson. This is uh Delilah.
SPEAKER_01Uh three. Perfect. Absolutely Delilah. You can call me Dr. Leonard Cabinet if you want.
SPEAKER_04You can actually change it like that.
SPEAKER_03There's somebody lurking back there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, he's checking out our he's testing out our new floating selfie stick. It's fantastic. Floating? Oh the I see, yeah, the one where you yeah. Does it work well? Oh, it's awesome. It shoots like really nice 4K video and it's like doesn't bounce. It's like very smooth, so it's it's pretty cool. It was a hundred bucks.
SPEAKER_05Is it called smooth or something like that? What is it?
SPEAKER_04Move. Smooth? It's called the gimbal. Oh, the gimbal. The gimbal. I thought it was called the smooth move. The smooth move.
SPEAKER_01I think it should be.
SPEAKER_04That's not for everyone.
SPEAKER_03Hey Xlax, you gotta pay up mention.
SPEAKER_00Are you getting this? Are you recording over there? Perfect.
SPEAKER_03I gotta open the door. My office is like an oven. So I have to periodically open and close my door.
SPEAKER_01How hot is it in Arizona right now?
SPEAKER_03I don't know.
SPEAKER_01It's just too hot. It's not pants weather, I'll tell you that much. It's no pants weather.
SPEAKER_03Shorts. Ever since like late May, it's been shorts. I just can't I can't do it. And I think people don't trust you if they come in the office and and you're wearing a suit. Like I just it's it's flipped, right? That that whole suit mentality is just is out the door.
SPEAKER_01Somewhere in a career path, you went wrong if you're still wearing a suit. Like something went wrong somewhere. We were talking about that earlier. Yeah. Somewhere you went wrong.
SPEAKER_00Do you remember the suit shorts? Are we gonna pull that back out?
SPEAKER_01I like the suit shorts. I'm sure it exists.
SPEAKER_05I've been trying to get, we work with a life specialist here, and he he wears suits all the time. I've been trying to get him into suit shorts. Like that's the look.
SPEAKER_00White one classy, or maybe some suit leggings.
SPEAKER_01Can you go full cutoff? Like the muscle shirt suit?
SPEAKER_03What about the tuxedo t-shirt?
SPEAKER_01Oh can't go wrong.
SPEAKER_03The classic, right?
SPEAKER_01It's seven days a week. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00We might want to pull that off at the insurance conference here in a month. That would be awesome. That would actually be a good idea. Some branded glove box, you know, t-shirts.
SPEAKER_01I like it.
SPEAKER_03So you did you guys come from the insurance world?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. So we built a uh we built about a hundred million dollar agency here in Colorado uh over the past nine years. About 95% personalized, and we just sold it uh about two weeks ago. So a hundred bucks.
SPEAKER_00It's an easy way out.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. Okay. So about a hundred million. Yeah. What was the number?
SPEAKER_01It was like 98 million in premium. Nice. How long? About nine years.
SPEAKER_00Okay. That's totally a new year. So we had about 120 agents, independent agents, and a small inside sales team of about 10. So we had uh they were like 1099 agents under you guys.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_00Yep. Yep. Family agency. Uh our pop started it about 25 years ago, but it really only grew to about 5 million um in the 15 years that it was uh around. And then Ryan and I came in about a Ryan was about a decade ago, and I was seven years ago.
SPEAKER_03So when did you decide that you wanted to scale it to that kind of level?
SPEAKER_00Boy, it was all in the marketing.
SPEAKER_01Um, it just kind of happened organically. We just started running, and then it was like, oh my god, this thing won't stop. And then Sean, our our X Flex guy back here, he uh he was one of our top agents. This guy was doing like a million three a year in new premium. This guy was an animal, and just home and auto insurance was nuts.
SPEAKER_03From what? Leads or internet?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, mortgage brokers. We became kind of the guru with mortgage brokers. We just we were in every major mortgage shop in Colorado, and we just you know, we'd get them drunk, take them golfing, and they would just send the deals.
SPEAKER_03So you'd be the party guys, go out with all the the dudes, and then they just send everything over.
SPEAKER_01Send everything, yeah. Yeah, then you get them with their processors, feed them booze. It's just it's it's just it's a spiral. It was a spiral, and so it just grew like crazy.
SPEAKER_05So that was the primary primary source right there.
SPEAKER_00What was yeah, I'd call it about 80, 80, 90 percent of our leads were come the door that way. And then admittedly, it was just the fact that you know the market got to know who we were and they enjoyed who we were as as agents, and uh we were just crushing it. It was fun. How were you and what did they like? Uh you want to know what's funny? I started when I uh when I was 25 years old, and I used to tell people I was 30 because I was you know, I can't you can't get away with that when you're 24, 25 years old. So I would uh kind of lie to them, I'm 30, you know, and then like, all right, whatever. Uh but no, like you know, you go out with these guys, like you said, have drinks, golf, all that good stuff, and so they just they enjoy that, you know.
SPEAKER_05So now did you guys actually enjoy golf? I I always ask people he loves golf.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, loves golf. The problem with golf is if you're not good at golf, it's not a good forum to showcase yourself. Like it's hard to sell someone that you're good at business, but you just hit three houses. Like it's hard to like trust that person.
SPEAKER_00And they're like holding your whole never one up, man. It's been like a five-hour round, and you're you're the reason.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, that's a good point. So here's another question is uh so so you actually did you actually enjoy golf and were you sober or were you drinking?
SPEAKER_01Always drinking.
SPEAKER_00Depends on the company.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would never I would never play golf and and not drink. That's for that's for the pros. Leave it to the pros to just play sober golf. That's not me. What about you? I mean, do you do you play sober golf?
SPEAKER_05I I I don't play golf because I just find it incredibly boring, but I also don't drink. Oh so I think that there you go.
SPEAKER_00For you, yeah, at that point.
SPEAKER_03So I I used to play a lot of golf, but at the same time, I also drank a lot. And then when I when I stopped drinking, stopped golfing.
SPEAKER_00Correlation. Okay, I don't think so.
SPEAKER_03There is a heavy correlation between golfing and drinking, unless you're pro.
SPEAKER_00See, I can hit the crap out. John Daly. Yeah, John Daly. I can hit the crap out of the ball, but it's not going straight. I mean, I can 300 yards boomerang 300 yards, who knows?
SPEAKER_03You know, whatever works. It's amazing how it can do that.
SPEAKER_01Just take that hard right. It's crazy how like one time it's right, and then the next time it's left. Right. This is not, you know, this is not consistent whatsoever. I could at least suck one way, but no, I suck both ways. Right.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no consistency.
SPEAKER_01Which don't quote me on that, by the way.
SPEAKER_03That'd be a bad quote.
SPEAKER_05We'll put that in the show notes. I think I might not like golf even more because of the fact that my wife gets so mad at me when I leave to go golf instead of work and she's home with the kids. I think that might have something to do with that.
SPEAKER_03You hit the nail on the head. Well, it's too long. It's five hours. I mean, what the hell? Plus the the drive there and the drive back, so it can be a six or seven, and then a bar afterwards, eight hours. I mean, it's a full day. Nine holes is plenty.
SPEAKER_05Then there's three full days of recovery from the the wife getting pissed.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I mean, it's not about getting away from the kids, is it? Wink wink. Um, no, no, and admittedly, uh, I don't know. I like golf, so I try and get out as much as possible.
SPEAKER_05No, it's good. It's good. I always joke around because it's some people love golf.
SPEAKER_01Our one of our business partners, he wears a knee breaks golfing. He loves it so much. I didn't know you could get injured.
SPEAKER_05So good. That's funny. So you were talking well, okay. So you were talking about how um how you're 25, you're pretending that you're 30. Take us through the journey too, because I I think a lot of people that are listening probably are like you know, there are a lot of insurance agents, they want to scale and they they're hearing your numbers and um probably drooling right now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Um, admittedly, my role was a little bit different within the agency. Um, I was the marketing guy, I wasn't the agent. So I had an inside sales team who was just quoting and selling the insurance while I was out in the field all day, every day, um, hitting up 10 offices, mortgage offices a day. I got to know my route, I got to know my people. It wasn't no longer about insurance, it was just about who I am and getting to know these people and having relationships with 150 mortgage brokers. So eight hours a day, five days a week, out every day visiting these people, getting to know them. And admittedly, I didn't even have to ask anymore. They were just giving me I was getting seven to ten leads a day. So I'd get them into my team from each or from oh total that day. So I would get you know seven to ten a day. I'd get them over to my team of seven to ten agents, they would sell them at close 80% of the time. We were writing a lot of premium every day. So wow.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's awesome.
SPEAKER_00It was enjoyable for four years, and then I got sick of it. So pivoted over to a manager role, uh, so on and so forth. Someone took over that internal marketing. So remind me how many producers you were feeding. Uh for my personal team, it was about 10 inside sales reps, but we had a team of about 120. At the end of this thing, we had about 120 independent agents that were doing the same thing for themselves. So they were generating the leads and selling their own home and auto.
SPEAKER_03Well, at what point does there become how are there that many lenders?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. I mean, the housing market out here is insane. So, and what we would do is teach our outside agents to go develop their own markets. And that I think that's probably one of the biggest um training pieces for agents, you know, ones that are calling quoting selling and marketing, doing the whole show themselves is is committing to the marketing plan. That's what we see with agents. You know, they'll go out once, they'll meet a couple lenders, and then they won't go out again. And they expect, oh, you know, I met Gary and Gary doesn't send me any deals, and what's going on? It's like you got to see Gary 10 times over the next three months to earn Gary's business. And it just takes a while. So it's um it's definitely a process. That's what we see. The biggest faux pas with agents is just the inconsistency in marketing. They just stop doing it. And even when you get busy, you got 10 lenders sending you deals, they'll go, Oh, I'm so busy, I don't have to go market anymore. And then once it runs dry, they're like, Oh, back to square square zero again.
SPEAKER_03They forgot about you. So you have to continue to hit them.
SPEAKER_01You got to keep seeing it, man. They want to see your face. It's it's a weird anomaly in today's tech world where the face-to-face, shake your hand, talk about your kids is valuable in marketing.
SPEAKER_03So how how long does did it take to start to get results? Like if you, you know, like you go in the first day and you say hi. I mean, obviously, you don't get something the next day.
SPEAKER_00I mean, honestly, I was all about meeting the person at the top of the food chain. So if we're getting really good with the branch manager and you get on his level, his or her level, I mean, you're gonna work your way down and they're gonna meet you, they're gonna introduce you to the whole team. I mean, I would always be adamant about getting in front of a sales meeting, speaking very well at those meetings, engaging, not just talking about who I am and what my company's all about, but bringing value, you know, talking about the industry, talking about pitfalls of the industry, talking about things they can do better to help their clients within their process. Things like that bring value. That's what makes you stand out. It's not about just showing up every day, but you got to bring that extra value.
SPEAKER_01So and it's a 90-day, it's a 90-day plan of meeting as many lenders as possible, weeding out the ones that you don't fit with personality-wise. You meet those people and you're like, nah, this is not gonna be a good fit. This person's gonna try to walk all over me. It's not worth it. Or, you know, they're crabby and it's just not worth it. You know, there's plenty of lenders that will think you're awesome, that would love to, you know, go drink beers or whatever it's you're gonna do, go go-karting. We've got agents that take them to the movies, like you'd be shocked the activities that they'll do with their lenders, but it's just finding those lenders that you find a cohesion with and you know, narrowing down your funnel, but it's a 90-day plan, and you gotta stick to it, and you gotta hammer LinkedIn, you gotta be really good at LinkedIn, uh, create your brand, and uh, it literally is foolproof. Like it works if you just do it.
SPEAKER_03So that's the problem. People don't like to do stuff. They don't like yeah.
SPEAKER_01I was listening to the uh, did you guys hear the Grant Cardone and uh Wolf of Wall Street, Jordan Belfort uh podcast that came out the other day? No. Best quote from Cardone, he goes, People want the abs, but they don't want to do the workout. It's like it was perfect, right? It's you know, that's and the workout isn't that hard.
SPEAKER_03I mean, just do 50 sit-ups a day, right? If they're consistent, yeah, it takes two minutes, right?
SPEAKER_00Two minutes.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, but literally two minutes. I go to Orange Theory almost every day. So I do I actually do a lot of sit-ups, and I don't get I have the abs, but they're buried under the ice under the yeah, under the K. But you know they're there. You know, they are there, they have they're under about an inch.
SPEAKER_01There you go. Yeah, if you have a chance to check out that podcast, it was pretty pretty amazing.
SPEAKER_00And Ryan mentioned uh about the LinkedIn piece. It's for us, it's big. We pitch that a lot. Um, we get what are you gonna call our our podcast about our internal podcast about six months ago, the insurance brothers? Is that what you called it? Yeah, uh, because we were brothers, obviously. We had an insurance brothers podcast, if you will, on LinkedIn. We're hitting home on LinkedIn every single day about your brand. It it means everything. You gotta stick with it. You can't post once a month and expect any results. You gotta develop something different from the the marketplace. And so um we are adamant about that. We trust and believe in it, and we utilize it every day. So more so than Facebook.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, way more so. Way more Facebook's only good for birthdays, birthdays and and talking to your wife when you're sitting right next to her, like saying happy anniversary to your wife when you're sitting right next to her. Like, I'll never on Instagram. That is an anomaly to me. I don't get it. Like you're sitting right next to her. Yeah, you get a little email, you get the little uh can't yell at you when you're uh just texting, but it's frowned upon if you don't do it, it's like not getting them a card, it's like frowned upon.
SPEAKER_05Well, I mean it you I mean it's strictly B2B, so B2B is all LinkedIn.
SPEAKER_01You and I think that's what agents miss they're they're so thirsty for their next deal, which I get in the beginning, but you've got to look at where are the faucets? How do I turn on the faucets? You know, what's pumping the water in? You want to get to those referral partners that are gonna send deals, you know. They're on the Ferris wheel. They're on the Ferris wheel, and they're they're sending deals every single day, like clockwork. And then you're not working so hard. You're not buying internet leads and chasing those people around. And you know, every year they want to reshop on, you know, on whatever website you found them on. It's like when these people are buying homes, they're not they're not even thinking about insurance. Insurance is just a speed bump for them to buy that house. So now you have an emotional sale tied to insurance, and as long as your rate is good and your coverages match, they're gonna buy and they're gonna stick with you because they're homeowners and they tend to be a little bit more stable, and so your retention goes up. It's just a better way of running a business.
SPEAKER_03And then you get their cars, right?
SPEAKER_01Because they like you. Yep, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Umbrella, the whole nine, selling some life insurance, life insurance because they have a it's that it's that event, right? It's a huge event to purchase that first house.
SPEAKER_01Yep, yeah. You're literally hitting them at a point of of need, and it's great. Your agency did it all.
SPEAKER_05Did you guys you led with home and then you it's all personal lines?
SPEAKER_00We were actually all about uh home and auto bundling right away. We typically didn't like monoline homes, you know, it doesn't retain very well, and you're probably gonna forget about cross-selling if you don't get on it right away. So we were all about bundling right away. So that being said, uh, we actually didn't do life in-house, we just did the home and auto piece. Um, and so I we felt like that was the best bet. And commercial came later on, but uh 95% personal lines.
SPEAKER_03You could have funneled all those life policies down to Arizona. Oh god.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if we had a nickel, right? We take the Gary Keller approach. I don't know if you've read The One Thing, Gary Keller, he uh created Keller Williams, he wrote a great book called The One Thing, and it talks about just doing one thing and doing it really, really well. And so that's kind of the mentality that we took. Yeah, just home and auto and let's do a bunch of it. And so we got so good at it, it's just you know, it's second nature.
SPEAKER_05I think that is a hundred percent the problem with um we're we're from the captive world, and they do want us to do everything. Yeah, you know, but I mean if you're gonna do it that way, then you have to have like departments specifically for it. Like have the person that's the expert at that and do it well. So and then you can quantify it.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, I mean, you can't you can't sell home an auto and then put your mutual funds hat on and try to sell them a home loan. And it's like, where what what were we talking about again? Where are we at? It's like geez. Save my car while I'm at it, you know.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, that's crazy. I mean, I that uh the amount that you guys were able to scale is crazy awesome.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was fun when we started hitting a million dollars a month. That was probably the the point in which we know we knew it was working well and we wanted to grow as quickly as possible, get on as many agents as we could.
SPEAKER_03So so with that kind of growth, you may not have had processes in place and and the systems already, or did you?
SPEAKER_01No, I mean, we were we were really, I mean, we hit a lot of growing pains, as you can imagine, especially on the service side. I mean, service in the independent space is very labor intensive. And, you know, especially as time goes on here, the on-demand expectations of consumers with the antiquated processes that or technologies that are currently in place, they don't align, right? So it is it's a strain. And we went through growing pains of you know, uh, how many calls were we dropping today? Uh, let me quantify this for you. We had about 100,000 clients, and we were getting roughly 13 to 14,000 phone calls a month for service. It was insane. Yeah, and how many calls were they dropping, Andy? Not on purpose, but a couple hundred a day. Absolutely couldn't even answer, couldn't even answer. It was like a telethon, it's like we were giving away free candy.
SPEAKER_03The system couldn't handle the capacity at which the phone the calls were coming in, just couldn't hire fast enough.
SPEAKER_01You know, it's hard to keep CSRs anyway for you know what you can pay them and the demands of the job, and it's we just couldn't staff up fast enough to to uh handle that catch up to the sell. You know, we just um we we retained the business that we could and we continued to sell and uh you know our our service team eventually caught up. It was just kind of uh sell first service later mentality, and that's that's the way we went.
SPEAKER_03I guess it's a good challenge to have, right? That you're growing so fast you can't service the people if you're gonna have a challenge. I'd rather have that than too many service people, yeah, not enough new biz coming in.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the only problem with it is you know, how easy it is to review people online, you know, it's very easy to ruin your reputation. And so that's it's tough, it's a balancing act, it's really hard.
SPEAKER_03So did so, did you guys get really good at at acquiring new CSRs or did you get better at the hiring process, or how'd you hone that?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's interesting. We actually used um a predictive predictable index uh assessment that was really helpful and making sure we had the right people on board. Now, a customer service rep is typically a different type of person. They're not money motivated, they have a shelf life, but admittedly, we just found the right mix, the right equation, if you will, from this assessment that allowed us to hire the right people. It gave us a longer shelf life and and probably a more stable culture and team. Uh, we had what 25 to 30 uh customer service reps by the end of that thing.
SPEAKER_01Any one time, yeah.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03I thought a lot of indie shops don't they don't go straight to the carrier for well you you you can, but think about this.
SPEAKER_01So let's say a client's with nationwide, right? And you say, hey, we're just gonna have a nationwide service this account. What happens when nationwide's rates go up? They're just gonna send them right back to you because you they can't shop through SafeGo or Travelers or Progressive or Hardford or State Auto or Auto Owners, or the whole portfolio. So, you know, reshopping is a whole nother uh service task that dominates the independent channel, and captives don't have to deal with that, right? So but That's how we keep our business. I mean, we're not just tied to one carrier. So that really made it difficult to rely on the service center, the carriers, because that reshop is such a big factor.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we so we have to explain the value of what we do and why it's important to stay with us and why the rates go up, that whole conversation. And you guys go, Well, yeah, no problem. Here, yeah, here, but but there's this whole new set of work with maybe not any additional revenue.
SPEAKER_01It's a new sale. Every time once someone wants a reshop, you're reselling them on the product. It's a brand new company. Maybe we're splitting it up now. Oh man, you know, hail hit Colorado, and now your home rate shot through the roof, but your auto still looks good. So let's keep your auto in nationwide and now we're gonna rent your home with travelers because it looks good. Uh hence where Globox was born. Yeah. So, like, yeah, it's it's just an interesting thing. What about that? Go ahead, Andy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Globebox was mainly um kind of brought to light because of the fact that clients were sick of calling in to the agencies trying to take care of the things that are so basic that we wanted to empower them to go access their policies on their own. Um, agents don't want to pick up the phone either, by the way, to handle these things. They don't make money from it, it waste time during during their day. Uh so regardless of the carrier you're with, you can access your policies, home auto, umbrella, uh toys, renters' policies, whatever you need. Um, and what's gonna come down the pipe here is paying a bill, initiating a claim, uh, getting connected to a vendor if you do have a claim. There's a lot of things that we're looking forward to that are coming down the pipe, but the original concept just being let's stop wasting time servicing or taking care of these service tasks that are so basic that a client can do on their own. Now, the other piece of it is that the the carrier portals are out there and that you can certainly utilize those, but um it's been mentioned that hey, if your homes with progressive and your auto's with Safeco, you know, then you have to have two apps and I have to go to two different portals and it's obnoxious. Um, and so you switch companies every year and you don't know who's who and what carrier am I with. And is the independent agency my carrier? I don't know. Um some clients are confused on what that's all about. So that's kind of why Glove Box was brought to light.
