The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Welcome to the crack. Some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee talk. You know, talk about what talks, tortoise, whatever. Coffee twerk. Coffee talk. What's it time for? What's it time for?
SPEAKER_00
Um, I think the bumper rolled, and they said it was guffee talk.
SPEAKER_02
It is glovy to they.
SPEAKER_00
By they I mean us. I guess they are us. We are the us. We are them. Yes, we are the us.
SPEAKER_02
They they are us. We just lost half the listeners. That happens every episode. Okay, so I have something that I think folks would like to talk or hear us talk about. Okay. How about commissions, payouts? Sure. So yeah, one of the things that uh the company can afford to help with when we are on that uh scratch, a scratch contract where you know you get you get that enhanced commission. Those words I can say. Sure. Yeah. It it allows us to attract and hire higher caliber salespeople, right? Traditionally, especially if you have a loan, and even more especially if 2% is coming out for something. I won't say what, but then the cash flow is pretty crunched, right? Margins are compressed because there isn't this huge amount of cash flow. So for your labor cost, what we end up doing is we get caught in the cycle of, well, we'll get this person at 12 or 13 bucks an hour. And if they write business, then they'll get the money. Except the problem is who are you attracting?
SPEAKER_00
Hmm. Truth. But hashtag truth bomb. So so here's the uh the antithesis to that. Doesn't a salesperson wouldn't they rather have higher commission and lower base pay? If they were confident in their skills. However, this space a hundred percent, wouldn't that be it?
SPEAKER_02
However, fifty percent, however, in this space, there's high barrier to entry, also, right? If they're not licensed, okay, if somebody's bartending or somebody's selling cell phones and making eight grand a month, why are they gonna take a month off to learn to pass some test when at the end of that rainbow is 12 bucks? And maybe they'll be able to sell insurance, right? I think there's too many ifs involved.
unknown
Sure.
SPEAKER_02
So you can see my glowing face and my unshaven chin.
SPEAKER_00
So that brings up yeah, that's good.
SPEAKER_02
I mean, so what the what this enhanced thing does, right? And as both of both you and I embark on that journey here, it's round two for you, right? No, round one, no, round one, yeah. So both both of us round one, but we've talked to enough people that hopefully we have enough intel to do it right. But but I found now I can attract a slightly higher caliber, right? There's a insurance company in here in my town in Tucson, Arizona. Again, if you have any clients moving to Arizona, so but in my town, Tucson, Arizona, there's a call center for a lizard light company, right? And these are they're highly paid, right? In the 20s, 20 bucks an hour, except there's a lot of structure, it's a call center, it's probably not the most fun environment. And so if we can leverage that fun, high-powered environment, give them the tools to be successful and be able to afford that higher base, now there's interest, right? And I think we can then acquire a higher caliber salesperson.
SPEAKER_00
And I I guess that would just be depending on where you are, too. Um because yeah, I mean, I the I guess there's always going to be that argument. Do you uh do you know 5% higher and a few bucks lower?
SPEAKER_02
Right. Well, and it this whole conversation sparked from you and I showing each other our comp, right? The comp. The comp. So you have a slightly lower or high more aggressive back end comp with a slightly lower base. And I'm I'm have this other thing going in my mind, and you know, there's a million ways to skin the cat, but I'm sitting here thinking, what if I pay just a tiny bit more up front? And I know it's counterintuitive because of the the whole notion that, hey, look, Shin and a salesperson just not want a base and want extreme commissions. Sure. Right. But for some reason, that hasn't, I haven't seen that work, at least in this space.
SPEAKER_00
Right. And and then we were also talking about um selling. So when you when you're interviewing people, you're selling them. So you gotta have the pitch down, just like you, like just like you expect your agents to have down, you gotta have your pitch. And man, I feel like such a such a salesman lately hiring people because I got my whole all the the great things, like we built up the whole, you know, your typical insurance agency sucks. They don't do this for you, they don't do this, right? Am I right? And every time they're like, yep, yep, and we're doing this and we're getting aggressive with this. We're hiring, you know, we're we've got this team working for you. We're we're buying you this many leads, like it's gonna be crazy. And that pitch definitely helps.
SPEAKER_02
Sure, but then also you can't you can't sugarcoat it, right? You also have to try to scare them away in a way.
SPEAKER_00
Yes, and I definitely prior to that, the first thing I do in the interview, um uh a few lists of questions, and then I tell them every horrible thing about the job. And would you be willing to do this? Would you be are this is the most stressful job? It's like I literally every bad thing about it, just just let you know. Yeah, I have them by the end, then I can tell them.
SPEAKER_02
Well, I mean, I I follow the interview guide and and I'll I'll go through each one and right at the beginning. Hey, this is a this is not an easy job, right? This is this is on the phone, 300 dials a day. I mean, luckily there's technology that helps with that. You're not doing it like this, you know, like I was at at Mother Merrill when I was cool calling, but um, you know, and we're giving and we're providing leads. So, you know, if you're if you're averse to being on the phone all day and having something dial out, this is not a fit, right? This is not a fit at all.
SPEAKER_00
I guess that's what I do. I I guess I go into the pitch on the phone. I go into the pitch prior to get them into the to to do the assessment, to get them into the interview, and then at the interview I scare them and then make them sell me something, something ridiculous.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, you do that whole sell me that pen. Sell me the bell. Yeah, and then we get brutal with them with objections and so what's the funniest one that or you know, crash and burn when you handed somebody the bell?
SPEAKER_00
It was somebody that had uh I'm already laughing, and I haven't even straight laced and okay, yes, and like was like very like robotic almost, and we had her sell us a beach ball. Like, okay, okay. Well, this beach ball is really good, ready, it's it's ready, it's fun for summer. The way she was like selling it, it's ready, fun for summer. She's like, I first I would come up with a with a slogan, and my slogan for this beach ball would be slogan fun time ready for summer. So take this beach ball, it's fun time, ready for summer. Like she went on. It was like a a pitch from Mad Men or something that she came up in her head, and she just she just was not the right fit. So she didn't say god balls. No, that would have been interesting.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, it would go there.
SPEAKER_00
But yeah, there's been some there's been some weird ones, and then we also do a panel, panel interview.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
So when it when we do sell those things, it's it is funny because they get nervous.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. I and I have to thank you because you did put this push the idea of the multi-person interview, which has been that's been huge because it it does seem like you get like I'll do the the the screening, right? VA does the screen and then sets up the appointment. So you have five scheduled. I mean, one will show up sometimes, two will show up. I've never more I have never had more than two of the five show up. I don't understand it. I did, I had, I had one I told you about it a few weeks ago. Two of them had family emergencies. Family emergencies, right? I mean, I'm like, wow, that's amazing. The the second one I said, that's amazing. The per the other person that was scheduled at the same time also has a family emergency.
SPEAKER_00
That's crazy. I got I got crickets. And you got you have to set up those hurdles. So it is funny that we we laugh about it all the time. Like we had five people the other day, two called in a couple hours before, and then like I don't think anyone showed up. So it's five with no with just no one showing up. They've been called multiple times. Um, they filled out the assessment, they've they even had a follow-up or a phone call to confirm the appointment. They did all this stuff, and then they just don't show up.
SPEAKER_02
I don't get it.
SPEAKER_00
I mean it's a shit job. Oh, I cursed. Dang it. I mean, really, it's checking the little cursed box. And I think that people don't realize that um, I mean, it's a it can be fun, but but oh, it is fun. There's a there's a tremendous amount of potential, but it's not cool. It was cool 20 years ago. I mean, everybody's gotta be kind of realistic about this. Uh it's pretty cool. You have a striper poster on your backdoor back when there's but what would do you think your kids would be like, Wow, guess what? I'm working in an insurance agency, or do you think they want to say, dude, I just I'm working at Google or I'm working for the startup? There's all this excitement, right? And there's all the social media, and you see all these glit glitz and glamour. I this is a more of an ancient industry, and it's not as it's not that glamorous. So, how do you put lipstick on the dinosaur? Well, you have to that's where you I mean, I think it goes back to the selling part. Like, how are you gonna sell it? What do you have in your agency that's different? Like, what are you doing that's different? Are are you just telling them to come in and make a whole bunch of calls? Like, that sucks.
SPEAKER_02
Right. And then you're grinding on them like how you only made 150, not 300. Right. That sucks. Okay, so how how do you make it fun? Like what you know, you you sell them on the great idea, but then they still come in and they still need to make a million phone calls and work a million leads. So, how do you how do you make that fun?
SPEAKER_00
Um, like we have daily meetings. I think it's important to get everybody out out of the out of their box for the day.
SPEAKER_02
Um do you have the meetings?
SPEAKER_00
We do it afternoon after lunch, because that's when people are tired.
SPEAKER_02
That's a fly.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, that was a bug. That bug is bugging me.
SPEAKER_02
Um that's why they're called a bug.
SPEAKER_00
And by no means do I have any of this completely figured out. I like trying a lot of different things, um, almost to a fault. But uh yeah, so we we do those. We we have like bells on everybody's desk, we do all kinds of incentives, all kinds of like bonus things. Um, whoever gets high sales for the week gets a hundred bucks. Try to do those short little goals. Um create like goals for the team goals that we can build upon so everybody knows, you know, kind of what's going on.
SPEAKER_02
I like the weekly, like the weekly goal instead of the monthly goal, because you can have that crappy week, and then you know, you get dejected, and now the month's dead. Well, what if you focus on a on the week? You know, focus on the week. You gotta get that 5,000 for the week, right?
SPEAKER_00
I think the week is the only way to go.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah.
SPEAKER_00
Month is too long, yeah. Because if somebody's crushing it the first week of the month, they're like, oh yeah, I'm trending for you know sixty thousand for the month.
SPEAKER_02
No, you got zero right now, buddy. You gotta start over.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, and then next week it's like, oh, I don't know, I can skate a little bit. It's like, no, no, no, we need to crush it. Try to crush it every week, and then those high weeks will help offset the low weeks, but right, yeah.
SPEAKER_02
Well, and if you don't crush your pipeline, like putting new ones and working those new leads today, then in two weeks you you're dead again. Right? It's always it's it's a huge, it's it's of huge importance to to be to balance that, right? The new stuff and then the stuff that you're moving towards call number 30. Yeah, it's gonna take that.
SPEAKER_00
And it's always important to, on the days that you are crushing it, make sure that you're doing the same amount of work the rest of the day. Yeah. The the gutter. Um, our EFS is uh amazing, Eddie. And he he always says, like, as soon as I sell something, I just lost someone in my pipeline. I have to refill it immediately. That's why he gets smart. Yeah, and he goes into for at least two referrals and he tries to at least double the pipeline. So he all he always tries to he looks at it from the pipeline standpoint rather than the point.
SPEAKER_02
What a great thing to put in the mind, right? Of of all of the producers is yeah, you great job, you got a sale, you just lost a hot lead. Yep. Imagine that hot lead just moved out of country, you know, it's the same thing. Yep, lost a hot lead. So where's the next hot lead coming from? It was so hot, so hot. Sizzle. Yeah. That's something, but it's just coffee talk. It's coffee talk. Hey, so if if you enjoyed this coffee talk, go ahead and click. What do they click? Subscribe, subscribe, make a comment. Subscribe, make leave a comment, put a little five-star review. Join the group. Join the group.
SPEAKER_00
There's a group over on uh the Book of Fashion, just a that's Facebook dudes and dudettes.
SPEAKER_02
There are a lot of dudes, so don't be intimidated if you're a dudette and you think it's a bunch of dudes.
SPEAKER_00
No, I would almost say that the dudettes have brought some giant nuggets of wit. Lau Laura Harris was uh I mean I need to listen to that ten times and write a book on that on just her cast. Put a bow on it and call it a dibity-doo. We gotta get her back.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. For Laura Harris part dih. Part yeah. Part d. Alright, and that's whoopyduck. All right, that's it.
SPEAKER_01
Has finding, training, and retaining the best insurance producers ever been your struggle? It's why Agency Vault built the Sales Strengths Identifier to uncover if candidates and current staff have the specific sales skills to get you top results. Try it free at www.agencyvault.com slash dudes. That's www.agencyvault.com slash dudes and assess your lowest performer for free. Try it now. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe.
SPEAKER_00
We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.