The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Welcome to the insurance! Hey Craig. Let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee talk. You know, talk about what? Talk, tortoise, whatever. Coffee talk. Coffee talk. Is this a needs diagnosis coffee talk?
SPEAKER_00
Okay, so Craig and I were just talking about um uh about policy reviews and what we both do in our offices. So Craig has a very uh streamlined system for it, and I think this would be great to uh record. So Craig's gonna do it on me, and this is basically what uh in his in his agency what he's doing for policy reviews, which ends up upping the coverage, he was saying, right? Upping the coverage, and then um they forget why they were pissed off in the first place.
SPEAKER_02
Right. So you you you said, you know, hey, they call in and they're pissed, and then we have to try to resell them and all this. And it's like, well, let's let's follow the same formula, the same seven steps on reselling them, if you want to call it that, as we do with when we actually acquire the new business, right? Because there's three strategies retention, acquisition, and development. And I'd call this kind of two of those. This is retention and this is development, because you're looking to keep the current client that's mad, and you're also gonna develop them because you're gonna look for additional lines and um increase their coverages, right? If it if it's best for them.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, and that's and that's the technical great side of it, but as far as an agency owner, like you just want a process that everybody follows that works. So this is what works for Craig. Yeah, yeah. This I have my own process, a little different, but I think that we're gonna move over to this because this is Yeah, I'm convincing convincing my co-host here. Yeah, buddy.
SPEAKER_02
So so um, all right. So I would just say ring, ring, ring.
SPEAKER_00
My my my hey, hey, Craig. Yeah. Uh my coverage is it's I mean, this is ridiculous. My rates keep going up.
SPEAKER_02
Oh man.
SPEAKER_00
I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_02
Huh? Change my rates. Okay, I'll I'm gonna I'll I'll wave my magic wand. No, actually, what I'm gonna do, if you don't mind, um it looks like we haven't updated your file in a while, Jason. So I'd like to I'd like to ask a few questions. If I have your permission, um, I'm gonna dive a little bit deeper than we have before. We have a new process that we're going through just to make sure you have the right coverage because I know it's important to get the best value, and I want to give you that. I want to wave the magic wand, but but before we do that, just in case, because I see you've you've been with us 12 years and I really, really appreciate your business. Um, I want to make sure that we have it right because things change. Fair enough?
SPEAKER_00
Fair. Is it gonna be long time? And I mean, I only have no more than 10 minutes.
SPEAKER_02
How about eight minutes?
SPEAKER_00
Eight minutes is better than 10. All right.
SPEAKER_02
Perfect. Perfect. So I have your permission to ask all these questions?
SPEAKER_00
Yes.
SPEAKER_02
All right, cool. So um currently you have 50,000, so you have 5100. Um, do you know what that means? Uh yeah, that's that's what it pays out, right? Yeah, yeah. Why is this? Oh, I'm gonna have to put the email. So put my email in. So I asked for permission, it's granted. Um, and then hey, so Jason, I'm curious, on a scale of one to ten, how happy are you with us right now? About uh four. That's why I called in. Four. Well, I know that we can do better than that, and I'm hoping that by the end of this, I've converted you. Um so you're giving me a four because you're up you you're not not liking the prize to want to get better rates, right? Right. Okay, cool. And when was the last time? You know what? I'll usually skip this. So I'll do a timeout. I usually just skip this in the review process, but I'll skip the uh asking them the last time they did a review was in person over the phone. So we just skip it, just click in, um, just say never, and we don't need to ask how they ended up with their current limits. So I'll just put a bunch of stuff. Uh, so I know you own your home. Do you have any idea about what it's worth market value? I have your your replacement cost, but that isn't always the same.
SPEAKER_00
Well, I I have a home in California, so about 140,000.
unknown
Okay.
SPEAKER_02
Really?
SPEAKER_00
They have homes for 140,000?
SPEAKER_02
Let's so 740? Yeah. Okay. Any other houses, uh, buildings, anything like that?
SPEAKER_00
Nope.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. So you're not really not doing any rentals or anything like that. Perfect. Um, and about how much do you owe on the house?
SPEAKER_00
About 450,000.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. So a little equity. Awesome. Congratulations. If something happened to you, would you like that 450 to pay it off, be paid off so your wife isn't stuck with the mortgage? Uh, sure. Okay. So I'm gonna have uh I have a partner that that handles that. He'll actually reach out and just talk to you a little bit about the um mortgage protection for that 450, okay? Okay, awesome. And you'll be as nice to him, you'll be as nice to him as you are to me. As long as he doesn't want to charge me more. Uh it's nothing. Big discounts. So uh perfect. Any other debt? Uh nope. Okay. And then any valuable items that we don't already have listed, jewelry, um anything like that.
SPEAKER_00
Uh I have a gold watch. Okay. About how much is it worth? About 40,000.
SPEAKER_02
Ooh, well, we should probably put that down here. So we're gonna put 40,000.
SPEAKER_00
I used to watch the Sopranos a lot.
SPEAKER_02
Huh. Well, good show. Who's your favorite character?
SPEAKER_00
Uh Vinny.
SPEAKER_02
Vinny. All right. Uh, and then you have the two cars. So you have the uh Lamborghini and the minivan. Who does your wife drive the minivan or the Lamborghini?
SPEAKER_00
Uh she has the Lamborghini, I have the minivan. Perfect.
SPEAKER_02
That's that's what I figured.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah. Yeah. And a 20 uh 2019 Lamborghini. You're getting the bad end of the deal there. Uh that's not what she's done.
SPEAKER_02
All right. So we have about uh what is that, 150,000 in vehicles? And your your car's worth 1,000, her car's worth 149.
SPEAKER_00
Right.
SPEAKER_02
A Lambo and um minivan. All right, cool. And I put minivan, doesn't really matter. Um, and then your stuff at your house. Like let's say you took your house, you pulled the roof off, you shook it upside down, all the stuff that falls out. What would all of that be worth? And you can ballpark it. We don't need to be perfect, okay. Any boats, RVs, other toys?
SPEAKER_00
Nope, I put it all on the Lambeau.
SPEAKER_02
Well, you know, sometimes you gotta make that kind of decision. Um, how about in your checking account? About how much liquid asset do you have? Liquid cash? 49,000. Okay. I'm gonna call timeout here. A lot of times, or sometimes somebody may be if you don't have rapport with them and they're a little upset still, they may give some pushback. And this is when you remind them that you asked for permission, and they said yes. So it's real important to ask for that permission up front because then they're more inclined to dive deeper. So, okay, here we go.
SPEAKER_00
I I'm not gonna why why do you want to get into my checking account?
SPEAKER_02
Jason, come on, at the beginning, remember I asked for your permission to ask these really important questions to make sure I can get the right coverage. That's about the coverage, and even more so, those liquid assets that you have, the 49,000 in the bank that I'm assuming you have, is the most liquid of your assets, right? So all of this other stuff is at risk, but the cash you have is most at risk in a lawsuit.
SPEAKER_00
Hmm. I thought you were asking that to make sure I could pay for like more expensive rates.
SPEAKER_02
Well, that too.
SPEAKER_00
Okay.
SPEAKER_02
Okay, so $49,000. And then how about in savings?
SPEAKER_00
Uh I that's we'll say that's one in the same.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. Uh, and then any investment accounts? Nope. Nope. Okay. How about CDs, not the music ones?
SPEAKER_00
Oh, because my CD collection, now that's about a thousand, nothing in CDs.
SPEAKER_02
Nothing in CDs. Do you have a how about an old job, like a 401k sitting at an old job? Anything like that?
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, 20, 20,000.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. Perfect. And it's at an old employer.
SPEAKER_00
Yes.
SPEAKER_02
Okay, cool. So actually, when Mike calls and he helps you with the uh mortgage protection, he gets you set up on that, he can help you with this because a lot of times those 401ks are in some pretty limited assets, and they may even have a wrap fee on them that we could get rid of. So just to plant the seed, I'm not gonna talk anymore about that, but I just wanted to let you know that that's that's an option.
SPEAKER_00
Is it the same wrap fee as vanilla ice would charge?
SPEAKER_02
Uh pretty close, yeah. Ice ice baby. And then uh income. How much about how much household income is there?
SPEAKER_00
Uh about 92,000.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. And we asked this, you may be wondering why do we ask that? Well, in depending on the state, uh up to sometimes up to 25% of your annual income is at risk for wage garniment, garnish garnishment in a uh personal injury lawsuit. So you have to be we we like to ask just to have that cushioned because it's important. We don't want to get in that predicament where money's coming out. And then uh yeah, last but not least, how about your current employer?
SPEAKER_00
Chuck E. Cheese.
SPEAKER_02
Chuck E. Cheese. All right, great place. Chucky. Do they have a uh do you know the HR person there? Uh very well. Very well, cool. Do they do they have AFLAC or anything like that? Health insurance?
SPEAKER_00
I don't I don't know.
SPEAKER_02
Okay. Perfect. Um, so you don't know. Okay, great. So so this is what we're seeing right now is you you have 50,000 of protection, right? So if you hit somebody, they got injured and um and you got sued, our our policy, the policy you currently have, would pay up to 50,000 for their injuries. Now you have about uh a uh million dollar exposure, right? So right now there's a gap of basically a million dollars. The recommendation that we have is actually right at a million, it's a million 49 because you have the 50. But um, so so what we really ought to do is actually change those coverages. We're a little bit short because you know, when you signed up 12 years ago, you didn't have these assets that you do. Now you do, and we're looking at about a million. And the easiest and best way to protect that is to raise your home, your auto coverage. We're gonna raise that to 250, 500. So that's gonna really protect you on that. I know you have the kids that are about to get licensed, so we want to really make sure that's safe. And then for about 25, 50 bucks a month, we're gonna be able to get you a million-dollar umbrella. So we're gonna throw that on top too. And I know that's an expensive umbrella. Well, it's you get a million of coverage for like 50 bucks a month.
SPEAKER_00
What's what's what does that mean? I that's not an actual umbrella, right?
SPEAKER_02
No, it's it, yeah. So I see what you're saying. It's no, it's not the thing that you lift and that gives you bad luck if you open it inside, but it's it's actually this this protection that overarches over all of your assets. So let's say you hit somebody, they get injured, uh, or they're you they're dead and you get sued for a million dollars. Well, your auto policy is gonna get exhausted at the 250, and then the uh the umbrella coverage is gonna kick in, and that's gonna protect otherwise think and and for 50 bucks on that, right? 50, let's say it's 50 bucks a month. I'm just guessing. Well, we'll work it up and get you the actual figure. But but let's say you don't have it, and now you're on the hook for a million. Would you pay 50 bucks to not have to pay the million?
SPEAKER_00
Uh yeah.
unknown
Right.
SPEAKER_02
I would have to pay. All day every day. All day every day. Yeah. You you'd actually probably pay $999,999.99, right? So anything less than that million, you come out ahead. And so it's it's really a no-brainer.
SPEAKER_00
Anything less than the best would be a felony.
SPEAKER_02
That's what they say.
SPEAKER_00
Vanilla. Vanilla vanilla.
SPEAKER_02
Way to really tie it together. So so now knowing that you gave us a four, it's not really gonna be much of a difference to get this, plus that umbrella, but at least we're gonna have the right coverage. Would you still give us the four, or where do you say we are now?
SPEAKER_00
Uh I would probably I would definitely give more. Um, I'd give you a 10 if that happened, you could save me. Save right.
SPEAKER_02
So, so I totally appreciate that. Thank you. Um, so we'll get this worked up uh before we actually push the button on the on the umbrella. I want to give you the great news about how much it is, and then we'll get that in force. But if you could do me a favor, um, we have a Google revamp, uh, Google review link. I'm gonna email that to you, or I can text it, whichever's better. Would you be good with giving us five stars on Google?
SPEAKER_00
I think so. Now, what is Google?
SPEAKER_02
That's coffee talk.
SPEAKER_00
There's some curveballs at you.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah. So no, but but um, so so now that we actually did that, I mean what Jason. Yeah. I like it. Yeah, I like it. I mean it works, it works, and then even if they don't make any changes, they're usually happy at the end of this. And you explain why it goes up. I mean, we all talk about frequency and and the cost of the cost of claims and all the yada yada yada, all the stuff that causes the price to go up, but right now we're giving them value, right? When you give them something, they're willing to pay for it. If they called, you know, some other place, likely this isn't gonna happen. And they're gonna fight, they're gonna try to either lower coverages, which is never a good idea, or almost always not a good idea, or they're gonna try to find some additional discounts or whatever, which I think looks kind of sketchy, also, because it's like, well, if you didn't have if you could have given me those before, why didn't you give it to me?
SPEAKER_00
Right. No, this is a for this form for people that can't see it, is awesome and it just walks you through it. How do we how does everybody get this form?
SPEAKER_02
So it's it's part of the whole agency vault package. So um it just comes with it. Yeah, so it's it's one of the newer, yeah, newer, newer things all built, it does the calculations. Um, so if you haven't seen it, it's um yeah, I believe in the in the current uh special that we have going, you get it, it's all included. So this is included with it. Sounds awesome. Yeah. I hope that was helpful. That was good. Did we talk about do we talk about dogs?
SPEAKER_00
No, oh Doras. My my my accent's horrible on that. I gotta work it. I gotta put in some time. I will see you next week.
SPEAKER_01
So has finding, training, and retaining the best insurance producers ever been your struggle? It's why Agency Vault built the sales strengths identifier to uncover if candidates and current staff have the specific sales skills to get you top results. Try it free at www.agencyvault.com slash dudes. That's www.agencyvault.com slash dudes and assess your lowest performer for free. Try it now. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance deals. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.