SPEAKER_05And and maybe tell us a little bit about Glove Box, like what does it look like?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean, we develop Glove Box with you know being at the epicenter of hearing the clients' frustrations, the agency frustrations, and really hearing or and also seeing the position that the carriers are in currently. You know, the carriers are taking a taking a stance that they are going to rely heavily on the agencies to handle the service work. That's their mantra. Uh what happens is and kind of what we alluded to is just the overwhelming amount of service work that's it's being put on the agency owners. 90% of it is things that could be handled with technology. Um, and and so we create a glove box with the agency in mind to take this off their plate, make them look good, make it branded, allow them to cross-sell, allow them to communicate with their consumers with a product that their consumers actually want to use and like to use and make it easy, right? Insurance is a thing you hate, but you want it to work when you need it. And if it doesn't work when you need it, that's you know, that's trouble for everybody. And so we really created Glove Box to make it just super simple. Access your documents, pay your bill, report a claim, feel good about the agency you're with without having to communicate with the agency you're with, right? And so that you know, there's so much value in that. We always talk to these agency owners and they're like, Well, I really like to service my own clients. And it's like, do you though? Like, do you like the Johnson's calling you on a Sunday afternoon because they need their auto ID card because they got pulled over? Do you really like doing that? These and and so much in insurance we see is is agents sell in service, right? They do everything. And you can't be jack of all trades. You cannot be that. Think of the you know, the the time spent on service work and the opportunity costs wasted by these agency owners by having all to do all this service work, those are policies that you could be selling. You could be selling more insurance and making more money. Carriers are dropping commissions, especially on the captive side. We know that. And overhead's going up, right? Yeah, anything we can do to sell our insurance and make more money, we're in. And so all of these things are coming into play as we're developing this product.
SPEAKER_03You can't create more time, you know, and the the agent that that that whole business model of the agent servicing the people because it makes them feel warm and fuzzy. I mean, if you're if you're not replacing that activity with either a $12 an hour or an app, right? A zero dollar an hour thing, then that's insanity.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you can't grow a multi-million dollar book of business that way. Right.
SPEAKER_03I mean, you can keep your million-dollar book of business what you do. Absolutely. That's plateau would happen.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and as your commissions go down and overhead goes up, your take home just starts dwindling away, and and now you're just spinning your wheels, you know.
SPEAKER_03It seems like whether in the captive world or in the indie world, the the focus now is on growing these enormous agencies. Yep. Right? And with that scale, you have to create automation. Yep.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And so we're the first ones to be directly connected to the carriers to be able to pass information back and forth.
SPEAKER_03Um you're connected to all of the ones that uh uh indie would be normalized of hearing.
SPEAKER_01We're working on it. It is a process, yeah, it's another for sure. Yeah, it's it's it's a new idea for these carriers. It's a brand new idea, and so kind of easing them into the lot of departments involved. You've got the billing department, the legal department, you've got the automation department, you've got the claims department, and you know.
SPEAKER_00And they don't talk to each other, so you gotta figure out.
SPEAKER_03Of course not first.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so yeah, that's with the industry being so antiquated, so are the carriers and their decisions. So we want to make sure they understand that yet there's in sure tech and there's carriers, and then we got to meet in the middle. That's where the clients want to be. Um, and so we gotta, and they they are starting to pick up on that. So that's been fun, fun conversation.
SPEAKER_01It's it's pretty funny. Um, just some of our conversations we've had lately. We'll meet with a carrier, and uh there's a huge discrepancy when you look at portal adoption between the independent channel and the captive channel. You know, everybody knows State Farm, Allstate, American Family Farmers, and USA. Everybody knows those brands. Very simple. I buy from Allstate, I download their app, simple, simple. It's an easy relationship. So we were at a carrier uh about a month ago, and we're kind of showing them these numbers, and I'm comparing it to Geico, right? So we go on iOS, their Apple app, and we're looking at Geico. Geico has 1.5 million reviews on their Apple app. So, you know, that's going to equate to users, right? They have users. Allstate has like 450,000 reviews on their app. So obviously, they have a lot of users. We're talking to this carrier, and this is a $20 billion carrier, mind you. This is not a small carrier. Take a wild guess how many reviews they have on their app.
SPEAKER_0311.
SPEAKER_0140.
SPEAKER_03Oh, it's pretty close. 40 reviews.
SPEAKER_0140, 20 billion dollar carrier, 20 billion dollar carrier, and they have 40 reviews. And you go through this whole presentation of why this makes sense and what we're doing, and then they circle back and say, but we really love our app. Our app is just so good. It's a good thing. They love it. They love it.
SPEAKER_00They're spending so much time and money on this thing, but who's even looking at it? It's just like, I understand it. Your brand means a lot, but we could be better. Yeah, it could be better. So it's just it's tough. And here's the other thing you didn't or we don't think about is that the agents, the independent agents, are the ones who are supposed to be branding on behalf of the carrier, but they don't have time to do that. They're trying to sell policies and get through the next one. Um, yeah, we're taking care of the clients, we're moving on to the next. We're not taking time to brand the carrier on their behalf. Uh so that's something they got to think about too. So that's where Glove Box does come into play as well. We are going to be branding that specific carrier on the app for that client. So if I'm a if I have my auto with progressive, you're gonna see progressive all over that thing. Uh, you're gonna see your independent agency all over that thing. It's gonna be branded very well. It's gonna basically turn the glove box app into that agency's app into that carrier's app.
SPEAKER_05That's awesome. That's crazy. So, how many carriers do you guys have right now?
SPEAKER_01Right now we've got uh we have five committed, um, and then we're in development with another 10. So and then we're talking to, I mean, our list, we've got 75 independent carriers on our list right now that we're we're talking to. I mean, we can only develop so fast, so we're kind of staggering our development, but um, we're working as hard as we can to get as many carriers as possible to uh again to appease our our agencies. So that's so cool, man. Yeah, and the other thing is it live?
SPEAKER_03Is it live now?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03Okay.
SPEAKER_01We went live about a month ago. It's an MVP, minimum viable product. It's working, it's pulling docs. Um, we're making some nice enhancements. We'll be adding Apple Wallet here in about three weeks to be able to add your um your auto ID cards to Apple Wallet, which will be great, no matter what carrier you're with. Uh one little thing that's coming. We're we actually got referred to the Colorado DMV by the insurance commissioner, Rolf Kalman, here in Colorado. And we're working on being the first here in Colorado to offer uh digital vehicle registrations to your Golf Box, which I know exists in Arizona, I believe, and maybe California as well. I don't think so. Arizona, I think they do.
SPEAKER_03And you but you only renew when you're like 90. So my yeah, I got my license when I was 18 here, and it it's good till 2045.
SPEAKER_01So this would be like your vehicle registrations. You know, you get the little piece of paper you put it in your glove box. Yeah, we're so we're gonna be able to offer those digitally on Glove Box as well. So now when you get pulled over, you've got your insurance and your registration in your Apple wallet ready to rock and roll.
SPEAKER_00Again, it's just about the client and understanding what they want. They want this stuff, they're screaming for it. So we got to do something about it to make it happen, and it's all gonna be in one ecosphere.
SPEAKER_03Did you I I I'm sure I would I would assume you guys did a lot of market research beforehand. So you have data on you know the different cohorts of people. Yep. So those the millennials, like what is their position on like they will this this is the way they want things done.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you're speaking to a couple right now. So we have I love you guys.
SPEAKER_01Well, check check this out. I read a um a JD Power article the other day that was saying millennials, um, less than 50% of them are now bundling their insurance policies, and that's going down by about 3% a year, which means they're not just taking a package deal that's given to them because it's so easy to shop for insurance now. You know, you get root, you get hippo, you get lemonade, you get nobler. It's like, and they want to try out, you know, the new Tesla of insurance, which is root, you know, the usage-based, the metro mile. Um, so millennials and down are really, they're not just taking that package business that's being handed to them. They're, oh, that's a good home rate, but my auto rate's a little bit cheaper over here, or hey, this maybe fits my lifestyle a little bit better with the user-based product. And so we're seeing a lot of those separation now, that segmentation in products with carriers, where which is where Globox takes over. So we're not just the independent channel with these insure techs that are coming into play, we're gonna be a huge value for them as well.
SPEAKER_03What's the position of the of the millennials on agents? Like, do they feel there's a need?
SPEAKER_01With home insurance, yes. With home insurance, there's still that need there, right? Um, I mean, it's you know, that's a lot of we're still alive. And honestly, that's that's a huge philosophy of ours. You know, we're we were bred out of the agency channel, as we mentioned, and we want to preserve the agents. That's what we want to do. Can we keep the agents in place forever? Of course not. We all know that at some point it's gonna be automated, they're gonna figure out a way to earn the trust of the consumers to where an agent is not necessary. But if we can preserve the agents as long as possible, that is our goal.
SPEAKER_00Are you talking about Amazon by chance?
SPEAKER_01I may or may not. Talking about Walmart.
SPEAKER_00Tesla, I guess they're gonna jump.
SPEAKER_05Yeah. That's cool, man. I I love uh I love the name because it is it's old school, right? That was a big win.
SPEAKER_01Tell them about how we got the name, Andy.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was kind of fun. So uh we're just gosh, that by the way, this concept of glove box goes back three years, and we've been how many names have we had four or five different names?
SPEAKER_01But some stupid names.
SPEAKER_00What were the stupid ones? Coverage dashboard was one of them. Protection dash. Yeah, we thought like the concept is there, but we just got to grasp this thing. But anyways, we did some research uh research on what it would take to get Glove Box, and uh we found out that um how many years back? Uh six years ago, maybe uh Geico uh tried to take the name Glove Box and they initiated their app and it was similar, similar concept. Um marketing.
SPEAKER_01If you Google Glove Box, all the Geico stuff comes up. It's kind of funny.
SPEAKER_00This was trademarked by an individual out of uh New Orleans and he sued Geico and he won. And Geico cease that uh that work in progress. So they they don't have Glove Box, and this this gentleman out of New Orleans, we reached out to him on LinkedIn, actually Ryan did, and got his blessing to license us the trademark, the exclusive trademark for um glove box. So we have that we have that exclusive trade.
SPEAKER_03Did you have to buy the domain from him?
SPEAKER_01He doesn't own the domain. Yeah, surprisingly. Yeah, someone else owns the domain, he just has the trademark. How much do you have to pay for that domain? The guy was shifty, man.
SPEAKER_03It was interesting. There's a lot of people, that's their business models to buy domains.
SPEAKER_01And our worry about the domain, the domain's not a big deal. We're actually gloveboxbox.com. Yeah, like it doesn't really matter. We're waiting on one to come live on on GoDaddy and we're gonna snag it. We're just waiting for it. They're they're supposedly creating it right now. Are you talking about uh docs in a box right now?
SPEAKER_00We have docs in a box out there. Oh, nice. There you go. That's funny. Yeah, yeah, but it was a funny process getting the name, but it was a big win. Like you said, that's a good one. Uh that's probably you know the biggest reason why we know we're gonna why it's gonna work because it's easy to you know what's in it, right? What's in your glove box?
SPEAKER_01So yep. What do you guys see from the the captive side as far as like portal adoption? Do you see a pretty good number of clients utilizing the portal?
SPEAKER_05Yes. Okay, at least but but what we do a ton of internet stuff at my office. Um so they're already on the internet searching for searching for insurance and stuff. So that's how they want it. And to be totally honest, I mean, I I just don't see you just gotta look at what everybody's doing in general. It's all apps and buying with one button. I mean, it's that just makes sense. It's easier to adapt that, I think, than than not than to not.
SPEAKER_01Do you see areas where you sell that kind of you know, when you're when your auto product is is is not competitive? Do you guys see that a lot or your home products is not competitive? Um and then you kind of see monoline stuff, a lot of monoline stuff kind of coming into play.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we're always working towards the bundle. I mean, he in in California they can't write a lot of home. I mean, here we're always really focused on the bundle. I know in Colorado the the premiums on um on the company that we represent are a little bit tougher because of the roof issues up there. Yeah, there's a lot of hail. I mean, I know I don't know if you guys know Travis Turner, he's a agent up there that I talk to all the time, but um, and then Eddie Pacheco, and you know, so there's I know a lot of yeah, everybody knows both around in his FJ.
SPEAKER_01Actually, I think he just sold his FJ. Yeah, he had this little Toyota with his picture on the back.
SPEAKER_03I think he just got a Tesla, so you know must be doing all right. Like speaking of Tesla, like that's that's something that that Elon talked about a lot, is is how people respond to notifications. Like notifications are are almost the new text, yep. Right. So as you guys build out that app, like people really respond to notifications.
SPEAKER_01And I thought I talked about that billing piece or well, I was gonna ask, so do you guys see an opportunity for Globox to connect to the captives when you have monoline products? So like when you when you didn't sell the home, you only sold the auto, and so they had to go get their home somewhere else. Do you see an integration value of having that within the captive world?
SPEAKER_03If if you can knock on the door of the people who are in charge and and get them to move to action, I mean, I'll tell you right now, if if if if they used Glove Box instead, right? And I'll just say the company, sure. But if the company used uh Globox and you had the information on, okay, we didn't close them on the auto, we have the home, they're coming up for renewal now. So you have the X State and it shot a notification, said you're coming up for renewal with your current carrier. Here's a quote. I mean, are you kidding me?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, or what about what about paying them and saying, hey, by the way, you know, if we didn't mention we do life insurance as well when they're in need.
SPEAKER_03Like just not something excessive, but some little mini campaign that every now and then hits them with a I mean, I'd I'd be 100% all over that.
SPEAKER_01We're coming out with something called the feed, and the feed is going to allow our agency partners and our carriers, unique to that consumer, that specific policy holder, communicate with them. So you'll be able to post stuff to the feed, say, hey, by the way, did you know the John Smith agency does life insurance? Click here to get a quick quote. Or, hey, did you know we just added you know a really robust jewelry coverage policy that you can get, you know, click here to get a quote. Right. So it's going to be a way to communicate with your clients. Um, you know, in a way that we haven't seen before.
SPEAKER_03I think that would increase your retention and your development of your current book, right? Yeah, yep. Um, and then it's a cool, neat thing to have, so maybe it even helps with acquisition.
SPEAKER_05Yeah, I don't it's all I I think that the uh captive carriers wouldn't do it because as soon as their product, let's say the autos on the app, right? All this other thing, hey, your renewal's coming up, let's shop for it. It's like there's no way that because the captives want all the other products too. So they're that eliminates the need for that. Yep. So I I don't I don't think that that would work in the captive world because I think that they're trying to hoard everything they can.
SPEAKER_01It's kind of a double-edged sword because then if you don't do it, and then you've got someone who has glove box and they have their autosco, but they have their home that's called farmers. And farmers isn't on glove box, but SafeGo is. And so now they're like, oh, how easy is it to get a home quote? So you know it's kind of that double-edged sword where it's like damned if you do, damned if you don't. It's kind of fun when I'm fine line.
SPEAKER_05So I think if you built it big enough with all the other carriers, yeah, and then it was like uh we either join this, or as soon as they think that they're not gonna have as many sales, but if they think that it's jeopardizing sales, I'm sure that yeah, they look at data and they have all the data and they make databased decisions.
SPEAKER_03So if you could show them data that shows that look, you're gonna increase your revenue by X percent when you have it this way or what you've seen, then I think you have an argument. Yep, you know, yeah, but they don't like giving up the client that client information. You're you know, it's a no-no, no sharing, of course, right? And we never would, right, Jason? Never.
SPEAKER_01Never, never, ever. You know, another cool feature for our for our glove box agency product is gonna be uh to be able to refer your agent out and just a click of a button. So I if I'm sitting next to Andy, I'm talking about oh yeah, man, I bought insurance from this guy, it was super easy. Oh, send me his name and number. Oh, boom, there you go. That's awesome stuff.
SPEAKER_00Oh, it even says boom when you click it, it goes boom.
SPEAKER_06Yeah, boom, actually it's it's simpler going.
SPEAKER_05It's funny because a lot of these uh companies have had these apps for a while, including the company that we work for, and it's shocking that they don't have that. I know, right?
SPEAKER_00Like come on, it's fun, it's engaging.
SPEAKER_01Can you take say whatever X carrier that you're with and then make it the John Smith agency? Like, do they let you take the app and then brand it to your own agency? Do you guys have that? Well, I they didn't have our name and picture.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, okay. Yeah, and you can make your own outside app, but it can't it can't have the name of the carrier on it. So then you lose the power of the branding.
SPEAKER_01Interesting. So like we could white label you our product if we were connected to your carrier, but we can't mention the carrier. Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_05You can get the data. Interesting.
SPEAKER_03If they'll say yes, I mean, you know, there's the like agency zoom. Yeah, they've been allowed to integrate and and move data back and forth. I mean, there's a handful of approved vendors, right? I mean, but that's a fun process.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's a process for sure.
SPEAKER_03What do you mean?
SPEAKER_00What an industry, huh?
SPEAKER_03It is, I tell you.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so our biggest thing was just, you know, we just want to help evolve the industry, help improve the pitfalls and the the gaps that are in there right now. We just we over the course of the past decade that we were involved, it's just we noticed a few and it's time to capitalize on that, so we feel like we're doing that.
SPEAKER_05So yeah, it's awesome. I I love that. I love the concept. So a whole bunch of agents are listening right now. What would you what what is the each of you individually? What is the nugget of information that you would pass on to somebody with uh maybe a smaller agency and they're looking to grow? Any kind of wisdom through what you guys have been through.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Uh for me it's gonna always be that brand because if you're gonna stand out from the competition, it's gonna be for one reason. It's probably gonna be your persistency and how consistent you are with your marketing efforts and your brand. If you stick to that, you hold yourself to it, and you make sure you do that each and every day. At the end of a tenure career, you're gonna look back and say that was worth it. I, you know, it was annoying. I had to come up with content and be that brand got, you know, I didn't know what it was and evolved into something, but it really that's gonna be most important for you, most vital. That's what we did.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Mine's gonna be uh segmentation of duties. You know, stop having your salespeople service business. That is a bad road to go down. It'll never work. You're you'll never have to get insurance agents and you'll never have service reps because again, dancing between the the two of them, you just can't do both. Salespeople don't like to service, that's just the reality of it. You know, we hunt, we kill, we pass it along to get cooked, you know, and that's just kind of the reality of the business. So stop having your salespeople service.
SPEAKER_03And vice versa.
SPEAKER_01And vice versa. I mean, now train your service reps how to sell, because if they're especially in the independent channel, if they're remarketing, you're you're selling. And so they need to have sales skills, you know, and maybe they want to graduate into being an agent, but stop this, stop this sales and service madness. It's just it doesn't work. I've never met an agency where an agent was crushing it to doing both. Like you just can't do it. Like, go go market your ass off and sell a crap ton of insurance and let somebody else service it.
SPEAKER_03Well, that salesperson's best use of their time is on the phone closing the deal. I mean, they're probably marketing or that's what they wanted to do all along. That's what they came here for. So they're not give them the ball and let them run.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, go out of the forest. There you go. Yep, feed the beast.
SPEAKER_05Dude, it's crazy. There's a there's I don't know if I'm allowed to say this, I don't care. Uh, triple A out here. They've all they've always had uh you know a bunch of sales agents, they have like a direct sales unit. Now they're having their they're losing a ton of agents because they're making um well they're lowering their commissions, but they're also um giving them like two hours of service work a day. Like like they're going backwards, and it's crazy because to your point, salespeople don't want to do that and they're all leaving.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, they they think they're cutting costs, but they're actually losing sales, so right and personnel.
SPEAKER_03I mean, that's it. What's harder than selling? Yeah, getting producers, right?
SPEAKER_01I mean getting them to sell.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, convincing them that this is the best ever.
SPEAKER_01There's a captive, there's a major captive that is now allowing a major captive that's now allowing their agents to sell outside products. So now they're able to get independent contracts. And if the client doesn't fit with that captive, they're at sell outside products, which is uh, you know, it's it's it's a mess. It is a mess. Think about trying to service a captive market and then oh, but no, half my book is independent, and so now I have to service these people as well. Like that is that is a bad road to go down. Wow. Craziness. Yeah, it's crazy.
SPEAKER_03Well, cool. So, how could people find you guys online? Where do they go? Is it on box.com or what uh docs in a box?
SPEAKER_00No, yeah, that's just the that's the fun one. We're gonna have that eventually. But no, uh, we are on iOS mobile right now. Uh so your app store, head on in there and type in glove box for the first one that pops up. Uh check it out, connect to your carrier, let us know what you think. If you don't uh have your carrier in the app yet, because we're still working on it, let us know who that is. We'll email you when it's ready. And then, of course, the extra features that are coming out here in about 60 to 90 days. We're just working on right now phase two of development. Um, we also have an agency model. So if you're an agent and you want to learn more about how to brand you on our app, go to gloveboxapp.com backslash glove box agency, and we will be able to chat with you about what that looks like.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we'll stick that in the show notes so it's easy to click to. Um awesome having you guys. Yeah, all your success. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Thank you so much. And if you hit us up on LinkedIn and mention uh your guys' show, we'll give you 10% off uh your first year subscription to the Glove Box Agency. Boom! Look at that. And you guys have a sneak peek because uh we've got a waiting list of about 200 agencies right now, and we're about to cut it off for beta. So if you want to be an agency in beta, definitely get with us as soon as possible so we can get you on the list.
SPEAKER_02Cool.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, awesome.
unknownThank you.
SPEAKER_01Hey, thank you. Appreciate you guys. Thank you so much. It's been fun. Yeah, we're gonna have to cruise out to uh to Arizona and Cali and play some golf.
SPEAKER_03Pick me up, we'll drive out to Huntington Beach and hit the waves. Awesome, guys, yeah. Take care.
SPEAKER_05Okay, thank you. I didn't have a good one.
SPEAKER_03All right, but 55% of insurance sales producers say that they have had little or no sales and training. Us agents focus on marketing to drive activity and often overlook the sales presentation. Improvements in mindset, shifting focus, rapport, needs diagnosis, value building, creating buy-in, and overcoming objections lead to drastically better closing numbers. The solution? Enroll your team in September sales summit offered by Agency Vault. We will even assess your team to see which of their sales steps need the most improvement. Head to agencyvault.com to sign up before it's full.
SPEAKER_05Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman