The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
Shoot Us A Message!The World Famous Insurance Dudes Dudes chat over Coffee!Oh man, this week was CRAZY! But you know what we grew, we hustled and we coached. We talk about the secrets to success through giving and receiving help!For All Things Related To Being An Insurance Dude or Dudette, Incredible Tips, Amazing Tools, and Valuable Resources, Check Out The Insurance Dudes Hub!-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------Support the showHey there! ...
Welcome to the insurance hey crack. Let's get into some coffee talk. I love it. I love doing some coffee talk. You know, talk about what clothes. Whatever. It's coffee talk. Coffee talk.
SPEAKER_03
Is that better? Boom. Five mics, you know. No, I'm just kidding.
SPEAKER_00
I'm telling you, almost every episode, right, Craig? I'm like, I forget to plug in the mic. I'll plug in all this stuff and then just the mic cable.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah. That's true. I literally said I have for mics. So to make sure I'm on the right one, it does tape. I gotta remember to I gotta remember to switch it, but well, so so yeah.
SPEAKER_02
I let me finish. So can I finish the the thing? Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt. I didn't mean to interrupt. Oh, it's all good. That's on you. We just interrupt each other the whole time. Um wait, hold on.
SPEAKER_03
Let me interrupt you, Craig. Do I need to have a cup of coffee right now? Or do we I don't have I don't have my detail. You got something. Hold on. Go with a can of seltzer's next best thing. Perfect.
SPEAKER_02
It's a weird episode of coffee cluck. Welcome to coffee clock. We got Josh Boog. Love it. All right. I won't interrupt you anymore, Craig. No, it's it's fine. Now I can't even remember what I was talking about. No, but yeah. So it so the so the episode came on, and I thought, you know, hey, I'll reach out to this guy. What the heck? You know, and so uh being an insurance dude, I just I just called him. He or he he said I could call him, gave drop the number. I give him a jingle and I said, Look, I want to do a podcast. I I have no idea how to even turn my computer on. What do I do? And so he like reverse engineered how to do this. And so the next, I don't know, it was pretty quickly, right? I think I I got I grabbed um who was the very first, I think it was that an attorney. So I tried to do it. Yeah, so I uh Elizabeth, um, and she's in New Orleans, she's she's awesome. I still talk to her, which is so fun, right? That's the fun thing about this, is you just end up meeting all these people, including you, right? You're the first person I met via the podcast, and then then I asked Jason to come on, and you know, the rest is history, but um yeah, it was it was awesome. I mean, you you helped create this thing.
SPEAKER_03
Well, hey man, I'm happy to help. I still want to grab tacos sometime. You're right down the road from me, right?
SPEAKER_02
And we definitely have better tacos than Tucson, so you need to come down here.
unknown
Yes.
SPEAKER_02
It's gotta be on a Tuesday.
SPEAKER_03
Josh, what inspired you to do this? So we um it's actually okay. So let me say, I've considered or I've I've thought about doing a podcast for a couple years, but I didn't really ever have a like a I don't know, anything really driving me to do it. I I basically I couldn't find an excuse to make it, you know, work. So anyway, um in January we started an aggregator type, I call it an anti-aggregator, but it's an aggregator. And um when we did that, we did it in conjunction with the podcast so that we could have a way to basically get the word out. Although do I do a terrible job of actually plugging it? Um, but that that's why we started the podcast.
SPEAKER_00
Because that was just the excuse to to start doing it.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, yeah. Basically. Yeah, it is. It's fun. It's time consuming though. Man, I you guys probably don't edit your own stuff though, do you? Dude, I uh yes. Oh, do you? Okay, so you know, you know, yes, yeah, it's crazy.
SPEAKER_00
My wife's my wife's pregnant. We have a one a one-year-old, a three-year-old, and or no, a one-year-old, a four-year-old, and a seven-year-old. And it's just it's madness. We're we're growing the agency, we're doing all this stuff. So at night, I'm like, oh, I gotta finish this stuff, like trying to get it on YouTube and uh ripping the audio is the a little bit easier, but dude, yeah, it crazy.
SPEAKER_02
It is time just so time consuming, right? Like chopping it up and then and then sitting there waiting for it just to load. You're like, oh, and it's just yeah, but it's the things we have to do for our for our listeners. Yeah, we're so thankful for them.
SPEAKER_03
Do it for the team. So what are are we are we just just talking today? Is there a topic? There's or am I the topic? Is this it?
SPEAKER_00
This is it. This is it. One thing I was telling Craig that I wanted to do is I thought it'd be really cool to all talk about like what's what's some of the things that we've learned, right? What's or that's gotten us excited with all these great minds that we've talked to.
SPEAKER_02
I'll I'll tell you, I'll jump in and interrupt everybody and tell you that um the the episode that really got me super excited about doing this was the Nick Ayers episode on um on your thing. Because it was like he was dropping just tidbits of like just a little tickle of of just incredible knowledge, you know, like the just the the piece, what is he says something about the like the YouTube ad, if you pay for if they don't watch it for over 30 seconds, it's free, yeah, right? And and it's like, whoa, wait, what you know? I rewound that and listened to it like five times. I'm wait a minute. So okay, I mean that's huge, that's that's huge information right there, right? Totally, totally. If you have a branding ad and you want them to leave before 30 seconds, you have a free ad. For sure, right?
SPEAKER_03
You put your logo out, right? And then you just make it totally terrible so everyone can.
SPEAKER_02
Terrible at second 20, you know, or like fiend, fiend. Yeah, what have you yeah, for me?
SPEAKER_03
So I've um a lot of the episodes I've done have been surrounding this kind of like new business or lead gen, right? It's like hot topic all the time. You can't go wrong with it. Yep. And so um I guess in the past, I would hear somebody talk about something, some new thing or something I hadn't thought of, and I would immediately jump to, man, I gotta start doing that. Man, I gotta start doing that, you know, and then like kind of get sidetracked from what I'm doing and and head towards that thing, and I'd just kind of be all over the place. But one thing that I'm I've really been finding is that there are so many options, and and not all of them are you can't do them all, I guess, is one thing. So, right, so pick pick what you do well, pick what you want to do, focus on that and stay in your lengths. If you go nuts and try to do everything, you're not gonna be successful at really much, or you're not gonna be very successful at anything.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, there's a lot of ways to skin a cat, right?
SPEAKER_03
Ton of them, man.
unknown
Ton of them.
SPEAKER_03
Have you ever skin a cat?
SPEAKER_00
No, I I actually don't think that that's probably is that a PC saying nowadays? I wouldn't admit it. I wouldn't admit it if I had.
SPEAKER_02
Do people skin cats?
SPEAKER_03
I don't know.
SPEAKER_00
I feel like maybe in other countries.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, probably.
SPEAKER_00
Is that a thing? Is that just a is that it just an American, you know, dumb thing to say.
SPEAKER_02
I can tell you that. It'd be offensive to say that they do skin cats in other countries to somebody who will be offended.
SPEAKER_03
Maybe maybe not. You never know. We'll find out.
SPEAKER_02
We'll test it. Let's test that.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, no, but you're you're 100% right. There's you learn so much from all this, and it's like, oh, I want to do that. To your point, Craig, how many times have you ran a YouTube ad since then and gotten that free ad? A few. Did you? Yeah, I have. You you've have you dabbled or did you go all in? I've dabbled.
SPEAKER_02
I've dabbled. I'll I'll tell you, so I have an understanding of Facebook ads and and how to run ads in Facebook. At least I did until they've this most recent iteration where they've changed some stuff. But the the stuff behind the YouTube ads is very challenging. It is challenging. They've created it to be very confusing, so that you need to hire people like Nick Ayers to teach you how to do it. It is got two bugs.
SPEAKER_03
It's really hard. And yeah, Nick, man, he's the guy.
SPEAKER_00
Jason, what have you learned? Um gosh, uh selfishly, I love marketing. So selfishly, like I love getting on the marketing dudes that get that do those deep dives into, you know, like Nick Ayers or uh really I love the way Bobby Bobby stocks is that scaled his business, is so interesting. Um what have I learned? Gosh, I guess a lot. I guess I learned that I like doing this more than selling insurance. No, it is yeah, go ahead. No, but I mean, honestly though, like you learning about the way everybody does everything is so cool.
SPEAKER_03
It is, and it's really cool being able to talk to all these people that you probably otherwise wouldn't get a chance to talk with. You know, yeah, you get to kind of like form these, I wouldn't say they're not deep relationships, at least on the outset, but you get to form these relationships and kick it off. And like, you know, when when I see any of these people I've interviewed, I feel like I'm gonna need to hug them and be like, how's it going? How's the thing? You know, what's new, whatever. Yeah, start that conversation.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, yeah, totally. Yeah, we um we're so lucky. We took we we this has been like so. Tuesdays now is like our our day that we just go all in. We try to line up as many podcasts as we can, and we got to do a couple uh big hitters today, and one was Dr. Alex from Mentor Box, which was just super cool.
SPEAKER_02
Um wax on, wax off.
SPEAKER_00
What is the jingle?
SPEAKER_03
What are we listening to there?
SPEAKER_00
Somebody in the office old this is what we have on everybody's desks.
SPEAKER_02
I gotta guess that is great. Shiny auto sold that's a sold button.
SPEAKER_00
Yeah, go on Amazon. Just ding ding ding, bells, bells for sales. You like that?
SPEAKER_03
I like it. We used to have a uh when I was an all-state agent back in the day. No way, yeah. It was like, man, 10 years ago, I I moved over to the independent side, something like that around there. So I was an all-state agent for three-ish years right in there. But we had an easy button. Like, you know, remember Staples that had the easy button? Like you hit it, that was easy. Um, we used to hit that every time there was a sale in the office. So life policies is that what got you over the hump with the life policies for the year? Dude, I never I never got there, I never hit my life goal, not once.
SPEAKER_00
Sad it's crazy. You gotta like honestly, like we partner our EFS is just awesome. Oh, yeah. Without him, it there's no way. Yeah, because you can't again, you can't spread yourself too thin. Like, you can't do everything fantastic, right? Yeah, or you can't grow. I mean, there's something that's going to, and I like to grow. I like this, I the sell for me is fun. Like, I like bells going off.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, that's the best best thing.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, this is the best thing. I really so we have two offices. We have one in Arizona and we have one in Washington. And we've wanted to, and I I haven't found a solution for this yet, but we wanted to have a um a dedicated screen in each office with a live ticker of you know, uh like monthly premium sold, daily premium sold, or whatever that both agencies were contributing to. But I haven't found a solution for it. I think that would be awesome. Agency zone. Agency, yeah. Agency zone, Zoom. Oh, agency zoom. Oh, they do that, dude.
SPEAKER_02
That's that's what it is, dude. It'll be the oh Tolga. You have the independent one, so it's even better. And they're building some agency stuff, yeah. They're building out a bunch of stuff. Agency Zoom, talk to Tolga. He's one of our guests, and that's a great episode, too. Forgot about that. That was a we haven't even dropped that one yet. Coming soon. Oh, wait, it will it will have already been dropped by the time that people will hear this.
SPEAKER_00
So I'm speaking from the but to your point, yeah, it's got the it's got the scoreboard and everything. E automatically sends out emails when people do sales or any kind of books, life appointments, or whatever. It's like it's fun. So it lit like you can have a dedicated screen in the office, and it's yes, you get one of those little um USB computer sticks, throw it, yeah, throw it in a TV, throw the big TV on the wall, and you're golden.
SPEAKER_03
I love it.
SPEAKER_00
Man, dude, do that. Yeah, it's fun.
SPEAKER_03
That's great.
SPEAKER_00
That's another good person to talk to on your on your cast, it's Tolgan. Yeah, he'll go on.
SPEAKER_02
Yeah, he's awesome. Very awesome.
SPEAKER_00
Check out agency zoom, see everything that it can do, and then you're gonna have all this like, wow, how did you do all this stuff?
SPEAKER_03
No, I feel like um I'm the I'm the wrong person to have uh people who are offering a product on because I'm like, yeah, I need that.
SPEAKER_02
I don't allow to talk to any salespeople anymore.
unknown
Right.
SPEAKER_00
Um I just I didn't realize that you've been doing this for 10 or 13 years now.
SPEAKER_03
Yeah, dude. And before that, I was uh life and health licensed, so I was even selling health insurance prior to that in my very brief, brief stint as a uh financial planner. Terrible. I was terrible.
SPEAKER_02
Where where were you financial planner? Did we talk about this?
SPEAKER_03
No, we didn't. Uh I don't think so. I came from Merrill. Oh, did you? So eh, I use the term financial planner very loosely when I talk about my history. No, it was um Waddell and Reed. Oh, okay. So nothing against it. It's just like, eh, you know, could I?
SPEAKER_00
I thought you were gonna say I helped my 13-year-old sister open her piggy bank and separate the change.
SPEAKER_03
I was um I I uh started out as an account. I I graduated with my degree in finance, um, business administration with folks in finance. And while I was in college, I started working at a big four accounting firm just as an intern. And that turned into a job preparing taxes. And I did that for like five years, two years during school, three years after, and then I got married and I was like, I freaking hate this. No way I'm gonna do this for the rest of my life. And I did not want to get into a spot where I was um like I couldn't replace my income, and so I was looking for something else to do, and man, it I think I must just be terrible at writing resumes and and applying for jobs. I could not even get an interview, and so somebody from uh Waddell and Reed reached out to me and I was like, yeah, I really don't want to do that. And anyway, I ended up there.
SPEAKER_00
So well, you went on the right path, sounds like you're doing well. Yeah, it's great, man. You went indie. I did, I did, which is nice, right?
SPEAKER_03
It's nice, you know. It's okay. I given anybody's situation, I would always say I think going independent is probably a better option, but it's not to say that captives don't have a ton to offer, especially newer agents. And and there's just things, there's training and and like concepts and and ease of doing the business. Like you got one carrier, you can learn that product and just know what somebody's rate's gonna be. You know what I mean? You can know the ins and outs of everything, do it in your sleep. On the independent side, you're talking about multiple companies. You have to know all the different billing screens, all the different you know, underwriting stuff, like who takes a horse, who takes you know, whatever, all that kind of stuff. It's a lot, man. It's a lot more to manage. And you have to pick all, yeah, you have to pick all your own like agency management stuff, all your own automation stuff, all your own phone systems, like like nobody hands you anything. You have to figure it all out.
SPEAKER_02
So a lot more unless you get an anti-aggregator, unless you get an anti-aggregator, baby. Make a good t-shirt. It should say that above that lion on your shirt.
SPEAKER_03
Anti and then underneath aggregator.
SPEAKER_02
I like it.
SPEAKER_03
Or anti on the front, aggregate something. We'll figure out well.
SPEAKER_00
Thanks for jumping on here with us, Josh. We should do more of this. It's a long quaffy talk.
SPEAKER_03
It's a quick sorry. You get three people that host podcasts on one again.
SPEAKER_01
Has finding, training, and retaining the best insurance producers ever been your struggle? It's why Agency Vault built the sales strengths identifier to uncover if candidates and current staff have the specific sales skills to get you top results. Try it free at www.agencyvault.com slash dudes. That's www.agencyvault.com slash dudes and assess your lowest performer for free. Try it now. Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dates. Hey, please subscribe.
SPEAKER_00
We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.