The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Ryan Chao: Startup Agency Mentor Masterclass
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Do we have somebody to this tweet? We do, and it's agent then for masterclass. I'm gonna get my toe in and then get all this in this I'm gonna fizzle that thing around till it's a fizzle.
SPEAKER_01Okay, you wouldn't have the back even force value stage uh curse word.
SPEAKER_00That's a good question.
SPEAKER_01That's a good one too. I mean, I don't think you can have the curse word as the name of the movie. A movie Fox. Well, I mean, okay, it's some it could be it's the back room of a rental store, but but you know, not main room.
SPEAKER_03I'm suggesting that it likely is so you're if it's if it's uh if it's a cuss word and a title, then that negates the actual meaning of the word, right?
SPEAKER_01I think title of a mainstream movie, like you know, something that's at the regular movie theater. Right. Right.
SPEAKER_03Well say you maybe maybe the first to attempt that.
SPEAKER_00We are off to a killer start. Everybody's gonna be contemplating whether or not jackass or bitchin are curse words for the rest of the day. Everybody ask everybody.
SPEAKER_01Split on a poll.
SPEAKER_03Yep. Is poll a curse word? I don't know. I think I'm gonna start a new face group called the bitchin' jackasses.
SPEAKER_0110,000 members.
SPEAKER_03Right, you know, big time. It's all the name, buddy.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, high quality, just waiting to buy your stuff.
SPEAKER_03How are you doing, man? Man, I'm doing really well. I'm doing really well. Um man, I'm just in the thick of it getting this uh new agency up and uh running. And uh I didn't didn't you say, Jason, that you were you were gonna you were going to ECP as well?
SPEAKER_00Yes, October 1st.
SPEAKER_03Tell me about it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No. I mean, uh I'm doing the work, but am I ready? Not even close.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. If I could show you what my office looks like right now, it would be it would be a disaster. But uh it's organized, uh it's organized chaos. Is what it means.
SPEAKER_00What are you working on right now? What's the number one thing right now? Selling. Oh, when did you open?
SPEAKER_03I opened up September 1.
SPEAKER_00September 1. Gotcha. Fill in those pipelines.
SPEAKER_01Fill the pipeline, right? What's your what's your goal for for day one, September 1st?
SPEAKER_0380 items. We're on item 20 now. There you go. We're we've done it for two days. We've been up and uh selling for two days so far.
SPEAKER_01Are they they're not bound? They're and if we need to chop this out for any reason, then no, no, we're good.
SPEAKER_03Um, no, we're we're ready. We had payment on several. Um, but I will tell you that when they have to get bound, they don't get bound to me. So I I have I have I'm writing for another agent right now on the ones that I do have to bind. But I'll tell you right now that uh the money that I'm spending in marketing has proven with the right LSPs and the right uh right coaching, you know, and the right talk path, as you well know, um, you're gonna be able to write, you know, 10 to 20 items a day if you have the right process in place and if you have the right market. A lot of people obviously would laugh at this because they're in markets where it's very hard to sell at the moment. But in a market like uh Georgia, um we can crush it. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01So in any market though, you could figure out how many, it's gonna c it's gonna raise your cost, right? But you can figure out how many you need to sell in order to, or how many you need to quote in order to sell, right? Right.
SPEAKER_03And and and that's the uh that's the key. I mean, that's that's really knowing your act cost of acquisition, what you're willing to pay to acquire each item, right? And understanding uh how you make money and what you're willing to spend to generate revenue. Um, that's part of being prepared. Um, you know what I think? You know what I think have been some of the past failures of agents, um, anybody in business, right? Is when they start their business, they have really engineered mediocrity or smallness into their business plan. Yep. You know what I mean?
SPEAKER_00Totally. So you can almost zoom out of that, and you can almost say people accept mediocrity in their life, like everything, like goals are so low, and everything's so low.
SPEAKER_03And they organize that that business plan to mirror what they I guess they know in their personal lives, and before you know it, they realize after year one, they haven't built that pipeline, or they haven't built that revenue or that book of business to a point that'll sustain them, and then the clock starts ticking. So I went on uh a plan with uh uh that uh y'all remember the ADB plan? Yeah, so that was a day one uh eye opener for me. So if you have anything in your life, right, that you can go back and repeat, right? And you had a second chance, right? And you have, you know, like high school, right? I would have been, I'd be a stone. Oh tear it up, let's game changer. Great, yeah. So, but going back to see, I I was a scratch agent before two years ago, a little actually about uh almost three years ago now. Actually, three years ago, September 1. It's kind of ironic. Wow. So I was a scratch agent and I came in knowing nothing. I had some business background, business experience, but this industry is a totally different beast than what I was used to. And not knowing what it was, not knowing what it took with the right perspective, the right processes, the right marketing, and definitely the right personnel and being prepared, I accepted mediocrity and less than every day, and eventually talked myself out of the industry and out of the agency. So I sold it. But I looked back on it and I said, if I had it all to do over again, I would be so prepared and I would swing for the fences, you know. So I took a step back and uh actually got hired by one of the larger agencies in the country, and um they gave me the opportunity to learn a tremendous amount. And uh because of that, I stepped back and uh worked with another agent before I started because he was he's crushing it in Georgia, writing over 150 to 200,000 in premium a month with just a team of four. And I went and worked in his agency for uh five weeks, and I realized what he was doing versus the background plus the training that I just had with this other agent, and I looked at it, I said, Man, I had engineered so much mediocrity into my business plan when I first started, and uh I'm now I'm engineering success. And it's and it's all about putting together, first of all, you got to know how you make your money, right? So with with with how with with your with your revenue streams and understanding what your overhead, what your net profit will be, what your uh expenses obviously are, and knowing how you're gonna generate revenue and what you're willing to pay, right, to acquire that business, right, and understanding your ROI, then you can engineer success in your business plan. And I really feel like that's what we've done. And uh seeing it played out in that other agency that I'm still kind of writing business for, seeing that played out day in, day out gives me the confidence to really swing for the fences. I mean, I'm talking for me, it's a big, big swing, but I'm 20,000 in so far into marketing. I'm 20,000, 20,000 uh in uh in my marketing expenses so far, and I'm already seeing the gain.
SPEAKER_01And not no no pay, that's not including payroll, right? No, no, payroll, yeah.
SPEAKER_03We're gonna have a tremendous overhead. Yeah, yeah. Overhead should be if you are in a territory, right, if you're in a region where your average um premium per item is about 750 to 850, man, I'm telling you, you're in the way this this uh the EAOT works and the way this program works, you should you should shouldn't even balk at a $250 item acquisition cost. Not even not even bad an eye.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_03So just being prepared and knowing how you make that money, right? And then backing into it and having that $100,000 at startup, that's a true thing, that's a real thing. A lot of these people don't really understand, right? Because you guys are agency owners, so you know what it's what it takes to generate that revenue and know what it takes to keep the personnel and trained, you know the process. Right.
SPEAKER_00So and here's another argument like you're talking about just the front end uh break-even point, right? Well, what about the back end? Like, what about the fact that most of your clients are probably gonna stay with you, what, six years? So even if you're losing a little bit on the front end, it's still worth it. Because you're still gonna make money.
SPEAKER_03Absolutely. And um if you factor all that in and really run out that business plan and and that that that model and really model it out and and and really understand that PL as it goes through year one, two, three, four, and even five, yeah, it's a no-brainer to spend the money.
SPEAKER_00Totally. And but here's the here's the from the other side. So what about the person that has been on the fence that doesn't necessarily have the means and they do want to swing for the fences? Do they do it or do they keep waiting? You know what I mean? Gosh, I don't know.
SPEAKER_03I think questions. I was looking at it, weren't you? You were looking at it. I think the industry's changing. I think now is the time to take action. And um I wouldn't hesitate. I mean, I see that I can't see past five years in this industry. I don't know the dynamics of um artificial intelligence with everything happening. Um, you know, you know, our competition, what's happening there, and there's the dynamics of the auto industry and um some of the automation that's coming into that and self-driving. I think I think we're gonna be in for um a root awakening, I think, in the next five years, 10 years. So um I think now is the time to take action and to take advantage of the industry as it stays as it is now because I feel good about it. I feel good, feel great the next three to five years.
SPEAKER_01But uh, yeah, I have no problem spending what I gotta spend in order to grow that that uh look at what the cost of being risk averse and waiting until now was, right? Like three months ago, unlimited upside, right? Now stop at five. So it it it that changes a lot, right? I mean maybe it makes it a little easier because you don't have to be scale as much, you know. You can so you're you're you're swinging for the fences is a little more realistic, but I think we're also a lot of agents or new ones that were in your position three years ago, Ryan, fall short, is not understanding that month one isn't time to learn, right? This isn't time to figure out which phone system to buy, which you know what you know what leads to get. Like that was supposed to be figured out five months ago.
SPEAKER_03Right. We don't realize, we don't realize that the most most people that are coming into this industry, they don't realize the undertaking, and they don't realize the amount of details that have to go into establishing your process, establishing your resources, establishing your office environment, your personnel, and getting everything fluid before day one. They start that process on day one, and it's 30 to 60, 90 days gone before they start getting their act together, and they realize I've just lost so much opportunity for growth and so much opportunity to create revenue for myself, then they start thinking about downsizing and and and they literally after six six months, they're cutting people and they're trying to say, how do I make a living out of this if I can do it on my own? And then that's that's not the mindset you have to have in if you want to crush it. Um, but with it with a great market, um, with a great uh company name, great product, this is the time to jump in and really have an incredible game plan. Um, I will tell you, I came in with a decent game plan on day one, and man, I I I really did come out swinging well. And uh after about a year and a half in, I started seeing the writing on the wall after the plan, the the ADB was was gone. I was gonna struggle to make enough income to sustain. You know what I mean? So yeah, so if if you're not coming out, Jason, how how about you? How much is your um is the premium per item in your uh state?
SPEAKER_00Um I am right around 550 right now.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. So so so that's that's a little bit lower, right?
SPEAKER_00So you so yeah, so backing in and but don't worry, bills aren't expensive here in California.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, that's a good thing. Rents almost nothing. That's funny. That's we're at we're at about 600. We my agency does about 700 because we spend a little bit more time and go over those coverages. Now, uh in the ECP model, I don't know if it needs to be more just you just gotta blow through them and get to the next one, you know, get to the next one. So yeah, how about that? Are you do you anticipate spending as much time per each acquisition to really get them where they need to be? Yeah. Oh okay.
SPEAKER_03I won I won today. Yeah, I won the day by by building the wall, if you know what I mean. Um there you go. Uh we tripled the coverage. I didn't even talk about price. We we got the yes and wrote the home, and it's 5,000 and annualized premium. Um, and it was and we went after coverage. We sold, and that's what this, that's what all state's all about. We're not we're not all about the um the numbers necessarily as far as how many people we can talk to. It's the quality of conversations that you can have and getting yourself in front of people at the right time. So, what I've done is I'm doing the lively transfers, guys. They are getting the right people that are interested at the right time. These people come in asking for price, right? Uh can you beat my price? It's awesome, right? Because we accept that, sure, let's talk about price. In the back of my mind, I'm always thinking about the price that I'm gonna pay for you if you hurt somebody, right? So we have some great conversations building that and helping them understand, right, the importance of coverage, and then we sell the premium. So my average premium here in Georgia is around 772 per item, and I average around 825 per item. There you go. So I'm willing to spend $250 per item because if you look at how you make money on the plan, that's an X, it's an exponential return. It's a lot total.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You have to you have to refocus their need to where it to where it needs to be, because they come in just exactly what you said with the wrong need. Right. You don't understand it, right? All they know is I have to have it and I hate it and it sucks, and I pay it every month, and and they're you guys are all crooks, right? And and we have to we gotta change that because no, we we are likely, we could be. If you have the accident, if you have the one where you kill somebody, we are the most important person you ever talked to, or we're the worst person if we did it wrong, they now are they're screwed. Like you literally can lose everything. And it's it's it's so funny how you know there's the the financial advisor is held in such high regard, right? Oh, it's a financial they're Wall Street. Oh, they're so but you know what they they take your money and they gamble it. I mean, at the end of the day, they put it in the market and you you have no idea what the market's gonna do, right? And and here we are that are we're protecting that money. Like we want to make sure that money doesn't leave. And you know, so it's it's and they get that though. When you do, you know, as you said, build the wall. When you show them the need and then you show them why they need those coverages. I mean, I did one before, I was telling Jason, I did one before. I I I was on with a client and he had good coverages, 300, 300. But we we have an umbrella now because there was a $300,000 gap. But he understood it. I mean, we were on the phone for a half hour. It takes a little time to to you know switch their mind over, but when they get it, you know, and he was talking about he was in two accidents, he got it. He's like, Man, I I thought I hurt this woman badly, but I didn't even think about that that she gets out and says, My neck hurts, you know, and then and there's attorneys involved, right? And then that's right.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. We're selling we're selling something that's intangible and that people don't know. So without that, what's that?
SPEAKER_03No, I just I I had a little bit of breakup. Are you am I coming in clear for you guys too?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, cut off for just a second, but but now we're good.
SPEAKER_00My freaking internet. Um yeah, so we're what basically we're selling the Mercedes of insurance, but nobody can see it. So you have to paint that picture. And that's what people don't understand. You can say it, but they still don't understand it. Right. Like it's just we have to paint that. And and what I really like is the sales process. I we get so excited when we sell a policy that's $40 more a month. Like, because that's an actual salesperson, right there. You know what I mean? You somebody that sells something at a lower price is not a salesperson. The internet can do that, Amazon does that, like you can automate that. No skill.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00Um so it's like, yeah, we have to paint that. We have to paint a picture. The better you paint.
SPEAKER_01I think there's even there's even more to it. There, there's three. There's the there's your order taker, that's when we're less. There's the there's the salesperson that's slamming them into the thing that is pretty close, and then there's the advisor, right? We are an advisor. And when we when we identify their need and and then deliver the value, because again, the value doesn't matter. They don't give a shit about what we have in the way of draw, you know, all these different bells and whistles, right? The gold or the platinum or the purple or whatever, right? They don't care about that. I mean, they're glazed over if you're talking about insurance, but when it serves their need, serves their, yeah, like I mean, Jason falls asleep if we start talking about insurance, but it's it's it's that need like that. Need is the critical missing piece that most people don't ever even go into. Right? They're good at establishing rapport. Okay, they like me. Now let me show you what we got. Right?
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_01But the what you got has to serve.
SPEAKER_03I love it when they come in with Geico or State Farm or you know, any progressive, thank God. They do such a great job at writing a policy that I would never touch with a 10-foot pole. And when you show them the betrayal. This happened. The betrayal premium and an exchange, right? They're giving you nothing when you have that accident. So we're all about a fair exchange. Would that wouldn't that be right? That's mine and your job to make sure that we educate them, give them as much discount as possible that we can, right? But also give them a fair exchange for what they're paying for. So if I can give you access to 250 or 300 or a million, right, for only a few dollars more a month, why wouldn't you take that? Why would you settle for 2550 or the state minimum for almost the same amount of money? That's not a fair exchange. So I pivot on that as well. And that works a lot.
SPEAKER_00And that meant that mentality right there is what's hard to convince other agents. Is is that you can like it's three times more coverage for ten dollars. Can you imagine? You're already paying a couple hundred bucks, right? Or five hundred bucks. But for some reason, convincing people to to do that process that you just said is so tough. I don't know why.
SPEAKER_03It's it's you know, it's tough because people are so transaction-based, um, and they live their lives that way at the young, especially younger generation, it's just the way it is, and they end up selling that way, and they sell out of their own pocket, and they don't find a lot of um value in some of the things they're even saying, or sometimes they don't find value in the trusted advisor. And getting them to believe that that starts from the head down, and it starts from having that process and that mentality from day one, and not trying to figure it out 60 days, 90 days into your agency, because then you got to let people go because they don't adopt that mentality. They see you fly flamming. So it's best to have a good talk path right in the very beginning, best to have a company culture where that is how we lead. We lead with a great talk path and talk about the value of our coverages, right? That's how we lead, and you coach on that, you reinforce that, you pull calls, and you continue to set the expectations, right? You add volume behind that, right, guys? You add uh lively transfers, and you just get people that are on the phone at the right time, and you have the right process and the value behind what you're selling, you're gonna write a lot of business. I was on the other, I was on the phone. I only spoke, we only I've only spoken with four clients today. And uh Jessica, who's working with me now, she's spoken five or six. We have different approaches. I closed three of the four, and she's closed, she, I think she's still on her phone call, she's getting payment for the third one today. So it's as it's it's all about you can see it in your in your call volume, right? You can see it in your talk time, and then you can see the amount of quotes, and you can really work and back out and see if they're actually following the process. And if they are, it's gonna result in items that are being written and your higher uh premiums as well. And those are the clients that are gonna stick with you, yeah, because they're not gonna let they're not gonna let the progressive guy goes to state farms betray them again, right? Right taking the money and give that in exchange, give them nothing.
SPEAKER_01And they're coming to them at price, right? You've just they now understand what it's really all about, that you're the advisor and you've protected them. And they're they're leading with, hey, I'm gonna try to save you you know 10 bucks a month. Right. Out of here, get out of here, clown. You know, like they don't want any part of that.
SPEAKER_03The all state's not about the price game, um, necessarily. They're trying to, right? With their backing down their overhead, and we're we're potentially gonna, you know, have to see that down the road. But I'm telling you, if we stick to the trusted advisor and we we put volume behind that, as far as bringing people, bring a lot of times you get a great person that's great with people, but they don't like to make those calls, right? But that's okay, guys. That's okay. You're just trying to connect them with the right person at the right time, and you're gonna have to outsource that, especially with the new plan that we have. We can afford to outsource that, Jason. We can outsource that and get lively transfers coming in as much as we can. Uh, I'm not a big fan of web leads at all. I don't see a good uh return on my investment there. My acquisition cost is usually about $650 per item, which is ridiculously insane. Um unless you have a two-year, unless you have a two-year uh sales cycle on those things, um, then they start to average back down. But under a new startup, I would never go web lead, ever in my life go web lead. Uh the cost uh for those certain uh words, right, that are that are out there are have gone absorbingly high. So they're really buying crap and they're giving you crap. So live leads, organic live lead transfers are a fantastic way to grow your business. And you work, you as age should work on the process, work on the coaching, get your team up to uh above par, right, to be able to sell the value and then get people in front of them and let them go to town and hold them accountable, hold them accountable. And I'm telling you guys, this new plan is gonna be freaking phenomenal. And be willing to invest in bringing the opportunity and also set expectations when the opportunities are not coming in, but then to make outbound calls.
SPEAKER_01People are just writing this down, they're like hitting pause. What did he say that way?
SPEAKER_00I I agree a hundred percent with everything you say except the the web leads.
SPEAKER_03Oh you guys have web leads?
SPEAKER_00I do what that's all I do. I won't do live transfers. My R my ROI and web leads are unreal. Great.
SPEAKER_03So so I'm gonna ask you a question.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, how long does it take?
SPEAKER_03No, what's your acquisition cost per item with a web lead?
SPEAKER_00Per item? Uh what's 50 divided by 1.5?
SPEAKER_03That's 25. Divided by 1.5. Why are you making an insurance agent, buddy?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, what are you? I'm not a rocket scientist. What is that? So my connection.
SPEAKER_03Wait, you're writing so $33 per item is what you're paying. Yes. In marketing, that is at $400 an item, dude. That is phenomenal. You're making uh seven dollars, right? Obviously, per item on your first in the renewals, right? But on the ECP, it's exponential, right? In that first 90 days is so exponential, and it's incredible.
SPEAKER_00So the problem with first 90 is are the best because that doesn't include the time that it takes to call them, right? My ROI per sale is about uh $200 for the first two-week cycle on web leads.
SPEAKER_03Wow.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Okay.
SPEAKER_03So you are generating your own web leads?
SPEAKER_00Nope.
unknownOkay.
SPEAKER_00I'm I'm buying them. I'm buying them from the most general company that um, but you know, the broker.
SPEAKER_01The most the most hated, the most the most despised and hated company that everybody complains about. But but here's the thing.
SPEAKER_03All right, Jason. I just I think I just dropped 10 grand today with them. So uh I'm not gonna be a hypocrite, but it's not Weblies, it's lively transfers.
SPEAKER_00Um you just cut cut out a ton of time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's the you're you're speeding up the sales cycle, right? Like you're entering at the 15th call instead of at the at call one.
SPEAKER_03Right. And uh I will tell you today, we had nine lively transfers, okay? And I we if Jessica does it, we we've written seven households out of the nine lively. That is phenomenal. That is insane.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, but it's not it's other people are not gonna have those same results because they don't step into it with the same mindset that you come to, right? Like they're like, oh hey, you know, and they're timid and they're they're order taking or they're selling. Right. You can't sell, right? Right.
SPEAKER_03You can't. So that that that's that's false. Now listen, I had a I had uh three years ago, I had a 40% close ratio on web leads. They just tried their um organic type, you know, um web leads where they were organically generating themselves, and I was close almost all they're all home web leads, and then that that gripped off because it wasn't profitable for the amount of money they were paying for per lead, and then they weren't making any money, so I lost them. But there are phenomenal opportunities. What's your close ratio on web leads?
SPEAKER_00Uh really bad, like uh between 3.5 and 4.5 percent.
SPEAKER_03So the sales cycle is two years for you, is it not? Is it a two-year sales cycle? On most on the other uh 97% or 96%. Meaning that you brought you got them two years ago as a web link and you close on the day.
SPEAKER_00No, no, no. So I my my uh the sales cycle can can range. So it's as long as it's in the system, that's why my acquisition cost right off the bat is like 200 bucks for two weeks. Right cycle over time. That the those numbers were specifically from January 1st of this year till about a month ago. Wow. So so in and and back to your point with um mindset and everything else, right? I just went like I did live transfers, and when they got expensive last year, I figured out and it didn't start there. It started at $300. Then I could figured out how to get down to $250 of policy, and then I started getting it, you know what I mean? You you do it, you just figure it out. And and to your what I love about what you're doing is you're all in on this and you're keeping it narrow. When people go too wide, this like what we do will not work if I bought live transfers and I did web leads and all this stuff, right? Because then you're doing all this different stuff and you can't narrow down on what works.
SPEAKER_03So yeah, I I think if you got if you if you analyze the data, what you'll do is a as a new agent, I would go with three sources. I'd go with web leads, I guess. That's that's actually that's my third. My first option would be live leads, right? Yep, second option would be mailers. So I just dropped 20,000 mailers and I have about a 1% response rate, it's right, 0.78. But out of that 1% response rate, my close ratio is 40%.
SPEAKER_01My acquisition cost is well, those are, I mean, they're hot, hot, hot. They called in and they're excited about the thing they're holding out.
SPEAKER_03And they gave, yeah, they that you haven't interrupted their day, they set time aside for you. So I'm one call close on all of them. So so the so the mailers people say I would never do no. Listen, find a system, make sure the acquisition costs, you got to run it at least two or three months to see your acquisition costs. If you were below 250 on the new plan, you better invest everything you got in that. Okay, if you can get down on a mailer to $150 per item, guys, just keep going and just keep plugging at those dollars away. Um, and Web Lee's cost $33 an item. Listen, I I I'm I almost wept my whistle there. I'm almost ready to go on some weekly, but I I've experienced uh different um, but everybody has different experiences, and then the um live lead transfers, those are no-brainer. And I would go with companies that really give you the time to vet them and hang up and they get credited. Um there are companies that are set up that'll bait you in on lower costs, but you're gonna be stuck with 95% of them and you're gonna have a higher acquisition cost. So everybody starts thinking about okay, um, I've got $100,000 that my dad gave me and he he took it all back. Now that I don't need my account anymore, now I got 20 grand. And all of a sudden, they're engineering smallness, they're engineering mediocrity into their business plan because they got to start thinking about how they're gonna make money.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_03That's this, that's you're just engineering a plan for suc uh for failure, and that's why you see such a high turnover in uh agents in the industry, and uh because they they they planned for that in the very beginning, they didn't even know it. So if you don't have a if you don't know how much money you want to make, if you don't back into that and figure out what it's gonna cost to get it done and how you're gonna train, people think they're just gonna open up on day one, they're gonna start making calls to their friends and family and start and it ain't gonna have it.
SPEAKER_00No, that dries up fast.
SPEAKER_01No, well, and then they get rewarded for you know their mediocrity, I guess. The the 30,000 they wrote, they're like, Oh, I got I just made you know whatever it comes out to, and and they think that it all's great, and then it's a little less the next month, and then a little less, and then all of a sudden it's two years in, and they're like, wait, I didn't make enough to pay my my payroll.
SPEAKER_03Right. So the new plan, guys, honestly, I would if you're not at a million at year one, and uh if you have something around 750 per item to 800, you should be at a million easily before the end of year one. If you're at 400 to 500, there's still a way to get it done. It's just it your acquisition costs has to be, I would say your acquisition costs has to be well below 250 in order to be successful enough to be able to reinvest and have retain retain those earnings back into the business and reinvest them back into marketing, continue to keep that pipeline going. Um but you also have to put the pressure on your sales staff to organically generate opportunity through every conversation, right? Asking for that referral, making sure that the talk path is there to get that referral, to instill that value in the conversation and not just be a vending machine. And you got to hold them accountable. So all these agents that are LSPs are coming into it, right? Thinking I'm just gonna write all the business. When then they got they're gonna have their you know flunkies, their LSPs just kind of you know waving in the background, right, in the wake, and they're writing that they're contributing 10 or 15 items a month and they're carrying the lion's share. Where if they just invested in them, right, in marketing, and they coached them and they taught them how to handle the opportunity and create value, there's an exponential return right there that most agents don't realize until there's too late, until they're out.
SPEAKER_00So and the third month into it is too late, like to your point. Like if we're talking about this the specific contract, uh then you know that that first two months is it. Like that's the time to go balls to the wall, not months.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. I mean the fourth month, you're making half of you're making half over the same the same next 12 months as you do on the first right 12 months from the first month. I mean, then that's thanks to Jason showing me this. But that's the thing, you know, like people aren't shown this, they don't know that.
SPEAKER_03They don't know it. The first 90 days, it's it's cumulative in this plan. So you better load up the most you've ever written, should be the first 90 days. And that's it. If you if you deleted everything out of your plan and just had the first 90 days put in there and you maximize that to like a you know 400,000, look at what it pays you, right? Delete all that out and see. So running simulations in that plan in the EAOT all day long should tell you exactly how important the first 30 to 60 and 90 days are.
SPEAKER_00That's what they should. And the 60 days is the key, man. And it does. And if you look at it, it sets up that number that you're that cash flow, it sets it up for the entire cycle. Those first really 60 days. 60 days is real 90, yes, because 90 is still good, it's still in there, but the first 60 days sets up your paycheck for life.
SPEAKER_03Life, that is the word. Yeah, people don't understand that. So that's why I'm okay. I'm okay with putting my marketing in now. I'm okay with having to write my my business to to another agent. I'm okay with all that, okay with doing that because now when I hit September 1, I'm telling you, if I'm not writing less more than $15,000 in premium a day with the plan that I have, the investment, and the processes, and the training and the accountability I have in place, I'm not doing it. Now, now the same for me, the same amount of activity for you at $400 an item, my expectations would be around $9,000 in premium a day.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03With honestly the same amount of marketing dollars spent. So that's tough. So I would know in your position, I would definitely go in with the web leads and really forcing those outbound calls in my agency and holding them accountable. And I would be buying age leads all day long, all day long, and working the hell out of those. Um year one year age. The one no, the over year. The over the yeah, three years. Over the year, yeah. Six days, yeah. So I would uh I would be buying those at around 10 cents, and I'd get four to five thousand in per agent as much as you can. You have to go to different age lead providers to do that, but you have those age leads running and it lead manager, a lead management system. I don't know what you're gonna use, is a hundred and ten percent of everything.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_03I mean, if it's it's a people people are actually being convinced in their territories to run e-agent as their lead manager by their I know, right? It's it's so it's so hell yeah. They need a five.
SPEAKER_01It makes me sweat thinking about the fact that like they're coming in with no phone system, no CRM, and they're not gonna be writing if they write anything, it's gonna be in the 90th or 120th day, and it's like 30,000. It's like you're you're done. You're done. Like when I got all excited, and and then Jason and I were gonna talk at the same time, which we always do. I I would like when you said that 90 days, like literally, they should say the only way you own this agency is if you crush it here, like just pretend it is really these 90 days, you know. I mean, and that's it. Like, what if you don't own it after 90 days? How would you take all of your money and invest and plan for writing during that time?
SPEAKER_03Exactly.
SPEAKER_01Because you know what, you'll get it all back, you get 120% of the of the first month back.
SPEAKER_03I mean, your ramp up Jason, um your ramp up is this, and the problem is everybody comes in thinking that they're just kind of slowly ramp up because they're gonna work their mortgage brokers, they're gonna work their friends and family, they're gonna work their quote sheets that they all gave them and they're that was six months ago, you know, and it's guys they uh all state knew what they were doing, they knew that to be successful as a new startup agent, it's all about the 30, 60, 90, right? Yeah, yep, and that's where your success comes from. So that's why they've emphasized it and incentivized it so much. So I'm I looked at it and within the first five minutes. Now, I'll tell you, I went to Chicago, I was forced to go to Chicago for seven days. And sitting in there, listening to the business plans of new agents, I had to stop many a times and and and help people understand the importance of starting up correctly. And um it ended up I have a great group now that they all they they call me and we we talk a lot and they shoot ideas by me. But I'm telling you, even after I've spoken with them and tried to help them, they have mediocrity. It's the fear factor, right? They have that engineered into their their plan. And unfortunately, some half of them won't be around if they stick with that that plan.
SPEAKER_00Less than half of them. I mean, the statistics are it's yeah, 25% will be around.
SPEAKER_01A lot of people go into goals thinking, oh, goal, what whatever, whether the goal is high or low, you think that's the ceiling, and I'm gonna get close, right? So if you have this low goal and and really the curve is low, what it you know, 20,000 or 30,000 or whatever it is, if you know that's the bar, and you're like, okay, well, if I get 15, I'm 75%, I'm doing okay. And it's like, no, you need to 10 times literally 10 times it.
SPEAKER_03Right. I have a little Excel spreadsheet that I will not share with anybody. Um, once you preface that. Um, but uh, it just gives me my cost of my acquisition cost. So it's just a formula that shows me how much I'm spending, what I'm quoting, what I'm closing, what I'm writing out of it, and just a quick acquisition cost. That's it. And that's all you need, guys, to help dictate how you need to spend what you need to spend. Marketing, but I would go pick pick whatever it is and go hardcore in it, go all in, and you better dedicate 15 to 20 grand those first two to three months, and then you can back it down, you can scale it down, you can see what's working, and then maintain half of that, or you know, 25% of that. But you better come in, you better be ready, ready to spend that hundred grand before um that first paycheck.
SPEAKER_01Well, you get it all back, yeah.
SPEAKER_03And that's the thing, you get it all back. Jason, see that's why you can go into this thing so confidently because you already know your acquisition costs, you already know what it is, and you can back in from that and say, Okay, how am I gonna make this thing hap? Knowing that, you can scale it.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_03Knowing you can scale that, right? Yeah, you can get 15 LSPs in there and just keep scaling, right?
SPEAKER_00And that's and that's the thing, and it's it's even more granular than that. Like, I mean, it's learning the the like the scripts, the talk paths, the exact way at the the second they come in there, they can change it a little bit after they've mastered it, but it's doing that. It's um what's the onboarding looking like? What are these time frames? Like down to every second, you gotta know what is going on. You gotta know the formula for every bit of your agency to know like I I'm going into this confidently, even though even though I'm very behind uh time-wise, but I'll make it happen. It's just because I just had a kid last week, but but whatever.
SPEAKER_03Congratulations, man. You don't even have any bags on your eyes.
SPEAKER_00What's that?
SPEAKER_03Is that California living? You don't even have any bags on your eyes without the with the lack of sleep.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, I don't know. I'm nuts. I mean, he wears makeup.
SPEAKER_03That's California.
SPEAKER_01They wear makeup of avocados.
SPEAKER_03Avocados, buddy.
SPEAKER_00Cucumbers, avocados, facials. You a big hell stuff dude? Uh I I was. Um I w I wish I wish I was uh I need to get back on the train.
SPEAKER_03I injured my back and I'll excuses look at physical therapy engineering mediocrity into his uh you know yeah.
SPEAKER_00No, it's true though. It's true. It does trickle down, but yeah, no, I need to I'm I'm doing a little bit, but I need to be more all in.
unknownRight.
SPEAKER_01If you can't, you must. If you can't, you must. If you must, you can.
SPEAKER_00Yep. That makes sense. I just like I like a p like I had a pizza last night. I freaking love pizza. Love pasta.
SPEAKER_01Well, that's okay. That's okay. You can have a cheat day. Those sugar ties are amazing. So so how about I I know you went into it a little bit. Would you say that there's a different there's a different AC or acquisition cost for for each different lead type? Or do you just set a baseline like should should I know you're not going to share your sheet, and that's that's fine, but you're you know, what would you tell somebody going in so they have a little bit of a of a baseline to look at? Like, you know, if it's over this amount, nope, can't do it, or I need to figure something out.
SPEAKER_03Right. And um I think uh I think they won't know that data until the first because your sales cycle, let's say you have a two-week sales cycle on average, right? Um with web leads and anything that's kind of hot, sometimes it's an average two. Sometimes it's one call close. If you're good, you're you're creating the urgency, divergency, creating the need, establishing the value, then you're closing it. That's what you're trying to coach, and that's what you're trying to instill in your team. That's gonna skew your curve, is it not? Yeah, right. So um that's all you're trying to do is skew the curve. You're trying to skew the curve as much as possible. And um I would say if you start looking at how much you've spent on creating uh those opportunities in your marketing in that certain segment, that how however you want to categorize it, and then you see how much you've closed, right? Then you divide it by the number of items, right? And that's your acquis yes, cost for acquisition per item. And if it's above 250, think about that. If you need to write so much business and you're gonna spend 250 per item, and your item uh premium is 400, you are upside down, and the ECP plan will bail you out. It will, but it won't be bailing you out after month uh 90. You're you're out of luck on that one. Yeah, you need to you need to be considering a lower um, but the first 90 days, I don't care. If my acquisition cost 500 an item, I don't care to get that premium because it becomes exponential. It's cumulative, it grows and grows, and I get percentages on that on top of my 10 renewals. It becomes an amazing. I mean, I think at the end of it, I looked at it at the end of my three year, I'm almost 200%.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So they want I would say here's the caveat to that. So yes, your your uh acquisition cost can be anything. It's but it's speed. Speed is what you need for those first 90 days. Speed trumps the cost of per acquisition in the first 90 days, and then after that is when you during that time, you better be squishing that price down. So if you are it's $500 uh a lead or $500 for sale, dude, spend as much as you can. Like literally borrow money and just do it as much as you can. You know you're gonna get it back. But here's the thing is that you can only do that for so long. So you that better be on the downward trend.
SPEAKER_03This is the problem, is people don't believe in their ability to coach and inspire and build a good team. So if they're gonna spend, they're gonna spend five thousand. I'm spending my commitment is to spend four thousand on every LSP, and if they're doing phenomenal, I'll go up to five thousand per LSP every on marketing. If they're not doing well and they're not riding their bare minimum, then they fire themselves and I'll have to worry about it because that's in that's extra I've set the expectations up front what we gotta write in in the agency handbook, and uh their commission plans are signed off on, they understand it. If they're not trending, if they don't hit their goals, it's unfortunate they're gonna fall off. Um but if they do well with my commission plan, if they're writing 70, 75,000 premium a month, which they will imagine, imagine getting $4,000 of marketing help, right, at $825 per item and you're being coached well. I'm telling you, $70,000 and it sounds audacious. People are saying, oh, this Ryan guy, oh my god, he just makes it sound. I just Jason, you have the business model you've tried, it's tried and true. You know what you're gonna be able to do by putting that much more money in marketing, right? And by by by by uh scaling that. So get your marketing first, know it, know what you want, and I would diversify into three. I do. I guess if you like it, I'd do some web leads. In my area, you'll find it they they fail very you you you won't run a good agency with web leads. Um with lively transfers, those are those are really good for me. And then mailers, I'm not playing around. If I drop 10,000, I'm expecting 100 calls, and I'm expecting to write 40 of those households. And let's say the average household is 1.5 items. I'm gonna get 60 items out of that. What's 60 times 875, guys? I don't know. Uh hold on, I'm I'm I'm doing the math 4,500. Yes, 52,500. Put 52,500, right? And those 10,000 millers cost me 5,000. That's my average LSP. My average LSP better write 52,500. I'm spending that money on them. That better be the return. And that is what the statistics, what the math, what everything tells me. All I gotta do is make sure I have great, fantastic LSPs. I coach them, I hold them accountable, and I spend the money on them because I trust, first of all, my process, right? That what I've developed. And um you can I would be in the office two to three weeks trying it out, making sure that you're running fluidly uh before day one, because that's when it counts. So um, but that's the simple math, guys. I mean, think about it $825 an item for me.
SPEAKER_00I would say anybody that's listening to this that might not be as A-type as let's say you are, uh or that doesn't have uh the experience, I would say mail just to let everybody know, mailers is more of a long-term play, a little bit more. There's a tail on it. Don't go in all mailers, like and all mailers day one, and don't go in web leads. Like your best, the best way that that anybody without that much experience in trying different marketing techniques is definitely lively transfers because those are people that you're actually quoting that day.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and if you're good, it's it's a one-call close if you're good. Yeah, so work on your talk path, um, create an environment uh where people are willing to listen to each other and willing to help and coach each other and just pull calls, hold people accountable. If they're not being held accountable, they're gonna take the easiest road and easiest path possible. What's your price? What are you paying? Let me check it out. What's your VIN numbers? Who's driving? Okay, well, I'm gonna I'm gonna see what I can do to help you out. Oh, and I've seen I've seen people do exactly opposite of what we're supposed to do, right? Uh, in order to kill, and it's just hold your team accountable. But I will tell you, if you're coming in with cost budget, now there is a formula. If you're coming in with a budget, you're like, I just can't spend that, I can't see myself, I'm engineering mediocrity, my whole plan, I cannot break from okay. If you're creating this environment and you know you're gonna be mediocre and you're so happy with it, you're dead set on it. Buy age leads, just buy them. You're gonna like them. They have good emails, they have good cell numbers, scrub them and call them, and then put them on a great lead management uh uh software. Um G guys what do I use? Yeah, man, y'all are gonna think it's hilarious. Now I've used it. I know, I know the answer. No, no, no. I've used ricochet, and um, I gotta tell you, I can build out a ricochet uh that I'll ricochet in in just a few minutes, actually. Um, I got very fluid with it, it's fantastic, it's probably one of the best um lead management tools out there. It's amazing. Um Lids, I've used that. I did very well with it. Um they don't have some of the tools that I would want, like texting and so forth. Uh follow-up tool, phenomenal. Um, they're still getting their act together uh on a lot of other things. I think it's gonna continue to be a phenomenal tool. I can set up a um I can set up a um a workflow in a few minutes with them. Um I've used Velocify. I've used DYL, and I'm not a fan of DYL at all whatsoever. So listen, if you want simplicity and you want something easy, go follow-up tool, right, with Lightspeed. If you want something that you need to spend several weeks on, go ricochet if you have time to master it and understand perhaps more than a few weeks. It is the matrix. You're looking for the woman in the red dress every day, and I'm telling you, you have no idea why things start happening, and you gotta plug in ricochet, you're plugging all the holes so that everything runs the funnel and runs the process and the workflows, and they don't trickle over to other workflows. Um, it's a process. I'm sticking with, and I've seen too many people just recently get like a all safety manager. Um that is bliss manager, huh? That is bliss. No, no, no. I've used bliss and lead manager of bliss, true parents. No, lead manager is the baby of blitz. Um, yeah. How about this? Try having something really it's like having this perfect child and then having horrible parents that screw it all up. So um that's kind of what all state has done. Love it, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um it it but I'm making it work, guys. I do believe that in think about it, if I'm writing 175 to 250,000 premium, there's gonna be some eyeballs on my business, and I want to make sure that I am as compliant as possible. I see where all state's going with all of this. And I don't know if you guys have heard the word quantum. You've heard that out there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, just the TV show quantum lead.
SPEAKER_03No, it's something that uh Allstate's made up. Um, so Allstate Lead Manager, in my opinion, in my humble opinion, will be what we're all using in the next year or two. Uh, we'll be using their phone systems, lead manager, if lead manager will go straight from the lead, straight to Allstate's quoting platform, and it'll all be fluid and everything will be scrubbed properly continually, and we won't have to worry about anything, it'll all be on all state's time. Uh but they will be managing all of it. So I'm I'm an early adopter on it, and hopefully it will work in my favor. Um, but if you get if you're going to start up and don't have experience, do not use all state lead manager. They will they will stife it'll stifle you uh about 20-25% of your business. Um but I'll be working in in conjunction with a couple other things to make it work for me.
SPEAKER_00Nice.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Nice. Uh one one last piece of advice. What would you the number one piece of advice you give everybody that's listening from all your experience, all your agencies, your multiple scratch agencies now, what is the most valuable thing that you think an agent that may be a little less uh knowledgeable about all the stuff?
SPEAKER_03Like I don't think you know it all.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Um I am regurgitating back to you guys the things that I've been told and things that I rejected in my first agency as just um maybe wives' tales. Um just just disregarded them. Find a mentor in this in this business and go work for them before you open up day one and learn how to run an agency. You'll learn what not to do and what to do. You'll formulate your own ideas and plans, and you'll be able to see the light at the end of the tunnel, and you need to be able to call on that person when you're having a tough time or when you're having an issue. But make sure you're not necessarily with the veterans, the 25-year guys. You want to be the guys that are zero to, you know, we actually about the two to five year that have learned how to scale the business and grow it tremendously. If you can get some of their time and you can work within their agency, you will learn the best practices possible and you'll learn things that you don't want to do. Make sure you work there four to six weeks to really get a hold of everything, and uh that way you can bring that in and know and have some sense sense of confidence when you come in to start your own agency.
SPEAKER_01Nice. I love it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I'm sure I'm sure you're willing to hire some of these people to come and do this for you.
SPEAKER_03I will can I mention other names I'm gonna tell you guys. I don't know if you know him, but his name's Rudy Sarovic. And he helped me and brought me in and showed me the way, even though I thought I knew it. He showed me the way to be able to scale this thing, and he showed me I can see the light at the end of the tunnels. I have no fear, none. No fear. Just because I've seen it and it's he replicates it every day and he walks the walk and talks and talk, and then he's allowed me to come in and actually start my agency within his agency with people. So if you're a mentor out there and you can do that uh for another person, it's it's a life-changing opportunity will extend to somebody and uh show them the way, and it's the way all state agencies should be doing that for each other, lifting each other up, supporting each other, and giving them a path, showing them a path. Um, and and and and writing $100,000 or premium for them while we're doing that is is always a plus, you know? Yeah. So um he is always good. It was good for him, it was good for us, it still is good for him. Um, and uh he was on the ECP as well. So I'd say if you're an all-state agent and you can help somebody in that capacity, that's what we're all about, I think. That's what makes us unique.
SPEAKER_00I love it. Ryan, thank you so much.
SPEAKER_03Thank you, Ryan.
SPEAKER_01There were so many bitching nuggets. No way.
SPEAKER_03All right.
SPEAKER_02Well, this is uh 55% of the different sales producers. Agents focus on marketing activity, overlook sales presentation, improvement and mindset, shifting focus on force, leading three overcoming lead drastically closing numbers. Solution enroll your team in september sales summit offered by agency ball. We will even set your team to see which of their sales tests need the most improvements. Head to agencyball.com to sign up before it's all.
SPEAKER_00Hey, please for checking out the experiences. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming up.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman