The Insurance Dudes©
The Insurance Dudes is a weekly podcast for independent and captive P&C insurance agency owners, hosted by Craig Pretzinger and Jason Feltman, covering lead generation, sales scripts, DISC-based hiring, producer training, recruiting, automation, and the KPI tracking that scales an agency past $10 million in premium.
Craig and Jason ran their own agencies blind for years. No read on contact rates, quote rates, or close rates. Just grinding, and blaming the leads when production stalled. Then they started tracking the numbers that actually move revenue, and production jumped without adding a single hour to the week.
That shift became this show: 800+ episodes on what actually runs an agency. Real-time vs aged lead economics, how many dials a day a producer should be making, scripts for the rate-increase objection, how to leave a captive carrier and go independent, how to run an agency on a 4-day week, and how to value and sell an agency when you're ready to exit. No theory, no motivational filler. Just the math and the systems that took two agencies to over $10 million in new annualized auto premium.
If you're wearing every hat in your agency and ready to stop, this show is built for you.
Website: theidudes.com Built from the show: TeleDudes for outsourced overseas dialers, TeamIQ for DISC-based hiring, LineShield for phone reputation, and Insurance Agency Trader for buying or selling an agency.
New episodes every week. Subscribe, and let's sell some policies.
The Insurance Dudes©
Floating In Positive Vibes, it’s Preston Schmidli (2 of 3)
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Hey there! Thank you for listening! We'd be SUPER GRATEFUL for a subscribe!
And a review over on the Apple Podcasts would be incredible!
Check out our newsletter, webinar, and some great Internet Lead tactics at The Insurance Dudes Homepage.
We appreciate you!
Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman
The Insurance Dudes
A lot of balls in the internet, man. How do you do it?
SPEAKER_01On the Preston Interview Part 2, we talk Gary Vaynerchuk, Agent 2021, and his book, I Were You.
SPEAKER_03So this brings up a good point. So you're doing you got your agency going, uh, you got uh good vibe squad, digital natives. Um you're you just said that you went to 20 different places last year. Um that's a lot of balls in the air, man. How how do you do it?
SPEAKER_00A lot of balls. Uh so I I don't I don't sleep as much as I would like to, um, which is hard because I actually require eight hours at this point. Um 30 hit hard, man. I'll tell you that much. Like I, you know, I hear 60 year olds talk about like, oh, you don't know. I'm like, no, bro, you don't know. Okay. It's true. Um, so I don't sleep a lot, but there's also like I have a I have a really big vision, man. It there's a big part of this where it's like like the marketing part of it, you know, like the good vibe squat is our done for you, and and Digital Natives Academy is our is our like our course and our our content model. Um and then we have friends who benefits the agency, right? So that's like the the main um that's the main structure there. But I feel a fervor inside to inspire and provide the resources to other agents to be able to to be in the situation that I like to be to get out of situations like I was in. You know, and when I talk to somebody who's already making, you know, they're they're pulling in, they have multiple office locations, they're pulling in, you know, 40 a month. It's like, yeah, you you don't care. You don't care. Like if you can get 100 leads a month to you, it's like, well, whatever. You know, that's you got FU money at that point. But to the agents that might have been struggling and who have skills, but they're it's just circumstantial, right? Like you could totally be a great person in the wrong environment and kill yourself slowly. And you know, I think part of that is I want to help people wake up to their circumstances and their potential. I want to help provide the tools and resources to change their life. And if I and even if I'm only one brick on that path, you know, and and that's the that's the beauty of it, is just seeing the trajectory change, you know, from people that are they might not see it, but slowly going towards the abyss, right? And and you know, when you can help them reframe their situation and come out stronger, uh that that inspires the shit out of me. And so I I think that that's a big moving uh thing for me, is like I want to be a better teacher, but I also want to be a better student at all times. So I'm not too good, and I'm not too good to admit that, you know, like I have coaches. I'm sometimes I'm my coach's coach. Like, I don't look at it like it's a this or that, you know, it's one or the other. It's it's not binary. It's it's you know, um, I think we all have things to learn from each other, and I'm just open-minded enough to that to go, yeah, whatever. I mean, I know enough to charge for it, but I'm also humble enough to listen.
SPEAKER_03That's cool, man. Um talk about Agent 2021. That's I'm curious. How did you get involved with that? Um, tell us about that experience.
SPEAKER_00Agent 2021 was actually really cool. So the highlight, I'll tell you about the highlight first because I think this is actually really cool. This was the this was for me. I'm I'm just selfishly gonna talk about this because I enjoy talking about it. So my business partner and I, we were trying to find a place to strategize because we're like, okay, we want to make some content at this. Like, what's what what are the what what are like if we could get XYZ and call this a win, what are those things? So we're trying to find a speaker room, right? And we go in, we go into one of the speaker rooms um just to get some quiet because it's really busy, it's a lot of people, and and we go in and it's Gary, Gary's actually in there, and he's filming content. Uh, it wasn't D-Rock, he had uh one of his other videographers there. D Rock was on a on a trip somewhere, and so they're just filming content, right? And there's a few, there's like a few people, and uh there's like one other person in the audience, and I didn't know who she was at the time, uh, but it was his wife. Uh, I found out later. But then as we sit down, his dad Sasha and his mom walk in, and then they sit down, and it it was just such a cool moment. Gary's doing his thing, recording content, his most immediate family, you know, his and and that's the cool part, it's like it's it's you get to watch, like, you know, you're uh Gary, Gary, and this is kind of the cool thing to come full circle for me. It was literally, what was it? It was crushing it that uh that I would literally I had the the F and needle in my arm at the plasma center as I'm as I'm reading crushing it. And so to go from that where I'm reading this dude's content, taking it in, like he was one of the people that kept me inspired, like hustle, move. You know, this is back now. He's on this whole like humble, like I'm supporting you, like that's like his message. Back then it was like, dude, who fuck sleep, get you know, get in there, you know, cut your teeth, work hard, hustle, hustle, hustle. I was like the the thing, right? And at that time, I was like, I needed that because like I'm sh I'm in this bed, it's like you know, you get incredibly apathetic when you're at that place in life, right? And so like I needed that guy to just yell at me, and then he was that guy, and so you start to see these other characters on their journey, right? So, like his dad, Sasha, and all that, and the wine library TV, and and Sasha was the inventor of the of the company that became Wine Library, and and to be in the same room with them and just watch them do their thing, there weren't you know, it was a very natural thing, it wasn't like the TV was on, type of I don't know. That was it, that was probably the most rewarding part of it for me was just being able to watch him in his habitat with his people.
SPEAKER_03Um, like behind the curtain.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that was really inspiring, man. And it was just him with his family, you know, it was it wasn't anything special. Like it's it's crazy because I tell a story and people are probably like waiting for the hook, and I'm like, dude, that was it, and that was the coolest part. Is that hanging with Gary? Well, that's that's watching with his family.
SPEAKER_03That's the most real anyone's gonna be. Like when I'm hanging out with my family, with my kids and stuff, that's the most real I'm gonna be. So yeah, to see that, it's like, yeah, watching a lion and it's happened to have with its family, and it's cool, dude.
SPEAKER_00It's so cool. Yeah, and and you know, it's one of the things I do like about him is I I feel like there is an element in business where it's eat it's very easy to fall into this whole hopefully you die the hero, die young enough the hero, so you don't live long enough to become the villain, right? Like, like work is hard and and we sacrifice so much of our character in the daily grind, the daily hustle. You know, I and I do it. Like I I just realized a lot of this on my uh session with my life coach. And it and it it's it's a constant fight. Every day we have to, you know, commit to abundance over scarcity because it's in everything we do, it's how we live. Um, you know, we have a lot of bullshit from from our childhoods that we wade through every day, right? Just programming that we're that we're constantly re-reliving. And it's like we have to make a conscious choice to bypass, to get past that, right? And and one of the cool things that I love is that despite how successful he's been, how many ventures he's had, how much investments he's made that have panned out really well, uh, you know, all the wins he's had, still a really humble dude. The dude is just so humble. Like it's it's almost past like, you know, and and not everybody can say that. You get to a point where you become Scrooge, you know, like like it it it it kills you inside, even though you've quote unquote made it, right? Like I've seen that happen time and time again, even in the insurance vertical. Like sometimes you sacrifice your family, you know, you get divorced, you lose your kids, they all leave you, but because you're like so tunnel visioned on this one thing, and and everybody leaves you, and then it's just you in a pile of money. And and it's like I see this guy who's like he I don't I don't necessarily believe balance exists. I believe that I believe that what we consider balance is like this perfect ratio doesn't exist. I think that there's a spectrum and you can have certain percentages, but it's really at the end of it, it's prioritization, right? And it's really cool to watch him despite all the success, despite all the investment, right? Because he's hustle, let's be honest. He still maintains time with his family. He he he he's still a very humble person, and you get to see that when you meet him. So that was a really cool experience.
SPEAKER_03Um, and balance can be different for everybody.
SPEAKER_00Oh, 100%.
SPEAKER_03Like your version is different than my version, and yeah, like integrating it. Maybe, yeah, he is working, but he has his family there. So I mean, that's probably more valuable than the dude on the couch with the family that's got the TV on and they're all on their cell phones and no one's talking to each other.
SPEAKER_00Oh, dude, it's insane. Yeah, I mean, and yeah, and that's the that's the crazy part in 2019 is you can have everything around you and be more disconnected than ever. Um, and so I think that you know, like this is honestly stuff patients need to hear because uh everybody listening probably knows how to sell a policy, knows all their underwriting guidelines, all that. It's like, well, okay, if you know all that, what else is there? Um healthy living, you know, it's like make time for the things that are actually important to you, uh, because eventually they won't be there, they'll die. Like, and that's the most real shit that you'll you'll hear. Yeah, everything around you is slowly decaying. Yeah, so live like it.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you see the you'd press and you see the young the young agents and they have their phone and and they're like, oh, I'm I respond to the emails the second they come in, and it's just like the prioritizations are everything's out of whack, right? It's like I I removed email from my phone because right it bless your soul.
SPEAKER_00I'm still the young agent. Uh granted, I've hired a virtual assistant to help me with that, but I'm still very much the guy.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and that that type of thing, like we could go down so many paths, but the the VA is like, and that's in that's in here, right? In the book. Um the guy.
SPEAKER_00And we could talk, I mean, that's probably a healthy way. So this is actually, I think, the most important part of the book, right? There's a ton of content, and I and I and I structured the book to be let's let's kind of go down this for a second. So I structured the book to be like I wanted it to be something that was valuable. Um, because you know, if you get it through my funnel, it's only I think eight dollars. And uh, and so Jason, you ordered it through my funnel.
SPEAKER_03Uh no, I actually ordered it off as Amazon.
SPEAKER_00I ordered it on Amazon. What? When do you guys okay? Well, I got a notification. I'm waiting on the book, so I I got the author copies coming in. So I'll I'll ship it out. I swear. No, I I know. I'm pretty sure it was you, Jason. Anyways, or somebody's got your email. I don't know.
unknownUh but anyway.
SPEAKER_03I did go to your funnel. Maybe I put in maybe.
SPEAKER_00I've made the book eight dollars, which is just covers shipping, right? It's like that covers all my shipping costs. And the reason I did that is the book has so much content in it, because it's technically a novel, like it has enough to where if you only had eight dollars, that was it, and you had to spend that eight dollars and invest it, you will get very, very positive ROI if you implement. Oh, um, you know, I didn't want uh, because it's like you know, you could pay thousands of dollars to get into our course or any other course, and you'll grow if you implement. You could join a mastermind or go to an event, and you'll grow if you implement. But what about the people that are also at the Plasma Center that are I was like, that was kind of the way I structured the book. And so I was like, well, there's three different things, three different main struggle points that agents have money, time, and scaling, right? There's a lot of agents that have lots of money and they they haven't seen their family in years, and it's like, okay, let's do they have a time issue. There's agents that have money and time, but they they just keep doing this off the ceiling, right? They can't get through it. Okay, well, they have scaling issues, right? And so I was like, well, okay, there's three different main sets of issues, and so I structured the book based off of that. Like, if if if you had a most immediate need, like you're like, I don't have a I it's literally I'm eating hamburger helper without the hamburger, which is that's I I did that, you know. It's like I've done that. You know, it's like yeah, you know, and so it's like when you're in that situation, I want you to be able to start at the front, go to the money section and make some revenue so that you can afford to have the other conversations. But you know, it's like there's also the mid-level agents and the high-level agents that's like, you know, if you got time issues or scaling issues, then that then let's segment that. And so we built it to be uh to handle those issues, and uh, and so my favorite section of that was actually the time because most agents don't recognize how big their time issues are. Everybody focuses on money, but but why do you want money? At the end of the day, like if you and this is a really healthy exercise, you know. Um, and and we'll just try it with one of you guys. So uh who wants to be like me? Okay. So Jason, you're an agency owner, yeah?
SPEAKER_03Yes.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Why are you an agency owner?
SPEAKER_03Because I want to be my own boss.
SPEAKER_00Why?
SPEAKER_03Uh because I don't like being told what to do, which is funny that I work for with Allstate. That's neither here nor there.
SPEAKER_00Why don't you like being told what to do?
SPEAKER_03Um I like doing things my own way, even if it doesn't work out. I I like that. I like being able to navigate.
SPEAKER_00Why do you like doing things your own way?
SPEAKER_03Because uh I like the wins and I like the losses. I like both of them. But I like it when it when it's me at the at the wheel um making those decisions instead of I I feel like my everybody has their super talents. I I would say I really like I feel more comfortable in the driver's seat rather than the passenger seat.
SPEAKER_00So this is good. So control's a big thing to you, Jason. So if you ask why five, six, seven times on something, right? Because people always give you a bullshit answer on the first why. Not always, but 90% of the time, because it's the shit that they tell themselves when they wake up and look in the mirror. So if you ask somebody why on something, right? Why do you, why do you why do I do anything? You know, if you ask any agent that five, six, seven whys in, they start to get to shit like, because I I I'm scared that I'm not gonna have time with my family and that my kids are gonna grow up and I was never there to at the dinner table with them, and they don't really know who their dad is, even if they're aware of who I am. It's like you start to get to the shit. You know, it's like the first one or two whys, it's like, well, well, you know, I want to make more ROI, I want to make sure I'm profitable. You know, it's like it's it's all this bullshit we you know we have in these district meetings and stuff. Uh, but it's like at the end of the day, we all have very primal fears, very, very primal needs, right? Like, you need control. Why do you need we could have gone a few whys down in that? Why do you need control? There's probably some fear, fear of something with your family, right? Like you don't just need control because you need control. There's a reason. Yeah, you know, and so like if we actually ask ourselves why in this, you'll start to see like it actually is almost all rooted at some level in time. The more wise, it might be a little further away from it, but at the end of the day, all almost all of our fears, why do you need more money? You just buy in time, right?
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00We don't call it that, but it's like if you realize like the same reason you got rid of email, well, email we can't say it's not important, it's very important. But you, Craig, recognize the the necessity of your time. Yeah, that's a very fortunate human.
SPEAKER_04200 messages at night isn't gonna get me anywhere, right?
SPEAKER_00Right, but but you're a very fortunate human. Most most agents die before they recognize that. You know, and it's not just your email, it's everything you do. You beat it, Craig. Barely.
SPEAKER_04Barely.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and and it's that whole thing, like I don't know if you guys have seen the study, but there's more data produced now in, I think it was in four years. It's either four or two years, but there's more data in four or two years than all of the data that existed from I think 2007 and before in all of human history.
SPEAKER_04That makes sense. Remarkable.
SPEAKER_00That's insane. That means that around a thousand days, we produce as much as the rest of human existence. And so you got to think about that biological implication on your brain and how you process your circumstance. Like, well, I I'm at you know, the whole the idea of ADD, we all have it. It's not I I'm not gonna say it does or doesn't exist as far as a human condition, but if we ask ourselves, I think it's more environmental than it is individual. Like we have to, we of course we have attention deficit, like there's too much incoming information. You know, we have so many senses and we can't filter it fast enough. So it's like, yeah, I think if and and and if you leave a human to that judgment, we're gonna fail almost every time. And what ends up happening is we prioritize the money because it's quantifiable and it's measurable over the time because it's it's more blurry, right? It's like, but when you ask those whys, you start to get down to the core issues, and it's almost always time. And so when when I was writing the book, we put a lot of emphasis there, you know, like you were talking about virtual assistance. Um, dude, some of that stuff is a game changer, especially when you start going into it. Um, because there's a company called Agency VA that does virtual assistance. Uh a good friend of mine, Wes Anderson, is uh one of the founders, and I helped them. I we we just restructured their entire sales process and we created a uh like a 25-point checklist for agencies, right? And what is it? And it's great. I mean, it's it's a free tool that they do on their s in in their sales process, and and it and it's it really gives transparency. And it's funny to watch agents come in. You ask an agent, well, what do you value yourself at? Oh, I'm you know, $300 an hour. Easy. Okay. Are you answering phones? Well, absolutely. What's that worth to you? $15 an hour. Okay, great. How many hours a day are you doing that? Wow, that sounds really valuable, Bill. You start to recognize you say you're $300 an hour, but what you say and how you act are not in alignment. And so it's like, you know, when you start to microassess your day, you realize, wow, okay, I'm not in integrity. I'm not that valuable. I mean, I am, I know I am, I know my potential is valuable, but the way I live is not. I live like I'm only worth $15 an hour. And and there's a lot of fear around that, right? Well, if I don't do it, who's gonna do it? I then my team doesn't do it right, so I'll do it. It takes more time to delegate it, you know, than just doing it myself. Well, how many excuses? Right. All the excuses. It's still a $15 an hour task, and you're doing it, so you can't say you're $300 an hour. Like that, that isn't an integrity, and you have to either be honest or just continue to lie to yourself and then live with the repercussions.
unknownSure.
SPEAKER_04So you got to identify the leverage, the the points where you can get that leverage, right? And time 168 hours, right? That's how many hours everybody has in a week.
SPEAKER_00Right. And so the book was really geared around. I didn't want it to just be for the person who just needs the now money. It's like this is a mindset issue as well. Like, how are we going to make this something that's valuable for somebody, whether you're a one-year agent or a 25-year agent? Because some of this is just not even industry specific. It's like you have to value yourself. Everybody on that's listening to this is incredibly valuable. Whether they're living that out is a different story. 100%.
SPEAKER_03I think that was, I mean, that was the big shift when I took over this agency was the first year. I mean, I was trying to do it all. Um, which was good, and I knew it because I think anybody needs to get like if you're gonna open a restaurant, you better have bust, you better have been washing dishes at some point. Um, I only say that because I come from the restaurant industry. So but but uh like I I think that's awesome. I I did all that stuff, and I mean, I tell even my staff that's some of the happiest I ever was was when I was, you know, busing and and doing a good job and working your way up and just simple life crushing it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Well, and I think there's also a respect thing too there. I mean, you know, like let's just relay it back to combat because I think combat's very black or white. Like it it is what it is. Like, you know, you can't it's not it's emotionless. You know, if you if you look at like, would you rather have would you rather have an 18-year-old lieutenant take you into to combat or or like a 30-year-old multiple full-time deployed sergeant? I'll take the lower ranking sergeant that's seen it, done it, been it. You know, so it's like you know, there's only so much schooling you can have. I mean, some of it you just got to get kicked in the teeth and know what your own blood tastes like.
SPEAKER_03Right. Well, that's pretty much from your story, is pretty much how you got where you got. Like you wouldn't have if you weren't, you know, given blood for you know, for leads and and all that stuff, and it I mean it kind of changed your mentality, it sounds like.
SPEAKER_00I wouldn't, I wouldn't, you know, it's it's a weird thing to do, especially because I have like PTSD around it, and that's what we talk about sometimes on my life coach calls. But um I wouldn't trade it in. Like if if I could go back and um no. It's like if it it, you know, sometimes you just need to be forged in the fires of hell, you know. Like I don't know. I don't know that you can get those lessons in another way. Like it's just the hard lesson, you know. Um I agree. And it's unavoidable. Like it's like if you wanna if you want to avoid the hard lesson, you're really avoiding growth, is really what it is, dude. Of the day. Um, yeah. But yeah. So, you know, that to to to kind of get into that, uh, Craig, it's I I think that you know, virtual assistants are nice, time leverage is really important because money, money is good, but like at the end of the day, what are you doing it for? Like, you you're if you want to invest, you're buying your time later, right? You're just where do you want to buy your time? Do you want to buy it now? Do you want to buy it later? Do you want to buy what where are we buying time? And and you know, when once you can reallocate that, I think you become a much more successful agent. Um, because you also realize the value of your staff in the tasks that they do, um, and and things start to get measured differently, right? It's like not all ROI is immediately quantifiable, which was an interesting thing for me to learn on my journey because I I got into all this because I was like, oh, I can quantify it now. It's like, well, some things aren't though, you know, like relationships, culture. Like, how do you how do you but but but despite how unquantifiable they are, one of the most necessary things you can have as an agency, especially as you get staff. If you don't have culture, you're dead, you know. And I and I see agents that complain, they're like, I can't retain people, people quit, people are assholes, you know, people, people like I said today in a forum, people are greedy. I can only retain agents for two years until they get greedy and leave. It's like wait, let's actually evaluate that, bro.
SPEAKER_04Right.
SPEAKER_00Your shoes, is that greedy, or did they just not get what they needed as a human being? I mean, let's be honest here.
SPEAKER_03Or if they moved on and they grew, man, be proud of that. Like you help instill that.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_03Hopefully.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_03Or they're running.
SPEAKER_00That's a great point, man. That's a great point. So, yeah, man. I uh I really I'm really hoping that the book makes an impact. I mean, our goal is to distribute 50,000 of them this year. Um we're a decent way onto that. Uh, we're gonna start pushing a lot harder, but uh if if we can make if we can get it out to even a fraction of that and we can change some lives, then mission accomplished, you know. Um that's awesome. Yeah, too many books go off. Too much information. There's there's too much information, right? And and it's like it's the furthest thing from a cash grab for us. We really want to be able to help people, and if they implement on that, I mean I'd imagine that the sky's the limit. How can people find I'm sorry, go ahead.
SPEAKER_02What was that, Jason? Uh is there an audiobook on the way?
SPEAKER_00There is only for our consulting clients because, and this is why, um I'm always weary of mass distribution, and I'm a big believer that if somebody wants to steal my work, I want them to have to physically take and rip the book out of the hands of somebody that they care about.
SPEAKER_03Nice, hand to hand.
SPEAKER_00And if you're willing to steal it out of somebody else's life physically, then you need it.
SPEAKER_04You need it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so that's it.
SPEAKER_04And you brought up you brought up the funnel. What was um how how can people get to that funnel and they can get the book for eight bucks?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's eight bucks shipped. It's if I were you book.com. And if they go to if I were you book.com, um, yeah, they can get it. It's eight bucks shipped, and and we'll get that out. Um, you know, we'll we'll make sure that uh they because the goal is just mass distribution. Like um, it's a very specific book, obviously. I wrote it with the intention of I don't care if you read it. Like if you're in the real estate community and you're like, oh, this looks good, like yeah, hopefully you pull something. But it's it was specifically written, you know, as you as you went through it, the verbiage is very like it is insurance lingo. It it was written for the agent, you know. Um so yeah, they can go there, they can get a copy. Uh, if it comes through, I try to spend the time to you know personalize and and put a personal message in there uh for everybody that orders, just because you know, if you took the time to go through it, um I want to connect at some level. But uh yeah, I I and it's very even though it's written from the perspective of an independent, it's my I think I think that my former captive life bleeds into it too because um I don't want I didn't want it to write it it. I don't think it would apply heavily to like a life in health, like you know how like uh Allstate has like those I don't I can't remember what they're called right now, but they're like financials. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. I I don't think it would, I mean, I don't think they'd get terribly much out of it. I do talk about life insurance a little bit in there, but like I don't really care. I mean, they can figure it out. That's uh that that's a life I don't really talk too much about. Um, but uh P and C, whether you're captive or independent, you should be able to pull a bunch of nuggets out of there.
SPEAKER_01Hey, thanks for checking out the insurance house. Hey, please subscribe. We got some really great stuff coming out.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
The Telefunnel Growth System
The Insurance Dudes: Craig Pretzinger & Jason Feltman