The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
DOUBLE THE PRODUCTION half the Staff | Macro Changes 4 Mega Results with Eric Brown
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey, dude, who do we have to that?
SPEAKER_03Earth round in Ohio. Let's go ahead and have a need to be processed.
SPEAKER_02Let's do this.
SPEAKER_04Look at that. Are we getting like a smoke intro? I want smoke and lasers right now. That would be great. What is that? Is that a map of the old world? Where's the intro V deck? Oh, let me queue up intro these deck.
SPEAKER_03Now we're alienating all of the non-Star Wars decks. I love the uh build-up right now.
SPEAKER_04I'm feeling it. Yeah, it's basically great. It's a good build. It might be it too.
SPEAKER_03I forgot that we're recording.
SPEAKER_04This is gonna be a good intro, by the way. Uh I mean.
SPEAKER_03Okay, let me up-prouse the wall. Is that the sensor up there? Oh what's next to the Goonies map? What is that next to the Goonies map? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04That's the key from the movie. From what movie? From Goonies? From Goonies. Eric. What's up, guys? How you doing?
SPEAKER_05Good, man. How are you?
SPEAKER_04Good. Dude. So you came on, it was just your office. And I was like, dude, this is gonna be a rad intro. So we're gonna queue up some intro music. I was thinking smoking lasers.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we're we wanted smoking lasers. Well, you know, so did Dr. Evil. Ooh. Freaking sharks with freaking laser beams.
SPEAKER_01Right. Right, exactly. So, you know, but unfortunately, you're gonna have to settle for me.
SPEAKER_04Dude, you're doing you're doing uh webinars and podcasts non-stop these days.
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah, my my schedule's been pretty busy. I don't I don't know what the deal is. For some reason, I think it's because I say the F-word a lot and it makes people laugh. I don't know.
SPEAKER_04You're rocking the tribe, you're rocking um ASA.
SPEAKER_01Well, yeah, and uh I mean I I don't know. I wouldn't say that I'm rocking ASA. I just you know, but they invited me out to come talk and I was super honored to do it. Um I don't know. It's just dude, it's just that thing, man. You know, when when you get in that groove and you're able to help people, um, that's that's your duty to help. You know what I mean? Like you should do something every day to to lift somebody else up. So Yep. Sound like Dave Williams. Dude, I'll tell you what, man, that that dude is he's he's awesome. You know what I mean? Yeah, yeah. So inspiring.
SPEAKER_03Hashtag inspire a nation.
SPEAKER_01Right. I know. I was I I got I was super down. He uh he reached out to me to do um his uh that day challenge uh you know for his brother passing, and I was all set to do it, and uh a bunch of stuff went down that week, and my my week just it completely got away from me, and I wasn't able to get it done. So I I gotta I have a makeup day to make sure I still get it.
SPEAKER_03I did it the day after.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, and that's what I'm gonna have to do. So, but I'm still committed to getting it done for him.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, same here. I I was gone. I was gone and um I was off the grid, and I was like, oh crap. Yeah, uh I'm uh I'm with you on that. Yeah, so it uh but you know, hey, exciting times. Exciting times. How's the agency going?
SPEAKER_01Uh so far so good. Uh I mean you guys have seen I I I stole some uh advice from uh from from a boy Jay Atkins there. He says, you know, take massive action. And uh I think I I took about the most massive action anybody could take uh concerning my agency. So um, you know, hey, it we're getting there.
SPEAKER_03Can we talk about that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. Talk about that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I yeah, how how did that work out? Or or how how how has that worked worked out integrating Stephanie into your into your agency, having her come in? I mean, that's some pretty powerful credentials and a huge land. I remember when you told me and and I was like, what?
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah. Um, no, and and that's exactly it, man. Uh she she's been an absolute game changer. Um, you know, it is one of those things of uh you can't pass up the opportunity. So uh, you know, when when that opportunity presented itself, I I absolutely had to take it. Um, but uh dude, she's been she's been a game changer. I mean, everybody kind of knows her legend. Uh anybody that spoke to her or at least knows her name, and I can tell you it is absolutely true. Um that I've I've never met a coach better than her. Um, and she's just overnight. I mean, she came in and instantly changed the culture of the agency.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome.
SPEAKER_01Awesome.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, talk about details of that because uh, you know, everybody hears, everybody thinks that there's a silver bullet uh with funding agency or sales or anything, right? And it's all comes down to processes and actually actionable things that we can do. So, what does she do that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, and so you guys are gonna have her on, so I don't want to steal her thunder. Um, but just from what I see from like kind of a high-level looking down, um, is man, she's just she is relentless. I mean, she just she doesn't let off the gas all day long. I mean, she she beats me into the office every single day. Uh, normally I'm driving to work and she's already, you know, texting me like, hey, I need to log into this. What's your password? Or you know, whatever. And I'm like, holy crap, man, like, all right, hold on, I'm I'm getting there. Um but it so you know, she's the first one here, the last one to leave every single day. Um, and she is she is on my staff. Uh, you know, if they don't close, if they don't one call close uh a prospect, she makes me uh she makes them download the phone call and send it to her so she can listen to it and coach them on it. So every single call that they get on her. If they don't call close it, yep, every single call. If they don't one call, close it, they have to download it and send it to her. And uh, you know, and then she'll go through it, she knows what to look for. Um and she immediately coaches them on it. Um, you know, and that's the thing. I mean, as as soon as like she's online listening to their calls live as they're going on, uh, you know, which with the VoIP systems, everybody has that capability. So if you're not doing that, uh I guess my question would be why? I I know my answer at least was because as an agency owner, you know, you get bogged down and you're like, oh, I'm too busy, I'm too busy, I'm too busy. But then when the numbers start to slide, it's nobody's fault but our own. So you have two choices either you make the time, you let your agency fail, or you hire somebody that that that's their sole responsibility in life. Um, but you know, I mean, just in the impact she's had in in two weeks with me now, uh, you know, the the the cost, the additional cost of having somebody on staff to do that is easily going to be paid for by the increase in production. That's awesome. How how have you changed? Um I feel useless for the first time in my life. Um, you know what though, and and actually it's a good so I I read every single morning, right? So I'm I'm a huge proponent. I think you should read a book every day. And so the the best advice I got was read 13 pages every day. Because if you read 13 pages a day, it's something like 80 books a year that you'll end up reading. It's insane. Um so so that's what I've been doing. And I I had just finished um in May, I had just finished uh what's the extreme ownership from uh uh Just Willy, yeah. And so you know he talks in there about leadership, and he's like, if you're a leader and your team needs you, you're a horrible leader. Like you have failed. If your team needs you, you have you have completely missed the mark. Um, you should your team should want you, but they should never need you, right? And so up until this point, over the last you know, 15, 16 months of growing my agency, uh I always felt like my team needed me. If I was gone, it felt like my office was sort of falling apart, you know, and stuff like that. And so I restructured here in the last two weeks. I I moved uh my uh Nicole, who is here in my office. I moved her over to service. So she is my service manager and and the actual office manager just managing like day-to-day operations, which is the absolute she is phenomenal. Anybody that's emailed me, texted me, messaged me, stuff like that, normally you get a response from Nicole. Um, and uh so so she is phenomenal, making sure I get where I need to be when I need to be there, and making sure that that my customers are taken care of and the agency is running smooth. And then Nicole came or and then Stephanie came in, took over the sales team, coaching, leads, analyzing leads, all that kind of stuff from me. And and so for the first time it's been weird walking around and you like pop in and ask Stephanie, say, Hey, you know, what do you need for me? Nothing. Okay. Then you go in and you talk to Nicole, like, Nicole, man, what do you what do you need? Nothing. Go talk to my sales team, like, hey, what can I do for you guys? And they're like, nothing. And I'm like, well, Dan, I mean, like, what do I do? So so now, yeah, legit, like the now my focus can be on on actually setting the vision and growing the agency.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome.
SPEAKER_03So, so with this is interesting because with with Nicole, what was she was a good producer, like writing a lot of business?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, um, she would I would say above average, um, but she was consistent. I mean, she was my rock. So uh you know, that's that's hard when you when you make that transition and you pull somebody that that consistently delivers results, and you say, okay, you know what, I'm gonna do something else with you. Um, that's a tough call to make. But did you assess her? Uh no, she actually she started with me probably three weeks after I unlocked my doors.
SPEAKER_03I'd be curious to see her assessment, but but what we've what I've seen a lot of and and what I think is important is is having those sales personalities in the service arena. Because at the end of the day, there's there's still sales, right? It's a different kind of sales. But if you can have the person at the top being the you know, the sales manager, a really strong salesperson, then they're creating that culture in your service team, right? When it's okay, I mean we write half our stuff is from service calls, right? Half of the items that we write in this place is is service calls. I mean, that's gimme's and we need those, right? Yep. We won't get into the challenges with the other thing, but uh the hot topic.
SPEAKER_01But so yeah, it's it's it's been a good transition. Like I said, we're only uh actually about a week and a half into it now, but I'm I'm curious to see. I think June's shaping up. It is already, it's shaping up to be our best month we've ever put on the books. And uh, you know, realistically, we're down to about two and a half LSPs um and no outright back when I had six. So um, you know, yeah, so it's it's it's starting to kind of come around. And now I'm excited because we've got a couple other prospects in the pipeline, and that's where you know, that sales strengths identifier, that's where that's been huge, is because it's it's so easy. It's so easy to integrate into my my hiring. And as soon as they get on and they complete that assessment, boom, it comes to me, it goes to Stephanie, and she just goes through and there is a legitimate numerical value put on every single strength. And so she can just run through it, say, you know what, this person's strong, this person isn't. I'm gonna call this person, I'm not gonna call this one. Um, so we've made some hires, we got people licensing, and I'm like, man, you know, if if my staff is gonna write what they're trending for this month already with just two people, and I add two more, we're gonna be killing it.
SPEAKER_04So that's great, man. And you gotta build a a solid foundation to bring new people into. So it's way better to start with a strong base and build upon that.
SPEAKER_01Yep, and that's that's what was tough. Like this year, I I wiped out my agency. Uh, you know, I walked in June uh January 1st with uh eight staff members and took it down to three. So it uh but you know, and that's it. I mean, you got to build that strong foundation and build it back up.
SPEAKER_04That's it, man. And the stronger the foundation, to your point, and like the way you've hired, and you you do have extra people that are now uh assisting the sales and all this stuff. I mean, talk about building a strong foundation. And to your point, if they're writing what six people did, imagine each person's gonna substantially help.
SPEAKER_01And and that's it. I mean, you know, you you talk about you get each producer writing $45,000, $50,000 a month. Uh, you know, I mean, with with four producers, you're writing $200,000 in premium a month. I mean, that's that's just that's huge, especially in Ohio, because Ohio, like you, you know, Craig in Arizona, man. I think you guys are right there with us in your cost and premium. I mean, having having low premium states is is rough because you just you just you have to write a ton of business to get that premium up there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Sometimes I long for Texas.
SPEAKER_01I know, right? I know I talk to Anthony all the time, and uh, you know, I I have to write double the items he does to equal his premium.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Yeah, that's crazy. But it could also be challenging on the close with the yeah, it's it's it's just something else. It is something else. So you go sorry.
SPEAKER_04So a lot of agencies, you know, we start with we're doing all the work, right? Then you have like one or two people helping you, and you're always that piece that you're talking about. You're that piece that kind of the glue that holds it together. So I think one of the biggest challenges for me uh when I started go going out of that was like how do you how do you build that? And what metrics are you holding people accountable to on all ends, whether it be service or sales or like like what is the exact process to follow? And I think that that could help a lot of people get out of that mindset of I have to be here. Like it's I have to do everything.
SPEAKER_01Right. So uh, you know, I mean, I like to leverage as much knowledge as I can from other agents. Uh so just FYI disclaimer, none of these are original Eric Brown ideas, these are all over from other people. Um, but you know, so you just reach out to where people's strengths are. I mean, when I started, I'm like, okay, you know what? I'm gonna revamp service and we're just gonna we're gonna tear it down and we're gonna completely because when you looked at service, and I'm like, okay, I'm retaining it at 82, 83 percent on my book. If I can bump that up to 90 percent on seven percent, even on a million dollars in premium, you know what I mean? Like you're talking what seven uh seventy thousand dollars that you don't have to write now, like that's huge. So you know um being able to do stuff like that. Um so like I just I reached out to Laura Harris, you know. I'm like, let's let's reach out to the process queen because arguably there's nobody better in the service game. And uh so I reached out to her and I'm like, man, hey, what can you help me with? Give me some ideas and some advice. And and so you know, she gave me stuff like um, you know, looking at the averages of um how many reviews each of your service staff can get done on a daily basis. So, like implementing those minimums. Um on my sales staff, I have minimum, and I think all of us have that, right? We have minimum performance qualifiers on sales staff, so you gotta make this many outbound phone calls, this much talk time, this many quotes, and and those are metrics to hold them accountable to. But what do we do for service?
unknownRight?
SPEAKER_01We're like, oh, just go love our customer. That's it, period, end of story, right? And we just kind of leave it open. Well, how do you measure that? So, like now, we implemented um, you know, you have to do an average of three to four uh reviews every single day. So if you don't do any on Monday because the phone's ringing off the off the hook, then you've got to pick it up somewhere else in the rest of the week. And that's again, that's a minimum. You know what I mean? Like that's a that's that is the bare minimum to keep your job, is you need to be doing three to four every single day. Um you know, so looking at that, uh in incentivizing my service staff now, uh, we're paying them bonuses for leads or for every uh item that they transfer to the sales team over 10 items. So uh, and we just tiered it, just like a lot of people tier their LSP's commissions, you know, we're like, hey, we'll pay you eight bucks per item that you transfer over to sales after you get 10 items, you know, and it's retroactive all the way back to the first one. And then once you get to 15 items, we pay you 10 bucks an item. And once you get to 20 items, we'll pay you 12 bucks an item. And then once you get to 25 items, you know, and we just kept ramping it up until you get to 40 items. Uh, and and so imagine if you have two service people, right? If they're each transferring 40 items to sales every single month, and you have two service people, that's 80 items a month. So even if you're paying them uh a bonus on transferring those over, what would you be paying for leads that are closing at 60% from a lead vendor, right? Uh, you'd be paying, oh my god, you everybody'd probably be willing to pay 50 bucks a lead for that easily. So why aren't we giving that to our service staff?
SPEAKER_04And how much more do those clients stick when they have their buddies that are at the same agency and every, you know, it's like right, yeah.
SPEAKER_01So so now I've got clients that you know I'm increasing my bundling rate, which because I'm I'm enhanced compensation, so I don't get that broaden your book, you know, for the all-state agents yet. But you know, if if you're off of enhanced compensation, yeah, you're gonna get that broaden your book bonus. You're driving your retention numbers up, we're starting to get life cross cells, I mean, and we're starting to get all this stuff, and so those customers are retaining better, we're getting more referrals, we're taking care of whole households. I mean, so you're just you're solving so many problems.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. And you're out, you're out reading books. That's it. Read books, meditate daily, read books.
SPEAKER_01Awesome. Where are you at in your agency? What year? Uh, I'm in month uh 19. Just started my 19th month in business.
SPEAKER_03What's the ECP length in Ohio?
SPEAKER_01Uh 44 months.
SPEAKER_0344? Yep. Okay.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I still got a decent time left. Um, and then we were gonna try and open our second ECP this summer. Uh, you know, but again, Laura told me she's like, hey man, don't scale chaos. You know what I mean? So I'm like, that's a good point. So we we choked back on that. Um, you know, and I let I let the mothership know, I was like, hey, look, I don't think I'm ready to open my ECP yet, which uh they stepped back because I think I'm probably the first agent that ever told them that. Of uh, you know, hey, let's pump the same thing this year. Right. So um, so we pumped the brakes a little bit, and uh, you know, but I'm like, let's let's get these processes put so that when I open those doors on on the second location, man, I'm just it's like lightning, you know, we'll be like a shotgun blast coming off.
SPEAKER_04Totally. Now, do you have everything in a process manual?
SPEAKER_01We do. Yep, everything. I mean, from the way that you answer the phone to check and voicemails to onboarding customers, all of it. Every single thing is in there.
SPEAKER_04Awesome. And that's obviously an evolving thing.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Yeah, as we get new technology, obviously it starts to evolve. And then now, like I'm rewriting it again because now with the addition of Stephanie, she took a lot of processes away from other people. So you know, it's it's all right. You gotta make some changes.
SPEAKER_04No, it's good. Uh the the the process manual thing. We've always had uh it kind of all separate. So now we're really making a cohesive, a cohesive one in the agency, and it really is a game changer. When when when there are when every question is answered on a how to do it, uh and b um where to find it, right? Then there's no in expectations. I think expectations are huge for everybody to be very clear.
SPEAKER_01And and that's the thing I noticed too a lot on like when people hire, um the the big changes I made to hiring. One was uh seeing how like in in again, once once you sign up for like the sales strength identifier, right? You get that that hiring manual, um or interview manual, this one right here that sits on my desk. So um, yeah, it literally sits next to my phone. What's that? I didn't have to ask for it. No, well, it sits next to my phone because every once in a while you get a person that calls in, hey, you hired? Yeah, great. Let you know, let's talk real quick. And I just run over there. And uh, but you know, doing your whole thing there at the end when you're like, man, you know what? The interview's gone great, you sound great, you seem like a great kid. I just don't think you're a right fit for this agency. And just see what they do. Um, that that's been huge. So, like, actually I like that move. Yeah, and I I think the problem is Yeah, it is. It is real hard, but I think the problem is uh too many agency owners sell their agency to the Candidate. You know what I mean? Like we come off in the interview, we're like, oh, but this is such a great place to work, and we do this and we do that. And you know, and so when the candidate comes in and it's not all, you know, roses and unicorns and Disneyland, like you described it, they're like, well, wait a second, this is nothing like what you made it out to be. This is this is hard. So just setting those expectations up front of like, this is hard. Like, you've got to want it, you know, sell yourself to me. And then being like you said, Jason, man, being super clear on the expectations of like, look, you know, we have a rolling average for sales. If if over a two-month rolling average you ever fall below 25 items, you're fired. 24 items, pack your desk and go. There is there's no there's no gray area, there's no reprieve. It is what it is. It is a measurable metric that you know you have to stay above.
SPEAKER_03Well, dude, and 25 items, you know. I mean, if if if they're not hidden that, they're in the wrong spot.
SPEAKER_01Right, but how often is the premium, right? And I almost I almost put that into place to hold myself accountable because I don't know how you guys are. Like, I love everybody. You know, I come into work and you know, I'll be like, hey, where's that new guy I hired two weeks ago? And you know, like everybody will be like, well, we fired him like last week. I'm like, oh no, I really liked him, and they'll be like, bro, he couldn't sell anything, he sucked, you know. And uh, you know, it I think too long will we'll pull people along because we're under the impression we have to just fill seats to fill seats, and we're like, well, this guy has a pulse and confogomir, so you know staff, and and we think we can uh like try and raise the work ethic, but 25 items is just work ethic. There's not like you don't need any skill to sell 25 items, like that's just picking up the phone and making the dials. So yeah, if you can't hit that, you're just not even coming in and trying. Yeah, true. So, yep. So I put that in almost for myself and not for them. Like, if they fall below 25 items, that's my signal that I need to let them go.
SPEAKER_03I you to you hit a really important point about selling the agency to the employee employment candidate versus the other way around, and and it became and it it really is this it's this dichotomy where agents typically aren't going to be looking or hiring until they need right, and then when they need, because they're you know, they're firefighting, they're not the fire captain, they're the firefighter, and they're putting out all the fires. I don't have time, I can't do it. But just like your book reading, 13 pages a day, you get however many books that is in the same way, you know, two hours a week of of screening candidates, two hours, like everybody can find two hours. You know, you don't easily jerk around doing something else. If you if you put it on your calendar, you're hard and fast and it's your rule and you hold yourself accountable to it, you get to those candidates, and then you become that person who isn't hiring out of need, right? Because you you can be more selective. Hey, look, I got five coming in, or I'm I have five I'm talking to. Some weeks I'll have none. You know, I'll have none. Some weeks I have more. It averages out to about two hours a week. But you're you're always talking to them. And you know, I've heard from so many agents also um, you know, well, I can't do that because I don't have a spot. And it's like, yeah, but you're not gonna find somebody, right?
SPEAKER_01It's a week. Let me address that real quick because somebody actually just said that to me the other day. I'm like, dude, you need to be recruiting. And they're like, Well, I don't have any open spots. Here's the thing I didn't have an open spot for a sales manager, right? Right. And and so if if you're the if you're the owner of the Golden State Warriors, you know, when they're winning all these championships, and LeBron James and his prime comes over to your team and is like, hey man, I want to join Steph Curry and all these guys. Can you find a spot for me? Dude, if you're the Golden Stoke State, yeah, you're like, dude, I will no more no more seats in the locker room. Like, yeah, like we're we're selling towels, we're doing whatever we can to afford you, bro. Like, I will make room.
SPEAKER_03And so that's like his or herself. You bring on a killer, you bring on, I mean, Stephanie's paid for herself in two weeks. Oh, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_01For her for a half a million dollar salary, you know, and and and the thing, the thing too that to think about on that is like on day one, she comes in and you know, at 19 months in business, I I would I would say I think anybody that's 19 months in would probably be like, dude, you're crazy, you don't need a sales manager. You know what I mean? You're 19 months in business, but like think about all the things that they have dropped the ball on on training us on that we don't know that somebody with her amount of experience knows. So, like in day one, she came in and showed me how to mine 6,000 leads out of my current book. So she added 6,000 leads into my CRM from my current book of business. And I'm like, holy crap, man, like those are just audits and reports that I never knew existed that I didn't know how to run. And and so again, I mean, what would you pay for 6,000 leads? You know what I mean? Like, so it, yeah. So if you start kind of looking at the cost that way, it actually becomes very doable. But yeah, so just like to your point, you know, if just because you don't have a spot for somebody, man, never stop looking. Because when a rock star presents themselves, like you make room, you figure out how to make it work. Like, I'll dude, I'll work out of the room closet and give somebody my office if if that's what it takes. You know, I will make room for you.
SPEAKER_03And you know, you have somebody you have to get rid of that you weren't expecting, right? You find out somebody writing bad business or whatever, there's that lag time, and because we love everybody, I mean you and I are similar, I love everybody. And it's just like uh it's a killer when somebody turns on you, you know, and and and so so then you have that open spot. If you don't have somebody, if you don't have a bullpen, you know, if people to potentially reach into, you're three months out, yeah. That person that you get, you're making a lot of concessions, you know, because they can fog a mirror and they have a license, and you you go, all right, I'll bring them on. I know that she seems a little wonky, but but let's let's do it anyway. And then three months later, you're like, Well, I just spent eight grand and I have to fire her.
SPEAKER_01Yep, and and you're thousands into that person, you're thousands of dollars when you talk workers comp and and and salary and taxes and training and everything, man, you're thousands into a hire, like right, so yeah, absolutely. You know, and and on the recruiting two hours a week, dude, it's nothing. Like, I gave you my email address to set up on that assessment for my cell phone because think about where you sit and you generally Facebook all week long, right? And so I was like, you know what? When I'm sitting in when I'm sitting in the executive office, uh, you know, if you know what mean I'm on my throne, I'm like, I'm gonna look at assessments rather than Facebook. And I mean, and it's surprising how much time you have. So, like, I would never actually take away from my work time to look at those assessments. I'd look at them while I was kind of breaking.
SPEAKER_03Yeah. Well, and it takes two seconds, right? You pull it up, you boop, bad. Next one. Yep, exactly. Pull it up. This one's good, sweet.
SPEAKER_01Instead of trying, yeah, instead of trying to figure out like, well, what does this profile mean? Like, could this person be a good fit? Like, I I like the the numeric base of it. Of you know what I mean, yeah, exactly like you said, uh sevens are above, cool. I'll call you. Anything below seven, probably not even gonna call you.
SPEAKER_04It's clarity again, it's clarity. Just yeah, yep, exactly. Um I like what you said. So I think the bigger picture of this is that um you do have clarity of your vision of where you want to take the agency. That's why you're reinvesting in new staff. That's why so I think clarity of vision of where you want to go needs to be nailed. And I think people a lot of times are hoping and wishing, and hoping and wishing doesn't get you anywhere. It's you got to take the steps to get there. And I think a lot of a lot of agents like they're like, oh, I want to do this, but I'll say, you know, or whatever, and there's all these factors, but it's like, dude, what's where where do you really want to go? Like if like if you want to go, reverse engineer it. Yep. And and we got to take a hit right away.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, you're always gonna have an initial upfront investment. It is what it is, but you know, small action. So I don't know if you guys ever listen to Grant Cardone or anything like that, but you know, I like his stuff. And so he always talks about you know, there's four types of action there's no action, there's retreat, there's average amounts, and massive action, you know, and he's like, and the most dangerous action is average amounts because you actually think you're doing stuff and really just wasting time, you know. But like, whereas no action, like, yeah, okay, you didn't do anything, so you don't expect a return and retreat, like you're just kind of worthless anyway. So, but average action is the most dangerous thing you can do. So, like, if you need to do anything, take massive action, you know, and and that's like that's what I'm trying to focus on now. Is just if you're gonna do it, just do it big. Go big or go home. Yep.
SPEAKER_03So it's it's what happens when the when the owner is disengaged, is is that average action happens. The the employees will typically, and you know, Stephanie's a little different than a typical employee because she's pretty much like an agent, but but most employees in general, and it's no offense to them, it's just human nature, will start to slide towards the average, right? You pump them up, if you do that seagull management where you come in, you know, yell at them alone and take off, uh, then you know maybe you get some response right when you had the meeting, but then it's like we're moving back towards the average. Yeah, and they'll slide to the what they perceive as something easier, even though they're really not getting any results from doing that, right? Whether it's how they sell or how they how they make the calls. I mean, I I had an example here where I I looked at the process. I was like, man, you're not hitting the whole cancellation audit. Let's look at it. And we we drilled down and it turned out she's looking up. You know, she's looking before she calls each number, looking up, checking the billing, and and I said, Well, so how many how many of the people that you call do you actually get a hold of? Uh one in 10. Right. So but you're checking before on each call. So how long does that take? Oh, only a few minutes. Okay, let's say it's three minutes. You know, three minutes times 10 is 30 minutes, but you only got a hold of one of them. So you spend 30 minutes prepping for one person, right? She's like, right? It's like, well, why don't you just do it as you're calling them? Right.
SPEAKER_01What does it matter? I mean, why does it matter? I mean, the numbers right, the numbers aren't going to change if you look at it before you call or during the call. Like they are what they call. I mean, they might if it's if it's an alliance, they'll probably change. They'll change like, you know, but uh yeah.
SPEAKER_03But it's that you know, just simplifying and then and then they go, oh, that is a better way, right? But it's so critical for us to provide that support because sometimes they just don't think of it like that. Yeah, we're numbers, people. Yep, you know, one of my favorite Oh, sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_04I was just gonna say one of my favorite things to do is that we we have a dialer for Russian roulette, and it's everybody, and we just run through a dialer. And when you get them on the phone, say hey, thanks for being with us. Start a con a normal conversation, and then while you're on the conversation, see what they what you know, any gaps or anything they need. Like you don't have to know, it doesn't have to be, oh, we're looking at you know, mono-line autos that you know what I mean. It's like, who cares? Like everybody needs something. We have a ton of ton of crap we can hawk. Yeah, and we're total protection.
SPEAKER_03We all we all know the only way to have an effective conversation is for them to like you, right? So that first part of the call has to be what Jason's saying. You're talking to a buddy. Hey, how's it going? Why are you calling it? You know, like we I like it where it goes where you take it as long as you can until they say, wait, why did you call? You know, like that's fast. Then it's like, oh, I totally forgot I was having so much fun. Yeah, exactly. I mean, how much better is that than hey, this is just Heather calling from all state? We want to go over your policies. Is this a good time? Vomit. Who wants to go over their policies? Nobody wants to have anything to do with their insurance.
SPEAKER_01That's what I tell everybody. Here's here's the secret, and this is this is one of the things that we're teaching. So, you know, we're getting ready. Uh, uh I'm hosting a live event right here in Ohio uh with the tribe, and it's gonna be amazing. Um, but that's one of the big things that we've been teaching and preaching is you know, just on that initial answer, how many times? And and I listen to phone calls a lot from other agents, um, you know, where I'm trying to help uh maybe figure out where they're going wrong with their internet leads. And like they're like, hey, is this is this Craig? Right? And if somebody calls and says that to you, hey, is this Jason? What's what immediately what does your mind tell you? Oh, salesperson, I say no. Nope.
SPEAKER_03How am I gonna get off this call?
SPEAKER_01Right, yeah. You're immediately, oh, it's a salesperson, right? And so, but like, and yeah, you might be wrong every once in a while, but if you answer and I'm just like, hey, Jason, hey man, how's it going? You know, and you're just like, Yeah, like, yeah, this is Jay, you know, and so like people are like, Well, what if you're wrong? Then you're wrong. Who cares? You know, who cares? That's the the what ifs are horrible. Who cares? Yeah, but it immediately catches them off guard because they're like, Oh, is this a friend? Oh, this person knows me. You know what I mean? And and so you're kind of already in before they even catch up to realize why you're calling. And then Craig, just like you said, man, that's exactly their next response. Is like, hey, wait, why were you calling? Like, where are you from again? We're like, Oh, we're from Allstate, and they're like, Oh, you know, but it's already too late, we're already down the rabbit hole, like we're off, we're off and running.
SPEAKER_03Like you, it's like me that they're not gonna hang up on you, right? Exactly.
SPEAKER_04I I heard your uh your script, and it's so similar to ours. Um, we have the exact same thought process, and that's it. Like, and when I tell other people, especially because it's it's different per state, per county, right? Everybody greets somebody different, but take literally take how you call your buddy and say that right off the bat, like sound and and tone and everything else. Like that's the simplicity of it, is that. And if you do that with internet leads, you're gonna win. And then it's and then it's assuming the quote, assuming like you just keep going. Like, don't ask. Like, he do you want to quote? I know I sure don't want to quote.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, no, I'm good. Yeah, crazy. Is that a good time to go over your quote? No, never.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So, you know, and so and to that point, here's a neat little game you can play for for anybody that you know wants wants to look into building a better script to get a hold of people. Have all of your staff call five of their friends from your VoIP system so it's all recorded, right? Love it. How about each one person just be like, call five of your friends and just ask them um the whatever plans are for the weekend, right? And then go back and listen to the intro on every single call. Because if you have four producers and they each call five friends, you have 20 intros. Listen to how all 20 intros start. And and like you said, depending on where you're from, they're gonna be really similar. You know, if if if you're from like down south and stuff, I mean you know, it might be like, hey, howdy, my friend, or so I don't know, whatever they say, you know. Um, you know, whereas like you know, if you're yeah, you know, if you're Boston or whatever, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_05Like you're gonna, you know, right.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, if you're if you're Boston, you gotta have like gunshots in the background and stuff, right? I mean, like just how they roll up there. So it's uh but yeah, so you know what I mean. Like listen to the way that your staff talks to their friends and then build your script around that because you want the person you're talking to to be a friend.
SPEAKER_04Yep. And when it comes to internet leads, the damages and the details because every they're getting blown up by so many people. Uh if you're aggregating your own, it's a different story, but still, like it you there's nobody wants to deal with this. That's the bottom line. So you have to leverage whatever you can to make them want to deal with it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and that's you. Well, I was saying the thing that we have being, you know, like also being with Allstate and stuff, the thing that you have is GEICO and and your call centers, they don't get that because their call centers aren't in probably in your same state, you know what I mean? Like you've got somebody from like here, you know. If I put in a quote, because in FYI, if you're not having your staff do this, you're crazy. Have your staff get quotes from other carriers, like because your staff needs to see what they're saying. And so whenever we put in a quote request from GEICO, it's somebody from like North Carolina calls us. So I'm thinking that might be where their call center is at. You know, but you can tell they're not from Ohio, and it's like, so wait a second, you know, and and so leverage that dynamic and be where you're from. Don't don't sound like a call center that's from on the other side of the country. Right.
SPEAKER_03There's one here in Tucson, too.
SPEAKER_01Is there okay?
SPEAKER_03I think I'm gonna park a car out in front and just have a big banner across it. Right.
SPEAKER_01Now hiring. No hiring. Do you hate your call center? Dude, just do like me. So I'm telling you, I I run my hiring ads, and because we have progressive world headquarters is right here in my backyard, and I literally so I go on Facebook and I run my ads and I drop a pin right on Progressive's Call Center, and uh, and I target anybody that inside of that circle. And uh so that way when anybody's sitting at work and they jump on Facebook, they see my ads. And we get a ton of people. Yeah, we get a ton of so yeah. If you've got a guy called call center or something like that, man, just drop a pin right on top of it with your ads and and blow it up, put like a hundred dollars a day on that thing, you'll kill it. I mean, there it's it's easy for me to get 65 applications a day from Progressive Call Center. What percent do the assessment? Um, we're at maybe about 25-30 percent. Yeah, that's good though. If you got 60, you got 20, 20 viable candidates that are already licensed, have insurance experience, yep, are good on the phones, can pump out how to talk to people, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, sometimes you're right. They may not have this the right words coming out, but they do know how to talk to people, right? Because they're you know, progressive is not bringing anybody on that sounds like you know a moron. So no offense to morons. No, yeah.
SPEAKER_04But Eric, yeah, what would be your number one piece of advice that you would give any agent that is feeling lost or you know might have that mindset uh uh you know there's not yeah, so what's that?
SPEAKER_01It it was slow a little bit, but I think I got the gist of it. So hopefully I'm not repeating him because I I know you guys talked to Tolga. So hopefully this this was stolen from him. Best advice I ever got in my in my life. Um so the the but this is what I did, and this is how I found my clarity. Okay, so I put four giant pieces of paper on the wall. Oh, hold on a second, let me shut my phone off. Look, rude, fail ring right there. I know that ring. Oh wait, my bad. Sorry about that. Jeez, shut up. All right, so anyway, um put four big pieces of paper up on your wall. And you gotta get good at this, so you have to do it like every single week for like the first couple months, and then it'll it'll start to become second nature. At the top of those pieces of paper, write one word, right? So it's you should be focusing as an agency owner on four areas every single day. Recruit, train, motivate, make it rain. That's it. So before you do any single action, write down on one of those pieces of paper where that action falls into. Recruit, train, motivate, make it rain, right? So every single day you should take some time to recruit. Every single day you should train the people that you recruited, you should motivate the people that you trained and make it rain for all your rock star staff, right? That's it. That is your job as an agency owner. So if what you're doing doesn't fit on one of those pieces of paper, don't do it. Delegate it out, give it to somebody else, get it off your plate. But stop wasting your time on crap that doesn't matter. It needs to fit in one of those four categories.
SPEAKER_03So much crap that doesn't matter. That's so easy to jump in that lane, right?
SPEAKER_01Like emails, I'm not gonna lie. Emails are the biggest, biggest productivity killer, and and agents are like, I spent three hours a day trace chasing my thousand emails that we get from Allstate and everybody else. Do those do anything for you? No, why aren't you having your service staff answer your emails then? Because most of them are service related anyway, right? So designate one person to answer your emails for you. If there's something important, they'll let you know.
SPEAKER_03Aren't you just supposed to push control A and then delete?
SPEAKER_01I know, right? Oh so FYI, my Stephanie's first day with me, she's like, hey, uh, you know, I'm gonna go through your emails. I'm like, cool. So she opens it up and she's got an OCD, right? So I have 11,000 unread emails. She's like, I'm stroke. So she's like, those will be gone by the end of the day. I'm like, I have added. And uh yeah, so it was bad. So yeah, feel free to ask her about that. She'll probably fall over because yeah, she's not having it. So, but uh yeah, I so there you go. That'd be my biggest piece of advice, right? When did you implement that?
SPEAKER_04And how did it change? How fast was the change?
SPEAKER_01So I started doing that probably November of last year. Um and so here, I mean case in point. So really it it took me until about January to get good at it. Um, because you know, a lot of times you just take off and you forget before you do the action to list it, right? Not only that, but you'll see also what you do in a day. If you list every single action, you'll see what you do. Um, but uh so by January, I got pretty good at it. And I mean, we're up growth-wise, so our market's harder this year, I would I would venture to say, talking to other Ohio agents, everybody agrees our markets a little tougher. We took some rate increases. Um, but we're already up uh 63% over what we were last year at this time with half the staff.
SPEAKER_03Nice. Congratulations.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. You know what I mean? So again, measurable analytics that you can actually look at and be like, okay, I'm doing something right.
SPEAKER_03And I cut you off on the last part and then just cut you off again. But the the you said with half the staff. I mean, yeah, that's enormous. Yeah, enormous. Yeah, right. Look at the the productivity increase by implementing these things, and then that cost, right? Now your expenses have gone down, or even if it stays the same because you're you're making it rain for them, right? How much happier and how much longer are they staying? Right when they're making twice as much.
SPEAKER_01Yep, exactly. You you know, you pay a staff six, seven thousand dollars a month, yeah, they're gonna be staying with you a lot more than a staff that you know you're made, you're that are struggling and getting by with 1700, 1800 bucks a month.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's no good for anybody.
SPEAKER_01Yep. So yeah, I I mean that's it. You know, just be very purposeful in what you do and very careful and stop wasting time. Like, we waste so much time.
SPEAKER_04Oh so true. I uh this is the only industry. Like, I used to work in restaurant, I love the restaurant business, and I love how fast-paced it is, and like you're just I'm like, I love it, like I love that. And then I got into insurance and I'm like, oh my gosh, like this is so slow, it's like a freaking turtle, right? And it's like there's all this stuff that's just it takes a long time, and it's so easy to fall into this like mundane, like right, and that's it.
SPEAKER_01But you know what, you gotta make it fun. And and if you're if you're starting to burn out and you're getting into that where it's like it's people don't like going to work, in all honesty, this is kind of the truth. People don't like going to work because you don't work enough, right? And as dumb as that is to sound, like, if you work harder and more, you'll have more fun because all of a sudden it's no longer just going to a job. Now it's like a lifestyle, you know what I mean? And so now you're just like kind of coming in and you're just living life rather than like I have to go to work for eight hours and you sit there and watch the clock. Like, dude, I uh you know, I get up at 5 a.m. and and I start my routine and it's the same every single morning. Um, and generally, I mean, I don't I don't really watch the clock, but I get to the I get to the office anywhere between 8 30 and 9 30. Just depending if I get into my workout, maybe it's feeling good. I just you know, I might go for an extra hour or something. Who knows? Um, but generally, so I'll get into the office 8:30, 9:30, and dude, I just I just work until I don't want to work anymore, you know, which is generally eight o'clock at night. And I'm like, all right, cool, I'm done, I'm out, go eat dinner with the family, you know, watch some America's got talent, and uh, you know, hey, call it a night.
SPEAKER_04There you go. So that's it though. I mean sorry, to go back to what I was saying, the like it can be like that and it will be like that unless you make a conscious decision to push yourself. I think everybody's expectations of what can happen is ridiculously low. And I think when you do push yourself and you push your staff, A, it's gonna make the the vibe way better because it's like, holy crap, I can't believe I did this, right? And then it's also the time's flying by, like people want to stay later because it's like, oh, I just want to get this last policy in. It's like it's a whole different vibe.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and that's the big thing too, is I I changed the culture uh in my sales center. Everybody had individual offices, scrap that. Uh so I just added, uh I don't know, but I think some people started commenting on it. So I added uh a hammock swing and beanbag chairs and stand-up desks, and it's like you know what I mean. Like I can hear their hipster playing through the wall. I can actually feel the bass on my wall right here from their screens over there in the sales center. But yeah, so I dude, there's they're over there having a good time. You know, I mean they just have fun and and it is what it is. So just let them do their thing. Hey, wait a second. I was on a way, I don't know why I did that. I gotta put in a ticket.
SPEAKER_04It bounces you off if you get a call in. Oh, I'm about to bet. So that's what happens when if if staff does that when they're like on a break, then it'll pull them off. And then yeah, if you have an outside people doing calls for you, it can be a little frustrating.
SPEAKER_01Oh, gotcha. All right, yeah, it happens.
SPEAKER_03This is awesome, man. We are uh up against the wall here. Any famous words?
SPEAKER_01Uh yeah. Um, just uh tell Stephanie that she that I won't get to see her podcast, and that way you guys can ask her stuff about me, and I'll be able to watch it later and see what she really feels.
SPEAKER_04Um then we'll get you back on, and it'll be like a Jerry Springer type thing. Maybe we should just I could just I could sneak in like on the screen, but yeah, and be like both both of them on and just really you know have them duke it out.
SPEAKER_01Nah, you know what though? She you know, being from down south, man, she's tough. She'd probably beat me up. It's fine, you know, whatever. So that's awesome.
SPEAKER_03That's awesome. So um you can and you know you can watch it on you. This this the visuals on YouTube. Yeah. When we get it on there, uh, and then iTunes, Spotify, and what's the other one? Google Play. Don't even know what that is, but yeah, it's there.
SPEAKER_01So I've been watching uh because uh I had to watch Anthony's on Spotify. Heck yeah, man. Yeah, nice. So that's my boy. Gotta see, gotta see how my competition's doing down there in Texas. Right on, man. Well, thank you so much. Yeah, guys, I love what you're doing. It was a blast having uh being on again.
SPEAKER_04So love watching your energy, dude. It's awesome. Positive. Like we I love I love the agents that are super positive, process oriented, and just want to crush it. Like that's it. That's the name of the game, right?
SPEAKER_03That's it. It's fun. Find the opportunity. Yeah, absolutely. Don't worry about the the challenge. It's like boom, just move move to the opportunity.
SPEAKER_01Yep, exactly. So, guys, it was great, man. Thanks for having me again. And you know, let me know whatever I can do to uh to be of uh service later on.
SPEAKER_04Thanks, buddy. Thanks. Same with us, man.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_02Your insurance dudes podcast is sponsored by Agency Vault, an industry leader and agency coaching, hiring and retaining top talent and sales training with the seven-step trusted advisor, sales framework. Are you up for the challenge? For $99, you'll get 28 days of access and an opportunity to join our private platform coaching. For more information, navigate to www.agency vault.com.
SPEAKER_04Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance bids. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman