The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
He knows TRAFFIC, and media, he’s the Traffic Dude - Mark Jeffrey
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
Well we I can fix it.
SPEAKER_02Fix it.
SPEAKER_01Let me how did you get that rad background?
SPEAKER_02Uh I'll tell you later. Talk about that later. But but let me I I'm the worst multitasker in the world. Get him pulled up here. Why is it oh here? I'm working in three different things. Can you read can you can you read me the um hold on you you're killing me? Can you read me the uh the uh zoom meeting at the top, at the top of the zoom it's oh I got it. Never mind. Should I be using my mic? Oh I stop good. The operation managers at Total Traffic Network.
SPEAKER_00Hey Mark Jeffrey here. Hey Mark Mark. How's it going, guys? How are you doing? I'm doing swell, thank you very much. Thanks for asking.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and you you can call us dudes if you want instead of guys.
SPEAKER_00Dudes. I use dudes all the time. You do? Well, you're just right up the street.
SPEAKER_02You're up in you're up in Phoenix, right?
SPEAKER_00I'm in Phoenix, Arizona, sitting in the uh the iHeartRadio building as we speak.
SPEAKER_02That is awesome. I know that that that gets me excited and Jason excited. So so let me introduce myself and then my co my co-partner here. Um your cohort. My cohort, co-host, whatever you want to call it. Um I'm Craig Kresinger. Um I'm an insurance agency owner. I have a couple locations, one in Tucson and one in um Capagran, so even closer to you. Uh nice. Jason, my compadre here uh has uh an agency in Huntington Beach out in California.
SPEAKER_00That's right. Oh, very good, very cool.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we've been doing this podcast, and to your question uh the uh on Facebook, uh we're Why me?
SPEAKER_00That's what you're getting at. It's like so. Basically, what I asked for for for all your listeners there, I asked, uh, hey, that's cool. Yeah, I'd love to be on the show. Uh why me though? What's up? Uh should I give you a bio of me? So maybe the folks listening will wonder or will understand why I asked you that question.
SPEAKER_01Perfect.
SPEAKER_00I'll give you a quick bio. So 1983, I became uh a radio guy. My dad was a radio guy for a long time. So since 1983, I've been a traffic reporter. I spent 20 years in a helicopter and an airplane talking about traffic mostly over Phoenix. Been on the radio every day since 83. Um, I'm still on the radio now. I'm on seven radio stations every morning. The other half of what I do is I'm boss of Total Traffic, the traffic arm of iHeartRadio for the region. So I'm in charge of traffic reports for about 100 radio stations for Phoenix, Tucson, Albuquerque, El Paso, and Las Vegas. Um, so it keeps me pretty busy. Uh we talk about traffic accidents and all kinds of problems that get in folks' way. And so that's pretty much what I do every day. And in conjunction with that, uh the fact that I'm on several radio stations, I kind of have a social media presence, and that maybe is what led us to be talking now.
SPEAKER_02It is. So you're in my network. I don't know how or when we became friends, but it but we are. So that's pretty cool. And um I have I have noticed your posts, and and um, you know, as an agency owner, and um maybe I'm older than than your typical millennial, but but in working with these millennials and understanding the value and importance of social media, uh, I mean you you seem to have it nailed, and and you're I think closer to my demo than um than millennial like myself, right? And Jason as well.
SPEAKER_00Well, you know, the thing is, Craig, and I have uh I have a bunch of employees, I have uh 24 employees, and most of them are younger than me. And one of the things I get into, especially when I'm hiring, is um we get into their social media presence. And one of the things that I I tell them that I'm looking for is um there it's just as important what you post and what you do as what you don't. What you don't nowadays, I say, uh, your traffic people, I do not care about your politics. Matter of fact, I don't even want to see your politics because, in my opinion, all you'll do is lose people. That's it. If you want to go change your name, different Facebook name, be my guest, join all those radical clubs you can find, either on the left or to the right, and have a good time. But the name that you use on radio stations I put you on, I do not want that name associated with either the hard left or the hard right because we're a service industry. So I tell them, not only what you put up is important, but what you don't get involved in is important. And then a step further, I have two daughters, roughly 30. When they were younger and going through college, I said, I don't, you know, like one of them went to ASU. I said, the last thing I want to see on Facebook is you participating in the undie run and things like that, or drinking out of a beer bong, because that stuff will stick with you for life. Because I'm a hiring manager, and one of the first things I look at, you know, is I'm going to hire people. Matter of fact, I'm hiring a uh traffic uh part-time traffic reporter right now. Is uh one of the first things I do is I look at their social media presence Twitter, Facebook, Instagram. I look at everything. You can tell a lot about a person by what they put on social media. Gotcha. Did you look at us? Yeah, I gave a quick scan of your stuff. You have some good stuff up there, buddy.
SPEAKER_02Oh, cool. Yeah, Jason's Jason's the architect back here.
SPEAKER_01What was the uh what what were some um some danger zones that you noticed on ours?
SPEAKER_00You're like well, I didn't look that far. Do you want me to do that now and and and judge you in real time? Because I can be a super judgy person, dude.
SPEAKER_01So I I love it. I think it's uh m mine's especially uh all over the place. I I I did a little grooming a few years back, especially when I joined All State, um, to be totally honest. But um yeah.
SPEAKER_00I'm looking to you guys you guys do some pretty good stuff. I mean, uh one of the things I'll tell you that I do, and and and I have a little bit of an advantage because, for example, one of the radio stations I'm on is KEZ Radio, and that's the number one station in Phoenix. I'm also on KISS FM with John J and Rich and K and I X. I'm on K and X Country Every Morning. Um, it kind of gives me a platform. And um one of the things I do is is I try to put up something every day that's kind of light and fun. Today I put up a thing about I found some candy cigarettes at a store. So I just put up a thing, hey, who remembers these? It's just to get folks to interact, you know, um, ask them questions about traffic, just keep it light and fun, because I think that's what social media's my portion of social media, that's what it's for. Because, you know, like I said, you put stuff up there, if a person puts stuff up there, that's gonna stick with you for life. That stuff doesn't go away. And because I'm a reporter, I sit in the in a giant newsroom that serves about 2,000 radio stations. I'm I run the traffic department, which is uh us on the side of it, but I sit in a giant newsroom and and these folks all day deal with all kinds of serious news items. And one of the things that comes up as a reporter, what you do is if you see a name that's involved in a story, you go, huh. I wonder what they were doing on Facebook six, seven years ago. Go, oh, look at this. This is interesting. And I think both you guys have seen, both of you dudes have seen you know recently that stuff you posted, stuff people posted on social media years ago can come back to haunt them. And that's just kind of sad. I mean, so all I recommend for folks is I'm not gonna, it's free speech, do what you want, uh, but my name is my brand. Mark Jeffrey, I've been working on this name, trying to keep it clean since 1983. That's how come I get endorsements and things like that. That's how come I stay employed because I don't have a lot of negative energy attached to my name. And and plus that brings us to another thing. I'm not about negative energy. I think you know that sort of stuff falls uh follows you around. So I just try to keep it positive. I think that uh if folks, you know, check on my Facebook page and it makes them smile for six seconds, I've done my job because nowadays radio and social media, all we're doing is fighting for people's attention. That's it. The life is about attention, whether it's television or reading what you guys post or listening to this podcast, we're just hoping to give some people something positive to consume their attention for whatever length of time. It used to be when my dad was on radio for 35 years back in the 50s, 60s, and 70s, it was either radio, television, newspaper. That was it. Or you know, throwing magazines, you know what I mean? Um but now people's attention is so scattered, um, I'm just hoping to make them smile for five or six seconds. That's about it. And then while I do traffic reports, I'm trying to help them out.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's exactly what Craig and I were talking about earlier. It's so funny you brought up positivity thing. And and that's what's so funny that drew us to you and your profile is like this guy is awesome. He looks like he likes to have fun. Which is I do.
SPEAKER_00Hey, I appreciate it. And and I think, and you guys have noticed as I scan back over your pages, it's being authentic because yeah, I'm a radio guy, and um, you know, I drove motorcycles, I uh I'm in a lousy metal cover band. I play keyboards, we play 80s and 90s, ACDC, Def Leopard, stuff like that. You know, um I've The real mistake. I've had the Yeah, exactly. I've had the opportunity to meet a bunch of celebrities because I work in a radio building. Uh so I have fun with that. So I'm fairly authentic about you know my life and what's going on, because um it's a little different. Back in my dad's day as a radio guy, nobody knew what he looked like. Well, today in the media world, even though I'm on radio, my face is all over the place. They put me on these radio station web pages and whatnot, so I'm a little less anonymous. So I try to be a little bit more careful with uh, like I said, it's my name. Um, one of the things I tell reporters that work for me is, you know, you want to do a good job in part because, you know, that's party be your spirit, but also because at the end of every traffic report you say your name. And if you screw that up, that's on you. It's not on me. So if you keep doing a lousy job and go, hey, I'm Mark Jeffrey, and you do a little lousy job again, and hey, I'm Mark Jeffrey on whatever station, that you know, people are gonna go, that Mark Jeffrey doesn't know what he's talking about.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, I think that's that seems to be one of the biggest changes, I think, is that uh uh people aren't anonymous anymore. And uh it it's your brand. Like you have to shift your mind and and just realize that when you when you're just on the internet, like we all go on multiple times a day, that it's you're really promoting your brand and not you're not just having fun.
SPEAKER_00Right. It's it's all about we're all in the brand game. I mean, I have friends that are I don't want to say civilians because I don't want it to sound the wrong way. Um, but like my best friend, he he pours concrete driveways for a living. Um and he does real well. He's not really even on social media, so he doesn't care. He doesn't have a reputation necessarily to protect on social media. He's got a good reputation personally, but otherwise he's not worried about it. Uh, but for somebody like me who uh is kind of half expected to have an online presence, because uh I'll let you in on a little secret. In media, radio and television, I know a bunch of folks, um you're expected to have an online presence. Matter of fact, it's pretty much mandatory. Uh a lot of these radio stations in Tucson, for example, um, you know, they have a bunch of iHeart stations there. Well, you guys, people are listening to this show all over the world. So I'll I'll make it in a more global aspect, because I know you have um you know fans everywhere. Um that part of it is that uh you know, when you're in on radio and TV, um they're gonna expect you to do, for example, if you have a morning show, you're expected to do five posts a day on uh typically on Facebook. Sometimes they'll let you do it just on Instagram, but you're expected to, and it's checked upon. So it's that that was something that wasn't required. When I when I was doing radio back in 83, the internet didn't exist and nobody cared. I didn't have to do social media posts. Well, now you do. You're gonna have a radio show or do whatever you do on the air, and you're also gonna have to have five minimum of five interactions on social media a day, and your boss is gonna check up on those, and they're gonna look to see was it good, was it bad, you know, uh, and so it gives me a little bit of an advantage finding out from other people that are really successful at it, um, you know, what they put into their post to get a run. For example, I work for iHeartRadio. An example is Ryan Seacrest is an iHeart employee. He's on a radio station in Los Angeles. He has to, he does anyway, but he's got a post every day, a bunch of things. And I look at some of his and thinks, well, sometimes he asks a question, sometimes he's just got a funny picture, sometimes it's an interview with somebody that'll be a little tease to get you to click a link so you can listen to a whole show, that sort of thing. So um he's and of course he's got a giant crew that works for him. I do mine on my own. Um, but you know, there's a lot I know a lot of people that put a lot of thought into their social media presence.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I'm hearing I'm hearing mix it up and do it often.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. And another thing that you could do is um I have an advantage. I'm I don't know if it's an advantage, I'm up and on the radio every morning at 5 30 a.m. So I I do my best, what I think are my posts that are gonna run. I do them uh by 7 a.m. every day. Um I tell friends of mine that I'll see a post come up, a really good post. They put it on at 7.30 at night. It's like I don't think that's the right way to go. Because what's gonna happen is your post will maybe get some run for a couple of hours, it'll die overnight, and then you know, you you won't get the full advantage. It's just a theory of mine, because we know Facebook and Instagram and uh, you know, all those Spotify, they all change their algorithms on a regular basis so we can't figure it out. But I just personally think that I like to have a good post every morning, you know, kind of with my coffee and something that I think is gonna run all day. And uh I don't I try not to do a really solid post late at night because I'm afraid, oh good, I'm gonna have 50 people that'll like it, and then it'll die overnight, and I'll get nothing the next day, unless somebody comments on it and brings it back up, you know what I mean?
SPEAKER_01That's awesome. That's good food for thought right there.
SPEAKER_00Well, I I don't know if it's true or not. I it's just something I've noticed. I can put up a post, you know, it's at night, and it's like, huh, that's weird. I didn't get a ton of likes, and then I can put up the same exact post about three months later in the morning, boom, it runs all day long. Like I put up a thing today about candy cigarettes. I think it's past a hundred likes already. And that's not a ton, but it just started something and it went. And I just have a feeling if I did that at 9 p.m., it just wouldn't work. Because then, you know, that you we talked about the demographics that we are in. Um, you know, Craig and Jason and myself, we're in a demographic that's maybe a little bit different. Are we on Facebook at nine o'clock at night? Yeah, I'm usually with my wife doing something else. You know, so I I I figure that the folks are you know checking it during the day. Um do you guys do Facebook uh and Instagram on your phone or is it on a computer mostly?
SPEAKER_01Phone.
SPEAKER_00Kind of both, but but yeah, likely more phone. Well, and as you know, that gives you a different experience. You know, um the phone is a different I and I look at it mostly on a computer monitor because where I do traffic, I have three giant monitors, and usually one of them I have dedicated to social media, the other two are for traffic because that's my primary job. But um, so I look at a lot of stuff on uh the computer monitor, and the things I look at on my phone, um, well then uh and I do look at Facebook on the phone, but I don't look at like uh videos and things like that, because I don't like small videos. If I want to watch a video, I like to watch it on a bigger screen so I can get the full effect. Yeah. So so that's another thing you have to consider is what you know, how are people consuming um your social media posts? How long have you guys been doing this podcast?
SPEAKER_02Were we a month and a half in?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, not long.
SPEAKER_02Not long, not long not long, but it again it's it's that consistency, right? We're we are we're committed to to hitting getting somebody on here every week, and and we've been pretty good at at doing that so far. Now we have a power power guest.
SPEAKER_00Well, yeah, I I I well I'll hardly agree with that, but I appreciate the sentiment anyway. But consistency is the thing because here's the deal. I've been on Morning Phoenix Radio every day since 1983. You know, and that's not brag, it's just a fact. One of the things that's done for me is when I go places and I say, hey, I'm R. Jeffrey, folks will look at me oftentimes sideways like, um, sounds kind of familiar. Part of that, you guys, is because I've done uh almost three-quarters of a million traffic reports in Phoenix on various radio stations. Yeah, my wife added it up for me. Um I was like, really? No kidding. Yeah, it's uh she calculated about 742,000 traffic reports, and that was like two months ago. So anyway. That's awesome. At the end of every well, I appreciate it, but at the end of every one of those traffic reports, I've said my name. So that you know, if you're a Phoenix radio listener, my name has been hammered into your head every friggin' day since 1983, and so you know, it's given me a little bit of an advantage because whether folks, you know, like me or not, that's besides the point, they've been exposed to my name all those times. Um, and part of that is consistency, consistency, consistency. You know, you just keep hammering it every day because a lot of folks today, especially social media, that folks want to make money, you know, make a quick buck or whatever, you know. I tell them you just have to keep hammering away every day, and you're gonna get better at it and better at it. You'll gain more fans, you give them something of value every day, uh a couple of nuggets they can take away from it, say, hey, you know, the information that Craig and Jason gave me there, that was some useful stuff, you know. Um and it made me not only maybe gave me something to think about, but it made me feel better. Or I chuckled or or whatever, you know, so you guys can become like their pals and they're and they keep coming back every week to listen to you guys.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and I think I I think that's key. I think a lot of a lot of people these days are looking for the quick you know, the quick fan base or the quick buck or whatever, um, and they're not in it for the long game, but when you're in it for the long game, you play the game differently.
SPEAKER_02I think it's more about value and uh and there's a lot of data stuff. So all different in all different stages of their agency ownership career. And it's a we feel the the concern over oh, I don't want to overflow so I don't want to bother, and and we're like, no, you've got to that's where the valuable markets it's like it's that reinforcement of how important it is to be in front of somebody. We must because when they get mad at their current insurance or do that, and it's time to bounce, they want to think of us. Just like with you, you know, if they're mad at whatever radio station, they remember you and they're they're going back to your traffic reporting protocol.
SPEAKER_00Well, and and and that's and I believe um that's an excellent way to look at it because we're just staying in, you know, trying to keep it positive, staying in front of the folks. Uh I it's funny because um if I had to categorize the occupation of the majority of my Facebook friends, easily it's real estate. I have I've got to have seriously, dudes, because I have like four seriously, like 400 real estate agents, you know. Well, I bought a house about a year ago and I picked one, and it was mostly because I he just put up a bunch of posts I like, and I saw the day I decided I'd seen a post of his earlier in the day, and you know what of all things it had to do with is he had a family member who was uh addicted to heroin and had recently kicked the habit. It was kind of a serious thing, but he had in some some interesting takes on it and just a couple lines and and saying, you know, I pray for all those that you know are trying to kick an addiction or something, and and it wasn't about, hey, you know, buy you know a Buy a house with me. Um, but I noticed he was an insurance agent, and so I private messaged him. I said, Dude, I'm looking to buy a house. Um, can you help me out? He was like, Hell yeah. And so literally within two hours, he's showing me a house up the street from mine, and we ended up buying it. It happened that quick. And it was just because, like you said, it was he was he'd impressed me with the way he was on social media, not always saying, I'm the best insurance or I'm I'm the best real estate guy, I'm the best real estate guy. No, it's just positive stuff. He seemed like a good guy, you know, because I had my pick. I love hundreds of agents.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, the then I think that's a killer point right there, is that when you do like if you're doing the cookie cutter post, the you know, oh you you know, and for insurance, oh, you know, auto insurance, save. It's like the same stuff over and over again. But to your point, you pick that guy because of how genuine he was. And I think that's awesome. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. So it's uh to me, it's about being genuine. And you know, folks will know you can throw in things about insurance, but you you mentioned cookie cutter. Well, you can tell that when people are sharing posts that we've all seen before. I think some people make the mistake of thinking, hey, I took this post from a friend of mine and I'm gonna share it. It's like, dude, we all saw it. You know, we've all seen that meme. That meme went around last year, dude. You're a little bit slow. You know what I'm saying? It's like I laughed at that last year, but nice try. You know? Um so try to be original or put an original take on it somehow. Also, you know, uh it's a it's a dumb thing, but my wife laughs at me because we'll be wherever we're walking, or if we're doing something a couple of months ago, I'm in front of some big fountain. We were at a mall. I go, hey, take a picture of me uh looking like I'm gonna jump in the fountain. She goes, what for? I said, I don't know, I don't know. I don't know yet. You knew. Well, I knew I'd do something with it, but I here's the thing. I didn't have to know at the time. You know what I mean? I didn't have to know. You guys are in Tucson. Do you know there's an intersection of Mark and Jeffrey, and that's my name, and it's even spelled that way? I actually drove to that intersection, which is in the southeastern part of Tucson, and I stood up on the hood of my car and took a picture of my head right next to Mark and Jeffrey. Now, I had it in my phone for like a month, and then I posted it, and folks thought it was funny as hell. Well, so my message there is when you're at a store or you're out with friends or with if you see something odd, take a picture of it, and you don't have to know at the moment what you're gonna use it for as a post. And maybe you won't use it, but anyway, you you got some stuff instead of here's another selfie of me in my office, here's another selfie of me in my office. You know what I mean? Um give yourself some give yourself some stuff to to post with. And then when you look at those pictures, you know, a week or two down the road, maybe something triggers in your mind, and you say, hey, you know what would be funny with that.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Also, it sounds like you guys are smart, Alex, and that's let's face it, that's half of what social media is about. A little bit. Being a smart ass, you know. Yep. Uh like yesterday I put up a picture of a banana. I drew a face on it and put it in front of a map and just said, hey, time to do the traffic reports, you know?
SPEAKER_03It's just uh funny.
SPEAKER_00Well, if people are looking at it and going, what the hell, dude? It's like, well, um, I use that traffic banana a lot. Um and then the one prior to that is me holding two headless mannequins. Uh and it's just like I said, I'm not looking for a lot of attention. I just if I it's five or six seconds because um, you know, people's it's hard to get their attention for any length of time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00We're in the attention game, guys.
SPEAKER_01That's it.
SPEAKER_00And you guys are in it now that you're doing a podcast, you know, you're fighting for that attention.
SPEAKER_01Yep. Dude, though that that is some great um great advice, Mark. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_00Hey, well, anything I can do to help you, just let me know. I'm set for my insurance needs, but I'll tell you this: if I need any insurance, I don't need uh I don't need aviation insurance anymore, thankfully. But uh, if I if I do, you guys are gonna which one of you is better at insurance, by the way.
SPEAKER_02Well, Jason's in California, so you'd have to work with me by default.
SPEAKER_01There you go.
SPEAKER_02So bonus.
SPEAKER_01And Craig's been doing it longer, so he's definitely better.
SPEAKER_00Well, actually, guys, hey, uh I I have to break it off only because I gotta jump back into this radio work that really is my primary job. But hey, it's been fun talking to you, and I wish you the best of luck in your endeavors.
SPEAKER_01Thank you, Mark, for taking this time. Yeah, we really appreciate it.
SPEAKER_00Oh, sure, guys. Anytime you you have a great day. You too. All right, take care.
SPEAKER_02That was awesome. That was good, man. That was really good. Your insurance dudes podcast is sponsored by Agency Vault, an industry leader and agency coaching, hiring and retaining top talent and sales training with the seven steps, trusted advisor sales framework. Are you up for the challenge? For $99, you'll get 28 days of access and an opportunity to join at Five Five Coaching Foods. For more information, navigate to www.agencyvolve.com.
SPEAKER_01Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance data. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman