The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
INTERNET LEADS DECODED: Behind the Curtain at the largest aggregator with a top account manager and insider, giving us tips and tricks to maximize results.
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Hey! How are ya? My phone is ringing in my ear. How you doing, Justin? Good. Pleasure to meet you.
SPEAKER_01There we go. There we go. Jason, I thought you were a technology guy. What's going on over there?
SPEAKER_04I always forget to plug in my mic. I'll plug in my DAW. I'll plug in everything. Just the mic port I forget. How you doing, man?
SPEAKER_01Good. Been busy. Been busy, but that's always good.
SPEAKER_04I bet. That's cool. Oh, Justin. Okay, so correct. Justin and I go way back a couple years now, probably, right?
SPEAKER_00Yep. Probably two months and a half, maybe three months. Tell me about there.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, well, it is these days. Justin was working in an internet company that uh I guess he had us as an account and he got me into internet loads. He taught me the road.
SPEAKER_03There you have it.
SPEAKER_01Short learning curve for him. He did just fine.
SPEAKER_03Usually, yeah, usually uh this is awesome because it it worked out and you're a good dude.
SPEAKER_01It's uh it's like crack though, Jason. Once you once you're on a man, you can't live without them.
SPEAKER_03And then it does talk about it non-stop.
SPEAKER_05Welcome to the welcome this week on the Internal Students Podcast, secrets you never knew about internet leads from inside one of the largest internet lead companies with Justin Marks.
SPEAKER_04So Justin, uh tell us your background with internet leads and sure.
SPEAKER_01Um so I landed on a digital marketing company, frankly, by chance. Um I originally from the East Coast and ventured out west coast after graduating college and frankly had no job and um enjoyed the beach for a solid month and realized that there was um you know bills piling up and frankly needed to get a job. So Lennon and myself uh downtown San Diego with with one of um the best places to work in San Diego at the time, and um from there uh didn't really understand what they did uh first couple days, first couple weeks, and uh slowly learns uh what a lead generation company is, what a digital marketing company is, um, and then from there just wiggled my way through the company and and moved up and around and uh eventually landed to working with folks like yourself.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome, man.
SPEAKER_01And what what would you do on a daily uh daily basis, a lot of communication, uh outbound proactive, uh outbound proactive communication was probably at the forefront of my day for most of it. Um second part of my day was filled with uh looking at data, making sure that uh leads were flowing, making sure that uh partners had good application rate, had good close rates, and ultimately uh we're on the path to scaling those businesses.
SPEAKER_04Awesome. Greg, I got you off. What were you doing?
SPEAKER_03Keep going. I can't remember going that far.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome. So your role there was more of talking to agents like myself. Um what advice? So going into this, I I'm sure that there's a lot of agents out there that uh hate internet leads, right?
SPEAKER_01Preconceived notion, preconceived notion around web leads or phone calls is one of the biggest mystical creatures out there, right? Everyone's heard of it, they've heard the negative, they've maybe heard some positive. Um, frankly, it's okay to be scared. Um, I think it's good to be cautiously optimistic for products like this because frankly, um they're not it's not a one-size-fits-all solution. So um you could have the best leads in the world and give them to two different agencies, and one agency is gonna tell you you have the worst product in the world, and the next person's gonna have that that fantastic producer who's gonna work it like it's their only job that they have to do, and and frankly, they're gonna make a lot of money. So it's um it's definitely a two-way relationship with lead generation uh companies and having a great relationship and and really outlining the path to success. So I think precon preconceived notion on Weblees is is huge, right? And most people have been jaded or they have been um hearing the stories that you know I had 100% disconnected numbers or whatever those uh made-up features that the people talk about are. But frankly, it's um it's really not a mythical creature. It's it's simple. If you have a team and you can put that team on a path to success with outbound dialing and reaching out on multiple channels and having a process that you can outline for those teams, it's really not rocket science. Um, just getting people on the phone, engaging in real conversation and um understanding them on a personal level, and then ultimately helping them save money, right? Um, that's kind of the goal of every insurance agency is to a give them better coverage, uh, b um make them part of your family, uh, and C, you know, ultimately, yes, you do write their business and scroll and scale your business. So it's twofold. Um it's not not uh not bad at all. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_03Creating, we we talk about it all the time, creating, developing a process, and then executing on that process consistently, right? And what what many people do is it's tough in the beginning or they don't get results for four weeks. So these leads suck. I give up, right? And you can look at the numbers too. Obviously, now we all have the phone systems that give us the the the visibility into the dials, and you know, uh three, four, five, they stop. And I think Jason, Jason, you said 20, right? We've talked about it multiple times. Yeah, 15 to 20 calls, and and the vast majority don't get there. I I think everybody at you guys have probably seen it. There's a there's a it's like a one pager that says the data over the over the course of 100,000 dials, and it shows, you know, shows where the contact is. And I mean, this is off real data, right? And you're dealing in data and it's it's it's it's data. It's like there's no unless they don't qualify, right?
SPEAKER_01But I think I think it's important to really put yourself in in the consumer shoes, right? So when you go out and search for something, or when you get a phone call from a random person that frankly you don't know who it is or who's calling, um, your first inclination is to ignore that phone call. Um so if you put yourself in that consumer shoes and you start to understand, wow, you know, I wouldn't write like a million random calls and probably might be a little irritated at first and uh probably get a couple that first day if it's uh a you know a lead that's been sold a couple times. But the person who's persistent and the person who is not rude but just persistent, I guess is the great way to call that, often would get my business. Um so it's it's interesting to think about it from their perspective because uh ultimately uh lead generation companies are trying to serve consumers, um, and you're trying to conserve consumers as well, but everyone's perception just gets twisted or or turned around sometimes when they take that for granted.
SPEAKER_04So here's another thing that I know about you, Justin, is that you have worked with some of the biggest insurance agents in the country, um, in the all-state world and outside of the all-state world. So uh to give you a little bit of uh credibility to whoever, you know, not a lot of people probably know your your name, but hey, maybe they've worked with you before. But um what what what kind of data? Because you analyze data, you're the data guy. I am um tell us a little bit about what you do.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I think uh data, data is one of those, it's missed, it's like a mystery feature. Like everyone has AI powered today, or everyone is data, data driven is one of those those fun words that companies love to brand themselves as. So um I think data is gonna be a little bit different in terms of a conversation with every team and every focus. So I think the important thing about when you have a conversation about data is you know outlining what are your goals, right? Our goals ultimately for an H search agent are to bind business or write more policies, right? So if you break that up into the small bits or the small performance metric pieces that can help you outline the larger data picture, um, you you end up with a couple simple, quick things. Um if you're making phone calls, contact rate, right? If you can't contact them, it the data is gonna show that. Um I think as you go down that funnel and down that pipeline, you start to see, you know, it starts with contact rate from the contact rate of those consumers you've contacted, who or how many or how few are you quoting those consumers? Um, and then ultimately you you take the step down from there, okay, from the quotes you provided, um, can I bind that business? Now, those are kind of like the three steps that I typically judge data on. So, you know, contact rate, quote rate, and sales rate. But within those three massive uh ladder rungs, you have so many other small pieces. Um, if you break apart the quoted status, you can see um quoted not interested, right? Um quoted didn't qualify because of underwriting guidelines. Um quoted just doesn't have the economic um means to do that right now. So you can really take each ladderung and break it apart in a couple different ways. Um, same thing with contacted, right? Contacted, um, you have a conversation, right? That that's pretty simple and clear. Contacted, hey, uh had a conversation, but please let's book an appointment for next Thursday at five. So I think it's really interesting when people talk about data is they really need to go back to the basic simples. You know, what are the goals? What are the things that I want to understand about that that piece of information? And then frankly, how can you turn that around and use that to your advantage, right? So if if you are if you're thinking as a business owner and you're thinking of overhead, obviously the more people you can have your sales team contact, um, the less overhead is gonna be wasted just dialing for dollars, right? So that's kind of the first piece is when you look at data and web leads or phone calls is that contact rate and judging what you want to be successful, right? Some agencies might say one in 10 contacts or dials might be successful. Other more finely tuned agencies might say one in two or one in three. Uh, just kind of how you view that business and how you set that goal and how you can analyze that goal.
SPEAKER_04That's awesome. And what where are you seeing uh analytics? We were taught Craig was talking, you know, we were talking about 15 to 20 dials. What are you seeing across the board?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I would say um every source is gonna be a bit different. It's gonna fluctuate for so many different reasons. Um, for example, Easter uh was just around the corner, right? Um naturally with people I work with, uh, we noticed that contact rate went down a little bit, right? Uh contact rate went down around um tax day, which is a huge, big um either scary day for people or exciting day for people, right? You can do that in two different ways. So I think understanding um you know the the seasonality and that plays a huge part in it, but um also where your company is getting leads, right? Do they sourcing leads from high-intent places like Google, Yahoo, Bing? Um are they all over the social networks like Facebook or Instagram or Snapchat is new for a lot of folks there doing the generating? Or um do they run a display network maybe on Yahoo um on CNN or on any other banner ad network, or maybe they do affiliate traffic. So I think breaking up your sources and asking those folks where they're generating the leads, you have completely different numbers, right? So the holy grail of lead generation is the the search, right? That consumers on their own intuition, needing a product, they're going in, they're typing in the exact keywords that they're looking for, you know, auto insurance uh in Huntington, California, or um home insurance quote in California, and that intent is really high there. So naturally, if someone's doing it on their own intuition, you would expect a higher contact rate, right? So Google Eads should be you know 35 to 45 to maybe even 60 percent contact rate, depending on your source. Um, as you go down the funnel with different um generations, such as display or Facebook, you typically can see a little bit lower uh contact rate because they were pulled in or based on something they saw, uh they they gravitated their intent over to that ad and filled out a piece of information. I mean, affiliate traffic, some of it can just be right place at the right time or wrong place at the right time. So those are kind of the three pieces how would break up contact rate. Typically, your highest contact rate and highest success rate is you know your SEM or or sourced Google being Yahoo leads, your Facebook, your display is gonna be a little bit lower. And then if they have an affiliate network, that's probably gonna be your lowest contact rate.
SPEAKER_04So, how does an agent control that?
SPEAKER_01Um, well, that's a great question. Uh, I think it this is part of the mysterious box of lead generation, right? You know, what goes on behind the scenes that agents don't know about, or what questions do I ask, right? So I think that it first comes down to you know, who do you partner with? Do you trust that organization? Are they um out to make a dollar or are they out to grow partnerships, right? Those are probably two different visions and probably have two different business models behind the scenes. So I think um educating yourself on um where you're buying those leads and where primarily they're spending their marketing dollars. There's so many websites out there like SEM Rush or a couple other websites where you can go and you can see a landing page and find out where the media is coming from. Is it organic? Is it um paid media from social? So asking questions uh on where leads are coming from from a lead generator is is always important in my from my point of view. Will they be able to change it or only give you leads from that certain source? Depends on the organization, depends on the company, it's just a business decision they that they make. Um so I think asking the right questions of where they're coming from, asking the questions on you know how many how many times are the leads sold, I think that's a critical uh point these days, right? So if your leads being sold to 15 other agents, uh your probability of having good contact rate and a great consumer experience are probably a little bit different with an organization that might sell a lead two or three times. Um ultimately, again, it's it's aim, lead generation's aim is to serve consumers, right? Provide three or four unique quotes, and ultimately the person with the best price, the best value would potentially win that business. So I think just asking questions and understanding how they run their business is important, um, even if you don't have the ability to pull a trigger and say, hey, I only want leads from this bucket or that bucket. Um, but really being cognizant of watching quality, and quality shouldn't have major spikes or or major uh downward trends. It should be pretty consistent if the folks know what they're doing on their end.
SPEAKER_04Here's a question for you. So with one of my internet lead providers, they're telling me I I'm noticing that a whole bunch of other agents are quoting these people. Um and they're telling me, well, it was only sold to one Allstate agent. And I'm like, I know that's not true because I'm I'm going through, you know, figuring out what's happening to our leads. And then they're telling us that, well, you know, this company sells to this company and then they sell back. So it's probably it might be the same lead, but sold from different companies. Now, is that just a inner is that like a a used used car lot talk?
SPEAKER_01Or is that yeah, so I think that can be looked at that in two different directions. Uh first of all, great question, right? That's that's something that I heard many times and probably will hear for the foreseeable future, right? It's a really realistic thing that that frankly happens. So again, you got to look at it from the perspective of a consumer, right? So a consumer, what's their end goal, right? To get insurance, but their end goal is to get insurance at probably a discounted rate. So as someone who goes and shops, um, as an educated person, or I'm sure you guys do the same, right? You go to multiple organizations or multiple websites to inquire where you can get the cheapest product. So um, is it likely that those consumers are going and shopping in multiple areas on a personal level? I would say yes. Um, I think it's it's hard to hold uh companies accountable for things that consumers are going to go on and do something on their own intuition. Now, that being said, um there are companies that keep it very clean, in my opinion, um, and don't don't cross-sell that consumer multiple times or reserve that consumer. Um so again, those are questions you should ask the lead provider of where they're getting them, uh, where what website, um, things along those lines that they they should be able to share in a pretty vague way, but enough to give you granular detail. So I would say it will it happen? Absolutely. Is it totally avoidable from from your end or their end? I don't believe so. I think it's ultimately just a consumer going online shopping and trying to find the best rate. And unfortunately, they don't see it from your point of view where you might be competing against another all-state agent or another captive agent in the same same um you know quoting bucket that you might be in.
SPEAKER_04How honest do you think the internet lead business is with all these companies that you've dealt with?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I I would say um everyone has different um areas of greyness, I think is proper way to put that. So I believe there are some true great characters out there. Um I think those are the ones who are typically growing, they have great quality, it's pretty consistent. And then there are definitely characters out there who um probably have put profit often before their own agent base. Um and unfortunately, that's just a business decision that those folks make. So um no matter who you work with, it's it's always important to review your numbers and make sure they are being on that consistent path. So, from my point of view, you know, anything in life, you never put all of your eggs in one basket. So, you know, really investing in only one marketing source or only having one company who you spend all your money with probably isn't the wisest decision. Should they choose to change their business model or should you know something happen on the marketing team where they can't generate leads? So I think diversifying yourself is never a bad idea in this industry. Um but that being said, most of the most of the people on the street these days are are fairly honest. Um, and I would do business with with most of them and wouldn't feel bad about giving them money to most of those folks out there.
SPEAKER_04So you've you've worked with some of the big Craig, I'm sorry, I'm I'm steamrolling this. Uh you work with some of the biggest all-state agents and other uh other agents. What's the common thread between the people that are successful doing this and the people that just, hey, your leads suck?
SPEAKER_01Sure. Pro process and people. Um I think it can be pinpointed to those those really two things. So um, you know, as a leader, uh your job is to empower others to do great things, right? As a business owner or as a manager or anyone that fits under that hierarchy structure. So oftentimes um you'll get the case where maybe a business owner isn't fully involved in the lead marketing uh of their agency and the wrong place, the wrong time, they walk in and they see a situation that that isn't acceptable or that's that's very explained, but just hard to explain from that point of view. So um I think the people who do a really good job with with internet leads or phone calls, really, they they trust the person who's running it, whether that's their right-hand woman or right-hand man, um, and they have those dialogues, they have those conversations quite honest. Um often the people who don't do well, they don't have that process nailed down, right? Either they they choose to do it all themselves and they're frankly just too busy. Um, they're still running business or they're not delegating things there. And um I think it's just important to have those people that you trust and empower really take hold of the marketing game. Because if you're not keeping a close eye on it, um things go awry pretty quickly, right? Um and it could be a matter of a hundred dollars that you could go off the track or a couple thousand dollars, right? Um, especially if we're talking about phone calls where phone calls are not a cheap product. So if you have your team members that are don't having a process and miss 20 or 30 phone calls, that's a couple hundred dollars, right? And that that stuff adds up quickly. So, you know, a couple hundred dollars could be a couple thousand dollars in a premium really quickly. They had just um you know, either shrunk down the time where they buy those calls or had a manager paying attention to um their ricochet or whatever lead system they might be using where um the lead status is still you know not yet contacted or new, or one of those really clear telltale signs that someone either didn't do their job or they missed that phone call.
SPEAKER_03Awesome. How important is it to be the first one to hit the lead?
SPEAKER_01I mean, obviously it it's it's very important, but I think um I I think well, A, the data supports, yes, uh it's extremely important. But B, um I think what's equally if not More important is after the 15th call, who's going to be the one to stick at it, right? So oftentimes I would hear stories from someone like Jason or one of his colleagues where you know, month one and two, the the quality might not have been uh fantastic, right? Maybe in the contact rate, but all of a sudden on month three or two and a half, when frankly everyone gives up, all of a sudden you bind a great policy, right? And that policy could be a couple hundred thousand dollars, you know, over the course of a year. So the folks who really do well, in my opinion, uh, yes, they do have a great initial contact rate, but but equally, if not more important, is they have that follow-up process. And when every other person or every other agency or every other character gives up, they are the first one to that door, whether that's just because luck of the draw or because they're memorable, right? Um, those two things will equal a lot of money, in my opinion. So keeping that process solid. And even if they don't qualify, right, uh having that X date bucket or having that campaign set up for a touch every few months is critical, right? Because you could catch the person at the right place, the right time. They could have had a shift in their needs, and all of a sudden you're there to serve them when everyone else gave up. So I think you know that that follow-up from 30 days plus is extremely important as well.
SPEAKER_04How many, how much money, how many leads would you say is enough to have an opinion of this? So what I see a lot of times and I hear a lot of times is let's say like an older agent that has their own process, uh, they start to do internet leads or live transfers, they'll spend two, three hundred bucks and say it doesn't work. And they don't really have they don't have a CRM and they have some guy with with you know printing out the leads and an Excel spreadsheet, yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Well, I think um I think that's a hard number to nail down because every agency is gonna be a little bit different. So it comes down to risk and exposure, right? So um someone who's a tensured agent who might be on a little bit different of a comp plan probably has a little bit less room for you know spending a couple thousand dollars and and um their wiggle room might be a little bit wider. But a newer agent, someone who's on a new contract that might have a different payout plan or um whatever those economic conditions might be a little different, I would say you have to break those up into two different buckets. Um I think you have to really understand um, do you have the right processes in place? Right? Many folks out there should not buy web leads, they just not for them. Or many folks out there should not buy phone calls. They're they're uh don't have the processes in place to work them successfully. So um I think it's an internal decision on what those risk factors might be. Um and you know, setting yourself up for failure on Excel is 100% gonna happen if you stick to Excel. So investing in a product that can uh help you simplify your life or help automate your life is the answer for that. And um I would say, you know, after um phone calls, you know, 100 phone calls is is a substantial amount. 50 to 100 phone calls is a good amount, especially if they're pricey phone calls. Um but seeing those early metrics are equally, if not more, important, right? So if we're talking about web leads and you have a 1% contact rate, it's unlikely that the 1% contact rate is gonna go to 50% contact rate overnight. So, you know, I think that's why you can't really put a firm number and say, you know, $5,000 is that magical number that if you plug and chug the right way, it's gonna equal success. You know, I think I think you'll know pretty early on whether the quality is there based on contact rate on the web leads. Um and on phone calls, you can kind of understand what type of consumer were they actually interested in the quote or were they coerced in some way that they just got caught the right place at the right time because the telemarketer was uh an aggressive or uh a smooth salesperson, right? So I think those are the two telltale signs that you can tell pretty quickly on whether a source is frankly worth your money or not before spending five, six, seven thousand dollars and saying, oh man, this this just isn't working. Um so I don't I don't have that magical number. I think everyone's gonna be a bit different there, but just keeping an eye on those close two telltale signs on the data lead side and the phone call side will do a lot of agents uh a lot of good.
SPEAKER_04I but I think that says a lot because you you mentioned right around 100, right? You can't do 10 live transfers and have enough data or information to really form an opinion.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think uh, you know, when you talk about data as well, so today's today's results and uh two and a half months from now are gonna be polar different results, right? So oftentimes folks um that had a limited budget, they might say, Hey, um, I have a thousand dollars to run with you, and um, they'd pause their account. And the real key, you know, Keater is right, if they have a great follow-up process and they only had $1,000 to spend, what does month two and three look like for those folks? Because $1,000 in data leads is not gonna last that long, right? $10 a lead, $1,000, right? That not that many leads, or whatever that magical number might be. But having the follow-up process and going back on month two and three after they've truly worked the full life cycle of that lead, they might have a completely different story, right? Maybe the first week or two or the first thousand dollars, they didn't really have a you know great quote rate, they had a good contact rate, and something wasn't hitting, and all of a sudden, month two and three, they closed three policies, and all of a sudden their cost per acquisition is in a great place. So going back and revisiting those things if you have a limited budget is definitely a good idea because you know, not not everyone's gonna close on the first call, right? Some people just have it a rule of thumb, they won't spend money unless they think about it overnight. And that's you know understandable from a consumer perspective. So when you look at things like the at that, you need to make sure that you're letting it bake in and mature.
SPEAKER_04Gotcha. Craig, I I got another question, but keep going, man. Okay, team roll. So yeah. Question. Uh internet leads. Okay, it's a two-part question. Internet leads versus live transfers. Live transfers are more popular, sure, but can they coexist in the same agency with the same agents, or do you separate those? So I guess that's three questions.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it's personality. Personality is gonna drive all three of those questions that you just drove. So um naturally uh LSPs all have different personalities, right? Um it would be dangerous if they didn't, I think is the right way to put that. So naturally you're gonna have the go-getters, and I don't think age is a factor in this. In fact, I've proven myself wrong. Age is not a factor in this, but there are some people who are just have that grind, that grit, where they can get on the phone and they can finagle their way into a great conversation, right? Not in a slimy way, not in a bad way, but they're just naturally smooth and concise on the phone, and they build that trust factor really, really quickly. Those people are gold for data leads, right? Take those people, be nice to them, give them coffee, all of those good things, right? Because if those people are having a great day and they're smooth, you're having a great day as an agency owner. Finding those people, very difficult, in my opinion, right? And making sure and monitoring they're not getting burnt out if quality goes down is extremely important. Um, that being said, phone call is a little bit different, right? So they need to be a smooth talker, but you also have to keep in mind that the price point on a phone call is much different, right? So if you put all of your new team members that are green as can be on a phone call, they're not gonna be aggressive enough to close that consumer or to ask for that next piece of information they need. So I typically don't recommend giving phone calls to the person who's been there for a week or a day or something like that. That's just never been a powerful solution, in my opinion. Um, so I think finding the right person for that phone call where they're aggressive enough to either ask for a close or ask for a follow-up is great. And again, age is not a determining factor in this as well. Um I I've seen people, you know, well up there in terms of age, do fantastic on both of the products, but it's really more personality. So as a business owner or as the person who's managing the marketing, right, you're managing quality, but you're also managing the emotions of how well these people are doing these products, right? They start to get burnt out on data leads. Well, now you have an easy product that has a hundred percent contact rate, and you can switch that person's team, or maybe you say, hey, the rest of the day, I'm gonna give you a couple phone calls to work because frankly, you deserve it, right? You've been you've been doing really well, you've been doing great jobs, your talk time is amazing. Now, can they coexist in the same office? I think so. Um, I think that everyone knows, um, and your neck of the witch, Jason, that phone calls are a hot commodity, right? Everyone wants them. They're the they're the coolest new thing on earth, right? Uh, because who doesn't want to pick up the phone and just have someone that's qualified right there? Um, but because supply demand is so high, supply is obviously not going to be able to meet that criteria. So having a balance or an understanding that frankly there's only so many transfers out there in a day. And if you want to grow to a multi-million dollar business, there's no way you can just rely on transfers, 150, 250 transfers a day, right? It's it's a great dream. You might tell a vendor, I have I'm willing to pay hundreds of dollars a day in phone calls, but yet they don't have the supply to meet that. So pick a realistic number, monitor it over a week, a month, you'll understand what their volume is, right? It's not going to have huge spikes. It might go down a little bit, but it's not going to spike up, you know, 50 extra, 100 extra calls a day. So having the data leads to siphon in there or age data to call when um when there is downtime is is really critical because frankly, if if your team members are not talking all day, they're not making money and you're not making money.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that cost adds up fast.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. And then you walk in at the wrong time and you see someone just idle, and you're like, wow, it's expensive idle time, right? So it's it's twofold. You know, arming your team with enough product to work is important. Um, and then equally, if not more important as well, is putting too much product in front of them is probably gonna overwhelm, and the follow-up process is gonna be the first thing that's gonna go away, right?
SPEAKER_03Yep. I'm so fascinated by how stuff works. So walk me through how a warm transfer gets to that producer where it started. Sure.
SPEAKER_01And I know you can't give away the secret sauce, but I would say I would say every organization does it a little bit different. Um, and and that is part of their secret sauce. Um, and I don't think there's a right way or a wrong way to do it. So um, you know, a typical way for most folks to generate a transfer is um there it's all gonna start with a lead of some sort or a banner ad or some sort of advertisement, and that advertisement's gonna uh have a comparison, typically a comparison uh analogy, you know, compare and save, um, bundle and save things along those lines to captivate the intent. And um typically the consumer is gonna fill out a web lead form, a generic form that ranges from contact information to um you know what type of insurance they're looking for and specifically um what are their past history claims or things like that. And oftentimes they'll hit the button, they'll hit the submit button, and um a call center will outbound dial those consumers and verify intent to receive a quote. They might ask a couple quick questions to make sure they have time for a quote, and then typically they ring the ring the office and say, Hi, I have uh the consumer online looking for an auto quote in California. So that's definitely one way of doing it. There are other organizations who don't put a contact center there at all. Um, so some of them just have a phone number. Typically, the phone number will prompt them to put in a zip code or prompt them to put in some sort of unique identifier from a GL perspective that they can understand where those consumers are. Um and then sometimes they write them directly to the agency. So there's no right way to do it, there's no wrong way to do it, it's preference. A lot of it comes down to consumer experience. Um, so call centers can typically be a little bit rougher on the consumer, right? They're in their goal is to generate transfers, right? So they're gonna be pushy oftentimes, edging that consumer over to the transfer center and to the office. But I don't think there's one way that works better or the other. I think it's more of a staff and a personality thing. So if you have a really strong staff personality, you probably don't need a call center, right? If your your team member is a little bit more green and probably need a little bit more hand holding, you know, having a contact center help you know warm up the consumer or you know, verify a couple quick questions probably is a good thing for your team.
SPEAKER_04Makes sense. That's awesome. Um what uh what data I already asked that one. I have a I have a whole bunch of questions for you. And we kind of jumped around. But um, where do you where do you see the the internet lead game going? Like you've lived through quite a quite a bit of a transformation the last few years.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, I I think that's a great thing. Um transparency is probably the utmost important thing if I was to pinpoint you know one thing that's gonna change. Um I think some of the actors out there are being very transparent with what they're doing, and they give you the ability to pick uh and target certain types of leads, certain areas and geos. I think that's gonna be the trend of the industry, right? Um in my opinion, there are um, like I said, a lot of people doing the right thing out there, and I think they'll continue to do that. And I think as you talk about uh lawyers and as you talk about folks out there who are you know looking to get the latest TCPA compliance lawsuit, you know, that's definitely a big risk, right? Um so having a partner that you trust or having a partner that can trace back where their leads are coming from is very important. Um I think that you know having advertising uh that your partners are using is really important as well, right? They're promising free insurance, and you get on the phone with the consumer who says, whoa, whoa, whoa, your insurance is not free, uh, you're obviously going to have a jaded experience. And and same thing with um you know the experience of the consumer, right? It all comes back to the consumer too. So, you know, as a business owner, you're trying to get consumers, but you have to put yourself on their personal level to understand the uh marketing material that they've seen and the promises or hopes that they've been uh shown and having to meet those things in the middle are often a little bit tricky. So I think you know, as uh organizations like Facebook cut down on the types of ads that people are served or um all the underlying factors on you know the big data stuff that's that's very present in the world today, I think things will become a little bit more transparent. I think there'll be some maybe regulation in terms of what ad copy can say, what ad copy can promise. Um so I think it's just gonna be a little bit cleaner. Um but with that being said, there are folks out there that that won't affect them because they're just doing a great job and they have great people behind uh the scenes who keep it clean and keep it concise.
SPEAKER_03Do you obviously you know that that there's people that generate their own leads, right? So the so those people that are generating their own leads by writing their own copy and and creating their own funnel are competing with with you guys. Now, as as the aggregators, and I don't know if that's the right term, but um as as the big data, the big data companies um continue to buy more ad space, what is that gonna do to the people that are trying to do it themselves? Uh eventually they're gonna be priced out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I mean it depends where you advertise, right? So I think um I think Facebook's a great example of that where um you have large organizations investing very heavy in Facebook, um, and Facebook's obviously very sensitive to the time of year that you advertise, right? The room the the last two months of the year um in those holidays drive up prices on display advertising quite a bit. So I don't think the the little guys will go away. Um I think that um will it get harder? Sure. Um will they put more regulation in terms of what you can put on the ad copy that maybe the bigger guys can adjust to because they have a full team dedicated to that? Probably. Um but that being said, I don't I don't feel that the little guys will totally go away. Um, there's always gonna be some sort of keyword you can target that maybe you're smarter than the big guys are, or some sort of niche that you can leverage as a local individual that they run national ads and won't have that niche. So putting fun facts in there or something that's gonna captivate the local audience is probably where uh folks that are smaller are gonna capture that intent quicker or better than someone who's running a generic blanket ad that's gonna serve all 50 states.
SPEAKER_03That's interesting. You you need to, well, you guys need volume, and so you're gonna target the the big keywords, which obviously drive up the price of those words. And a a friend of mine loves to say the riches are in the niches. And you know, if we can find that little secret thing that that may work, whether it's landlords or some derivative of landlords' policies, to for us to get the foot in the door, that may be the way to look uh to augment our internet purchase as well.
SPEAKER_01Sure. Yeah, I mean it's there's niches everywhere, you just got to find them, right? Um the big companies have massive teams doing it, but that doesn't necessarily mean mean you're gonna be better or more uh more prone to click that big ad versus your small ad. So I think it's just how you present yourself um and what spin you can put on it in a clean way that's probably gonna make a difference and make the little guys still be able to get in there.
SPEAKER_03I like that quote. The riches are in the niches comes from uh somebody we're gonna get on, his name's Todd Hartley. That he I feel like there's the riches are in the niches.
SPEAKER_04I feel like there's another word that could rhyme that you could gangsterize that that saying the riches are in the niches, bitches.
SPEAKER_03Could be no great, I just blew it.
SPEAKER_01It was so clean, it was so clean.
SPEAKER_03There you go. Now it's okay. I think Justin, he won't cut that out either.
SPEAKER_04Awesome info. Um it's cool too, because it's here's the other thing that I that I think I'm gathering. It's kind of complicated in a sense. Not complicated, but there's a lot to it. So it's time consuming, right? To to be involved in this world.
SPEAKER_01Time is everyone's worst enemy, right? You don't have enough of it. And if you had more, you could you could run the world, right? So um sometimes it's worth it to outsource things where frankly people are only doing one thing a day and they're really good at it. So it's that it's that balance as an uh business owner where yes, you could probably save a couple bucks here and there, but you don't have time to do stuff that you need to do from an agency perspective, right? There's just only so many hours in the day, and you can stay up late night and work on your campaign structure, or you can stay up late night and game plan, game plan all these big things, and one thing's gonna come and just completely kibosh your plan. So um, you know, valuing your time and valuing others' time and and just picking the right partner who you trust, I think is extremely important. And yeah, it's complicated, right? If it was easy, everyone would do it. Um there's just so there's so many niches in there that little folks or or folks out there are really good at and you'll probably never hear of because they don't spend the marketing dollars to go be heard, but they're out there. You just got to go find them. Um and the big guys, right? They do do a lot of marketing, right? Everyone knows the big couple companies out there who generate a lot of leads, and there's nothing wrong with partnering with those folks. Just having a good relationship, um, understanding what uh is success from them, and and they should understand what success is for you. So it's a two-way street. Um I think you we talked about it earlier, but you know, that that preconceived notion is huge, right? Just because someone had bad leads uh six months ago doesn't mean today they'll have bad leads, right? Those folks change, right? As their business shrinks or as their business grows, they need to either generate more leads or they maybe need to work on other things. So, you know, not counting anyone out in such a small but big world is really critical. So, you know, my perspective is don't write anyone off forever, right? Give them a give them a cool-off period, uh, let them do the thing, understanding what they're gonna do different, and then give it another shot.
SPEAKER_04And I think that's the most unique thing about that business, uh, opposed to almost any other business, is like one company, and we had this one of the biggest companies was freaking awesome for us. Almost every live transfer was we were crushing it, and then all of a sudden, uh they were the worst. So then all those dollars that we were like, okay, we're gonna invest more in this, it just all of a sudden our our our uh costs were skyrocketing at a mass overnight. Um and so yeah, then they sucked and I invested a ton in them, and then and then they sucked. And yeah, that was a that was an eye-opening thing for me. Yeah, like a it's an ever changing thing.
SPEAKER_01And and some of that's part of their probably their their doings, and and frankly, there are some times where it's just it's the consumer uh who just now Changes. So I I think it many factors are at play there. Um, and that's why it's important to keep a close eye on stuff and um you know have a good relationship with with someone who can solve your problem versus you know yell at them or or you know tell them they're the worst human in the world, right? There's all those folks in different ways to address it. But yeah, keeping a close eye on them and just saying, hey, you know, things have changed. Is there anything changed on your end? And keeping a close eye on it is is frankly never a bad thing.
SPEAKER_04Is it better to invest a big amount with a company or a small amount so that you always have the leverage?
SPEAKER_01I thought big amounts of money were totally useless. Most companies are uh their cash flow, the way it works and their business model, like you know, there were many people I used to work with who say, you know, I have X amount of money and I, you know, you're gonna treat me differently. And and frankly, I didn't care if they put a dollar down or ten thousand or a hundred thousand dollars. It didn't drive my decision different either way, and they're not gonna go in the back and be like, okay, this lead goes to that guy because he put down ten thousand, and that one goes to that guy because he put down fifty. So, you know, it's some people get the matches with big big stuff, but I don't think it's a deal breaker, in my opinion. And um, there's really no upside to putting you know hundreds of thousands of dollars in one marketing source because frankly, things do change. So um I was never a big fan of you know thousands of dollars down and and locked in because then if something was to go wrong that couldn't fix, I had no solution. So it's kind of a lose-lose in my opinion.
SPEAKER_04Makes sense. I don't want to take up all your time, Justin, with all these questions.
SPEAKER_03Uh you, Craig, do you have anything? Well, there's just so many forces at work, it's hard to determine what creates the leads being good or the leads being bad, you know. Yep. Uh it's just I think it's fascinating.
SPEAKER_01I think uh it can be kind of summed up by personality. I think that's the number one thing that that sways the most, right? As a producer, as someone who's writing business, if your mood's off and you're not on your game, you're you're not gonna get that business. So lead quality, sure, it does fluctuate, I'm sure, but the biggest thing that fluctuates is personality and how your LSPs or how your producers are approaching that. So um staying on them and and using my favorite slogan of you know, gentle pressure relentlessly applied. I think that's the biggest thing you can do as a as a business owner is just you know keep just minimize the dips, right? So if your team can be really consistent and maybe not kill it every day, but just are being more consistent, then then your quality is not going to fluctuate as much. You'd be surprised on you know that the someone's having a bad day and all of a sudden your leads are bad, or they're having a good day and it's like, wow, these leads are the best leads ever had. The reality is it that there's zero things that have changed besides the personality of the person who's working that lead.
SPEAKER_04Yep. And it seems like this is that in in all parts of your of your agency, um if it's not being monitored and you're not spending time constantly working on it, it's gonna dip. There is no set it and forget it. And I think that's what most insurance agents want.
SPEAKER_01Set it and forget it. That's a unicorn that doesn't exist. Um and when it does, you should be scared, right? So something's some something's too good to be true. That's just never gonna be that way. Um, but yeah, I mean it's it's not a um set it and forget it mindset. There's just not how the business works. And um, those who probably go on the set and forget probably coast a little bit too long. And uh, you know, when stuff hits the fan, it hits the fan hard when you've been coasting. So that's my opinion on that one.
SPEAKER_04I like that the PG version when the stuff hits the fan. Yeah. Way to go. See, Craig.
SPEAKER_03That's how you learn someday.
SPEAKER_04Justin, dude, thank you so much. This was this was awesome.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely help people. Absolutely. Let me uh send me the link when you guys are done. Love to see it. Okay, you got it for sure.
SPEAKER_03And then go ahead and just forward us the ad copy and the landing page.
SPEAKER_04Good, no problem.
SPEAKER_03No, I'm just kidding.
SPEAKER_04And then we'll set it and forget it.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, set it and forget it. Because it's simple.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it'll be it'll be perfect. It'll be a perfect plan, perfect Friday plan, right?
SPEAKER_03Put our ads, set our ad spin, and it'll it'll just come rolling in.
SPEAKER_01Just no budget. They set it to no budget, and you'll be great. Only good things will happen, right?
SPEAKER_03Just or close it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Awesome, guys. Well, uh appreciate the time as well, and uh looking forward to the finished product.
SPEAKER_03That is our good dude, Justin Ryan.
SPEAKER_01See you guys later.
SPEAKER_03See you, buddy. Yeah, thank you. Your insurance dudes podcast is sponsored by Agency Vault, an industry leader in agency coaching, hiring and retaining top talent and sales training with the seven-step trusted advisor sales framework. Are you up for the challenge? For $99, you'll get 28 days of access and an opportunity to join our private platinum coaching group. For more information, navigate to www.agencyvault.com.
SPEAKER_05Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance dudes. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman